Q&A: Noah's Ark? Is Music Prohibited?

Original air date: November 19, 2011.

[@flutistnotflautist4740]

As a flutist who is interested and learning about Islam, I would be have a hard time understanding why instrumental music would be haram. Music does evoke emotions, but so does poetry, paintings, photography, etc. Music can definitely be used to manipulate people - especially when used with bad lyrics. Music can also be therapeutic and healing. It’s like a lot of things - when used well, it’s an incredible gift. When used for bad, it can be harmful. Side note: I stopped listening to the radio years ago for this reason.

[@thahiraiqbal7021]

I am writing a book answering why Allah has prohibited certain things. As for music, it is allowed in praise of Allah. Not to deviate from Allah

[@Swordwarrior1000]

You are right. In simple terms, the justification is that music drifts your heart away from thinking and glorifying the almighty.

[@ceooflonelinessinc.267]

All you need to know is that Islam is an evil ideology.

[@jeyhunhashimov3478]

It’s not haram. Allah didn’t prohibit music in Quran.

[@samahmad8203]

@@jeyhunhashimov3478 what are the benefits of music ?

[@premiumchannel6244]

1:53 He Starts to answer the Music Question

[@JSoulKeys]

Its so nice to hear this perspective and definitely leaves me feeling relieved. I think too many of these imams are power tripping on themselves by saying you will burn in hell and it is all haram no music, no nothing... you can't even play the piano or participate in music production. Im a revert to islam and before I reverted I had already been playing the piano for 28 years and did a degree in music production, it was and still is my career and my question to my imam was can I still make music (instrumental) and he said it is subjective, and don't worry just take your shahada. I felt unsettled but at least he wasn't one of those power tripping imams who said yes it is.. alhamdullilah, I thank Allah for this imam! I will follow his perspective.

[@alleballeism]

ofcourse. and by that standard al-ghazali had no iman, neither did rumi and a bunch of other scholars. music is a debated issue, saying that ANYONE that listens to music has/had no iman is a dangerous statement.

[@TerrorBite1]

Rumi had a imam his name is shams tabrez

[@dontinsultme4821]

@@TerrorBite1 rumi is sufi right?

[@eyessmile6173]

@@TerrorBite1 he sed iman my bro not imaam😂

[@kia3199]

Agree with him 100% Think about it; Saudi Arabia is the most religious country in the Islamic world. They banned pork, drinking, and adultery These things are written in the Quran multiple times. It’s crystal clear that those things at haram. There’s no clear indication that music is haram.

[@haydenbowlesmoments]

It's mentioned in sahih al bukhari , The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Among my ummah there will certainly be people who permit zinaa, silk, alcohol and musical instruments…” (Narrated by al-Bukhaari ta’leeqan, no. 5590; narrated as mawsool by al-Tabaraani and al-Bayhaqi. See al-Silsilah al-Saheehah by al-Albaani, 91).

[@lw97nilslinuswhitewaterweb15]

Alcohol is illegal tho

[@shaikmudassir6455]

@@haydenbowlesmoments bad translation and poor understanding of hadith

[@7khan012]

And Heroin too....

[@binyameen9018]

Be careful who you take your knowledge from. Scholars have done takfir on Shabir ally. He has no problem with homosexuals, and masturbation, and has dangerous beliefs.

[@lamiaislam1]

Thank you for your insight, Sheikh. Brothers and sisters, let us obstain from using offensive rhetoric towards other Islamic groups. We all have different interpretations and surely we all seek to please Allah SWT. No need for prideful comments. May Allah SWT be pleased with us all.

[@truthseeker630]

Thank you for the explanation Dr. Ally!

[@mouhamaddiallo176]

Anything that takes you away from the remembrance of Allah, the Qur'an, and the messenger of Allah PBUH, then that thing is HARAM...

[@leun6768]

Then this is pretty individual.

[@alexmaurilewis]

KZbin IS Haram

[@leun6768]

Àlex Mauri Source?

[@alexmaurilewis]

Because the KZbin takes you away from the Quran and Sunna.

[@leun6768]

@@alexmaurilewis Prove it to me.

[@user-k229]

Subhaan Allah. Dr Ally I Salute you! It is about time we had scholars like you who speak with wisdom and the correct understanding from the Quran. I am so glad you have clarified the verse that Allah states about vain speech. This verse IS NOT referring to music. I agree with you. Many millions of hadith lovers will disagree! Disregard them. The Ultimate Judge is Allah and not Bokhari et al. The Quran strongly condemns scriptures or hadith other than The Hadith of Allah i.e Al-Quran. Thanks once again.

[@Crazy_Rich_Asian]

Khal7861 you speak like a quranite.

[@abdulmalikmcgill6221]

Also just look up tafseer ibn kathir on the verse he talking about on Quran 31:6

[@alexojideagu]

Exactly. Can anyone name me one Islamic country where Musical instruments are banned from sale? There are musical instrument shops in Saudi Arabia. But the Salafis cannot handle this. Name me an Islamic country that allows Alcohol? Alcohol is clear.

[@MrJaipaul1]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/f2aaY6toirCCp6s false wisdom exposed, fallen angel is exposed and its agenda

[@youknewmebefore]

So.. I assume you don’t know how to offer salah.. cz you don’t care about Al-bukhari..So.. there’s no verse in the quran How to pray? No verse.. Damn it.. I don’t know what are you following!

[@johnnygoodman2003]

Music and music literacy is one of the 9 intelligence. It has been studied and known that music benefits the mind and improves memory and mathematics skills. Not listening to music is like getting rid of an important nutrient in your diet. Music is a mental nutrient. People have been making music since the stone ages.

[@Farhadmoh]

Hadith takes people to dark ages, the early Islamic golden age did not rely on these Hadith

[@mrtaz4340]

He pointed out the truth and the extrimest salafis are angry now lol

[@abdulmalikmcgill6221]

Also just look up tafseer ibn kathir on the verse he talking about on Quran 31:6

[@abdulmalikmcgill6221]

You may not even know anything about salafis because of whatever you hear. Hopefully these videos clear it up brother and I hope that, In Shaa Allah, you will try and understand with an open heart and with an objective lens. And, to clear up any ignorance that you may have from it. From Digital Mimbar - kzbin.info/www/bejne/iaami6iEos1mosk From ahlulsunnahwaljammah - kzbin.info/www/bejne/a4bNomR4gr6Ciqs From Dawah2Islam - kzbin.info/www/bejne/eaXRhXSHqdR6fcU

[@user-rp5ix9vk8d]

@@abdulmalikmcgill6221 Here is an interesting article that analyses all the opinions regarding Music in general. islamicmusichub.com/blogs/is-music-haram-or-halal-in-islam There appear to be 3 main opinions about it, universally we can all agree that bad music that promotes haraam is haraam. However, it is dangerous to tell someone they're going to hell for simply listening to music with no intention of worshiping other than Allah or to inflate one's haraam oriented mindset with haraam lyrics. Only Allah will be the final judge for humanity. When there exists different scholarly opinions with valid reasoning (as studying Hadiths is a science in it's own right), you should respect their choice and not show a judgemental attitude. Human psychology does not work this way when people are constantly judged by people's opinions. The ummah today is disconnected from the Quran and is broken because of sectarianism and this overly judging attitude. Music is controversial in Islam as different people have different opinions, all of which are valid according to the correct methodology of reasoning, due to *contradicting* hadiths, it is important to understand context and meaning in detail, considering why different ulema have different opinions. We cannot say we're right and they're wrong because this is exactly what creates division within the Ummah. I ask you and others to consider this when giving a view point in Islam, to acknowledge the existence of other opinions and not to judge others.

