Java Redstoner Tries Bedrock Redstone

[@Purplers]

Get the new REDMAGIC 10 Pro this Christmas: bit.ly/3AEZeUH www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0DMSMNB51

[@FinnSaysThings]

Amazing!

[@tvtrexrexbean2094]

hi

[@suezq74]

I love your videos purplers - Riley

[@tvtrexrexbean2094]

@@CheezyFruit ah yes the famed "mabey"

[@longforchannelnamenumbers]

THE COMMENT IS NOT PINNED!!!! (maybe its pinned for those in the furture)

[@noahkuhns2032]

As someone who has played a lot of bedrock edition here's a few tips. 1 on pocket edition go to video settings and change the ui from pocket to classic. 2 Make sure you chunk align your redstone, if redstone crosses a chunk border it will mess with all kinds of timings and stuff. Also change the controls. There are so many better options in settings.

[@mitchib1440]

You have to align your redstone to chunks in singleplayer??? How do ya'll put up with these kinds of weird quirks?

[@noahkuhns2032]

I mean you don't have to but if you want precise timings things will work a lot better

[@tdubmorris5757]

or just play java edition with keyboard and mouse

[@someonequinof]

Number one tip for Bedrock players: - Switch to Java If you don't have a PC: - Get one

[@randomphantom3976]

@@someonequinof Or go back to Legacy Console, which was better than Bedrock and AT LEAST equal to Java.

[@MrBrineplays_]

Watching you use the tiny mobile controls when you can modify it to your liking (resize buttons, adjust position, etc) is so painful to watch

[@LilyTablet-n3z]

Na not in my opinion

[@StarDroid77]

Bedrock edition is always painful to watch 💀

[@teknoshadowwashere]

It would still be hard since he's not used to mobile gameplay

[@Aldrich.a.w]

Yeah i agree they need to resize the controls

[@Alkilburn3]

​@@StarDroid77 yeah when Java players play for the first time

[@brendanmchenry1826]

When you were making the double piston extension in the four by four you said the top piston wasnt working because of bedrock tick jank. It actually wasnt working because the redstone next to the piston goes into the block next to it causing it to extend when the piston is pushed. Visible at 12:14

[@Brick_Soup]

Pretty slick product placement lol. Didn't even mind it because it made sense for the video. Love the content, get that bag!

[@SkyGravity137]

Important info for "Bedrock Redstone": Just because it works on bedrock in PC, doesn't mean it will work in other conditions, such as bedrock on a console, or on a pc during high cpu usage. In order for your Redstone to work 100% it needs a certain kind of padding depending on the circuits. Most bedrock redstone tutorials on KZbin are not actually tested on a console, and even when using a latest Gen console, your redstone may fail due to skipped redstone ticks and other issues. Edit to add mob farms, similar problems. Some mob farms just will not work on console despite working on pc bedrock

[@SJrad]

Bruh

[@boogiehasfun]

wow such a well programmed game!

[@OokamiKuro39Ch]

wth? why?

[@Porkey_Minch]

Bedrock can skip redstone ticks!? That's so cursed

[@1unar_eclipse]

Yeah this is why I only play Bedrock for servers

[@GabrielPrado-cf3iw]

Its the real Quantum mechanism you won't know if it will work until you see it

[@ironicpants2651]

Redstone on bedrock is a joke, as someone who has played bedrock for a very long time, redstone isn’t stable and is almost unusable outside of the simplest contraptions.

[@Ekipsogel]

TRAITOR

[@oopsispilledmymilk7300]

I completely agree, I have hundreds of hours on bedrock, but I hate redstone in bedrock with a passion. I once spent hours trying to make a functioning vertical piston extender that wouldn’t work because of the randomness

[@ironicpants2651]

@@Ekipsogel I still play bedrock lmao. Im just stating a fact😭🙏

[@Ekipsogel]

@oopsispilledmymilk7300 I have a 4x vertical piston extender wall (5 extenders in parallel) on bedrock that pulls down a slime pillar with blocks on it, which means on side is mostly unusable, two more have other extenders on them, and the others have to be unmoveable, while fitting under a floor at the hight of the top slime block when retracted.

[@redthunder6183]

I like it, I built a 8 bit computer in bedrock. if it’s unstable outside of simple contraptions, then you don’t know what you’re doing.

