Abu Bakr In The Qur’an: A Case Study Of Manipulation

REFERENCES:
The verse of the Cave:
Qur'an 9:41 (verse 40 in non-Shi'a numbering)
Abu Bakr is not invited to the cave:
Tareekh al-Tabari, Volume 6, page 144
The Prophet worried Abu Bakr will snitch (Shi'a Narration)
Tafseer al-Burhan, Volume 3
(1/2) The term 'Companion' being used in the Qur'an for a disbeliever:
Qur'an 18:38 (verse 37 in non-Shi'a numbering)
(2/2) The term 'Companion' being used in the Qur'an for a disbeliever:
Qur'an 12:40-41 (verse 39/40 in non-Shi'a numbering)
The Prophet tells Abu Bakr to USKUT (shut up) in the cave:
Sahih al-Bukhari, Volume 5, Hadith 3922
sunnah.com/bukhari:3922
Abu Bakr was crying in the cave:
Ibn al-Jawzi, Zaad al-Museer
Qur'an example of Allah is 'with' hypocrites meaning He is present:
Qur'an 58:8 (verse 7 in non-Shi'a numbering)
Abu Bakr's account in the cave aligns with Allah being with us meaning He is present:
Sahih al-Bukhari, Volume 5, Hadith 3922
sunnah.com/bukhari:3922
The verse of al-Mubahala:
Quran 3:62 (verse 61 in non-Shi'a numbering)
(1/2) Allah sends down His tranquillity on His Messenger AND upon the believers:
Qur'an 9:27 (verse 26 in non-Shi'a numbering)
(2/2) Allah sends down His tranquillity on His Messenger AND upon the believers:
Qur'an 48:27 (verse 26 in non-Shi'a numbering)
Imam al-Ridha (peace be upon him) confirms this verse has no good in it for Abu Bakr and that the tranquillity of Allah was NOT sent on Abu Bakr (Shi'a Narration):
Tafseer al-Ayyashi, Volume 2
Qur'an states that Imam Ali, peace be upon him, sells his soul for Allah at the same time while Abu Bakr cries in the cave out of fear:
Qur'an 2:208 (verse 207 in non-Shi'a numbering)
Imam Ali shows no fear of dear when the pagans attack him in the Prophet's bed, while Abu Bakr cries in the cave out of fear (Shi'a narration):
Khisa’is al A’immah, Sharif al-Radi
Abu Bakr tells the Prophet 'I fear death' after he tells him to not grieve (Shi'a narration)
al-Ihtijaj, al-Tabrisi
00:00 - Intro
00:12 - The Verse Of The Cave
02:07 - One: The Second Of The Two
11:25 - Two: His Companion
15:19 - Three: Don't Worry
19:04 - Four: Allah Is With Us
25:55 - Five: His Tranquility
32:49 - Imam Ali vs. Abu Bakr
Website: rafida.org
Twitter: / rafidaorg
Support: / rafidaorg
Location: g.page/RafidaOrg
WhatsApp: [phone]

[@RafidaPlus]

References in the description!

[@alichaitou5874]

Brilliant ❤️ Keep it up brother 💎

[@af5star549]

❤️

[@mersadmesihovic3641]

This is funny brother, and do you know why it's funny, well because if it was Ali ibn abi Talib a.s and not Abu Bakr this verse was speaking about the Shia would use it to prove the superiority of Ali, just like the Shia use the verse that says "those who give charity and making ruku' ". May Allah guide us all and purify our hearts so we can understand the Quran.

[@mohammedal-nedawi6646]

Mersad Mesihovic to create an impossible hypothesis and then presume that the Shia would have used it to prove the superiority of Ali defies both logic and early Islamic history. And the Shia have shown that they do not have double standards.

[@mersadmesihovic3641]

@@mohammedal-nedawi6646 Selam aleikom my dear brother I hope you don't have dubble standards and that Allah guids me first then you too ameen. If you check on any Shia website you will see that the Shia give meaning to verses that include words like the "rope of allah" sura ali Imran or in sura rahman "two oceans than touch but don't mix" to be the ahlu bait. I hope you are are true Shia of Ali a.s as I am a Shia of Ali a.s. and see through this guys hatred and misspresentation

[@volkanbeyoglu235]

I love this guy! I love the way he talks, I love the facts he says, the way he delivers them! Allah bless you! Please keep posting more videos, YOUR videos. THANK YOU Love from Bosnia

[@Aurora-lm5ns]

He doesn’t talk like a man. His voice is like the voice of his sheikh the short guy the British agent so feminine.

[@volkanbeyoglu235]

@@Aurora-lm5ns shut up nasibi

[@Aurora-lm5ns]

@@volkanbeyoglu235 nice attempt to silence the truth lol it must hurt to know your silly boy is a British agent.

[@volkanbeyoglu235]

@@Aurora-lm5ns doesnt matter. He is telling the truth,.everybody can confirm it, check the facts,.there are sources and proofs. Please give proofs, dont slander and call names.

[@istheBruce]

@@Aurora-lm5ns that’s called eloquence. The reason you cannot recognise that is because your sheikhs sound like they work on a market

[@Fizafeez]

This is so beautifully explained MashaAllah. I have goosebumps SubhanAllah. I'm go happy with my decision to be a Shia Alhamdulillah.

[@annamariana8140]

Yes be open-minded n do deep scrutiny, I became a Shia 15 years ago n the 1st in the family to do so. Initially I faced rejection n hostility coz my community is predominantly Sunni..now we learn to coexist n the best part, I had the chance to visit karbala twice n once participated in the arbain walk n I'm a 58 year old grandma🤗

[@Fizafeez]

@@annamariana8140 MashaAllah, thank you for sharing sister. May Allah guide all of mankind to the path of Alhul Bayt (AS).

[@thelion2087]

@@annamariana8140 Mashallah 🥰

[@alisheikh3585]

​@@annamariana8140this is so wholesome!! May Allah bless you with the ziyarat of all our Imams repeatedly.

[@MuhammadAbdullah-yt8zd]

We are from Indonesia and we love learning from you. It is a perfect explanation. Thank you so much, we love you brother.

[@am7016]

This has nothing to do with islam, these people curse the best of companions

[@Janasrar]

@@am7016 these people curse the munfiq not best companions

[@user-xv6nc7ig3d]

@@am7016 لعنة الله عمر وابي بكر زنديق وعائشه الفاحشه

[@makavellitheprince5256]

@@am7016 you’re a liar ! Even Sunni’s don’t believe Abu Bakr is the best of companions!

[@yasirhasan1095]

@@makavellitheprince5256 he is the best of the best companion and every Muslim knows that and respects him Abu bakr (RA)

[@TheLadyOfHeavenPlaylists]

Peace and blessings upon prophet Muhammed and his pure family❤

[@Mahdi-sx4ql]

Good video brother but you missed the main argument about recipient of the tranquility. @28:00 The verse starts: "If you do not aid the Prophet - Allah has already AIDED HIM". so what is the aid? The "tranquility" at end of the verse. This intro further confirms that "Allah sent down his tranquillity upon HIM" referring to the same "HIM" at the beginning of the verse, otherwise the verse makes no sense and also pointless for Allah to use "IF". Its like me saying "if you do not help John then know that I have already helped him in the past." So how did i help John? Here is an example: "I sent down my help upon Peter and helped him with funds you did not see." So if you believe tranquility was sent upon Abu bakr then you must also believe that Quran's logic and elloquence is as poor as the example given above. Second argument you missed is at @7:15 "when the disbelievers drove him out" Quran clearly states him not them. أَخْرَجَهُ not أَخْرَجَهُما. Quran itself says the Prophet pbuh left alone.

