The Big Picture - Article 370: A Review

The Supreme Court on 14 January agreed to hear the PIL of BJP leader & advocate Ashwini Upadhyay, challenging Article 370 and separate Constitution of Jammu and Kashmir. The Apex Court tagged it with another pending matter and will hear all matters on Tuesday 2nd April. Article 370 of the Indian constitution is an article that gives autonomous status to the state. The article is drafted in Part XXI of the Constitution: Temporary, Transitional and Special Provisions, the state of Jammu & Kashmir has been accorded special status under Article 370. All the provisions of the Constitution which are applicable to other states are not applicable to J&K. For example, till 1965, J&K had a Sadr-e-Riyasat for governor and prime minister in place of Chief Minister.
Guest - Rana Banerjee, Former Special Secretary, Cabinet Secretariat,
Sushil Pandit, Social Activist,
J. Sai Deepak, Advocate, Supreme Court,
Naseer Ahmed, Senior Journalist,
Anchor - Frank Rausan Pereira

[@jamesmicheal4814]

Love him or hate him But you can't avoid the brilliancy and articulation of J Sai Deepak Sir 👌👌👌

[@Ask35720]

No reason to hate him unless one is too bigoted or can't digest facts

[@anupamsharma1]

Always a pleasure to hear J sai deepak.

[@viveknair2809]

J Sai Deepak - the God's Advocate in the Sabarimala Case is now the Kashmiri Pandit's (in a manner of speaking) advocate. Always in awe of his articulation.

[@alopal3191]

Sai Deepak is magic! Susheel Pandit no less!

[@ashishranjan5264]

Hiiii...Alo pal

[@abdulpreetsinghdsouza7723]

Hi ;)

[@abhijitghosh1787]

J sai Deepak is a rockstar of Indian judiciary...,✌️✌️👌👌👌👌

[@tenzindajon]

Whenever we discuss about the Valley, then we must not forget it's significant region called Ladakh. Because they are main victims of all the issues going on in Kashmir. This is the main reason that they are demanding Union Territory status, means they want to separate from the Valley based government. Ladakh importance must be considered whenever we are dealing with the issues of the state J&K....... Thanks RSTV for including Ladakh in your discussion, especially for Mr. Advocate Sir.......!

[@tenzindajon]

@MLone Sadiq I am also from the District Kargil.......! We must not forget that 1+1=11

[@amitmatre4722]

Congratulations Valley boy!! Ur wishes r granted... Ur land is mesmerising!! I though, at the same time hope Laddakh doesn't get overpopulated...n despite the growth that ll come... The wilderness stays.

[@SagarChaudhary2006]

Congratulations you got UT

[@San-iq6gz]

What an articulation and clarity of thought Sai Deepak has!! Stupendous!:)

[@arpitasingh7853]

I can listen mr. j sai deepak every day at any time..

[@govindKumar-yh6it]

listen his others talk too in dharmik matters

[@arpitasingh7853]

@@govindKumar-yh6it where I can get that.?

[@govindKumar-yh6it]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bYLNd4ikmdOKetU see this and search j sai deepak only his all speeches are fantastic

[@YASHPRATAP007]

"J sai deepak sir" is so logical and Rational.... it's a pleasure to hear him....

[@AbhishekBhartimdp]

Rana Banerjee only played with words and had no substance... Mr Sushil Pandit showed great light on the issue and I don't think much need to be said about j Sai Deepak

[@milindboruah8500]

Pleasure to hear J Sai Deepak Everytime

[@deshrajbhardwaj6314]

yeah ..good j. sai deepak start with empower women of j&k well point.

[@healthywealthywise1314]

Mr. Sai Deepak is a right man at right place. He knows his subject well. It is always very enlightening to hear him speak. With due respect to Mr. Pandit and his grip over the knowledge of the issue. He shouldn't have given the debate a 'personal touch' reflecting his emotional bias towards this Kashmiri issue.

[@ravirajkamal]

Frank Rausan Pereira is Amazed by J Sai Deepak knowledge on legal matters.

[@anusuya6722]

Advocate Deepak argument is simply great

[@amitmatre4722]

It seems Amit Shah had a cup of tea with J Sai Deepak on the evening of 4 August...

[@shashiupadhyay7103]

I am very much agree with SUSHIL SIR AND SAI DEEPAK sir ... It's important to remove 370 for development of india and j&k as well...

