Ranking All 58 Super Bowl Winning Quarterbacks From WORST To FIRST

If you're new, Subscribe! → bit.ly/Subscribe-to-TPS
TotalProSports on Social Media:
Website: www.totalprosports.com/
Facebook: / totalprosports
Twitter: / totalprosports
Instagram: / totalprosports
For copyright matters please contact us at: [e-mail]
All images licensed through GettyImages
Host: Aaron Leger
Editor: Kyle McCormick
Writer: Jon Goldfarb

[@joschkaebel6497]

John Elway and Joe Theisman were so disgusted with this ranking, they chose to stay absent…

[@123shoshan]

This is so stupid the 2017 eagles were picked to win 7 games by most and some had them 3-13 their top receivers were Nelson agholor and Alshon Jeffries both those guys are average at best . Arguably the worst roster t ever win a Super Bowl .

[@Phil-fs4gx]

​@@123shoshanyou're not serious are you? Let's pretend having the best offensive line and an elite f7 doesn't matter...Jeffrey had a few thousand yard seasons with the bears was he top of the line? No was he still a good receiver? Yes he was. Foles didn't carry that team by any means

[@TheBigBadWolfO7]

Where are John Elway and Joe Theismann?!?! You remember Trent Dilfer and Brad Johnson but not Elway and Theismann?!

[@123shoshan]

This is so stupid the 2017 eagles were picked to win 7 games by most and some had them 3-13 their top receivers were Nelson agholor and Alshon Jeffries both those guys are average at best . Arguably the worst roster t ever win a Super Bowl

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Don't forget that Jim Plunkett threw a 99 yard touchdown pass to his hall of famer teammate Cliff Branch vs Redskins 1:24

[@Him_Slick]

This ranking is very interesting, I can't seem to figure out if you're ranking the superbowl performance themselves or the qb as a whole 😅 I pray it's the superbowl performance tho lol

[@deaniart]

Doug Williams is ranked higher than Aaron Rodgers. Therefore, I think that is Super Bowl performance and not the QB as a whole.

[@andrewgrove1691]

​@@deaniartrodgers sb win was a fluke. He hasn't dome squat since

[@rpc717]

Joe Namath and Johnny Unitas are in the bottom 5. It's impossible to imagine they're talking about overall. Then again, Doug Williams is also in the bottom half, so saying it's the Super Bowl performances doesn't hold water, either.

[@ethandegge3127]

Seriously 😂 TPS has gotten really bad

[@123shoshan]

@@deaniart This is so stupid the 2017 eagles were picked to win 7 games by most and some had them 3-13 their top receivers were Nelson agholor and Alshon Jeffries both those guys are average at best . Arguably the worst roster t ever win a Super Bowl

[@eugenemelendi1589]

In my personal opinion John Elway & Payton Manning are the best Quarterbacks ever.

[@TylerHorn-wx9eu]

Lemme guess you’re a broncos fan

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Kurt Warner had such a phenomenal underdog story from a Grocery Stocking Shelves to Super Bowl Champion now a Hall Of Famer as well 10:33

[@ShanaynayGosby]

He was a badass in the arena football

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

​@ShanaynayGosby Oh Hell Yeahhhhh he was

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

As a Steelers fan Ben Roethlisberger was a absolute winner with the Pittsburgh Steelers 1st Round 11th overall Miami of Ohio 2X Super Bowl Championships in 2005 and 2008 what a wonderful football life he's had I know i miss him but I'll see him in Canton Ohio the Pro Football Hall Of Fame it will be tremendously a homecoming for him Thank You Ben Thank You Ben Thank You Ben👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽 4:00

[@williamsummerson1204]

AMEN.

[@paulweston8408]

I wonder how many of his fans remember how close he was to being traded to the Raiders after Ben's rape allegation during the time you would rather play ANYWHERE but for Oakland and Al Davis!

[@deki120890]

John Elway???

[@freddieware7418]

2:53p What happened to John Elway?

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Jim McMahon has won two Super bowl's with two legendary greatest franchises in NFL's History 1985 Bears and 1996 Packers 1:40

[@josh_allen_17]

So do John Elway and Joes theisman j not exist?

[@mpf4114]

Earl Morrall is the best backup to win a Superbowl. Coming in relief to help the colts and Dolphins win it all

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

It's absolutely crazy as hell that Jim Plunkett doesn't gets enough credit for what he has done in his career the Heisman Trophy winner in 1970 and 1st Round 1st overall pick in the 1971 NFL Draft drafted by the Patriots but in the 1980's Mr.Plunkett got a big break while he was with the Raiders he won two Super Bowl's in 1980 and 1983 and he's not even voted or getting enough love for the Pro Football Hall Of Fame? It's Criminal like absolute Criminal 1:11

[@robfalter2522]

an interesting note about plunkett. he is the only player in nfl history to be the heisman winner , be the number1 overall draft pick and win a super bowl mvp

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

​@@robfalter2522Damn Right

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Stone Cold Steve Young was awesome in that Super Bowl to be throwing 6TD's and no interceptions excellent 11:35

[@ElKabong78]

I don't understand the criteria used to compile this list.

