Should Muslims Believe in Black Magic? | Dr. Shabir Ally

[@Colby_0-3_IRL_and_title_fights]

If the pharaoh of Egypt couldn't find even a single person to do real magic in front of Moses then your auntie in Pakistan definitely can't do black magic.

[@aminasoofi4861]

Awesome comment 👏

[@areedkhalid6549]

Lol yeah 😂

[@khairt1731]

The pharaoh actually did find magicians.

[@theconsciousentrepreneurs198]

good one, that’s too funny 😂😂😂😂

[@AC-mp7cx]

firawn literally gathered dozens of magicians there

[@Colby_0-3_IRL_and_title_fights]

Blowing in knots doesn't give you magical powers in the same way bowing to a statue of an 8 armed elephant man won't give you magic powers. Bowing to idols or blowing into knots just means you're a pagan who believes in power other than God.

[@khairt1731]

Of course it does. Black magic does exist this is why we recite FALAQ to take REFUGE from people who blow on knots. Don't spread misinformation

[@JSoulKeys]

Deep

[@QuantumSwift]

We are Muslims and we believe this type of magic exist however as Muslims we are not suppose to practice magic. Quran takes a logical approach to everything and it is for people who are searching for the truth and guidance.

[@Danish-ww2jl]

My q is how can I believe that something else or someone else has inhuman power which only god can have? Doesn't it go against god and Islam? To believe those magic exists? Doesn't it comes directly under shirk? To believe someone else than Allah has these powers?

[@QuantumSwift]

​@@Danish-ww2jl Power of magic doesn't equal power of Allah because Allah has power of everything at all times. Magic exists because Allah mentions in the Quran that He sent two angels (Harut and Marut) to a group of people to teach them magic as a trial/test, however these people started to corrupt the teachings of these angels and caused problems among each other and married couples. Also Prophet Muhammad(pbuh) was impacted by magic. One cannot practice magic without comiting shirk and thus it is forbidden. There is severe punishment if someone gets caught practicing magic. To protect ourselves from magic, we should read the Quran often and pray our daily salat. Often recite Surah Yasin, Nas, Ikhlas, Falaq, Mulk.

[@Danish-ww2jl]

@@QuantumSwift 1st, please mention the Al Quran verse and Hadith verse for proof?

[@fidelcatsro6948]

May Allah protect us all from evil doings of ourselves and others ameen!

[@salmi8298]

They ˹instead˺ followed the magic promoted by the devils during the reign of Solomon. Never did Solomon disbelieve, rather the devils disbelieved. They taught magic to the people, along with what had been revealed to the two angels, Hârût and Mârût, in Babylon.1 The two angels never taught anyone without saying, “We are only a test ˹for you˺, so do not abandon ˹your˺ faith.” Yet people learned ˹magic˺ that caused a rift ˹even˺ between husband and wife; although their magic could not harm anyone except by Allah’s Will. They learned what harmed them and did not benefit them-although they already knew that whoever buys into magic would have no share in the Hereafter. Miserable indeed was the price for which they sold their souls, if only they knew! Quran 2:102

[@Danish-ww2jl]

if it does exist, who 1st taught those to people? As we know that Allah didn't. So who did? And if whoever did taught it? Then how can Allah be God the all powerful in this scenario?

[@sHuRuLuNi]

"Blowing on the knots": It most probably referes to jinn "blowing" or "whispering" to the knots, i.e. the nerve knots in the brain, - that is the suggestions jinns (devils, evil jinns) can bring to the human. They themselves cannot physically force you to do anything, but they can "whisper" suggestions to you - i.e. "blow on knots", interfere with brain nerves which then in turn manifest into "thoughts". An example I always take about this is the following: Imagine you walk down the road, and you, being a good person, see an apple tree with apples hanging out of the garden of some person. Then, in one millisecond, a thought comes to your mind to pick one apple and eat it. You of course don't do that, because it is haram, it would be stealing - but the real question is: where did that thought come from, seeing as you are a believer and a good person and not a thief?` My idea is that this is what is described above - as the devil (who is a jinn, an energy being) influences your mind by "blowing at the knots" in order to create to you this suggestion to steal the apple.