[@MECKENICALROBOT]

ok, last thing to note…. which might help. components on bedrock light up (or off in the case of the torch) when the components are actually powered in (where as java lights up with the power out)

[@ItsMeKriqu]

Purple complaining about bedrock being bad at 12:17 but the redstone dust for the last closing pulse just powers the front of the dpe cause it's not redirected anymore lol

[@PhilippSiebert-p1r]

I mean he's right it is bad but it just wasn't the problem scource THIS TIME

[@RedAnimations24]

Purplers, you can click the chest icon in the top right to choose your display of inventory. I recommend the one which shows your character ,inventory and creative menu

[@Moonwisp165]

you now know my pain of finding stuff in a creative inventory

[@SMGamer108]

Bedrock inventory in creative is better imo

[@icantthinkofaname4723]

​@SMGamer108wrong

[@SMGamer108]

@@icantthinkofaname4723 how?

[@sonicSnap]

i think a combination of java and bedrock would be peak. more specific categories with bedrock's inner collapsed by default categories

[@IDoBeCalvingTho]

⁠@@icantthinkofaname4723 An opinion isn’t “wrong” just because it isn’t yours, I personally agree that the bedrock creative inventory is better and that’s not objectively wrong.

[@thediamondking1999]

I don't even need to watch 5 minutes to feel your pain, pistons are even crappier. It's like quazi-connectivity in the size of redstones update area

[@RipVanFish09]

I love how you can timestamp exactly when he recorded one of the clips, because of the event timer on bedrock’s title screen.

[@1unar_eclipse]

Also there's a bug rn where skins reset arm width after relaunching (I love this game) so the fact his stayed on slim means either 1.21.3x or recorded in one session

[@twoslimes7251]

@@1unar_eclipse It says he is on 1.21.51 on the main menu

[@1unar_eclipse]

@twoslimes7251 I may be stupid

[@Clash-r3s]

Man I respect your 4x4 door man. I never thought you could make it like that. I am also play bedrock but I really want to play java because I watch java redstoners and it just looks so much easier. I have also played minecraft on xbox and can agree that there is some qc in it but not all. So with that from playing minecraft xbox one edition I can so that I prefer java. Even though I play bedrock on my PlayStation. I really like java. And well done for having a go at bedrock. It is hard if you have play a different minecraft.

[@GilWanderley]

2:28 For _reasons_ , I can only play Minecraft on my phone, but by God, I swear the on screen controls are the worst thing ever. Get at least a Bluetooth controller. EDIT: And Purple did.

[@macesith]

If you've played mobile fps games for 3y like me it isn't too bad, you just have to go into settings and change the experiment toggle.

[@W1nd0w55]

2:02 No it's not Bedrock isn't on Linux SO LET ME GET THIS STRAIGHT i HAD to completely miss the eyeblossom cape because i COULDNT EVEN PLAY BEDROCK ARE YOU KIDDING ME-

[@EaglexEyeGaming]

Yeah I don't think they really care

[@ThatGeometryDude]

ME TOOO

[@NEOMatrix-bd7uo]

"I can finally go back to doing proper redstone in java" I've spent the past five years doing bedrock redstone, this sentence made me feel like I was doing something improper all this time. And i understand it was meant as a joke, I've been watching you for three years now

[@nixsonhenderson]

Why. Is. It. RANDOM?!?!??!!!? I’ve NEVER understood why my favorite feature in Minecraft is random in the version Microsoft prefers

[@redthunder6183]

It’s only random when you try to do two things simultaneously, that can’t be done simultaneously. Like placing two pistons facing each other and powering at the same time. Mutually exclusive events are random when you try to do them simultaneously. Everything else is perfectly predictable. IMO, this makes sense. It’s a lot better than having it locational or directional.

[@Junparidize]

Purplers used soft inversion! Poggg!!!

[@Monkeymario.]

Whats that?

[@you.called.funky.]

Soft inversion is the when you put a torch on the non-moving part of a piston and powering that piston to turn off the torch.

[@Mico544]

Fun fact : he recorded the phone on Dec. 12

[@SSamYou]

You know that bc you play bedrock right?

