Ranking EVERY Character In Roblox Classic Sonic Simulator V11 from WORST to BEST

[@ThePainZone404]

Metal Sonic literally is Lord Speedrun Meta. It’s rare seeing someone acknowledge him in that department, since he’s overshadowed by Tails or even Knuckles because stages like the entirety of Marble Zone exist. I kid you not, I managed to beat two Super Sonic users in a race across the first three premade Green Hill Zone levels as him. Outside of speedrunning, he’s STILL a pretty solid but underrated character choice. God bless all Metal Sonic enjoyers.

[@retrohill5848]

Amen Brother as a Metal Sonic Enjoyer I do agree Also God bless you and your family and have a great day!

[@riniabraham5579]

Metal Sonic also can run through enemies when he is running with full power

[@S.F.Y.T.A.G]

Isn't he just Sonic_SCD with a double jump?

[@2DCheese]

@@S.F.Y.T.A.G No. He doesn't have peelout.

[@NinjaElectroYoutuber]

God bless you too and your family

[@AnimsOfTheAnims]

7:16 Those two Sonic’s deaths were so *PERFECTLY TIMED* that it looked like Metal Sonic defeated them with his little dash move thing.

[@2DCheese]

true

[@Kakarot-N15]

Ye

[@possiblyJARED]

Eggman would be proud.

[@krispeydude]

Rouge is also in ONE more way different than Knuckles. If Rouge glides for a bit longer time she starts to glide faster.

[@Slaymisi]

Also from what I remember she can't break blocks without a spindash while knuckles can

[@S.F.Y.T.A.G]

She also has a drill move

[@TarazGamingTB]

Metal sonic is basically sonic 2 sonic with the electric shield if he couldn't lose the electric shield

[@Ggg10908]

No,its sonic cd sonic

[@freekenjaku]

@@Ggg10908 then wheres the peelout

[@Ggg10908]

@@freekenjaku i forgot

[@Retro_expresso]

@@freekenjaku his peelout is basically a invincible dash when he reaches high speeds making him able to dash through enemies

[@syahmisafian3700]

Bro his spindash is from sonic cd

[@genericgamer1131]

Random Fun Fact: Did you know that Amy and Tails has smaller hurtboxes? If you roll as Amy, you can go through gaps that are 7/8th height of the block Tails can go even further, with his spin dash allowing him to move through gaps that are 5/8th height of the block. Besides, he doesnt even need to roll to go through single block gaps!

[@loghf718]

The only things that can kill super sonic are time out, the void in bottom of levels, and getting crushed.

[@kamariwright6225]

Someone else knows and so super is 2nd best metal is the best character. Any counter arguements?

[@loghf718]

@@kamariwright6225 super sonic it's just op.

[@nothingtoseehereiswear1011]

@@kamariwright6225Metal can die to the same things

[@Duo1069]

What about drowning?

[@Vento.capitaodogpaganossacoca]

Super is slower than cd and metal

[@ellengianini7110]

Well here we go: 12- Sonic 1: Since he got no spindash he kinda sucks to get speed and he will need shields to it. 11- Amy She got a dash that you can spin and a jump that you will hit after pressing again so "semi" jumps and spindashes. Also, she can jump the height of eletrical shield and water bounce so she surpass Sonic 1 by that. 10- Robotnik Yes, he fly and have some enemy immunities, but he can't fly in water, low jump and is bad against spikes. 9- Sonic 2 True spindashes and jumps and also shield boosts, a pretty average character. 8- Sonic 3 Same as Sonic 2 but with insta-shield. 7- Shadow Same as Sonic 3 but with 5 ring boost. 6- Rouge She can glide and have a quick fall but she is behind knuckles just because of his "destroy walls" ability. 5- Knuckles Same as rouge but with a better other ability which is "destroy walls". 4- Tails Great flying ability, can swim, spindash and carry light characters. Robotnik but way better. 3- Sonic CD Best spindash, super peel-out, shield boosts, a very speedy character. 2- Super Sonic Invencibility, but it has a terrible spindash and falls a lot of times. 1- Metal Sonic Sonic CD spindash, double jump, invincibility when running fast (Yes metal sonic can defeat super in a race) better because it does not fall very often. Edit: It is just my opinion based on stats

[@I_Hate_Monkeys_69]

Yes super sonic is trash at platforming levels

[@kamariwright6225]

Your right as soon as I saw the this tier list I'm like super sonic not best metal is bc super can call Godspeed to fast get crushed time runs out of just drowning which thats weird but metal sonic is the best character.

