Cnoddings follow up video from Chicago is what gave me red flags about this marker. He broke his marker down and had issues with the eyes. He said that he still broke paint after switching to the smaller oring. He also said his teammate who had the MXR had the same problems. Hats off to PunishersPB for a video to address concerns from the consumers.I think I’ll wait for the MXR+ 🤣
@CriticalGMR4 ай бұрын
I’d like to see him do these tests with a .679-.682 paint
@vand10073 ай бұрын
@@CriticalGMR For sure. I like that the eye pipe is better material but i'm not sold on the oring detents. Also, the whole point of the eye pipe was to stop paint from blocking the eyes. The thing has two holes in it. Maybe explains why Cnoddings had eye problems. I felt the MXR and the ergos are very nice.
@Cliff771274 ай бұрын
Bought the dls on drop day. Not making the same mistake again
@bigdaddyreg4 ай бұрын
Did the same damn thing, and its funny how they left it off the 20 year of dye markers. DYE made another marker in support of Planet Eclipse making $1600+ markers ready to go vs a DYE 2nd marker release with issues
@nicholasvafiades6363 ай бұрын
I am in the same boat.
@corbindallas19543 ай бұрын
Same bro. Dye will never get another dollar from me.
@dasfrundselt4 ай бұрын
Glad I went for the Geo R5!
@brandonstevens44854 ай бұрын
R5 has been the biggest and best release in years since the CS2
@DAILYSMAKАй бұрын
If aftershock players says it's a fire marker that's all I need. 1000000% trust it.
@mickdostert73104 ай бұрын
No issue to keep it in Nxl ramp but I was shooting soup a lot of the time, thanks for the fixes I'll try it out
@damianculley674 ай бұрын
Sorry, But for a brand new gun at $1000+....This video and issues should even not exist. Period.
@Propsroadfool3 ай бұрын
It's not the gun, it's the presenter, who sucks
@DD-jx9jd3 ай бұрын
I can't understand why they would use a oring as a detent. Every other company and including their old detents work fine. They could of went with the aluminum eye pipe with their old detent and been fine. But typical Dye
@spartan_scrub24754 ай бұрын
I'm probably going to wait till thanksgiving before i get one. See if the bugs get worked out. that being said ill be buying from you guys just because of how straight you guys are on these things.
@vamp91904 ай бұрын
This is why I decided years ago to just go with PE as a primary (can still grab other brands for collection) -- less maintenance (double the number of o-rings on other brand bolts, etc.), better reliability, and fewer quirks and issues.
@CanyouGigАй бұрын
Question ! Mine is blinking blue and red idk whats wrong with it ?
@wutanga13xАй бұрын
Can you do a video on the bolt guide oring? People are changing it from 016 to a 017
@KERTER214 ай бұрын
When the marker was released Billy Wing went live and said that you can change the oring depending on what size paint you have. I believe he said all the pro players using the MXR was use the 16 oring
@boosted94sc30011 күн бұрын
im curious about the first shoot, you said it was stuttering but then said there were no issues. was the stutter not the marker? ty.
@awol101993 ай бұрын
It’s too bad I really like the look of the MXR and a lot of improvements I wanted to see have been implemented over what the M3+ had. But damn it has to be able to shoot properly. I may still pick up one but probably after Dye acknowledges the issues and has fixes.
@IBOTCHvx334 ай бұрын
Seems to happen every release..... Would be pretty obvious to catch all of these issues in development and testing.
@foolishcreations22593 ай бұрын
Hey is the stuttering issue possibly due to the oring issue? Maybe the ball isn’t sitting where the eyes can see it and it’s not firing until the eyes can see it? Eyes off does it have the stuttering???
@leeholloway62844 ай бұрын
No more Dye products for me following my DLS, though it's a nice looking gun.
@rexjames81003 ай бұрын
Ya what’s up with the luxe grips ?
