'Rangers should have had a penalty!' insists former referee Des Roache | Hotline Live

[@goodluck-t8p]

Your picture shows at least 9 inches between the Celtic defender and the Rangers attacker, if your picture shows when contact was made it was outside the box, always moaning. This game gave Rangers the advantage as it was played at Hampden which was Ranger's home ground for a good part of the season. Celtic were terrible today and still won.

[@BlairMayne-iv2bw]

@@goodluck-t8p you were made to look terrible because playmaker mcgregor was taken out of most of the game by bajrami

[@goodluck-t8p]

@BlairMayne-iv2bw Ach well we still won the cup, My wife said to me after it finished, where are all the Rangers fans, I said they left, she was amazed and said after the effort they put in, they never waited till they picked up their medals, and when you think of it, it was pretty bad as these Rangers players surprised us all with their effort.

[@thomasmccormack8045]

Dry yur eye's. 😂😂😂

[@dndfindfindfbdjs.745]

@BlairMayne-iv2bw Celtic have won 20 cups from 25 since rangers got promoted in 2016. Rangers have won 3 and finished 3rd twice. Dry your eyes zombie. Your clubs rotten to the core. Sold for £1 Gordon Neely and Harry Dunn. Chase the cash up with the liquidators- walking away the rangers way

[@MAGOO-1]

What your ref doesn't know that the whistle went b4 his feet went on the line.

[@bigred7318]

I would have sent John Scales off and gave Ally McCoist the penalty...

[@GetItRightUpYees]

We lost and certainly I lost in grace,one for the ages and an excellent advert for Scottish football,well done Celtic,gutted.💙

[@johnhiggins779]

Well said Sir.

[@Ruairí-n7b]

Fair play mate

[@colinstephen2018]

The way it should be mate, it's a game of football and yes a rivalry but after the game it should be like this instead of the sectarian pish, unlucky today and what a game it was indeed.

[@McLaughlinP-y1c]

Well said... you should be proud of your team yesterday they gave it their all

[@StevenBarr-z6m]

It's embarrassing pal,great effort from your team pal and I'm certainly as dignified in victory and defeat

[@johncopeland3826]

Wow ..the daily Record acted fast in wheeling out their referee for his opinions ? Pity he or the rag have no input whatsoever about the result .. absolutely nothing ....impotent , in fact....

[@McLaughlinP-y1c]

A rag referee as well

[@davidparsons426]

Great game considering celtic where playing against the linesmans disgraceful calls all match blatantly incorrect, call it carma. No penalty

[@jamestoland7961]

100% m8

[@tommystewart1745]

Twice the ball went out of play by a theRangers player in the first half and the linesman gave theRangers the decision 🤦‍♂️

[@kegalormoon]

​@@tommystewart1745yep that was the first two he went to then it happend the other way and the commentery team went mental because rangers didnt get a throw

[@Edi-r1888]

Var did look at it and it wasn’t in or on the line, but the daily rangers picked a photo that made it look like a penalty. Because the foul happened a second or two before that photo.

[@BlairMayne-iv2bw]

@@Edi-r1888 he's still got a handful of his shirt that's a continuation of the foul.

[@greatgreedyguts]

It was a penalty mate. These things even themselves out over the season , so we have been told for years.

[@Edi-r1888]

@BlairMayne-iv2bwit depends when the whistle blows, if it blows before he puts his foot on the line it’s not a penalty.

[@ononewheellad]

@@Edi-r1888wtf you on.

[@markgallaghermfg]

Foul before penalty area blown for so the ball wasn’t in play and cant be a penalty, manufactured controversy and something for the meeja to talk about and rangers to moan about

[@geraldrae8351]

@@markgallaghermfg you don’t know the rules obviously

[@geraldrae8351]

@@markgallaghermfg face it Celtic won it unjustly, stinks up the place

[@adyseven1]

Tee hee 😂😂😂 Hun tears​@@geraldrae8351

[@lsmlsm2115]

This is embarrassing... He is clearly not in the box. There was no 'clear and obvious error' to justify VAR intervening anyway. None of the players or supporters were calling for a penalty at the time.

[@garymccafferty4654]

A throw in is awarded when the whole of the ball passes the touchline, so am no sure what they are on about here anyway. one foot on line & rest of body outside box.... Will we just do away with the box lines then, no point having them lol

[@lsmlsm2115]

@@garymccafferty4654 Yes, the bitter Rangers fans and Clement are arguing the rules state that having one foot on the line counts as being inside the box. Weird, because I have literally never heard anyone arguing that ever in all of my 25+ years of watching football. You'd think Rangers were just sour about losing or something eh...?

