Ending Over-Reliance on Hadith | Shaykh Atabek Shukurov

[@williebrown4989]

I truly appreciate this discussion. When I go through the Quran I have never had any trouble in its messages. In fact, I find it captivating in understanding and making sense of its verses. When I come across a few hadith on the other hand, I feel confused, deeply troubled and at a place of not recognizing the religion and even the Prophet that I have come to know and admire. Thank you to the people at Let the Quran Speak.

[@williebrown4989]

@@kanizfatima1377 Yes true. Like I said, a few. The hadiths have its importance and cannot be simply discarded. I hope to find more beautiful and true hadiths just like you have.

[@fatimaxo4885]

Willie brown- I agree! When I read the Quran I feel so much at ease and happy but some hadiths really disturb and make me uncomfortable. I’ve felt very disturbed by some hadiths even as a kid when I didn’t know the difference between hadith and Quran, I would hold both books close to my chest as if they’re the same. Of course I know difference today... but Allah has given children that natural feeling (as a means of self protection) when something doesn’t seem right, it also doesn’t feel right even if we don’t have the vocabulary developed to describe it. Today I can say with confidence that such hadiths need to be tossed away and we need to out more emphasis on the Quran which doesn’t teach such barbaric things or making the prophet saw seem like a violent person the way hadiths do.

[@NRFP]

Hadith destroyed my believe my respect & imam on islam(about captive women)

[@blumachine]

@@fatimaxo4885 true, we are abandoning quran for hadith, the complaint that prophet muhammad will say on judgement day in the quran

[@BeeRoyLee]

It doesn’t help that many Internet scholars claim Hadith are equal to Quran.

[@ayubosman3288]

Some people follow all hadith. Some people dont follow hadith at all. Listen follow the hadith that agrees with the quran. Reject the ones that go against the quran...if you see some hadith that neither agree and go against the quran, then just give them a low status. As a student, i think this is the best way to study hadith

[@gregoriysharapov1936]

You are absolutely correct. The Qur'an is our furqan, or final criterion. There is no need to reject everything.

[@arafatramon3776]

Do you tell me how you pray?

[@sahinyaman2185]

(A)llâhu nezzele ahsene-lhadîśi kitâben muteşâbihen meśâniye takşe’irru minhu culûdu-lleżîne yaḣşevne rabbehum śümme telînu culûduhum ve kulûbuhum ilâ żikri(A)llâh(i)(c) żâlike huda(A)llâhi yehdî bihi men yeşâ/(u)(c) vemen yudlili(A)llâhu femâ lehu min hâd(in). Allah has revealed the most beautiful Message in the form of a Book, consistent with itself, (yet) repeating (its teaching in various aspects):the skins of those who fear their Lord tremble thereat; then their skins and their hearts do soften to the celebration of Allah's praises. Such is the guidance of Allah. He guides therewith whom He pleases,but such as Allah leaves to stray, can have none to guide.

[@GeniusIzz]

People Will say People WHO dont read or follow Hadith are kafir 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️ This is a big problem in the Ummah

[@Al-NABIL-ISLAM.]

One question how would we check whether the hadith on the age of Aaisha is reliable.

[@drk-ent]

MAASHALLAH. At last someone brave enough to propagate the use of logic..... May we all become 'people of understanding '. We forget the biggest sunnah, and that is that our Prophet Muhammad SAW lived the Quran. So I agree.... Quran rules supreme. it's time to filter out non authentic and contradictory hadeeth.

[@زينب44]

“Quran is fully detailed” so there isn’t much need to lock everything down that isn’t prescribed in the Quran itself. The arrogance of the Ummah to impose their own interpretation of Islam is a decease that needs to be addressed. The oppression that has ruined many lives needs to end.

[@sal_strazzullo]

The fact is that the Quran Alone is enough for guidance

[@asimsparks]

It has already been done and dusted .

[@asimsparks]

Please show the method of Salah as we pray, from Quran only.

[@sal_strazzullo]

You will not find in the Qur'an the "method" or "steps" or "raka" of how to pray, because this concept did not exist. Allah asked the prophet and his people to pray, and they prayed.

[@yusuffulat6954]

These sorts of Ideas give me a hope and belief in Islam. I have had numerous doubts on the ethics and morality on many of the aspects of the religion. But this sort of fresh thinking is so highly needed, and would help solve some of the problems within the Muslim world today. My only melancholy is the idea that for hundreds of years Muslims have been misusing the Hadith and it is only now that we know to rethink what we believe a little.

[@corazoncubano5372]

No need to be sad. It just proves that the truth which is Quran will always rise to the top. Allahumdulillah.

[@alexhill5079]

This is so helpful- I have struggled so much to make sense of the hadith in my decade-long “career” as a Muslim. I was scared away from hadith because of the false ones and their being placed next to (or, quite often, above) the Qur’an. At this point, I view the Qur’an as a beautiful painting that is perfect in itself, with or without a gallery or museum to house it- but a good museum and a tour guide help us understand and enjoy the painting. The painting doesn’t need the museum, but the viewer does. They are tools- not perfect but they serve a purpose- to understand a perfect book. I should ask a good scholar if this analogy sounds right but that’s what I’m going with for now I guess. Allahu alim.

[@nooralammolla7208]

Exactly the same happened with me.i was brainwashed to believe in all hadiths.

[@JahidMasud]

Very intriguing analogy there!

[@centric145]

@@nooralammolla7208 oh i ve been brain wash to believe in lot of things

[@khanimania]

Absolutely i agree, i realise long time ago listen to all and see what's the reason and logic, basically i follow all 4 schools thought

[@Amadeus-ms9lt]

Remember the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) in his farewell sermon stated we must follow Kitaab wa Sunnah, NOT Kitaab wa Ahaadith Saheehah. I recommend you read Root Islamic Education by Shaykh Abdalqadir As-Sufi (RA), who made the distinction between Hadith and Sunnah very clear. Hadith and Sunnah aren't synonymous and this is a very common mistake, leading to confusion and distress.

[@esfanintan]

I like when he says to go to heaven just do the fundamentals which is don't lie, don't cheat people, etc, and then welcome to heaven.

[@DBUification]

I mean fair but there is a very long list of fundamentals and many MANY sins that one can get caught up in along the way. People need to be quite literally hold tight to the rope or Allah (ironically as it says in the Hadith) and do the best that we can to objectively follow things that are clear Islamically (for those who have sense at least)

[@azzy1971]

Respect to the good Shaykh, Imam Hanifa was the closest to any of the early great scholar to the truth. Iblis is at work but Quran is protected and has all the tools to fight his screams.

[@TheMuslimCowboy]

Nicolás Vera Cabello bismillaah, don't compare between great scholars with such lowly and downgrading speech. you are nothing like any of these men and I advise you to be more careful in putting one scholar above the other. do what you can for the Deen and try to convey the message to the najs disbelievers instead of fighting amongst yourselves.

[@TheMuslimCowboy]

dont try it is possible. it is called ijtihad, and I suggest going and doing a class on the methods of rejecting and accepting evidences. a good place to start is the 40 Hadith Nawawi lecture series by Sheikh Navid Aziz.

[@azzy1971]

Nicolás Vera Cabello and Don't Try you are well with in your rights to have a preferred so called school Allah SWT does tell us to ' listen to all kinds of speech and take the best" for our self development remember judgement day we are on our own armed only with what we have learned?

[@kadnan6111]

Mr T who sheikh atabek ?

[@samsmith6279]

Actually I would say Jaffar As Sadiq r.a.. He is the true Shaykh of Islam.

[@asifmech74]

Seems like there were vibrant intellectual discussions between early scholars, knowing that gives me hope...there's room for intelligent debate regarding some of the controversial contemporary issues.

[@mohammedjamil2277]

@aqeel -محمود that's why I got rid of my sahih al bukhari set all nine volumes in 2012! Gave it to Muslim charity shop. Even the charity worker was embarrassed with what I had to say on the matter.

[@ADeeSHUPA]

@@mohammedjamil2277 all nine volumes

[@corazoncubano5372]

That is as it was in early times. Not so much now.

[@MultiDivebomber]

I also have problems with hadiths that cause disrespect to Rasulullah. The life of prophet should only bring admiration,.....

