Ranking Baked Gelée Eyeshadows | Collab with BoB Mindset

[@TheStyleStumbler]

It's so fun to see you do a collab with Claudia! Both of you make such great content. I really enjoyed how you talked about so many different aspects of the formulas - from the textures to the feel, to the look. It's wonderful to hear all that nuance in the descriptions. And now I'm even more curious about those Guerlain quads than I was before.

[@mariam.a.]

@@TheStyleStumbler thank you Stephanie! ♥️ I think part of the reason I moved on from only seeing eyeshadow as matte/metallic was definitely my encounter with PML. It literally changed the way I think and do my makeup. And Claudia!! She has been my guru in baked gelee since day 1 😂♥️😊. Ohhh that ways I love these Guerlain baked quads…you have to put them on your lids to understand. Sorry I am enabling 🙈!

[@TheStyleStumbler]

@ That‘s ok! I’ve strengthened my slow-buy muscles enough to resist temptation. But if I ever get the chance to try them, I certainly will! Those Guerlain shadows sound lovely.

[@dawnmarie240]

Thank you! Love this video. I love the faint veil from Bobbie Brown. It’s exactly what I want most days 😊

[@mariam.a.]

They are really lovely eyeshadows!

[@clidrevandijk]

I knew you would have focused much better on the different finishes by Pat! Such an enjoyable video! ❤

[@mariam.a.]

@@clidrevandijk thank you Claudia! I absolutely love your analytical and critical mind. I have learned a lot from you!!

[@verenaweisz1713]

What a great video, so detailled! I enjoy the Gerlain Quads a lot, the latexy formula as you call it is what I do appreciate! I also love the In Extra Dimension eyeshadows from MAC

[@mariam.a.]

@@verenaweisz1713 thank you babe! The latex mattes are the texture that I find is the most divisive between people. Some really struggle with it. Never had one of those but I have face powders in that finish and I loooove them!!

[@mayraholzer4542]

As always, I thoroughly enjoyed your descriptions. You always inspired me to reach for my Motherships :)

[@mariam.a.]

Thank you for watching and I am so glad to hear you enjoyed it!

[@africke744]

Thank you Mariam. I enjoyed this. I must re-watch your guide to the PML formulae. ( I don't think you linked it). Off to see Claudia's take after supper.

[@mariam.a.]

@@africke744 ahh nope forgot that! Will link it later.

[@raychell1]

I was waiting on you to make a video on the topic! I love this formula so muchh

[@mariam.a.]

Love that you enjoyed the video! Thank you!

[@isabelab6851]

I must admit that I have not focused on formula like you have. I think I will have to try and see. I have a lot of these so I should do that soon. As I age, I need shadows that apply smoother on the lids…so something to think about.

[@mariam.a.]

Definitely food for thought and some good old fashioned experimentation!!

[@carolinepak5752]

Lovely video! I’m feeling inspired to pull out my Motherships and try layering over other brand liquid and cream eyeshadows. I always enjoy your content. 💝

[@mariam.a.]

@@carolinepak5752 that’s my favorite hobby so I highly recommend trying it! 😁♥️

[@lr8607]

Appreciate the information on how to identify these formulas. I didn't realize the Chanel Eclat du Nut was baked gelee. No wonder I like mine so much!

[@mariam.a.]

@@lr8607 Eclat de Nuit is baked, not gelee. But it’s fabulous indeed!

[@RoseOfMadina]

Mariam, this was sooo relaxing and soothing to watch. Please do content like this for every mothership! 🤩 I love how you explain and describe things!

[@mariam.a.]

@@RoseOfMadina I have the guide to Mother’s formulas if that helps. Also you will be delighted to hear that in Dec at some point I have the ambitious plan to film a series with the Motherships only. 😁

[@RoseOfMadina]

@mariam.a. yes yes I have watched that! It still remains a delight to hear you speak about the formula's!

[@mariam.a.]

@@RoseOfMadina 💕😘

[@mayraholzer4542]

@@mariam.a. So excited to see new Mothership videos!! I hate that she hasn't released any new ones, and that #9 was the last with her baked shades :(

[@Glowfessions]

This has been so helpful! Thank you

[@mariam.a.]

I am so glad to hear it! Thank you!

[@spgard29]

I've popped over from Claudia's video to see your perspective. I appreciate your information -- and your insight. Thank you, Mariam. I've just subscribed! ❤

[@mariam.a.]

I am so glad you enjoyed our videos! And welcome! ♥️

[@LisaF_]

I love that you did a collaboration with Claudia! I could listen to both of you talk about eyeshadows (and swatch them)all day!! I really love the Guerlain baked mattes, too. Oh how I wish they’d make more quads with their baked formulas! Pat comes out #1… of course!! Her baked shades are just next level. I love that Pat got first place in Claudia’s ranking, too. My very favorite is also Pat McGrath with Guerlain in second. It’s too bad both brands don’t seem interested in their baked formulas anymore. I’m glad Bobbi Brown is!

[@mariam.a.]

I actually love that both of us declared Pat the Queen. That says a lot! Guerlain is interestingly a very divisive one, some love it some find it hard to work with. Tastes differ I guess. I am also super bummed that my top 2 have discontinued their baked formulas.

[@cherb1971]

This was so interesting and I learned a lot. Thank you so much Mariam.

[@mariam.a.]

@@cherb1971 my pleasure! ♥️

[@ralphandleosmom9075]

I adore Clionadh smooth formula eyeshadows. So funny that you used them to compare. Now to watch your rankings! I saw Claudia’s already.

[@mariam.a.]

