PSA minimum size not met? Let’s see what SGC has to say.

[@eddyscardboardchaos]

Just another reason for me to stay with SGC. At this point I have no reason to even consider other alternatives. You got me with the 'breakfast tray' line.

[@Redneckclector]

@@eddyscardboardchaos thanks Eddy! I’m not ready to completely write off Psa yet, but this is one more reason to send more to SGC. I’m glad you liked my line, ha! Thanks for watching.

[@Doug-JoeWoodCollector]

Very nice results on your SGC reveal Joe . Your cards look so nice in their new tuxedo's. Thanks for sharing with us all.

[@Redneckclector]

@@Doug-JoeWoodCollector thanks Doug! I do love how they look.

[@vintageonvintage817]

Hey Joe, great submission! Congrats on those two PSA minimum size cards getting a grade from SGC, especially that Gibby! Love the exhibit cards, I think they look amazing in a tux! Congrats!

[@Redneckclector]

@@vintageonvintage817 thanks Steve! That Gibby in a 6 makes me very happy. The Exhibits absolutely pop in a tux.

[@jlbaseballcards]

Gibson PSA Minsize to SGC 6 was unbelievable! Congratulations! I'm just learning about Exhibits cards, so thanks for sharing them!

[@EverydayCardCollector-Jason]

Great return Joe! Love the royal desserts Musials and the Yogi exhibit cards are beautiful my friend! Well done my friend!

[@Redneckclector]

@@EverydayCardCollector-Jason thanks Jason! I’m super happy to have both Musials and Yogis.

[@90sKidCardTaste]

Love the deep dive in to the forced crossovers - the more data and info on these issues - the more comfortable I am resubmitting elsewhere. Thanks for the recap!

[@mozzie22]

Just found your channel, and I really enjoyed it!As a Cardinals fan these last 40 years, I can appreciate those beautiful cards. I'm going to go back and check out some of your prev videos. Well done.

[@Redneckclector]

@@mozzie22 thank you so much! I’m glad you found me too. Always glad to have another Cardinals fan around.

[@billyballgamesportscards]

Awesome submission, Joe! You sent in some amazing cards! Congrats! I love those Yogi Exhibits!

[@Redneckclector]

@@billyballgamesportscards thanks Bill! I’m slowly converting to the church of SGC.

[@Hodges1455]

Gave a video like. I think you are right about PSA being nervous. Folks don't always mention that. If they aren't sure, then they decline to grade which is understandable. Those Stan Musial cards are fantastic! It is wild that PSA charges $40 for oversized cards now. What a shame. It's like they want you to have their SGC coworkers' grade those instead. The Yogi stat back is sweet! Have a great weekend, Joe!

[@Redneckclector]

@@Hodges1455 thanks Brian! They are trying to protect themselves. $40’is crazy to grade cards I’m buying for much less, so SGC is going to get more of my business. I appreciate you watching!

[@mookiechillson]

Well done!!! That’s a great result!!! Both are beauties!

[@Redneckclector]

@@mookiechillson thanks Mookie! I’m very happy how they turned out. I appreciate you watching.

[@RobCashCards]

Joe! Congrats on 300 subs, buddy! Also, great return. Vintage looks so much better in the SGC slab. Plus, I’m sick of the PSA min-size crap. Thanks for sharing, buddy!

[@jk-califkid5017]

SGC does a lot of not meet minimum size, too.

[@MarksDodgersCards]

Congrats on the returns - some nice looking cards! Especially those Musials.

[@Redneckclector]

@@MarksDodgersCards thanks Mark! Those Musials are very unique for sure.

[@brentrichardsbaseballcards]

“Breakfast tray” 😂 Awesome cards Joe! And great results on the crossovers! Nice job man 🤛🏻

[@Redneckclector]

@@brentrichardsbaseballcards thanks Brent! I’m eating breakfast off of a PSA slab right now!

[@brentrichardsbaseballcards]

@@Redneckclector hahaha

[@Valuevintagecards-Aaron]

Wow, man! This video is straight viral! Amazing as always and glad to hear your perspective on the grading process.

[@concretebuddy59]

New subscriber here. Thanks for the nice video. In the past, I have also sent "min size not met" cards to SGC and have received realistic grades. Also, I am a fan of oversized cards too.

[@RipFan8]

Hi Joe. Congrats on getting some really good grades, and those two PSA (Min Size), getting a number from SGC. That Stat Back on the Yogi Exhibit is a really sharp card. Thanks for sharing my friend, talk soon pal.

[@Redneckclector]

@@RipFan8 thanks Stephen! I was happy to be vindicated by SGC.

[@LowDownDirtyCardboard]

Enjoyed your video, glad I found your channel. Love the Stans and Gibby. All the others are awesome too. Congrats on adding to your collection.