[@milenarahmanova4032]

Indahnya Indonesia oh trnyata di indonesia ada jg org yg sepikiran dgn sy...

[@milenarahmanova4032]

Lorenzo Lamas setuju. Banyak bgt.

[@milenarahmanova4032]

Lorenzo Lamas ya.

[@milenarahmanova4032]

Lorenzo Lamas harus hati2 juga mas, tapi quranis di indo lumayan bnyk.

[@MultiDivebomber]

Memang perawi dan pengumpul hadits tidak maksum. Saya juga agak ragu dengan hadits2 yang dijadikan alat untuk menyerang Rasullulah. Tapi selama hadits dan sunnah sejalan dengan Qur'an dan isinya baik, Insya Allah saya jalani. Tetap ada kemungkinan bahwa sunnah2 itu memang asli berasal dari nabi. Untuk para qur'anis, teknis menjalankan sholat, wudhu, puasa dan lain2 seperti apa ya?

[@Auudubillahi]

As a revert to islam , i can say what really held me back from fully embracing islam is not the quran , which i think is perfect, but the hadith, which really made me flabbergasted

[@tobeywan8331]

as a born Muslim myself, I'm really interested in understanding the Qur'an deeply, and i find many popular hadiths go against the Qur'an. and I completely okay with "throwing away" those so called "authentic" hadiths.

[@Can_Cem]

Selamun aleyküm dear brothers and sisters. There is a slight misunderstanding among some muslims against hadith corpus. I like to think myself as a Quran-centric muslim. That's why I neither totally reject nor accept hadiths. You know why? Because there are many verses in Quran that asks the prophet Muhammed (pbuh) whether or not the stories of certain events or people has reached him or he has heard them. That means that even Allah (cc) doesn't disregard the fact that some information can and will be transferred from people to people verbally and can be relied on that means you don't have to eyewitness the event and they don't necessarily have to be written in a holy book for them to be considered as truth. For example, 85/17: Has the story of the armies reached you? 79/15: Has there reached you the story of Moses? 105/1: Have you not seen how your Lord dealt with the men of the Elephant? Pay attention the last verse I quote here. It is a known fact that dear prophet himself never witnessed the event itself yet Allah (cc) still asks him if he has any information about the event. That means Allah (cc) doesn't disregard the fact that some information can be transmitted from ear to ear. And these transmitted words don't have to be *always* false. Even the Qur'an itself came to us by the people before us. You may ask "ok but how can be sure which hadith to accept and which one to reject?" The answer is simple. If you put Quran in the center and check any hadith's meaning in correlation with Quran, you can easily realize whether or not something is against Quran or not because the prophet could never say something against the Qur'an. For example there is a hadith that says the prophet said to his daughter that "My dear daughter even I cannot save you from the fire..." Now let's check this hadith with Quran. 39/19: ... Then, can you save one who is in the Fire? Now When we reconcile the hadith and verse it can be said that the hadith in question may have been uttered by the prophet because it is in agreement with the verse and there is no reason to reject this hadith and it is not even necessary for someone to be certain whether or not this hadith had really been uttered by the prophet because whoever formed that hadith it does not go against Quran. Of course there are many hadiths that goes against Quran, no harm rejecting them and I don't mean that every hadith can be found in Quran word by word. If they do not advise bad things there is no problem. Finally Allah (cc) tells us to choose the best of the words. Zumar 18: those who listen to what is said and follow the best of it. These are the ones ˹rightly˺ guided by Allah, and these are ˹truly˺ the people of reason. I think our approach to hadith corpus should be like this. It doesn't matter from where or whom the words come as long as they do not go against the Quran and logic and they advise the good. The Quran is the ultimate guide. Let it guide you! There never comes good out of Total acceptance and rejection of anything. Allah (cc) knows the best. Selamun aleyküm dear brothers and sisters.

[@mohammedcharlesmurphy2837]

best comment

[@loveknight2245]

Walaykum as salam...I understand your viewpoint on this, but one thing: I don't think saying Allah (swt) 'admits' would be proper. Why would Allah, The Exalted, need to admit anything? I think using a different word would be more proper.

[@bilalamarumosi8282]

Just because Allah asks the prophet about certain stories by no means is a way of telling us that to its ok to use other books beside the Qur'an.

[@advenco344]

Brilliant comment. I agree. We should be Qur’an-centric but that doesn’t mean we should reject all hadith.

[@Can_Cem]

@@loveknight2245 I changed the word.

[@qmate7701]

Masha Allah, may Allah bless you. I came across such person for the first time. Today people are fighting for many such issues that has nothing to do with basic principles of Islam. Jazak Allah

[@ahmadkhalidyong9886]

Al-Quran is the most advanced book on earth, it is a living document meaning that we must always review the methodology of translation and interpretation. Unfortunately muslims scholars had never review 3 most important: The Logic/mantic/kalam, the usulut tafsir al-quran bil-quran, and the grammar of the arabic language.

[@MB-id1uh]

Fakhr ud Deen Razi Imam Ghazzali

[@Amadeus-ms9lt]

There's another angle to this which this video alluded to, but was emphasised heavily in Shaykh Abdalqadir Al Murabit's work "Root Islamic Education". The matter is, we have been ordered to follow "Kitaab wa Sunnah". Kitaab is obviously the Quran, but many are a bit unclear on what Sunnah is. Many assume Sunnah=Hadith. As Sayyidah Aishah Bewley mentions, this is a false equivalency. Hadith are statements but often in themselves mean nothing without a proper methodology in which to understand. Many are also ignorant of the methodology and ethos of various Ulama when they made their Hadith collections. Malikis make a strong distinction between Hadith and Sunnah. We are obliged to know the Sunnah, which has largely been transmitted through amal, NOT through text. When one looks at the number of Sahabah narrating, they're few in number. Yet the Sahabah still taught Islaam via amal aka action aka Sunnah. Thus even if a hadith is Saheeh, it does not mean it is necessarily the Sunnah to be followed and enacted upon.

[@frankly5171]

Alhamdolillah!! So glad I found this channel! JazakAllah Khair.

[@dianewinchester2930]

Masha Allah, what a wonderful way this man has of speaking. I have never been more proud of being a Hanafi Muslim. I want to hear more about this brother. He speaks so calmly.

[@muhammedsonko2936]

There is no such thing as Hanafi Muslim. We have only Muslims

[@muhammadmustafiz8040]

The fiqh of imam Abu hanifa stipulated that the beard of a Muslim should not be less than 1 fist. This "imam" looks to be unaware of this. All you have heard of is his opinion. This is not the concensus of the general ulema. Do not fall for things just because you like the sound of it. It makes no sense that he technically defines usury of mortgages to be not usury by Islam. Islam forbids usury, which is selling money for higher amount of money or anything same for more amount of the same thing, eg some dates for more dates.

[@faaiz6482]

@@muhammadmustafiz8040 beard is Wajib in our fiqh not fardh

[@myasinsaeed]

A clear and straight path. Wow. Much obliged. Stay blessed, always

[@diaralcasanibrahim6582]

It is not any man to reject a hadith but it is the Quran that rejects hadith.

[@esfanintan]

How wonderful this program is. this program is great in totality but this one was absolutely the best.

[@saabsk5955]

I like this guy, he is very fair minded, and intelligent. We are told to study and find things that have truth to study something, we are told to seek out what is right and what is wrong. The Quran is the source of this guidance. There is nothing wrong with learning history, and even prove the Quran, see what archeologists and historians say compare and verify. In this case I would put the hadith not as a source of law for Muslims, but as a reference of let's say an idea of why a verse came down. And of course you look at history. Somet things can't be answered by history or by hadith. We take the hadith as a reference, but not as a guidance outside of the Quran. Meaning you can't make an islamic law out of hadith. You can make rulings based on the Quran and its interpetations and how they would fit into your society.

[@BigThumpSC]

MashaAllaah wa Al hamdulillah! Great explanation akhi! BarakAllaahu Feekum, Aameen. It was funny when he said they missed the first and last part but "kept the licking bit". 😂 Classic

[@mp6471]

That's why the Turks are necessary to Islam. They carry the hanafi madhhab which can make Islam a modern religion.

