Ranking All Earth Island Monsters! [Remastered] (My Singing Monsters)

[@rossmair6862]

I wonder, would you consider ranking every MSM Island? That would be fun

[@FiddlementMSM]

Or ranking every monster

[@itsjustanoob]

@@FiddlementMSMthat would take too long

[@FiddlementMSM]

@@itsjustanoob I can wait

[@jasonlung1557]

4:33 Ah, Yes. Nobody was singing "TALKER" tracks..

[@Mosiee-u5m]

This guy has got to be my favourite msm ytber. i just randomly saw if now i can't stop watching him.

[@MrMcSirMan]

Let this man rank again 🗣🔥

[@TruDoesStuff22]

7:22 matt shea is questioning his life now

[@Reebro58992]

imo 1.Epic Wubbox👑 2.Reedling🟣 3.Hyehehe🟣 4 & 5.Hoola and PomPom🟣 6.Dipsters🟡 7 & 8.Tawkerr and Stoowarb🟡 9.Rare Wubbox🟡 10 & 11.Furcorn and Dandidoo🟡 12.Tweedle🟡 13.Potbelly🔵 14.Mammott🔵 15.Clamble🔵 16.Quarrister🔵 17.Humbug🟢 18.Noggin🟢 19.Wubbox🟢 20.Drumpler🟠 21.Shrubb🟠 22.Thumpies🟠 23.Humbug🔴 24.Colossal🔴 25.Pango🔴

[@TheClodsire]

My ranking: 25/24: Hoola/PomPom 🟥: They both completely ruin the song. 23: Noggin 🟧: Does practically nothing. 22. Shrubb 🟧: Unnecessary side percussion 21. Pango 🟧: Slightly better unnecessary side percussion 20. Colossal 🟧: Adds a bit of suspense like it does on every island 19. Humbug 🟩: Not a bad sound. It just gets drowned out by epic wubbox. 18. Thumpies 🟩: I really like thumpies on earth. They would be way higher if they played more. 17. Tweedle 🟩: Pretty solid vocalist 16. Potbelly 🟩: Sounds great with mammott but mid without. 15. Dandidoo 🟩: Creates a fire melody and is like a backup singer to furcorn. 14. Furcorn 🟩: Carries the furcorn/dandidoo duet. 13. Epic Wubbox 🟦: HOT TAKE. Epic wubbox doesn't exactly ruin the song, but IT DROWNS OUT EVERYTHING. This monster is the reason why people can't hear humbug. Its sound is very good though. 12. Wubbox 🟦: Another hot take. The wubbox goes hard on every island and its loud dubstep fits in perfectly somehow. 11. Cybop 🟦: Carries the third verse before hyehehe and is still straight fire. 10. Dipsters 🟦: One of the best dipsters, very good melody. 9. Mammott 🟨: The backbone to the whole song. 8. Tawkerr 🟨: Both werdos are fantastic on earth, but stoowarb is slightly better. 7. Stoowarb 🟨: Both werdos are fantastic on earth, but stoowarb is slightly better. 6. Rare Wubbox 🟨: This is one of the greatest rare wubbox tracks ever. Its sound is straight fire and fits perfectly into earth island. 5. Clamble 🟪: Clamble and Drumpler HARD CARRY THIS ISLAND. These were the last two naturals i got on earth and i was blown away by how much they carry. 4. Drumpler 🟪: Clamble and Drumpler HARD CARRY THIS ISLAND. These were the last two naturals i got on earth and i was blown away by how much they carry. 3. Quarrister 🟪: I think everyone knows why this is here. No explanation needed. 2. Hyehehe 🟪🟪: These two carry the melody so hard that they deserve double purple tier. 1. Reedling 🟪🟪: These two carry the melody so hard that they deserve double purple tier. Reedling does get the edge over hyehehe, but just BARELY. Overall ranking: 7/10

[@PorygonBugado]