[@abdulmalikmcgill6221]

@@user-rp5ix9vk8d Dear brother or sister, this article has some distortion in some sense to begin with, with all due respect. For example, It can't even give the full tafsir of the ayat in surah luqman ayah 6 properly, it only took a portion from tafsir ibn kathir. This matter was made clear in the books of tafsir, the mufasireen from the sahabas, the tabieen, and the likes that music is Haram and that the only instrument that was permitted on occasions such as weddings, eid, was the instrument called the daff. That's it. This is clearly mentioned in the Quran and it's explanation as mentioned earlier and the authentic AHadeeth regarding the matter of music being Haram in the general sense (with the exceptions like I mentioned earlier, about the daff being the only instrument that was permissible and no other instrument) is clear from multiple aunthentically reports from the companians of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him). It sounds like, with all due respect fellow brother or sister in Islam, that these people who try to claim such things as permissible are doing so based off their shahawat (desires) or shubuhats (doubts). People have the tendency nowadays, even apart from music, to make certain things that are halal, Haram (which is an act of kufr), because one is changing the Legislator's (Allah) Legislation in the deen to fit their desire and this is something I seek refuge from first and foremost my dear brother or sister and I hope that every Muslim seeks refuge from it. Is there such thing as valid difference of opinion in islam? Yes, but this isn't one of them. The people want to make such matters controversial making the exception the general. For example, when it was mention the authentic AHadeeth of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) about him allowing the girls to play the daff for that one day because of the occasion. The article tried to make it seem like a proof for music being permissible in this regard in a general sense where it can be played any time when there is the Quran and the other authentic AHadeeth that makes it clear that musical instruments are Haram. And when you look closer in the hadeeth you see that Abu Bakr, who was the best man on Earth after the anbiya (prophets), told them to stop doing what they were doing when he saw this, showing that it's impermissible, and he was correct in the sense that music was Haram in the general sense, but the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) made it clear since it was a special occasion they can play the daff. Musical instruments is Haram in the general sense, and the only musical instrument that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) allowed was the daff on occasions like weddings and eid for example. No controversy whatsoever. If that is the case we can make a lot a controversy over so many matters in this deen. Take pork for example. We know it's Haram in the general sense. Is there a time we are allowed to eat it? If one is starving in the middle of nowhere and there isn't anything for this man or woman to eat, and this person is about to die and needs to eat and there it's nothing but pigs than this person has to eat the pig for this person to survive. And it's permissible. But I'm not going to make the exception the general. meaning I'm not going to be like old guys we can eat pork now because it's accepted in this regard therefore we are allowed to actually eat pork (in a general sense). And I can say all this was my difference of opinion, so we can have pork to eat whenever you want, just because of an exception? That would be incorrect. There is no difference of opinion in this matter. Like wise with musical instruments, in the general sense it is Haram and if you read the full tafsir from ibn kathir and others from the mufasireen it is clear from the Quran and on top of that there are authentic narrations that mentions explicitly that's musical instruments is not permissible in the strict, general sense. And there are exceptions for such as wedding and eid like mentioned in the narrations. read the link in which I posted earlier because I chose that link specifically because it is verified by scholars and they take contemporary scholars, prominent scholars, evidence from Quran and Sunnah , etc. And explains it in great detail as you can see and beautifully explained. Pretty easy to comprehend when you read their answers. And they take different valid scholarly opinions as well when there is a valid difference of opinion. Such like from the 4 madhabs or amongst contemporary scholars themselves, etc. I hope it didn't seem like I was trying to attack you in any sort of way dear brother or sister in Islam. I just wanted to clarify on points in which people often get confused on because I'm still studying as well. And you got to be careful where your sources are coming from my dear brother sister because there's others out there that can easily missguided an individual I've seen them where it's just outright wrong and which people could just see it. And there are others which are pretty slick with, and that is why it is important for all of us to seek the proper knowledge from the correct people. Anyways I hope this answer wasn't too long I hope I explained everything well. I could have said much more but I'm very tired but I'mma leave to links for you to read one of them is the one from earlier and I suggest that you read that very closely to the best of your abilities In Shaa Allah. Also I will be sending another link soon written by a student who went to the University in Makkah (Umm Al Qura), which is a big uni, regarding the issue of music. Very deep but it's very beneficial I know that you would benefit greatly from. May Allah increase us and beneficial knowledge in to take the means to seek beneficial Knowledge from the correct understanding and from correct sources. May Allah give us and the Muslims the best in this life and in the hereafter. Ameen. P.S. again I hope I wasn't rude in any way because I surely didn't mean to make it come out like that. Please forgive me if you felt like I was rude in anyway. I was just trying to explain and to benefit us both because I've been there like where you been and many others. so I'm trying to explain it in the best possible way that I can in from the reliable sources. السلام عليكم ورحمه الله وبركاته

[@abdulmalikmcgill6221]

@@user-rp5ix9vk8d please brother or sister to me if you need clarification on anyting and I'll do my best to answer. Here is the second link: d1.islamhouse.com/data/en/ih_books/single/en_Music_and_Singing.pdf

[@alii66]

An ulema in Undelucia wrote a risaleh about music (I thought his name was Ibn Abd, not sure). Due to several hadiths which are cotradictionary to each other, he came to this conclusion (just like the İmam above). Music which feeds the Nafs (derives from the Quran) is haram, which doesn't feeds the Nafs are permitted. So that means, stay away from gangsta rap etc. and listen to good nasheed if you desire.

[@kumpulanvidiohiburan9801]

alii66 ao can we combine azan with discotic or hip hop genre?

[@LittlePalmTreee]

@@kumpulanvidiohiburan9801 No… I highly recommend you not to

[@Aripuni1]

then just listen to instrumental music, its safe

[@Farhadmoh]

Not just good nasheed, music on life, poverty, marriage romance is all good providing language is good

[@AshrafAli-is4wv]

Yes music can be bad, aa it can leads to clubbing, drinking and can take you away from the right path, but we can't say Allah totally prohibited because if something is permissible and we making it prohibited also is a sin. If something is unclear, we should ask Allah to shed light on it.

