Ranking Every Madden NFL Game From Worst to Best!

In this video, Eric Rayweather will rank every Madden game from worst to best! For more Madden 22, NFL, and other content from Eric Rayweather, make sure to subscribe!
Main Channel: / ericrayweather

[@EricRayweather]

Look at you Eric.

[@Michaelsmithh]

This guy cute tho

[@xxcantwoopmexx1862]

2005 was the best year cuz Madden and NCAA were both 🔥🔥🔥

[@soxnpats4lyfe]

And espn 2k5

[@AntonVitullo]

Madden 05 and fight night round 2 were the very first game I got on the ps2 almost 20 years ago which is crazy

[@martazebrown9803]

Madden 06 and 07 was the best maddens qb vision was a great addition idk why they took it off they ability to look off defenders was lovely

[@xxcantwoopmexx1862]

Madden 06 was the best because it separated the elite passers with the QB Vision imo

[@sjwdestroyer6336]

I miss the vision cone so much

[@soxnpats4lyfe]

Madden 03-08 was the reason madden cant meet my standards today. Mini camp, hit stick, qb vision. The customized screens of my favorite players. 12 year old me was a spoiled football fan 2005 was amazing Madden 05 Espn 2k5 Mvp baseball 2005 All top tier games

[@TheChrisPhoenix]

Don't forget NBA Live 2005, many consider that the greatest NBA Live ever

[@soxnpats4lyfe]

I missed that because I had arguably the 2nd best one which was NBA Live 2004. Sports games in the 03-06 range are just unparalleled

[@Nordic_Eric]

I agree with this list except for 1 thing. In my opinion, Madden 10 is the greatest Madden of all time for one reason.... The Extra Point presentation. At the time, this presentation was absolutely ground shattering, immersive, made you feel like you were watching ESPN or Sportscenter to figure out how teams were doing. Just perfection.

[@DarynKirscht]

Just played Madden 08 today. Love that game! Love the video as well!

[@terranxe7469]

Soundtrack was top tier

[@bobbyray2487]

Agreed! 08 is the best! 1st one I ever played on the ol' xbox 360. I feel like madden hasn't been as good (besides graphics) after 2012

[@DeuceDeucePhantom]

Madden 2000 started everything for me. Mainly because that intro with Ludacris.

[@Catalfanocurse]

Madden ‘04 had rush attack too! Playing that in the dorms all night long. Better than 11 on 11. Made things more personal :)

[@DanDDirges]

Great video! I like watching both your channels. I`m new to Madden and video games in general. I been playing Madden 08 on gamecube emulator the past couple months and recently got a xbox one x and now play Madden 21 as well. The controller layout is completely different. Anyway do you or anyone know how to switch the X and B receivers so they are on opposite sides of the field all the time in Madden 08. On the controller, B is on the right but on the screen he`s on the left and vice versa for the X button. Spent half a day on googoo trying to get an answer to no avail. Anyways keep up the good work!

[@coltonestes393]

I played 04-08 and haven’t touch one since. Was thinking about playing one again. Glad I’m not missing anything

[@BSTVsports]

Madden 02-05 were a three peat for EA. 05 being the best ever to me. It was flawless throughout. 03 was the funnest madden imo. You could get those EA created teams you had to unlock like the monsters. Miss them days💯

[@2kbrady810]

I don't hate that take but imo 06 and 07 was imo

[@kellydavis4456]

05 is my favorite too

[@booboo4ever24]

01-06 was was great for madden. 04 was sick playing with unstoppable Michael Vick. 05 was koo with the hit stick

[@TheWaveRolled]

@@booboo4ever24 01-08,10-12,25

[@noahschakat5712]

06 and 08 were my favorites. Back when even the sound track was good

[@MP-io8ij]

What should I get for Ps4 if I never played anything? 16 over the trash from 18-22 cause a bit better gameplay

[@jacobsparks1214]

They need to bring back create a play where you could create your own formations and make custom run and pass plays🙌

[@penguinrea0088]

God bless you Eric

[@jiliel7887]

08 was so good

[@_Jayskiii_]

Madden 20 was just a really fun game, so many memories

[@GoDigital448]

Facts, especially on MUT

[@_Jayskiii_]

@@GoDigital448 fasho

[@StruggleBoxing]

U should go back and play Madden 06 on Xbox 360. U gonna laugh so hard by how much that game is broken. I threw a pass 90 yrds behind me on the 10 yrd and it was a fumble. Scrambling 90 yards to try and recover a fumble is something I will never forget.

[@KingsRight]

what was the last madden game to have "QB Vision Cone" feature?

[@mexiguero646]

Madden 03 had the best soundtrack.

[@jacksonwillis9457]

Look at Eric man!

[@jackmorgan240]

Look at Eric back on the 2nd channel🔥

[@marcussims1615]

There really wasnt a bad ps2 madden...

[@dustyrhodes2673]

Madden 04🔥🔥

[@zacktaylor8759]

I just got madden 04 and a ps2 and I love it so far.

