The Big Picture: Challenges for Federal Structure

Anchor- Rajat Kain
Guest-
Abhilash Khandekar, Senior Journalist
J Sai Deepak, Advocate, Supreme Court
Shekhar Iyer, Senior Journalist
we have seen instances of tussle between the agencies of central government and the state governments... The latest in the list happens to be IT raids at the offices and residence of aides of Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister... which saw run-in between the CRPF officers and the state police officers...
Such instances were witnessed in West Bengal, Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh as well... where the central agencies proceeded with corruption or irregularity probes...
The central agencies are formed in a federal structure and have primarily the responsibility of probing issues against government staff and serious cases referred to it by courts or by the state governments itself...
Besides the cases of corruption probe... another subject which raises issue of a federal structure is statements made by the leaders of Jammu and Kashmir centric parties on Article 370...
Now, what are the challenges before smooth cohesion in the federal structure and what is an ambit of central and state agencies... for more on this very important discussion... we are joined by

[@shivanivijay4259]

J Sai Deepak -Much applause !!

[@abhishekraj-yb6on]

J Sai Deepak is pure class. Always a pleasure to listen. 🙏

[@chandanchoubey4691]

J Sai Deepak Sir is a Great Man......

[@dailycurrentaffairsshorts3422]

U can't listen J SAI DEEPAK with 2× speed ☺

[@invinciblewill7091]

#As well u can't tolerate to shekhar iyer at normal volume. He is too loud..

[@jaynulali1271]

Right ..

[@anjalisharmapusa299]

He's already in 2x speed

[@VivekBharativivekbharti2870]

I can 😍 a Habitual Listener at 2x

[@Rahulorock401]

@@VivekBharativivekbharti2870 same here man

[@healthywealthywise1314]

The anchor conducted the show very smoothly given he is a novice to BIG PICTURE. When Frank Pareira took over from Late. Girish ji similar voices were heard to do away with Frank. The question is..why are we so aversive towards new comers?

[@jayanti5202]

j sai deepak is the reason i see rstv debates. he is awwsmmmm

[@souravtiwari4514]

how boring u guys are they use tricks of exaggeration to be different..... therefore they ie deepak , tharoor are not worthy to be listened ..as we must be econimical with respect to time

[@jayanti5202]

@@souravtiwari4514 tharoor is more of vocab than content n depth. n in comparison to all the rhetoric n chaotic debate cum shouting which goes on, RSTV is comparatively better.

[@dhanushgowda2550]

We want Frank back

[@ishwarsharma9944]

Federalism is not a umbrella for hiding corrupt government . interest of nation is more important then states of India. we are federal in body but unite in sole.

[@bagha7660]

Rightly said

[@snr5950]

As usual, Sir Sai Deepak is not only crystal clear in his mind abt the issues but makes the viewers/listeners also very wise about the subject at hand....

[@IASachin]

Dear Rs TV With lot of respect we request u to please bring back Frank sir. Because big picture is one of most watched show of this channel and Frank sir is important to maintain its constructivity and exploratory manoeuvre. Thanks Ken sir must be given some other show for the time being. Because he need to develop that skill little bit more. Although he also try his best but it need more Thanks

[@avinashkoli5021]

J Sai Deepak...on the mark 👍👍

[@siddharthagupta5908]

J sai deepak is legend in explaining legal technicalities🔥 ..thnkuh sir

[@mridulshepherd]

J Sai Deepak is pure class.... Shekhar Iyer knows nothing except for certain political kissa and stories. Had to fast forward during his exposition. For legal constitutional aspects he just says "everybody knows".

[@sudharsansiddavatam6089]

J sai deepak sir your speech good sir

[@gameplayndall]

J Sai Deepak.... marvelous

[@bijoyendranarayan5336]

Pl elaborate on the constitutional arrangement regarding the raids as such and the state government s.

[@RajivKumar-dt3yn]

1.financial autonomy:the states have limited source of revenue generation with uch dependence on finance commission recomendation report. 2.all India services:control of centre is dominated on their functioning 3.governer role:appointed by centre govt., has many discritionary powers. it makes functioning of the state govt difficult if in conflict ith central govt. 4.use of art 35: to dismiss the state ovt still prevelant even after SK bommai verdct eg. UK ase 5.Strong Centre vis a vis States : Centre makes policy and states implement them. Policies made from New Delhi is not adaptable to all circumstances. One size fits all approach Consequence's : against democratic decentralization principles and weakens democracy. Development suffers way ahead 1.States should be given more autonomy. 2. own model of overnance, bureaucracy and local govt with firm safguad 3 governer appointed with state govt role in selection Nucleus of development has shifte to states with states like Gujrat, TN, Kerla leading in socio economic paramter. Its time for more decrition provided to state govt to capture the demographic dividend

[@ramk2792]

👍

[@santoshkumarbarik8134]

Can you explain a bit on point 4 of urs art 35

[@athrishpanthati1156]

@@santoshkumarbarik8134 I think he is referring to Article 356 and 365 - president's rule. in S R Bommai case, Supreme court declared that federalism is basic feature of Indian constitution and Supreme court also kept some restrictions on imposing president rule on a state. Now president proclamation should be approved by both the houses of parliament. Till then president can only suspend the state legislature.