[@zytechnology]

every person on the internet making up his own islam by explaining things to others that are not true. You saying " most probably " does not make you a sholar. Fear ALLAh and ask the people of knowledge instead of spreading falsehood. . Go back to the Hadith and dont talk things that you have no clue about.

[@david2815]

@@zytechnology it's true they are energy beings they live side by side with us you just can't see their world they leech off of our energy and our electrical devices. Somehow at the beginning of this lunar New Year I was contacted by one and I invited it into my household to live with me which I wouldn't recommend anybody just doing it's only because I know where I go in the end 🪄and they do whisper into your ear but only you can prevent yourself from doing what they tell you to do. Not all Djinn are bad just like us humans ✌️✨ peace and love from Nola

[@anushkawangsawirana8950]

​@@zytechnology Ok but I am now curious about what YOuR thoughts are about the subject.just let's forget about the comments of others.what is your belief???

[@iniminimaynimo]

​@@zytechnologythis channel is fake. They want to mislead muslims. Be careful.

[@sapla2367]

Surah2:102 clearly shows us that black magic exist and jinn(Satan jinn) help to do this stuff.From Qur'an and also historical evidence tells us that the first magic was revealed in ancient Babylon.

[@nabeelmohammed3335]

And they followed [instead] what the devils had recited during the reign of Solomon. It was not Solomon who disbelieved, but the devils disbelieved, teaching people magic and that which was revealed to the two angels at Babylon, Hārūt and Mārūt. But they [i.e., the two angels] do not teach anyone unless they say, "We are a trial, so do not disbelieve [by practicing magic]."1 And [yet] they learn from them that by which they cause separation between a man and his wife. But they do not harm anyone through it except by permission of Allāh. And they [i.e., people] learn what harms them and does not benefit them. But they [i.e., the Children of Israel] certainly knew that whoever purchased it [i.e., magic] would not have in the Hereafter any share. And wretched is that for which they sold themselves, if they only knew.(2:102) The will of allah in this ayah is not a joke

[@notafeminist5948]

U believe in black magic only when it happens to you. May God protect us from this.

[@daughterofthenile4008]

Exactly

[@oui775]

You didn't talk about verse 102 sourate 2

[@hajirpirouzfar9481]

I always enjoy listening to the Drs responses to question. He is pragmatic and is balanced in his views. Thank you so much Dr.

[@AC-mp7cx]

hes heterdox

[@zachtavaris5378]

MashAllah both father and daughter are doing great work for our Ummah. Sister Safiyyah has taken after her father and asking direct, sharp on the topic questions. May Allah Subhan Wa'Tala Protect them from all evil, and Guide all Muslims in their short comings, and Forgive our sins. Ameen.

[@Colby_0-3_IRL_and_title_fights]

I didn't study for my exam but I only failed because my jealous sister did Sihr on me

[@areedkhalid6549]

Bruh

[@khairt1731]

You're a little kid making childish comments

[@leviackermann188]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@akbarmohammed1667]

Black magic can causes psychological problems,,,,

[@iniminimaynimo]

Surah An Nas I think the last chapter of the Quran tells about that people, Djinn and the Devil can blow into the hearts of other people. That's magic.

[@lilyrosesoul0077]

So black magic does not exists? I find this scholar's interpretation at odds with the Quran and Hadith. Black magic does exists as does the evil - even today there are still cultures who dabble in these practices. To be fair it doesnt mean that as muslims we go around blaming black magic for everything wrong - this is not how the prophet behaved.

[@markward3981]

I agree with you, while I admire his efforts to preserve people's faith he is struggling to reconcile modern views with Quran and sacrificing clear concepts of Quran to support this modern world view. May Allah grant us Yaqeen and increase our Iman.

[@jamal7404]

many cultures practise many ancient practises, that doesnt make them true. muslims today seem to be watching too much harry potter

[@ibnuSalih]

I'm astonished when he said to have scientific mind to explore these things. If we put physical reality (Science) in front of believing concepts of Islam, then everything will be questioned (believing in Jinn, Angels, Tajjaal, Ya'juj Ma'juj, etc.) And He forgot to mention about Evil Eye Ahadiths. We should believe in Aqeedah how companions of the prophets believed in Islam.