[@Redneckclector]

@@LowDownDirtyCardboard I’m glad you found it too! Can never have enough Stan the Man or Gibby in my collection. Thanks for watching!

[@alyn6242]

I love the Todd Zeile Donruss over your right shoulder! That card was legendary at my elementary school ! Back in the day of course...

[@Redneckclector]

@@alyn6242 that Todd Zeile was huge back in the day! I thought it was going to retire me someday. I appreciate you watching.

[@LonelyBasementBaseballCards]

Love those Yogis! Congrats on the grades Joe!

[@Redneckclector]

@@LonelyBasementBaseballCards thanks Keith! I’m always happy to bring more Yogis home.

[@3D80sKid]

Kinda crazy that the min size spec for standard size cards would be different. Although even crazier are the videos I’ve seen where people try again with PSA and get a grade. It’s not like size is subjective. Great cards either way. Congrats Joe

[@Redneckclector]

@@3D80sKid totally agree! How can measuring be so different between graders? Thanks for watching John!

[@SouthernCollector14]

Amazing cards my friend! I love the Frisch!

[@Redneckclector]

@@SouthernCollector14 thanks Tony! The Frisch is super cool.

[@hammerforty-four]

Love that '34 Goudey Frisch! That green does indeed pop!

[@NMauro]

Just discovered your channel. Excellent work and great content.

[@CleanCheapShots]

Graders are like umpires, sometimes they get it wrong. Thanks for sharing Joe.

[@JC-pu7gi]

The problem is there prefer customers will get all card graded and grades that they deserve & better.

[@RustyVintageCards]

“Slabnostic,” I like the term. Man, what a deal on that Mantle! And those Yogi Exhibits cards are so cool. I’m a big fan of the exhibits. They’ve really grown on me the last couple of years. On the min-size, I agree it’s a technicality that doesn’t always make sense on vintage cards.

[@blixcards]

Awesome reveal, Joe... I've had similar experiences. I always like to say every order has a "sacrifice" card. Maybe 1/2 of 1% of PSA reveals have 100% of cards graded since Nat Turner took over. My latest PSA order has 50 of 58 cards ungraded - no joke. . We as collectors know far, far more about the cards we grade and buy than these "experts" do.

[@Redneckclector]

@@blixcards thanks Ben! I agree that I’ve always had one card come back ungraded once in awhile, now it’s every order has multiple. I’m also starting to realize the average grader has no idea what they’re doing.

[@blixcards]

@@Redneckclector I guess we're just stuck with it! It's a sad fact but I think it's obvious.

[@Peacemakercards]

Nice reveal, Joe. I've been looking for the '61 Koufax, hope to pick one up soon.

[@Redneckclector]

@@Peacemakercards thanks Dave! I hope you find a good one too!

[@BaseisBeautiful]

The more time I spend with 1961 the more I like the design and photography on that set. Congrats on getting grades on those “minsize” cards 😉😏😁😅

[@raidersacdc4892]

I sent 6 into SGC. They received them on Jan 25th and as of yesterday they are already in post grading processing. I’ll continue to send my collection to them for my grading

[@diamondgems45]

As far as the Gashouse Gang is concerned I really like the 1934 Gold Medal Flour cards. The Dizzy Dean is awesome and i hope to pick one up at the National. Great SGC return-I have a 1961 Paul Hornung I have to send them because just like you it came back MSR.

[@Redneckclector]

@@diamondgems45 I’m watching a Gold Medal on eBay and I plan on adding one at some point. Send that Hornung in! I’m sure it will get a number grade. Thanks for watching.

[@JayAvgVintageCollector]

I simply cannot understand how determinations are made at the grading companies anymore. There is just so much inconsistency. This is part of the reason that I will no longer send cards in. I’m frustrated for you! But, I’m glad it worked out. Great cards. I love the Frisch. That Mantle Giant All-Star is great too! I have not seen that first Berra before, but it really got my attention. Thanks for the video and thanks for sharing!

[@Redneckclector]

@@JayAvgVintageCollector thanks Jay! It’s a frustrating process to deal with for sure. I still do it though, so some of the fault is my own. Glad you liked the cards. I appreciate you watching.

[@thecollectingnomad]

Love the cards. I think if a card hadn’t been trimmed or altered and is just minsize from factory I think it should get a grade. Just my opinion. Thanks for sharing those great cards. Really like those Stan Musial and Yogi Berra cards.

[@Redneckclector]

@@thecollectingnomad thank you! I agree with you. I just don’t think they take enough time on each card to make a proper evaluation. They just default to calling it all min size and it’s frustrating. Thanks for watching!

[@KSHE1967]

Since you live in the St Louis area have you been to Rediscover Antiques & Collectible on S. Broadway in Lemay They have vintage cards. Lots of Cardinals & Blues Hockey.