The other singles go crazy on their respective islands, clackula, fluoress, Kayna ghazt, reebro, etc. (with of course some exceptions) And then theres noggin wich plays 1 note

[@NickTheFlasque]

3:27 the third track literally just being plant island mammott:

[@Battle_brawlstar]

THE HUMBUG DISRESPECT IS INSANE

[@Shrimpotheangry]

I can't hear him

[@rivinduweerasinghe8504]

Better than his ranking video future fricking flamed on that guy

[@Playerano8isntcool]

It is quiet, so it’s valid

[@Playerano8isntcool]

Personally, I’d put it higher

[@MrMcSirMan]

He sounds good on his own, but you can't hear him in the song.

[@kuziperales2471]

Ngl, Dipsters being in Gold is like getting 3 Epics back 2 back or Z'rt being Number 1. (And by Gold, I mean them being in Gold Tier)

[@Toonanproductionzcrewc5315]

Did you SERIOUSLY just say Z’RT?

[@Thatonesticko]

Watching this two minutes before school goes crazy

[@flaviaanglarillmendez3790]

Video Idea: Rank every collosal

[@FutureProGamer90]

I would go mentally insane

[@flaviaanglarillmendez3790]

@@FutureProGamer90 All collosals: *Red Tier*

[@fakemickeymouse]

I love your ratings :)

[@c4r3na-s]

I feel bad for humbug ngl

[@Shrimpotheangry]

I can't even hear humbug he's is a cute monster and awesome sounding but TOO QUIET

[@PentumbraMSM105]

Personally I really like Humbug, but like C'mon man, he's quieter then the Thumpies. That's saying something

[@thestewartfam6333]

Humbug and cybop should be top 7 monsters in this ranking

[@BuzzOffInga]

Yeah maybe in your ranking

[@FalseAmazook]

@@thestewartfam6333 that's your opinion, they have a different one

[@thestewartfam6333]

Why are you gooning

[@thestewartfam6333]

Earth island is the best island in msm. IMO 15 of the 25 monsters go in g.o.a.t.s tier, and 4 go in perfect, cybop, hyehehe, reedling, and epic wubbox.

[@Aguywhodoestuff]

Its suprising how Humbug was one of the lowest ranking monsters ever to rising above the red tier

[@rubenmartinquevedo9508]

W rating love your videos

[@DaTruelyRealTeeterTauter]

I think tawkerr. Stoowarb. And Epic wubbox are goated. Because I remember the do the earthquake memes

[@rarewubcoolbox]

Imo 1-reedling 2-quarristers 3-hyehehe 4-mammott 5-cybop 6-dipsters 7-pompom 8-stoowarb 9-tawkerr 10-epic wubbox 11-rare wubbox 12-wubbox 13-hoola 14-colosall 15-furcorn 16-dandidoo 17-potbelly 18-clamble 19-drumpler 20-tweedle 21-shrubb 22-pango 23-thumpies 24-noggin 25-humbug

[@Sawyer_Harding972]

“Humbug is the most quiet Ethereal” Boodoo and Mirror Earth Island:👽

[@mrsgbrandi]

0:40 i never knew colossals could be orange tier

[@JaxLacasandile]

Reedling in Water: Eh Reedling in earth: REAL SHIT

[@nosemajbub]

you know the song is goated when theres 7 monsters in yellow tier

[@banjaw-m6i]

So about that question on what island i should recreate in composer You said faerie.... But the problem is that i have already done faerie island So that is not an option (Also fire haven and earth island)

[@FutureProGamer90]

Cold island

[@banjaw-m6i]

@@FutureProGamer90 great pick! I'll be working on it!