[@qasimalvi1]

There is no such thing as black magic

[@qasimalvi1]

@@markward3981 there no such thing as black magic..

[@Natureo-hr9xc]

I am afraid we muslims have our minds so entrenched in the believing in the black magic,many of us can't be comfortable with this view.Yet it seems to me to be a correct one.

[@axb-w4u]

Incredibly helpful for my journey. Thank you

[@deen.al-islam]

I have to say that in this matter you are wrong Dr. Shabir. science is a method, not all methods are science. and as you mentioned, in surat al-baqara 102, a relationship between shayatin (evil jinns) and sihr (magic) is clearly mentioned. not everything is science, because if we base everything scientifically, then we would have to scientifically prove the existence of jinns and that is not possible and that is not why we are going to say that jinns do not exist. it is even impossible to scientifically base morality. the scientific method is limited to the observable.

[@iniminimaynimo]

Magic is not turning a staff into a snake. Magic is that Djinn can influence people. I believe that a Djinn can not control a practicing muslim. Dr. Shabir clearly doesn't know anything about this topic.

[@amilitarymind]

There are illusions yes, but there is also real sorcery that the Quran mentions as well. Example, the verses about the 2 angels Harut and Marut teaching people sorcery as a test in Babylon.

[@mahinrahmanable]

So this sheik is telling Jinn cannot harm us, tell my why it is in the Surah nash- minal jinnati wannash- means save me from jinnn and human, if Jinn doesn't have the power to harm people why it is in the Quran to seek refuse to Allah from this Jinn.

[@JacksonShepherd-s2h]

@@iniminimaynimo really?

[@iniminimaynimo]

​@@JacksonShepherd-s2hlook at the title: can black magic harm us? Every muslim knows black magic is real and can harm you. Even the Prophet sallallahu alaihi wa sallem was affected by black magic. In another KZbin video he said that you should not take the story of Adam alaihi salam literally, he said that we descended from monkeys.

[@theconsciousentrepreneurs198]

What an amazing explanation mashallah. That’s always been my thoughts, Muslims are giving so much more power to these things than what they have, and I think it’s from their own traditions unrelated to Islam. If Allah is the Most Powerful how can he possibly allow these things to have effect on a Muslim who prays and spiritually protects himself/herself?? The only power it has is the power you give it. Allah has power over all things…

[@AC-mp7cx]

thats like asking "why would allah let someone who prays to get cancer or get stolen from?" same thing

[@thearchivistprimaea7292]

@@AC-mp7cx what the Lord ordains, and what other put upon you, are very different things.

[@AC-mp7cx]

@@thearchivistprimaea7292 "stolen from"

[@theconsciousentrepreneurs198]

@@AC-mp7cx no not exactly. There are things in this world which cause cancer, maybe Allah allows it but it doesn’t mean it’s from Allah just like magic is not from Allah but he allows it as we all have freedom to choose what we wanna do even poor choices or good choices we still have the choice. If your diet is poor and you live a very unhealthy lifestyle which causes you to have cancer just because Allah allowed it doesn’t mean it’s from Allah. Cancer is curable anyway I know people who have healed from their changing lifestyle and taking natural medicine to heal themselves, and Allah did say for every illness there is a cure. Also being stolen from has nothing to do with magic

[@kamilehime8633]

@@AC-mp7cx haha not quite. If only devout muslims got cancer then what you're saying is correct. In the case of Jinn possession, it is almost only a devout muslim women thing. So your analogy doesn't hold.

