Rémi Brague - "The Question Atheism Can't Answer"

[@fmitchellland7790]

I believe in a loving and transcendent God. Dr. Brague's presentation is superb.

[@geoffreygeorgeattard]

Would anyone know if this talk has been published and where, please?

[@Sfenx_Muenchen]

@AR333 your comment is severely lacking logic: If you "object" for instance that "evolution is ipso facto unintentional'", then there is no objection at all to the cited statement [you are quite simply confirming the rightness of the used attribute »unintentional«]. The other "objection" lacks content [there is no palpable substance in propositions like "this has been thoroughly discredited"]..

[@AR333]

As a student at McGill and an atheist, I found this lecture to be severely lacking. For one thing he sneaks in low-blows every now and then such as "Darwin's *doctrine* of evolution". Also, his point at 38:30 about reason being an "unintentional byproduct of evolution" is flawed on many levels. First, evolution is ipso facto unintentional. Second, his reformulation of Plantinga's argument of reason coming from "unreason" is extremely unconvincing, and has been thoroughly discredited.