[@jeffsmith989]

So about 15 years ago I sent in a bunch of 1961 Topps baseball in really high grade. These literally came from an attic that have been sitting there for like 50 years. It was a guy that I work with that was retiring. So out of the lot two cards back came back min size requirement? Of course it had to be a Mantle and a Clemente. All the other cards came back 8s or 9s. So I ended up sending them both to Beckett and they both came back 8s. All this to say PSA has been doing this for years. Obviously those cards weren't trimmed. They were original owner cards from when he was 10 years old.

[@the701man]

I love that mickey mantle...I have the same sgc 3

[@CraigsCards62]

Nice return. SGC for me. Cool Stan M. desserts

[@MrJmangini]

Haha. I’d venture to say 90% of the min size came out of the pack that way.

[@Redneckclector]

@@MrJmangini I would 100% agree John. Thanks for watching. I knew you would appreciate it.

[@godisgreat8462]

Nice my friend

[@Redneckclector]

@@godisgreat8462 thank you!

[@renoraines6322]

I received the MNM sz not met on a rare serialized card from PSA so I sold on eBay. A year later that card is now listed in a PSA slab. I thought the size was at least an objective part of grading.

[@cryptonite8495]

On the 1948-66 exhibits, Yogi had one every year until he retired. But I believe MADE IN THE USA in all caps indicates it was printed in 1948-1950, near the start of Yogi's career. I read about that on Net54 when I was researching my 1948-66 Exhibits Jackie Robinson.

[@Redneckclector]

@@cryptonite8495 I don’t know that, thank you! Net54 is such a great place for knowledge. I can spend a lot of time there reading. I would love to have the Jackie someday. It has an awesome image. Thanks for watching!

[@EarthtonesCymbals]

Thanks for sharing your cards. That Koufax is a 5. PSA sucks. Tommy Edman does not miss St. Louis.

[@BrianBlankenship-f6l]

The yogi is very nice card great pick ups

[@Redneckclector]

@@BrianBlankenship-f6l thanks Brian! I appreciate you watching.

[@Rocketrickj18]

Joe, I actually prefer SGC now. The slabs look better and I think they are a bit more durable. The grades you got are fantastic!

[@Redneckclector]

@@Rocketrickj18 thanks Rick! I’m slowly converting to the church of SGC. Thanks for watching.

[@mqncteacher]

PSA charges you whether they slab the card of not.

[@jpacrylicstudio145]

That is great! I don't like PSA, for reasons like what you mentioned. The "Experts of the Hobby" are not so "expert." They should be nervous, because they have little transparency of their standards, get proven over and over how little they know and keep making the same mistakes. I have never been disappointed with SGC. I hope they stay true, despite being bought out by the same corporation that owns PSA.

[@Redneckclector]

@@jpacrylicstudio145 I think Psa is their own worst enemy right now. They are operating very arrogantly these days and it’s turning a lot of collectors off. I’m going to continue giving SGC more of my business. They are doing things the right way. Thanks for watching!

[@Vintage_Dave_T]

I don’t get PSA min size not met. Why not slab as A with their disclaimer. They could then charge you. Which would you rather have? No charge or an A? The way they do it at least you don’t have to crack it out. Thx for sharing your slabs.

[@Thehuntingshow]

PSA is now “forcing” collectors to send to SGC and no one realizes this. The parent company is doing really well with PSA and now need a better ROI from their newest acquisition in SGC. PSA wants to be known for modern and SHC for vintage, unless it’s a really big card.

[@Redneckclector]

@@Vintage_Dave_T thanks Dave! It really makes no sense how they are operating with vintage right now, but I’m glad I didn’t have to pay for their incompetence. I’m happy SGC got it right.

[@Redneckclector]

@@Thehuntingshow I don’t disagree at all. I don’t know why they just don’t come out and say it? Or give us a combined registry and watch it happen overnight.

[@JC-pu7gi]

Please Submit Again. PLEASE STAY AWAY

[@TheDadsAreHere]

The min size determination really irritates me in regards to vintage. With the lack of technology back then, how can anyone expect perfect cuts 100% of the time. The +/- threshold needs to be adjusted for vintage specs. I feel that with vintage, if a card gets min size, it better get a trimmed qualifier as well. Just my thought.

[@Redneckclector]

@@TheDadsAreHere I 100% agree. They just aren’t taking enough time on each card to determine factory miscut vs trimmed. Or the more obvious answer…they don’t care. Thanks for watching.

[@mitchellriles]

PSA charged me for a min size on a p manning rookie refractor

[@threeg6966]

SGC over PSA every time.

[@bourbonbeltcards6392]

PSA can’t even agree with themselves on minimum size.

[@Redneckclector]

@@bourbonbeltcards6392 exactly. They are their own worst enemy. Thanks for watching!

[@chrisrunyon2372]

Just shows you grading is a sham