DONT TRUST THE CAT (The True Villain) CORALINE THEORY

[@RandomCritique]

Hi guys!! I feel like I haven't been on youtube since forever but I have not forgotten about you all!! I am so close to being done with school, so you all will be a bigger once I am done! But I've been to school even on weekends... So I have very little time right now. Regardless, I hope ya'll enjoy the video!! PS.. I have so much attitude in the beginning of this video and I have no idea why lol. SO SORRYYYY for that 😅

[@stqrz4mai]

i love your vids i had a shout out before but can i get another one

[@layapayton8478]

Hi I am a subscriber and can you do a Toy Story video please ❤

[@layapayton8478]

And can I get a shout out I haven’t got one before

[@lillanie125]

hellooooo i love ur vids. May i pls gets a shoutout?? Tyy

[@SummerMiffy]

Hello 👋 BTW love your videos❤

[@G23417]

I love how even after 20 years, Coraline still has us creating theories to untangle her story. A true gem of writing and filmography!

[@zavierjoiner7295]

*14 years

[@jazprio]

@@zavierjoiner7295 the books came out in 2002

[@darkplayer237]

you are right but since we already know everything we can know (about coraline)the rest is fanfiction that's why none of the theories are close to good.

[@arandomsteve2251]

​@@darkplayer237 do we know everything about it though? Have you sat down with Neil Gaiman and discussed every motive and inspiration behind writing the story? It's a deep and layered story and there are hints upon hints that something more is going on. I'm not entirely convinced by the theories I have seen however I think there are aspects that ring true.

[@filmtheory783]

thanks for making me feel old

[@anniesharp4871]

I'm convinced there are two cats -- an idea that the theorizer came up with. I've since noticed that in some scenes, the cat has a massive chunk missing from his ear. In others, he has smooth pointy ears. Why would the film makers go to the trouble of making two cat figures with such different features? I think they are different cats. One is helping Coraline, the other isn't.

[@Dabis_adopted_daughter]

Yes probebly

[@Dabis_adopted_daughter]

I just watched Coraline.

[@issabellaotinianocastillo3106]

It’s probably because of the portals which switch the appearances of each other

[@anniesharp4871]

@@issabellaotinianocastillo3106 both appear in the other world though -- the scruffy one and the neat one!

[@C23_I]

There’s a theory that the little turtleneck shirt in the corridor is actually the white piece of clothing that belonged to the “boring blue boy” implying that he was real and was probably the Beldam’s child!

[@ethenallen1388]

What I think is that after Wibe's grandmother's sister disappeared, she began studying witchcraft to find out what had happened and enlisted the cat's help, one way or another. They found and sealed all the passageways the Beldam could use, including the well which they blocked off with the fairy ring, except for the one in the Pink Palace because there the Beldam was too powerful for them. They tried to keep children away by not renting rooms to families with children, but ultimately realized that she could outlast them, so they gambled that the right kind of child could rescue the trapped children's spirits and weaken her enough to seal off her world. They choose Coraline but did not tell her since it would tip off the Beldam and she'd be on her guard. After Coraline had freed the trapped children, the cat wanted to take the key to Wibe's grandmother but decided that since they had set up the fairy ring around the well to block the Beldam, it would do well enough.

[@freyastephenson]

One way or another I’m gonna get ya (it’s a song)

[@RosesTeaAndASD]

This is very well thought out.

[@Jenny-ql7lh]

I saw somewhere saying that the striped clothes in the portal belonged to the boring blue boy in the painting and there’s a theory that the boring blue boy is the beldam’s son… What if the cat was the one who killed her son and that’s why his clothes are in the cat’s portal? I guess it would explain the hatred / competition between the cat and the beldam.

[@cornerduncee]

yay, new video! I love your editing so much aaa edit: your hair is so pretty omg 😭

[@shigeokageyamakin]

It’s been a while since I’ve seen a coralline video, I love the editing!

[@RandomCritique]

Yay! Thank you☺️

[@mykkimc521]

@@RandomCritiquegood job

[@BrulePlays_.]

