Ranking All Islands in MSM in Order

[@BluDr3w]

potbelly and maw are always just consistently so good

[@fledbeast5783]

I think people dislike Shanty because of bad memories, for a while basically every monster was a vocal singer, so it was wildly imbalanced.

[@-_Blitz_-]

That yippity yay thing sounds soooooo baaaaaaad

[@whatswrongwithmybrain]

If i had one word to describe hoola on that island it would be the word gay.

[@lizzierainejimenez4615]

😢but it was my favorite island 🥺😞😔

[@wsgn8740]

@@whatswrongwithmybrain LOLL

[@ballsexisking]

People don't dislike gold island typically and that island is painful.

[@DinoDylan1118]

Fairy island was okay, but now it is so good! I loved fairy island since it released

[@Rinnpochi]

As someone who likes all the islands (except party), I respect your opinion ! About Space Island being underrated is so real, like some people don't Even know it exists, it's very beautiful and i can also Say this is my favorite island

[@GaboliaGames]

Uuuh another party island hater kid🙄 Grow up and get a life

[@rizekaijouku]

My theory about the reason why Shugabush island looka like plant island is because the monsters helped Sugarbush set up a concert on plant island

[@Hamza27632]

Could be possible if you think about it

[@obnoluke]

i love how for ethereal island there’s just no explanation at all lmao

[@BudgetGames69]

That 1 guy 0.00001 seconds after a new island releases: oH, wHeReS tHiS iSlAnD, yOu FoRgOt ThIs IsLaNd-

[@WeaverIsCool11]

Most people are going to hate this list because they have not played the game. A completionist has listened to the song many times and regards how enjoyable it was to be on the island and it’s mechanics compared to just the sound and looks. Some of these are a little harsh in my book, but as a player I agree a little more

[@makbran3627]

We are all entitled to our own opinions. I’ve completed almost every island and agree with only half of this list, but that doesn’t make it invalid.

[@Idontnoesanymore]

I have and I still hate it. (Kinda cuz some are pretty good opinions to me.)

[@leirot3460]

He put my favorite island in the last 😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@KaijuEdits875]

​​@@leirot3460ro same Faerie is amazing

[@KaijuEdits875]

Bro*

[@MightyBlox214]

I actually am very glad that there is someone who finally doesn’t hate Seasonal Shanty. I like the song, and I can see why people hate it. One reason being that some monsters don’t really fit that well together.

[@beacon3359]

The only reason is that the island sounds horrible and it makes my ears bleed. Especially with that annoying yIpPiTy yAy yIpPiTy yO

[@NinjaMelon]

​@@beacon3359 thats the reason why the island is good its the YiPitY Yay YipIti yO

[@wekindaspell7188]

Its a good song but spurrit just makes it’s rating go lower

[@beacon3359]

@@NinjaMelon your not human. How tf can you find that voice "good". Unless you just simp for her.

[@ballsexisking]

It's really hard to make a song out of vocals only. The island improves a little when bookworm and clavavera were added.

[@lcajueiro]

My top 5: #5: Wublin island This island is so good. Wubbox carries it, and it’s chaotic nature is amazing. Every wublin (except creepuscule, screw you) contributes a ton to the song, and there are very little bad parts. #4: Gold island This song is amazing simply because of furcorn. The intro is also very good. I don’t know what to say other then it’s just a good island. #3: Cave island This song is extremely underrated. The 2nd best beat drop in the entire franchise. Every part is unique, and I love how chaotic it is. #2: Magical sanctum This song used to be the #1 spot, but a recent island has dethroned it, barely. Nonetheless, this song is beautiful. Every monster contributes a ton, and enchantling is SO GOOD. Carrilong also made an S tier island even better, and it’s final verse is amazing. Onto #1. #1: Amber island Remember on cave island where I said it was the 2nd best beat drop in the whole franchise? This is the reason it’s #2. This island is hated a ton and I don’t know why. Most monsters contribute a ton, it’s an amazing beat drop, no bad parts, and overall a bop. This song used to be #2, but with the addition of Gnarls and the extension, it has been bumped up to #1. This island’s monsters are amazing, have cool designs, and an actually somewhat reliable way to get shards. The crucible is also a very fun feature, and same with the waves mechanic. This island would not be nearly as fun had all monsters been available at all times. I love how big blue bubble was able to completely destroy the community’s thoughts with the quints, and twist them. For example, we all thought the plant quint was gonna be some big guy that had a flute sound. Instead, it was this giant tree with parasites attached to it with a choir-type sound. Same with tuskski. This island is phenomenal, and I could go on for hours about how good it is. However, this comment is getting long, so I’ll end it here.