@Zander13Productions4 ай бұрын
R5 had loader issues and an o-ring inside the bolt that comes loose too.
@austink47124 ай бұрын
The r5 didn't have loader issues. Th loaders were having issues with how well the r5 was made. Virtue came out with the fix, not PE
@Zander13Productions4 ай бұрын
@@austink4712 the loaders received an update so that they could work with the R5. Those loaders never had a problem on any other marker. Something about the R5 caused slow fire rates. Maybe it was too soft or 🤷♂️
@RCboyzTV4 ай бұрын
@@Zander13Productionsgood problem to have
@williswoods22454 ай бұрын
@@Zander13ProductionsIt had to do with the loader’s software logic and the timing of the R5’s bolt cycle. Definitely not an R5 problem as I could slap any non-ctrl2/Spire V loader on without issue.
@rexjames81004 ай бұрын
Speaking of the idol grips when will the upgrades be available
@dmonahan67714 ай бұрын
Mine shoots like a dream. I have not done anything to it at this point. Over 3 cases of GI and not any issues.
@stevenmiller12033 ай бұрын
Will there be new basic colors for this soon?
@kcnova15614 ай бұрын
Ramp sustain reminds me of the OG vapor and the ape board. Loved my Vapor but I also shot it with a Ego 11 Virtue board. Bought a DLS. Will definitely be skipping this.
@weroliera4 ай бұрын
People in comments called me crazy in the Last video. I want my cookie for being right😂😂😂
@PBReligion4 ай бұрын
It seems like to me there is a delay with the eyes. This could be where the ball isnt quite settled in the breach. And everyone is moaning but ALL guns have issues. Ive had eclipse, empire and dlx guns do the same thing when ramping straight out the box.
@mbaroneva764 ай бұрын
Ugh, I’m a huge Dye fan, run two m3+ and they’re absolute work horses and I love the way they shoot. I still think the mxr is ultimately going to be a great gun. It’s true that other manufacturers have had issues on their releases but Dye could’ve used a clean launch. The r2 forcing double feeds isn’t an issue because who uses an r2 at this point besides sponsored teams? If they can fix the ramp logic quickly and it feeds fine with a spire/cntrl then hopefully it’ll be good to go.
@k3mikal4 ай бұрын
"the r2 double feed isn't an issue because the only people who use an r2 are sponsored". Where did you get this data from? I'm not sponsored and use an r2. And you're saying it's fine for sponsored r2 users to have this issue? Hahahah bro stop with the copium
@mbaroneva764 ай бұрын
@@k3mikal, I was’t saying it was backed by a peer reviewed study, lol. I just don’t know why anybody would use an R2 unless they were sponsored, it doesn’t make sense to me. Everybody knows they jam, the free flow internals slow the loader down to less than Ctrl 2 speeds and it still jams. Sure a marker should work with every loader especially the one the marker manufacturer also makes but here we are. Personally I’m sticking with my m3+. They both run great, see no reason to switch.
@kevinb54364 ай бұрын
very noticeable ramp kick in issues here in the vide
@coryjames704 ай бұрын
I personally agree I think the gun is great and honestly a simple software update could easily fix the ramp thing. I play in semi so it's a none issue for me but I definitely think it's a simple fix and people need to chill and stop comparing it to the DLS.
@axledog72974 ай бұрын
The comparisons with the DLS are ignorant. Functionally, the two share essentially zero features.
@vand10074 ай бұрын
You think people are comparing it to the DLS as in the actual marker. We can all agree that they are completely different. It’s more so that yet again, another DYE product was released with issues. I definitely want the MXR to succeed. Paintball wouldn’t be as fun if we all ripped the same guns. Great video from PunishersPB!
@badchevelle723 ай бұрын
@@vand1007Exactly! This!
@Dmorris5564 ай бұрын
Could be a paint size issue. Out west, it is hard to get paint that is not 675 or 677.