[@styggythestegosaurus5740]

⁠@@kamariwright6225fr super Sonic’s speed is both an advantage and an disadvantage because he’s super slippery

[@DariaGrishchenko-n4t]

super sonic has only one downside: it's very hard to control him because of his speed.

[@Atrael]

You forgot to mention that Rouge can glide after cancelling in the air

[@A_Stigly_Person]

That was removed after the v9 update

[@Atrael]

@@A_Stigly_Person oh, never noticed

[@A_Stigly_Person]

@@Atrael it’s alright

[@Jerrymchicken]

hey i hate fnf as well

[@mehiloll]

Wait I didn’t even know Shadow had an extra move! Learned something new I guess

[@GottaBGlitches]

It makes me happy seeing my favourite character ranked 2nd

[@Emperorflimsywhale_CW]

YO YOU SHOULDVE ADDED THE UNLOCKABLE/DEV CHARACTERS! idk what any of them do (except Baldi) but i would rank baldi 13 as his only special move is KILLING OTHER PLAYERS which cant help you at all, his jump is VERY LOW he cant even jump onto a spring when the ground is flat, he cant even use a loop without noclipping into the backrooms. oh also he can gain ALOT OF HIGHT but only when he is underwater, or by jumping constantlt while moving on a slope, but to gain hight the slope has to be tall and long. he is a good character IN TERMS OF HOW MUCH WE ALL LOVE HIM (he would be #1 if it wasnt how good he is at beating levels) but overall he sucks, oh also he cant go through tunnels thus making him worse

[@NiNj_indisguise]

In older version of classic sonic sim all sonics and shadow had the peel out and S1 had spin dash (this was removed later)

[@hellsencyclopedia1721]

You forgot to mention that cd sonic doesn't have a roll jump lock

[@FLARE371]

?

[@tuomasgaming4210]

Actually, Tails can defeat enemies while flying, if you hit them with Tails' tails. Also, Tails has a smaller hitbox compared to the rest of the characters, meaning that he can get through smaller gaps.

[@Lightning-Spiderproductions977]

If you touch an enemy with tails' tails when he's flying it gets killed

[@StretchyAnimations]

You made me change my mind about Sonic CD spin dash forever

[@justsans.]

Metal and Amy are my mains, Amy is good for momentum on steep slopes going downward, and her spin dash being a peel out makes it easier to keep her momentum going, Metal has his dash mode, op as is, and then has a double jump and a CD spin dash, bro is built different like that.

[@Lo-Sir]

I main Metal and CD CD is good because I enjoy the peelout, his spindash is good and I get to flex my Pink Sonic Skin I use Metal when I want to cheese a level a tiny bit

[@ScorchingStoleYourToast]

Im literally you

[@miles0]

5:12 CD Sonic is the Best Sonic becuase he has the Best spindash velocity,peelout and he can use elemental shields

[@PasquiGaming]

Tbh I think that eggman cant spindash for logic reasons, but yeah for the rest I agree

[@mlgpapas1319]

dude I don't know if you know this but if you spam the spindash button with any character that can spin dash they go the same speed as the sonic cd spin dash so overall cd sonic wouldn't be the best sonic but idk if you know that you're supposed to click the spindash 6 times and not click it once

[@GutsyMacGamer]

That's what makes CD Sonic better. You can reach insanely high speeds with only ONE click

[@mlgpapas1319]

@@GutsyMacGamer but is takes longer to charge up

[@yona3271]

amy can perform spin dash after you perform the peelout and then press down then you can do it at a certain speed but still good enough and second thing she gets a high jump ability you can use while move which is hold up and then jump the thing is it's tie with metals double jump

[@Shlo0000sh]

Amy is a easy to play hard to master character, if you dont know how to use her, you WILL HATE HER.