12:16 quick theory?, what if she escapes the other mothers dimension but doesn’t go back to normal, by normal I mean the original world, what if she went to another world, that’s why the tunnel is different , what if the other mother purposely set that up, a completely other universe , a new world where Coraline doesn’t know about the other mothers plan , and in coralline 2 it’s called’ coraline 2: the other world’

[@HanzoYts]

I think the reason why cats doesn't said any warning to keep away its because the cat knows coraline like she is brave so basically the cats needs coralines help to help those 3 lost souls idk xd

[@Rocky_578]

She said injurie so calm 🤣💀

[@Welshmacmillan]

Your editing is just getting better and better, absolutely love your theory videos on coraline. ❤😂

[@liltmarshall8717]

Glad your back with a Coraline theory! Love these ❤

[@sjemccabe]

9:24 now imagine what would have happened if the other mother warned her about the cat?

[@tyleroutland435]

I love the Coarline videos i don't care what anyone says i want a Coraline sequel i don't believe the other mother died i think she is very weak at the end though. I feel like she is planning on getting a revenge plan on Coarline, Wybie, and the cat.

[@ju2545]

Coraline also needs a prequel with what happened with the other kids

[@hannahlarocco4699]

Agreed

[@mrstealyogirl1366]

​@@ju2545yea that's uh good idea

[@oliviajade3655]

I think the beldam pulled a Voldemort like physically she is very weak (maybe not even having a full physical form anymore) but still alive ready to get revenge on coraline and the cat

[@KitiaraWright]

i feel like the only resean for the beldam to hate the cat is because she dont want him to help the kids like he did with coraline

[@itz-meluna2]

Another thing I noticed is while wybie is talking to Coraline about her grandmothers missing sister The cat was in the roof when he turns around and sees the Caroline doll in the window

[@harperrroth]

"The Belledame wants to sew eyes into Coraline's... eyes" -A Random Critique 2023

[@CozmicKaos]

Clicked on that notification immediately Love your videos Btw, you don't look a mess at all. You look great. Gorgeous. Keep up the amazing videos 😁

[@roy.shrestha]

This theory makes so much sense. You are such a talented theorist😀

[@EloiseTardif]

This theory is Mind-Blowing!! Like wtf where do you get all those ideas?!! Honestly, it’s kinda impressive

[@cierrarosejones6145]

When wybi fell into the well what if the hand was dragging him into the well... And the bell dam if she's still alive gone after Wybi to get coraline?

[@Zahra-l1l2r]

i feel like the ghost kids only saved themselves and left coraline alone and she put the keys back to the other world 🤨(random)

[@blurreddream1500]

I love the intro. Thank you for making these theories.

[@sovety865]

I thought the cat in Coraline is a good cat,but he's lying,he is a witch.

[@moniqueboucher8011]

Witchs are girls

[@RealG23__]

I could literally talk about coralline w u all day

[@mari-carmenpizarro1784]

My eight-year-old grandson and I have been watching your videos. He has a comment he wants me to share. "No, I do not believe you. Then why was the cat helping her? And well... The cat is not a fairy, and one kid did give the name of the cat.

[@savvyscorner1989]

YES HIS NAME IS VERMIN

[@savvyscorner1989]

Remember the scene “and you brought VERMIN with you”

[@yminnah]

@@savvyscorner1989yes!!!!!

[@Airbornesoulja0082]

I think that the cat is there to protect Wybe he goes to the other world to see what is happening there then he reports what happens to Wybe’s mother because she knows that is happening there that’s why she won’t let her son go there.

[@Mercedes_Rose9]

My theory is that the cat made all this to help the other mother and she ask like she hates cats and makes it seem like coraline is in the real world cuz how did the mirror Illusion in the real world so she is stuck in the other world forever and the cat used to be a human and became a cat from a witch kinda like in hocus Pocus and at the ending the cat disappeared

[@DONTASK689]

Ok so one of my theory’s is when the three kids from awhile ago traveled to the other dimension the would of had to have a key so they must have went in with the key because these kids probably had to have been able to travel back and fourth before so when Coraline moves in there is the key. Sooo because the key is one of a kind someone must have been able to travel back to put the key back there or they’re not one of a kind. So we know that the belldam can travel to the human world so how did that key get there the cat maybe they are really working together or the keys aren’t as rare as they seem and belldam can make more and more to drag kids in

[@leia3618]

A mess?? What are you talking about?! Girl, you are gorgeous!!