[@RafidaPlus]

Appreciated!

[@LoyalMinion]

very true

[@kamruzbari0103]

EeèeèrpaPq

[@johnsanchez8029]

I recently came across your channel yesterday. To be completely honest, i only accepted islam about 15 months ago at age 36. I am still learning everyday; but your disposition makes a lot of sense. I have been in many situations where companions try to cast doubt upon me when they are supposedly on my side. I ultimately decided they were a burden more than anything as i began to realize their doubt slowly became my doubt. I hear so much bullying about the shia that i began to investigate their claims.

[@user-xv2gd7wo8c]

Salamualykum you are on the right track continúe investigación insha Allah ,the islam os the Alhubait make sense and will motivate you for you to become a better muslim.

[@lailakurji1350]

Why was Abubakar worried? When a person is with the Pro of Allah why worry? Abubakar had NO FAITH

[@layana5095]

What about prophet moussa?

[@mrsolo2859]

That’s why he was called Al sadiq that’s why he was with the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him in the cave when the mushrkin chasing them that’s why he have donated all his wealth to charity he was the first men to believe in Islam. Praise be to Allah. Firstly: Al-Bukhaari (3671) narrated that Muhammad ibn al-Hanafiyyah said: I said to my father - who was ‘Ali ibn Abi Taalib (may Allah be pleased with him) -: “Which of the people is best after the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him)? He said: Abu Bakr. I said: Then who? He said: Then ‘Umar. Imam Ahmad (835) narrated that Abu Juhayfah said: I heard ‘Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) say: Shall I not tell you the best of this ummah after its Prophet? (It is) Abu Bakr. Then he said: Shall I not tell you the best of this ummah after Abu Bakr? (It is) ‘Umar (may Allah be pleased with him). The commentators on al-Musnad said: Its isnaad is hasan. Ahl as-Sunnah wa’l-Jamaa‘ah are unanimously agreed that the best of this ummah after its Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) is Abu Bakr as-Siddeeq, then ‘Umar, then ‘Uthmaan, then ‘Ali (may Allah be pleased with them all). Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyah (may Allah have mercy on him) said: They - i.e., Ahl as-Sunnah - affirm that which is narrated in mutawaatir reports from Ameer al-Mu’mineen ‘Ali ibn Abi Taalib (may Allah be pleased with him) and others: that the best of this ummah after its Prophet is Abu Bakr, then ‘Umar, and they mentioned the third one as ‘Uthmaan and the fourth one as ‘Ali (may Allah be pleased with them all), as is indicated by the reports. End quote from al-‘Aqeedah al-Waasitiyyah (p. 117) You people who dived the religion and curse the companion of the prophet peace be upon him you will be accountable in the day of judgement.

[@Shahi313]

Main point of abu bakr following the Prophet into the cave and crying etc was to alert the other hypocrites. This was yet another assassination attempt

[@Loyalsurly]

Subhanallah. What a mesmerizing explanation. Jazakallah akhi, this information is extremely important and useful

[@mohdakbarali1840]

Jazak-Allah (s) Keep exposing the enemies of Islam. Bulb

[@UponTheShadows]

Yes he exposes the shia so well

[@mohdakbarali1840]

@@UponTheShadows ohh really. I wasn't aware that tyrant and coward abubakr was Shia thank you so much for letting me know. Keep exposing shia a/k abubakr

[@smm9059]

@@UponTheShadows doubt you even watched the video

[@thelion2087]

@@UponTheShadows 🤦‍♂️ #clown

[@abiabi9353]

@@UponTheShadows sure he exposes shia as a true religion which have roots from the Holly prophet

[@loverofahlulbayt7268]

May Allah Bless all your efforts. Great Video.

[@truthseeker7260]

Amazing ! keep going brother thank you

[@soniasaurus5345]

So refreshing. May Allah subhanAllah ta’Allah Azzawajal bless u!! Thank u for ur hard work!!

[@aqilalhu]

We are Rafida, refusers of falsehood and corruption on earth,thanks brother

[@thebeast-ki3mm]

you are the bringer of falsehood and corruption and bring la3nat on the companions on the prophet and his wife

[@sakinanaqvi9499]

Thankyou very much for authentic TRUE references in history books 📚 appreciated

[@mohammedal-nedawi6646]

Only the Khasais al-A’imma reference was probably mixed up for another narration.

[@RedA-ld4de]

The bakris in this comment section drank too much mama Aisha milk

[@unclephd6190]

hahahaha she did became a mother that she produce milk now? so many sons and daugthers to feed. she transended and became a diety with multiple breasts.

[@yourmomshouse8993]

Now that’s funny 😆. Be careful they are very sensitive and they will oppress us more. They will try to start a war because you made fun of their mother lol.

[@theladyofheaven2268]

😂😂😂😂LoL😂😂😂

[@unclephd6190]

its true.. they even suckle her camel in jamal.. and took its urine and dung as souvenir

[@user-hg8mj9og2l]

Haha, I see how you feel about having a mother that wasn't shared through mut3a... there there, it's okay.

[@Abdullah-jj2qu]

Mashallah keep spreading dawah akhi 🙏🏼

[@MohammadAli-nv8sr]

Very informative Thanks

[@Anony_mous5001]

Love you man please make more videos bro may Allah protect and bless you.

[@TheRedDevils071]

Loving these type of videos by the brother ❤ Could you make a video on Shia Hadith Vs. Sunni Hadith. So the general audience can have the better understanding of it, even Gengu Teli could learn a thing or two by this video 😉

[@husseinf2527]

You guys need to drop more videos!!

[@ferdaus1359]

beautifully presented.

[@af5star549]

Amazing video❤️May Allah bless you with everything. I Learned a lot today.

[@whatifurdu7370]

Thanks for sharing

[@nedakadri]

I grew up in a Sunni family - of old school Syrian origin - but was blessed enough to be taught religion by my Shia Iraqi stepfather.... I still always considered myself "Sunni" until perhaps two days ago of which I firmly came to the conclusion that I am of Shia Ali may peace be upon him. First and most importantly Allah Subhanu Wa Ta'Alla states clearly in the Quran that Prophethood and knowledge of The Book is a CHOSEN BLOODLINE elected by Allah Subhanu Wa Ta'Alla Himself.... It is not a democratic process that flawed humans are in charge of. Second, and this perhaps is what caught my attention the most is my research into other religions, cultures and traditions. I learned that EVERY civilization and religion from the beginning of time up until the Christians explained the JINN world in extensive detail (as far as electromagnetic/manifestation, etc) and how they effect our consciousness and corrupt our relationship with Allah Subhanu Wa Ta'Alla.... They also described TWO - a man and woman - that will come during end times that will be able to gather ALL the knowledge since the beginning of time and put in in a cohesive way that demonstrates Allah Subhanu Wa Ta'Alla as being THE TRUTH. Why then was this not included in Islamic texts?! Why has our religious culture negated the woman and claimed Allah Subhanu Wa Ta'Alla created her to be at home when throughout the physical world FEMININE and MASCULINE are complementary?! There is still much more to the subject, but this brings us back full circle for sake of this comment.... I am now starting to firmly believe that Abu Bakr and his cronies were to Islam what Peter and the sell out disciples were to Christianity. They not only altered the message and withheld text.... They implemented an INSTITUTIONLIZED religious doctrine in which ONLY they were the gatekeepers. The only TRUE source of knowledge. I don't buy Iran's version of Shia Islam either.... They are just opposite sides of the extremist system while both are controlled and loyal to their love of power through use of oppression.... So I find myself in a really particular place.... I am seeking knowledge. Early Islamic Scholar knowledge without any biased input based on political allegiances.... I wish that more information like this that breaks it down in an academic way existed!