[@posty_]

Somehow i kept reading the title as java redstoner tries bedstone redrock

[@Zombrine21]

It was bound to happen

[@AirTrafficControlRPLY]

5:46 yes it made my cry

[@samuelc.s.deoliveira163]

Thanks for remembering Mcpe, almost every time someone from Java talks about Minecraft Bedrock, they don't talk about the additional difficulties of Pocket Tip: You can disable slow breaking, you can set it to copy coordinates (if it's useful) and you also now have the option to copy block

[@inferno9010]

Pro tip for pocket edition. Split controlls and classic ui. Underated asf

[@HelPfeffer]

This makes me happy bc I started in Bedrock, but now I'm a happy java coffee bean It makes me feel my pain is seen

[@ninjadude_yt404]

2:09 When you brought up playing Bedrock on a phone, I was prepared for, and EXPECTING, a Redmagic 10 Pro sponsor, because I’ve seen them quite a bit now. 😂

[@DigiTech9000]

The twitch cape really match your skin👍.

[@captnzap9588]

Great episode I enjoyed it. As a bedrock player who recently tried Java for the first time, this was very funny to watch.

[@Imperial_Squid]

0:13 reminds me of creative mode in the beta days when the creative menu was just one huge list of every block ordered by ID numbers (Also, bonus meme for the old players: "/give 46 64" lol)

[@blacklight683]

All redstoners(me included) when Redstone works as (you) intended: :D When the Redstone works as (the game) intended: D: No but I still absolutely hate the random update order cuz of how I got used to ordered update, like I get some things like fixing bugs that are the bases of Java Redstone but random update order is just stupid

[@GwnTim1]

14:40 Something deep inside my soul was triggered by the left side being slightly faster than the right side

[@redattack9630]

As a redstoner that started playing on pocket edition and moved to java, i don't know how i managed to play on an iPad for nearly 6 years. Believe me, i actually was a great bedrock redstoner and did some crazy things! But when i moved to java i was overwhelmed by the crazy confort there where by playing on computer, and the insane simplicity of java redstone. I just improved exponentially in like three days! Now i just can't play minecraft bedrock anymore; i'm just so used to the java confort, practicality, consistency and overall "supremacy" that i'm not able to even build a double piston extender. in pocket edition.

[@smugless191]

I really like the bedrock creative inventory for building, you get to see so many items at once. I wish we could do something similar in Java. Hell, give us a bigger survival inventory if BE can handle big inventories.

[@TheOnePizzaKid]

He forgot to pick classic instead of pocket also he also forgot to make the ui smaller and to turn on split control (i actually do this to make my ui cooler and easier)

[@MECKENICALROBOT]

12:49 observer looking at dust fluctuates, also it as an extra redstone tick before it outputs. i prefer observers looking at rails or hoppers, as the observer will activate on the power in of whatever is powering the rail. real talk, if you account for java QC …in bedrock, there’s a few things you’ll need to account for, like that.

[@RunstarHomer]

You know what's worse than an ad in a youtube video? An ad that's dispersed throughout the ENTIRE youtube video.

[@FMasterMCPEG]

For the 3x3 We practically do it 1 wide For the 5x5 You need to use the 540b layout from RSP

[@ProfessorRex824]

dangit youtube! You can't make me 12 seconds late!!!

[@procraft4516]

Bro is making better redstone than me at first time and i am playing minecraft from 5 years 💀

[@WolfPackGamingOfficial]

I have genuinely never understood making and maintaining two separate versions of the game if they have so many differences.

[@hex1640]

performance and compatibility

[@WolfPackGamingOfficial]

@ if they have this many differences

[@frozenturbo8623]

​@hex1640 Only compatibility cause LCE had better performance

[@hex1640]

@@frozenturbo8623 exactly, only for consoles, they were maintaining so many different editions it was just so inefficient and clunky, so they merged it into one. lce was only really played with a cap of 60 and i'm not saying bedrock is the fastest

[@Ekipsogel]

Can't abandon java because they would get murdered by redstoners, can't abandon bedrock because that cuts off a large playerbase, can't combine them because some things like qc would break something whether added ir removed from both.