[@CaelynRomero]

Omg I never thought of it that way! The cat is such a mysterious character. What if the cat was stuck in that form. Why don't we ever see him in his true form? Why did he choose a cat form? What if he has his own creations like the Beldam? Love your videos! Please put me on your shout-outs❤❤❤❤

[@briseismercado6163]

I have a question about the souls, do or would they fade over time and eventually disappear? thoes 3 ghosts might not be her only victims but her latest victims which are still new.

[@cohanstoddlerfun]

Omg I love your vids 💛

[@TotalContemplation]

I did not know the bit about fairy names having power. Interesting. That makes the scene in the book regarding names *Both with the cat and the ghost kids* very.... Interesting. I already wonder if the cat is Cait Shide? But, I actually don't think the cat is good or bad. I think he's indifferent. And I think he has his own motives for doing what he does. But, I also wonder if he's a spirit of the mist.

[@livingwithautism3789]

I did not know the bit about fairy names having power. Interesting. That makes the scene in the book regarding names Both with

[@theterrifictrickshottricksters]

I love your videos and I have a theory about bobinski you know how mister bobinski is blue well so is Emily from corpse bride I think bobinski is dead. he does all those acrobatic moves without hurting himself, he can talk to animals like Emily could talk to scraps, he can travel through dimensions, and hes made of mice like the dead people were made of bugs.

[@G23417]

Bro i Never thought about that!

[@Logabone]

This is…..the biggest reach of theories ive ever heard 😭

[@Ameliarrrrssss]

Can u plz do a video on coraline on her first arrival bc on her cake it says welcome home in cursive but the "home" has a double "O" wich means lie

[@splendisdude]

RANDOM CRITIQUE!!! I love all your videos! You’re voice is enchanting. Shout out plzzz ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@LisaLazers]

I love your videos ❤❤❤❤

[@Rayne90day]

What's so bad about taking over your own world and building it to hold it you want and having those you would like. Sounds like heaven

[@allthatsnostalgic1779]

At the end of movie Wybie said it was the cats idea to stalk her in the first place so he was talking to the cat in both worlds If the cat knew about the place to begin with why only help Coraline why didn´t the cat help the other kids because he was apart of it the whole time she still stuck there and in one scene it shows Beldam posing as her mother with regular eyes then when she blinks it goes back to buttons showing she doesnt need to have buttons on her eyes its a trick. Coraline was not saved in the end she was still trapped in the other world. The cat put the doll near the door so she would find the door the cat was the only one that was sneaky enough to do it.

[@lilahgonzalez2337]

Omg l love your vids 😊

[@Snoop_slay]

the cat does have a name tho. When the belldam is like the spider, she says, "Oh, you brought . . ." I havent seen the movie in a while so i dont remember it all

[@miku-ek3zg]

i think Coraline never escaped because at the end of this movie the cat disappeared into a portal shows that there's magic still around. How could magic exist in real world? And I've heard people say " if Coraline never escape then why everybody have real eyes because only Beldam can do that" that is because Beldam already had enough souls to do everything she wish for. Four souls including Coraline's. We can know by the four holes on the button resemble to the four souls. Remember when Beldam show coraline her button eyes in the kitchen for the hide and seek game clue? that is the proof. I think it's only Coraline soul who think that she still alive. PS: only my thought

[@yminnah]

Oh my god that makes so much sense!!!!!!

[@Muichirochannn]

Hey I just wanted to point out that we get a little hint of the cats name in the movie because one Coraline find all the ghost children’s eyes the beldom says “so, your back and you brought virman with you” btw I love the theory’s you come up with!

[@Lynnziethealien]

Her: *talking about the theory* The doll in the back: 👁️ 👄 👁️

[@elibethy7108]

What if both the beldam and the cat are both pawns to a bigger entity

[@TezviFrench]

I NEVER THOUGHT ABOUT THAT!!!! u smart....