[@219nes]

This man! I think he is living the purest form of Islam! We need man like this! We forget the essence of the islam because of ignorant pre islamic cultures. Too many so called muslim young brothers speaking on youtube but they are so dangerous. Please help us’

[@willyounotthink3903]

Magic: to trick the eye or the senses and make the person believe something that isn't there. 1-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, God wouldn't have said the magicians of Pharaoh tricked the eyes of the people and intimidated them: "He said, “You throw!” And when they threw, they beguiled the eyes of the people, and intimidated them, and produced a mighty magic".7.116 So will you not reason? 2-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, and you can turn a rope into a snake by this force, then God wouldn't have said Moses "Imagined" the ropes and the sticks to be moving, and instead simply said the ropes were made into snakes and were factually moving: "He said "Rather, you throw." And suddenly their ropes and staffs imagined he from their magic to be moving".20.66 Did God make a mistake? or God isn't that precise with his wording? So will you not reason? 3-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, why would God call it the "Hidden Plan" of the magicians or "Kayd" in arabic?: "Now throw down what is in your right hand-it will swallow what they have crafted. What they have crafted is only a magician’s plan. But the magician will not succeed, no matter what he does".20.69 Shouldn't God call it the work or the dark creation of magicians? Or is God pointing to the fact that magic is nothing but a trickery, a hidden plan to fool the eyes and senses of people? Is God just bad with words? or you are the one bad with understanding? So will you not reason? 4-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, and you can turn a stick into a snake by this force, God from the start wouldn't have sent to Pharaoh a miracle in the form of a stick turning into a snake! Was God trying to confuse Pharaoh? Or did God already know that Pharaoh knows the reality of magic to be just tricks and will 100% certainly realize the miracale once he sees it? After all God claimed that Pharaoh as well as his ministers, immediataely recognized Moses miracle to be real, yet called it magic out of arrogance! "Put your hand inside your pocket, and it will come out white, without blemish-among nine miracles to Pharaoh and his people, for they are immoral people. Yet when Our enlightening signs came to them, they said, "This is obvious magic". And they rejected them, although their souls were certain of them, out of wickedness and pride. So see how the outcome was for the mischief-makers".27.12-14 So will you not reason? 5-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, why did the magicians of Pharaoh use ropes and sticks instead of other objects that didn't look like snakes? were they weak magicians or did they need the items to look like snakes to trick the eyes of the people? So will you not reason? 6-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, why didn't the magicians bind Moses and cast spells on him and made him under their control? Didn't they out number him? Wasn't spelling him a better demonstration of their power and knowledge than playing with sticks? Were they weak magicians? or is magic just a trick of the eye? So will you not reason? 7-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, the magicians of Pharaoh wouldn't have admitted Moses's prophethood and would have simply said instead that he is indeed a more knowledgably magician than them, after all magic is a mysterious force and they got outplayed by him. So will you not reason? 8-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, and you can change a stick to a snake that eat others with that force, then even if the magicians of Pharaoh had just one atom of a doubt that magic is indeed mysterious force, they wouldn't have accepted the horrible punishment of being butchered and crucified. Did they forget what magic is? Or is magic just a trick of the eye and they knew this fact, and witnessed a miracle? So will you not reason? 9-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, God wouldn't have destroyed Thamud for killing the she-camel, because bringing a she-camel out of a rock is exactly what you would expect from a dark and mighty and knowledgeable magician, so did God wrong them? or is magic just a trick of the eye and they knew this fact and yet denied the truth? So will you not reason? 10-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, the people of the prophet would have been totally justified in saying he is a magician, wasn't he bringing thousands of people into his new religion? doesn't that look exactly like a spoken spell? or is magic just a trick of the eye and they knew this fact and yet denied the truth? So will you not reason? 11-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, the radical-Jews would have been totally justified in crucifying Jesus, because walking on water and bringing the dead and breathing life into clay and telling people what they store in their homes is exactly what you would expect from a dark and mighty and knowledgeable magician. So will you not reason? 12-If magic was a dark and mysterious force, all the deniers of truth would have been justified in denying it, if indeed there were people out there controlling dark and mysterious forces, because how can one recognize a miracle from a dark and mysterious act? So will you not reason? It's time to stop using the light of God to lead people into darkness. It's time for the islamic world to go back to its golden age. It's time to leave the age of magic and enter the age of reason.

[@yahyarochdi7510]

Great answer but is it also mentionned in chapter 2 Harut and Marut , was that a test only to those people ? Or is magic from that time that can break a spouse and her husband still exist ?