[@dakotacornish6616]

To be honest id agure robotnic is second place you have to design the level around him or you can break levels eaisly with him he may not have good speed but its mostly not needed to complete levels and can mainly work to your advantage sense as super sonic you can just fall down a bunch of pits sure robotnic is slow but he can beat levels that are impossible as super or anyone eles

[@bro_does_shorts]

HOW COULD ROBOTNIK SPINDASH!??!

[@akramelser140]

Enemies don't attack him

[@not_kjb]

Putting Amy at the bottom Is just a skill issue

[@Moddballfromonline]

But Rouge isn't as strong as Knuckles as he can break through walls without spindashing.

[@William_Afton11]

Yea

[@Qwertyexists]

Yes but fire dash does the same thing

[@letsgojoe2141]

7:27 tails can kill enemies with his fly, if there is a enemy above you then you can kill it while he is flying with his tails

[@IceColdSoda69]

fun fact: I was speedrunning a blank stage (average stage in css) and sonic cd's peelout outran super sonic

[@Vento.capitaodogpaganossacoca]

The peel out was removed by sega because it was op XD

[@takiallahjamai]

Sonic 2 sonic is for you if you want to play it fair

[@LucaStan-gz8ei]

4:29 i just use sonic cd i love the peelout and everything

[@beyondhaircraze4418]

I’ll like to say amy is a very unique and underrated character, and shadow is probably one of the best if you manage the dashes correctly.

[@some_body_else3636]

"she is without a doubt the worst character in css" Skill issue bozo

[@Shimodragon]

but tails does destroy the badniks when hes flying but u gotta lower tails below the badnik for that to work

[@Michael72022]

Finally I found another cd SPINDASH brother

[@ECRALSE40LPS]

I just don't know why they split sonic 1 and CD into 2 despite they look very identical except for key differences but still I want them to merge together. Plus sonic 2 & 3 don't have the super peelout anymore which is sad. I want the Sonic 2 & 3 peelouts back cause it made people to not force them to use sonic 1/CD but after V9 it made people force them to use sonic CD.

[@TheSimplyNoah]

For me, super sonic and Amy are around the same place! That’s just my opinion though! Cd Sonic is the best for me and metal sonic is just behind him for me!

[@animated_finn]

Actually amy can spindash into a ball, just press down after spindashing and she turns into a ball

[@Therealcheezit11]

All characters, EASY to HARD Easy: Sonic 3 Sonic 2 Super Sonic Meduim: Sonic Cd Metal Sonic Sonic 1 Tails Knuckles Rouge Hard: Amy Eggman (Shadow is up in easy level I forgot about him)

[@Emperorflimsywhale_CW]

baldi should be in "HARD DEPENDING ON THE LEVEL" because his jump is so low when not in water or when on LONG AND TALL SLOPES (yes ik he is a dev only character)

[@Livia_Poiana]

red sonic and blue knuckles: you didint have to cut me off-

[@ZWTLSATMR]

I wanna to add modern sonic for v13

[@-majdtheandroid-]

0:14 and this is why sega made amy perfect in origins plus

[@Shimodragon]

2:38 just because dr.robotnik is a villan dosent mean hes immune to everything

[@shibey8655]

i remember when sonic 1 sonic had a peelout and s2 spindash

[@CrystalIsWellMade]

The characters below also have a pose 1) Sonic (SCD) 2) Sonic (S3) 3) Tails (S3) 4) M. Sonic ( SCD That's all. Sorry if i forgot to mention How to do a pose Look up and while holding arrow up press the number 1 This works on pc or laptop only

[@TheAmazingAnimator]