@KW-tq7xy4 ай бұрын
So we're not supposed to be upset if our brand new 1k+ marker doesn't shoot correctly?..like buying a car and having to send it back in and be happy about it?
@JJG837244 ай бұрын
Why continue to use an R2? Please use a spire V
@williamduckworth3054 ай бұрын
Thanks for this vid. I just bought the mxr. Still waiting for it to come to my pb store. So u hot to change a o ring and fool i with the settings, my new idol has shitty grips. .glad yall came up with fixes in stead of whining...
@HikoSejuroVIIII4 ай бұрын
I feel like it has become dye’s MO to realease guns that are not ready for the consumer.
@MudPeppers4 ай бұрын
Punishers is the greatest store on earth.
@Blackoutpb144 ай бұрын
The geo r5 had issues with certain loaders, any new marker has some sort of issue on release. This was a valuable video since I'm interested in the mxr. Can you do a video of the o ring that you can put on the bolt that slows it down and make the marker smoother?
@EKKsoldier6224 ай бұрын
It was due spire v/ctrl2 timing issue with its coding; brought to light in some of them when using r5. It was not a fault of the r5; just occurred as a bad combo between the slowed forward stroke of the bolt and a mistiming in the loader. Different than dyes [possible] quality control problems.
@Blackoutpb144 ай бұрын
@@EKKsoldier622 I don’t disagree just stating things happen that you won’t know until you release the gun
@bobspalding24774 ай бұрын
@@EKKsoldier622Wrong. If those loaders work flawlessly with Every other marker on the market, and you drop a dud for the most popular loader then you didn’t do enough testing.
@EKKsoldier6224 ай бұрын
@@bobspalding2477 You’re welcome to disagree with what Virtue and Planet Eclipse have stated as an intermittently occurring problem due to the SpireV’s eye logic. However, since it was the fault of the PE and the r5, I’ll be sending in about half a dozen for the bolt redesign and software update they offering to the public to make up for it. Oh wait…
@bobspalding24774 ай бұрын
@@EKKsoldier622 “brought to light when using the R5” sounds like an R5 problem. I’m happy Virtue stepped up to make a work around for their customers that couldn’t get off PEs dik.
@johncouture67524 ай бұрын
The ORing will swell and become more flexible when grease comes in contact with it, a plastic detent might be better, I thought the acrylic eye pipe just needed metal reinforcement.
@TacticalPortugee4 ай бұрын
Valid point
@MrBottlecapBill4 ай бұрын
The smaller oring should help maybe even bumping up to a 90 duro instead of 70.
@johncouture67524 ай бұрын
@@TacticalPortugee obrigad
@axledog72974 ай бұрын
A buna oring will not swell when it comes into contact with grease. There are potential issues with this design but that's not one.
@axledog72974 ай бұрын
@@MrBottlecapBilli would highly recommend against going up in durometer. That is not a good suggestion.
@RichardRacks4 ай бұрын
DYE must have seriously rushed this to market. Incredible that there could be some many different isolated issues. Especially this day and age where all brands are putting out a highly optimized and fine tuned product.
@RCboyzTV4 ай бұрын
Dave Youngblood needs to pay for his child SA lawsuit
@DaddyBigMad4 ай бұрын
@@RCboyzTV which is why no one should be buying this shit.
@GeoR5shooter4 ай бұрын
They need to give me my money back for that DLS. DYE
@RPod894 ай бұрын
The price of the lowest MXR is a DSR+ + IM kit + UL-I kit with 3 Pwr inserts, but unless you are in D1 D2 or in pro division I don't think a MXR will be worth it at this stage. Or keep your dsr+ as a spare one for the time.
@the141monkey4 ай бұрын
Whole idea behind the eyepipe system was to protect the eyes fom paint ingress if a ball broke. Now they made a metal one but drilled holes in the pipe exposing the eye !!
@Pauwke14 ай бұрын
The eys are sealed of in the breach. TAAC tower and seal!