[@notsoperfect6391]

Gracie looks upset, love your theories❤ lets hope Gracie is not hunted 😮

[@hannahlarocco4699]

Haunted really?

[@notsoperfect6391]

@@hannahlarocco4699 Everything is possible.....If we do not see it it does not meaning its not here....just like air

[@sjemccabe]

That intro would have been a great trailer! Make it live action, and I'm down. I wanna see a rated R version of Coraline

[@Mysteriofreeflying]

I would love to see another Coraline film.

[@Ringleader.]

I have never trusted the cat but now I'll never give him the benefit of the doubt.

[@2cornichons]

The cat controls the beldam

[@AniSeikatsu]

I love your Channel

[@DerpyICEcube]

The missing sister that went into the other mothers world what if there was another version of her twin sister with buttons for eyes just like wybie and maybe tried helping her to escape but was not succesful Reply

[@brelaflair4111]

please make more videos and a lot off topic but how did the REAL mother know the right key to open the little door

[@yminnah]

I think bc it’s the key. That stands out the most

[@deathviller]

Would you do a theory with the corpse bride slash coraline with coco similiarities that leads to the nightmare before christmas does make sense that Coraline never made it home the pink palace could end up being built over a cementary. Cheers Mia

[@ju2545]

Just a random funny thought: what if Coraline walked into her room and found Wybie wearing one of her outfits? And then saw he put one on the cat? And her other clothes thrown on the floor cuz he was trying all of them on? Hehehe

[@DMTMilk]

He’s one of the spies helping the other mother keep tabs on coralline

[@aubs.thatgirl]

Now that I finished I think your right Coraline and Wybie both aren’t safe because the ghost children said “Once we saw the Beldam we never saw our real mothers again” Coraline isn’t safe and it honk Wybie is next

[@dreamsans7448]

WAIT I HAVE A IDEA, ok ok hear me out. Let's put to of your ideas together. What if the people in the house are helping the other mother and that's why they have dogs and mice the dogs and attack the cat but they die so often. That's why they keep geting dogs. All the mice are to distract the the cat.

[@savy_wavy1071]

What.. are u talking about fr. Some of the stuff that you explained in this makes no sense, secondly majority of the stuff you talked about already have a fixed reason as to why it happened and it was even shown in the movie. What you're talking about just makes it seem like u skipped passed all of the very important parts of the movie and focused on the meaningless stuff which really and truly didn't have anything to do with the storyline or the plot. Please rewatch the entire movie and actually pay attention instead of scanning it.

[@faygo_cupcake]

Another thing not the fey is the can curse each other by winning games agent another fey so maybe the reason he can't shape-shifting back from a cat is because of the bedlam

[@siesimonxia]

in the movie the other mother says the cats name is verman i love ur channel btw

[@bakacdaz]

I don’t think the cat don’t have any ill intention to Coraline or helping her just because he’s a hero. But more like he’s use Coraline to get rid of Other Mother. (Maybe they are both local gods who fight for this territory or something like that.) So the cat know Spider Mom is hungry then he use a little girl as a bait to lure her into his trap.

[@livingwithautism3789]

I don’t think the cat don’t have any ill intention to Coraline or helping her just because he’s a hero. But more like he’s use

[@diliuswilius]

your videos are so cool 😎

[@marygracecipriano9574]

Holy macaroni i also thought that the real world was actually an another dimension in the past😮😮

[@myownchannel1714]

I like these theories

[@ceciarizmendi3259]

Can I get a shout out pls I really love your theories by the way did you know that Henry Selick is the director of coraline and James and the giant peach it shows bugs in both movies 😮

[@broski.toasty2817]

The beldam calls the cat by name (vermin) during the spider web scene!!