[@mohammedal-nidawi8896]

بارك الله فيك أختي وأحييك على هذه الثقافة العالية الأخ عبد الملك نشر تغريدة في حسابه على تويتر حول أحد تعليقاتك قبل أيام

[@hass316]

relateable

[@alihassanliaquat1327]

Informative video!

[@aliagha1221]

Ma Sha Allah to you brother!

[@rosminbanuesufally3628]

Very very true its high time the truth is revealed keep it up

[@baraslim]

I always wanna cry Hearing the story of Righteous people Fighting for their struggle to uphold the justice Struggle for their believe Sacrificing all they have to Alloh How Rosulullah saww did Sayeda Khadijah Sayidina abu tholib Sayidiha ali And than sayeda fatima Sayidina hasan Sayidina husain Peace and belss upon the holy prophet and his ahlul bayt Allohuma sholi wasalim ala sayidina muhammad wa ala aali sayidina muhammad

[@waliallah1744]

May allah bless you brother, for spreading the truth

[@Hk313-14]

Can I cut and use your videos

[@RafidaPlus]

Ofcourse

[@Hk313-14]

@@RafidaPlus ❤️❤️

[@mohammedal-nedawi6646]

@@Hk313-14 if you do that brother please let me know. I also subscribed to your channel.

[@abdishakurdiriye4673]

How can (Allah is with us), and (Allah is the forth of them) have same meaning. If we believe your point which is that the verse means (Presence and watchful), then the translation becomes (Allah is our presence), so does that mean Allah was not the in the presence and watchful of the pegans?

[@Loyalsurly]

brother don't confuse yourself by overthinking it like this lol

[@operso5460]

Excellent may Allah reward you all.

[@UponTheShadows]

Reward you all with sin

[@yunusalwi.1237]

👍👌👌👌

[@smartypants6502]

There is another place where abubakr is indirectly mentioned, where the sahaba including abubakr, umer and uthman ran away in battles.

[@yourmomshouse8993]

Forget that why didn’t any of them lay down in the bed of the prophet when they tried to murder him. It was Ali it was always Ali. Ali the Lion of God. How can I follow a religion that believes Muwaia is a leader of the Muslim world did these people forget who his mother and father were? Are these people blind, his mother and father battled the prophet Imam Ali and Hamza killed his grandfather and uncle in battle you think he just forgot that? You think his mother forgot that she ate Hamza’s heart like a cannibal. Did they forget that Yazid was responsible for the massacre of Karbala. Forget all the Hadiths and playing word games. This is basic logic. Bani Umaya lost and they manipulated Islam to continue their business and rule over Mecca. They don’t recognize this was all revenge for losing Mecca to the prophet.

[@Saber23]

Where the hell have you been brother? We’ve missed you ❤️

[@alisheikh3585]

Tough love 😂

[@Saber23]

@@alisheikh3585 what are you on about?

[@gudduthakur1249]

Ya Ali a s madad 🌹💗

[@gudduthakur1249]

@ONLINEINTELLECTUAL you hve any problem

[@sadiqahussain2282]

Truth and the whole truth and nothing but the truth...may Allah bless you brother for being with the truth !!!!

[@yasirhasan1095]

💀 lies upon lies and 🤦‍♂️

[@sadiqahussain2282]

@@yasirhasan1095 These lies upon lies ..who are you referring to...

[@yasirhasan1095]

@@sadiqahussain2282 who else duh 🙄 this why y’all believe everything y’all are just so dumb

[@kazimsyed7367]

@@yasirhasan1095 ignorance upon arrogance.

[@yasirhasan1095]

@@kazimsyed7367 I know how they create lies and people believe is wild when it’s so clear

[@Wassalaam92]

No one said Abu bakr RA is the “second of the two” mentioned in THE VERSE. The expression “Thani ithnain” simply means “one of two”, like YOU YOURSELF said. So the prophet SAW is one of two, and Abu Bakr RA is also one of the two. When you have two people, both are ‘one of the two’. Hence, Abu bakr is also Thani ithnain…..but obviously the subject in the verse is the prophet SAW.

[@latrelld8187]

So technically the story of the “cave” starts from the verse of Imam Ali (a.s) selling is soul for the pleasure of Allah by sleeping in his bed. I think it’s important to stress this point and the ahadith that state Imam Ali asks the prophet “will you be safe” when he’s asked to sleep in his bed. This will further help in drawing the difference between the “the one with grief” and the one who was willing to sell his soul for the pleasure of Allah!

[@indianrational6887]

I have a question. How did the people searching for the prophet know about his location in the cave. Who informed them

[@la3la3laa.3a2isha]

Interesting question 😂 it has a very interesting answer

[@indianrational6887]

@@la3la3laa.3a2isha I have seen this cave which is on a mountain and why would someone search on a mountain . Looks like someone leaked the information. Any guess?

[@la3la3laa.3a2isha]

@@indianrational6887 nope. No guesses. We already know. Find out all the information about that 24 hour period and you will find everything you're looking for. Don't tell the sunnies though 😂

[@thatshiairaqi]

@@indianrational6887 It was Abu Bakr. When he first went to the prophet's house, Ali and the prophet were there. The Prophet ended up telling him his plan to leave and when he did, Umar (la) left and that's when a group of men who wanted to kill him came to Umar and asked him where the Prophet went. Umar didn't even hesitate to tell them.

[@Ali-rs2wt]

Great, really Great

[@amiroghyanoosi6659]

I love you my brother for this huge success of spreading the truth so beautifully and clearly with researches of Abubakr and Omar maybe Curse of Allah be on them forever for all the dark evil problems they caused to Prophet Muhammad and his Ummah in Islam…I’m from Iran and I am watching this in Russia right now and feel very happy to see my Shia brothers and sisters are spreading the truth ,no matter how big the army of sunni deviants lost are(which I consider them as my brothers and sisters in Islam),the truth has always stayed in few hearts of people among most lost souls and history has proven that always among all prophets and their people,only few hearts have been chosen by Allah to send down the truth in them Allah Has put the love of Ahl Al Bayt in the certain hearts ,it’s not so easy for many to love Imam Ali and know his position in glory of Allah and hate the 2 of most hated by Allah …Omar and Abubakr Who caused the death of Best of lady of universe Fatimah Zahran Salam Allah to her while she was pregnant with her third son Mohsen ,our hearts cry blood everyday for this sorrow and what happened after to Hassan and Hussain and the descendants Of Hussain till arrival of our master Mahdi which Allah has strengthen our hearts to him ,inshallah we will be in his army against the dark disbelievers and justice shall come to its place

[@captainjacksparrow1518]

Criticizing and sending curses upon the Great Caliphs of Islam is a good way for you to enter jahannum. Well done brother

[@abdillahijalalkhan2128]

"The curses of the infidels are but lost in oblivion! " The QUR'AN.