@the141monkey4 ай бұрын
@@Pauwke1 eyes will still be blocked if paint gets through that hole and covers them . Polycarbonate eyepipe would be self cleaned via bolttip oring and eye diodes still paint free.
@Pauwke14 ай бұрын
@@the141monkey good point!
@the141monkey4 ай бұрын
@@Pauwke1 BTW, I'm a dye hard fanboy. I just don't understand the engineering around this idea
@Pauwke14 ай бұрын
@@the141monkey got mine yesterday. Playing on sunday. going to set it up as they say.
@Acc0rd794 ай бұрын
After the DLS I sure as hell would not trust Dye for a long time. Let some people be the test dummies and see what it looks like after 6 plus months. At this point I'd gladly take a DLX marker and clearly a Planet one far over any DYE one. It's sad, this is what happens when you don't have long enough testing on them. I'd much rather you take time and have months of testing vs rushing. My 2 cents.
@foolishcreations22594 ай бұрын
The DLS was not a little issue it was a complete catastrophe for the majority of owners. I think the excessive hate is due to that main reason. The R5 had a loader issue but was quickly resolved by Virtue. The LV2 was quickly addressed by planet. Mind you nothing to do with paint handling. If you can’t shoot paint than it’s a paper weight. Paint handling is #1 on the list when it comes down to a tournament paintball marker. The MXR should be able to handle GI 5 star paint.
@EviLRyU-s9y4 ай бұрын
DYE DLS all over again?
@axledog72974 ай бұрын
No
@bigdaddyreg4 ай бұрын
DYE should have tested this before mass roll out, Dye fooled me with the DLS the MXR isn't giving me confidence to get my dollar.
@MrBottlecapBill4 ай бұрын
For youtubers out there......this is why you do NOT TEST with old paint. It creates false impressions in the minds of people with less experience.
@MrBottlecapBill4 ай бұрын
Out of curiosity, for anyone who has an MXR can you check the stock ramp settings to make sure they're correct? If not can you try to create a custom profile and set the ramp settings up as they should be to compare? I don't know if that's possible with the MSR or not.........most guns you can do something like this. My logic is that if you create your own ramp settings that are NXL compatible and it suddenly works then it's a software issue for sure. Perhaps testing in any other ramp settings the board has available may also help.
@Zinojn4 ай бұрын
@@MrBottlecapBill ill the same issue using outlaw mode with a similar configuration to what NXL would be
@vand10074 ай бұрын
I agree with the bad paint. But Cnoddings follow up vid from playing in Chicago gives better perspective to the issues he had even with tourney paint. Hopefully DYE can solve the issues
@NAYAPRAVADA4 ай бұрын
That shit could not maintain ramp.
@PunishersPaintball4 ай бұрын
Stay tuned 🫡
@NAYAPRAVADA4 ай бұрын
@@PunishersPaintball Likely a simple software update fix. Troubling things like this slip by QC though.
@robertoloza56924 ай бұрын
@@PunishersPaintball are you guys posting s video once you know the fix? i bought one and its definitely hard to get used to
@codybartley97914 ай бұрын
But why are we having to fix the shortcomings of dye like oh outta box you gotta change 6-7 dif things not a good look
@xD12xSiCkNaStY4 ай бұрын
Sounds like dye got cheap on the test stage and skimped on it.
@ozone51504 ай бұрын
They had plenty of problems with CS3 in the beginning! Give Dye a chance already 😊
@Zinojn4 ай бұрын
@@ozone5150 I own all their guns, multiple of them. Just wish they would handle new releases better when it comes to customer feedback.
@NoahWeidner124 ай бұрын
@@ozone5150no because the DLS cost me enough and there’s no fix for it, it’s like a game that comes out too early with bugs, instead of releasing it at the opportune time, just make sure it works
@axledog72974 ай бұрын
@@ozone5150what revisions have been released for the CS3 to address functional issues?
