Why Doesn't God Rescue Children in Gaza from their Suffering? | Dr. Shabir Ally

We're seeing a lot of death and destruction in Palestine, and in particular, in Gaza. Is God aware of what is going on? Why doesn't God intervene? Dr. Shabir Ally says that if God micromanaged human beings, this would diminish our free will. God judges us in the Life Hereafter and rewards or punishes us based on our choices in this life. He cautions that God will only tolerate the suffering up to certain point. God will intervene, but in the meantime, God is testing us. God doesn't just test the people suffering, but also people like us who are far removed from Gaza, and world leaders, who have the power to put an end to the vicious massacres but don't. Dr. Shabir says we can expect that God will bring about good from every act of suffering, including this one.
If you enjoy this video, please support our work financially by:
Visiting our website www.QuranSpeaks... OR
Sending an etransfer to [e-mail] OR
Subscribing monthly at Patreon.com/QuranSpeaks
► DONATE: www.quranspeaks...
► SUBSCRIBE: www.youtube.co...
Facebook: / letthequranspeak
Instagram: / quranspeaks.tv
Twitter: / quran_speaks

[@lolab7255]

Thank you so much for a balanced answer. I was crying and talking to God about this and the suffering around the world. Shortly after I saw this post. I feel so much better because I know God answered me through your wisdom and insight. I am Christian and I haven't heard anyone speak with so much love and understanding regarding how God test our hearts. Blessings to you!!

[@roycetondesilva4949]

Where is Allah. He is right there punishing the people who killed his own jewish children. Allah is God to the jews first before anyone else.

[@audreyheart2180]

@@roycetondesilva4949 we are all God's children. God always does what is right. Believe and Fear not... We cry out with raised hands to the Heavens for God's wisdom, justice, and forgiveness.

[@GeneralKnowledgeEcosystem]

she just brainwashed you lol

[@2l84me8]

So what was addressed? Did anything get fixed? No it did not.

[@syedsalam3199]

Allah SWT says in the Holy Quran, no one will escape the Judgment Day, and justice be served in His court. What a profound solace given to the believers.

[@John76125]

allah didnt write the quran moohammad made it up

[@analyticallysound2716]

@@kaluludhianvi Indian religions say bloodshed is due to poor choices which accumulate negative karma. Those who commit injustice will pay for their sins through a bad rebirth until their karma is burnt off. Infinitely more just than the islamic system which only gives people one shot to "pass the test" and it's either eternal torment or bliss.

[@thetruthwithproof8802]

We will Surely test you with something 0f FEAR and HUNGER and a Loss of wealth and LIVES and fruits, and give Good tidings to the patient ( Quran 2 : 155 )

[@the_batmobile0.4]

​@@analyticallysound2716um WHITE PEOPLE still living large, invading, conolizing, black people in congo etc, where's their karma?

[@JJk_edits4-b5y]

@@analyticallysound2716does your infinitely just system have any practical real world semblance? Let us say, in life you fail at something, do you keep getting chances? If you have to get infinite chances then what is the purpose of a test?

[@rdaleyj1]

Yessir many people are getting away with so much in this life but they will not escape the judgment of God. No-one will. 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻

[@DawnAlRayyan-mv9mq]

Hamdolah yahrub

[@roycetondesilva4949]

Where is Allah. He is right there punishing the people who killed his own jewish children. Allah is God to the jews first before anyone else.

[@bonniekerr4964]

@@roycetondesilva4949 Jews were once the chosen people. That was changed. And gentiles were also included.

[@faridamahomed1753]

S​@@bonniekerr4964

[@faridamahomed1753]

awnAlRayyan-mv9mq

[@anz2024]

For Muslim rulers in this situation the test is not to show " forgiveness and be cowardice" , not only the public but the all the Muslim rulers are being tested to see " whether they March in the path of Allah to help the helpless or would they just cling to their comfort and convenience". It will certainly invite the wrath of Allah. Those who are silently observing this genocide happening are inviting the severe torment for themselves

[@aminansar5294]

True, and what about muslims other than the rulers? Like us, shouldn't we do something to help also? Donate money to Gaza or help them in some other way?

[@doneracer5994]

@@aminansar5294 You brought up a topic that puzzles me. I thought that zakat was collected especially for situations like this. And all those Islamic theocracies which surround Israel but *refuse* to take in the Gaza & Palestine muslim refugees really sends a different message about Islam to people like me, a non-muslim. I would have thought they would all have united and rushed to help their muslim brothers and sisters. So what's that all about??

[@aminansar5294]

@@doneracer5994 Yes, there are in fact lots of muslims helping them. But of course not everyone is aware of ways to send money to them and some of those who do, are helping them out for sure but some are not. Not everyone is a true muslim, yet, or is willing to donate money to help others in need and that's how the world is. If I had money or I was a president of my country, I truly hope God would have made me give refuge to the palestinian brothers and sisters.

