Q&A with CSI Starbase | Fire and Ice Review

Join this channel to get access to exclusive perks:
www.youtube.co....
Please consider supporting CSI Starbase on:
Patreon: / csi_starbase
PayPal: paypal.me/CSIs...
Twitter: / csi_starbase
CSI Starbase Production : Geoff Allan
/ deffgeff
Huge thanks to the following photographers and content creators who make all of this possible!
▶︎ Ryan Hansen Space - CSI 3D Forensics Agent
Patreon - / ryanhansenspace
𝕏 - x.com/RyanHans...
KZbin - / @ryanhansenspace
▶︎ The Space Engineer
𝕏 - x.com/mcrs987
Chameleon Circuit - CSI 3D Forensics Agent
Patreon - / chameleoncircuit
𝕏 - x.com/Chameleo...
Andi Ashtorak - Starbase Simulator Video Game:
Download - ashtorak.itch....
𝕏 - x.com/StarbaseSim
📷Virtual Space 3D - Highbay & CSI Headquarters Renders
Patreon - / vs_3d
x.com/Lolomati...
x.com/Benedikt_3D
x.com/2legit2q...
📷 Starship Gazer - Starbase Photographer
Patreon - / starshipgazer
𝕏 - / starshipgazer
KZbin - / @starshipgazer
▶︎ NASASpaceflight
𝕏 - / nasaspaceflight
▶︎ RGVAerialPhotography - Starbase Weekly Livestreams
Patreon - / rgvaerial
𝕏 - / rgvaerialphotos
KZbin - / @@ucqbke0rz62u47tz8vmk...
Cosmic Perspective w/Audio from Andrew Keating
▶︎ / @cosmicperspective
Tim Dodd - The Everyday Astronaut
▶︎ / @everydayastronaut
Last but not least I want to give HUGE SHOUTOUT to the entire CSI Starbase team on discord. This dedicated team of 200+ agents with specialties ranging all across the board, has been crucial in getting the most accurate info for these episodes. Couldn't do it without yal!

[@macebobkasson1629]

Hi Zach, I love all your videos and information. Very sad to have missed this, but glad to see you're answering questions! Thanks for everything!

[@kersebleptes1317]

Loved the skits, mate! But the engineering is indeed king...

[@dukenukem001]

yes the skits are a great part of the vids .... its you!!

[@Darky.]

Just saw this Zac, just awesome! I'll try and catch the next one live

[@bgdx.5049]

It was impossible for me to watch you live, you are the 1st on my todo list!

[@Ed-jg3ud]

The vacuum skit was awesome!!!! Keep the skits coming, don’t listen to the haters! I actually rewound it several times to watch it again; it was hilarious!!

[@Chocobollz]

I second this. I love the skits. They're pretty funny and very well done.

[@Clark-Mills]

A quick "Thanks!" for your in depth engineering opinion; appreciated. :)

[@makespace8483]

Your deep-dives are simply stellar productions. Kudos to all involved.

[@donaldcharlong9586]

Your videos are by far the most informative and insightfull of all, not to mention very entertaining. I hope that you never go away.🙂 I'm amazed at the depth of your content.

[@matpower6587]

Thanks Zack👍🏽

[@eugeneawimbo6976]

Not bad. I wish I was confident enough to do live streams. I've learnt a number of thigs from your videos. You should see the pause, the rewind and the rewatch I do lol😂 Great renderings!

[@Hoopaball]

Cheers to the Engineers!

[@davidwarwick4745]

You may well hate being on camera (I understand completely) however you are really great at it !

[@crixmorgan]

congrats on first live stream!! keep em coming please!! I love watching your videos!! Thanks for delving into this stuff for us!!

[@davidfellowes1628]

Zack, that 50% o0ss at the beginning may also be partially clumsiness on the part of the person watching. If you open subscriptions in KZbin and view All, there is a danger that the mouse might trigger the Vlog it was hovering over when in fact the user was intending to go elsewhere. I do it often, so maybe not CSI's fault.