My opinion: 12. Eggman: not a fun character. 11. Shadow: has potential but never used. Also dash is just a bad move 10. Super Sonic: too easy and is only gopd when used correctly 9. CD Sonic: He's just not a used character, S2 is better 8. S2 Sonic: Nice character, nothing stands out much. 7. S3 Sonic Better than s2 because of the insta sheild and nicer sprites 6: Knuckles: Great character in general. 5. Rouge: The Cooler Knuckles 4: Tails fun character 3. Amy: fun character with downthrust and high jumps. 2. Metal Sonic: Perfect for speedeunners, most of the CSS community 1. S1 Sonic: best platformer hands down, perfect for basic platforming kaiso levels, speedrunning and anticheesing. a well rounded character with good physics and an ideal character for most pro CSS players.

[@Jim_the_guy]

0:19 HOW DARE YOU RANK AMY THIS LOW, I MAIN HER EVERY TIME, YOU GRRRR!!!!! BTW ur just bad, if ur good amy is the best if used correcly

[@wildberrysherbert3803]

I wish that they just added Mania Sonic honestly

[@Picsasworld]

my opinion: (LOTS OF HOT TAKES) 12. Super Sonic - He makes the game too easy to the point where its not fun anymore 11. S1 Sonic - He is very Meidiochre because he cant spindash but he does get access to the elemental shields 10. Amy - She can spindash but not into a ball, she does get a special ability to jump up high but thats it 9. Robotnik - he can fly but thats it 8. S2 Sonic - he gets access to the spindash and the elemental shields which is cool 7. S3 Sonic - his insta shield is OP and he gets access to the elemental shields 6. Shadow - Im ranking him above S3 Sonic because the Boost that costs 5 rings makes him amazingly better than S3 Sonic 5. Knuckles - he can glide but when he lands it takes away a bit of speed 4. Rouge - she does get a move to throw herself to the ground if that makes sense which makes her better than Knuckles 3. Tails - he has the best flight and is an awesome charecter himself 2. Metal Sonic - basically CD sonic but slightly worse also he can double jump but no elemental shields 1. CD Sonic - he has the superpeel out, the best spindash access to the elemental shields with one more pro, He is amazing

[@dappleofthedualies]

Metal Sonic's top speed animation can also kill enemies, so one more point to Metal.

[@krithehedgehogyt]

metal is literally the modded copy of Sonic CD Sonic but without the peelout

[@wuickon]

with the peelout*

[@krithehedgehogyt]

@@wuickon but you can make peelout when you as stopped

[@NoCreativity0]

ok, I understand that Amy can be bad, but it's not possible that she is behind Sonic (1) and Eggman, Amy is bad for those who don't know how to play, but she can be a great character, almost above the 3 sonics (CD) (2) (3), it's terrible for beginners, but great for those who know how to play. maybe he only counted the characters that are normally playable. practically what he said about sonic (3) 3:35. "If you time it right" this phrase defines Amy's abilities, so yeah, Amy isn't actually as bad as she seems. Something about Amy's abilities are: the hammer, which is the normal ability, also has a bigger hit box than the others (just like sonic 3). the super jump is useful either to avoid some spikes or to avoid/attack buzz bombers (I don't know if that's the name). also an ability that I didn't see him mentioning but which is kind of useful (kind of because it's one of the most useless of Amy's abilities) it would be the ability that if you jump and press the button to lower, you do an ability that spins your hammer and makes Amy fall SUPER faster AND deal damage (like rouge). about the super peel out (nerfed) it might be bad, but you can make it a spin dash by simply holding down button. Another fact is that as Amy is smaller, she has a smaller hit box, so this makes it easier to dodge spikes (upside down) and attacks from some enemies, this goes for tails too. By the way, did you notice that the only defect that makes the character fall in this rank is the fact that she doesn't do the normal sonic jump? Of course the peel out is nerfed and there is no spin dash but in my opinion it is just the jump that is the main problem. By the way, in my opinion, I think Amy is really cool to play (my opinion). but the rest of the video is great, and thank you very much to those who read all of this (1% of people lol) :) EDIT : Just letting you know that if my English is wrong it's because I'm using the translator because I'm from another country.