[@deaniart]

I believe that the performances of the quarterbacks within the Super Bowl games are considered. Nothing outside of the Super Bowl is considered. That is why Doug Williams is much higher than Aaron Rodgers. Williams had a great Super Bowl statistically and came through when it mattered.

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

R.I.P Bart Starr one the most underrated QB's of the Green Bay Packers 12:50

[@kekkomartin5848]

he is absolutely NOT!! AN NFL icon, a Packer icon and holds the record for best postseason win % and more NFL championships than any QB not named Brady Bart Starr is in no way underrated. Saying he is would be as stupid as saying Vince Lombardi is underrated.

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Joe Gibbs is the only coach in NFL's History to win all three Super Bowl's with all three different quarterbacks 6:44

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Ken the Snake Stabler was excellent in that Super Bowl vs Vikings R.I.P to the Snake he's a incredible player the best to ever do it 4:37

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Joe Flacco was splendid in the Super Bowl vs 49ers in 2012 earned Super Bowl MVP 8:26

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

R.I.P to Len Dawson if you told me that is he underrated in the best group of hall of fame quarterbacks? I'd will say absolutely because he ran Hank Stram system as well as anyone could without a doubt 11:42

[@moolah1733]

Not even watching because the comments said “no Elway” in there. What a goof 🤣

[@michaelheathington9546]

Wow how you forget Joe Theismann?

[@tawshu]

I'm sorry, where is John Elway?

[@aaronorr5586]

Still walking that Lombardi across the Las Vegas Raiders field into the hands of the Chiefs....

[@AA712Beam]

Fun Fact Plunkett is the only QB thus far to start and win multiple super bowls and not make the HOF

[@kenhill3230]

It is a shame really. When he got on a decent team he rocked.

[@Coffeeguy18]

Favre at 16 and Rodgers at 15 is criminal. Both of those guys played better than Stafford and Dawson did in the Superbowl. This feels very much like you're also taking into account the number of Superbowl's the guy played in and their career in general. So regardless not sure how Favre and Rodgers are middle of the ranking.

[@jogendron6320]

John Elway went to 5 Super Bowls and won 2. He’s not there.

[@King-zs1ny]

Bruh the guy was getting a lot of numbers wrong he said Steve Young won super bowl 49 when it was 29 and Eli Won Super Bowl 44 when it was 46 lol. He also forgot to list super bowl 55 for Tom Brady

[@BiscuitsOfWrath]

dude really said Troy Aikman was drafted in 1999 😂 I think he meant 1989

[@rpc717]

For the FIFTH TIME, it's Earl "Moral," not Earl " Morale."

[@glass_oni0n]

This is genuinely one of the most nonsensical videos I’ve ever seen on the internet. What’s the methodology for this list? Brad Johnson and Jeff Hostetler over Joe Namath and Johnny Unitas? Nick Foles over Ben Roethlisberger and Ken Stabler? Matt Stafford over Brett Favre and Aaron Rodgers?? You malign Namath and Stabler’s INT’s yet rate Terry Bradshaw 6th? Eli Manning in the top 5 over Drew Brees, Bart Starr and just about every HOFer just mentioned? This list is shockingly bad, to the point where you I’m 95% certain you’ve just forgotten John Elway, possibly a top 10 QB to ever play the game. No one should view this list or the person (bot?) who made it as having any credibility. Believe you’ve forgotten Joe Theismann as well, 34 QBs have won the SB not 32. Good god man, you should really be embarrassed by this.

[@BravesAvsFan]

Good video, but you made 3 errors. First, Jeff Hostetler didn’t throw any interceptions in Super Bowl 25. Next, Eli Manning’s second Super Bowl win was in Super Bowl 46, not 44. And finally, you left out Tom Brady’s victory in Super Bowl 55, his lone Super Bowl with the Bucs.

[@Eddieavina123]

First, hi, love your video TPS and keep up the great work you are awesome

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Brett Favre the OG of Gunslingers 9:14

[@spencersquires3858]

Yeah find it crazy that I didn’t see John Elway on here hahah this ranking.