[@Yasmin-ue4qb]

It does not say anywhere in Quran that music is haram there good music and bad music

[@binyameen9018]

@@Yasmin-ue4qb “And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) to mislead (men) from the path of Allaah…” [Luqmaan 31:6] Be careful whom you take your knowledge from, Shabir is lost.

[@RIPer-rg2cz]

Eating sweets can lead to addiction for sugary foods, obesity and illnesses that can lead you far away from faith. Do us a favour and live on bread and water for the rest of your life, okay? There's good and bad in everything. If you decide to ignore the good and cherry pick the bad then everything can be haram.

[@binyameen9018]

@@RIPer-rg2cz shhh clown

[@farisyahya5902]

@@binyameen9018 And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) *to* mislead (men) from the path of Allaah…” [Luqmaan 31:6] also mufassirun had other different interpretations

[@S.Tagore]

Amir ibn Sa'd said: "Going in and finding Qarazah ibn Ka'b and AbuMas'ud al-Ansari at a wedding where girls were singing" I said, "Is this being done in the presence of you two who are companions of Allah's Messenger (peace be upon him) and were present at Badr?" They replied, "Sit down if you wish and listen along with us, or go away if you wish, for we have been given licence for amusement at a wedding." Nasa'i transmitted it. Tirmidi Sharif Hadis

[@Suhelahmed_1729]

If you go by such unauthentic and n number of hadith you will end up forbidding breathing

[@darko7mc186]

​@@Suhelahmed_1729 how is it unauthentic? Please explain to us w/o spreading Personal Opinions. We don't care about your opinions about Music. We need Factual Information to be convinced.

[@statixlaw5675]

Specifically women singing at weddings about permissible things is halal and they should not be heard by men. Music is still haram though and one of the multiple evidences is this: The Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said: “Among my ummah there will certainly be people who permit zina, silk, alcohol and musical instruments…” (Narrated by al-Bukhari ta’liqan, no. 5590; narrated as mawsul by al-Tabarani and al-Bayhaqi. See al-Silsilah al-Sahihah by al-Albani, 91)

[@askiaeducationalnetwork4978]

You cannot take your scholars as your Lord. This is what the Christians did and do, be careful or you will be commenting shirk

[@leun6768]

We take scholars for fatwa, nothing else. Why are you watching this then if you are so contempt

[@MrSaylica]

Yes I agree. Many people think scholars can't make mistakes and don't even check their rulings against Quran or even common sense. When you start reading the Quran in a language you understand you will start to see that many nonsense things that you were told was part of religion actually are not.

[@saiyajinnoouji9871]

It's really weird some say it's prohibited some say it's not, very frustrating

[@darko7mc186]

Because nowhere in the Quran, Music & it's instruments was ever mentioned for the sake of it's prohibition. Only the Ahadiths of Al-Bukhari does. Yet the Hadith itself is contradicting about this topic.

[@minhajdesigns]

It's not prohibited. Period. If it was Haram, it would be mentioned in the Quran clearly. It's only prohibited if it contains vulgar stuff. And so anything, if u speak bad or abusive words to someone it's Haram. The Quran doesn't go in specifics it only gives a principle and everything under that principle would be taken into consideration. Try to stick to the Quran more than Hadiths. Hadiths are just a historical records. Consider only those hadiths that align with the Quran. Discard others. JazakAllah.

[@gonfreecss9801]

Isalm ohalakoume i have a very sensitive and serious subject to talk about, i deal with depression and i have attempted suicide multiple time before. I lisent to music when sad because it helps me to feel better (the songs i lisent to are all about self love and remembering yourself as a child and accepting yourself and tey your best at being happy and basically there is no bad words or anything that has to do with shirk) and it help me to get the sadness out of me, so does it still mean its haram even tho it helps me with my mental health (+i pray every sallah without even 2 min delay and i finish one ayyah from the Quran everyday no stop and i always remember allah with EVEYTHING i do i love allah so much words can not Express amd i kesp teaching my familly about the things i know of the quran and every ayah i finish i go amd look for its explanation so iam a person who is extremely close to alalh (swt) ) Islam oualakoune thank you my muslims brother and please try understand and answer as fast as possible 💜

[@farhiyamohamed___]

Manshallah I will keep u in my prayers and dua could you recommend me the music u listen to

[@Crystalclear-so2yr]

Listen to the Quran InshAllah. Trust me it’s way better than music. And also try listening to Nasheeds as well 😊

[@gonfreecss9801]

@@Crystalclear-so2yr I do and thank you

[@Crystalclear-so2yr]

@@gonfreecss9801 Your welcome 🙏 May Allah (SWT) help you get through your problems and may Allah (SWT) bless you with a happy life. Ameen 🤲😊

[@gonfreecss9801]

@@Crystalclear-so2yr thank you a lot

[@aboveorbittv9633]

Please answer with honesty! What if an artist wanted to combat allll of This evil music with peaceful music with a message that turned people TOWARDS the Quran & Allah instead of away from! Please answer brothers and sisters!

[@tahsinhaider9770]

not sure

[@imadhhisham6709]

The music that is created today is definitely not good for our soul. We cannot find peace in the Qur'an if we mix both music and Qur'an. There are different degrees to which music can be harmful But then I'd recommend that Islamic nasheeds/poetry with strictly vocals by artists such as brother Siedd or brother Omar Esa are declared by scholars as far as I've heard to be types of music that we as Muslims can listen to!

[@mansoorkaghaz9669]

I am surprised that dr Shabir does not understand that prophet Daoud alislam who's miracle was singing and music and he could bring birds down by his sound and make mountains sing .in echo that melted the iron ..eventually which is so deep yet he did not speak of it... Which shows that the utmost beauty of human voice is in singing and just like Yousef alislam was a perfection of beauty so was Daoud th perfection of voice .. and if U understand the meaning of music , recitation, azan and singing are no different and also most chapters of Koran are musical and has drum sound and music and melody but one has to be an expert in it

[@drac.96]

1:59 music

[@TraPortal007]

I’m a rapper who performs in United States who accepted Islam and had my music message follow my beliefs but use it as a tool to bring other people from music culture closer to Islam

[@oskadavid2964]

Music is not Haraam people have invented a lie against God

[@abdulmalikmcgill6221]

Also just simply read the tafsir ibn kathir of the quran verse he mention [31:6]

[@S.Tagore]

Amir ibn Sa'd said: "Going in and finding Qarazah ibn Ka'b and AbuMas'ud al-Ansari at a wedding where girls were singing" I said, "Is this being done in the presence of you two who are companions of Allah's Messenger (peace be upon him) and were present at Badr?" They replied, "Sit down if you wish and listen along with us, or go away if you wish, for we have been given licence for amusement at a wedding." Nasa'i transmitted it. Tirmidi Sharif Hadis

[@binyameen9018]

"Music and Quran, cannot be in your heart at the same time"

[@oskadavid2964]

@@binyameen9018 says you or God?