[@iamlightschannel1467]

I saw someone harmed by black magic. His stomach grows and grows. He sought help from my father and was fine for a little while. Then it came back and it was it for him. I still remember his face he was nice to me

[@nahidamine2452]

He could just have had a tumor .

[@iamlightschannel1467]

@@nahidamine2452 i can understand why people would see it that way…i was sceptical myself but I saw not just one but more in my lifetime

[@mariaray7614]

That is when Surah falaq and nas came because it affected him by Allah's will for us only. Personally ruqyah works. Also in Ayah of riba.. Allah says they will wake up like touched by djin that drives crazy. Yes one should not be obsessive but seek ruqyah if things become too weird.

[@saurav1096]

I always thought this as quantum entanglement ( Not knowing that knot hadid wasnt considered as 100% pure) , but who knows it can be my wild thinking

[@yahya2925]

I had a similar thought. Allahu alum.

[@saurav1096]

@@yahya2925 yeah kind of fits the physics, So quantum machanics is black magic 😂

[@yahya2925]

@@saurav1096 LOL nah. Sihr is still different. Even eating is quantum physics

[@khairt1731]

You just admitted that illusion of the eyes is found in the Quran and you agree with that and the problem with this is the prophet Muhammad s.a.w had the same magic done to him. The magic was he had the ILLUSION that he(s.a.w) had relations with his wives and he wasn't aware until 1 of his wives said something. This was not explained in an honest matter.

[@ibrahimahmed6454]

While short answers are good, the Dr should've discussed the Hadith on the knot and Harut and Marut.

[@golpokaku8535]

Now I actually have a question here. What’s Dr. Ali’s view on the supernatural entities like The Jinns and of their abilities? If they exist, say on a different dimension from where they can see us but we can’t, can there be any actions of them in particular which can effect a person? I look forward to and will be pleased to have answer on this topic please. Stay blessed.

[@amadzbalboa]

Well. First time human sees the earth is sphere was only 59 years ago. And yes the jinns do coexist with us in their realm. Yet, we have no good or better constructed the theory of another realms/dimension of these being. Because our observations are very limited. Before 1969, we could only theorised about how does earth look

[@jeroenschilder9463]

@golpokaku @letthequranspeak: in 14:22 God tells us clearly that Satan (the most powerfull djinn) has no authority over men except inviting him...

[@iniminimaynimo]

​@@jeroenschilder9463heey Jeroen wat vind jij van deze Dr.Shabir die zegt dat magie niet bestaat?

[@tifikamberi3585]

I don't know if im the only one that i disagree with him Because on Surah Bekarah ayat 102 explains everything about magic Harut&Marut And magic can take effect only on those ho Allah allows.

[@hakimkato2746]

Thanks Dr Shabir and Saffiya

[@A1un9ine]

simple, no.

[@sajsultan1839]

If someone dies by black magic will they be sainted in the hearafter ?

[@mohammadayub2760]

Salaam to everyone whether u believe it or not it real it does happen

[@tavishkaif4651]

Sister humble request , please say "peace be upon him" while taking the name of RASOOLALLAH(ṣallā llāhu ʿalayhī wa-ʾālihī wa-sallama). I have been watching your channel for so long and I have observed that you never say peace be upon him like Dr Shabbir does. I hope you understand my request .Ramadan kareem, Asalaam walekum!,

[@zytechnology]

It happened to our beloved Prophet Muhammad ( Peace and blessings be upon him ) so that we can learn from it by narratives !

[@attarehman6030]

Careful research shows that though it was attempted but prophet Muhammad peace be upon him was never under the influence of any majic

[@RationalBelieverMuslim]

Black Magic is true, read surah baqarah, chapter 2, ayah: 102. only this one single ayah is enough to proof the reality of black magic & what can be done by Black Magic. There are so many hadith about black magic, which are sahih; so how many hadith you are going to reject? are you in the path of hadith rejectors?!

[@satsumasatsusatsat2913]

@12:50 actually yeah there is. research on quantum entanglement

[@calebacrutto9601]

quantum entanglement doesn't prove or disprove what he is talking about.

