RANKING EVERY BIG BROTHER 5TH PLACE GAME

24. Sam (Season 20)
23. Howie (Season 6)
22. Victor (Season 18)
21. Chicken George (Season 7)
20. Jenn (Season 14)
19. Alyssa (Season 24)
18. Bunky (Season 2)
17. Renny (Season 10)
16. Jee (Season 4)
15. Jeff (Season 11)
14. Marcellus (Season 3)
13. Judd (Season 15)
12. Alex (Season 19)
11. Kalia (Season 13)
10. Hannah (Season 23)
9. Ragan (Season 12)
8. Natalie (Season 9)
7. Karen (Season 5)
6. Cirie (Season 25)
5. Austin (Season 17)
4. Tommy (Season 21)
3. Frankie (Season 16)
2. Memphis (Season 22)
1. Eric (Season 8)

[@sonsetonGod]

not me thinking the first part was the intro in no particular order and THEN you'd rank them and share reasoning 😂😂

[@tattoofixerstattoos]

I would swap Tommy and Memphis. Tommy beats everyone in a jury vote if he makes the end for one thing, which is not even close to true of Memphis in 22.

[@whats_holden_up]

Memphis probably beats anyone besides Cody. I could however see Tommy being at 2, the 2-5 range was really close for me

[@tattoofixerstattoos]

@@whats_holden_up Tyler crushes Memphis. Christmas even admits she votes Tyler to win over everyone (including Memphis) and she is now engaged to Memphis, LOL! The others? I agree he beats Christmas, but not sure why you are so sure he beats Nicole or even Enzo. Breaking both down. vs Nicole- Memphis would get Tyler and Christmas easily. Da'Vonne hated both. Dani probably votes Nicole. David and Ian both hated Memphis so obviously vote Nicole, despite Ian being bitter at Nicole, I still think he votes her over Memphis. Cody, probably depends how he goes out. Enzo didn't like Memphis, so might lean Nicole. Kevin, not sure, but probably also leans Nicole. So Nicole has Dani, David, Ian all for sure and only needs 2 out of Cody, Da'Vonne, Kevin, Enzo, with Enzo and Kevin probably both leaning Nicole. Seems he likely loses to her. vs Enzo- Enzo would get Ian and David for sure. Da'Vonne pretty much for sure. Cody probably leans Enzo. So Memphis needs every other vote. Memphis would get Tyler and Christmas easily, but would he get all of Nicole, Dani, Kevin over Enzo? Kevin especialy probably leans Enzo. So no, I think he only beats Christmas of the Final 6. Beyond that though he had almost no path to the Final 2. Someone like Tommy is for sure better than Memphis, he both had WAY higher jury win chances, in fact Tommy is certain to win in any Final 2 vs anyone, and a much better shot to reach the end than Memphis did despite both going out at 5.

[@whats_holden_up]

@@tattoofixerstattoos you also have to keep in mind that Memphis was the only one who would've taken the shot at Cody towards the end. He would've been over Enzo as I think in that case he'd probably get Dani, Cody, Tyler, Christmas, Nicole and probably Kevin. vs Nicole, he gets Tyler, Christmas, Kevin, Da'Vonne, while I think Cody and possibly Kevin are toss ups. Vs Tyler its possible he loses that one. However Memphis started the committee, would've been willing to take the big shots which would've boosted his chances. I would probably agree Tommy had better chances with season he's on but he got completely outplayed by Michie at the end of the day. Tommy was better socially but Memphis was better strategically. I can't get mad at Tommy being above Memphis cause I honestly considered putting Tommy at 2

[@rolandgreen7484]

Tommy down at 4th is ridiculous. He is atleast 2nd. Ragan is far too high. He was a goat who had now winning Final 2s, even Kathy might beat him in a Final 2, and still had no shot at the end. Memphis should be much lower than 2nd. Wouldn't even have him in the top 5. 5th seems too high for Austin. He was decent, but still was basically the same game as his showmance, minus not even reaching the end. 14th is too high for Marcellas. Guy was clueless and gave away veto when he was the clear target. Karen is much too low. I would have her 3rd behind Eric and Tommy. No way are Memphis or Austin better than her.

[@whats_holden_up]

I honestly don't hate any of those criticisms except the Austin one as he was the head of the snake and the brains who was in control of the Austwins alliance. What would your list look like?

[@rolandgreen7484]

@@whats_holden_up Hmm would need to think of it some but will give you one later. Will give you the start of mine though and do the rest later. 1. Eric 2. Tommy 3. Frankie 4. Karen-debated between Karen and Frankie As for Memphis, yes he was probably the most strategic of him, Liz, Julie, but ultimately despite that he was the biggest target of those 3, was always going home before Liz imparticular, and was only an equal jury threat to Liz with less chance to reach the end than Liz did. And I don't consider Liz a strong runner up compared to others.