[@doneracer5994]

@@aminansar5294 Muslim countries like Egypt also have had terrorists running their countries. But Egypt managed to kill and throw out the terrorists and since then, they blocked muslim refugees from entering Egypt out of fear there are many terrorists among the refugees. It seems like Islamic theocracies should have gotten rid of their own terrorist brothers but instead thet did nothing. And now they just sit back and let their common enemy, the Jews, do the clean out of the terrorists by themselves. Islam's words and actions are Very confusing

[@doneracer5994]

@@aminansar5294 Thanks so much for your answer. It is sad that your attitude is not that of all the rulers of wealthy Islamic theocracies.

[@candicecole19]

“My Lord, You are my protector in this world and in the Hereafter. Cause me to die a Muslim and join me with the righteous.” ~ • ~ (Quran 12:101) 🤍

[@NinaSofia_]

Ameen

[@YahyaMuliana-h3w]

But the reality is God does not protect Gazan Hamas ...

[@samueld.webster2438]

I have been watching Let the Quran speak and i like it i have been studying the Quran for some time and I'm inspired by it

[@shaunshaikh8617]

God bless you brother. Peace

[@toshadenysekey5467]

May Allah guide you to accepting Islam as your way of life

[@maramjaber9016]

The holy Quran is a masterpiece. Nothing compares to its beauty in Arabic language. May Allah guide you to love the noble Quran.

[@thetruth871]

yes Shabir Ally i agree with you on this one! God tests everyone and yes God allows things to happen God loves us, but because of our sinful nature, He allows these things to happen. He knows that by allowing us to experience failure, pain, and struggle, we will grow stronger in our faith and to become closer to Him and moving away from sin. God bless

[@alberthoogendoorn2396]

Hard to understand, children and woman used as shield by Hamas, woman and children murdered by terrorists in the kiboetz. The Quran forbid murdering expletive so what is the matter with Hamas terrorists.? It is a crazy world .

[@5Poisons]

Allah - SWT- says in Quraan: "For each one are successive [angels] before and behind him who protect him by the decree of Allah. Indeed, Allah will not change the condition of a people until they change what is in themselves. And when Allah intends for a people ill, there is no repelling it. And there is not for them besides Him any patron." Aya 11 Sura 13: AL-RAD

[@ucapsalam]

Let those who would sacrifice this life for the Hereafter fight in the cause of Allah. And whoever fights in Allah’s cause-whether they achieve martyrdom or victory-We will honour them with a great reward. And what is it with you? You do not fight in the cause of Allah and for oppressed men, women, and children who cry out, “Our Lord! Deliver us from this land of oppressors! Appoint for us a saviour; appoint for us a helper-all by Your grace.” An Nisa 74,75

[@sulaimansabo8591]

This verses you quoted is addressing the situation at hand In another Ayah, Allah says” And what is the matter with you that when you are been called to fight in the cause of Allah you become heavy on earth? Are u pleased with the life of this word? And what is the life of Dunya compared to Akhira except a little”

[@user-lp423]

Our response defines us. Although I have left religion for many reasons, my path, now a spiritual one that is devoid of dogma, brings me to an understanding that we humans must spread love and peace in order to attain higher consciousness. All children are sacred... So, we adults must be the example of love. Enjoyed your discussion... Peace and love.

[@stevedeangelis5617]

Well said!

[@frankjones3508]

Easy for you to say, if you have the resources to make your life comfortable so that you can spread love and peace. Poor and weak people are almost non-existent or trivalized in most people's eyes...

[@uthman2281]

Without god there is no good or evil

[@fabianschrotter]

@@uthman2281 Beyond good and evil...Have you read Nietzsche's book?

[@uthman2281]

@@fabianschrotter I haven't read that book. What is your point?

[@M10FUN]

''freedom of choice''.....every MOMENT is '' a choice '' as to what we do during it...alhumdu Lillah. Praise Allah all the time.

[@mansurhallaj8568]

he is lieing, in Islam there is no freedom of choice

[@ezesolomon3996]

Is it the choice of the oppressed to be oppressed

[@GeneralKnowledgeEcosystem]

then why praise him and give him credit for good

[@andydallo5826]

we have kids and women murdered and you guys talking about the judgement day. GOd brought them on earth to live this life ?

[@muhammadali-bv6qx]

He is one of the best scholars from the Muslim world. Jazzak Allah, Sir.

[@muhammadali-bv6qx]

He is limited to " AL Kitab." And we all know Quran is free from all doubts, and the Quran is directly given by the Holy Prophet (pbuh).

[@muhammadali-bv6qx]

@kaluludhianvi right. But each and every religious book will be considered in the light of the Quran. Quran is al meezan , al Furqan and al muhaimin.

[@MekkaMehamedi]

ነብስና እንተዘይቀይርና ኣላህ ኩነታት ኣይቅይሮን እዩ።

[@kamariahkamis8356]

Thanks

[@QuranSpeaks]

This means a lot to us. Thanks so much!

[@ezesolomon3996]

If God cannot prevent an oppressor exercising his freewill, why can't he protect the oppressed since it's not his freewill to be oppressed?