[@redcroftbearbear185]

*Everyone saying we should have had a penalty,…We got five and still didn’t win* 🤷🏼‍♂️

[@IainDavidson-h2w]

Usual, bet celtic would have been checked

[@JohnBarton-t4x]

Best game of football I have seen in Scotland for a long time !!!

[@shaunbreslin6360]

Don't talk pish! VAR would have picked it up!

[@ccammy1]

No penalty scales grabbed him when he was outside the line but he smartly put his foot on the line but the foul was over by then in other words he played for it

[@JohnMacdonald-fs2gw]

Interesting Scales still had a hold of his shirt while his foot was on the line which by the law.....is a penalty. So playing for a penalty or not it's still a pen and I think anyone would rather try to win a penalty there rather than a free kick

[@Me-jr1ek]

That’s why he wrote smartly 😂😂 get the violins out always cheated never defeated

[@tonymiller6714]

Rubbish. The ref was correct. The first foul took place just outside the corner of the box and then Cerny stood on the line for what looked like a second foul. Well done John and the VAR.😊😂

[@PJMCM]

The actual contact initiated about 3-4 yards back from where your photo shows. Nice try - keep greeting!

[@geraldrae8351]

@@PJMCM laws are the start of fouling has no bearing on decision, tugging was ongoing while cerny was on the 18 yrd line. 1000%PENALTY, CHEATING BIAS

[@Reargunner-o7h]

3-4 yards, You are having a laugh!

[@benbhoy9]

Not a Penalty … the Foul was originally commited OUTSIDE THE BOX …Therefore the Officials where Right

[@weeJinky]

You say you dont know why var didnt intervene because its a clear and obvious error but then admit none of you thought it was on the line until you seen the picture. How many brain cells do you have between you? Why are you unable to connect the dots here? if its that tight then it isnt a clear and obvious error then is it? 🤯

[@henrymcvey6538]

I can see why Des no longer referees🤣

[@johnmcneil465]

It’s absolutely astonishing and you can only conclude it’s a corrupt var panel there’s NO excuse not to give it

[@Chazthefurr]

The foul was blown for by John Beaton on first contact, not when they moved forward to the 18yard line. I HEARD it clearly AS I WAS WEARING AN EARPIECE. Go on check it out.

[@MisterGlasgow]

I think the game should be replayed…. Considering Celtic just overtook Rangers in the tally of actual cups win since both teams were formed , even though Rangers win more Micky Mouse cups …. Skol Cup v European Champions…. A cup win is a cup win … I can see it VAR enough

[@rabmcnair4488]

No mention about the fact there were two fouls. First foul scales kicked him outside the penalty box. This is the one that was given, so the pull is irrelevant as it happened after the initial offence

[@iansoutar5324]

Was Willie collum ( mr Celtic) the VAR ) official.

[@barryjohnmillsip2853]

Giruy

[@davidt510]

Alan Muir is vastly experienced in giving big decisions against Rangers

[@dublinbears1872]

Lots of referees speaking out and saying this was a penalty… The SFA need to explain why VAR got this blatant penalty wrong. Why does the VAR calls always favour Celtic ?

[@MrBagpipes]

When a foul is committed outside the box it's not a penalty. 🤡

[@Chazthefurr]

I clearly HEARD the ref blow for the foul on first contact, wide of the penalty box. I had an earlpiece and heard the whistle. Go back and check this for yourself. Therewas a replay with a long end shot and it confirmed that again listen to the audio.

[@MrBagpipes]

@@dublinbears1872 when Celtic gubbed your shower of failures in September VAR chopped off a goal by Kyogo. It's a self-pitying fairy tale VAR always favours Celtic. Rangers lost. Again. As usual.

[@seanmurphy6056]

I've only ever heard this level of whining from a Hellcat supercharger

[@gmc1992-w2m]

No penalty… grow up

[@chickwood3883]

Was a penalty

[@gmc1992-w2m]

@ outside the box

[@BlairMayne-iv2bw]

On line... Pen that's the rules

[@pablocarlos3441]

@BlairMayne-iv2bw Not when the jersey was tugged. He lands on the line after the offence was committed.

[@gmc1992-w2m]

If that pens given against Rangers, you guys would be up in arms

[@gartnait1]

Stonewall penalty missed by var.Rangers robbed.

[@Darren.ftk.]

Up yeeeees

[@tonymiller6714]

Additional comment. Why do you keep rolling out mediocre referees who couldnt hold a candle to John Beaton and classifying them as experts?

[@BJSwing]

The whistle was already blown for the foul that happened outside of the box. The still image is just their momentum after the ref officially stopped the game. It's really easy to understand, clearly not if you're a The Rangers fan.

[@Chazthefurr]

Exactly. I clearly HEARD the ref blow for the foul on first contact, wide of the penalty box.