[@lance8467]

Valid 👌

[@timeforgames8608]

Definitely agree with Cave island being underrated. Might even by my favorite island!

[@gwgaming5085]

agree

[@GaboliaGames]

I dont agree with Amber island. Bro, Gnarls ruined everything

[@lcajueiro]

@@GaboliaGames go to a doctor

[@catofcartography5944]

This tier list is better than most lists I’ve seen

[@Zitro-qz5eb]

I am kinda depressed that faerie is the worst but still good overwise! Can next rank Fire haven pls?

[@Duck_man_tds]

Good tier list 😊

[@Falinkslord12]

Galvana only ruins the second half of starhenge, but makes the first half even better. So a win lose situation.

[@ConcernedKayna]

I don’t think they ruin it at all. But I could understand not liking their constant praise of Rootitoot

[@maximsava2129]

the reason why is gold island emotional its because it was supposed to be the last song of the msm and its sonud like goodbye song

[@Dabababa8888]

I kinda don't know why people says that starhenge is better without galvana. Imo, galvana makes the song much more alive! Along with glaishur "rootitoot".

[@VijiKarthikeyan]

0:06 farie isnald 0:20 shugabush isnald 0:47 party isnald 1:11 cestail isnald 1:37 cloud isnald 1:53 air isnald 2:13 fire oasis 2:36 tribal isnald 2:59 light isnald 3:23 cave isnald 3:51 water isnald 4:12 psychic isnald 4:36 seasonal shanty 5:02 starhenge 5:26 cold isnald 5:50 space isnald 6:15 fire haven 6:42 gold isnald 7:05 earth isnald 7:29 amber isnald 7:54 mythical isnald 8:18 plant isnald 8:44 wublin isnald 9:12 ethereal isnald 9:33 the continent 9:57 bone isnald 10:22 magical santum 10:53 credits

[@GaboliaGames]

ISNALD💀

[@HungryWarden]

No offense but your spelling made me puke from how awful it is.

[@hiba-lh4xh]

I love your ranking new subscriber

[@luckymarker_lol]

3:37 how do riff and pongping even ruin this epic song? they fit in well so much. yelmut does ruin kaynas part to make her quiter

[@bluberi777]

kayna deserves to have her mouth taped shut every moment of her stupid little life, she is horrible

[@whatswrongwithmybrain]

I can totally agree that magical sanctum is the best. THE DESIGNS ARE SO COOL AAAAAA ESPECIALLY THE OSSTAX DESIGN.

[@HoldMyBlanket]

Continent be hitting hard when bowgart, phangler, and quibble play at that one part

[@zardoge]

Fun fact, shugabush island is a real song made by Kristin Bush called Love it money

[@ballsexisking]

"Love and money"

[@MikKaellion]

And in the 2nd track I heard from Shugabush Island, he said like "Scooby-doo."

[@JaxsonShehane]

If you drank a shot every time he says “slaps,” you’d run out of alcohol a minute and 15 seconds in.

[@PurplyWasTaken]

the reason people dislike seasonal shanty is one word: hoola

[@Luiki_77]

Nahh you did Faerie island dirty, one of my favourite islands

[@teofriends2204]

excuse me? why is seasonal shanty so hated? seasonal shanty is so epic in my opinion, and its so beautiful to me that charilong sounds like the castle melody. edit: btw i agree with you magical sanctum is the best island. no, it IS the best island.

[@quantaviousbartholomewding5588]

Seasonal shanty is dogshit lmao

[@WLacking]

Hoola completely ruins the island. I don’t like music when the music is someone annoying saying, “Hippity yay”.

[@ballsexisking]

Gobbleygourd dueting Hoola is so horrible it's unbearable.