[@tasrifkusuma5265]

The oppressed has free will to be impatient to God, to go on rage, to go suicide, OR to be patient, to endure, to fight along with the fighters to retaliate the oppressors. Everyone has free will, but not everyone has privilege.

[@ezesolomon3996]

@@tasrifkusuma5265 then Allah is not useful for anything. The orphan has to struggle for himself to survive even though people say he has parents

[@truthseeker4625]

@@ezesolomon3996 If you seek truth,reason and wisdom that has been presented in the vedio clip. You and I are being tested too and I pray we pass and not failed and malign God due to impatience and emotional desperation. Read this: "And never think that GOD is unaware of what the wrongdoers do, he only delays them for a day when eyes will stare in H0RR0R ( Judgement Day ) ( Quran 14 : 42 )

[@oak7OO5]

You need to realize that this is the reality of the world. Killing, murdering, being dead is not a fantasy concept. This is real. You can't blame God just because you want to deny this reality. God created everything but destructions are caused by evil. You simply can't comprehend the Big picture that God has put in his devine governance and everything of his creation under his Majesty. His Majesty and favor is far past beyond everything you can imagine of sufferings. He's beyond and above everything. But don't worry God is just and that's why there's an eternity in the here after. True justice is what would come From God on that day.

[@oak7OO5]

This life is only a mere test remember. It would feel like one mere surge of a dream once we discover ourselves in the Eternal life. The True life.

[@echoa9252]

Dr Shabir is a man of faith, a man of reason and a man full of wisdom. Compare Dr Shabir with Rabbi Mizrachi who expresses deep hatred toward Arabs. Dr Shabir please continue spreading the noble message of truth and reason.

[@M10FUN]

O Allah owner of the Day of Judgment, help the helpless. Aamen, Alhumdu Lillah

[@showdoctors]

This is What you sow what you get

[@kissygu2842]

Why does the explanation for this question 0:25 put into frame the freewill of those who acts bad only. And they are the main subject of the answer. It never accounts for the victims or those who suffer from those acts. It is like they don’t exist in the answer. Is that they are forgotten by the answer?

[@JJk_edits4-b5y]

Behold, thy Lord said to the angels: "I will create a vicegerent on Earth." They said: "Wilt Thou place therein one who will make mischief therein and shed blood?- whilst we do celebrate Thy praises and glorify Thy holy (name)?" He said: "I know what ye know not." Surah 2 verse 30

[@MN-io8iy]

Shocking! I was just going to post this exact same ayah!

[@omara9427]

Comes down to God honouring His promise of giving us the Freedom of Choice.

[@Melungeonpeople]

I'm a Sephardic Jew in America. I'm also Cherokee, Lumbee and Athabascan Indian. I understand both sides but ultimately I must with the Palestinians. We Jews had been gone for 1000 years from Palestine. We were exiled for a reason and that Exile has not ended. It would be like all of Sephardim returning to Spain and Portugal and putting all Spanish on notice that we are now in charge or my Native American relatives taking over all the lands taken in colonization. I have no idea how to fix this situation. I pray for both sides. I am a Nationalist and I reject all forms of colonization regardless of the pretense. This includes Mass migration to Europe, America invading the Middle East in order to destabilize the Arab World, China in Africa, or Africa in Europe. Multiculturalism will never work and never has. Somebody always wins after much blood shed. We need diversity of nations not people.

[@MuscleJoy]

Beautiful and wise words

[@roycetondesilva4949]

Where is Allah. He is right there punishing the people who killed his own jewish children. Allah is God to the jews first before anyone else.

[@lelouch19]

Multiculturalism has worked. Under Islamic caliphates ones that were true to the religion. Jews and Muslims and Christians were living in peace before the Zionist came. You might want to think about why that is..m

[@Luvurself87]

It’s great to see someone who understands. But there were Jewish people living in Palestine along with Muslims and Christians. All 3 religions were living peacefully, until Palestinian lands were given away and they started unaliving the Palestinians to take more of their lands and ethnically cleanse them. I have Israeli friends, that left Israel because they were treated badly. She told me specifically that the Jews that actually lived in Palestine before all of this, were and is still are treated like minority, almost like slaves. They are hateful towards Jewish people as well. This is all about power and control.

[@Luvurself87]

Just to be clear it was the Israelis mistreating the Jews there.

[@Ron_po]

is issue has shown us the true face of everyone and tested our faith (imaan). No matter what happens, never lose your faith, and things will change over time.

[@mahatabdiabdullahi5527]

Allah is all knowing,all hearing, all seeing ,all wise, the best planner. We are confident Allah has good plans for the people of Palestine in the unique way of Allah.

[@faisalsheikh7426]

Much respect, but how can the suffering where a child survives but loses parents and siblings. How can the level of suffering be allowed and how can a child be exposed to trauma and pain by the all mighty , is he testing a child

[@2loco]

No. He's testing everyone. The family of that child, the ones who inflicted the suffering and murder, the ones who supply the weapons, the ones who fund it, the reporters who lie about it, the politicians who hide the truth, the ones who sit idly whilst the genocide us taking place and let it be when they can actually try to intervene. The list goes on.