[@AhmadBlue10]

@@captainjacksparrow1518 I think you didn’t watch the video and it is not the eyes that are blind, but it is the hearts.

[@abiabi9353]

@@captainjacksparrow1518 can you give one proof to show that abubakar and omar were chosen by the prophet.The fact is abubakar,omar and othman imposed themselves on the Muslims as leaders

[@baqirhemraj7639]

During Hijarat Abu Bakr followed the Prophet (PBUH) and ended up in a cave, the motive was to get the Prophet (PBUH) killed. Abu Bakr disobeyed the Prophet (PBUH) who had instructed him not to follow him. What is the status of a person who disobeys the Prophet (PBUH)? Where was Imam Ali (as)? He was sleeping in the bed of the Prophet (PBUH) to save his life.

[@Abu-Yazid22]

Where did the prophet pbuh tell Abu Bakr r.a not to follow him?

[@user-hg8mj9og2l]

Since when did Mr.Tumnus leave Narnia?

[@omidfazl7809]

Good information... This is good for people who study(or like) history

[@UponTheShadows]

This is good for people who like to accumulate sin in ramadan.

[@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam]

@@UponTheShadows Abu bakr worshipper

[@omidfazl7809]

@@UponTheShadows abubakr is your God ? What is Sin towards your thoughts? Every one who doesn't accept abubakr is Sinful? I ACCEPT THAT EVERY ONE WHO ACCEPTS ALLAH IS SINFUL ...so choose what is your God ! Abubakr(l.n) or Allah جله جلاله

[@quranenglishtranslations9315]

@@omidfazl7809 bro be quiet you literally made no sense right there. Abu bakr R.A. Was one of the best friends of the prophet saw, how dare u guys curse his companions Like the size of your guys Balls man to go up against Allah Prophet Muhammad and his companions Fear ur grave and repent

[@thelion2087]

There is no merit or any evidence in Abu Bakr being the second person, since this can mean that he is either a believer or a disbeliever or a hypocrite and establishing his belief through this is incorrect and baseless. So, togetherness and being the second one can’t be used as proof of superiority and eligibility for caliphate. Mention of both the Holy Prophet (s.a.w.a.) and Abu Bakr together in the same place doesn’t prove any merit for Abu Bakr because as stated in the first point being together at the same place is not the proof of superiority. It is possible for a believer and a disbeliever to assemble in the same place as the Holy Quran testifies: 3: tranquility was sent to the Prophet ONLY in that verse while Allah ALWAYS sends tranquility to the believers 4) As for the argument that the Holy Prophet (s.a.w.a.) said to Abu Bakr (لا تحزن) ‘Grieve not’ not only is it far from being a virtue it is in fact a reprimand and it proves Abu Bakr’s disobedience for which the Prophet (s.a.w.a.) reprimanded him. Prophet(s.a.w.a.) has used the plural form (we) over here, just like Allah, the Wise, used the plural form for Himself in the Holy Quran in many places - for e.g.: in the Verse of the Cave, Allah the High mentions only one recipient of the tranquility while there were two residents inside the cave and clearly this sole recipient is the Holy Prophet (s.a.w.a.) and not  Abu Bakr.

[@anonymousartist7195]

the line between respect for a historical figure and shirk was crossed a long time ago by many Muslims...but is it not the same for the followers of Ali?

[@javadh417]

I was watching Muhammad Hijab debate the other day and when the debater asked him tough questions about the preservation of Quran he got mad and lose his temper. The guy basically used Shia 's argument if there was no one after the prophet who had authority from God to confirm the current Quran (and others with different Ahruf) is preserved, because of these variations, you can't call it "perfectly" preserved. Also, he brought Aisha's belief in breastfeeding verse in Quran that it was lost to prove his point. instead of saying she was a liar, he threw the Quran under the bus to protect that despicable woman and try to change the topic to racism. It was ridiculous. Must watch kzbin.info/www/bejne/q6XHimZ8iLKpjLs

[@zafaramiri]

I will watch this, thanks!

[@Loyalsurly]

Crazy video indeed!

[@javadh417]

@@zafaramiri​ @Loyalsurly the fact is Sunni can't prove the preservation and chain of narration of Quran from their books. and they have many sahih hadith that Quran is changed but still lying that Shia has different Quran. If you are interested in this topic see this as well: kzbin.info/www/bejne/qZ7Nd4KfrdWke8U

[@zafaramiri]

@@javadh417 thanks

[@truthseeker-cz6lf]

These people are incapable of thinking and they feel entitled based on their numbers. Imam Ali " as" said Learn your religion do not copy your religion. These so called Sunnies " monkey see monkey do" I mean it literally.

[@firdosRS]

Brother you very good 👍 👏 👌 mashallah

[@yazahra_yaali]

لُعٌنْ آلُلُهِ عٌمْر وُعٌآئشُةّ وابو بكر لُعٌنْآ ڊآئمْآ آٻڊآ سرمْڊآ لُآ آنْقٌطُآعٌ لُآمْڊةّ وُلُآنْفُآڏ لُعٌڊڊةّ يَغٍڊوُآ آوُلُةّ وُلُآيَروُح آخرة لهم ولاعوانهم وانصارهم ومحبيهم ومواليهم. 🤲🏻✈️

[@abubakarkabir7357]

Illahy Ya Rabby

[@TheLadyOfHeavenPlaylists]

اللهم صل على محمد وآل محمد الطيبين الطاهرين وعجل فرجهم والعن أعدائهم من الأولين والآخرين

[@ammaryasir4942]

Why this channel is not working in Pakistan.thank God i have vpn

[@la3la3laa.3a2isha]

Because sunnies 😵👈

[@thatshiairaqi]

Probably because the government doesn't like Shias in general.

[@adamnouri23]

It is clear enough when the so called Sunni Muslims mention the Prophet ( S ) they do send salawat / salutations upon him ( S ). However; they scramble to say it or scramble it saying " sasallam " or " sawsallam " . But when it comes to Atiq ibn Abi Quhafah known as Abu Bakr, they praise him nicely. They eloquently say " as-siddiq radhia Allahu anh ". No surprise to me. I know for sure they don't mind elevating their beloved sahabah over the Prophet himself. To them, the Prophet is but a man who happened to be the carrier of the holy Qur'an. Otherwise, he is subject to all kinds of shortcomings, weaknesses, faults, errors etc. Omar is always there to " correct " the errors and Allah would support Omar's views ,,, He had been " bewitched " . He used to act like doing somethings while he was actually not doing. " mad " and " hallucinating ". He even " frowned upon the blind man Abd_Ullah ibnu Maktoum ". If you say; for instance, the Prophet ( S ) had never frowned upon the blind man. It was Othman son of Affan who did it. They always go angry saying that the great sahabi / Prophet's companion would not do such a thing. Othman is so great to them to the point that the angels would humble themselves before him. I call them sahabist not Muslims. Ex Sunni Maliki Muslim from Tunisia.