[@seth094978]

Yeah I was wondering how auto play on mouse over/scroll might affect that, combined with people who are interested, but look at how long the video is after clicking on it and decide to wait until later.

[@seanplaystoomuch]

thanks for doing this! been a fun watch and cant wait for the next one

[@spacemanmat]

Yeah those people clicking off in the first few seconds are like oh it’s over an hour. Do that myself all the time, but will always add it to my watch later list and watch it when I have time. I expect that’s why it’s nearly at 50%, because most people can’t just click on a video that long and just watch it. Needs to be done at certain times.

[@tedspeers6334]

62 here ... love the skits

[@danielemancini2547]

Thanks a lot from Italy for your analysis that are always so deepest, accurated and full of wonderfull animations.

[@christiansteinert6189]

Thank you for the great videos. And thank you for NOT cutting out breath pauses. I find it impossible to focus on people who talk without pause and always in the same time of voice. It's not a question of speed but of accentuation. So thank you for keeping the proper pauses. Interesting also how you said that intentional pauses help with video content.

[@joebushnell143]

I enjoy your skits because they bring real and potential issues front and square. And your deep dives are a real winner. Keep it up. 🥰👍

[@kanahn7402]

Sometimes i leave Ur vid early because I'm just listening to stuff at the moment. Then I come back when I've got time to big screen it.

[@hilaryhenderson1443]

I sure like your episodes; you get in depth and explain it so I can understand the subject. Make more.

[@benjaminhiemer3335]

My favorite Starbase investigations! Keep it on!!

[@DanielRichards644]

Yes Zac, Argentine calls it's currency the Peso and has since 1992.

[@lukecanride]

Love this raw content

[@brianforman1516]

Love the deep dives and engineering videos👍

[@doug3691]

Thanks, Zach!

[@paulsidhuUK]

Sorry I missed the stream. Great to see you just chatting.

[@johnwiebe8581]

I really enjoy your videos and presentation style; even the odd skit is fun. The in-depth and thorough investigations helps viewers learn and understand the amazing complexities involved in the space industry. RE: the fluid contamination, would this not be an issue with starship as well and therefore be an issue once the ship does a Lunar or Mars landing? RE: kidnappings, I know Jack Beyer is around Starbase all the time, maybe he might be a good intel source (NSF collaboration). RE: CSI= Commercial Space Investigations?

[@vivid996]

Thanks!

[@Greebo7uk]

I’d leave off getting to far into a chopsticks vid till after a catch attempt, you know there will be big changes the first time it reaches them!

[@Morpheus-Sco]

Hello Zack, THX for this kind of Q&A. Regrading ice in front of the inlets. Why SpaceX don't use the somehow the same method as it is on airplanes? On each flight at 10km you've minus degrees outside and the water in the fueltanks of an airplane turns into ice and would block the inlet pipe to the jetengines (very, very simple explained). By airplains it's called fuel-oil heat exchanger (FOHE). The story to find is by keywords AIR CRASH INVESTIGATION: The Heathrow Enigma | British Airways Boeing 777 crashes at London Heathrow | MAYDAY. Instead of missing oil, electic generated heat may help here out. Sorry for my bad English, I'm German. Kind regards and please continue. I like to see your thoughts.😀

[@jellybean7000]

A Song of Ice and Fire

[@badrinair]

Love all your super informative videos dude. I know this is not a one man show. There are other enthusiasts like yourself who have decided to work as a team and bring up such wonderful content

[@ot44eto]

I started watching like 10 times and stopped after a minute or so because I was interrupted. I managed to watch it fully on the 3d day. So I definitely messed some statistics. :)

[@frankch28]

The way YT works on my TV, a new recommended video start playing about 15 sec. after watching another video whether the viewer wanted to watch it or not. Because of that, I can see why the YT stats show a drop off on most videos after the first minute. Like Zach said, a lot of times if I’m interested in the new video, I’ll stop, save and go back to watch it later.