[@jesseshort6278]

Aikman was drafted in 89 not 1999

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

It's tremendously nice and satisfying the fact that Nick Foles was the one who saved the Eagles 2017 season when Carson Wentz got hurt vs Rams but they went to the Super Bowl and they got the job done thanks to the Philly Special that was the icing on the cake on the big stage on a 4th and 1 play Job Well Done Mr.Foles and he earned Super Bowl MVP too 5:20

[@jordangrimes7820]

Stafford being that high with 3 touchdowns and 2 interceptions is wild this guy dumbbbbb

[@ajanitor4981]

If I recall he was battling injuries that game maybe that’s why

[@youthinkyoureallthatbutyou7270]

one of those was a total arm punt tho

[@spidamitchell8311]

Can make excuses for everyone and Stafford had 2 tds 1 to kupp and one to obj

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Joe Willie Namath said were gonna win the game I Guarantee it 1968 with the Jets 2:00

[@FEL_Official]

"Nick Foles, Brad Johnson, and Jeff Hosteler are all better QBs than Johnny Unitas." -TPS 2024

[@benmurawski]

Great video!

[@williamsummerson1204]

No it wasn't.

[@scarefrow1]

Elway?

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

NFL's Comeback Player Of the year Joe Flacco 2023 8:44

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Trent Dilfer may have won the Super Bowl in the 2000's season but the Ravens Defense is the reason why cause while Mr.Dilfer scores touchdowns Ray Lewis and the defense takes care of business 0:40

[@limesareprettycool]

god

[@edgarcorrales2943]

Joe Montana should be number 1, he put up some ridiculous numbers in the super bowls he played in (1142 yards 11TDs no ints and a ridiculous 127.8 passer rating), not to mention he went undefeated in the big game. I completely understand that Brady went to a ridiculous 10 ABs winning 7 of them and that is pretty impressing as well, that and long as he's other accolades is want makes him the GOAT, but if you rank them only for what they did in the Super Bowl Monatan should be ahead of Brady.

[@ShanaynayGosby]

Im glad that they said super bowl 44 for mt saints usually people say super bowl 42 and im like bruv you should be ashamed

[@msarzo]

It's RIP-IN, not RIPE-IN

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Drew Brees will be in the Hall Of Fame he's the only quarterback in NFL's History to throw for 5000 passing yards 5 times on 5 occasions 13:25

[@kenhill3230]

It is insane when you think about Brady's accomplishments. When you look at most "Dynasty" teams they were loaded with Hall of Famers. Brady did not have that level of talent around him.

[@zachsmith3685]

You did miss TB12’s Super Bowl 55. But as a Chiefs fan, I’m okay with that omission 😢

[@13BC30]

Please put the black on white TPS background element into the “Do Not Use” folder.

[@lucasandrews578]

Your list seems pretty valid. You got the Mt. Rushmore of Peyton, Mahomes, Montana, and Brady correct.

[@123shoshan]

This is so stupid the 2017 eagles were picked to win 7 games by most and some had them 3-13 their top receivers were Nelson agholor and Alshon Jeffries both those guys are average at best . Arguably the worst roster to ever win a Super Bowl

[@BrandonCultraroGamerVideo33194]

A good video idea: every NFL’s teams’ best team to not win the super bowl

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Before Tom Brady there was Joe Montana 4-0 in Super Bowl's as well with 3 Super Bowl MVP's 16:26

[@RBSmada]

Brady won so many you didn’t even remember them all

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Bob Griese was part of the Perfect Season in 1972 17-0 Dolphins 8:50

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Eli Manning always has always was always will be the only QB in NFL's History to beat one of the greatest coach and the greatest QB of all time not once but twice in the Super Bowl's like come on now there's no damn debate whatsoever as to why Eazy-E still owns the Patriots to this day enough said 14:42

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Nothing said"s Black History Month without Doug Williams the best HBCU player of all time 1st Round 12th overall Grambling State 1978 NFL Draft the first ever Black QB to start in the Super Bowl the first Black QB to win Super Bowl MVP phenomenal journey to this day he's still is the best 6:24

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Troy Aikman 3-0 Super Bowl's of the 1990's all with the Cowboys 1st Round 1st overall pick UCLA in the 1989 NFL Draft 13:55

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Patrick MaHomes quite simply put the ABSOLUTE BEST 15:58

[@alexdeanda1838]

There's no way Flacco is better than Big Ben or Russell Wilson

[@doctornonsense4726]

Brad Johnson over Broadway Joe?

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Roger Staubach great excellent player Roger the Dodger be able to escape pressure won the Heisman Trophy at University of Navy so Thank you for your splendid service 12:18

[@adamthespinygiant]

Finally. Eli Manning gets some respect.

[@jasonbrooks3219]

Wow, this video is full of mistakes. John Elway was completely skipped, and i am pretty sure Troy was drafted long before 1999. Quality Control guy needs a reduction in pay with all these mistakes.

[@geroldtjadenjr.9621]

It is rip-un like "rip" paper in half!