[@yazahra_yaali]

عٌبد آلُمْلُڪ❤️🌼مْنْوُر

[@shamiemaaboobaker539]

💯… excellent… good job keeping the truth in perspective.. may ALLAH reward Rafida Plus.. ALLAH HUMMA SALLE ALAA MUHAMMED WA AALE MUHAMMED WA AJJAL FARAJAHUM WA AKHLIK ADUWUHUM MINNAL JINNI WAL INSI.. 🤲🏼♥️💐

[@mustangadam9931]

Ahsant

[@tameemansari707]

Abdul Malik sir, profound knowledge

[@neelzafalludba]

What a ridiculous argument. Quran is revealed in Arabic.

[@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam]

Yes so? 😂

[@LoyalMinion]

what a riduculous argument am I right? I had pancakes for breakfast.

[@Aurora-lm5ns]

Only rafida can make a praise into an insult and an insult into a praise lol. No sane person would view this verse negatively let alone drive takfeer from it. Lol

[@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam]

@@Aurora-lm5ns yes they would easily the anwser is if abu bakr was praised in the verse why does Allah prohibit the zakina from him as stated in the verse that he only sent it on the prophet which proves abu bakrs hypocrisy

[@Ali-kv3uu]

Salaam ,You're simply blessed by Allah & love of Ahlul Bayt of the prophet, that was a great study using wisdom, but the Sunnis are so brainwashed that they just blindly follow their scholars who do not have wisdom just follow assumptions on case studies of Quran. Thank you brother for this great insight!

[@Ali-abo-Jawad]

💜💜💜

[@GIXXRBRAH750]

The prophet Muhammad (pbuh) asked who would sacrifice himself to be in the bed and Imam Ali (AS) ameer Ul-mu’mineen (AS) Stood up like the solider he is and done it

[@mustafairaqi2580]

😍😍😍

[@aliahmaddoust8967]

i believe your tafseer of alsani alsanain is wrong,it refers to the event it was the second time mohammad (sa) had to leave mecca first time was the 3 years in the vally that led to death of his uncle and his wife,and the single verb shows that prophet was alone leaving the mecca

[@DrAhmadMohaddespour]

Very good brother. But it was good to show more about the Shia’s narrative on this event. You can easily find the references: Abubakr knew the Mushrekin’s plan that night (or he even planned it, cannot clearley remember). Thus, he was surprised when he saw the prophet PBUH why he was not in bed. Prophet knew he will rat out and thus unwillingly had to take him along. Abubakr even in the cave tried to make some noise by his feet moving some rocks to get the prophet arrested but a sanke scarred him. He used every single opportunity.

[@yazahra_yaali]

لُعٌنْ آلُلُهِ عٌمْر. وُعٌآئشُةّ.وُآبوبڪر.

[@migranboyz]

All your answers are the book called peshawar nights and when I was guided. I read these book and I cam close to Allah and the true religion.....

[@BisnesRancak]

These two books. I read it too. Truly mind blowing and change my mind

[@HassanRadwan133]

Interesting and well presented analysis. I was unfamiliar with the Shi'a narrative of these events and you make some excellent points. But it only makes me wonder why an omniscient and omnipotent God could not think of a more effective way of conveying his message to all humanity, seeing that he would know with infallible certainty it would be corrupted (as in the case of Jesus) or hijacked (as you believe Islam was) resulting in generations inheriting an ingrained psychological and emotional bias towards the beliefs they were raised in, rendering them immune, in most cases, to other beliefs - through no fault of their own. (Wasting their lives in a vicious squabble over which humans from 1400 years ago were better than others due to their inherited biases - which btw you are not free from also.) Then for a Wise & Merciful God to make all this the basis of eternal joy or eternal torture? I suspect you might say people can search for the truth themselves. But the vast majority of humanity haven't been able to do that and are unbelievers. Are they really all evil doomed to Hell? The reality is most humans - past & present - have little time, opportunity, or circumstances to explore all world beliefs and philosophies in any meaningful depth. Most struggle to simply put food on the table for their families. Most humans are not bad or evil. Just flawed imperfect creatures - as we all are. If a Merciful God exists I would expect him to be better and wiser than this. (I'm an ex-Muslim btw)

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

Allah is merciful but he is also just, this life is an exam to us he gave us the answers but we need to search for them and approach them with a pure heart, Allah gave us the choice and he told us the consequences of them and above that he gave us the answers yet some people will reject them but others submit to them and choose to follow the truth, treating both the rejectors of truth and it's followers the same is against Allah's justice

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

Aslo regarding that humans aren't all capable or have the means of reaching and searching for the truth like for examples the indigenous tribes of the Amazon, this is addressed in the Quran itself and it support Allah's justice by the verse 17:15 which says (Who receiveth guidance, receiveth it for his own benefit: who goeth astray doth so to his own loss: No bearer of burdens can bear the burden of another: nor would We visit with Our Wrath until We had sent an apostle (to give warning).) So Allah the most merciful won't punish the people who didn't receive the message, Allah indeed is most merciful and the most just I encourage you to rethink and research and upon your heart maybe this is a way, a door opened to you by Allah to invite you to return to him

[@kingslayer8121]

First of all, you have the whole concept of hell wrong. Secondly, the verse is as clear as it can be.. only people with a wild lost imagination would give any merit to Abu bakr based on this verse. Lastly, it’s not important whether you like abu bakr or not.. it’s the intention that matters. If you like him bc you think he was good, you are good. If you like him bc you think he’s bad, you are bad.

[@GatekeeperOfTruth]

I must say, Mr Radwan, your videos have sent me off on many a journey of questioning and contemplation. It is very interesting to see you commenting here, but it does seem you have somewhat changed course. For a start, I note you now self label as an "ex-muslim." Therefore, I hope you don't mind us establishing some common ground Like you, I agree, the brother here presents the Shia reading in a very engaging manner. He is no doubt motivated by an unshakeable conviction in the Shia Islamic creed. But let us, for one moment, isolate the academic merit this exegesis brings. Does it make any more sense to what you have always understood ? Is it any more true? Irrespective of your answer, I would like to know if you believe there is any merit in devoting ones capacities to sincerely rejecting falsehood and upholding that which is true. Does our collective human experience tell us the pursuit of truth is neccessarily that which is politically expedient, socially convinient, or conducive to our immediate wants and desires?

[@kazimsyed7367]

its a test to live with differences and find the truth. only if people do research by themselves and view different pov they'll surely understand.

[@ahmedlion2116]

لم نسمع الرسول الاعظم يقول ان الاية تمدح ابوبكر او تعطيه اي فضل ولا حتى ابوبكر نفسه اقترح ان هذه الاية تمدحه او تعطيه اي فضل ومنقبة فالصحبة لاتعني ابدا الاخلاص او الايمان

[@murtaza0608]

do you Imam Baqir's wife was abu bakr's grand daughter

[@thatshiairaqi]

No he didn't. Where do you get your information from? What was the name of the wife of Imam Baqir (as)? Do you even know?