[@yasinislam9962]

THE DECLINE OF THE ‘MUSLIMS’ AND ITS CAUSE In the early days if Islam, for many centuries, Muslims were at the forefront of human civilization and achievement. They made tremendous scientific discoveries in the fields of medicine, astronomy, algebra, exploration etc. and there societies exhibited excellent examples of justice and freedoms for all…women, minorities, other religions etc. All of this success was due to the teachings and wisdom from the Quran that emphasized philosophical investigations, scientific discovery, justice etc. No considerations were given to Hadith as Muslims relied on the Quran. In fact, during the time of the Prophet and the four caliphs, many written Hadith were burnt and it remained illegal to write down any Hadith as the dangers of following unreliable hearsay and rumours were well known. These dangers were later overlooked as the Muslims consolidated their use of the Quran and perceived no harm in writing and keeping the Hadith. The roots of the Hadith were then planted, and it would take many centuries later that we would see their fruits. The Hadith books that are full of human-rights violations, child abuse, slavery, sexual abuse, blasphemy laws, apostasy killings, stoning-to-death and many other vile and disgusting teachings that run contrary to the teachings in the Quran were finally being adopted into Muslim lives. Freedom of belief, independent thought, philosophical investigations, innovations, adoption and adaptation of cultures, arts and literature among many others ….all banned by the Hadith. The huge volume of the Hadith corpus and the numerous rules in interpreting it made it impossible for the layman to understand it without the help of the religious clergy. The religious clergy (and other leaders) understood the powers and authority the Hadith had given them in controlling and managing their societies….and will never be willing to let it go. Consequently, the Muslims have fallen into the abyss of darkness failing to be guided by divine light as they see the Quran through the lens of the Hadith. Indeed, the prophet says on the day of Judgement 25:30 "And the messenger will say: O my Lord! Indeed! My own people/community took this Quran as a forsaken thing / ignored it / abandoned it (Arabic: Mahjuran)"

[@user-k229]

Yasin Islam WOW!!! Subhaan Allah. May Allah bless you for this insight. You are totally correct in your understanding. Several verses in the Quran also forbid us to follow and accept hadith other than the Hadith of Allah swt i.e Al-Quran. The clergy... mullahs and Priests are a curse to the people. Allah actually says these people " Are a wall between Allah and His people." They have corrupted the Deen of Allah beyond all recognition. Now we have mazhab and not Deen!!!! Muslims fell asleep and lost a Precious Jewel (The Quran) and replaced it with a dark stone that has no value. But they placed a false value to it in order to take people away from the Quran for their own petty gains!!!

[@timran8553]

@Yasin Islam , by your name I am assuming you are Muslim with that being said I would like to say Aslam Mu Alikum. I would be very careful with your conclusion. Please study the Islamic history during Islamic Golden age, the scientific and philosophical progression was not due rejecting hadith, I can name a lot of scholars of that time that mastered philosophy, science and scared knowledge including Hadith. You say that we should only follow Quran, how can you understand the Quran without the life of Our Prophet (saw) hence Hadith, seerah etc. To say that we are not progressing in scientific studies due Hadith is the same as saying lets take the Prophet (saw) out of our lives because we are not progressing in this world (OstukafurAllah), the Quran is here because of the Prophet (saw) and your going reject the Prophet (saw) sayings. Now you mention lot of modern principle the hadith does may not comply with but there are thousands of hadiths that are timeless and will always apply, "white is not better than Black but in piety” ( paraphrasing) how come you did not mention that. Conclusion the difference between Islamic Golden age and now is has do with modern humans do not train them self with scared knowledge and sciences of today. Most tend to do either one but not both and it's a difficult task. Stay a keyboard warrior. Allah knows best.

[@dhumput]

MashaAllah, SubhanAllah What an enlightening discussion Shaikh Atabek Jazak Allah Khairun

[@ElecAndAll]

ماشاء الله Beautifully explained

[@Therestrial432]

Read the Quran in the chronological order and you will understand much more

[@jimmybeam1550]

Was thinking about attempting this. Im still divided in the belief it was revealed the way they say it was revealed as in out of order. But ill attempt it anyway. However i am 100% confident the Quran was completely compiled prior to the Prophets(PBUH) demise.

[@leilamazhar74]

Maybe even imam bokharis book has been changed. In the early times there wasn’t many people who can write and read an that book ha published hundreds time. And why no one think about that when you hear a speech from someone you can not 100% remember it the same way and the Hadith has been written at least one generation after first Sahabi, so surly they didn’t remember everything what a sahabi says that has heard from Prophet peace upon him. They was human too.

[@bilalamarumosi8282]

Absolutely

[@DBUification]

Fair, but Islamic scholars and Imams have gone through a very rigorous process of preserving these Hadith. I don’t think it was perfect though, and I think some of the original Hadith (Saheeh or not) may be missing surrounding context due to the natural forgetfulness and imperfect memory of human beings, while others simply could have been translated or transmitted incorrectly, or worse and less likely, fabricated. However I don’t think that rejecting Hadith in their entirety is necessary or appropriate, I believe what’s best is rejecting the ones that contradict the Quran and ignoring others that seem to conflict with the Quran or present the prophet or Sahabah in a negative light based on what we know about their personalities and character. You cannot have a prophet (SAW) who is advocating for women’s rights and saying Muslims are all equal except for what Allah judges based on their good and bad deeds, and yet degrade or demean women and suggest that they’re inferior to their husbands or lacking mentally or spiritually.

[@abdullahreed]

Alhamdulillah, brother Atabek has done good work. Yet this is authenticity, and is secondary to the problem of authority. The usul of hadith, or status of hadith, in islam, role of hadith in islam, and the hazards of these matters, are not discussed enough. The hadith are very hazardous. Please go further and re-examine what has been attributed to Imam Syafi'i regarding the need for hadith. I helieve that if the authority claims made on behalf of hadith are corrected we will be a more effective ummah in shaa Allah.

[@greendino8099]

Subscribing is not enough. Spreading this important video to every mosque is needed.

[@thmallik]

Very enlightening, Respect!! I would like to ask about the name of that Hanafi (RA) book which gives the guidance of rejecting hadith..

[@omourali5406]

Masha Allah i liked it sister especially how you brought questions which relates to an ordinary Muslim.

[@xxXsoundtrackerXxx]

A very informative and a much needed topic of discussion in today's world, especially for the younger Muslims like me who have probably heard more haidith in their lifetime than the translation of the Quran. For a while, I completly rejected all hadiths that I heard because I didn't quite understand them or just out of ignorance. However, I totally agree with shaykh for taking a balanced approach. Thanks to the whole team at "Quran Speaks" for the great work. Jazak Allah Khayran!

[@rteetfghhv3785]

A real hanafi scholar

[@andrewdelgado7020]

I’m a revert, and I know what I’m about to say is unpopular but I don’t follow Hadith. I didn’t realize how many Muslims never read Quran to understand, but learned to recite . “Thee Alone do we worship, Thee alone do we seek for guidance” Pretty clear to me. Great lecture tho, very informative.

[@Bing.chilling.1]

You need hadith to know how to recite the quran so it does not make sense to reject ahadith.

[@andrewdelgado7020]

@@Bing.chilling.1 so you rather recite than understand?

[@Bing.chilling.1]

@@andrewdelgado7020 i don't know if you're trolling or not, but just for your info if you are sincere ill explain: diacritic markings (fathah, kasra, dhammah) are not used in arabic originally and weren't used in old copies of Qu'ran until scholars added them to help non-arabs. How do we get these markings? From transmission of hadith.

[@waleeyahya198]

5:38 reference of this Hadith?

[@Scenic-Drone-4k-Australia]

When the shaykh is speaking arabic at 15:38, can someone please let me know what he is quoting? It sounds like Quran but I can't find the ayah. Jazakallah khair

[@Scenic-Drone-4k-Australia]

All good, found it: 29:43 'Watilka alamthalu nadribuha lilnnasi wama yaAAqiluha illa alAAalimoona' "And so We propound these parables unto man: but none can grasp their innermost meaning save those who [of Us] are aware"

[@Scenic-Drone-4k-Australia]

at 15:49 in the video he is quoting 58:11 of the Quran

[@Azura-adamson]

I can't speak for Saudi, Pakistan and Afghanistan. But rest of the Muslim world is desparately wanting scholars to revisit all interpretations and translations and science of hadiths. We can't say that out loud because we are afraid that we will be called slaves of liberals, but attitude of traditional Interpretations and actual Qur'an text doesn't match at all. Why can't we benifit from Qur'an at it's best potential, why these ultra traditionalists and literalists stop us from doing that? They don't have monopoly over Qur'an. Just because they got tawhid right doesn't mean everything they say is right. And to detachment from old pagan religions and superstitions, we muslims are arriving on natural Tawhid on our own. Shirk is dieing it's own death due to science. 90% of muslims are not even following what these literalists preach, muslims are living in apologetics fashion, because they can't practice literal meanings in practical life. Then why not give muslims the interpretation which they can practice in practical life. May Allah make things easy for us.