[@lenny3206]

Called it live thtat it was in the box, no idea how VAR missed it. Hopeless, but sadly crucial moment in the match. .

[@garymccafferty4654]

hows that in the box ? lol. one foot on line & rest of body outside it? you dont get a throw when an inch of the ball touches the line usually when it goes over no? sure thats the point in the lines but maybe am missing something.

[@MrBagpipes]

Failure FC are the same every time, 'always cheated never defeated.' Their predictability is boring.

[@Cumberland_swasige]

One still picture to try to make the case for some sort of moral victory. Huns always crying.

[@amk68sco]

Making rangers GREET again 😅

[@JimmyTimmy-wh8dz]

Lets see all the previous frames instead of one still image.

[@JimmyTimmy-wh8dz]

I would be more concerned about conceding three goals.

[@Kevin-l4]

Go look at beatons position . He couldn't see shirt pull . Two separate incidents the foul and then the pull . Beaton seen no advantage so gave original foul . Outside box . No pen .

[@Kevin-l4]

This is why refs shouldn't look at still photos afterwards from fans eye view and make hero calls .

[@theunderwatercabbagesalesman]

HONEST mistake from Brother Beaton 😂

[@jamaicanjock6305]

Not all shirt pull is a foul 😂

[@undersoundproductions1915]

Watch one corner in an epl or spl game. Count the shirt pulls. To claim for this at the corner of the penalty box is lowering the bar.

[@rougescot81]

This needs to be investigated in the game needs to be replaced

[@dndfindfindfbdjs.745]

Can re investigate the tax bill to see if rangers paid it 😂😂😂😂

[@charlieking6718]

Watched it again and the foul was outside the box. He pulled him on to the line and that’s the picture the daily ranger has posted .Fake news

[@frasermunro9975]

He isn't continuing into the box he is running away from the box. The foul initially happens outside the box

[@ianmeechan2040]

VAR should be accountable that's why they are there.

[@magnusmowat8024]

Ffs stop bleating and crying cause Sevco didn’t get a penalty..how many times have other teams been cheated out a penalty but nothing said but of course its a huge deal when it’s sevco.

[@AsifSiraj]

If you have to say "I'm not a sympathiser I'm not a sympathiser" then you're a effing sympathiser

[@Reargunner-o7h]

Apart from that, what about the trip by Kuhn on Diomande just before he scored their third that wasn't looked at. Two tier officiating.

[@AR-dn6kh]

Jorge cadete 2 yards onside at ibroke ,beston blew the whistle just before , dry your eyes

[@John-qi3eg]

Get over it mate. The never ending cry of losers. Not particularly Rangers, every team that loses and their support.

[@connor4223]

As a celtic fan this is the where rangers mess up. Clement especially to come out claiming this penalty which fine maybe it is maybe its not but the focus should be on there tbf decent play and improvement. Instead the conversation is about this on the line penalty

[@donaldcunningham2386]

As a Rangers fan, I agree. I think we've made a bit of progress and improvements over the past few weeks. Certainly better than the demotivated , disjointed crap we were. Frankly, I think this really entertaining match bodes well for both halves of Glasgow, in Europe. And what an atmosphere, better than anything south of the border! Cheers, mate.

[@ononewheellad]

Maybe big Phil is guilty of watching too many Brendan post match interviews regarding decisions. BR is the fkn worst offender.

[@Mickyfinn1888]

Funny how no one made anything of the incident until after the full time result lol Excuses as always.

[@rian202003]

Never a penalty

[@wullieman]

His hands on him. You blind where in that picture is his hand on him. Could of picked a better picture 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🍀🍀🍀

[@geraldrae8351]

This is bias, no question

[@TheHazy111]

Dry yer eyes mate,yer clubs deed.😅

[@ononewheellad]

Septic looked deed yesterday.

[@Alan-b8q9j]

Meanwhile back in REALITY.......😅😅😅😅

[@Wastelander33]

Hahahahaha hun meltdown, the shirt pull was before he even reached the box, huns expect a penalty in every game 😂😂😂

[@ononewheellad]

You know you should pipe down wi the Hun stuff. That’s good advice.

[@riboid]

No post-mortems.

[@MrMontythemouse]

Another excuse, same as last the Cup final in May. Cheerleaders out in force.

[@stuartrobertson4714]

Tav took penalty and flew over the bar so still 3 /3

[@christopherknowles8710]

Then the keeper took the goal kick slipped into the ball vickers went to clear it and put the ball into his own net 4/3

[@mcdeezrfc]

Alan Muir nuff said

[@robertmcnab4346]

Not a penalty

[@Sa1amander71]

So the touchline is not part of the pitch ? Have you heard the expression across the line ? The line is not part of the penalty box. End of.