[@unfilterednations]

Thats why it called faith because you just believe, without have to explain the science of it

[@realjahanzeb]

Very helpful

[@tanvirkamal]

He is a human after all. No one can be 100% perfect either in terms of their scholarly theories or their understanding of religion. However, in the special topic there are several sura s and authentic Hadith’s involved. I would simply move on to next video and pray for his hidaya.

[@jeffreybillings1602]

Moses and Pharaoh's Wizards was matching wits . it wasn't magic . Staff represents Authority , the Wizards wisdom represents the Serpent ,( humble as a Dove , and wise as a Serpent ) They were matching wisdom , knowledge. and understanding . It was the battle of wits . No stick no snakes ! Its all symbolic .

[@zytechnology]

ANother Internet wise guy,,, Islam is clea and Hadith are also clear.... Dont spread falsehood !

[@caleb9190]

How do we remove black magic as there's not many legitimate imams that can do anything. There's s lot of people that are scamming and ripping people of. Please help.

[@Subxanallah1110]

Ask Allah SWT for help, read Quran for protection.

[@akkad-bakkad]

falak and naas 100 times everyday. no magic can withstand this inshallah

[@gjfjfk]

If Black Magic is real and one day someone got a spell on them because of magic then decided to murder his whole family . How would you tell if he did this out of evilness or because he had magic on him ?

[@khairt1731]

Go to masjid and do rukyah or rukah. It's when an imam of shaykh recites Quran over you. Anything else is fishy. Quran recitation is a must and certain stuff you can say before you go to sleep to protect you

[@gjfjfk]

@@khairt1731 Stop believing in superstitions believing in rukyah as a treatment is just a lazy way of ignoring mental health issues in a human.

[@bf6724]

The same thing that happened to Moses (PBUH) also happened to the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) The Qur’an and the hadith used the same exact word, so why would you doubt only the hadith if you were honest with yourself also questioned the Qur’an? Every time the hadith of the Prophet (PBUH) contradicts their belief, they resort to the easiest solution, which is to question the hadith, not in a scientific and systematic way, but only because it does not correspond to what they want to hear and the society in which they live!

[@xondeez757]

what is this guy on about? why is black magic considered a major sin if it doesn't exist? why does the quran mention it several times? harut and marut? this guy is making people commit kufr

[@Citizen052]

Excellent explanation Dr Shabir. It is a good strategy to insert some rationality.

[@AC-mp7cx]

bruh no

[@AC-mp7cx]

aql and naql both go together

[@tashtean]

How do explain the soul with physics then?

[@markward3981]

??? Please explain in detail what you are asking?

[@monamedusa792]

I agree on many of your points, but it becomes very "western" in the sense that seeing is believing. Black Magic is a practice, and even Mufti's that have higher knowledge acknowledge the practice exists and that muslims should in general protect themselves. This does not mean that Allah is not in Power, if Allah swt allows it, then Allah swt also send us the cure for it (via ruqya). But to say that Muslims shouldn't believe in the practice of black magic sihr, and its existence, and its effects, is a bit controversial in my humble oppinion. Why did we receive the guidance of Ruqya then?

[@amirbagali8414]

Quantum theory doesnt demand two objects to be physically connected. Mr. SHABIR, with all due respect, please check padticle entanglement and their behavior in real time. You affect one and the other behaves the same. Uts for real nd proven in science. This is the study of non materials that exists and the ancients studies it well, while modern science discredits it all. But wuantum theory will definitely leave possibility of something like magic . Please correct me if wrong

[@susmoys]

Your assertion on this subject is simply wrong. Are you aware of the following verse? Instead of God, they only invoke female gods and they ˹actually˺ invoke none but a rebellious Satan- cursed by God-who said, “I will surely take hold of a certain number of Your servants. I will certainly mislead them and delude them with empty hopes. Also, I will order them and they will slit the ears of cattle and alter God’s creation.” And whoever takes Satan as a guardian instead of God has certainly suffered a tremendous loss. Satan only makes them ˹false˺ promises and deludes them with ˹empty˺ hopes. Truly Satan promises them nothing but delusion. It is they who will have Hell as their home, and they will find no escape from it! (Quran 4.117-121)

[@goodlife4321]

Sir please collaborate with sir ghamdi...you both have the same mindsets approach!