[@binyameen9018]

“And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) to mislead (men) from the path of Allaah…” [Luqmaan 31:6] Allah says it

[@Aripuni1]

music is part of human art and knowledge, just dont understand why some muslim in another part of the world say its haram, when its never stated haram in the quran

[@waseemraza784]

Everything that may lead you to make you ignorant of the remembrance of Allah, is not permissible and you put most of the time in it, how would you be properly making preparations for the final day?

[@PowerGurhl]

Thank you for clearing this up….because i literally could not imagine that god would give people a talent and an enjoyable aspect of life haram. I do agree music of today is terrible but there’s so much beautiful music out there with just nothing but instruments. Then again the Quran recitation is music itself.

[@Mustafa_Shahzad]

We have clear hadiths prohibiting music. And the Quran recitation is not music! It is recitation.

[@showupnur1947]

Brother, Qur'an recitation is not Music.

[@meow_258]

@@Mustafa_Shahzad could you tell me some of those hadiths please

[@ayako_samaa]

@@meow_258 (1) Hadhrat Abu Maalik Ash'ari (radhiyallahu anhu) says that he heard Rasulullah (sallallahu alayhi wasallam) say: "Most certainly, there will be in my Ummah people who will make lawful fornication, silk, liquor and musical instruments." (Bukhaari)

[@edmqnd8128]

@@Mustafa_Shahzad yes it’s music, it’s not singing. Calling it singing is haram but it is still music indeed. A person recites in a melodic voice in a specific key and usually to a stable bpm. That’s music man.

[@LeviHortonsMusic]

EXCELLENT thanks!

[@booksolved2.172]

Sir, Dr.shabir Ally , I request you to explain al Bukhari hadith no. 5590 and also explain the Verse no.6 of surah Al lukman ... please.

[@binyameen9018]

for reall, he's lost

[@hbsblkk3842]

He’s using Quranic evidence which surpasses any Hadith.

[@-zohan]

@@hbsblkk3842there are two sources of shariah, 1) Quran 2) saheeh sunnah. And there is clear report in the sunnah about prohibition of music. Sunnah is the explanation of the quran and Allah says, An-Najm 53:3 وَمَا يَنطِقُ عَنِ ٱلۡهَوَىٰٓ Nor does he speak from [his own] inclination. The prophet didn’t forbid us from anything because he wished rather it is Allah who sends revelation to the prophet (sm) to guide mankind. Alhamdullila hi rabbil Alamin wa salatu was salam ala rasul (sm)

[@-zohan]

@@hbsblkk3842there are two sources of shariah, 1) Quran 2) saheeh sunnah. And there is clear report in the sunnah about prohibition of music. Sunnah is the explanation of the quran and Allah says, An-Najm 53:3 وَمَا يَنطِقُ عَنِ ٱلۡهَوَىٰٓ Nor does he speak from [his own] inclination. The prophet didn’t forbid us from anything because he wished rather it is Allah who sends revelation to the prophet (sm) to guide mankind. Alhamdullila hi rabbil Alamin wa salatu was salam ala rasul (sm)

[@kid_from_karachi]

In the end of his answer for music he says 4:18 "we can say that this is not entirely clear and the original presumption is that it is permissible."

[@hamzasohail6304]

Im confused becuase alot of people keep mentioning the hadith about how the Prophet peace be upon him says "“Among my ummah there will certainly be people who permit zinaa, silk, alcohol and musical instruments…” (Narrated by al-Bukhaari ta’leeqan, no. 5590; narrated as mawsool by al-Tabaraani and al-Bayhaqi. See al-Silsilah al-Saheehah by al-Albaani, 91). Yet if this is true why would the Prophet peace be upon him allow the duff to be played in certian situations if he meant all musical instruments? Reply

[@ceooflonelinessinc.267]

All you need to know ist that Islam is evil.

[@andipajaziti5388]

all of us the people saying Thank You to the sheikh, we are just relieved and we are helping ourselves feel better because he didnt specifically and excatly say that music is haram and so we're all like yesss sheikh, may Allah bless you, youre the best !! however, it is incredibly dangereous, i fear that we are gambling on this specific topic because we dont know for sure and the majority say that it is not permissible because lets be honest the music that we listen to either puts us in a depressive state or in a party mood which makes our next actions hmm not so bright and that leads us away from Allah, we should all be careful and do the things that do not distract us from his majesty because it starts like that and in no time we could find ourselves far away from home and we would not even know how to get back safe and sound !! May Allah forgive us all,purify us and the souls that he created in us and may he always be pleased with us !!

[@Anonym_.962]

Amin well Said

[@saygee5006]

You said either makes us depressed or in a party mood, what about using it for workouts, what’s the evil in this?

[@feminaabdulkareem5297]

Aameen

[@feminaabdulkareem5297]

There are many hadiths that talk about its prohibition. Please research. Majority of Islamic scholars have said that music is haram based on clear evidences. Please don't fall into the trap of Shaitan , brothers and sisters. Music definitely takes you away from the remembrance of Allah. Talking out of experience. Qur'an will not reside in a heart where there is Music. It's like oil and water. Please take care of your emaan . Don't just blindly follow any imam. May Allah guide us all to the right path. Aameen.

[@peace_y123]

Finally Understood the Hadith of Muhammad SAW.I was confused for a long time why will people make music halal after reading the authentic hadith.But Indeed there are some people who try to make it halal.

[@peace_y123]

All instruments are haram then why duff is same as "All dead animals are haram then why fish" ?. Always look at exceptions Given by Muhammad SAW while talking about broader classification

[@TheGynus]

We follow the word of god, if Allah never said it in the Qur’an, then it is not haram. Simple as that

[@mrrozhok2504]

Prophet said its haram. So it is. Simple as that

[@Truth_Seeker1]

@@mrrozhok2504It doesn’t say music is harm it says musical instruments.

[@Truth_Seeker1]

Theres a Hadith which says musical instruments are haram.

[@supakhan23]

The Quran doesn't explain how to pray, so then how do you know how to pray your 5 salat?

[@ayako_samaa]

@@supakhan23yeah but the Quran says that you HAVE to pray. There’s the difference

[@msarwar01]

I know all of us are brothers and sisters in Islam, but it’s weird to hear Safiyyah calling her dad, Shabir a brother!! 😊

[@jimmybeam1550]

As a Muslim, i must say, Muslims frustrate me. Allah never deemed music as haram. Please show where in Quran music is declared haram? Q66:1: O Prophet! Why do you prohibit from what Allah has made lawful to you, seeking to please your wives? And Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful. Q5:87 O you who have believed, do not prohibit the good things which Allāh has made lawful to you and do not transgress. Indeed, Allāh does not like transgressors. Quran 5:68 O you who have believed, do not prohibit the good things which Allāh has made lawful to you and do not transgress. Indeed, Allāh does not like transgressors.