[@BigLamarWilsonSr]

What about every teams most underrated wide receiver 🤔

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Peyton Manning still is my all time all F'N time greatest quarterbacks in NFL's History the 1st Round 1st overall pick University of Tennessee Volunteers Alumni by the Colts 1998 NFL Draft 15:33

[@erichgobills1016]

I don’t think there were any turnovers in Super Bowl XXV

[@laserxman779sports]

In the playoffs Joe Flacco is like Eli manning mid in the regular season but more then good in the playoffs delivers when it matters most he get too much hate for his mid requalar season play

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Tom Brady a 7X Super Bowl Winner he's the G.O.A.T not much else to say it but you already know 16:38

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Matthew Stafford will always have always is always will absolutely be the heart and soul of the Detroit Lions 1st Round 1st overall pick University of Georgia from 2009 to 2020 but in 2021 he went to LA Rams but won Super Bowl vs Bengals well deserve Mr.Stafford 10:15

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

As a Steelers fan Terry Bradshaw is 4-0 Super Bowl's of the 1970's a 1st Round 1st overall University of Louisiana Tech the man the myth the icon the legendary Steelers quarterback 14:08

[@mattherat13]

Where is John elway???

[@LamarBragg]

Brady over Montana is a travisty. Montana never threw an interception, never needed his kicker and everyone was a blowout. Brady got MVP because his kickers won his games

[@kooperuranus1503]

😂 16 to 20 over the Bengals is not a blowout.

[@dennis8683]

Aikman was drafted in 1999 but shaped the Cowboys 90's dynasty? Do you guys even proof read your scripts? 🤡🤡

[@sherwood1897]

Do this but with running backs

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

2007 and 2011 I might add 14:44

[@dontmindmeimjustspectating2871]

If its about ranking QBs to win the super bowl then Unitas should be way above Nick Foles but if youre ranking the performances Nick Foles needs to be alot higher so like...

[@sportstalk3513]

Rank every Super Bowl mvp

[@jameswhite4874]

Normally you guys are good at this stuff snd the details. But you just said troy Aikman was drafted in 99 and then went on to dominate the 90s.

[@brianvanasse7627]

Brady won Super Bowl 55 so why wasn’t it mentioned

[@jasonanderson3111]

Need to rank superbowl mvp

[@That1guySteven]

You forgot john elway

[@av2018]

The Aaron Rodgers disrespect is absurd. He’s top 5 at the very least. Oh, and he’ll take those damn Jets to win 59 and 60 the next two seasons. You can bank on that! Suck it, Packers

[@jogendron6320]

1. Jets suck. Enjoy losing for another 50 years. 2. Elway > Rodgers all day and #7 isn’t even on the list. 3. Rodgers has a great video on here, his Jets highlights, lasts 28 seconds I think 😂😂😂😂 4. J-E-T-S suck suck suck 5. There’s no way Rodgers is top 5, not even top 10. 6. Did I mention the Jets suck? 7. In case I didn’t: JETS SUCK.

[@michaelhillberry672]

Nick Foles is better than Ben Roethlisberger? HAHAHAHAHA

[@simoncohen9323]

Wtf is this list 99 petcent of these picks make no sense

[@daryltippens7932]

How the hell do they forget 2x Super Bowl champion & MVP John Elway? All time top 5 QB and somehow completely missed. Genuinely, the dumbest video ever released without any QC

[@jfrancis2768]

where the hell is Elway and Theismann?

[@MohammedKhaja-dn4qe]

Differ receives a bit too much hate.

[@user-zi8nx2hm8y]

Yall disrespecting Jim plunkett

[@johnyang1731]

Foles ranked above Big Ben?

[@jonathangustavsson577]

you guy forgot super bowl 55

[@dylankaemingk8550]

How is Nick Foles ahead of Big Ben.

[@Kauhl2912]

Y’all missed Brady’s 7th Super Bowl lol

[@MultiSkins4life]

Where were John Elway and Joe Theisman?! Also this list is laughable at times!

[@AlejandroHernandez-lv2eb]

And John elway

[@ellamartindale9734]

Bro say 53 but it’s 55

[@Liam-zu3yz]

Steve young had over 300 yards and 6 TDs and doesn’t make top 10?

[@jogendron6320]

Ask 5-time Super Bowl participant, 2 x winner and 1 x MVP John Elway what he thinks of the list! 😂

[@donaldwilliams5979]

How is Stafford over Rodgers

[@icomplainalot533]

Was there not enough room to add the 7th superbowl?

[@CODY--]

Tom Brady won so many Superbowl's there was not enough on the graphic to list them all, (G.O.A.T.).

[@neutral6941]

Montana should be 1st. He is undefeated in superbowls. Brady should be 2nd because he lost a couple of superbowls. Yes he won more but he lost 2 I think, he isn't undefeated in superbowls.

[@jogendron6320]

Elway should at least be on the list. 🤷‍♂️