[@jubairahmed6386]

But Ghamidi doesn’t speak English. He can however collaborate with Dr Shehzad Saleem who was a student of Ustad Javed Ghamidi & speaks English.

[@attarehman6030]

But does Dr. Shabir Aly speak Urdu or hindi?

[@antiochorontes6374]

If only black magic was real, then maybe it could be a weapon against nukes. But alas

[@ibnuSalih]

I'm astonished when he said to have scientific mind to explore these hadiths; Science would change itself, if another finding is discovered or portrayed. If we put physical reality (Science) in front of believing concepts of Islam, then everything will be questioned (believing in Sihr, Jinn, Angels, Tajjaal, Ya'juj Ma'juj, etc.) And He forgot to mention about "Evil Eye" Ahadiths. We should believe in Aqeedah how companions of the prophets believed in Islam. When you want to learn about Aqeedah in Islam it's better to stick around the views of companions of the prophet and Rightful scholars rather than these kind of new Ideas.

[@calebacrutto9601]

Scientific theory can change, but not science. A scientific theory is just that, a theory. However science is based on theories that have been confirmed and proven to be facts. Theoretical physics is just that, theories that can't be proven as fact. The same scientific method is applied. Now, if you were to apply the scientific method to what is written in the Qur'an about sahr, never does it say that the natural order of things created by Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala is atlered, only the effects on our own psyche because we lend power to it, and we should take refuge in Him and not the fall victims to such benign practices.

[@Rayhunn]

Magic is very real and hence there is mention of it in the Quran. I am amazed that he's talking about magic and no mention of the angels Harut and Marut who taught the unbelievers magic. You may not believe in something sir but that does not mean it does not exist.

[@iniminimaynimo]

Dr. Shabir is an imposter. He wants to mislead people. And all the people who react under the video are payed. Be careful.

[@sufiahmed100]

As Salaam Alaakum. Islam removes all superstitious beliefs.

[@BabaSalaam360]

As Salaam Alaikum. Islam removes superstitious beliefs.

[@AmonsRealm]

Is white magic permissible?

[@fidelcatsro6948]

you should only make good duaa to Allah

[@akkad-bakkad]

no. magic is haram and magicians are doomed to hell.

[@DonDiiiii]

No such thing.. Its black always bcoz of satan involvement

[@servantfollower9818]

If magic doesn't exist why people called prophet Muhammad pbuh doing magic?? Where the word " magic" came from?

[@theconsciousentrepreneurs198]

Pagans and idol worshippers who do weird rituals, that has nothing to do with Islam… magic doesn’t come from Abrahamic teachings period.

[@servantfollower9818]

@@theconsciousentrepreneurs198 So the conclusion is magic does exist.

[@BrawlWithZ]

@@theconsciousentrepreneurs198 It does exist in ahrahamic religions.

[@davidking1426]

VERY IMPORTANT VIDEO ❤️

[@billydagoat4416]

Harut & Marut ?

[@teddyraffudeen7056]

I enjoy listening to Dr. Shamir Ally.

[@nobleprince1238]

You enjoy listening to a Kufr?

[@teddyraffudeen7056]

@@nobleprince1238 explain that to me.

[@nobleprince1238]

@@teddyraffudeen7056 Sunan Abi Dawud 4603. Do you agree that is what Dr Ally is doing?

[@President12345]

Very WEAK grip on this topic by dr shb. QURAN clearly talks about Magic in Hazrat Suleman(AS) era when people blamed him of practicing magic however QURAN states in SURAH BAQARAH AYAT 102 ' It was not Suleman who disbelieved but the devils disbelieved who taught mankind magic ' so clearly devils were teaching people magic....Dr shb kindly have grip on a certain topic and then talk about it

[@rusyaraiju2232]

if people wana know more about this topic such Black magic, jin posses , i recommended to look to south Est country ... like Malaysia or Indonesia... our ancestor are closed to the race of the jin in the past.... its look like the knowledge about this aspect are lost among the Est side of the world.... Allah know better

[@clearthings9282]

All types of . Magics are shirk. Haraam, kufr... using devils....in this like the all other religiouns god. To whom they are devoting...