[@Abdullah-zo6fb]

May Allah Subhanahu wa Taala bless the Shaikh! Amen!

[@yayavellilion8136]

This saved me. For 2 yrs I doubted the ethics of islam. There is no reconciling some hadeeths and sira with kindness

[@rehanzamindar6533]

Can you give some examples..

[@sowhat9637]

Specially the hadith of war and captives section. They are very dangerous. They are enough to make a Muslim to leave Islam

[@jubs4388]

This is my struggle too. Esp Concubines

[@farukashraf5626]

Subhaan Allah, very good explanation! Shayk Atabek Dr Shabir Ally Mufti Abu Layth They help us to understand the real Islam!

[@jahedur]

I agree!

[@DBUification]

As personal advice, Mufti Abu Layth is not a reliable source as evidenced by his character and statements. I’m not saying this to bash him, but the man walks around in tight clothing that doesn’t properly conceal his Awrah, wears diamond necklaces and bracelets, and has said certain things are acceptable (like Muslims celebrating Christmas for example) which are undeniably haram and against the fundamental principles of Islam. He seems like a nice man, but his sense of judgement is heavily flawed and highly questionable from an Islamic point of view, he’s far from a Mufti.

[@Amadeus-ms9lt]

I can't agree about Abu Layth because from what I've seen, his methodology is all over the place leading to all sorts of odd conclusions.

[@RippleEffectProductions]

My question is very simple. First is that plz tell me that if Prophet Muhammad PBUH nominated any Sahabi to write down Hadith as he one Sahabi was given the responsibility of writing down Versus. 2nd Question is that plz elaborate that if a subject was never discussed or touched by Holy Quran and you find many Hadith about that matter so how you would take those to belief. 3rd and last one is that when Hadith were started compiling and why you find even 7 hadith with various words and phrases on the same subject in contrast of Qur'an and it's verses Will be much Obliged. Regards

[@AbdulH97]

Easy to answer: Firstly there were many hadith written at the time of the prophet like the collection of hadith by the companion of the prophet Amr ibn al As in the book "Al Sahifah al Sadiqah". Imam Bukhari merely compiled hadith that already existed from the time of the prophet, they didn't come with something new. Quick Question: The Quran says give the call to prayer(azan), what do you say in it? Do you just chant AZAN over and over, that's why you need hadith #2: The Quran says perform Hajj and Umrah, what's the difference between the two??? Again you need the hadith

[@OzemoyaOfDiyaar]

@@AbdulH97 Jazaakumu LLAAHU khayran. DO WE DO AWAY WITH HADEETH? OR WE TAKE WHAT GOES WUTH THE CONTENT OF THE QUR'AAN ONLY? ALLAAH has warned of a fitnah (trial) that will befall people who disregard The Prophetic statements with the claim that there was a lot about them. See this: فَلْيَحْذَرِ الَّذِينَ يُخَالِفُونَ عَنْ أَمْرِهِ أَن تُصِيبَهُمْ فِتْنَةٌ أَوْ يُصِيبَهُمْ عَذَابٌ أَلِيمٌ {And let those who oppose the Messenger's (Muhammad SAW) commandment (i.e. his Sunnah legal ways, orders, acts of worship, statements, etc.) (among the sects) beware, lest some Fitnah (disbelief, trials, afflictions, earthquakes, killing, overpowered by a tyrant, etc.) befall them or a painful torment be inflicted on them}. An-Noor, verse 63. He also said: وَإِنَّهُمْ لَيَصُدُّونَهُمْ عَنِ السَّبِيلِ وَيَحْسَبُونَ أَنَّهُم مُّهْتَدُونَ {And verily, they (Satans / devils) hinder them from the Path (of ALLAAH), but they think that they are guided aright}. Az-Zukhruf, 37. ALLAAH HAS ALSO INSTRUCTED TO HOLD UNTO WHATEVER THE PROPHET CAME WITH. He said: الرَّسُولُ فَخُذُوهُ وَمَا نَهَاكُمْ عَنْهُ فَانتَهُوا وَاتَّقُوا اللَّهَ إِنَّ اللَّهَ شَدِيدُ الْعِقَابِ {And whatsoever the Messenger (Muhammad SAW) gives you, take it, and whatsoever he forbids you, abstain (from it), and fear ALLAAH. Verily, ALLAAH is Severe in punishment}. Al-Hashr, Verse 7 HE ORDERED TO OBEY ALLAAH AND TO OBEY THE PROPHET: He said: قُلْ أَطِيعُوا اللَّهَ وَأَطِيعُوا الرَّسُولَ فَإِن تَوَلَّوْا فَإِنَّمَا عَلَيْهِ مَا حُمِّلَ وَعَلَيْكُم مَّا حُمِّلْتُمْ وَإِن تُطِيعُوهُ تَهْتَدُوا وَمَا عَلَى الرَّسُولِ إِلَّا الْبَلَاغُ الْمُبِينُ Say: "Obey ALLAAH and obey the Messenger, but if you turn away, he (Messenger Muhammad SAW) is only responsible for the duty placed on him (i.e. to convey ALLAAH's Message) and you for that placed on you (to obey him by complying with the message). If you obey him, you shall be rightly guided. The Messenger's duty is only to convey (the message) in a clear way (i.e. to preach in a plain way)." An-Noor, verse 54. He also said chapter 24, وَأَطِيعُوا اللَّهَ وَأَطِيعُوا الرَّسُولَ وَاحْذَرُوا فَإِن تَوَلَّيْتُمْ فَاعْلَمُوا أَنَّمَا عَلَىٰ رَسُولِنَا الْبَلَاغُ الْمُبِينُ And obey ALLAAH and the Messenger (Muhammad SAW)) and fear ALLAAH. Then if you turn away, you should know that it is Our Messenger's duty to convey (the Message) in the clearest way. Al-Maa'idah, verse 92. He stated same message in Ch 47 verse 32 and added: “and His Messenger, and do not render your deeds invalid (by disobeying The Prophet). THE PROPHET PERFECTLY DESCRIBE PEOPLE LIKE THIS, AS IF HE EAS REFERRING TO THIS CHANNEL AND ITS BLIND, FOLLOWERS. He said: عَنِ الْمِقْدَامِ بْنِ مَعْدِيكَرِبَ، قَالَ قَالَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم ”أَلاَ هَلْ عَسَى رَجُلٌ يَبْلُغُهُ الْحَدِيثُ عَنِّي وَهُوَ مُتَّكِئٌ عَلَى أَرِيكَتِهِ فَيَقُولُ بَيْنَنَا وَبَيْنَكُمْ كِتَابُ اللَّهِ فَمَا وَجَدْنَا فِيهِ حَلاَلاً اسْتَحْلَلْنَاهُ وَمَا وَجَدْنَا فِيهِ حَرَامًا حَرَّمْنَاهُ وَإِنَّ مَا حَرَّمَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم كَمَا حَرَّمَ اللَّهُ“.‏ Narrated Al-Miqdam Ibn Ma'dikarib: that The Messenger of ALLAAH (صلى الله عليه و سلم) said: "Lo! Soon a Hadith from me will be conveyed to a man, while he is reclining on his couch, and he says: “Between us and you is ALLAAH's Book (let's hold only to The Qur'aan). So whatever we find in it that is lawful, we consider lawful, and whatever we find in it that is unlawful, we consider it unlawful”. Then The Prophet added a warning: “Indeed whatever the Messenger of ALLAAH (ﷺ) made unlawful, it is the same as what ALLAAH has made unlawful." At-Tirmidhiy, 2664, Abu Dawud, 4604, Ibn Majah 13, Ibn Majah 12, And so on. INTELLECTUAL ARGUMENT: Let's even assume what Dr Ally Shabir claims and this Atabek, is true. The companions were closer to The Prophet. They have told us The things The Prophet said. Now, I want you to be very honest with yourselves. Do we throw all their narrations away in the claim that “it doesn't go with what the Qur'aan says”? The statements of The Prophet do not oppose The Qur'aan. It is our human shallow understanding that is defective. You want to use Imaam Abu Haneefah's statements to discard that of The Prophet, as narrated by the Companions of The Prophet? Common! The companions were right there with The Prophet days and nights. Abu Haneefah was not even born when the last companion died in 95 or 103 years after Hijrah. Do we accept his own, and throw the companions own away? Common sense determines that The opinions of The companions, not opposed by other companions supersedes that of Abu Haneefah. WITNESSING THE REVELATION IS AN ADVANTAGE. That the Prophet's companions witnessed the revelation of The Qur'aan is an advantage and they understood it better than any scholar that will live today. We should rather be follow the companions' assumed right ways than another person's assumed right. They knew the circumstances in which every verse was revealed and the reasons. They stayed and were trained with and by the Prophet. They can't be wrong while Dr Shabir Aliy and Atabek are right. If they narrated something, and we think they were wrong, do we then rely on Dr Shabir, who never met the Prophet? Dr Atabek claimed Abu Haneefah was closer to the era of The Prophet than other Imaams. Same way The companions were closer to The Prophet than Abu Haneefah. The earlier we follow The guidance of The Prophet the better for us. If the companions made mistakes, ALLAAH had promised to forgive them and told us He is pleased with them and promised them Al-Jannah. He also told us to follow their footsteps (see surah 9, Tawbah verse 100). Lastly, I want to remind you that ALLAAH categorically told us that we can gain success in life and hereafter by following Him and His Messenger. He said: إِنَّمَا كَانَ قَوْلَ الْمُؤْمِنِينَ إِذَا دُعُوا إِلَى اللَّهِ وَرَسُولِهِ لِيَحْكُمَ بَيْنَهُمْ أَن يَقُولُوا سَمِعْنَا وَأَطَعْنَا وَأُولَٰئِكَ هُمُ الْمُفْلِحُونَ The only saying of the faithful believers, when they are called to ALLAAH (His Words, The Quran) and His Messenger (SAW, his traditions), to judge between them, is that they say: "We hear and we obey." And such are the prosperous ones (who will live forever in Paradise). An-Noor, verse 51. May ALLAAH set our affairs right and guide us to the right path and keep us guided. May He take our souls only when He's pleased with us. Dear Muslims, let's think about the consequences of what we consume online. Your brother, Yusuf Ozemoya Abubakar, director and founder, Diyaar Academy For Arabic And Islamic Studies.