[@tasrifkusuma5265]

Ask the oppressors why would they do that.

[@faisalsheikh7426]

@@tasrifkusuma5265that’s not what the talk is about. The talk is about why god does not intervene to stop it and my question was to a scholar to better understand why suffering and evil still happen if god is merciful.

[@tasrifkusuma5265]

@@faisalsheikh7426 God will not burden a soul more than its capacity. If the child mentality cannot hold it and become crazy, then during the time of craziness, he/she will not be accountable to God's command. If the child can endure and pass the test, then surely God is rewarding. Remember, the life on this earth is like a few seconds compared to afterlife. Be strong not to fall to wickedness and ingratitude just for that few seconds.

[@GeneralKnowledgeEcosystem]

all rubbish , there is no ullah, stop relying on him

[@aslampars4393]

Thanks!

[@Irene_Hwang]

My heart is stirring for the many people out there who are blind to the cruelty that is happening in Gaza. They even mock Islam and Palestinians. 😢

[@siddarthkoul1]

Ask hamas terrorists to release the hostages first. Islam is a curse on humanity

[@tasspafitis848]

@@kaluludhianvi But God gave man free will , so man decides who he wants to terminate and massacre , so what he actually is saying is that the man Made God is incompetent & a useless entity in the imagination of the flock of sheep & goats that believe their religious texts written by illiterate & uneducated sheep herders thousands of years ago to see who could write the best fairytales and fool the world .

[@shaunshaikh8617]

@@kaluludhianvi Okay. So who's not allowing whom to "let live" in this case?

[@roycetondesilva4949]

Where is Allah. He is right there punishing the people who killed his own jewish children. Allah is God to the jews first before anyone else.

[@galactic_spectator6409]

@@kaluludhianvi A perfect Pajeet response. No depth, No sense, just provocation so he can get Rs. 100.

[@tentimesful]

I was 3 years old when I got shot in Somalia... the little creeps first robbed us and put us in a room where 1 or 2 of them started to fire machine gun all over the room, I was holding my grandmother from behind as a 3 year old but heard the bullets reflecting from the walls and ceiling... So deceided to step back and then bullets came at me I defended with my arms and so the bullets hit the leg of my grandmother and my to arms breaking them, then they left.,.,, but eventually my father flew us to nairobi to get the hit to a good hospital... for me everything regenerated and my hands and arms work greatly... well one question how couldl I stop bullets with my two arms, maybe god had mercy and sent angels down and helped me to be fast enough to protect my body... I was muslim at that age though, as I used to read suratal shams with grown ups, verse for verse and next and next... Im happy allah al hamd saved me but would have no problem if he took me away as a muslim as it will make things easy no sins and all the gifts of a muslim in paradise you will get...

[@jjassy752]

Keep string brother. Allah bless you all

[@3boys1family]

May Allah save the oppressed!

[@charlesmuhmanson3928]

May God judge the wicked who committed atrocities on Oct. 7th while protecting the innocent, freeing the hostages in the process.

[@Yashusayn]

@@charlesmuhmanson3928the wicked are the zionists

[@jadugarqatil]

​@@charlesmuhmanson3928scavenging for shekels, are you?

[@charlesmuhmanson3928]

@@HH-pv9ex Including the hostages captured and abused on Oct 7th.

[@Eric-fp4cj]

He's a terrible sinner all who kiss the black stone go to hell

[@robertgreen6125]

God is within you

[@kipgold893]

Beautiful

[@najamfarhan]

Takk!

[@nisarahmadi385]

May almighty Allah rewards you respected Dr Shabir brother for your meaningful insights

[@roycetondesilva4949]

Where is Allah. He is right there punishing the people who killed his own jewish children. Allah is God to the jews first before anyone else.

[@fajranshams1971]

Simple answer in all religions. None can't blame God.

[@zeshanhm]

Love you guys, may Allah preserve and keep both of you. Free Palestine.

[@fidelcatsro6948]

ameen, my cat loves u too! 🐱♥️♥️♥️

[@inaiyer1]

Well, Allah is watching us and Allah will judge each one of us. In the meantime, all I can say and will continue to say is that Latin American Countries Have More Spine Than Some Arab Kingdoms. Sickening but true.

[@fidelcatsro6948]

1. Pray for our brothers and sisters. 2. Spread awareness about the committed crimes on social media. 3. Spread the literature on this issue. 4. Local publicity (billboards, buses, venues, etc.) 5. Peaceful protests. 6. Boycott. 7. Contribute financially (charity, a portion for Palestine). 8. Condemn on mainstream media if you can. 9. File legal cases in international courts. 10. Protest at a diplomatic level (e.g., letter to the ambassador). 11. Total trade boycott at the country level. 12. Cut diplomatic ties. 13. Unite!

[@PraderpPaze-md3sl]

Am sure you living on benefit in western country That's bigotry You should live in Islamic country and civilised them

[@patrickokoroit2282]

We don’t use hate to avert hate. Love covers multiple of wrongs. You made a good point on giving but the rest it’s total wastage of time.