[@allenwindsor9879]

Dude you can just roll after a spin dash, however I agree with the hammer part.

[@stevenajadman2781]

Just pointing this out even though it's very useless (Unless if you're adding some frame perfect jump thingies in your levels???) but Shadow has a slightly smaller hitbox than S3 Sonic.

[@RafaelSonicgamer]

2:35 💀

[@possiblyJARED]

My ranking: 12-Amy (Dawg got the dash but not the spin) 11-Eggman 10-Sonic 1 9-Sonic 2 8-Shadow 7-Sonic CD 6-Rouge 5-Knuckles 4-Sonic 3 3-Super sonic 2-Tails 1-Metal sonic

[@shellder_gaming]

you should be able to use the electric shield as metal to triple jump

[@Harventhroke]

But like... people that use super sonic are cowardly babies.

[@TrackedToasted]

cool, guess I am one of the lazy ones.

[@A_Stigly_Person]

Tru dat

[@A_Stigly_Person]

It’s best to just remove him from the list in general.

[@sal_dragon]

Glad they added the feature to ban characters from your level in V11.

[@void22222]

@@sal_dragon that was in V10 but bad

[@ANTITHERIANANTIQUADANTIFURRY]

Doctor Robotnik is useless on custom levels, but on the main levels badniks can't attack him

[@M4ximeVRGT]

Yes yes finally like my favorite character

[@StretchyAnimations]

I wouldn’t say his Egman‘s fight is better than tails, but his flight is pretty good in some areas of levels

[@dappleofthedualies]

Well, it goes faster, and it has longer flight overall

[@SherlockSMasters]

When he said about how good Sonic CD spindash is and all Sonic's fans say that Sonic CD spindash is really bad

[@Shimodragon]

well according to classic sonic simulator, amy has the same ability as rouge wich is the ability the other characters dosent have, guess what ability is same

[@Shimodragon]

but it takes longer for tails and robotnik to get up to high places and amy's long jump dosent

[@allenwindsor9879]

Also, you can use a jump cancel so you do not have to time the hammer slams.

[@ScorchingStoleYourToast]

I basically CAN agree with amy rose but if you get used to it (like me), it might be around the middle

[@xiomaraaracena5243]

Also: if you didnt know amy has a ground pound like rouge.

[@pumpkingdounut_official]

Speed is a reward in classic sonic

[@SwagGamer9750]

4:04 *I think Sonic CD's first boss would like to have a small conversation with you.*

[@Livia_Poiana]

exactly

[@sonicx2.0577]

Tails is so broken that i need to put spikes in the roof and the sides just to a tails player not fly trought all my kaizo level

[@xiomaraaracena5243]

Metal sonic actually has a second ability, if he goes fast he can destroy enemies with no rings.

[@fungus8913]

yeah but he must go REALLY fast

[@Austinjackson2216]

How's theres the marble boss

[@Axie_y]

fun fact: if your playing as amy you could jump down instantly and also shes the only one who could do this (if theres any else that could that im missing, please reply to me lol) (yes i mean she has both up and down)

[@SonizzlySirry]

My favourite is Amy she has a twirl like Rouge but diffrent

[@fungus8913]

sonic from sonic 1 might not be the best, but he definitively has the best physics.

[@Kostas_-_-_-999]

Funfact: knuckles has a smaller jump height to the other characters

[@FlashGlove]

And thats why i say that Rouge is Knuckles but better. Knuckles: 3 Other characters (execept I AM THE EGGMAN): 4 I AM THE EGGMAN: 2-

[@Seifeddine345-Mynameinroblox]

You are wrong Tails Can Attack enemies when flying by touching them with his two tails

[@Spring2008]

5:56 Rouge Can Jump More Than knuckles

[@bilessyvaldez6698]

bro i was stayin' alive for years

[@myusernameishi]

as an amy user idk why you put her at the worst tier her spin dash makes her instantly so fast