[@NominalOrbit]

@Zack, Definitely curious in ya'lls ~200tb archive. Bet it's super helpful when looking back for info...

[@hardwareful]

re viewer retention: do chapters with time codes have any power? On Desktop, it's awesome to jump back in to particular topics. On mobile probably not so much.

[@seth094978]

Oddly, I have so far only used the chapters feature on mobile.

[@timod1999]

HI Zach, I would have loved to take part in the next livestream, but for us European viewers 3 am was a bit too late. Thanks for your awesome content and now I'm looking forward to watching the livestream replay!

[@PetesGuide]

Exactly 11 seconds over two hours-nice!

[@ErnestCF]

Hi Zack, I'm from Spain if you do more streams it would be very hepfull if you do them while it's still day here in Europe, so we can also be on the stream without having to drastically reduce our sleep time. Thank you for all your work.

[@wrxsti1987]

Awesome 👌

[@dennisvanmierlo]

Hi Zach, A very enjoyable live stream to watch. Some improvement points: change the lighting. You are one with the background. Use different background lighting and foreground lighting to see you better. The wither light from the window is too bright and not pleasant to look at. This also darkens the artwork tiles. Maybe some additional help from someone in the background who curates the questions for you. That way you can more interact with your viewers. Keep up your excellent work. I love your channel and the content you create! Lot’s of greetings, Dennis 🇳🇱

[@konradcomrade4845]

01:04:01 Your pauses in Your speaking are important. Especially if talking about complicated stuff, pauses are neccesary to understand something that is new to me. If someone gives a "speech" I start sleeping at the screen! At the end I know there was a general topic but the details are completely lost.

[@l-oiseau]

And in Australia!

[@johninyork]

I love the skits!...

[@awilliams1701]

I don't remember which video it was, but it blew my mind so much that it was an instant subscribe for me. I don't think I've ever subbed after only a single video.

[@ajeleven8597]

Does space x recover starship and booster to prevent trade secrets? What happiness to the ‘bobs’ strapped to the vehicle following several splash down or catch? Thanks

[@Hoopaball]

They must be. I missed the live stream, and that tweet, but 180 ft would have been a tourist attraction. Wow!

[@TheNheg66]

I've seen nothing to suggest that they recover splashed-down hardware. I think they just depress and let it sink

[@emmacheeseman4758]

​@@TheNheg66 Seems they have recovered at least the engine section from booster 11, based on my news feed today. Maybe for research, possibly to show cleaning up after themselves for environmental concerns with FAA? Cool photos of it though

[@hilaryhenderson1443]

I always thought it was "Commercial Space Investigation".

[@donaldcharlong9586]

Would a cyclone separater work to remove solids from the autougenous pressurization system sending the solids into a holding bin?

[@mtopley]

I watch multiple space KZbinr weekly review videos, because everyone covers a different view and sometimes present different details. I'd love to see more regular small dive videos but you couldn't do what you do as weekly content

[@skeelo69]

Hey Zak...how about an episode where you present the show post flight 5 from the beach location with both launch towers behind you ?.

[@richardnew1215]

Hi Zack, I really enjoy all the videos - including the skits! Humor is good. I especially like how you use your mechanical engineering background for indepth speculations. I'm 69 years young and remember Mercury/Gemini/Apollo. When Shuttle came along, I kinda lost interest in space related things because they weren't going anywhere - only to LEO. Now that Luna and Mars are/might be in the future for peopled missions, its more interesting! Too bad you can't change the name of your channel to SI Starbase - Special Investigations Starbase. Keep up the great work! 😀👍👍

[@DesignedbyWill2084]

I am 55 and I liked the skits...

[@happycamperinc.]

More skits in videos Zack. They are so relevant.

[@davidfellowes1628]

FAA embed them in the project. Only way to speed the process up.