[@rmns987]

Good to listen to this debate when 370 has gone just by a great move by Government. There is no scope of consensus before removing 370 given it can affect livelihood of many politicians. They won't let it happen

[@paumuansangvaiphei7814]

I wanna hear Panelist Jai Deepak speaking endlessly

[@rmns987]

He speaks as much he actively listens. :-)

[@attitudelearning15]

J Sai Deepak Sir Really you have an amazing ability of presenting yourself 👌🏻👌🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@ashutoshr.tiwari8051]

Mr. J Sai Deepak as always this time also you nailed it!! Man knowledge ho apni field mein toh like you man.👍👍

[@godgifted5882]

I really like the points *"Rights of women's in J& K"* that J.Sai.Deepak pointed out....He is such a knowledgeable(Lawable😃) person...deep knowledge of law and judiciary....👍

[@darshankharti4452]

Sai deepak addresses the core issues very well which should be taken into cognizance, politically there couldn't be any soln bcoz kashmiri separatists never stands upto national importance talkings, best way to deal with this is to be through litigations for women empowerment and minority rights.

[@ShivaniSingh-km5bo]

Its good to see Mr Banerjee on the panel. RSTV is actually doing something to bring out diverse views on the show.

[@michaelscott3190]

True. Some dumbfucks are calling him naxal etc. Bhakts everywhere, not able to use this amazing organ called Brain.

[@ShivaniSingh-km5bo]

So true man! Andh bhakts bro

[@sjtshewalepatil]

What.. That Mr. Bandopadhyay misquoted Article 370 as a special status, others had to correct him. He seemed almost ignorant to sufferings of people of Ladakh and Jammu.. What are you talking about bhakts re, Sushil Pandit is himself a Kashmiri Pandit he did not even mention what happened to his family..

[@ishanmishra9383]

@@sjtshewalepatil yeah let's just ignore the broader point he was trying to make because he faltered in a few technicalities. Good going... and he wasn't ignorant to their sufferings, he himself mentioned that it can be a starting point for the gradual revocation of 370.

[@sjtshewalepatil]

@@ishanmishra9383 Bandopadhyay is polarizing the issue.. It's not just Kashmir involvement in Article 370 leh kadak and Jammu is suffering as well.. Nobody is least concerned about them..

[@Jo-yb8cl]

This video should be titled 'Sai Deepak SMASHES - Ant-National' or something. That look after his point was put through, @19:46

[@debashishroy1397]

how about 'smashing' the 'anti national' article 370 for good and not bringing up the rhetoric of 'we are the only ones who can do it' everytime a national election comes calling

[@mokshsharma9162]

His #ofcourse ✌🙌

[@akshayugale2223]

Arguments in favour of article were weak.....RS tv next time ..For discussion on kashmir issue....Call SHAH FAESAL to debate

[@shreyanshsingh7802]

akshay ugale J. Sai Deepak will destroy him....

[@sreekanthpillai7778]

@@shreyanshsingh7802 Its not about who destroys whom Its all about getting a deeper insight on the issue

[@shreyanshsingh7802]

@@sreekanthpillai7778 true..!!

[@soumyakantaskp5723]

@@sreekanthpillai7778 rightly said . Healthy n detailed discussion is more important than bashing each other.

[@grapeshott]

No politicians allowed here

[@dhruvcharan396]

J Sai inspires me to study law and constitution.

[@Manish-mz8zs]

Article 370 must be removed with immediate effect from Indian constitution and should be ended the autonomy of Jammu and Kashmir...

[@noopursaxena7569]

Frank parera🙏 for such difficult debate such a good conduct.. Our arms open for kashmiri and kashmir remove these articles and move toward development

[@priyatamkumar5611]

See the j sai Deepak expression 19.46 mint.....

[@JaiHind-lo9dj]

I like it. J sai knows that Mr. Banerji's views were reflected a certain ideology

[@officialshobhit]

lol

[@AshishKumar-xl6dh]

Awesome 👍 Deepak analysis

[@Karthikeyan-de8xp]

It was a pleasure to hear all of them. Since there are many who are impressed by Mr. Sai Deepak, I would like to point out that Mr. Rana banerjee is coming from an implementation point of view. Getting a court to pass an order is one thing but the government there to comply would be another task altogether (as we see in sabarimala case, easy to pass judgement but no so easy to implement). He hence mentions "finesse". Mr Sai Deepak & Mr. Pandit on the other hand, are urging to do what is right. Have the courage to do what is right, take a step forward. But then, a bureaucrat lie Mr. banerjee is not what we needed. We thought a leader like modi could do it. A unanimous win would do it. Will the govt deliver?