[@fidelcatsro6948]

@@patrickokoroit2282 my cat loves u too!

[@khalidallynganzojr1676]

Thank you for increasing my faith

[@RAF0769]

Thank you for this video. I appreciate all the work you guys are doing putting videos togethor. I hope others are donating to help you guys in your efforts. I have made a small contribution, and I hope that it helps just a little bit!

[@jorgegustavozarantemaldona2277]

Thankyou! It is a great consolation because of that poor children and people in general.

[@realt1984]

Beautifully eloquently explained 🤲🏼🇵🇸

[@douaaomar4823]

As a non-religious person, when someone tells me that they may not be judged here but in the hereafter, that does not sit right with me at all.

[@Coconut9165-w3b]

10 months in the war, so where exactly is Alla? 😂😂😂

[@audreyheart2180]

Father, forgive us, for we don't know what we're doing... please protect our Palestinian brothers n sisters.

[@dmurphy3202]

Putting God aside.... why isn't the Arab world doing more as fellow Muslims? Why ignore the plight of the Palestinians? To me, the Arab world doing nothing to help their Muslim brothers and sisters is shameful.

[@Sum_Ting_Wong]

Because Arab nations are impotent and not capable of having war.

[@Kman666]

Arab leaders are not the same as the Muslim people. What this conflict has shown us is, it is not Gaza that is occupied but in fact the entire Arab world that is occupied.

[@xaheer1]

No one can help but ALLAH... Thats our iman our trust.

[@John76125]

theyre scared especially hezbol

[@kamariahkamis8356]

Some leaders are traitors

[@okman9684]

The coping in the video is so hard 🥵

[@sahar5522]

With all due respect, what freedom did God give to the children of Gaza by making them suffer 😢

[@waseemraza784]

Freedom is given to the people who are committing these sins, children will be in Paradise who suffered for these troubles.

[@amiamiri5978]

I am pretty sure that you won't make this asinine statement if your own children were among the dead.

[@savitar8002]

​@@waseemraza784 which means Israel killing Palestinianian children is good so that they go to heaven? Then y Muslims are condemning Israel's bombing?

[@toufikhasan5240]

Abosolutely yes​@@amiamiri5978

[@timeisfleeting2452]

The great Shabir Ally. And the great Dr Safiyyah. Two of my all time favourites. This non Muslim stands with you.

[@roycetondesilva4949]

Where is Allah. He is right there punishing the people who killed his own jewish children. Allah is God to the jews first before anyone else.

[@Xscrambler]

​@@roycetondesilva4949that's a blatant LIE

[@rudiborn]

"And if Allah were to impose blame on the people for what they have earned, He would not leave upon the earth any creature. But He defers them for a specified term. And when their time comes, then indeed Allah has ever been, of His servants, Seeing." (Surah Fatir Ayah 45)

[@tasrifkusuma5265]

God gives us time. He Himself is not affected by time. He has no beginning no end.

[@Jimmisierra-jw9mj]

god is busy enjoying my and others suffering

[@vandenberghsimon]

Amos 1:6 "So I will send a fire upon the wall of Gaza, and it shall devour her strongholds."

[@RizMetrix]

Allah is upset with us and our leaders . And he is showing us the true colors of our leaders too

[@rrost1500]

Gazans are being punished for failing to leave Gaza when required to do so even by Muslim scholars (Al-Albani).

[@jazzon2538]

​@@rrost1500Very true that there were many scholars and even scholars who are alived today that when Palestine was being occupied everyone should have left right away. Prophet Muhammad and the Sahab experienced a similar incident in Mecca or Medina I forgot which one it was. Prophet Muhammad told the Sahab to go to Abyssinian because there is a just king and to live in his country.

[@tasrifkusuma5265]

No, it is not wrong to stay strong in our position or land. But there are greater consequences if we do it, and hopefully greater rewards.

[@610MARYAM]

God is always here He's waiting for us to show unity And help make world better I saw a glimpse of heaven n so did the ppl I was with. End to oppression 🤲⭕💜🌠

[@kamron4u]

It's not test, FREEWILL, it's your freedom be good, get good and be bad get bad AFTERLIFE..

[@shajant6883]

The test thing makes logic go out of the window

[@tasrifkusuma5265]

It is connected. We have a free will thus we are tested. If we don't have free will, there is no test, we are just an NPC.

[@kamron4u]

@@tasrifkusuma5265 see there was no test. It was the free will of baba Adam he went against will and ate forbidden fruit. Just if it wouldn't happen. Were would be??? Or would be there or not. He ate so here we are.

[@tasrifkusuma5265]

@@kamron4u I don't think I would blame Adam. It already happens, we are on earth. Just do our best doing good in life. Hell is not a good place to settle. So yes, it is a test: are we worthy enough to be paradise inhabitants.