@dustinphillips75614 ай бұрын
@@axledog7297recommendation to change the orings in the Asa for the leaking asas was a thing
@christopherkeith6003 ай бұрын
Quirks? Why should a marker at over a 1000 have quirks?
@Drp15073 ай бұрын
Crazy how all these new guns are such junk that lose 50% of their value after less than a year of use and have all these issues. Pulled my 2k2 lcd fly out of the basement after sitting for 15 years, didnt do anything besides replace the battery and put 3 drops of oil in the asa and she shoots ropes like she did right out of the box.
@KERTER214 ай бұрын
MXR vs GeoR5
@mrb133714 ай бұрын
DSR+ 👈🏻😂
@nicktaranto91604 ай бұрын
Dude you could not keep the gun in ramp stop with the 1 finger just fill the hopper and try and keep it in ramp
@kevinb54364 ай бұрын
what? if he could, obviously he would. He wants these to sell. This thing has unavoidable ramp issues.
@axledog72974 ай бұрын
Of course the average paintball player will complain about having to adjust the trigger and replace an oring. With that said, I do believe the ramping code needs to be looked at. I suspect a software update will happen.
@kevinb54364 ай бұрын
~$1,800 doesn’t warrant a complaint about the gun needing to be “fixed” out of the box?
@axledog72974 ай бұрын
@@kevinb5436 $1500 for black, $1650 for PGA. Adjusting the trigger and (maybe) replacing an oring is not justification for whining. But I'm not your average paintball player. Your results may vary.
@DirtyBG333 ай бұрын
"hey guys when you buy this $1700 marker here's what you should do to make it work." 😂 I get you're a dealer but damn.... Lets just call it what it is. MXR is a flop.
@b0lbi4 ай бұрын
We just saw the mxr and r2 both fail more than once. Not acceptable when the dsr, 180r, even cs3 are in the same price range, and require none of this adjustment 🤷♂️
@bigdaddyreg3 ай бұрын
I know folks like to clown the planet eclipse lovers but disappointing releases like the MXR, and the Luxe Idol just further pushes PE's stock.
@benson1ification4 ай бұрын
Once again Dye releases a gun that needs loads of fixes after release, just like the NT, the DSR, the DLS..
@vwi8833 ай бұрын
Stick to p.e
@rickyramirez75564 ай бұрын
Or just get rid of ramp altogether. No skill whatsoever
@Propsroadfool3 ай бұрын
Stop letting this guy make videos...
@axeldange3 ай бұрын
The biggest issue is actually Dave Youngblood. Dude is in court fighting allegations related to child sex tourism. There’s 0% chance I’d give Dye a dollar while Dave is profiting.
@two-bit4634 ай бұрын
Boring! It's not that good of a marker as people make this out to be. its another mid range DYE marker that does nothing like all their markers ! Nothing to see here oh and the new mask DYE made does that one cover your upper lip like the other DYE masks do ? Good strap lmao
@Zander13Productions4 ай бұрын
Just got mine from you guys and it already had the black #16 installed 🤷♂️ 🫡
@MrJimbo98z4 ай бұрын
Wild that dye can't get $1700 marker out the door that just works out of the box on default settings. Congrats, MXR owners, you're all beta testers 🤣
@Zinojn3 ай бұрын
Yea. People need to hold Dye to a higher standard here. There is a reason PE markers have the rep they do. Every single PE marker is tested before being shipped. Why doesn't Dye do this? If we are paying the same cost for the highest end marker they offer, why do we settle for less? How these got through beta testing without ANYONE noticing the ramping issues is just crazy. They had to of known about this ahead of time and should of had a software update ready for day 1. Nobody cares that there is an board/software issue --- the problem is how Dye and their reps handled it by gaslighting customers.
@justinbryant66764 ай бұрын
This just sold me on a new geo. Thanks. I'll order one from lone Wolfe tonight.
@justinbryant66764 ай бұрын
Dye should be releasing a polished gun not one with all these problems