[@dreamssss3687]

Finally 370 chapter closed

[@tejasvapratap3586]

Sushil Pandit's arguments and facts gave much deeper insights of the stand of our national fathers on this issue and other atrocities happening in Kashmir on minorities.

[@pulkitgupta3903]

This is the way, every news channel should organize the debate

[@GhulamNabi-tu1gi]

Banner ji is good knowledgeable personality

[@officialshobhit]

because you are a muslim

[@noopursaxena7569]

Yes because it easy for him to forget genocide of kashmiri pandit and nobody want to talk about it

[@amiyadash9442]

The lawyer is a rockstar !!!!!

[@AyushSingh-gw8mo]

sushil pandit points were execption ...wat a points hatsoff really impressive sir

[@shabirkabir9020]

Being a ladakhi i think that Art 370 became a permanent provision.

[@shabirkabir9020]

We ladakhi r nt islamizing it but i think that u r belonging to that group which main aim is to divide the people on the Base of religion.

[@MankumariTamang-i6g]

Wow dami❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@snr5950]

Always look forward to listen to M j Sai Deepak...

[@bhavani805]

I can understand from this debate due to highest bureaucracy (like benarjee sir) India maintain democratic values.thank you sir.

[@Sandeep_Raii]

Rana banerjee....special secretary क्या बने " special " word se प्यार कर बैठे

[@Enlightenwithshubham]

Deepak sai and sushil pandit rocks

[@santoshchinnala2223]

Deepak anna superb nuvvu

[@Ck-yp7re]

When Article 371 Can be removed from Hyderabad Telangana State in 2014. if political will is there it can be removed

[@Akshayludhianvi]

sushil pandit's facts are awesome. great person

[@jamestoppo1500]

Its really a fruitful analysis

[@admin8446]

Rana Banerji is a complete dhimmi.

[@shlokwaikar7124]

Anyone watching after abrogation of 370 in August 2019?

[@michaelscott3190]

Thanks Frank for the usual.

[@abha8338]

So now is the right time to change these articles.

[@shailesh4100]

Hats off to J Sai Deepak, the way he put forward the whole issue on Article 35A. He is an epitome of clear thinking....See howz a retired cabinet secretary rank officer of GOI dilly dallying the things....

[@shivraj3770]

I think we always require some time to process what j Sai Deepak is saying

[@ManishPandey-dp8qj]

When Sai speaks, go back to normal from 1.5X Like a boss 😎

[@ramansingla296]

best episode and debate i have ever seen...brilliant

[@sahastraaraa492]

I like to hear Mr. J Sai Deepak very much as his concepts can shut the mouth of many law contractors in the judiciary.

[@macdavid713]

Thank you Rstv

[@melancholicguy.3681]

first India needs to solve it's problem from within before traveling across the world.. who is this deepak ji, of late i began to admire him more and more. Nice to listen while a good lawyer like you are in this show... #Tharoorji and Deepakji 👍👍

[@lifecaptured5295]

Nice debate Frank♥️👌.... Also very well talking comes from J Sai Deepak sir.... Ty RSTV keep going...

[@suchanderreddy]

J Sai Deepak will soon surpass Subramanyam Swamy. This guy will become a torch bearer for bharath varsha, in legal stand point.

[@baljeetyadav3981]

Sushilji is a very intellectual person so humble

[@lasku0007]

Sai Deepak just wipes the floor. The bong buffoon seems to have rattled. He looks like he soiled his pants after the brilliant counter by Deepak.

[@debashishroy1397]

u seem to have a serious problem with bongs as seen in ur other comments as well..so take some action ..how about starting with ur bosses who use nationalist slogans as a political tool written by a bong...the person they hail as the 'first real PM' of India who is a bong...and needless to say stop using the name of the person who formed the party from which the present day BJP emerged - a bong.

[@radha1831]

big picture is means big perception thanks rajya sabha tv

[@AyushSingh-gw8mo]

deepak sir ur views r very authentic

[@amardeep7035]

Rana banerjee is more logical and pragmatic here though he spoke less but well said .this time not convinced with sai deepak.

[@ajithsankar371]

Mr. Rana banarji was present as a true civil servant, 370 has become a part and parcel of j&k and taking away it abruptly will create a lot of uproar considering the volatility of valley ( it will be much more if it happens under nda government you know what I mean!!) and it will also give an opportunity for the separatist and non state actors to get in and create ruckus, an approach of continuous dilution and phasing out the provision would be a much better solution rather than taking it away completely.