[@pensatorseven1898]

Thank you for this.

[@abudujana13]

JAZAKALLAH KHAIR

[@Muslimsinternational]

When he says some people say lahwul hadith referes to music he is talking about the companions of nabi ﷺ, who at that time said music comes under lahwul hadith. Funny how he left that part out.

[@julianocean1734]

Salafists are like the Sith in Star Wars, they talk in absolute

[@rooblez9005]

They are khawarij

[@shabasubha7356]

I am confused. Those who says music is haram Don't have any quran or hadith evidence. They just say it's haram without any reason like alcohol.and use the weak hadith as an evidence. But al quaran mention alcohol many times.but music was not in quran. What to trust?

[@anntalks2569]

All I know is that there is a hadith

[@hbsblkk3842]

Quran

[@Asumareh1]

@@anntalks2569 is Hadith the word or God?

[@maxx418]

@@Asumareh1 Exactly what I have been asking. It is a manmade book. Not saying everything in the Hadith is wrong but how do they know that the people who wrote those Hadiths don't have cultural or political connection to what they wrote in there. The Quran is the word of Allah and I think if it was a sin that could take you to hell fire, Allah will state it clearly.

[@serialkiller928]

Assalam o Alaikum Sheikh I am a Pakistani. In our country noor bashr is a desputed issue plz make a vedeo about it

[@parhamgamerpprroo7641]

That was true. Thank you for the video. But let me mention that today's music is not that cool. Almost all of the singers nowadays are addicted to drugs or haram things and some of the musics when you reverse them, they have some devil messages. So my brothers and sisters, please don't get too close to music and get closer to Quran and the Allah(SWT)

[@wherejerry2592]

There is a Hadith (Sahih Al-Bukhari 5590) that states: There will appear people in my ummah, who will hold adultery, silk (worn by men), alcohol and the playing of musical instruments to be permissible. I am no scholar but I feel this goes against what is being said, could someone more knowledgeable clarify if I am mistaken?

[@hbsblkk3842]

The argument is that unless stated Haraam in the Quran by God then it is allowed. Imo any Hadith that outlaws something without Quranic backing is going against God and must be disregarded. God clearly says in the Quran don’t assign things to Him for which He hasnt said. Now music isn’t outlawed in the Quran so it’s permissible. That being said, if you listen to music about fornication and generally degenerate things then that would be a different matter as they are clearly sins in the Quran.

[@toka4392]

I literally look up to you sheikh

[@surajratti1329]

I just love music

[@mohamadkhateeb402]

Salafis and Wahabbis, please offer a verse which states that موسيقى "music" is impermissible.

[@josipcolic5304]

That word didn't even exist in that time...

[@mohamadkhateeb402]

@@josipcolic5304 Exactly.

[@lucyf9034]

@@josipcolic5304 What? LOL The Bible and The Torah are older and mention music.

[@josipcolic5304]

@@lucyf9034 the modern arabic word موسيقى didn't exist in arabic back than, it's borrowed from english, and this guy wants exactly this word to be written in Quran

[@binyameen9018]

“And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) to mislead (men) from the path of Allaah…” [Luqmaan 31:6]

[@mariamahq3742]

Evidence of prohibition of music and singing in the Quran and Sunnah Allah says in Surah Luqman (interpretation of the meaning): “And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) to mislead (men) from the path of Allah…” [Luqman 31:6]

[@jimmybeam1550]

I am absolutely sick of the elementary display of Qurans comprehension by Muslims. Quran says 'IDLE TALK', now had Allah wanted that to imply MUSIC Allah would have stated music. Did Allah run out of words? See this is the twisted juggling of Allahs verses employed by hadith worshippers. Music not haram, idle talk is to be avoided. Even Quran doesn't say haram, does it Miriam? Idle talk can be in many forms. Yes music CAN contain idle misleading lyrics but NOT ALL MUSIC only certain music. Idle talk comes in many forms, such as what you just did, you mislead from Allah true words and added music to the translation. Sickening!

[@GentleGazer162]

About Noah float, is it the whole earth?

[@velbo7712]

Asalamu 3alaykum Are musical instruments still haram, even if I always pray, fast, ...? I also listen quran recitation almost every day and also read quran more and more. For example; listening to music (with instruments) while playing. I personally don't feel like it gets in my path of islam. I have been struggeling A LOT about this and people around me said that I have been thinkig too much about this. Islam is simple, isn't it only haram if it leads you to do bad things and moves you aways from islam?

[@velbo7712]

Please help me

[@velbo7712]

@Abdülhamid thank you. The only time I actlly wanna play music is during gaming, NOT MORE! BUT I guess it is only haram when you forget obligatry acts right?

[@velbo7712]

@NikNok Dawah Thank you brother/ sister. I appriciate the time you took to write me this. I haven't listened to music since beginning of Ramadan ( this year). I just wasn't sure if it was A 100% HARAM all the time. I'll just not listen then Insha Allah. Nothing is worth Jahannam. If you are a brother, it will be nice to know you more. So if you want, you can send me your insta. Again, thank you. 💚

[@Haziq-xq1nr]

@Not sure the daf is also a musical instrument

[@darkheart9668]

@@velbo7712 can you repeat what NikNok Dawah responded you with? I would like to see what they said but the comment is not being shown

[@YamnayaSintash]

Her Hijab is really pretty.

[@artbella01]

I heard the sahi bukhari hadith is authenticated by abu daudh...and this hadith is the based of musical instruments haram and the majority of scholars and muslims follow this strongly Didn’t get a clear view

[@Aadil-kx8be]

Asalaamualaikum. We are living at a time where time is ticking fast. Music can lead to addiction. With that being said, it can then be very time consuming. And then you got sports broadcasted on television which is another time consumer. And then you got soaps, movies, media, gaming platforms, paying a visit to your friends/family, time spent at work, etc. My question is, how much time do we have remaining for our Deen?

[@saniatamanna7763]

Dear bro. My father watches tv (regularly) sometimes music also but he never misses his prayer . He watches tv every evening two hours after maghrib namaz. After watching it he again get ready for his isha namaz. He likes dance also but he never forget to remember me about my deen when I pass my time idlely. But I don't think so a person who watches TV ,hears little bit music and also likes dancing he gets away from his deen. In my house I don't think so. But about others I don't know

[@alyzak.8997]

Music is like the sword. In itself it is just a tool, it's usage can make it halal or haram. You may find modern music today that doesn't take you away from Allah SWT but it is rare. Classical music is a nice alternative. But whatever it may be, it must be listened to in moderation so that your heart is still in the Quran. The moment music moves you more than the Quran, beware you have crossed the boundary to the Shaytan's path.