[@Noggin-msm-u6p]

this is fire, good luck i have my extingisher 🧯

[@jmiguelcaraballocalderon]

7:22 wow totaly inexpected

[@chespeppermint]

i agree with the ranking, but you gotta admit humbug sounds good on his own

[@Ganaball]

You know an island is good when even the colossal sound decent

[@spoiledmilk404]

Ranking in my opinion: 25/24: Stoowarb/Tawkerr 🟥 I already don’t like English-speaking monsters, but I hate the werdos specifically because that’s literally their whole purpose 23: Noggin 🟧 This isn’t bad, it’s just lame. Probably the lamest percussion in MSM 22: Humbug 🟧 Most unhearable thing 21: Shrubb 🟧 Ironic how Future likes it here and not any other island, but for me it’s the opposite 20: Pango 🟧 Basic 19: Drumpler 🟩 Also basic, but less basic 18: Thumpies 🟩 :| 17: Colossal 🟩 The best colossal, I think colossal are okay 16: Potbelly 🟩 okay 15: Wubbox 🟩 It ruins the vibe unless you have Epic Wubbox 14: Dandidoo 🟩 Huh, neat 13: Furcorn 🟦 I like Furcorn as a monster, doesn’t really sound bad on any islands 12: Hoola 🟦 It’s cool, but this is the only island Hoola should be on, nothing more 11: Pompom 🟦 Nice 10: Cybop 🟦 I like the effect it has, and it sounds good in the song too, a little bit of pepper to it 9: Mammott 🟦 bom badom badom 🔥🔥 8: Rare Wubbox 🟦 Plays short, but it’s this high because a lot of monsters do 7: Clamble 🟦 If they weren’t on this island, it would be so boring 6: Tweedle 🟨 I like this, it adds some salt to the song 5: Epic Wubbox 🟨 Sounds amazing, so good that it improves other monsters like Wubbox 4: Dipsters 🟨 Carry the whole song, better than they sound on all the other natural islands 3: Reedling 🟨 Adds some more… garlic (im running out of metaphors involving spices) 2: Hyehehe 🟨 Overrated, but carries the song, especially with headphones 1: Quarrister 🟪 It feels like im doing a heroic journey in the depths of a volcano, I love it and you gotta love it to (im just kidding do whatever you want)

[@bomapetite_wublin]

Bro cooked, congratulations

[@Maygore]

One thing i dislike about Earth Island is how empty it sounds without the Epic Wubbox

[@jormdeworm]

Reedling on top? Instant upvote, I approve

[@Flute_doggo35]

BRO DROPPED A NEW RANKING🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@ultimaglitchonyt]

My problem with Humbug is that IT SOUNDS GOOD, but it would help if I could HEAR IT.

[@1614rich]

My favorites on earth island are Noggin, Drumpler, epic wubbox, Hyehehe, quarrister and tweedle

[@rivinduweerasinghe8504]