[@m3ga_c0d3r5]

he believes in black magic but not jin possessing , lmao

[@hilalal-harith6501]

Dr. Shabir, you should research Quantum entanglement. You will be amazed at what science is discovering

[@Killbill1933]

No proof for Magic! Mirical! God!

[@mohamedshirajabdulshattar7030]

I don't like black magic(sihr) coz it is haram

[@alyzak.8997]

So what I do about the jinn chilling in my room?XD I guess people will only believe if they experience it. Otherwise, it makes no sense.

[@jeffreybillings1602]

Moses and Wizards was matching

[@h2s528]

It's so sad listening to the fanatic materialistic approche of Dr Shabir on the question! His conception of "reality" and his epistemology ! A man of such merit It's so sad and terribly unfortunate! Dr Shabir, with this extreme materialistic approche, we'll end up negating Allah, Angels, shayateen, hell and jannah ! For the "isra wal miraaj", I assume your position is at the opposite side of Abubakr when he heard it for the first time from the kufar!

[@MastakongoPrez]

They do believe in black magic. It's all over the Quran and in the interpretation of the Quran by Muslim scholars. Brother *Christian Prince* may teach you things you do not know. You must refute him now because is converting Muslims to Christianity.

[@Cansquared]

Make the crowd believe mmmm sounds like religion lol

[@bigsatje]

Shir and evil eye exist!!

[@akbarmohammed1667]

Black magic is real,,,

[@iniminimaynimo]

But I think you are not real.

[@Magic818100]

I became a good magician I was told by cop magician when I was only 13 years old I was so good at it sometimes I have to tell my mother the tricks because she thought I was doing something evil. And one of my mother so how I did the trick she used to tell me all that's all you did and I used to laugh. What I never did black magic or those crazy stuff Voodoo thank God I never got involved with nothing like that

[@Walidmohamud-do9wz]

This man doesn't know what he's talking about

[@iniminimaynimo]

He's an imposter. Be careful.

[@m.e.e2878]

Love the Showwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww.

[@nahidkhan01]

balck magic

[@akbarmohammed1667]

He is misguiding ummah

[@thehourglassfan3515]

Yeah, next thing you’ll say is: “he’s a Christian posing as a Muslim” or something similar. Pathetic. If you don’t like his answers, don’t listen to them.

[@iniminimaynimo]

Yes he's misguiding the ummah indeed. Be careful. All of these people here are fake accounts. They're being payed.

[@iniminimaynimo]

Akbarmohammed1667 I think you're fake to.

[@ehsanulmajidify]

For sure this Shaikh is Misguided and he clearly tries to contradict Quran and Hadith just because he does not believe the reality of Black Magic. Do not ever listen to this man.

[@iniminimaynimo]

You are right.

[@BTVPic]

That man is amaaaazing! Always has a bent answer, quoting The Bible, Science, Hadith, Quran and other commentators at will. He is the real magician. We are a few who still hope for a clear and direct answer to one of the questions. We hope one day he will let the Quran speak without his own mad interpretation...

[@ish_blmfeministclimate200e9]

Note: And there are many things science has not discovered & is yet to be discovered- but in due time InShaAllah it will be. but to assume something is “black magic” is extraordinary. extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence to substantiate it’s validity. As always love your videos Dr SA & Dr SA jnr 😍MAShaAllah

[@uthman1114]

we have extraordinary evidence. Quran and sunnah. Allah clearly tells us what jinn are capable of in the story of Suleiman. Don't take the extreme view of materialism.

[@mrsm8821]

believe in black magic? yes . since your prophet was bewitched,

[@nobleprince1238]

He has a personal jinn...LOL

[@pav5542]

Alright chill out karen, go read about ur star signs hoping u find a bf at the age of 52 saying "universe is sending me good signs"

[@mrsm8821]

@@pav5542 you stone aged caved man . go beat Aisha how old is she 2? .... your profit was a kiddie fiddler.. you cant talk to nobody.. go bathe