[@tomshop8943]

thank you brather i totally agree with you . Quran , Surah Ali'Imran-7 It is He who has sent down to you, [O Muḥammad], the Book; in it are verses [that are] precise - they are the foundation of the Book - and others unspecific.1 As for those in whose hearts is deviation [from truth], they will follow that of it which is unspecific, seeking discord and seeking an interpretation [suitable to them]. And no one knows its [true] interpretation except Allāh. But those firm in knowledge say, "We believe in it. All [of it] is from our Lord." And no one will be reminded except those of understanding.

[@jamsheerp9304]

بَابُ الزُّهْدِ والْوَرَعِ 1482- عَنِ النُّعْمَانِ بْنِ بَشِيرٍ رَضِيَ اللَّهُ عَنْهُمَا قَالَ: سَمِعْتُ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ ﷺ يَقُولُ -وأَهْوَى النُّعْمَانُ بِإِصْبَعَيْهِ إِلَى أُذُنَيْهِ: إِنَّ الْحَلَالَ بَيِّنٌ، والْحَرَامَ بَيِّنٌ، وبَيْنَهُمَا مُشْتَبِهَاتٌ لَا يَعْلَمُهُنَّ كَثِيرٌ مِنَ النَّاسِ، فَمَنِ اتَّقَى الشُّبُهَاتِ فَقَدِ اسْتَبْرَأَ لِدِينِهِ، وعِرْضِهِ، ومَنْ وقَعَ فِي الشُّبُهَاتِ وقَعَ فِي الْحَرَامِ، كَالرَّاعِي يَرْعَى حَوْلَ الْحِمَى، يُوشِكُ أَنْ يَقَعَ فِيهِ، أَلَا وإِنَّ لِكُلِّ مَلِكٍ حِمًى، أَلَا وإِنَّ حِمَى اللَّهِ مَحَارِمُهُ، أَلَا وإِنَّ فِي الْجَسَدِ مُضْغَةً إِذَا صَلَحَتْ صَلَحَ الْجَسَدُ كُلُّهُ، وإِذَا فَسَدَتْ فَسَدَ الْجَسَدُ كُلُّهُ، أَلَا وهِيَ الْقَلْبُ

[@ousmanhamid8086]

I do not agree with his response and explanation on music

[@koolmoedee8954]

Then who do u agree with and where is the clear evidence of whatever u agree with.

[@binyameen9018]

@@koolmoedee8954 “And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) to mislead (men) from the path of Allaah…” [Luqmaan 31:6]

[@ryanthomas7119]

@@binyameen9018 How is “Idle talk” equated with music? That doesn’t even make sense. I’m not a scholar so could you enlighten me?

[@mustafarizvi4275]

We don’t take our Deen from the Quran only. We also take it from the Sunnah, and listening to musical instruments is clearly haram according to hadiths of our Prophet ﷺ. Their is a concensus among almost every scholar and all 4 madhabs agree on this. Who are we to go against the teachings of the sahabah and the best generations and the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ? Respectfully our opinion doesn’t matter. Whats Haram is Haram even if everyone is doing it, whats Halal is Halal even if no one is doing it.

[@cf5397]

Lol okay so you have the credentials to overwrite Fatwah?

[@jimmybeam1550]

U people worship hadith and associate it with Allah. Good luck, you're gonna need it.

[@saliamilasan9536]

Drum is a music in sound especially now a days modified into several fashions and sounds. if music for you is for relaxation and comport. go ahead, Allah knows best

[@boruto750]

Thank you for clearing this up that the music is not Haram. Now I can listen to Nicki Minaj and Lil Naz songs.

[@jimmybeam1550]

You illogical twisted dummies, u people are truly sheeps. Go do whatever you want.

[@raneemchrabakh7743]

It has to have lawful lyrics and/or meaning thi

[@kumpulanvidiohiburan9801]

Dear dr. Shabir, can we combine azan to a discotic music or hip hop or any other genre that will sound more modern and enjoyable?

[@burgeulfassal1523]

Kumpulan vidio hiburan yes you can, coba aja

[@no-sw8ry]

That sounds so wrong dont mix the Azan with instruments

[@CreativeNM-NMworks]

I think that will be very disrespectful. Keep what is sacred, the way it is. He is not telling you the truth, so that you can now abuse your values

[@Bean-qt4dy]

Flutes represent Pan the Greek God of rustic music who played musical instruments like flute

[@saltranger]

Not convinced by what he said. Majority of Ulema wont go with him.

[@utoob22]

Maybe majority wont but doesnt mean hes wrong

[@911beats]

@AsaD Ali thats a logical fallacy, in the Islamic corpus, things to be haram have to clearly stated not the other way around.

[@911beats]

@AsaD Ali this is false, Affirming a disjunct is not used by scholars to determine what is halal and is haram and they use hadith and other quranic evidences , this can be pointed out by saying the opposite as "there quran does not say its haram, therefore it is halal" this will then need to be proved using evidence backed up from the quran and the hadith to avoid the logical fallacy, Shabir Ally has given clear examples of why there is no clear evidence of general music being haram from the quaran and hadiths. Now as you claim that Music is haram then you have to back up your argument using the Quran and hadith to show why your point is true or you still fall into the logical fallacy .

[@ndumisocele3827]

@AsaD Ali the Quran actually prohibit one from making haram that which Allah has made permissible. That is why some people would say everything is halaal unless it is clearly stated to be haraam.

[@binyameen9018]

@@utoob22 no, “And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) to mislead (men) from the path of Allaah…” [Luqmaan 31:6]

[@amaarnazarani9685]

I'm a muslim and a metalhead

[@rubafathima4820]

Shut and adjust with it!!!!

[@alleballeism]

what you mean to say is "it messes MY iman up" .. stop assuming things.

[@farhanrafeed3944]

To sumarise those who are saying that music is haram, they are following the truth and not their desires. On the other hand, those who are saying that music is not haram, they are just following their desires and likes and trying to make their life easy... It is clearly indicated in surah luqman and sahih bukhari that music is haram now its upto you to what to follow... pleae check 31:6 of surah luqman and bukhari 5590

[@cf5397]

Ignoring differences and discussion in the Ummah is following your desires (bias), this is a sad excuse for people who cite two hadith and ignore all they dislike incluing Fatwah

[@abdulrazaqramat3728]

So did God say, we shouldn’t seek out any desires, remember Islam is a religion of moderation, isn’t wanting lot of money a desire?

[@mdjosimuddin4244]

​@@abdulrazaqramat3728 who told you Islam is a religion of moderation 😂😂😂. Please first read whole quran then ask those so called scholars who have said those words to you.

[@notionSlave]

How do you run out of time in 5 minutes lol. Literally less than five minutes.

[@vladimirmach6145]

May Allah bless Dr. Shabir Ally.

[@absaly]

music is small footsteps towards shaytan iblis path..........so why would you want to follow shaytans devils footsteps?

[@randomguyoninternet7618]

I heard there is a hadith where prophet(pbuh) said time will come when the believer will think for fornicating, drinking intoxication, Listening to musical instruments halal( something like this) It is mentioned in shahi bukhari?