[@Pebbsi_official]

Sounds too empty, not enough monsters there

[@straightupflask]

I’d agree with you on Faerie Island, Pladdie carries Edit: Starhenge and Celestial Island are the same, everyone knows that (Celestial Island is a different time period)

[@SG-tq2vy]

True bro, pladdie is that 1 good guy who gets put on the worst team

[@Kamarov]

It’s basically an alternative version of Cloud Island (plus the Ziggurab)

[@dasillygoober]

look who’s back

[@Deadshade]

I actually been liking msm for myself instead of playing it with my brother and got me interested as I got older plus my opinions are very different I do love seasonal shanty but some monsters are just really annoying like pumpkin for example plus I love wublins to

[@jcovik5132]

Pretty good ranking ngl.

[@goober_the_goobster]

Finally an island ranking that doesnt have seasonal shanty at the bottom

[@mateoveccz3849]

Like I don't agree on most of the ranks you gave to the islands but I am still happy that you showed your opinion and ranked seasonal shanty high

[@MikKaellion]

Wait @Huckjusta, the Gold Island isn't the last island, there is one more (Amber Island) that is the very last island in MSM.

[@CRINGEassdude]

W ranking

[@dean1vplays678]

Can you rank all magical monsters or colossal designs please?

[@Yourboidavid]

Finally someone says that seasonal shanty is underrated

[@RaiderNation1234]

I know right

[@-_Blitz_-]

I'd rank it last personally

[@beacon3359]

@@-_Blitz_- me too buddy.

[@beacon3359]

Seasonal shanty deserves to be underrated it sound like a song to tourcher the living hell out of someone.

[@jaxsonmerchant7684]

@@-_Blitz_-nah I’d rank shugabush last or light

[@Livin4JC]

Bro I actually agree with most of this! Magical Sanctum is really the best. I just wish fire oasis is a bit higher

[@baldiwutduhaiiiil]

it’s iconic on wublin island you mentioned maluch being bad and right after that you put the word “funky”

[@SalwaCreationTime]

Wait , someone who doesn't hate the Werdos ?? AND THINKS THEY MADE THE ISLANDS BETTER ??!! That's impossible 😨 (/j /pos) Anyways , this is a good tier list ! I do agree with some of these Magical Sanctum's Carillong kinda ruined it for me , but it's still one of the best islands ever made 👍

[@screemuproductions8924]

For me, Carrilong actually made it better. Now it feels weird for me to listen the Magical Sanctum without Carillong. Also, thanks!

[@diabelfugas111]

yeah same for me.. carillong ruined magical sanctum

[@SalwaCreationTime]

@@CPW_314 It was the placement that was a bit off for me , I thought that if Carillong plays at Cahoot's part only it would sound a lot better . But I'm starting to get used to it !

[@ballsexisking]

I agree with the werdos being over hated. BUT I definately hate earth island werdos.

[@justintoucour1014]

I dont understand do you rank how hard the island is to complete or how good it is

[@JJ-yh7zq]

Finally someone agrees with me on earth wubbox

[@evarem6819]

Finally someone who likes Bone Island

[@grapeguy69]

I will agree Faerie island has its flaws but I definitely don’t think it’s the worst.

[@arminasbu8030]

I'm suprised that this human really likes earth iland cuz a lot of people think that it's cringe. I love earth iland too and I think those people that hates it are wrong👍❤️

[@moocube1]

realy? i am pretty sure that everyone loves this song

[@term1n8er83]

Finally someone who doesn’t hate the Werdos, a man of culture

[@pkfreeze7807]

In my opinion I think faerie island is underrated tbh

[@armoredsquirrel]

I agree on you on faerie island It reminds me of that "fairytok" that scares me

[@NinaStudiosOfficial]

bro explained the entire life on Celestial island 💀💀💀

[@barsikk142]

Pov: Magical Island: tun tun tun AAEAEEAEAEAEAEEAAAA

[@mightytiger7783]

Never let bro cook again, also are these supposed to be based on sound or waking them up? Because celestial island is so good but you put it low because its hard to get them

[@snaocap1069]

frrr

[@WinterTurningYT]

Magical Sanctum has to be the most “magical” places of all!

[@seyiomg5523]

NEVER LET THIS MAN RATER EVER AGAIN🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@Thesoulofpros]

I'd be willing to bet the real reason they put Magical Sanctum on the top was because of Enchantling.