Starting a new tier list the mirror island tier list because future i dont think plans to rank the mirror island monsters bc they are the exact same but timing matters soooo Mirror earth island: 🟠Noggin first off his animation bugged and that just really sucks not only that but one sound is all he does and it's not special but not bad 🟠shrubb feel like you got more inaudible is that just me? Atleast he's alright.. at the end 🟠Thumpies congrats dude your audible still not that good but audible! 🟢 potbelly don't see the love in him in this island he does help the end tho and that's good enough to be in green 🟢pango I like pango on this island! Does it make sense that he's on this island? No- and that is why we love him 🟢drumpler second track is amazing the first not so much but atleast his animations are good and he still has a good beat 🟢mammoth you're amazing on regular earth island but you don't do alot here bud im sorry- still not anywhere bad tho! 🔵clamble just cooks here dude I don't know what the transitions would be without them it would sound horrible 🔵pompom she repeats her first track saying yippity yay yippity yay in most of the song is it good yes is it kinda annoying also yes.. but still good 🔵hoola similar to pompom but still manages to sound better by singing less. Less is more guys! 🔵hyehehe it's does its jump as build really well and does still have the catchy feel to it my only criticism is it plays it's second track too early 🔵tweedle oh my gosh the redemption is real for this one I hated and still do kinda hate tweedle on regular earth island here it just works- 🔵 and🔵 furcorn&dandidoo they both work really work well for this island just everywhere and just earn this spot 🔵dipsters Let's goo guys your not bad on this island you rolled a nat 20 is what I would say if the dipsters weren't just good on practically every island they are on except for haven and psychic 🔵rare wubbox yep he to me just cant sound bad in any song that he is in and regular earth islands rare wubbox was already my second fav rare wub so obv he would be this high he still sounds amazing 🟡cybop yep we hit goat tier already and im not afraid to say cybop works on every mirror island he's on even air surprisingly and this is no exception i mean look at him 🟡humbug i do not care for any criticism for this yall he is audible FINALLY and makes the song sound 5x better in my opinion he sounds like an earth quake alarm i cant be the only one who hears this T-T 🟡quarrister i mean what else is there to say other than he makes all the songs that he's in apart of the halo soundtrack i feel like im being carries to be executed when i hear this thing 🟡&🟡steewarb and tawkerr they carry the song for me and literally no one can disagree with me otherwise "do the earthquake!" just would be a thing and yes that still applies on mirror- 🟡Reedling the good puppy!!! He sounds amazing on mirror water and earth aswell def still caries but we got more 🟡epic wubbox the heart and soul of both earth islands without him we wouldnt be hearing the clanging and banging of construction noises as we do the earth quake and also the fact that goes 🛥🛥🛥 🟣common wubbox YOO WHAT THE HECK- listen to the one before the last verse of this island and you can just hear the rumbling of earth island from this dude he just carries he is just the goat he makes this island more earth island than regular earth island (Was that a good ranking guys did i do good i feel like i disappointed a few of yall but im open to a few suggestions except im not moving humbug no-) 🟡9/10 island- it's an amazing island even has story to it if your as imaginative as me some parts however could use some work but overall amazing onto water-

[@Playerano8isntcool]

2:02 Gorillaz 19-2000 shoeshine verse’s background chorus ahh voice

[@GoombossPro]

Fr

[@ratbabysgamingsquad4236]

Never let bro rank agai- GET OUTT 🗣️🔥🗣️🔥

[@mrsgbrandi]

My opinion on earth island: so many monsters fit the vibe andit sounds great

[@mrsgbrandi]

*talker and stewart* ☠️

[@JustA-RandomBoy]

Honestly I agree earth epic Wubbox is overrated but I think it actually deserves it, plain Enchantling doesn’t add much and over shadows every other monster making them inaudible.

[@mrsgbrandi]

Do water island next

[@Ganaball]

Rare and Epic Reedling are 2 more monsters added to the pill of monsters that want crowns

[@MSMthealtfire1234]

Rare reedling and epic reedling: where’s are crowns?

[@kurstonSewlal]

can you pls rank plant island played by ethereals pls

[@FutureProGamer90]

@@kurstonSewlal no

[@PlatonAltei]

Noggin carries the beat with Drumpler and Clamble

[@Vhenshun_Inc]

Are you going to rank Light?

[@FutureProGamer90]

Yes

[@NeK0xEVIL]

I mean humbug is quiet as hell but second to last is 💀

[@Peypey-wn4fr]

You. Can hear humbug but you just gotta find him in the song

[@Gabegeukzum]

Do you have an IF? (like the movie IF)

[@FutureProGamer90]

No

[@Gabegeukzum]

@@FutureProGamer90 I mean as a kid. (like who did you believe was with you)

[@FutureProGamer90]

@@Gabegeukzum that’s literally the whole point of the movie. You don’t know who it is

[@Gabegeukzum]

@@FutureProGamer90 did you know the composer of IF also composed the music from the incredibles?