[@jayshelke5096]

.....♨️THANKS RS TV♨️.... .....🌋JAY MAHARASHTRA🌋...... SAI DEEPAK SIR THANKS

[@purushottamkumar2607]

In the matter of art 370, one political party is against it and the other party is in its support and both are campaigning for their respective stands. So how can one decide that which party's stand is threatening national integrity and action could be taken against or both parties should be given directives against their campaigning?

[@everythingispossible9361]

EC must be unbiased in democracy,and should be informed before any cbi and ED action,and these agencies must be unbiased. These days action is taken only against opposition, if they join the party which is in govt, that man became harishchandra, like mukul roy and others. This is worse for democracy

[@vishaldubey9916]

It seems like u have watched the debate carefully, ur conclusion is totally different and ridiculous in this context.

[@everythingispossible9361]

@@vishaldubey9916 i agree. My comment is different in context of this debate. But that's reality

[@SamyakJagtap]

It is really unfortunate to see biased journalist that too on rstv. I think India has more neutral personality. Please maintain integrity on rstv

[@sudhanshusaini504]

1 is neutral 1 is against and 1 for. What neutrality you expect? 3-0 BJP lose?

[@bhramitaatma6026]

So for the sake of maintaining neutrality one should start shielding corrupt people

[@prashantkumarsingh6125]

If someone is telling truth it doesn't mean he is biased.

[@NishantSharma-tr6xl]

Hearing Kain at 2x feels normal. Hearing Kain at normal feels like I am spending hours on one discussion

[@tarunkadian2]

Mr. Iyer is way too Politically Biased ( and Loud too) to be called in Political Debates. J Sai Deepak too is Right Aligning but he good and balances.

[@shashanksinghpawar9785]

I totally agree that he is loud...but on the other side ..He is right

[@tarunkadian2]

@@shashanksinghpawar9785 Well, for One Side , Maybe. But for other side, maybe not. For a Balanced POV , totally irrelevant.

[@bhramitaatma6026]

@@tarunkadian2 what balanced POV when the other side is looting like anything and caught where's the space for other POV. IT'S time these corrupt people should be hanged because of these corrupt MF millions of people are living below poverty line and die of hunger . Pathetic

[@kumargaurav8140]

When will we see those " money launderers " going to jail ? What are the laws.. At least 100 years for 1 lac..

[@bhramitaatma6026]

Mr IYers statements were very right and to the point. We need more upfront people like him in the debates

[@rajatnagayach9558]

@8:36 Komedian Kain at his best😂😂👍

[@neelmaybe]

I think most of the people here are not capable of understanding what Mr J Sai Deepak says. We tend to get attracted to something that we don't understand. He is indeed a great orator and makes great points but he does say some stupid things time to time hidden beneath his alluring elusive legal jargon.

[@anandtiwari1906]

J sai deepak is now seems as an absorbed intellectual!!!

[@sshray1115]

Fabulous

[@PrasannaKumar-mm5wz]

Federal challenge_ corruption probe, central agency probing against state staff, political vendetta.7 th schedule, clear demarcation of subjects.national ramifications CBI.

[@onlyS.D.M.]

"Challenges to federal structure " title is very broad, but discussion was restricted to merely few recent events....discussion should have been broadened to include more challenges like 1-inter state water issues 2- central sponsored schemes 3- president rule 4- governors role etc

[@Studyx-cw4ht]

good job

[@ernestoaabhash6275]

Informative

[@rajeevsingh3083]

please don't call biased people like Shekhar Iyer . he doesn't have the requisite amount of knowledge and acts like centre political man ...

[@sushensharma9854]

He is not biased but your mind is biased .... Pappu ka chamcha

[@informationbyrohit10]

Where is Frank sir....????

[@ajitavhad353]

We want frank sir back.

[@sanketwankhede4461]

Cooperative federalism is academic language what happens is vote bank politics where political parties trying to secure votes in upcoming elections throught populist notorious initiatives .

[@tarunkadian2]

Why the Anchors are Angry? Kain isn't supervising the Police Force.

[@ajitavhad353]

I think.. the discussion was very relevant at this point of time.. federal structure academic discussion can be done any day..but today it has to be discussed in terms of elections. N panellist s exactly did it anchor tried to keep politics out but the panelists knew what people should know about fedreal structure and Central agency when parties are making this an electoral issue.

[@anoopharidas9261]

Hey RSTV, what's that noise artifact we hear when people speak? Its there in all your videos.