[@edward818ec]

Yesssss finally thank you thank you 🙏

[@farahhjackson1018]

anybody notices that we never actually see the cat enter the other world .. when coraline and the cat go in the tunnel together - the cat disappears . Why? if he reappears just with button eyes? When coraline throws the cat at the other mother - and coraline fake escapes , the cat is just magical there.... but it never shows how he ended up back in the real world. We know he teleports but still ... it would've been nice to see that... I do believe the cat wants coraline.. black cats are always seen as evil. brings around bad luck.. the cat loves games. "The other mother tries to keep me out but she can't"... why can't she if she CONTROLS that world? It would have to mean that he is the same cat and that's why, he doesn't have buttons for a reason... no buttons means no control for the other mother.. I believe the cat actually controls the other world and uses Wybie as a pawn to lure other children to the well portals.. nobody ever ask where's Wybie mom or dad? and the doll he gave her I feel like the cat retrieved it from the other mother once she threw it out the window.

[@kaleyw6368]

He gets distracted by a *mice* you mean he gets distracted by a mouse and when you said you were a mess you definitely didn't curl your hair to get it a perfect DNA strand look and a full face of makeup

[@thegamerboy9853]

u should watch cz’s world. he makes a rebuttal to all ur points in his video

[@VictoriaMoore-wo3ee]

can you make a theory about why wybie always went the gramma

[@AimeeandApollo]

Wait......ooooooo....I just wached the end of the video and the theory of that whibey is next....is a cool theory

[@Brodiethedog101-ul5zf]

If he’s working for the Beldam,then why did he rip out her eyes? Srry that’s just what I think ^^”

[@Anil-freinds]

RIP Gracey 🙏🏽

[@mayteallon8028]

I loved the video it really made me look at the cat in. A different way

[@aubs.thatgirl]

I’m still on the middle of the video and I thought his name was Vermon?

[@JaslynnShawnel-zw3uk]

And no one else remembers the term “devious cat”😂 I never trusted him😭

[@TezviFrench]

U don't look a mess! U always look good 😁

[@elizabethcotten7710]

NOW Coraline needs to save wybe😢

[@TezviFrench]

U should watch coraline deleted scenes and see how they fit ur theories

[@tressaschabes473]

I love the theory it’s so smart and creative but… I still love the cat😭😭 And if Wybie is next I’m suing lol Those r my three fav characters Wybie the cat and Coraline at this point I’m just gonna name the cat cuz no one else is lol 😂

[@donkeenum302]

I think this is a big stretch but amusing take

[@xxLul-Drench-Gang]

Cz world made a video about ur coralline theory

[@NicoDiAng3lo]

Hi i love your videos if you can may i have a shout out if not its fine LOVE THE VIDEO so far

[@RandomCritique]

Yes duhhh!!! For my next video I will give you a shout out!

[@jamesthorpe8059]

the cat is helping Coraline and the other dad is helping her and other wabe is helping her if the beldom doesn’t know what they are doing

[@MarsheaLomack]

He’s acting like that bc she’s going to throw the key away in the WELL WHCH IS ANOTHER PORTAL

[@lourdespachla6516]

seriously? i cant even trust my own cat anymore?

[@J.P.Robles]

So does Peter Pan control Tinker Bell because he knows her name?

[@sairachavez3757]

Hi hi I like vids and I’ve been watching since The coroner videos and I have a theory for you, if you have time can you please make a new video I would love that. So basically the theory is, that I have been watching your Peter Pan videos and they’re really similar to the Coraline Think about it Peter Pan and the other mother both lore people to kill, and I also think that Peter Pan is a fairy who created never land and lore people people so they can take there souls, but what about the mermaids? Well I found out that mermaids don’t have souls either. So probably they’re working together to get all those souls and the only reason that Wendy and her brothers escape is because Peter Pan liked Wendy, I hope he commits to one of your videos if you can and thank you.

[@savvyscorner1989]

Actually the cat has a name his name is VERMIN “and you brought VERMIN with you”

[@lorenzo_Angeles]

If you look closely at the cats eyes in the poster they're different showing his split personality

[@leowaves7513]

Btw guess what? Disney announced frozen 3!!! Maybe it could feature your frozen theories? Get excited!!!

[@crestfallenraven]

Say, is she actually in the faery cat's world at the end???!!

[@calaiyalaylay]

Wait so this whole time after 20 years I’m just now realizing that there fairy’s

[@coldtakes2735]

I just realized it’s here. YESYES YES YE SYS YE SY EYE

[@ZaidAdnan-m1c]

Whyyyyyy did you make the intro so scary