[@kamron4u]

@@tasrifkusuma5265 who is blaming baba Adam I am talking about freewill he had thats the beauty of Allahs finest creation they can deny. Allah has ilmay gayab. Don't stress bro it is not important topic, important is to prepare for akhirah

[@mohammedkoduvamparambath4271]

The answer - god is testing our patience - is not satisfactory. Why does He want to test.? He already knows the level of our patience and even know the aftermath. Everything is as per his plan. He is all-knowing - isn't he?

[@ClandestineGirl16X]

It's unfortunate that it's 2023 and nations still turn to death and destruction to "solve" issues. So sad and barbaric

[@steviacandyman7892]

Oh you mean like how Islam was spread for most of its history? What hypocrisy.

[@seanc2788]

It was prophesied 2,000 years ago. This is just unfolding as it should.

[@seanc2788]

@@kaluludhianvi That's a bunch of BS. Prophets were sent to foretell the future. That's why they are called a prophet. However, there are many false prophets. In the ancient days, false prophets were killed if their words about the future did not come true. Today they are allowed to say whatever they want. I already have the light and hope of Christ within me. Nothing else matters.

[@DrAzeemnephrologist]

Whatever happens is the test of Allah for the believers against the disbelievers But ultimately believers in Allah and his messenger will win Insha Allah

[@JibreelProductions]

Nothing happens without the permission of Allah SWT and his will, this world is truly a test, so we will only see the justice of Allah SWT when it happens, until then we are no one to assume of Allah SWT, he truly is the most merciful, and the avenger. Alhuamdulillah...

[@mkenareh]

Tell that to mothers of the dead children on both sides and yes nothings happens without Allah writing it so why did Allah do this?

[@SilkeFauve]

Thank you for the comforting message. I feel that God is present in your work.

[@Andrew_Young]

I really like the idea that it's just to take an eye for an eye, but to forgive is better. I also love how this Muslim perspective recognizes the virtues of Christianity and Judaism and takes the best of both.

[@Andrew_Young]

@@kaluludhianvi I mean, there are a lot of Christians in Palestine and there are Muslims in Israel and there are Jews who oppose Israel. So, it's not as simple as Jews against Muslims or vice versa.

[@khaliduae-qv5ni]

We have revealed to you ˹O Prophet˺ this Book with the truth, as a confirmation of previous Scriptures and a supreme authority on them. Quran 5 48 In this verse, the address is to Prophet Mohamed saying that to him Allah has revealed the Quran which confirms the Torah and Injil, Books previous to it, and is their custodian as well. This is because, after the people of the Torah altered the Torah and the people of Injil made changes in the Injil, it was the Quran alone which turned out to be the kind of overseer and protector which exposed the alterations made by them, lit up truth and reality in their proper perspective. Even today, the true teachings of the Torah and Injil still survive through the Quran while those who inherited them and those who claim to follow them have disfigured them to the extent that it has become impossible to distinguish truth from untruth.

[@Andrew_Young]

@@khaliduae-qv5ni I appreciate the scriptural quote, but prefer Dr Shabir's articulation of its meaning. I wish Dr. Shabir would quote directly from the Quran and Hadith more often.

[@zunairakhtarkhan]

What is the point of Dua if Allah is going to allow things based on freedom of choice ?

[@toufikhasan5240]

Valid question

[@Fitkick45]

It sounded that he didn't have a valid/justified answer to her first question. Sometimes I wonder, am I believing a fiction or a concept ? Tested when you are already vulnerable. What a concept !

[@thirstingknowledge]

I think he meant was humans were given free will. That God really interfere in that. And time doesn't exist in spirit world.

[@Fitkick45]

@@thirstingknowledge I am a born Muslim and probably know a thing or two about my faith. God gave free will to Humans to get knowledge and revert to Islam. Else, if you die without faith, you would go to eternal hell, unless God wants it otherwise. This logic makes it mandatory for the humans living in the jungles of Amazon, where modern civilization is yet to go, to get knowledge, revert or be doomed. How ? Is it fair ? And if not, how can God be wrong ?

[@GeneralKnowledgeEcosystem]

@@thirstingknowledge so when any good thing happens why you praise your ullah?

[@pissanukatika3720]

God knows everything and He has His time to act or to work.Wait for Him.

[@andreasmartin7942]

Maybe god does not like what Hamas is doing?

[@Sum_Ting_Wong]

but loves what Israel is doing?

[@fidelcatsro6948]

For the LORD had commanded Moses to say to them, “You are a stubborn people. If I were to go with you even for a moment, I would completely destroy you! Looks like pot calling the kettle black God doesnt like Israel too...😂😂😂

[@GLang-kq5lw]

@@Sum_Ting_Wong God doesn't love evil of anyone

[@andreasmartin7942]

@@Sum_Ting_Wong if we assume that there really is only one god then he loves both sides equally. He created them both, no? And watching your children kill one another is a very sad affair.

[@SALEEMKHAN-yj7mu]

All your points are valid. The question here is Why Allah not responding to Palestine's prayers meaning kids are dying for no reason. What happened to the attributes of Allah? Why does Allah stick to the static Quran??? Its a book but more than a book its kid life's. Why Allah tests his own creatures? Created by him Why Allah doubt human's? Allah intervened in Prophet Ibrahim event of sacrificing his Son Why Allah intervened then ? And why not now? Earth has messed up due to no intervention of God.