[@garymccafferty4654]

Talking pants mate, be expecting a throw in next time an inch of the ball hits the line then eh lol. whole point in the lines is to separate from outside to in is it no?

[@jamaicanjock6305]

On that was his Jersey in the box or did he pull it in the box 📦 😮

[@jimborland2491]

Penalty or not ,at the end of the day, Celtic won , we gave it our best shot, and now we move on All the bitching about it wont change the outcome of the game So whats the point moaning about it ,it's over and done with as i said we move on 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧

[@wesleyhewitt4683]

Revered bottled it

[@yacinebouachera6134]

John Scales 😂😂

[@mickybhoy]

Nae luck celtic were not on var and yer beelin coz youz thought youz were in with a chance of winning your 2nd trophy

[@ALMH199]

They had 5 penalties ffs 🤦‍♂️ 🤣

[@Seppi710]

His toe nails are clearly in the box, stone wall toe nail penalty!!!!

[@Sa1amander71]

You should be used to losing by now - Clement telling the press to "dig into it" wtf is he smoking

[@divrangers]

U know its never getting given

[@davidspiers1747]

Wasn't a penalty simple

[@ThomasOneill-ru6et]

Shoulda, coulda, woulda 😂😂

[@Vidson67]

Fact is they check every thing no pen 😂🍀

[@andrewwilson5182]

An honest mistake

[@JohnWeldon-xu3sd]

Have a penalty on me.

[@jamaicanjock6305]

And if the baw is on tge line its a goal 😮

[@MC17350]

Who would have took it....Dessers ?

[@fritzblob]

Butland

[@bobbysutherland4700]

Never a pen 😂🏆

[@MrJSamny]

Celtic in bed with SFA facts

[@johncarlin8755]

Aye right you are .

[@DanielLoveMetallica]

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA 😂😂😂

[@a267ndy]

Penalty all day

[@DanielLoveMetallica]

😂😂😂😂

[@jamesdoran6017]

Stop greeting 😂🇮🇪🍀🏆

[@Darren.ftk.]

Never got given so clearly wasn't

[@ononewheellad]

The Celtic var team at it again.

[@JohnWeir-i4h]

Get over it daily ranger's.

[@ononewheellad]

Celtic var team cheating again.

[@lauriemiller1690]

Rangers home ground . Nae bother

[@skint26]

top ref my arse

[@johnhasbullahbeck7941]

Cheating as standard 👍🌟 didn't expect anything different n can guarantee if it was the other end of the park it woulda been given quickly 👍🌟 best team lost

[@mick268]

Ye Ragin??......aye Hahah HES RAGING!!!!

[@johnhasbullahbeck7941]

@mick268 brother walfrid was an Irish defector who robbed another mans players n business model - EVEN they're COLOURS n exposed the poor children to some serious trauma 👍🌟 your happy supporting this coz yer just as sad n just as bad 👍

[@MicahMurray-q7f]

Best team lost on penalty aye nae bother celtic had double the passes and possession more a less but best team I keep kidding yerself 😂😂

[@GrahamWilliamson-w4m]

Hun tears only made sweeter because you don't even know the rules of the game....penalty incident was irrelevant as foul was few seconds earlier in the run up....another treble incoming 💚🤍🧡

[@johnhasbullahbeck7941]

Daily record censoring the truth 👍 know yer history

[@Sa1amander71]

So the whole of a ball has to cross the line to be a goal but standing on the line of the ,penalty box means you are inside it ? - bullshit and you know it , Des - whoever you are - it's where first contact happens and you know it - seen thousands like that starting outside the box but ending inside and it's never a penalty - contact must happen and start inside the box - not outside and not on the line - same with goals or throw ins - guiding principle is completely over the line- that's why there was no var

[@ricky8399]

It’s was a great game stop cry again cause yous lost again

[@fraco7926]

🇮🇪🍀🇮🇪🍀🇮🇪🍀🇮🇪🍀🇮🇪🍀🇮🇪🍀🇮🇪🍀

[@vincentmcnabb939]

Same new Huns - always cheated and never defeated. Get it right up ye, Daily Record. How’s your sales and ad revenues this month? 😂

[@jamiedonnelly4313]

Salty tears 🥲

[@OneForTheNorth]

The foul is given for the kick before the pull, just outside the box

[@davidt510]

the pull is the foul as well though ya clown

[@rougescot81]

Pen all day long

[@Crisis-What-Crisis]

Another ragin hun 😂😂

[@johant23]

rubbish. there were two fouls a kick THEN a pull. the free kick was given for the first foul the kick

[@raymondgoldie6162]

He just said it's not clear.

[@pato2200]

"You are allowed to make a foul." ???

[@wordupcornflake]

karma