[@binyameen9018]

yessssirrrr it is, and not only that, “And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) to mislead (men) from the path of Allaah…” [Luqmaan 31:6] Ibn Umar and ibn Abbas, Ibn Masood, and Hasan Al Basari said this ayah means music and singing.

[@mariamahq3742]

Please don't misguide muslims, mr. Shabbir ali

[@Usmanthemecano]

SubhaanAllah, music is haraam. Ibn mass'ud said that the verse in surah luqman definitely refers to music. and the hadith quoted couldn't be more clear, all musical instruments are prohibited except for the duff...the scholars of ahlul sunnah arent disagreeing about this...i'am waiting to see a sunni shaykh, not a break dancing sufi, bob his head to some jazz for example...come on now

[@S.Tagore]

Amir ibn Sa'd said: "Going in and finding Qarazah ibn Ka'b and AbuMas'ud al-Ansari at a wedding where girls were singing" I said, "Is this being done in the presence of you two who are companions of Allah's Messenger (peace be upon him) and were present at Badr?" They replied, "Sit down if you wish and listen along with us, or go away if you wish, for we have been given licence for amusement at a wedding." Nasa'i transmitted it. Tirmidi Sharif Hadis

[@muhdnasri8416]

Why is duff alone is permissible? Give me legit reasons. Its not about the tools is haram. It is about how u use the tools. Music is halal as long as u know your limit

[@Usmanthemecano]

@@muhdnasri8416 SubhaanaAllah... May Allah guide us all.

[@Fatima-zz7qc]

“Narrated Abu Musa: “That the Prophet said to him ‘O Abu Musa! You have been given one of the musical wind-instruments of the family of David.'” That makes it obvious that Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w) was not opposed to wind instruments. So there goes your “drums are OK” theory.

[@binyameen9018]

for reallll man “And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) to mislead (men) from the path of Allaah…” [Luqmaan 31:6] finally someone who has eyes has mentioned it

[@riadhvet]

Dr shabir ally is a great apologist so I think he should stick with it.Fatwas should be addressed to scholars of jurisprudence.

[@sanjarbek7037]

definitely

[@leun6768]

is it good?

[@ST073N]

bukhari 5590 is pretty clear about the prohibition of musical instruments except the duff of course. Also in surah luqman verse 6 is a pretty good indication and many tafsir also agree that it is prohibited. Why would anyone listen to it anyway the disgusting songs of today is definitely prohibited no doubt about it. Zina and free mixing all started with a flute these are instruments of satan instead of wasting your time why don't you learn quran may be memories some surahs read the vast amount of Islamic literature like tafsir fiqh aqeeda or about the prophets life just anything. Life is short do something that will benefit you.

[@hussinabdulrahman6869]

the hadith mention instrumentations and the ahly sunnah wal jameah tafsir as the very many instrumentations of gambling but the shiea rawafid and shiea wahabi says instrumentations as something else/pls do not believe any shiea rawafid and shiea wahabi salafi teachings

[@abdulmalikmcgill6221]

This is heavy misguidance from the "sheikh". Anyone who is objective read the tafsir he is talking about on surah 31:6.

[@alexojideagu]

The Sheikh is 100% correct. Even Saudi Arabia allows music.

[@vivaciouslyla9294]

AOA, please have a look at this article: www.islamawareness.net/Music/prohibited.html Narrated Abu Musa: "That the Prophet said to him 'O Abu Musa! You have been given one of the musical wind-instruments of the family of David.' (Translation of Sahih Bukhari, Virtues of the Qur'an, Volume 6, Book 61, Number 568)" There goes your idea of musical wind-instruments being haram.

[@peace_y123]

Because Saudi arabia allows music doesn't mean islam allows music. We follow Muhammad SAW not saudi arabia

[@binyameen9018]

@@alexojideagu Alex bro you keep mentioning that saudi allow it, saudi opened clubs, and allowed cinemas, does that make clubs and cinemas halal ya jahil?

[@binyameen9018]

@@vivaciouslyla9294 “And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing) to mislead (men) from the path of Allaah…” [Luqmaan 31:6] The hadith about Abu Musa, it means his voice, he has a meledious voice.

[@elliotpolanco159]

how young and beautiful they looked lol

[@Farhadmoh]

Great reasonable, these kind of teaching music is haram scares people away from Islam.

[@mansoorkaghaz9669]

I am surprised that dr Shabir does not understand that prophet Daoud alislam who's miracle was singing and music and he could bring birds down by his sound and make mountains sing .in echo that melted the iron ..eventually which is so deep yet he did not speak of it... Which shows that the utmost beauty of human voice is in singing and just like Yousef alislam was a perfection of beauty so was Daoud th perfection of voice .. and if U understand the meaning of music , recitation, azan and singing are no different and also most chapters of Koran are musical and has drum sound and music and melody but one has to be an expert in it

[@torontowrld3310]

bro please dont say Quran is music please dont say that

[@haydenbowlesmoments]

The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Among my ummah there will certainly be people who permit zinaa, silk, alcohol and musical instruments…” (Narrated by al-Bukhaari ta’leeqan, no. 5590; narrated as mawsool by al-Tabaraani and al-Bayhaqi. See al-Silsilah al-Saheehah by al-Albaani, 91).

[@hasinyanath8031]

That's what is happening in the videi

[@yasamini6346]

@@hasinyanath8031 the prophet when arrived medina listened to daff an singing of people what about that hadith?

[@yasamini6346]

@@hasinyanath8031 your profile picture is haram!according hadith

[@yasamini6346]

@@hasinyanath8031 بِسْمِ اللَّهِ الرَّحْمَٰنِ الرَّحِيمِ يَا أَيُّهَا النَّبِيُّ لِمَ تُحَرِّمُ مَا أَحَلَّ اللَّهُ لَكَ ۖ تَبْتَغِي مَرْضَاتَ أَزْوَاجِكَ ۚ وَاللَّهُ غَفُورٌ رَحِيمٌ

[@yasamini6346]

@@hasinyanath8031 there is no stonting in the quran but ahadith say about it ahadith are from sheytan

[@leun6768]

Salty salafi extremists are angry

[@abdulmalikmcgill6221]

Also just look up tafseer ibn kathir on the verse he talking about on Quran 31:6

[@leun6768]

@@abdulmalikmcgill6221 Put the verse in context and it doesnt explictly mention musical instruments. Then how would you explain the use of drums and musical instruments on Eid?

[@abdulmalikmcgill6221]

@@leun6768 the mufasireen from the companians like ibn abbas, who was also the cousin of the messenger of Allah PBUH, said so as well as the other companians and the other mufasireen. just read the link in full that i sent In Shaa Allah and search up the tafsir for the verse like i said. Tafseer puts the verse in context like what you are saying. Again please read the article in full brother. Assalamu alaikum.