[@umameer8943]

احسنتم موفقين بارك الله فيكم وجزاكم الله خير الجزاء انتم وشيخكم ياسر الحبيب حفظه الله

[@hamj97]

Hhhahah I noticed even their English sheiks say sawaslam 🤣🤣 they don't respect the prohept. Thank you man you so great that I addicted your videos.

[@dadir13505]

The other Sunni scholars say the other person was not abubakar

[@aql78614]

Awesome

[@alihaidar5680]

mashallah

[@yazahra_yaali]

مْوُفُقٌيَنْ لُڪلُ خيَر❤️اهل فدڪ

[@shaashshah2707]

Lets go off from the contradictions between us.

[@murtaza0608]

no how come Prophet was asking abu bakr to rely upon Allah when abu bakr was a munafiq ??????????

[@thatshiairaqi]

Because he's a Prophet his mission is to spread the religion of God. Of course he would tell someone to have trust in Allah (swt). As if he's never told a disbeliever to put their trust in Allah (swt) because it's what's best for them.

[@saadb828]

Why didn't the prophet PBUH reach this conclusion?

[@mohammedal-nedawi6646]

Wrong question. The Prophet صلى الله عليه وآله did not kill the ones who tried to assassinate him in Aqaba although they deserved it, and Abu Bakr was one of them. The Prophet صلى الله عليه وآله explained the reason. If he had killed them, the Arabs would have said Mohammed kills his companions.

[@baraslim]

​@@mohammedal-nedawi6646 Where is the prove that abu Bakr was 12 people try to kill Rosulullah saww in Aqaba?? Histortan In my understanding never mention all 12 people

[@baraslim]

@@mohammedal-nedawi6646 So... Your accusation base on dreaming and deluting That A was part of 12 people kriminal that try to assasine our beloved saww

[@rafida5360]

Good

[@Wassalaam92]

Secondly, according to the narration you presented, if Abu Bakr RA was an enemy, Ali RA would never have told him where the prophet was.

[@mohammedal-nedawi6646]

It wasn’t in his interest to snitch on the Prophet صلى الله عليه واله. In Shia narrations, Abu Bakr entered Islam because he had greed.

[@Wassalaam92]

@@mohammedal-nedawi6646 greed for what? He was one of the earliest to accept Islam, if not the first of the men. What greed?

[@mohammedal-nedawi6646]

Wassalaam92 whether or not he was one of the earliest to accept Islam is another matter, but he heard from scholars of ahlulkitab about the Prophet and that His religion will spread in the entire world.

[@Wassalaam92]

@@mohammedal-nedawi6646 if that was the case, he would have simply accepted islam later...and not suffer years upon years of poverty, torture, boycott, oppression alongside the prophet.

[@mohammedal-nedawi6646]

Well that wouldn’t have helped him because someone who enters a religion late cannot claim that he deserves a distinct position, can he?

[@lailakurji1350]

Didn’t Abubakar know when there two people Allah is the third ,if 5 people are there The 6th one is Allah we all know that our children know that but the Pro had to explain it to Abubakar !

[@arshkamran7795]

So I’m supposed to believe that imam Ali (Ra), told abu Bakr (Ra) where the prophet is even though he was an enemy, and could potentially snitch on him. Wouldn’t Ali(Ra) only tell Abu Bakr(Ra) if he trusted him. Doesn’t Ali(Ra) have the knowledge of the unseen and would make a mistake that could threat the livelihood of the prophet(saw). Doesn’t make sense right, goes against basic logic. Did the prophet(saw) keep Ali(Ra) in his house to manage his affairs yet Ali(Ra) told Abu Bakr(Ra) clear cut where the prophet(saw) is. Please explain

[@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam]

Yes Imam Ali told Abu bakr where the prophet is to prove his hypocrisy so that Allah will reveal that verse proving his hypocrisy as you said we believe that Imam Ali has ilm al ghayb by the permission of Allah and this is part of the ghayb so we can't talk about it

[@arshkamran7795]

@@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam I understand but why wouldn't allah swt clear cut just call Abu Bakr a hypocrite, why this process which is not even clear cut, and majority of the population has actually seen this as praise to Abu Bakr. Seems confusing please explain in more detail. Thanks

[@arshkamran7795]

​@Mahdy Al-Kaisy Look please do what you want in private, but don't slander them in public, as this is not the way of the ahlel bayt (may peace be upon them). It is fine to have a certain view point but don't publically slander as none of the imams slander, and only spoke logically and eloquently. Especially with a lot of people revering them this will cause less social cohesion. Hope you understand

[@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam]

@@arshkamran7795 I can make those same arguments about literally everything it's ghayb so we don't know it has it's unknown reasons for example why didn't Allah expose the wife's of lut and nuh until the last part of their lives and only then he said that they will go to hell it's the same anwser it's ghayb it has it's unknown reasons that we don't know as for you saying that the majority consider the verse praise of Abu bakr I strongly disagree I say that it shows the hypocrisy of Abu abkr let's debate show me from that verse praise of Abu bakr as for your advice to the other brother about not insulting them in public your claim is wrong the Imams did do it they didn't when there was taqiyya otherwise they did it for example Imam Sadiq From Dawud b al Nu'man who said Al Kumait entered upon Abdullah and implored“O my master! I want to ask you regarding an issue.” Imam said: “Ask.” Al Kumait said: “I want to ask regarding Abu Bakr and Umar." So the Imam said: "O Kumait b. Zaid! A drop of blood does not spill wealth is not obtained in haram manner and neither does fornication happen but that it (the sin) is on their necks till our Mahdi rises. And our community of Bani Hashim order our older ones and younger ones to insult/abuse them and to tabarra on them.” Rijal Al Kashi page 152

[@Aurora-lm5ns]

lol not only that but also the prophet used to trust talha and zubeyr. These rafidhi nuts are really stupid. Their brain cells have died long time ago from too much head striking. If you read the seera of the prophet he always TRUSTED his sahaba. He sent them to abisinia, yeman to wage war against his enemies without even going with them that’s how much he trusted them yet the rafidhi grave worshippers what’s you to believe the prophet was scared of the sahaba he didn’t call them kuffar and cursed them openly. Haha

[@user-zi2oq6lb9e]

7:45

[@Gulamqambar]