[@swizzamane8775]

Good to get to know it now before its inevitably too late 😅

[@good-sofa]

This is probably what it feels like to switch from an automatic gearbox to a manual one

[@pogsterplays]

Ok that was a very clever sponsorship transition

[@Phendet]

As someone who plays bedrock on mobile this video triggered me a lot. First, you can go to settings and change the gui to match pc. Second, you can customize your controls. I recommend the one with 5 buttons on the right because it offers a lot more customizability and allows for bedrock bridging. Finally, you can change the delay for breaking blocks in creative.

[@SimonsAstronomy]

We are doing this again 🔥

[@LEGEND_GAMERZ_44]

I am a pro bedrock redstoner so I will say that you can also take sculk sensor and wool as scull sensor gives 2 second pulse it's long I know but also you could choose redstone block or chest, droper and fill with items and take composted I did only till my own 4X4 door and 6X4 door and working number shower like 0 to 9 its ez bedrock redstone is ez but complicated and headaches.

[@Lyndelle_4010]

I used to play Mincraft on mobile for years, and I've become very much used to it… But seeing someone do it with this much struggle is both painful and hilarious to me😂

[@strategistaow3520]

4:04 use crosshair. using crosshair for phone is better than tapping on the screen

[@gorkiing66]

no.

[@juliocesarcamilo5132]

WHY DOESNT MOJANG JUST PUT QUASI-CONNECTIVITY IN BEDROCK?!?! "b- b- b- but its a bug" IS NOT A GOOD REASON!

[@cytrynowykisiel3715]

But its not about only qc, just lack qc would be fine.

[@Ekipsogel]

Because it's dumb and would break bedrock contraptions the same way the experimental changes would break java contraptions.

[@DreamyDan1]

@Ekipsogel You just angered so many java redstoners

[@Ekipsogel]

@DreamyDan1 i don't care, if they get mad about that they deserve to. They treat a bug that got left in because "why not, it's useful sometimes" as their president/king/equivalent ruler and fall apart whenever removing it is mentioned.

[@emoharalampiev1590]

I would not wish this torture on my worst enemy. You're insane XD

[@ValkyRiver]

Hey Purplers, do a little dance 🕺

[@shannonperegrin7357]

ive been playing bedrock ever since as a child and yes, bedrock redstone is always random if you try timing things in fast ticks it will just goes randomly

[@DarknexYT]

watching you build the mobile 3x3 was just brutal

[@AudiblePain]

Bedrock redstone is so janky it’s charming 😃

[@slimeyeetwhite]

Just yall know QC is quasi Conectivity which is quite essential in Java redstone esp in doors... and its quite a hard thing to get into when you have no idea what it is at the start

[@the_wobbly_witch]

advertisement done perfectly, unintrusive and will sell good. good job

[@jakewantstoplay1897]

I consider myself to be a,relatively good redstoner. On bedrock ive designed my own raid farms, redstone factory, all potion brewers and various mini games/escape rooms. But i refuse to build anything bigger than a 2x2 piston door because they drive me absolutely insane with the update order stuff

[@professorvatcraft]

As a person who do redstone on both bedrock and java, I can see why people struggle when trying to play the other version of Minecraft lol My only complain to Purplers is why the pocket control. It hurts my eyes seeing him not changing the size of the buttons :P

[@MECKENICALROBOT]

5:14 there you go… personally i prefer the backbone, but no complaints

[@Dubbysko]

i was making my go to sleep video playlist and i noticed its posted 15 minutes ago lol gn everyone!!

[@Stiky_Piston]

That touch control segment physically pained me 😬

[@SilverSabertooth]

Wait... why am I even watching this? The most redstone I've ever used is a pressure plate

[@J_Freak]

An IBXToyCat once said, like it or not, if Minecraft was made today (professionally) then the redstone would be programmed the Bedrock way, as the bigger differences Java has are due to bugs that instead of getting fixed became considered part of the function (e.g QC or sticky pistons letting go after a quick pulse)

[@pilotowl]

I would bot call "consistency" a bug.. bedrock redstone is just random, and you need to add delays for it not to be random.

[@tawsifking9336]

​@@pilotowl being random in those situations makes sense

[@oopsispilledmymilk7300]

@tawsifking9336 in what way does a vertical double piston extender without delay act different every time it’s triggered make sense?