[@abdulmalikmcgill6221]

Also, You may not even know anything about salafis because of whatever you hear. Hopefully these videos clear it up brother and I hope that, In Shaa Allah, you will try and understand with an open heart and with an objective lens. And, to clear up any ignorance that you may have from it. May Allah give us proper understanding of his deen. From Digital Mimbar - kzbin.info/www/bejne/iaami6iEos1mosk From ahlulsunnahwaljammah - kzbin.info/www/bejne/a4bNomR4gr6Ciqs From Dawah2Islam - kzbin.info/www/bejne/eaXRhXSHqdR6fcU

[@abdulmalikmcgill6221]

There are other videos i would like to share but there a bit long. If you have the time they are really good Alhamdulillah. May Allah forgive us. and Barakallahu Feek for taking the time out and to watch and learn about it through watching these videos (when you can), but the last one is really short, the second one is like 16 min, but the first on 48 min think, and taking the time out to read the link with understanding akhi. Please watch them and read the article fully when you can In Shaa Allah. Assalamu alaikum.

[@7khan012]

Than by this guy Kokain and Heroin is allowed coz there is no forbidence in Quran???

[@7khan012]

@Abdülhamid really? Than what is Shaitan voice?

[@homersimpson6787]

@@7khan012 Then songs that turn you away from god , not music but it could refer to waswas

[@7khan012]

@@homersimpson6787 music is satan speach.

[@7khan012]

@@roshansara5280 music is music. With song or with nasheed , its music. And in Islam is forbiden .

[@ahmedmirza5398]

@@7khan012 Allah himself created music.

[@whatsbefore47]

i heard makeup is haram?

[@lolyou6676]

Did he take fish on board?

[@eliasmalam]

Think about the fact that God flooded the whole world and that fishes can swim.

[@abazism]

Finally, imam with common sense

[@tayseersiddiqui1894]

Disappointed a bit! I expected a much better answer from the learner teacher.

[@marchowardsinisterexaggerator]

the thought police want the art on the wall its to suggestive

[@shabazhussain1576]

Add grammar to my rock hard fishing rod.

[@askiaeducationalnetwork4978]

You should only salute Allah and not the brother although Allah knows what your Nia was.

[@allgood6760]

I like playing the piano 🎹 music is the language of the soul.. I don't care about Islam.

[@sarahlumna1730]

4 madhab says music is haram

[@darko7mc186]

Choose one to trust: 4 Madhabs or Allah SWT (Don't commit Shirk even if it's minor)

[@prankeddlol7140]

@@darko7mc186 brother these arabs don’t understand that the madhab are people WITH OPINIONS whatever you say they will reject your opinion

[@Bean-qt4dy]

Annoying how Dr over analyzes everything to death. Music wasn't a thing when these books were written

[@amko123]

yes music was present back then

[@Usmanthemecano]

@TheKurdeXx Brother if one wanna follow his desires he may make anything halal in his mind and run with it...just now the story of the 2 saudi kids in their car blasting their music and their car flipped...while the helpers rushed to their rescue they were still singing along...They urged and begged them to say laa ilaaha illallah, yet they coudn't...to follow ur logic of "as long as you dont get addicted to it" could mean that drinking is also halal as long as you dont get drunk..Ignorance

[@sanjarbek7037]

Dr. Shabir is deviating from the main stream Islamic schools of thought, he should only get involved in debating with non muslims. Knowledge of Fiqh does not come from doing PHD in any western university.

[@abdulmalikmcgill6221]

facts!

[@gray-shawnteebles7317]

Hating on Dr. Shabir because he spoke the truth. Doesn't matter what an islamic school claims. Allah (SWT) has not prohibited all music. Music is vocal, instrumental, or mechanical sounds having rhythm, melody, or harmony. XD

[@Hamza00011]

Imam ghazali ibn al arabi and others all said the hadith are weak and music is permissable

[@mikechristian-vn1le]

Beautiful hijab.

[@money_1239]

Common sense here I’m American but Muslim , music is haram it’s talk about man and women touching each other etc , facts

[@qaipak1]

If a book is dirty like that does that make reading Haram? Talk some sense

[@alleballeism]

break dancing sufi.. thats not nice.

[@rubafathima4820]

Music is forbidden 😭🙄😄😂😎😉

[@bemindful6094]

Dr Ali, with all due respect to you, you are not a scholar. The scholars of Islam have concluded from the that you have just mis translated that music is haram. Because you u r not a scholar, it not clear to you.

[@yasamini6346]

Scholar ar not Allah only Allah can make things haram and it does not say anywhere in quran that music is haram

[@bemindful6094]

@@yasamini6346 the prophet made it haram from hadith in sshih al Bukhari

[@mymovies2741]

Lol, he is deviating from the four schools of law in islam

[@burgeulfassal1523]

SUN DAY and you must be an angel

[@alexojideagu]

Saudi Arabia allows music. Name me ANY Islamic country that bans music? They do not exist.

[@muhdnasri8416]

Along four scholars. Did you know some ulama in one of those scholars have different opinion about music being permissible?.

[@zubairahmed9471]

The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Among my ummah there will certainly be people who permit zinaa, silk, alcohol and musical instruments…” (Narrated by al-Bukhaari ta’leeqan, no. 5590; narrated as mawsool by al-Tabaraani and al-Bayhaqi. See al-Silsilah al-Saheehah by al-Albaani, 91). Please dont follow this man he is misleading our ummah

[@footballwithsteve4445]

Weak hadith

[@josipcolic5304]

@@footballwithsteve4445 it's sahih

[@anastasiadariov3057]

This Hadith is saheeh however it was mistraducted from the Arabic language. The real word used in this Hadith by our prophet pbuh did not mean musical instruments. I would give you the video that teaches me about this but it’s in French

[@zubairahmed9471]

@@anastasiadariov3057 please dont mislead other people by your assumptions If you want to listen to music then go ahead but dont misguide others

[@Aki-us3el]

@@zubairahmed9471 why is it haram though like just think about it logically

[@chrisberlin8464]

Funny people talking about fairy tales :-D

[@nitmateman6420]

Funny person that has no knowledge of religion and likes to be a troll :D

[@raafey1999]

yet you are here xD

[@MujahidOfTheRedwoods]

Like your secular utopia?

[@Think_pls]

Check Dr Zakir naik KZbin video, well known scholar of Koran , he says music is Haram, the problem is this interpretation of the scripture is so difficult, it already causing problem for the world, if for minor things there are different interpretations , what more for the violent verses in the Quran, that's why we have Muslim extremist , it's just another interpretation of the Quran, why can't God have a clear book, he speaks in way open for so much interpretation, I thought he was All knowing, sorry

[@Shane-cu1mj]

Cuz life is a test - In Exam, You only get hints, not answer otherwise pointless with the Exam

[@torontowrld3310]

god is all knowing watch what you say he doesnt have to tell you every single thihng please be respectufl.