[@bharatyaswaraj5641]

Cause God doesnt personally intervene on behalf of anyone

[@ClandestineGirl16X]

It's not Palestines fault. It's Hamas

[@uthman2281]

It is izrhell nazis

[@bellak2140]

Its zionists fault. Hamas didn't exist in 1948 when european jews stole Palestine with the help of Britain and massacred, raped, tortured and ethnically cleansed over half of the Palestinian population.

[@honeyb3603]

God is Just, He will compensate the oppressed and punish the oppressor in the way he want. People who think they are free to commit any crime in God's kingdom will regret forever when they ll face God on the day of judgement. For every person his judgement and punishment starts from the day he dies and leave the physical body. we can't witness that so we don't know how severe that punishment is. people have to never forget that God is Just and needs not any court to trial anyone, he has all the knowledge on every one

[@jackryder6732]

Well said. Alhamdulillah

[@HutanBeringin89]

God is an illusion.. religious people keep reasoning their illusion and halucination.

[@nasadeen1972]

Obtaining freedom is never free of struggle or sacrifice. As long as we understand that and do not allow it to stop us from taking action, "Free Palestine" will always have true meaning. May Allah guide and protect us all, inshallah.

[@kafir619]

Only true God can save.

[@fabianschrotter]

A God who is omnipotent and allows children to suffer is not kind. A God who is kind and allows children to suffer is not omnipotent.

[@steviacandyman7892]

The god of Islam likes torturing people. They tell us all the time about it.

[@santaclaus1208]

A God who is kind and omnipotent certainty does not exist in this universe.

[@aminansar5294]

Let me complete your statement here: God, who is omnipotent and allows children to suffer, then gives those children a place in paradise for what they endured, is not kind? This whole world's worth is not even equal to a tree in Paradise. Once you see it, one would want to suffer and die thousands of time to achieve it let alone once, as far as I believe.

[@santaclaus1208]

@@aminansar5294 did you go to paradise already? Can you verify any of these claims about paradise etc?

[@aminansar5294]

@@santaclaus1208 Well, I do believe in God. That's enough to put your belief in paradise. Just think, God would have made a perfect world as He is all powerful. This is certainly not a perfect world, people die, there are diseases and evil. Where is that perfect world? Well, that's paradise or whatever name you call it with but we humans have this innate desire for such a world for sure and this desire was certainly put into us by the Creator. Just ponder upon this

[@idalahow]

والله بصير بالعباد..... God can decide to micro-manage everything...but gives us freedom of choice....ability to benefit /harming others....

[@santhiramorgan8329]

I ALWAYS HAVE HAD THIS QUESTION. SORRY SHABIR YOUR ANSWER IS NOT CONVINCING. WHY MUST GOD TEST TODDLERS AND CHILDREN.

[@GLang-kq5lw]

@@HH-pv9ex the devil is the reason of all evil

[@heythere4218]

All the people of gaza will get highest level in heaven.

[@zeynepazman9785]

Elhamdülillah beautiful teachings ❤

[@stevejones2945]

Why would a God who supposedly knows everything and reads our hearts need to test us?

[@sadiqurakon]

Al-Mulk 67:2 in Quran ٱلَّذِى خَلَقَ ٱلْمَوْتَ وَٱلْحَيَوٰةَ لِيَبْلُوَكُمْ أَيُّكُمْ أَحْسَنُ عَمَلًاۚ وَهُوَ ٱلْعَزِيزُ ٱلْغَفُورُ English - Dr. Mustafa Khattab, the Clear Quran ˹He is the One˺ Who created death and life in order to test which of you is best in deeds. And He is the Almighty, All-Forgiving. English - Tafsir Ibn Kathir

[@timeisfleeting2452]

An Israeli minister is floating the use of nuclear weapons on Gaza, and Netanyahu is appealing to the genocidal example of Amalek, but remember only Muslims have extremists. Very instructive.

[@walkingwith_dinosaurs]

I envy people who believe there's God

[@rdaleyj1]

Whether you believe in him now or not will not change the fact that what Jesus did on the cross saved humanity, and one day either in this world or the next, you will be reconciled back with your Creator and Savior and the one who wakes you every morning and protects you throughout the day. 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻

[@shajant6883]

I too wished I hadn’t crossed that line. The realisation of reality that your no different than a weed. You sprout out, flower and try to spread your seeds and then just die .