[@Uxiy]

Played bedrock for years and absolutely hated doing anything technical cause of inconsistencies and stuff not making sense switched to Java recently and everything is way better and I can build things that works every time I am already a way better player than I was on bedrock

[@tawsifking9336]

@@oopsispilledmymilk7300 because there is no delay both piston should have a 50/50 chance to turn on Do you think one should have priority over the other based on where it is placed in the world? This also makes some contraptions just not work in many places

[@CuteKill93]

9:22 no mobile player knows Redstone that much lol you are actually the best bedrock redstoner no cap tho

[@Rail-t4r]

Yes I'm super happy

[@TheLegoAnimator863]

Thanks for making a Jeb door tutorial

[@Mrcriceto-v3j]

Purplers in the "why bedrock redstone sucks video: i never playing with bedrock's redstone One year later: OK I WILL PLAY WITH BEDROCK REDSTONE

[@lokrogamer29]

In the settings you can set your inventory to a different style

[@DaCookieLord]

When he used the controller i was surprised that he had an xbox

[@WaffleKingPancakes]

as a bedrock player I am happy to know that you like its Redstone so much 😊😊

[@MineTheLine]

yay finally my 3 years of (no longer existent) envy got someone to try it

[@Mateo-zi8ub]

"BuT jAva redStOne is MoRe BuGgy" If I ever see someone saying that again...

[@JadenM_XD]

You now know the pain of all bedrock players.

[@Nanj-oq1gt]

Im bedrock redstoner and i Play it on my phone and i was so confussed that you dont understand 😮

[@MasterAtRedstone]

That is actually unexpected

[@OfishalChill]

as a bedrock player. I NEED JAVA NOWWWW PLSSSSS PLS JAVA ON MOBILE PLSSS

[@reidmacdougall-g5m]

I do Redstone in bedrock a lot. The main problem is instead of ad you have weird activation randomness

[@Maxdeflax]

Nice vid man i subscribed 😊

[@PioteronYT]

Understand your pain. Idk if I will build any thing working in mc be

[@shargonreznove9969]

I was originally gonna comment something related, but after seeing a majority of the comments, i feel like if i did say something about redstone, im probably only going to be met by pitchforks

[@Oakleypaws]

Wait till he figures out part of the timings were due to P and C ticks 💀

[@G973_]

You're not a true bedrock player until you have an observer snake

[@FrightfulMC]

Tip 1: you can change button sizes on mobile Tip 2: you can change the menu to look like computer in settings

[@tanhrs8711]

Jazzi red managed to make a a wide door !

[@strings1984]

It works and thats better than all the ones i tried.

[@kennyxkazuki713]

one year i built a 5x5 piston door in pocket edition minecraft, school was very boring lol

[@JustAKid.]

Nubia's been sponsoring lots of people recently

[@Maxjoker98]

You can actually run Java edition on Android phones too. Including mods(probably needed for good performance).

[@z12as]

pojavlauncher

[@enderspider5001]

I love how he used the ″video that'll get you a lot more views″ as a way to have a sponsorship with a phone company lmao Like, he seriously didn't want to play bedrock, so the only way he'd even come close to it again is by getting literally paid!! XD

[@JamesRyder-w6l]

Make a Redstone elevator, I dare you in bedrock

[@Animator2023]

Now you can feel our pain…

[@OddOblivion]

great upload purplers

[@blu3260]

And this is the redstone system mojang wants the java version to be more like...

[@dungusfiles]

Bedrock is getting slowly better in terms of redstone

[@tvtrexrexbean2094]

na

[@Zubaboii]

Yes, but VERY slowly and java is much better in many ways

[@vinicus508]

Sure, you can say staying AWFUL means it’s slowly getting better

[@gearsgamer7115]

Id say java redstone is getting worse with the stupid updates

[@tvtrexrexbean2094]

@@gearsgamer7115 bruh how they added frickin remote redstone

[@kajatoth9151]

You can also play java Minecraft using pojav launcher

[@Gentolet_]

For phone, i think better using cursor than full touch screen.

[@xetelzow3516]

I just made a 3x3 in java without observers and 0 redstone experience, the one you made was FAR better

[@frozenturbo8623]

That's kinda the whole point, Java redstone is alot more consistent, logical and faster

[@SmitePlayz1]

@@frozenturbo8623 qc is NOT logical dude

[@MrTurtleWithTophat]

feel my pain