[@diaralcasanibrahim6582]

Bismillahir rahmaniir Rahiim! Asalamualikum! Scholars of Islam, Please read Quran 7:3 & 69:44-46, see if consistent with your teachings of Hadiths of men. Quran is complete, perfect, clear, in detail Words of Allah swt as finally & fully revealed to the last final Prophet Muhammad pbuh. How come after his death came thousands of hadiths of men all attributing them to Prophet Muhammad pbuh? How true they were all his words? How do you know hadith writers are not agents of the enemies of Islam when there is no way of confirming the TRUTH? I am not a scholar of Islam but I search & studied not only the Quran & Bible in search of TRUTH & I finally found that it is nothing else but the Quran Alone. Masha'allah! Subhanallah! Alhamdulillah! Allahu'akbar!

[@DBUification]

Hadith are absolutely a requirement to be a practicing Muslim in some capacity. It’s not unreasonable to believe that people documented the sayings of the rasool SAW during his lifetime (we have historical evidence of this as well), and thus the Hadith were born. However, the Hadith were meant to clarify some verses in the Quran. The Quran is perfect and complete in its own right in terms of laying out guidance, knowledge, ethics, rights, and punishments, absolutely. However, the Hadith serve to explain the details, rights, and conditions of the Quran’s verses and judgements, and I think it is appropriate to ignore any Hadith which doesn’t align with the Quran’s rulings and sounds questionable

[@DrWoofOfficial]

17:48 and note that Haroon was the Prophet there with them and even he could not stop Banu Israel from their disobedience!

[@gulshanmukhtar9651]

Excellent knowledge, well said.

[@greendino8099]

I like his accent, i like his content even better. SOOOO Glad found this video. Spread this vid!

[@swisscow1434]

Masha Allah! Great explanation.

[@dhumput]

Sheikh you have restored my faith in Hanafi / Sunni Mazhab

[@almiraalmira1451]

love this shaykh! hope to hear more!

[@ktheterkuceder6825]

"How can you understand the quran without hadiths?" Said the people who never read the quran on their own without hadiths and most probably never actually read but only merely memorize it and recite it.

[@DBUification]

There are certain things in the Quran which have additional details that are clarified in Hadith, which is why we have them. But the Hadith were intended to be a more detailed guide on how to handle various forms of guidance, not to overtake the Quran. But some issues are stark, like the killing of apostates for example even if they don’t betray the Muslim Ummah and are peaceful. The disagreement over issues like that literally causes people to murder one another, that’s extremely bad for the Ummah and it doesn’t make sense logically to kill a peaceful person who simply wants to leave Islam with no ill will towards the Muslims. That’s why we need more discussion and less rigidity on these issues

[@RobenArjen]

@@DBUificationprohibiting music also

[@laylaali5977]

True in fact there is no single Hadith that connects to any verse in the Quran also they argue how do you pray but there is no book of Hadith that tells you how to pray rather living suna does which is the person to person teaching how to pray a long other spiritual acts and ethics based on core principles/ethics of the Quran

[@huddz746]

Alhamdulillah the ending sentence answered the question keep it simple 5 basic principles good character

[@rehanzamindar6533]

The moment you say we hanafis...there's some problem... Rather you would be more just if you said...imam Abu Hanifa has a stronger proof here...hence I take it....

[@hilmyahmed6446]

You have a point... "we hanifis" does not come across good.

[@TheSaf7uk]

Hmm. I'm a bit wary of this video. It has some truth mixed with falsehood. He mentions a Hadith and makes the assertion that we can't rely on Hadith from prophet saw. However the Hadith in Q is mawqoof, not even a Hadith from prophet SAW. A lot of these types of ahadith are actually Israelite narrations from Jews n Christians

[@jenniraisovna5698]

In order to know which hadith are basically a lie, then comparison with Quran is needed to clear them from trash....Or just not follow hadith...just because it's not that necessary in some cases of life.

[@tazboy1934]

Jenni Raisovna nope u shud follow hadist too...don't talk like that sister

[@johunter4733]

Follow the real hadith, not fabrication.

[@NaeemKhan-cy2fg]

Jenni Raisovna Qur'an and mutawatir hadith and the practice of the three generation. Sahaba, tabieen and tabi tabieen

[@NaeemKhan-cy2fg]

Mr T Actually it's ijaza. Whichb is a stamp approval to teach th e Quran. But I know where your coming from. The guy is saying this as a fique prospectus.

[@tomward5293]

Does anybody know what verse he quotes at 16:00?

[@JavedKhan-he2pr]

Tom Ward Ayah 11 of surah mujadala

[@ahtishamkaramat2079]

James holmes True , Knowledge not=degree

[@ilyas8147]

This was great advise alhamdulillah

[@JaefarSABNW]

Prevalence of a belief or a practice certainly does not make it right. Belief and faith should not go against actual science. I agree that it is ridiculous to think inspiration would conflict with revelation or God would sanction a prophet who would cause conflicts with his teachings by example. It is important to realize the difference between what is attributed to Islam and how it may differ from its fundamentals and actually philosophy of religion.

[@Amadeus-ms9lt]

If you're talking about the Salaf of Madinah, then yes it makes it a Sunnah guaranteed.

[@voltage80x]

I needed this so much

[@tideturns4811]

How many sahih hadith can one reject and still remain a muslim? If the compilers of the hadith (all of them being Persians), have made significant errors, how can we trust them at all? Are there any original writings by Bukhari or others? If the Prophet a.s. has predicted the future and warned his Ummah about so many things (from proper use of bathroom to airplanes and Burj al Arab), why didn't he mention Bukhari or his likes? Why didn't he leave a book of hadith or give the instructions how to collect and classify the hadith?