[@oforimensah4711]

Psalms 83 O God, do not remain silent; do not turn a deaf ear, do not stand aloof, O God. 2 See how your enemies growl, how your foes rear their heads. 3 *With cunning they conspire against your people* *they plot against those you cherish.* 4 *“Come,” they say, “let us destroy them as a nation,* *so that Israel’s name is remembered no more.”* 5 With one mind they plot together; *they form an alliance against you* 6 the tents of Edom and *the Ishmaelites,*

[@auycharxernaighn7893]

I still don't understand how can a merciful God allow this to happen..please don't say test.. I really don't understand the logic behind "I love you so I make you go through so many difficulties".. 😥

[@Iammram]

It is a test... You think this is something, look to the example of Job ( Ayuub in Islam ) and what he went through, and he was a Prophet of God. The reward of the afterlife, the people will look back and say, I'll go through it all over again for this. Martyrs go straight to heaven by the way, along with the children ( children are with Prophet Abraham as he watches them play ) Sahih al-Bukhari 7047

[@rukundopaulin8432]

@@Iammrammartyrs men given 73 virgins as well in jannah

[@kano1652]

If things like that wouldnt happen this world would be jannah

[@ML-jw8kf]

Life is perfect - in Heaven. This is Earth - Earth is designed to be a place of trials and tribulations, of suffering and hardship. This is the very essence of Earthly life. Those who survive Earth (by making the right choices and passing the test), make it to Heaven.

[@uthman2281]

Your Problem is you know nothing about Islam

[@vladimirmach6145]

السلام عليكم و رحمةالله تعالى و بركاته و رضوانه، أختي. سبحان الله ، الحمد لله ، لا إله إلا الله، الله أكبر.

[@Muslimah_taqwa_dua]

As salaam o alaikum, thank you for sharing this information.. I personally feel it's also beneficial to tell people how believers feel when they are tested. We see these beautiful Palestinian people be so strong when Allah is testing them . There are people reading Quran because of that and reverting to islam. But there are so many people.. even Muslims questioning their faith.. it's imp to tell people that Allah takes care of people , his believers during these tests, eg Palestinians.. where are they getting their strength from? About Firauns wife.. Aasiya ..May Allah be pleased wit her .. she smiled wen she was being tortured... I have been tested by Allah.. Alhamdulillah... I got my strength from Allah... And it's easy to.. it's imp to tell these people not to assume the worst but ask these believers how they feel about Allah's tests... So as to avoid faith crisis.. may Allah guide every good human being in the world.. Aameen!

[@umourbe66]

I will add to the question, why God does not perish the Jews / Christian and all non believers despite the daily and continuous curses prayed in mosques against them. Why He doesn’t listen to his Muslims prayers to destroy them? Why he doesn’t send angels to fight like in day of Badr?

[@Farahjaaf]

Because God create us in this life to be tested the real life is in the herafter God have wisdom by making the disbielivers stronger a real muslim will not change his faith whatever

[@siaraddy7219]

God is with Israel

[@HumanityFirst24]

Did ‘god’ take a vacation during the hitler period?

[@Yashusayn]

Absolutely not

[@Jesusistheway5724]

Jesus died on the cross for all people, young and old! And God loves all people on earth, after all He made them, you and me. We cannot explain the suffering in the world. But God will wipe away every tear from our eyes (Revelation 21:4) in the new Jerusalem!

[@indigo2009]

Isaiah 41:8-17

[@indigo2009]

Leviticus 26:44-46

[@michaelco3069]

Jesus Christ said,Love your Enemies and do Good to those that persecute you.

[@jesus_isamuslim]

☝️The question should be why don't all Muslims fight in Gaza and come to the aid of their brothers in Palestine🇵🇸, why aren't we all united. "Allah does not change the condition of a people until we change ourselves."🇵🇸🇵🇸✌️

[@eurekacomment5719]

Well explained!

[@jeanclaude8028]

Beautiful answer and explanation

[@taqi2020]

There is too many test , no end to it.

[@gayahkamariah5486]

Jazzakallah for how this topic is explianed. I get some comfort in it as I sometimes ask the same question. Best of all is ar the end when Dr Shabir mentioned the good outcome from this cruel onslaught on Gaza. To me this has awakened the world at large to side humanity, generosity, justice etc, even though leaders were against these, by their show of support for Palestine.

[@suhel1986]

This world is temporary, the real life is here after.

[@abasnoordin]

1 The humankind resigns to the will of The Creator, Sustainer and Master of Universes. 2 They say: “Sufficient for us is AlLlaah, and [He is] the best Disposer of affairs.” 3 His obedient servants will readily volunteer, endeavour and die, when need be, to serve His purpose as per His commands. Which includes fighting oppression and the oppressors, protecting the weak, and helping the needy.

[@LeilaBilarab-is5sw]

I love Dr Shabir clear and precise explanation

[@reygomez8023]

As a Christian Catholic I feel the pain of the Palestinians 😢🇵🇸As a Christian I believe that forgiveness is the best course . That way you take all power from the evil one : Hate and violence.

[@RexAngo-sj7gt]

Totally agree with this man

[@gulisthafathima36]

You have lot of wisdom Dr Shabbir Aly. ✨

[@SardarKhan-gf8vq]

Great

[@anthonykingston7977]

Me being a white Australian guy, I love your content. But I don’t believe in god, but hell I wish everyone would get on with each other, life is short.

[@robertpresha9504]

Well said amen