[@randomguy37893]

My ranking (a bit of recency bias) 5. Amber Island - Good island after all, the monsters are kinda hard to get but it's worth it. It also has many of my favorites, Gnarls, Floogull, AND EVEN MY GOOD OL' ZIGGY BOI! 4. Magical Nexus - Extremely hard monsters to get but the island sounfs heavenly. Also, it has a space theme. How could I not like it? 3. Light Island - This is possibly the most overhated island in the entire franchise. Light Island's melody even got me to sleep one time. Even Yelmut is quiet! 2. Continent - This is the most adorable island ever. The monsters are all cute babies! Anyway, the song is beautiful, and with Gnarls and Hoola being the final monsters yet to come is just sad. Come on! Gobbleygourd and Spurrit are Fire Seasonals, right? Onto 1st place... If you're a fan of my channel, (probably not) you already know it's... 1. ETHEREAL WORKSHOP - THIS ISLAND WILL NEVER LEAVE ITS THRONE. EVERYTHING ABOUT IT IS GOOD. THE MONSTERS, THE DESIGN, AND OH BOY DO I HAVE TO SAY THE MECHANICS. ATTUNING MEEBS AND SYNTHETHIZING THEM IS JUST SO COOL, AND IT HAS FLASQUE, VHENSHUN, AUGLUR!!!!!!! NOTHING NOR NOBODY WILL CHANGE MY OPINION. ETHEREAL WORKSHOP IS THE G.O.A.T AND WILL ALWAYS BE. 🐐 It's also kinda sad that it only has 3 or 4 waves left, we gotta enjoy what we have dudes. Just imagine a quint! Oh! That reminds me. Triple Ethereals! We thought that single and double Ethereals were enough, (which isn't, because ethereal island is trash) but triple ethereals? Stability, Attuning, Synthethizing, I think I don't have to explain anything more.

[@RGWORLD796]

Cool

[@loveforladybug]

Even tho I disagree in every way I got to say that I appreciate the clear honesty

[@coblart]

w ranking

[@lucksgartues4006]

fun fact shughabush island is based off a song named love or money

[@ClawsomeMusic]

I agree with air island cause all the wubboxs are so loud and common wubbox is really out of theme and way to intense

[@jellypixel7139]

I love yool on seasonal shanty 😭

[@Pansito23]

FINALLY someone who agrees water island is not the best island in the game and says amber island is SUPER GOOD

[@Fran_gamer2011]

Why is celestial low???? I tought you would rank the sound not how you get the monsters, i think you should rank only the sound next time

[@theking13787]

Credit of all islands: MSMPokeGamer

[@ChillzNations]

1 Earth 2 air 3 Tribal 4 Plant 5 Gold 6 Water 7 Amber 8 Cold 9 Shugabush 10 Wublin 11 Haven 12 Etheral 13 Sanctum 14 Continent 15 Cave 16 17 Physic 18 Light 19 Seasonal Shanty 20 Party 21 Space 22 Cloud 23 Mythical island 24 Faerie 25 Starhenge 26 Oasis 27 Celestial

[@Yttrium.777]

I agree on #1.

[@kaybombsadventure6934]

How dare you put Celestial island on rank 24 just because it's hard to revive them.

[@sissinojonen7999]

Yeah, it was made difficult so the players who have played for long can have a challenge

[@TimmyDaSeagull]

75 bloody noggins…

[@bluberi777]

to answer your question, i think hoola makes seasonal shanty obnoxious.

[@Ollienations]

Shugabush island is based on a real song called, “Love or Money”.

[@xyster667]

"At least no one's gonna disagree Magical Sanctum now🙂"

[@candyofsomething]

This ranking is actually good, gold island, fire haven and seasonal shanty rating are great and the other island’s ranking were perfect

[@louisperry6138]

The only one I disagree with is faerie island

[@PBJellyBoi]

@@louisperry6138 same

[@kasakgaming1721]

@@louisperry6138 me to

[@evaggeliaastropekaki5831]

Me too

[@ballsexisking]

I feel the best rankings for the islands I've seen was by a guy named "sankis motis"

[@user-tx5qz5ty9h]

tribal island cybop, t-rox, quarrister part and contient pompom,cybop,tiawa part never leaves my head

[@KaijuEdits875]

Same! Hey everybody hey lets go! Hey everybody come on les go!