After the death of the holy Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him and his immaculate progeny), Muslims had two options for seeking guidance from. The ahlulbayt (family) of the holy Prophet. Others. The ahlulbayt are those family members of the holy Prophet who grew up in his blessed lap. Islam, Qur'an, Shari'ah, etc was revealed in their house. The angels descended with the blessings, mercy and grace of Allah into their house. The holy Qur'an testifies of their purity, infallibility, cleanliness and perfection. The holy Prophet left behind him the Book of Allah, the holy Qur'an and his holy progeny. They are the inheritors of the holy Prophet's knowledge, wisdom, understanding and characteristics. Ahlulbayt are the best examples, role models and ideals after the holy Prophet. Who can understand Islam, Qur'an, Shari'ah, the sunnah of the holy Prophet and so on better than the people of the house? This is why Shia's follow the holy ahlulbayt and none else. As regards to others, we are not sure of the state of their iman, source of their knowledge, information, understanding and guidance about Islam. Muslims ask Allah at least ten times a day in their daily prayers/namaz, "guide us to the straight path. The path of those upon whom You have showered Your blessings, mercy and grace; not of those upon whom You sent Your wrath and gone astray" The question is, how am I supposed to know who are the ones upon whom is Allah's grace, blessings and mercy? In the same salat/namaz, Muslims are obligated to send blessings upon not only their holy Prophet but also his holy progeny. This proves that the path of the holy Prophet's family is the straight and right path. Muslims need to carry out their own independent, academic and unbiased research and find out who rebelled against the ahlulbayt, usurped their rights, waged wars against them and spilled their blood. They are the ones upon whom is Allah's wrath and gone astray. The truth of the matter is that the vast majority of Muslims are victims of prejudice, brainwashing, ignorance, misconceptions and misinformation when it comes to the school of the holy ahlulbayt. Learn the biographies of personalities like the holy Prophet Muhammad, his beloved daughter Fatima, her husband Ali and their sons Hasan and Husain (peace and blessings of Allah be upon them all). Look into the history of Islam (not of the Muslims). Carry out your own independent and unbiased research on the following events:- Da'wat-e-Zul ashira Mubahila The event of Ghadeer-e-khum Saqifa Fadak The battle of Jamal The battle of Siffeen The death of Abu Zarr Ghaffari The death of Muhammad bin Abi Bakr, the death of Malik bin Nuweira Ashura www.al-islam.org www.imamali.net/?id=2390 Please listen to the beautiful lectures by Syed Mustafa Qazwini Syed Muhammad Baqir Qazwini Syed Mehdi Modarressi on utube

[@thehonestdude1067]

brother im an editor and i have to say your audio as clean as it is , has a lot of mouth noises, there are many tutorial on internet on how to filter that out, so tell your editor do to a search about it :)

[@RafidaPlus]

Thanks for the feedback. Interested in volunteering as an editor? Get in touch on WhatsApp: [phone]

[@ayanahmed9254]

Are you implying the Prophet (pbuh) did not know the tafsir of this ayah???? That he chose to keep a "disbeliever" as his close friend and ally before the eyes of the companions? That clearly doesn't make any sense brother

[@mande-lorean2182]

Judas too was a close companion of Prophet Isa..one can ask why Prophet Isa kept snake of a man by his side.

[@adamnouri23]

I personally have been thinking and pondering how come the holy Qur'an could curse its own readers. The Prophet of Islam ( S )( wa Aaleh ) is reported to have said ; SO MANY PEOPLE QUR'AN READERS WHILE QUR'AN CURSES THEM. Yes. It makes perfect sense. When the Qur'an readers think / believe simply the opposite of what Qur'an means, Qur'an curses them. Enjoy reading Qur'an. Enjoy reciting Qur'an. Enjoy listening to Qur'an ,,, however ; to think that the Prophet of Islam ( S ) was the one who frowned upon the blind man ,, in surah / chapter Abasa ,, and you don't want to accept that the one who frowned was othman son of Affan ,, Qur'an curses you. The same goes for Aisha. Surah / chapter At-tahreem is clearly against Aisha and her co wife / trouble making assistant. Yet, so many Qur'an readers believe Aisha was " the beloved wife " of the Prophet of Islam ,, and the praising goes on and on ,, and never think Aisha was actually the Prophet's killer. O yes. She was the one who killed her own husband by poisoning. The narrative of ladud in the book of al-bukhari. Ex Sunni Maliki Muslim from Tunisia in the West. Salaam , [e-mail]

[@farhadhaidar]

I'm an ex sunnite too there are two narration of aisha poisoning Rasullah in shia books they try to conceal it out of fear of these wicked people in our ex community the more realigoua they become the more najis they are regardless of which country they come from

[@Ali-kv3uu]

@@farhadhaidar Me too Ex Sunni, I m happy Allah chose me to Follow Quran and Ahlul Bayt, Alhumdulillah, Allah hu Akbar

[@MuhammadAhmedMuddie]

Saying Ali Madad is like asking Hazrat Ali for help and/or guidance is dangerous and problematic. Allah should be the one and further guidance from the prophet Muhammad. Rejecting and cursing Hazrat Omar and Abu Bakr has disbelieved.

[@thatshiairaqi]

Saying “Ya Ali Madad” is seeking the Waseela of Imam Ali ibn Abi Talib (a.s.) to get your wish from Allah (s.w.t.).Those who misunderstand it think wrongly. Seeking help from human beings is not shirk. Don’t you read in the Holy Qur’an how Prophet Sulaiman (Solomon) (a.s.) sought help of others to bring the throne of Bilqis? All other prophets sought help from people but never believed or claimed them to be God or His partners. We seek help from doctors when we need them and indeed nobody can say that it is shirk. What if we seek help from the best of the servants of Allah (s.w.t.) and seek their Waseela and intervention to pray for us to Allah (s.w.t.)? In the Holy Qur’an, Allah (s.w.t.) has ordered us to seek help from patience (sabr) and prayers (salat) (The Holy Qur’an, 2:45 and 2:153). Obviously, ‘sabr’ and ‘salat’ are not ‘Allah’, but still we must seek help from them. Saying “Ya Ali Madad” is therefore, absolutely in accordance with the Holy Qur’an and the Prophetic Ahadees. Sayyed Mohammed Musawi For more information you can refer to the bellow links abp-miftah.com/en/answer/8800

[@yazahra_yaali]

ﺰنْڊيَقٌ ابو عيوووشة🐒

[@murtaza0608]

you tell me one thing when according Tareekh Al Burhan abu bakr was a munafiq how come even Prophet in anger told abu bakr that Allah is third of them when he knows that abu bakr is munafiq and he is not a true believer

[@thatshiairaqi]

what the Prophet (sawa) meant is very obvious and even a non-Muslim would know. He (s) meant that wherever there's a group of 2 people, Allah (swt) is the third. Wherever there is one person by their selves, Allah (swt) is the second. Allah (swt) is with you wherever you go.

[@user-zi2oq6lb9e]

15:15

[@hdakahidef]

Can't believe the narrative here is "keep your friends and enemies close " so he brought his known enemy with him to keep an eye on him 😑suphanallah his own father in law,

[@thatshiairaqi]

The Prophet (sawa) married his daughter for a reason. It was a way for Allah (swt) to test the people after his death. Do you know about the battle of Jamal? Aisha, the wife of the Prophet, tried to kill Imam Ali (as) because she wanted to gain power. Allah (swt) made the prophet to marry her in order to see if the people would follow the orders of Him (Allah (swt)) or her (Aisha). Very clear in Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim which are Sunni books mind you.

[@kazimsyed7367]

clearing he was willing to disclose prophet location to save his own life. And he was clear liability during the entire thing.

[@thatshiairaqi]

So he could have gotten the Prophet (sawa) killed yet he (sawa) for whatever reason decided to appoint him as his successor?@@kazimsyed7367

[@Anwar-Mian]

Brother Tabari is a historian and there thing in his books from hearsay. We cannot rely on his books all the time

[@truthseeker-cz6lf]

May God bless your mom and dad! Beautifully prepared n presented. He was a pagan and died as pagan and will burn in hell.