[@fnafvids2841]

Why does everyone forget about amies hammer samck down

[@BubbleGumGuy-gx1xj]

I actually like sonic 1 sonic, He is like a challenge and I love sonic 1. But not gonna lie robotnik needs to be put a bit higher because it’s fucking robotnik (Jk good list btw)

[@thomasverslycken2563]

For amy, i mean, origins plus didn't exist at the time this came out & even not the can't roll in i believe most official sonic games & sonic 1 sonic, i meeeaaan, he just emulates the sonic 1 gameplay Eggman doesn't have a reason for his flaws, atleast not any i can think of & sonic 2 sonic has not really anything special because he emulates the... well... sonic 2 gameplay

[@realPurpleOrb]

You can really tell how much people use sonic 1 sonic by how they rank him.

[@William_Afton11]

someday i said to my friend in a sonic game (not classic sonic simulator) knuckles can fly my friend didnt know that today i was playing with him as knuckles and i showed him flying knuckles and my friends was confused xd

[@joseferd]

Sonic 1 can only spin dash on mobile, but for pc doesn't work.

[@Natoballdoesstuff_OFF.jontas]

They can't on mobile

[@Duperwrecker3214]

Knuckles’ low jump:

[@Shimodragon]

but theres a mode that allows tails to carry you

[@imhehe25]

You can span spindash so all of the sonic2and3is same as sonic cd

[@tailstheidiot5904]

Sonic 1 sonic doesn’t have a spin dash because in sonic two that’s when the spin dash was made

[@Atrael]

CD actually

[@TarazGamingTB]

Cd was made in 1994 while sonic 2 was made in 1992 so yea so tails your right

[@TarazGamingTB]

Also sonic could roll I sonic 1 by running and pressing down

[@Atrael]

@@TarazGamingTB Sonic CD was in development before Sonic 2 but because of how long it took to make CD, 2 came out first so that means the spindash was originally created in CD

[@TarazGamingTB]

@@Atrael but still sonic 2 came out first so that mean sonic 2 invented the spindash so yea but cd wasnt made yet at the time so still cd did not invent the spindash

[@Shimodragon]

but super sonic takes a unfair advantage and ik a new player is gonna play as super sonic because of how new the player is that theyre just gonna use the unfair advantage

[@Maikcarp_VR]

Rouge and amy both twirled in the air

[@oreganojb]

7:30 actually, tails can kill enemies using fly, but his tails need make contact and this is a little boring Obs: tails can swim

[@loghf718]

Super sonic is better for "just running by" levels. Metal sonic is better for "parkour at platforms" levels.

[@mober7430]

I don’t see the problem with Amy. Skill issue to me bet most of you haven’t really played Amy in any other game including fangames and mods. You also have the extra reach with her hammer but there’s only one boss so thats useless. Still think they should buff her by giving her the hammer glide from the Sonic Mania Plus Mod and buffing her spindash. S1 Sonic is worse. Also all the Sonic’s can use the elemental shields and you only pointed that out for CD Sonic to justify his ranking more. Vyriss should def add “Mania Sonic” he would honestly be top 3. Yeah and like you said the Insta Shield if you time it right you are shielded by anything so it has a very high skill ceiling. My Ranking: #1 Super Sonic #2 Metal Sonic #3 Shadow #4 Tails #5 CD Sonic #6 Rouge #7 Knuckles #8 S3 Sonic #9 Amy #10 S2 Sonic #11 Eggman #12 S1 Sonic

[@barbaradurham5845]

I get your opinion, but what do you expect from Amy eggman knuckles and s1 sonic. And also, it would make no sense whatsoever is eggman had a spindash.

[@tandris1085]

7:30 tails CAN kill eneimes with his tail, I made a level relying on this mechanic of killing eneimes with his tail

[@gamerestboi]

challenge: beat classic sonic simulator (gerrn hill - house) as sonic 1 sonic

[@CypherKakarot]

Nice

[@Always_right123]

How dare you put disrespect on my girl amy’s name