[@LeekyKale]

Tide Turns the prophet did tell he’s companions to learn what he said, abu huraira used to spend a third of his night memorizing Hadith. The prophet did not need to predict Bukhara because all Bukhara did was compile the teachings of the prophet.

[@sanjarbek7037]

they all were not persians

[@bilalamarumosi8282]

@@LeekyKale actually there's the hadith where he said don't write anything except the Qur'an

[@bilalamarumosi8282]

@@sanjarbek7037 yes they were. Name the one hadith collector who wasn't?

[@rehanrassi9410]

Excellent info!

[@PW-le6cr]

Finally! I needed to hear this so bad

[@samsmith6279]

Ibadiya are the closest to authentic Islam. I'm really fascinated by them. They are the earliest islamic school of thought initiated by Jabir ibn Zayd May Allah bless him.

[@Muhsinoon94]

Jazakallahu hairan... Very understandable

[@TariqSalymAziz]

ABSOLUTELY GENIUS WOW

[@cinaapekredhuanoon6215]

More of such content please. Opinion of learned alims in hukum.

[@showmethetruth328]

Ladies and gentlemen you are witnessing first hand the evolution of islam. Same as the jews and Christians evolved over time. The age of the knowledge has ripped religion apart. Wow. Sahi hadith are being rejected left, right and centre.

[@rocketshoot3027]

Please no sweeping statements

[@ismailfarah230]

I watched this programme and we know that there are people called Quran niyuun and basically they reject our profit’s saying. The Hadith is the explanation of the Quran. I have question for you show in the Quran how many Rakat are there in each salah? You have to refer for the hadiith. Ignore this man

[@زينب44]

It's a start. The Quran first and foremost and in my opinion only source.

[@ateya1]

he made huge mistake '"at 8:03 mint he said earth in the back of the whale is hadith ''' its not hadith its Quran tafseer > what a great scholar ...didn't know the difference between hadith and tafseer

[@zahinelahi2655]

Lol you are the ignorant fool because popular Mufassirs like Ibn Kathir they use and reference hadith in their commentary of verses to provide context or explanation. Earth being on the back of a whale is a fabricated hadith considered to be 'of the Israelites' bc they were taken from the Jewish tribes in Medina who were flat earthers.

[@arminfroozanfar4876]

It was more than extraordinary .... God bless you.

[@MrYusha]

Salaam. I'm a Jewish convert to Islam from Iranian and Aramaic background. I've been Muslim for 15 years and know if this hadith that says on the day of judgement the bushes and trees will speak and say, there's a Jew behind me, come kill him! This hadith really upsets me. Please explain this hadith, not just for me but also for general Muslims and non Muslims and people who follow this hadith literally. JZK

[@defencenotdesign]

Ask this question on Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth on his channel. Insha allah hope your question gets answered.

[@RobenArjen]

That’s why don’t follow Hadith it is not a revelation like the Quran

[@anisaomar4432]

I heard that's about the followers of dajjal who will be opposing muslims in a war , so not just any jew.

[@centric145]

Where can I find the real hanafi fiq?

[@fijianz1]

BE YE NOT SHEEP BUT A SEEKER OF KNOWLEDGE....... VERY WELL EXPLAINED SHEIK !

[@rilum97]

Welcome back and Salam.

[@maxmax1607]

Asalamu alykum wa rahmatu ALLAH wa barakatuh Quran Speaks could you expalain the 4 famous scools of Islam? and jazakum ALLAH khayran.

[@crescentviewhs]

Wonderful 👍

[@maxmax1607]

Asalamu alykum wa rahmatu ALLAH wa barakatuh could you explain the 4 famous schools of Islam, and Jazakum ALLAH khayran.

[@RyanX1899]

Max Max they aren't schools, they are sects within the religion of sunnism.

[@ydw8405]

If we dont believe in hadist how do we know the movements of the shalat prayers ? how many rakaat for each shalat etc ? , since it is not mentioned in the Qur’an.. ..or you just cherry pick the hadists ?

[@mohammedrafi4789]

Brother y do quranites are not following sunnah of Prophet Muhammad SAW.

[@mohammedrafi4789]

I believe in one thing that if the hadit goes against the Quran then it is not acceptable. What do you think of it brother.

[@ydw8405]

Mohammed Rafi .. Of course, thats the no 1 rule..

[@mohammedrafi4789]

@@ydw8405 brother my question to. Reminder: don't be angry at me. Do you really believe that the prophet is poisoned by Jewish woman. Like what hadit says. But that hadit is false. What do you think of it. Proof is here kzbin.info/www/bejne/nXTMlWtpoLd0aKs

[@Bing.chilling.1]

You need hadith to know how to recite the Qur'an so hadith is vital for understanding Islam. so I urge any muslims reading these comments to ignore them as they contain serious errors in aqeedah.

[@Alommd76]

If I'm writing book about God can I say or call Kitabulla word of God?

[@Quranforalltimes]

Over reliance is as a result of laziness of majority Muslims of the willingness to actually read and understand the Quran accordingly.

[@redbeardandfriends]

Salaam! In the book entitled, "Knowledge of Allah", the shaykh who dictated the book said ",people are tied to the times they live in," it is obvious that we live in a time where kufr is the dominant ideology. It is the worship of the self and the intellect not the worship of Allah who created all of that. The result is confusion to the point that even the scholars are confused. The Quran and authentic hadith go hand in hand. It is not an obligation on the common everyday Muslim to be a scholar of tafsir of Quran or Hadith the obligation is to consult with the scholars on these issues. The common Muslim is obligated to learn the basics, The Kalima, how to pray, the halal and haraam and how to recite Quran correctly. Allah says in the Quran, "ask those who know if you don't know," Allah didn't say figure it out on your own! Lastly, another scholar said that there are fundamentally two forms of knowledge in our world, 1) knowledge which serves mankind, and 2) knowledge which mankind has to serve. The knowledge which serves mankind is technology, agricultural, and these type of things. The knowledge which mankind has to serve is the knowledge of Allah and the Prophetic way of life. In the beginning these two were connected, and the knowledge which mankind has to serve was above the knowledge which serves mankind. The Shaykh said that this order has been flipped upside down and the knowledge which serves mankind has become dominant over the knowledge that mankind has to serve, the knowledge of Allah and the Prophetic way of life , and this is the root cause of the disequalibrium in the world today. The Prophet (SAAW) is reported to have said in the khutba ta haja, "whomever Allah guides no one can lead astray, and whomever He has left to go astray no one can ever guide." Ya Ikhwan fear Allah and ask Allah for forgiveness and guidance, steadfastness in this Deen and well-being in this life and the Akhirah! Ameen and Allah knows best.Whatever was said that was correct is from Allah and what is incorrect and out of otder is from shaytan. May Allah forgive us increase us in the knowledge that benefits, and unite pur hearts on the Kalima Tayyiba Laa ilha illa Allah wa Muhammed ar Rasulullah

[@Cameron-o2x]

Every Muslim should watch this video, Only Qur’an is the true word of Allah SWT, As Allah SWT says in the Qur’an: Do they not ponder about the Qur'an? Had it been from any other than Allah, they would surely have found in it much inconsistency. (Ch.4, V.82)

[@amortalbeing]

Salam, I liked it a lot. God bless you all.

[@corazoncubano5372]

Very good discussion.

[@sahar2sahar169]

+ The Fact that the hadiths need to be authenticated is proof that they are not convincing and thus cannot be the word of God. To uphold a word other then the word of God is pure shirk. People like Bukhari doubted the hadiths that is why they authenticate the hadiths. If pple like them r not convince abt the hadiths who r we to believe in the hadiths?? Some people create idols and treat them as God and worship them while some people create authenticated hadiths and treat them as the word of the Almighty God. Same old story of making partners with God. God forbid...??? How do we do the salah & the others? The FACT abt the hadiths shows that there is a need to do a re-understanding of the Quran without the hadiths. It also prove that the salah & the others are things that are man made inventions. "Additionally we have appointed for every prophet enemies from among the humans devils and jinn devils who invent and narrate to each other fancy words in order to deceive. Had your Lord willed they would not have done it. You shall disregard them and their inventions. (6:112)" Read www.revivers of truth.com

[@sameerishaque7635]

.