@@ralphandleosmom9075 haha they are very good, one of the best indie. But they cannot compare with a baked formula.

[@vjean04]

Pat McGrath sparkle is unmatched in my opinion. I ordered the holiday palette even though it’s not baked gelee.

[@mariam.a.]

@@vjean04 it’s still an amazing palette!

[@lisagreene7186]

This was very informative, thank you

[@mariam.a.]

You are very welcome!

[@s.clairegreen9577]

I just purchased the Luxe quad from Bobbie Brown, love it, stunning

[@mariam.a.]

@@s.clairegreen9577 ohh yes enjoy!!

[@bulyhinaolga2061]

Великолепный разбор текстур и подробнейшие обьяснение🤘👍⚠️, спасибо большое!!!! Вы молодец🙏⚠️🤘👍🌹

[@mariam.a.]

@@bulyhinaolga2061 Спасибо! ♥️🥰

[@ralphandleosmom9075]

Because of you and Claudia, today I finally ordered Sisley eyeshadow. I did find them 50% off. I had to have the blue Claudia showcased. It looked chef’s kiss.

[@mariam.a.]

@@ralphandleosmom9075 ohh what a steal! What a sophisticated blue right!!

[@ralphandleosmom9075]

@@mariam.a. I hope the reality is what showed on my screen - a blue with no hint of green. Fingers crossed.

[@cindypltnm]

I think I may have commented this previously but I really think you would like the Chantecaille Luminescent Eye Shades. They’re very reminiscent of this baked gelee formula and stunning on the eyes.

[@mariam.a.]

They are definitely good contenders.

[@catherinelynnfraser2001]

I have apples and pears. Thank you for this. This is so helpful. I am overwhelmed by pears. I am looking forward to buying more pears at the Clionadh BF sale. Milly has a collaboration with Clionadh.

[@mariam.a.]

@@catherinelynnfraser2001 haha enjoy your pears!! Clionadh is a good one.

[@adrian-rx8rg]

as usual you’ve managed to give us the best content of the day week month with this one Mariam! 🤩🤩🤩 i only have Pat McGrath baked shadows in my collection rn but those original six ombré g quads from Guerlain are definitely next on my list. good thing christmas is coming! 💀 is Imperial Moon your favorite??

[@mariam.a.]

Ohhh tough one! I like them all. Imperial Moon is the only one with cooler tones. I love Metal Butterfly too but you gotta love the colous. Royal Jungle is also gorgeous. I have a playlist somewhere with a whole week using the Guerlain quads.

[@adrian-rx8rg]

@ fair enough, fair enough. I love Metal Butterfly too from the looks of it! those two will be my first ones for sure. i found some marketing material on Saks that also categorizes Mystic Peacock and Majestic Rose along with Imperial Moon as ‘Cold’ instead of ‘Warm’ which was hilarious to me😭😭 still, the idea that the two lower shades in Mystic Peacock are supposed to represent new copper and then patina-d copper or whatever almost sells me on the palette even if it isn’t cool toned to my eye at all lol

[@mariam.a.]

@@adrian-rx8rg Majestic Rose does lean a bit cooler it has the pinks right?

[@Bazibishop]

Def checking out those Bobbi brown. And I realised I have one of her singles! I love it but it’s not a colour I use regularly. Love the Pat style special shades. By far the best

[@mariam.a.]

BB is the only brand that currently offers a formula similar to Pat. Beware though, not all of the luxe eyeshadows from BB are in fact baked gelee.

[@RoseOfMadina]

Also Mariam, after watching Claudia's video, I'm wondering whether you will try out Florasis? I trust your opinion! I'm a bit ill (seasonal flu), but this video put me in a really good mood. Thank you!! Sending you a virtual, virus-free, hug! ❤

[@mariam.a.]

Ahh beterschap!!! A virus has been trying to get me all week too, I have a bit of the sniffles but so far nothing too bad. I did get the flu shot though. For now, no plans to try Florasis but you can trust Claudia, she knows what she is taking about.

[@judylopatin6110]

Thanks, very informative. Is your Tom Ford palette here Body Heat?

[@mariam.a.]

Yes indeed, good eye.

[@judylopatin6110]

@ Well, I just got it-from eBay-a couple days ago!

[@mariam.a.]

@@judylopatin6110 I really enjoy Body Heat! I hope you do too!!!

[@nidiadoherty5405]

I always forget about wetting the baked shadows for more impact. I didn’t realize Tom Ford’s W/D formula was baked Gelee. Cool beans.

[@mariam.a.]

And he has LOTS of quads in that formula. It is a really good one!

[@alejandraornelas2506]

Hi Mariam, thanks for this insightful video. I've been very curious about baked gelée formulas since I tried the Patrick TA duos, unfortunately I don't hsve anything else to compare them to but I'm thinking about expanding my collection in this area. Have you swatched the Patrick TA duos? Are you interested in picking them up at any point?

[@mariam.a.]

I will unfortunately not get a chance to swatch (we don't have Sephora in NL) them but I get the idea they are similar to the BB/PML ones. For now I am not planning on picking up any because none of the duos really convinces me.

[@qingluo8069]

I had two dior quints and I didn't like any of them, one was very very powdery and expired quickly second just very lackluster. I would like to ask if dior soft cashmere is baked gelee too?

[@EXOmakemeHorololo]

It's definitely not. It's the standard powder formula

[@mariam.a.]

Soft Cashmere is a baked formula, except the shade in the middle. So it is not gelee but it is baked.

[@qingluo8069]

​@@mariam.a. thank you for answer 🌺