[@mrsgbrandi]

7:49 2 more monsters want crowns now

[@Takakkei12]

Humbug is one of my most disliked monsters, no wonder I call its element booger

[@Ty1er7h3borkbork]

My Earth Island Ranking: Bad 25: Earth Island Epic Wubbox (Reason: I know I’m probably gonna be infamous in the MSM fandom for this, but it’s too damn overrated, 1, its tracks (especially the percussion) get repetitive quickly (mostly because dude plays throughout the second half of the song), 2, and this guy drowns out Humbug and Noggin, 3. Please respect my opinion) 24: Thumpies (Reason: A quieter, almost inaudible version of Mammott) 23: Noggin (Reason: No way an Earth Island ranking where Noggin isn’t last? Well, it’s better than the other two because you can at least try to hear the melody. Duets well with Drumpler, though) 20: Colossal (Reason: Earth Island may be the most overrated Natural Island, but I guess it does a good job with the song? Would be in the orange tier if it was a tad quieter) Okay (Spoiler: it’s mostly just copycats) 19 and 18: Dandidoo and Furcorn (Reason: Similar sounds. A bit too similar…) 16: Mammott (Reason: Louder, vocal version of Thumpies) Good 15: Clamble (Reason: This is why Earth Island’s transitions are good! Surprising, coming from a quiet monster) 14: Rare Wubbox (Reason: Another overrated Wubbox, but I’ll give it a pass for sounding good and playing throughout the first bit of the song without getting repetitive) 13: Tweedle (Reason: Maggie Park really did a home run with the vocals! That’s kinda it tho) 12: Humbug (Reason: Quiet, but when you get and zoom into him, the sound is not only unique, but also super crafty) 11: Potbelly (Reason: Pretty good, that’s about it) Great 10: Wubbox (Reason: Dubstep really can pull off quite a surprise. Its animations also did it some more justice!) 9: Quarrister (Reason: Really good choir! The Wimmzies wish they were these guys) 8: Drumpler (Reason: Not only is the first track just a louder (albeit somewhat offbeat) version of Noggin), the second track goes HARD! Noggin wishes he was this guy) 7: Pompom (Reason: Three cheers for the most overrated Natural Island! Its sound is good tho) GOATs 6: Hyehehe (For the penultimate Mythical, QwinnQwerty really knew what to do. Fans loved his addition to the song!) 5: Hoola (Reason: Mostly just here because she’s the first Epic Seasonal I got) 4: Shrubb (Reason: I just find beatboxing enjoyable, okay?) 3: Cybop (Reason: Who gave this man permission to carry at the end of the song?! Oh, the Monster Handlers did? Okay sorry) 2: The Werdos (Stoowarb and Tawkerr) (Reason: It’s a tie for best vocals for this island! Seriously get these guys on Earth Island and your mind will be blown) PERFECT! 1: Reedling (Reason: Do I even need to explain? This guys plays throughout the whole song, does amazing duets, and he even has an adorable design! I love this guy, and if you guys don’t like Earth Island Reedling, I respect your opinion)

[@saraelliott9436]

I protect humbug every day

[@MagentaMagenta20th]

Earth Island Wubbox is underrated IMO

[@CoveyMeepingsHere80]

Which one? The epic or rare or just the wubbox

[@MagentaMagenta20th]

@@CoveyMeepingsHere80 the common one. That's the reason I only wrote Wubbox

[@CoveyMeepingsHere80]

@@MagentaMagenta20th ah okay I feel the same for you opinion

[@Boiky_Cheezooks]

I wish humbug was more audible in some way

[@rivinduweerasinghe8504]

Future are we ever per chance getting a mirror island ranking? I dont mean the monsters i mean the islands in general

[@FutureProGamer90]

@@rivinduweerasinghe8504 yes at some point

[@rivinduweerasinghe8504]

​@@FutureProGamer90okay noicee

[@mrsgbrandi]

Fun fact: the only rare natural i need on this island is rare dandidoo

[@martinamatzner573]