[@varsharajput4166]

A very well balanced debate. kudos!

[@abhishekanandsingh4052]

J Sai Deepak Sir was just brilliant.😊

[@gautamgunjan8471]

Pandit sir awesome

[@aqibwani5977]

shah faisel should have been invited in this debate

[@acajay03]

Such coercive arguments by Mr Rana Banerji highlight what made the issue persist for such a long time. Its saddening to know how such ill informed and biased bureaucrats can make country suffer so much. Congress Party is to be blamed for deliberate perversion of constitutional machinery to further their political agenda. Mr Rana was made secretary under UPA-I and now heads the task force on Intelligence Reforms at IDSA (Institute for Defence Studies).

[@ishwarsharma9944]

Mr pandit and sai deepak are very clearly about there legal and constitutional point of view but mr. Banerjee show their favor with separatist....

[@suppiahmurugesan8343]

Factual and legal arguments strongly give sound grounds to repeal Article 370. To say the least, it is a highly discriminatory provision, especially against women.

[@Ask35720]

Sai Deepak ripped the narrative of victimhood to shreds , I hope to see him in the supreme Court bench in the future(unless his appointment is politicised), also mr.banerjee has the traits of a successful diplomat , people are undermining his qualities that are perhaps needed to be a successful bureaucrat in the future.

[@technocrat3428]

What Gives the authority to Rana Banerji to unilaterally and arbitrarily project that the "special" status supersedes the "Temporary " nature of Article 370. I find this argument to be outrageous.

[@knowledgezone2238]

Rana Bannerji sir.. He put things in historical perspective and gives logical view about J&K. The need is to strengthen article 370 rather its abrogation.

[@ayushjain6605]

j sai deepak...great

[@allensebastian97]

I think for a counter point they should also have invited a Kashmiri Muslim to hear their perspective.... why are they sticking on to Article 370 and Article 35A

[@chandtalluri]

EXTREME STAND THROUGH WHICH LAWYERS ADVOCATE IS WRONG ......

[@StudyWithSKRavi60]

........ JAI HIND..... .

[@yashp765]

wow ! great !

[@cricketkedewane8362]

Rana sir u may be very talented and matured minded but u lost my respect today sad to know ur views

[@informativestudyrelated.6616]

Here i see the cabinet secretary talking in positive way but others arguments r too important so we need to include the cabinet secretary sir point .....for civil service. ...

[@zorro471]

Tact yes, cowardice and spinelessness NO!

[@pradeeppatel-dh3rc]

राष्ट्रीय विज्ञापन परिषद् को यूट्यूब पर अचानक आने वाले अश्लील विज्ञापनों की रोक पर ध्यान देना चाहिए । इनको तत्काल प्रतिबंधित किया जाए ।

[@soumyakantaskp5723]

The most important part of the discussion came towards the end. Let's ensure the women right, right of minorities n dalits , aspirations of ladakhi people at the start. Direct hard stance approach may not b so fruitful perhaps. Good to see DIVERSE OPINION which is lacking in some other programs of Rstv in recent times.

[@myshirganhillsadventure3719]

Banerjee... Is itself confusing...

[@prabhusreehari]

There is hope after Subramanian Swamy's era through Sai deepak

[@sheenushandilya]

Love sai Deepak

[@Anon-e7f]

What is this consensus consensus. Does he want a plebescite in the state. The instrument of accession was unconditional. They didn't sign it to ensure their indigenous identity is intact rather they were facing an existential threat from Pakistan. Few year later Abdullah convinced Nehru for the special provision. The fact that all this is coming from a former govt official that too at such high post is scary.

[@Photo209]

Its time to go 370 and must go

[@juststare2201]

This man sai deepak is a genius

[@KumarGaurav832]

Then if tomorrow majority will take law into their hands that is also acceptable according to Rana sir?

[@richatiwari3003]

Susheel pandit sir is best to articulate problem related to kashmir.but he is more effective in Hindi

[@learner4315]

Jammu is against 370 .

[@विकासकुमारचौबेविशाल]

Super look.

[@PositivityInfinite]

No wonder why 70 years pass but temporary seems to be more than permanent.....Just look Rana Banarji kind of people were Special Secretaries reached this post with the help of Banerjees and Like minded British left over

[@SanjeevKumar-te1zc]

I slute Dr Baba saheb Ambedkar.

[@bismaakbar8303]

Rana Banerjee argument is more democratic