RANKING ALL THE STARKID MUSICALS!

[@sethwilliams7311]

Me after hearing number one: You Gotta KICK IT UP A NOTCH! so good

[@justinborak]

SO GOOD

[@HaunaMyKiki]

_Love_ how you didn't just throw MAMD down to the bottom of the list like most people do! It has its flaws for sure, but it's a very sweet, funny, and charming show that I believe doesn't get the credit it deserves

[@justinborak]

IT CRACKS ME UP. Might not be the best but seriously still is very funny.

[@cheddarssalad1230]

It’s funny how Trail to Oregon has become the Lion King to Ani’s Pocahontas.

[@astrologia4968]

FINALLY someone who recognises how good starship is !!!!!!! i feel like its so underrated which isnt fair because its easily one of starkid’s best shows

[@dawnjeff49]

rip vhs christmas carol

[@zomzomino]

Didnt watch ANI, placing HMB second to last should be illegal.

[@maguitorres9616]

I don't know a lot of star wars so Ani is't for me, but I listen to that cast album all the time. would recomend at least listening to the songs

[@blake2521]

Vhs Christmas Carol erasure is crazy

[@Meeee12346]

Thank goodness I wasn’t the only one who relized

[@cactusisfruity]

mad respect for mamd being higher up than i thought it would be its such an underrated song

[@maguitorres9616]

omg i didnt even finish watching, hahaha. But holy musical batman and twisted being so low is killing me, haha

[@infinitygm451]

Yes, Starship is so great!!! Also yeah I've been listening to NPMD on repeat every day too lol

[@Abigail-lj4sv]

Twisted and Starship >>> (though obviously AVPM is a favorite too)

[@makleake6156]

i just got into started and i now need to watch all of these!! so thank you because i really didn’t know how many plays there were!

[@70percentlesscrazy]

Starship is great. VHS Christmas Carol is my favorite though.

[@sagegreeeeeeen]

Personally, I think npmd is #1 lol BUT I LOVE STARKID TOO

[@OllieStar52886]

My school did The Trail to Oregon two years ago now, and I was Son. I was the only 8th grader among Juniors, lol, but those guys are like my family 🫶

[@bel410la]

My favorites are the hatchet field series. Starting with Nerdy Prudes Must Die then followed by The Guy Who Didn't like Musicals, then Black Friday, but then my list follows a similar course to yours.

[@alphabo2776]

Fire bringer is at the bottom of my list to dw

[@lilyjade493]

NPMD and the guy who didn’t like musicals are the only starkid musicals I’ve seen so far, but yeah NPMD is in my top 5 fave musicals ever

[@MsBroadway209]

Too 3 for me: 1: Twisted (best musical they’ve ever made imo) 2: Trail to Oregon 3: GWDLM

[@Soy_boi]

Honestly, Trail to Oregon is my favorite, but I acknowledge it is not their best. Glad it made it to your top 5 tho!!

[@insertnamehere5615]

I cannot tell you how much I love starship, I literally watched it again yesterday

[@Starkidfan27]

SAME STARSHIP IS THE BEST AND YOU CAN NOT TELL ME OTHERWISE!!

[@zaramarazara]

WHERES MY BABY VHS CHRISTMAS CAROL

[@tabithahallows6116]

Yes! I love Starship!

[@ChefLouisMyBeloved]

My ranking of all the ones I’ve watched are: 1.Starship 2.Twisted 3.Nerdy prudes must die 4.The guy who didn’t like musicals 5.Black Friday 6.The trail to Oregon 7.Holy musical b@man 8.Firebringer

[@justinkador2496]

Starship is my top one too

[@mek2023]

I saw the apolcalyptour and it was amazing.

[@eliorak341]

seeing starship ranked as number 1 instantly earns my respect!!

[@adav135]

I was disappointed seeing Ani and hmbm so low but you made it up to me by putting npmd and starship at the top

[@adav135]

Honestly I could never rank them in order, I’ve tried but I felt guilty putting things at the bottom. I rated them out of 10 and nothing went below 8. I genuinely loved every show even Ani

[@adav135]

My ratings even though nobody asked 1. avpm 8/10 2. Me and my dick 9/10 3. Avps 10/10 4. Starship 10/10 5. Holy musical b@man 10/10 6. Avpsy 8/10 7. Twisted 9/10 8. Ani 9/10 9. Trail to Oregon 10/10 10. Firebringer 10/10 11. The guy who didn’t like musicals 12/10 12. Black Friday 8/10 13. VHS Christmas Carol 10/10 14. Nerdy prudes must die 10/10

[@sumguy789654]

Yoo starship love!!

[@Gills-wh8nq]

SO glad you put NPMD at #2! People don’t realize how phenomenal that show is (I’ve watched it three times help). I have to say I’m surprised that Starship is your #1 pick, even though I love it as well. I think it’s plagued by mostly mediocre songs - save for Kick it Up a Notch - and being too long.

[@Ozloz]

HMB being 2 is criminal.

[@Zoeeeee15]

SO AGREE WITH NERDY PRUDES. I listen to it every day 😂❤

[@artfulsam]

Starship isn’t my top favorite anymore, but it was when I was a kid and it does my heart good to see it ranked so high, it gets so overlooked! I can’t say I would have ranked it differently, really, but I wanna say that I think Ani is really funny, especially as a former extended universe buff, and Nick Lang is so unbelievably good as Obi-Wan. My hottest take is that Firebringer is the most forgettable to me, which hurts to say. I wanted to like it so bad, but it didn’t really leave much of an impression, other than “Fuck no, Zazz” and thinking that Zazz/Keeri were more endearing as a ship than Zazz/Jemilla

[@oscaruncomfortable]

putting twisted at 7

[@S.Hogardii]

VIVA LA STARSHIP

[@jenniferboyster5356]

I agree with most of this. I would have just put TGWDLM before Black Friday. It might just be because I listened to it soooo much that I’m broad with it now. But I love your top four.

[@maguitorres9616]

My unpopular opinion is that firebringer is my least favourite... I never listen to those songs, don't know why

[@mapleleaf65]

I feel like I agree with this entire ranking, but for me, nerdy prudes is at the bottom of the hatchet trilogy :( not sure why I can't get into it. But Jagerman was AMAZING

[@thesmellofadventure5370]

14: Me and My Dick 13: Firebringer 12: A Very Potter Senior Year 11: A VHS Christmas Carol 10: Black Friday 9: Ani: A Parody 8: Nerdy Prudes Must Die 7: A Very Potter Sequel 6: A Very Potter Musical 5: Starship 4: Holy Musical B@man 3: Trail to Oregon 2: The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals 1: Twisted

[@meepmeep1754]

I never expected to see Starship this high, but I personally agree with HMB & Ani, I don’t get a lot of the jokes and the storyline doesn’t interest me that much, because I’m not into the superheroes and Star Wars

[@nacho_girl]

Meanwhile my lowest two are little white lie (from 2007, it's a series and it is shit....anyway go watch my video essay about it) and Starship (I never really got into it but the music slaps)

[@Meeee12346]

Where is vhs Christmas Carol or vhs Christmas carols

[@tmeehan3044]

TWISTED AT NUMBER SEVEN ?!!??????1?1?

[@Totallysleepingrn]

Man guess the other shows better KICK IT UP A NOTCH… Yeah I’ll go-