[@ashtorak]

For 20 minutes I was wondering why you have this strong red light going on until I looked at the title again. Nice one! :D Also love the skits and I'm kinda old. Maybe make a poll again on X about it? Since people always react much stronger on negative emotion and not on positive you'll never get the correct feedback just by comments, and with youtube algo you have no idea what you get anyway...

[@w00tbassman]

WOOOOT

[@Dalisu87]

Smart Brother

[@Echo7Kyle]

There is video that was leaked of the booster blowing up after landing

[@dbavatar]

The oscillation can be stopped with input shaping the chopsticks.

[@CSIStarbase]

I will continue to disagree on that. If it was possible, they would have already done it. I’m confident they have done the best they can in that area

[@dbavatar]

@@CSIStarbase Any link to discussion? Or maybe a new video. Should be able to stop any oscillation as long as input control can drive that frequency. They probably need a map of input shaping coefficients depending on chopsticks height, maybe 2D map with initial XY position as well.

[@marxug1]

Keep keeping it real, man! Including rolling with the natural vocal pauses. I for one am super tired of the breathless editing style, which is kind of spiritual kin to constant pitch correction in singing. I’d much rather listen to a real human voice taking real human breaths.

[@hugolandheer7008]

It is not the intro why people leave but they see the length of the video and the dont have the time or patience to watch for more than an hour. Personalle I have not missed a second but I do the same with the RGV weekly episode. Interesting but too long for me. There is so much to watch....

[@jablewit]

I think Jeff's audio is a bit early.

[@geoffallan]

Story of my life lol

[@jablewit]

@@geoffallan Haha, sorry for misspelling your name Geoff! Thank you for your work with RGV and CSI! 160 hours over 10 days is insane!

[@toddincabo]

👍 Trying to get the new TikTok culture to last past 30 seconds on anything is damn near impossible, it's implied right there in the name. I'm going to enjoy this later for background while playing No Man's Sky, does that count?

[@hilaryhenderson1443]

Outer sleeve on the downcomer?

[@S1nwar]

you really shouldnt be worried about 20% people finishing a 1hour 20minute video. pretty sure those are good stats

[@kazimirleray8957]

👍

[@WilboBaggins-dm7ub]

I've a request for help. I'm dead serious. I've put in a plan to end the Jack Beyer Kilt nonsense. Via the Scotish Kilt Co I've ordered and paid for a proper 8-yard Kilt using the Cornish National JR 170T code. However, Ellie; I need to get it sent to Jack Beyer. Can you help please?

[@SecretionOrb]

Your audience is mostly older generation but there may be a way of doing your videos that aims to capture more of the younger audience without alienating the older audience. I have no suggestions, but a worthy goal nonetheless?

[@acidtreat101]

Are you single? (just kidding its a funny meme in some live streamers I watch)

[@emmacheeseman4758]

As opposed to being plural?

[@PeterMan2384]

F the 51%

[@PowerScissor]

Will these livestreams be uploaded to Rumble? KZbin app kills my battery way faster than Rumble. I can listen to the same exact videos all day at work on Rumble...but the same videos on KZbin app kill my phone battery by noon.

[@awilliams1701]

I hate tall buildings. And wobbliness is why. It makes me uncomfortable.

[@lucababnik141]

Starbase P.I.?

[@spacemanmat]

Sorry your Zac your videos are awesome but I find the skits a bit cringe. Please however do your videos how you like because I’ll watch it all and you like it that way. I do think the ones you are doing now are better though.

[@shouryabose5943]

Booooooo!

[@oldfinnishfarmer]

39:26 i do love seeing you on camera. Maybe it is because you don’t like it yourself 🤣 you have your feet on the ground, not posing etc. Most people love seeing their own face on camera and that really turns down the content quality. In my opinion!

[@edby995]

40:10 @AnthroFuturism ?

[@Hampus_006]

36:15 Ayo sus