[@haqqfarah1279]

I believe that you cannot make up knowledge if knowledge is lost.

[@anwarmamun2020]

His scholarship comes out when he speaks Arabic.

[@diarimachan]

Thank you

[@bashir_ansari]

Great talk.

[@Al-NABIL-ISLAM.]

Principials of hadith. We can reject hadiths based on what Which book of Abu Hanifa.

[@AtharQueen-th6ub]

Good but as for as correct logic is concerned,it reject everything that collides the Truth,it is a holy text or unholy text

[@jimmybeam1550]

I reject all haram, forbidden, punishment and reward (do this 3x get all sins erased nonesense) type hadith. Sunnah was supposed to be about actions of the Prophet(PBUH) and mannerism, etiquettes ect. An example, especially for early converts, for how to behave and carry oneself and interact in social and private settings.

[@anumrajput4234]

Great video..JazakAllah Khair!

[@alkhan6704]

Where there Hadiths...during Muhammad pbuh lifetime..or where they available the day after his death..no religion..should command you too become a scholar in order too get the message

[@mohammedrafi4789]

Yes there were hadit just research everything before you speak.

[@sabreeibrahim3775]

Finally!😊

[@hotmrd2203]

A liberating discussion, well done!

[@muhammadislaam9911]

If Hadith are tested by the Quran the criterion between truth and falsehood most of Hadith are nulled. Example, in Surah Ar-Raaf verse number one hundred and eighty-seven it says Judgment Day will come suddenly without any signs infact it can come right this next moment. This verse nulls hundreds of Hadith Concerning the signs pre Judgment Day. Second coming of Isa alaihi salaam, Dajjal, and Imam Mahdi gone out of window. May Allah give us guidance. Ameen.

[@mrnomad1737]

He also studied in Darul ulm Banori for 3 years and also I believe in Darulom karachi. Often the western centric muslims forget the science of islam us built on the contribution from the east nomatter how much they like to hide. Shaikh Atabek acknowledges this unlike the presenter.

[@josefineforsberg5807]

most these hadith he speaks about are weak to begin with, so you know they are to be rejected without a need of using mans ration which can be compromised

[@Sirdonrattray]

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله و بركاته Some of his reasoning is flawed. His attachment and ascription to being a Hanafi affects his ability to reason. He states in this video that he can not say that Saheeh al Bukhaari is the most authentic book or a completely authentic book because Bukhaari indirectly challenged Abu hanifah through it. He states numerous times that he cannot accept something because he is a hanafi. This is a closed and non-evidence based way of navigating the truth. These are claims that should be accepted or rejected based on them being true and being accurate or not and not anything else. The moment that you tie yourself to a principle or to a person or group that is always subject to change and susceptible to error you have set yourself up for misguidance. While he makes some great points I feel there is still an attachment to tradition that hinders his ability to be objective and view things without bias. I also feel with Shabir Ally that the reasons he gives for things being problematic are sometimes rooted in error. He will state that a Hadith is problematic because it makes things difficult for Muslims to, for example, buy a house because of the interest and for this reason it should be looked at. Or he will say that the ahaadith regarding music are problematic because we live in a time where music is unavoidable and it would limit us from being able to go to places like malls and this would be a type of extremism. These types of justifications focus on the difficulty a certain stance would cause to Muslims rather than the actual important thing which is whether or not it is prescribed or prohibited in a clear way. If it is proven that any of these things are prohibited or commanded and enjoined upon us as Muslims then it is for us to try our best to endure whatever hardship comes with that. It is difficult in many cases for a Muslim living in the west to socialise with non Muslim work colleagues without being prepared to go to bars and drink, or for many Muslim youth to fit in without being prepared to have casual and extra marital sexual encounters which are a norm in most western societies. None of these would be reasons to question the clearly established rulings pertaining to alcohol or Zina (adultery). I am not making any claims about the validity of the prohibition of music or giving any rulings or fatwas on interest and its characteristics, permissibility or conditions. I am saying that the reasons for questioning these things should be based on their validity and adherence or opposition to the evidences and what is true and correct and not what hardship adhering to the truth entails. I don’t care WHAT the truth is, I care that it is established based on clear, unambiguous and solid evidence and that once that is the case Allaah allows me to follow it, regardless of the hardship it entails, or on the flip side, the ease that it affords me.

[@criminozs]

You are absolutely right, Islam is complete. Not believing in hadiths only just because it is difficult to follow in current time is a sign of weak emaan.

[@Sirdonrattray]

Nothing that you said is in at odds with anything I said so I really don’t see what I’m wrong about. Would you care to elaborate and highlight what I said that contradicts the aayaat that you paraphrased? Allaah not wanting to cause hardship and granting us ease in the deen does not contradict the fact that an alcoholic finds it difficult to give up alcohol or the other examples I gave in the long comment I posted above. I think you completely missed my point.

[@OzemoyaOfDiyaar]