[@HailVictory-gs8wx]

Agustin Da Best

[@corndog7813]

alyssa is so high lol she literally has no game

[@whats_holden_up]

I mean nobody in the bottom 6 of this list is a good player. She could be a couple spots lower but 19th ain't too bad of a spot for her

[@themidoritwins9228]

If you want to talk about people with no game let’s talk about Alex from bb19. Girl was so carried by Paul into the final 5. She legit yelled at Megan and lead to her quitting all because of a misunderstanding.

[@whats_holden_up]

@@themidoritwins9228 to an extent. While I definitely wouldn't call Alex good, I feel like her game was mediocre to average. She was weak strategically but was like socially for the most part and was good at comps. While Alex has massive cons as a player I feel like there are good aspects to her

[@rolandgreen7484]

Her game was boinking Kyle and putting on make up. And her bromance with Turner.

[@elijahmanwarfield4869]

​@@themidoritwins9228She had potential though. If she had controlled her temper and not been so loyal to Paul, she could have played a great social game and possibly flip the house against Paul.

[@andrewdery2720]

How’s alex not in the top 10?? She was so good

[@Matias-jd5fx]

ur joking right

[@alexsheinbaum]

HOW IS ALYSSA SO HIGH? SHE SHOULD BE LAST. LOL (JK)

[@patrickmexiquinn]

I actually love that cirie next to Austin placement I think it's accurate move Tommy below cirie and that list is fool proof

[@whats_holden_up]

I honestly considered having Tommy below Austin, there's a case for it

[@tattoofixerstattoos]

Tommy should be higher. i would put him 2nd. He beats everyone that season in a Final 2, and was well positioned most of the game to have a good chance to make the end.

[@patrickmexiquinn]

​​@@tattoofixerstattoosyah he had great game and easily could have won and was the best player on his season I just think the 2 right below him do better if you simulate them in a house 100 times with random house guests.

[@tattoofixerstattoos]

@@patrickmexiquinn I disagree on that, on Memphis imparticular. Watching him my 2 seasons makes it clear to me he would never actually win Big Brother. He would go deep often (so does Tommy) but never win. Actually despite that he went deep in both his seasons, could see many casts Memphis is an early boot too. I strongly disagree with Tommy not easily being above Memphis. And I disagree on Austin too. I think there are many seasons he makes top 5, but many he goes much earlier, some even pre jury. Cirie I am split on. I think some are overrating her as a BB player due to her Survivor popularity. I found her BB25 game pretty messy and overrated by a lot of people, but she was also handicapped by her bumbling son, an awful BB player, being in the house.

[@Thumper7639]

I would put Tommy #1 cus he basically had majority until the Holly and Michie Winning Streak and he still wasn't targeted for a while and probably survives final 5 if michie doesn't go so far out of his way to save holly

[@burntfrootloop4073]

Hannah is too high. The best she gets is 2nd place to Tiffany. Tiffany, X, and Kyland carried the Cookout HARD.

[@whats_holden_up]

I agree with that but Hannah's game was decent. It wasn't spectacular but it was fine, she had a fine social game and mind. She's in the same tier as like Alex, Judd and those ppl but I feel like Hannah is less flawed than them

[@themidoritwins9228]

Yes Frankie!!!

[@Leo_2024-d8u]

No

[@sergipana1113]

Alguém do Brasil ??

[@sunnygolightly9996]

Am I wrong, or was the top 7, top 6 group are overall actually better?

[@JohnnyHikesSW]

Yeah there tends to be a peak where the actually good players are taken out before they go back to targeting weaker players

[@violin01]

Victor should have been placed higher imo

[@rolandgreen7484]

yeah the guy who was evicted 3 times, the only one in history who got evicted that much. In addition to a ton of other would have been evictions without comp wins. His future wife even voted him out all 3 times he was on the block, that is how bad he is at the game.

[@violin01]

@@rolandgreen7484 I would argue that he played a better game than Marcellas but I get what you mean, I still don't think that Vic played the worst 5th place game though

[@SportsGuyTalking]

Memphis is one of the best players to never win

[@MarsinMars]

Ehhhhhhhh on bb10 yeah, on bb22 he kinda made his own demise since he was never winning in both a commitee steamroll or a commitee wipe, hell if he didnt make the commitee I feel like he could've been first boot

[@googleassistantofficial]

Tbh I think Memphis is overrated, I just never found him that engaging to watch, I think he was okay on bb10 but he was awful on bb22

[@woodykusaki9970]

Just because you didn't find him engaging doesn't mean he didn't play well. Also, the word engaging is very subjective. I found Memphis engaging.

[@tattoofixerstattoos]

@@woodykusaki9970 He played well but not that well. He was terribly positioned to make the end and probably only beats Christmas in a Final 2 out of the Final 6.

[@tattoofixerstattoos]

@@googleassistantofficial He would have been no higher than 8th on my list. Having him 2nd is crazy, but to each their own.