[@Anandkumar-bo6mu]

Why does it feel like someone is dubbing mr. Khandekar

[@---h..----]

Sir anchor please control show when they are going off track

[@DeepakYadav-pz5oo]

RSTV ...one request ..plz don't invite mr. Shekhar iyer as panelist .he is far below to be called as expert on any matter .he sounds like 200% bjp rss pracharak...thnk you

[@bhramitaatma6026]

Tum logo ki yu hi jalti rhegi...Too bad tum logo ka 2024 tak bhosda yu hi jalta rhega

[@iamankurray]

Where is Frank Parera?

[@sssrrr1988]

where is frank? he is best suited for big picture.

[@UttamKumar-pj3vv]

please invite mk malhotra sir for constitutional issues

[@shreyajaiswal2374]

plz bring Frank back!

[@bhramitaatma6026]

Why is Mr Abhilash lying about the raids?? Clearly we saw the people going out of the complex!! What joke

[@michaelscott3190]

We need aware citizens, its good for politicians that masses are not aware of what's happening around them. Comes once every 5 year, take in votes, keep them stupid and repeat.

[@arbindkumar-ij7bg]

I think central institution should work against BJP rulling state. Then they Will be neutral.

[@niharikashukla7774]

Where is Frank sir?

[@kunwarrananjaypandey8065]

Rajyasabh tv please remove this anchor looking like sleeping and no energy at all .frank parera is best anchor

[@ajayias246]

Absolutely right

[@pratapi_sandeep]

I think there is some messy with anchor Frank after taking interview with Arun Jaitely

[@oramphani]

bring back frank pereira

[@kumzukwallz4199]

Where is Frankkkkkkkk?????????

[@supratiksarkar1195]

Well both mamata and kamalnath are corrupt. And you see these corrupt people are shouting that oh god federalism is in danger, central is bad, modi chor etc. IRS officers are doing their jobs. But sad media people are supporting people like nath and mamata. These are the real danger to democracy who thinks it is their birthright to rule and loot and still be safe. First hang lalu then these will fall in line.

[@vickytinta]

SUPRATIK SARKAR u seen to be really illiterate or modi bhakt may be

[@jaynulali1271]

Frank sir .come back

[@navodayavidyalayafreeclass3883]

Why so angry Mr. IYER ? Please keep kalm.. Raise ur facts not voice.. -^-

[@pankajkumar-mo9vh]

Shekhar ayyar is tamil version of sambit patra.

[@uttamrana97]

Yes yr I think you don't know

[@simranjeetsinghbhatia3422]

Bey yaar ye shekhar Iyer ko mat bulao yaar .. kya chamchagiri laga rakhi hain isne

[@manjumanju-tf2rj]

Please change the anchor.....

[@Rahul_Agarwal23]

We want Frank Rausan back

[@somkarsingh6311]

Frank ? where

[@RCDUP]

Frank is much better!!😁

[@m.leivownmokham3526]

Speak louder kain.. Do you have voice problem?

[@abhishekbhardwaj9254]

we know the news and the stories... we expect the big picture of the situation when we watch "THE BIG PICTURE".. we have plenty of political debates everywhere... here we actually look for the academic aspect of the matter

[@shilpisingh1301]

Anchoring requires more lucidity, it feels as if anchor has no knowledge of the issue in question.

[@coolankitmature937]

It's very easy to question someone's knowledge

[@nidhipandey7188]

Mr.Iyer statement is totally biased .not academic plzz dont call him again on such type of discussion

[@souravtiwari4514]

Nidhi Pandey ......conviction wid facts is enough to be represented.....it is art of extraction as tool be required when encountering such debate

[@dhanushgowda2550]

We want Frank

[@Shivanisingh-bg4ho]

I also

[@dhanushgowda2550]

No maga this anchor is not so good

[@dhanushgowda2550]

Frank is ultimate

[@dhanushgowda2550]

We want Frank back at any cost

[@tarunkadian2]

Frank is busy with Elections.

[@ShivamVerma-wx8hm]

Who's this new kid ?

[@madhumathijagadeesh2579]

Anchor needs to be more clear with his pronunciation , too much polishing of words or trying to have unique accent is distorting words.

[@Tiranga1947]

Rajat ko lagta hai jabardasti baitha diya hai...he seems to be out of picture in this Big Picture

[@entropy20]

Mr Iyer himself is giving political views only and trying to give a narrative which he thinks is right.

[@bkkaleindia5471]

Shekhar iyyar is a modi bhakt please dont call him in big picture

[@sushensharma9854]

Don't watch the video pappu bhakt... Simple

[@bkkaleindia5471]

@@sushensharma9854 its looks as you are andh bhakt of feku modi

[@simpson2430]

Iyer might want to compensate for the brain clots we all have suffered due to his presence.

[@souravtiwari4514]

he would commit suicide having seen ur comment.

[@souravtiwari4514]

conviction itself a reason to be represented .....don't put finger on !!!!

[@dhanushgowda2550]

We want Frank

[@dhanushgowda2550]

We want Frank