Thank you brother. DO WE DO AWAY WITH HADEETH? OR WE TAKE WHAT GOES WUTH THE CONTENT OF THE QUR'AAN ONLY? ALLAAH has warned of a fitnah (trial) that will befall people who disregard The Prophetic statements with the claim that there was a lot about them. See this: فَلْيَحْذَرِ الَّذِينَ يُخَالِفُونَ عَنْ أَمْرِهِ أَن تُصِيبَهُمْ فِتْنَةٌ أَوْ يُصِيبَهُمْ عَذَابٌ أَلِيمٌ {And let those who oppose the Messenger's (Muhammad SAW) commandment (i.e. his Sunnah legal ways, orders, acts of worship, statements, etc.) (among the sects) beware, lest some Fitnah (disbelief, trials, afflictions, earthquakes, killing, overpowered by a tyrant, etc.) befall them or a painful torment be inflicted on them}. An-Noor, verse 63. He also said: وَإِنَّهُمْ لَيَصُدُّونَهُمْ عَنِ السَّبِيلِ وَيَحْسَبُونَ أَنَّهُم مُّهْتَدُونَ {And verily, they (Satans / devils) hinder them from the Path (of ALLAAH), but they think that they are guided aright}. Az-Zukhruf, 37. ALLAAH HAS ALSO INSTRUCTED TO HOLD UNTO WHATEVER THE PROPHET CAME WITH. He said: الرَّسُولُ فَخُذُوهُ وَمَا نَهَاكُمْ عَنْهُ فَانتَهُوا وَاتَّقُوا اللَّهَ إِنَّ اللَّهَ شَدِيدُ الْعِقَابِ {And whatsoever the Messenger (Muhammad SAW) gives you, take it, and whatsoever he forbids you, abstain (from it), and fear ALLAAH. Verily, ALLAAH is Severe in punishment}. Al-Hashr, Verse 7 HE ORDERED TO OBEY ALLAAH AND TO OBEY THE PROPHET: He said: قُلْ أَطِيعُوا اللَّهَ وَأَطِيعُوا الرَّسُولَ فَإِن تَوَلَّوْا فَإِنَّمَا عَلَيْهِ مَا حُمِّلَ وَعَلَيْكُم مَّا حُمِّلْتُمْ وَإِن تُطِيعُوهُ تَهْتَدُوا وَمَا عَلَى الرَّسُولِ إِلَّا الْبَلَاغُ الْمُبِينُ Say: "Obey ALLAAH and obey the Messenger, but if you turn away, he (Messenger Muhammad SAW) is only responsible for the duty placed on him (i.e. to convey ALLAAH's Message) and you for that placed on you (to obey him by complying with the message). If you obey him, you shall be rightly guided. The Messenger's duty is only to convey (the message) in a clear way (i.e. to preach in a plain way)." An-Noor, verse 54. He also said chapter 24, وَأَطِيعُوا اللَّهَ وَأَطِيعُوا الرَّسُولَ وَاحْذَرُوا فَإِن تَوَلَّيْتُمْ فَاعْلَمُوا أَنَّمَا عَلَىٰ رَسُولِنَا الْبَلَاغُ الْمُبِينُ And obey ALLAAH and the Messenger (Muhammad SAW)) and fear ALLAAH. Then if you turn away, you should know that it is Our Messenger's duty to convey (the Message) in the clearest way. Al-Maa'idah, verse 92. He stated same message in Ch 47 verse 32 and added: “and His Messenger, and do not render your deeds invalid (by disobeying The Prophet). THE PROPHET PERFECTLY DESCRIBE PEOPLE LIKE THIS, AS IF HE EAS REFERRING TO THIS CHANNEL AND ITS BLIND, FOLLOWERS. He said: عَنِ الْمِقْدَامِ بْنِ مَعْدِيكَرِبَ، قَالَ قَالَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم ”أَلاَ هَلْ عَسَى رَجُلٌ يَبْلُغُهُ الْحَدِيثُ عَنِّي وَهُوَ مُتَّكِئٌ عَلَى أَرِيكَتِهِ فَيَقُولُ بَيْنَنَا وَبَيْنَكُمْ كِتَابُ اللَّهِ فَمَا وَجَدْنَا فِيهِ حَلاَلاً اسْتَحْلَلْنَاهُ وَمَا وَجَدْنَا فِيهِ حَرَامًا حَرَّمْنَاهُ وَإِنَّ مَا حَرَّمَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم كَمَا حَرَّمَ اللَّهُ“.‏ Narrated Al-Miqdam Ibn Ma'dikarib: that The Messenger of ALLAAH (صلى الله عليه و سلم) said: "Lo! Soon a Hadith from me will be conveyed to a man, while he is reclining on his couch, and he says: “Between us and you is ALLAAH's Book (let's hold only to The Qur'aan). So whatever we find in it that is lawful, we consider lawful, and whatever we find in it that is unlawful, we consider it unlawful”. Then The Prophet added a warning: “Indeed whatever the Messenger of ALLAAH (ﷺ) made unlawful, it is the same as what ALLAAH has made unlawful." At-Tirmidhiy, 2664, Abu Dawud, 4604, Ibn Majah 13, Ibn Majah 12, And so on. INTELLECTUAL ARGUMENT: Let's even assume what Dr Ally Shabir claims and this Atabek, is true. The companions were closer to The Prophet. They have told us The things The Prophet said. Now, I want you to be very honest with yourselves. Do we throw all their narrations away in the claim that “it doesn't go with what the Qur'aan says”? The statements of The Prophet do not oppose The Qur'aan. It is our human shallow understanding that is defective. You want to use Imaam Abu Haneefah's statements to discard that of The Prophet, as narrated by the Companions of The Prophet? Common! The companions were right there with The Prophet days and nights. Abu Haneefah was not even born when the last companion died in 95 or 103 years after Hijrah. Do we accept his own, and throw the companions own away? Common sense determines that The opinions of The companions, not opposed by other companions supersedes that of Abu Haneefah. WITNESSING THE REVELATION IS AN ADVANTAGE. That the Prophet's companions witnessed the revelation of The Qur'aan is an advantage and they understood it better than any scholar that will live today. We should rather be follow the companions' assumed right ways than another person's assumed right. They knew the circumstances in which every verse was revealed and the reasons. They stayed and were trained with and by the Prophet. They can't be wrong while Dr Shabir Aliy and Atabek are right. If they narrated something, and we think they were wrong, do we then rely on Dr Shabir, who never met the Prophet? Dr Atabek claimed Abu Haneefah was closer to the era of The Prophet than other Imaams. Same way The companions were closer to The Prophet than Abu Haneefah. The earlier we follow The guidance of The Prophet the better for us. If the companions made mistakes, ALLAAH had promised to forgive them and told us He is pleased with them and promised them Al-Jannah. He also told us to follow their footsteps (see surah 9, Tawbah verse 100). Lastly, I want to remind you that ALLAAH categorically told us that we can gain success in life and hereafter by following Him and His Messenger. He said: إِنَّمَا كَانَ قَوْلَ الْمُؤْمِنِينَ إِذَا دُعُوا إِلَى اللَّهِ وَرَسُولِهِ لِيَحْكُمَ بَيْنَهُمْ أَن يَقُولُوا سَمِعْنَا وَأَطَعْنَا وَأُولَٰئِكَ هُمُ الْمُفْلِحُونَ The only saying of the faithful believers, when they are called to ALLAAH (His Words, The Quran) and His Messenger (SAW, his traditions), to judge between them, is that they say: "We hear and we obey." And such are the prosperous ones (who will live forever in Paradise). An-Noor, verse 51. May ALLAAH set our affairs right and guide us to the right path and keep us guided. May He take our souls only when He's pleased with us. Dear Muslims, let's think about the consequences of what we consume online. Your brother, Yusuf Ozemoya Abubakar, director and founder, Diyaar Academy For Arabic And Islamic Studies.

[@mattschwarz6593]

Islam would have a better image without hadeeth. Quran is a wonderful Book and Islam is a beautiful and peaceful religion

[@RobenArjen]

Problem is not the Hadith but Muslims especially Sunni blindly believing it to be 100% authentic, why not follow what matches with Quran and disregard laws that are not found in Quran, adultery is Spoken in great length in Quran and not once is stoning mentioned

[@FawadBilgrami]

Hadiths are the reason Islam is intact. People would make their own ways of praying, give Zakat etc. Nobody cares about the image. One shouldn't be worried of others approval. Islam is easily followed if one has a sound knowledge of Hadith Sciences and Usul-e-Fiqh.

[@BeingHappy1000]

Welcome to paradise..Insha Allah :-)

[@rehanzamindar6533]

There will be a lot of errors in weak and fabricated hadeeths. Hence they are not to be acted upon. But can we challenge a hadeeth which is classified as authentic by major hadeeth scholars... Ofcourse not. So there's no problem in following hadeeth. Yes. Even if they sound irrational to us. For our minds may not be able to comprehend the wisdom.

[@tausif3k]

Who said that brother? Quran is Furqan(criterion to judge). Quran is infallible but who knows whether sahih bukhari and others got corrupted? or maybe Imam Bukhari or Muslim can make mistakes despite them being great Muslims who served Islam. Consider this please : [Sunan Ibn Majah Book 9 Hadith 1944 ] [classification: hasan] It was narrated that 'Aishah said: “The Verse of stoning and of breastfeeding an adult ten times was revealed1, and the paper was with me under my pillow. When the Messenger of Allah died, we were preoccupied with his death, and a tame sheep came in and ate it.” And response to this hadith by an Islamic scholar, Shaykh Imran Hosein: kzbin.info/www/bejne/iKTVhISbpK-XqdE So are you going to go with Quran, that it is a preserved perfect book or hadiths declared authentic but seemingly say that Quran is fallible? Brother Quran is furqan and is to be used to test hadith.If a hadith goes against Quran or says something other than Quran, then I am sorry. Please read this book: harun-yahya.net/en/Eser-Tipi/2751/Islam-The-Religion-of-Ease

[@hyrunnisa997]

That idea that you have to accept authentic hadith no matter what is what he was talking about. The contemporary Sunni religion is 80% hanbali. The salafis have spread their dogmatic views of Islam to so many muslims it's crazy. Even people who call themselves hanafi are falling prey to it. That is why we must follow the Quran and rely on the Quran. And reject false narrations.

[@rehanzamindar6533]

@@tausif3k Kindly give one example of a sound hadeeth contradicting Qur'an.

[@rehanzamindar6533]

@@hyrunnisa997 People who challenge hadeeth will probably challenge Quran also... Kindly read the first few verses of chapter 3.

[@ricbla3499]

@@rehanzamindar6533 in the hadiths we find that the Prophet said to stone adulterers, the quran says to lash them. Who is right? The quran or the hadith? The quran says that it is complete and fully detailed. Where is the stoning in the quran? There isn't so that hadith is fake

[@adicats]

God condemns Hadiths by name in the Quran.Period.

[@asimsparks]

Quran itself is also Hadith of prophet salallahu aleyhi wassalam. If we cannot trust what comes authentically from prophet, then the first thing we must reject is Quran itself.

[@LeekyKale]

adicats What you are saying is that god condemns speaking/talking. So in your view we can’t talk?

[@LeekyKale]

KebenaranBukanMilikAndaAtaupunSaya yes it is that does not mean we can’t learn from the prophet

[@bilalamarumosi8282]

@@LeekyKale U want to learn from the prophet then use the Qur'an.