Ranking Random Monsters part 2 staring with noggin 1. Blue or yellow tier Actually Fire heaven noggin is Fire🔥🔥2.Tribal blue tier I guess? Also plays trough the hole song 3.Fearie this noggin has a unused track thar is why it's high green tier still idk dude 4.bone island green tier plays through the hole song 5.Plant island green tier idk where to put it 6.Water island idk green tier 7.Air island okay tier actually............... BRO COPIED PLANT ISLAND 8.gold island okay tier Idk where to put it 9.Earth island okay tier but it's boring bruh Btw (PLS don't comment don't let bro cook again on Noggin I just don't know where to put these noggins and also let me know in the comments what I should change btw because I might Rerank some monsters in part 3!

[@lunabluefifteenXD]

Msmkaua will be mad if he saw humbug disrespect

[@martinamatzner573]

My opinion 8/10 Pretty fire🔥🔥 But song is so short and I don't like Stoowarb on this island It's a pretty good Natrual island😎😎😎😎😎

[@tibby4503]

I love this island

[@rivinduweerasinghe8504]

0:40 AYYY TOLD YOU M8 this one isnt that bad

[@Legoswampert190]

Technically noggin plays on Beats 1 and 3

[@watermelonecatto]

MSMKAUA!!! WE SUMMON YOU!

[@mrsgbrandi]

0:13 deserved red tier

[@osvaldoandresgamarrasuarez9319]

Agreed.

[@Egg7751]

My fav in this island: Epic earth wubbox (DO THE EARTHQUAKE) My Mid fav in this island:Drumpler (Track 1 is boring tho but track 2 is banger) My least fav in this island:Humbug,Colossal and Thumpies (Humbug is really quiet and you cant hear it,Colossal I hate all of the colossals I even closed my colossals! And thumpies when you gonna stop copy Mammot?)

[@mrsgbrandi]

5:51 how about tribal island

[@mrsgbrandi]

7:54 you said reedling has never been this good before Ranking continent: continent reedling was the best reedling in your opinon

[@Cybop1234]

I wouldn’t but 6/10 at a blue tier, I’d only do that to 8/10 and up

[@ShooterEx]

Werdos this high is a criminal offense, literally the worst monsters ever added to the game except Rare Stogg.

[@Joyful2967]

dip dip dip DIP! DIP! DIP!!!!

[@gaithaljaf5906]

HUMBUG HATE BEING CRAZY🗣️🔥🔥🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥

[@tibby4503]

???

[@FiddlementMSM]

I did and still do 😢 4:22

[@deadchannelagainaeeerrrrrr6047]

Humbug slander

[@PeckidnaPlayz]

Okay tier ? I thought red tier?

[@tigger4al]

7:49

[@NooniOfficial]

STEWART??????

[@AxureAcrobat]

Dandidoo should be in last

[@Flyingcow-animations]

0:37 boodoo:

[@NooniOfficial]

TALKER??????

[@NOTEBOOK_foreva]

how about you rank ALL the monsters 😊

[@FutureProGamer90]

No

[@Justshay123]

@@FutureProGamer90lol

[@NOTEBOOK_foreva]

@@FutureProGamer90 aw at least bing back fanmade Friday

[@Enderchomp0968]

Reedling solos

[@Thecyanpult]

reedlings overrated

[@Sonic_8109]

Bro you are running out of ideas so you are remastered your videos bruh

[@1614rich]

@@Sonic_8109 dude opinions change that’s why videos get remastered

[@EathenGaming]

​@@1614rich absolutely!

[@Sonic_8109]

Yeah you're right ​@@1614rich

[@FutureProGamer90]

@@Sonic_8109 or there’s something called “opinions” that can change over time but it’s not like you would know that kid with your sonic pfp. You probably don’t even know what multiplication is

[@Sonic_8109]

@@FutureProGamer90 are you blind I said right

[@mrsgbrandi]

75th liked