[@duckrails3790]

Bro why did my guy skip the infamous do the earthquake meme 💀

[@mackistwack]

celestial is by far my favorite island

[@Doinky420]

Please do best spunges for the video after the werdo ranking

[@donhenleyrico2217]

Faerie island is my favorite island but I agree at your decision 👍

[@alphachiu]

you know what, i entirely forgot that party island exists!

[@NorthCypriotBall]

Maulch is my favourite wublin island monster-

[@christophtiktok2995]

W Ranking

[@Formerlyknownasindonetskaya]

Ww

[@yaboi6393]

I dont hecking know why you hate maulch but i like ur opinion on wublin island ( maulch is kinda like that one dude who gives the next beat)

[@MikKaellion]

@ScreemuProductions, so that means Clackula is the best monster in your entire life because it apperaed in Bone Isalnd (2) and Magic Sanctum (1).

[@rarewubcoolbox]

Imo 1-wublin island 2-the continent 3-amber island 4-water island 5-ethereal island 6-mythical island 7-plant island 8-magical statum 9-bone island 10-tribal 11-cave island 12-space island 13-fire haven 14-fire oasis 15-cloud island 16-cold island 17-gold island 18-light island 19-celestial island 20-starhinge 21-earth island 22-air island 23-faerie island 24-physic island 25-shugabush island 26-party island 27-seasonal shanty

[@olivierah]

Bro made Faerie Island dirty.

[@FDB1234-wi7hn]

I love how he has just no opinion on ethereal island 💀

[@galaxyfan6403]

If you like magical scantum then can you do a video that you Ranked Monsters in magical scantum

[@scooteredward2961]

I don’t get why people are going crazy about you having to breed 30 or 75 noggins. It literally takes only a few seconds just for one noggin so it’ll just take A minute of breeding only noggins, and that’s perfectly fine.

[@c4r3na-s]

As soon as I saw Faerie Island at 27. I knew this would be a terrible ranking

[@troiandanecorneja9685]

Faerie island is really underrated in my opinion

[@katiesizemore780jamari]

Never let this guy rate again

[@danielfitz-gerald5301]

Why did you put my favourite island in last?

[@Mehga-cv8go]

No way they said this is just their opinion and then seconds later they act like they're opinion actually matters in the game and ofc gold island has a ''thanks for playing" vibe because it was supposed to be the last island

[@Cheesepuuf]

Bro my guy did faeri island which sounds atleast top 10 super dirty😭💀

[@marshenmelodies5108]

Rate every amber island monster or every hoola

[@bakedpotato99s]

In my opinion both Celestial Island and Starhenge(ig) are the best islands if i had a ranking list on my channel. but the #1 will be the Starhenge, in my opinion(ofc that's logic) Galvana is the best one of this island, bc of it's/her first verse(that "Ooo" verse). i love it's/her glorious and angelic voice (they have gender like the Werdos or genderless like the others? i think that they doesn't have gender too boi. i'm so confused 💀💀💀💀why i'm so cringe when i write my comments) (sorry of my bad and "stoopid" english i need Grammarly right? if you disagree "it's just my silly opinion" ok?) and yes the reason i love the celestial island. I love their designs, all of them are very cute, that if they exist irl i would hug, play, cuddle, theses affectionate ppl thing. :3 (yes i'm very affectionate) one question. if you know this, who/what make this beautiful nature sounds on the starhenge?? (i'm asking about theses sounds: 5:04 - 5:24) and i forgot to say why the Party Island looks and goofy and nostalgic 2000's vibe 💀💀💀💀💀💀💀

[@ballsexisking]

The werdos do not have genders they just designed them to look feminine or masculine to fit the voices better. But by msm logic, no monsters in the entire msm universe have genders.

[@F3lipeMonsters]

Bro riff its one of the bests in cave

[@yousefabu-amara5892]

Why didn't you give a explanation for ethereal island🤔

[@goosegooseproductions9587]

Me with Shugabush island in my top 10:

[@leatherface2001]

Im so glad bone island is #2 so underrated

[@deletemychannelsomeone]

nah its i bit over ratted

[@SG-tq2vy]

Yea bro bone just slaps 🔥

[@beacon3359]

@@deletemychannelsomeone true

[@theadventuresoffatdotty2356]

9:16 what a fantastic youse of words E T H E R E A L I S L A N D

[@michellegertsen1844]

Uh.. Why doesn't ethereal island have a description?