[@Gulamqambar]

Please study the following statements very carefully and ponder over the points discussed. The daughter of Abu Bakr, the wife of the holy Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him and his immaculate progeny), the mother of believers, Ayesha (may Allah be pleased with her??), waged a war against the sahabi, cousin and the son-in-law of the holy Prophet, a member of the ahlulbayt and the rightful caliph of her time, hazrat Ali (may Allah be pleased with him). Many were killed and many were injured in this battle. The holy Prophet had warned his wives against this battle. The name of this battle is the "Battle of Jamal" The son of Abu Sufyan and Hind, the father of Yazid, Mu'awiyyah (may Allah be pleased with him??) waged a war against the sahabi, cousin and the son-in-law of the holy Prophet, a member of the ahlulbayt and the rightful caliph of his time, hazrat Ali (may Allah be pleased with him). A highly respectable sahabi of the holy Prophet, Ammar bin Yasir (may Allah be pleased with him) was martyred by Mu'awiyyah (may Allah be pleased with him) in this battle. The holy Prophet had informed Ammar that he would be killed by a gang of traitors. The name of this battle is the "Battle of Jamal". As a free thinking Muslim, I am sure it is my right to analyse such episodes and search for some concrete explanation, such as:- 1. How on earth can Allah be ever pleased with the oppressed and the oppressors at the same time? If this is not a mockery of religion then what else is it? 2. Can a sahabi of the holy Prophet be a warmonger, an unjust, a tyrant and a bloodthirsty? 3. Can an oppressor, an unjust, a warmonger and a bloodthirsty be a sahabi of the holy Prophet? 4. If you were present at the time, whose side would you have taken and on what grounds? 5. What is the definition of a sahabi? 6. Did Ayesha, Mu'awiyyah and their followers accept hazrat Ali as the rightful caliph of their time or what? 7. What is the punishment for someone who rebels against the caliph of their time? 8. Who are the martyrs and who are the traitors in these two battles? 9. What would you say about someone who rebels against the flesh and blood of your own Prophet, usurps their right and shed their blood? 10. Did Ayesha, Mu'awiyyah and their followers pray namaz? In their namaz, did they send blessings upon their holy Prophet and his holy progeny? What kind of beings were they who sent blessings upon their Prophet and his family and at the same time oppressed them, waged wars against them and spilled their blood? 11. What kind of ideals, examples and role models were such beings for the Muslim ummah? 13. What kind of role model, example and ideal is Ayesha for the Muslim women? 14. We are told not speak against the wives or the sahabas of the holy Prophet regardless of their warmongering, oppression, injustice and bloodshed. The SON of prophet Nuh (a s ) could not escape from the wrath of Allah. The WIVES of prophets Nuh and Lut (peace be upon them both) did not go unpunished because of their corruption. Allah has cursed the UNCLE of the holy Prophet, Abu Lahab by his name in the holy Qur'an. What makes Muslims think that the wives and the so called sahabas can get away with injustice, corruption and bloodshed? Please read the first twelve verses of Surah Tahreem. 15. We are told that the wives of the holy Prophet are included in the ahlulbayt referred to in Surah Ahzaab verse33. This can never be possible for at least three reasons. a. the relationship between the holy Prophet and his wives is through marriage which can be nullified through divorce. b. how can someone who is drenched with the blood of the holy Prophet's own family member be also a part of the ahlulbayt? c. none of the wives of the holy Prophet claimed to be amongst the ahlulbayt referred to in this verse. 16. How can beings who are drenched with the innocent blood (and that too of your own Prophet's family members) be a source of knowledge, understanding and guidance about Islam? What kind of Islam (if that is Islam) can be expected of such beings? 17. Muslims claim to love their Prophet and his holy family and at the same time they love, revere and respect their sworn enemies. Muslims take the enemies of the holy Prophet and his holy household as their leaders, guide, source of knowledge and understanding about Islam. One wonders where does their loyalty lie. The truth of the matter is that the vast majority of Muslims are victims of ignorance, prejudice, brainwashing, misconceptions and misinformation when it comes to the school of the holy ahlulbayt www.al-islam.org www.imamali.net/?id=2390 Please listen to the beautiful lectures by Syed Mustafa Qazwini Syed Muhammad Baqir Qazwini Syed Mehdi Moderrissi on utube. Carry out your own academic and unbiased research on the following. Da'wat-e-Zul Ashira Mubahila The event of Ghadir-e-Khum Saqifa Fadak The death of Abu Zarr Ghaffari The death of Muhammad bin Abi Bakr The death of Malik bin Nuweira Ashura

[@user-zi2oq6lb9e]

31:42

[@Abu-Yazid22]

Ameer al mu2mineen abu Bakr r.a even Ali r.a gave him bay3a

[@Rezw.nn14]

How do we know that conversation between Abu Baker (RA) and prophet Muhammad (SAW) happened?? How do we know this is a fact

[@RafidaPlus]

Let's assume that conversation didn't happen, can we ignore everything else? Let us be sincere with the truth that Allah has made clear for anyone who wants guidance.

[@Rezw.nn14]

@@RafidaPlus I refuse to believe that Allah gave prophet Muhammad pbuh companions and a wife who is not righteous, and did not expose them to him while he was alive.

[@A416G]

@@Rezw.nn14 Who cares what you refuse to believe. This is like somebody saying I refuse to believe Allah would keep Iblis amongst the angels if He knew that Iblis would eventually fall like he did. You must refuse to believe that the Jews were tricked by a golden calf after a Prophet miraculously freed them from slavery and gave them revelation. You must refuse to believe Jesus's a.s. companions denied knowing him and one of them betrayed him to the Romans. You must refuse to believe Cain killed Abel. Your sentiments have little to do with reality. The Prophet's daughter a.s. called the people to stand against the "leaders of kufr" after Abu Bakr took power. Aisha started the first fitnah, disobeyed the Quran constantly and showered arrows on the body of the Prophet's grandson during his funeral procession. The Quran itself has ayahs dedicated to the Prophet's unrighteous wives in the beginning of Surah 66.

[@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam]

@@Rezw.nn14 the prophet knew of them being hypocrites even your own hadiths say that some of his companions will be dragged to hellfire on judgment day so you're just going against your own hadiths and the quran since it says that the wife's of prophet nuh and lut are in hell and that the companions/people of prophet musa many of them became disbelievers and started to worship the calf after he left so why don't you make the same argument against your own "sahih" hadiths and the quran?

[@Rezw.nn14]

@@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam you guys use unclear verses in the quran to back yourselves up. Allah specifically talked about this kind of person in the Quran.

[@haarychoudrey313]

I like this hate filled Raafidi. He at least clearly states his position as opposed to the other Raafidis who simply lie !

[@Loyalsurly]

Hate filled??? shias have faced oppression from sunnis for generations. You are the one who is hate filled oh bakri

[@T-19-]

@@Loyalsurly why doesn’t Ali madad you then? If you’re so oppressed. Ya Ali cannot madad

[@kingslayer8121]

@@T-19- oppressed people are lucky. They go straight to heaven. You can enjoy this worldly life 😂 Ya Ali madad

[@murtaza0608]

so Prophet P.B.U.H took abu bakr to madina and lived so many years with him there , did Prophet left abu bakr the muanfiq in peace for so many years for you sister ??????

[@thatshiairaqi]

It was a way that Allah (swt) can test people like you. You think someone can't be a kafr because they were around the Prophet? It's written in the Quran that there were hypocrites around the prophet. The Prophet (sawa) and Allah (swt) knew this.