[@lucaskimble747]

I think you got the top pretty good 04-08 are really the hayday of madden I also really loved madden 12 and im still playing madden 16 because everything since has been absolute trash Madden 64 is the game that made me love football so I gotta mention it at least

[@booboo4ever24]

I've logged the most hours on Madden 03 Marshall Faulk cover, 04 Michael Vick cover the best year, 05 Ray Lewis cover 06 McNabb cover, came back with the PS3 with that 09 Brett Favre cover. Went broke again and came back with that 12 Peyton Hillis #40 Browns fb cover. Took a break, came back with that PS4 O'Dell Beckham Madden 16 cover

[@HitStick98]

I know it sounds crazy but madden 07 on the wii is one of my favorite games of all time

[@cornelbutler3470]

I just subbed Eric

[@fawnnahh7438]

Eric, do you think you can rank the NCAA games? I always enjoyed them more than Madden.

[@reygonzalez2179]

For me madden 15,16 and 20 were the the most fun I had out of any madden games. 19 was just terrible

[@kidkokonut4581]

Madden07 in PS2. Best Presentation, best Franchise.

[@Dudeonwheels]

2005 is my personal favorite.

[@lbvols22]

This channel is the best TOO!

[@Johnnybox81]

As a Brit who only got into American Football the last few years, I'm itching to play a Madden game. However, playing older games - I won't know half the players. Playing newer games feels like I'm propping up EA's terrible buisness practices plus it sounds like the older games were better...

[@jonitalia6748]

I recommend you get ESPN 2K5 with updated rosters

[@jonitalia6748]

I recommend you get ESPN 2K5 with updated rosters

[@yief3194]

EA really needs to bring back rock soundtracks rather than this modern trash

[@dariusdafigga]

Unpopular opinion but I got back in to Madden after like a 10+ year break the my freshman year of college 2018 so my first game was technically Madden 19. I have so many fond memories having my boys come to my room and we play madden for hours beating one another. We would literally set the quarters to 1 minute to get a quick game in before class lol. So I don’t hate that game no matter how bad everyone says it is. I know the gameplay wasn’t as polished or realistic but none of us knew any better since they were all soccer players & I hadn’t played Madden in over a decade. I know my opinion is biased but I would put it at decent for me 😃

[@SaabJayce01]

What's the website

[@wernald2117]

Madden 07 is my favorite. I still play it today on the Wii because the new games are so bad.

[@NoScopingRedPikmin]

Madden 08 is literally the madden game I always go back to

[@SethAustin405]

Madden 03 - 08 was 🔥 Say what you will about Madden 12. I thought 12 on the 360 was complete!

[@kevinschindele4829]

04 07 08 2012 I loved playing safety on superstar mode in 2012 that was the last good Madden in my opinion

[@bobbyscott8322]

In 2005 the game came with NFL Sunday ticket. Mr. Barry on the cover.

[@WeAreSoBackBros]

Madden 13 was the best gameplay wise. Idc about make believe stuff like franchise, MUT, other football flavored dungeons and dragons stuff. They’re even adding zone defense back to madden 23 havent had that since madden 13

[@trot1310]

Madden 11 🐐

[@nicholasfinnigan9955]

18 is the worst to me in all sports games period I think 13 is trash too 19 isn't much better nor is the entire 4th gen era I think madden 04-08 on ps2 is the goat of course I think 15 had some decent Balance between corners and wrs 20 -22 are basically the same i dont think the arcadey xfactors thing is really worth having

[@heatherblanton2457]

Madden 08 is my favorite. Then 07.

[@stevenenglish3968]

They need to talk to whoever created 06 and try and put it in todays game

[@gokuson1234]

Madden 07 on GameCube was top tier

[@naseemspeach]

Great video, I Agree with most… but I can’t lie, madden 13 and 21 were sooo trash to me😭

[@jordanbabcock8494]

Can you score a touchdown with lagarette blount in every madden

[@bryansouza16]

Its so drastically different to see how most of the maddens in the early 2000s were some of the best madden games...and then the exclusivity rights kicked in, and then it was in the ok to good categories...and then ultimate team came and now most of those games fail to even be decent or memorable. Madden is awful now. Im glad i still have madden 07 to go back to whenever i wanna get a fix of football

[@booboo4ever24]

I wish I never missed a game in my prime, I don't remember 07, 08, 10, 11

[@djohnson504x3]

I agree with this list for the most part, me personally, I hated madden 25 and still hate it, definitely would have been in the trash category for me

[@CJSLFindaer]

I totally agree with your rankings, but I am disappointed you said "every" and had images of the old Maddens but then didn't rank them. If not including them, fine, but why have their images up?

[@mikedollaz3053]

Madden 07 hall a fame edition

[@ejcalii2253]

1. madden 07 2. madden 06 3. madden 08 4. madden 04 5. madden 11

[@booboo4ever24]

01, 03,0️⃣4️⃣,05,06 best years. Honorable mentions 09, 12, 16, 21

[@xtheprodigy02x]

Madden 2003 of you include the soundtrack

[@coltonlombardo4673]

Would be awesome if the f’ing file share would work

[@Maal7432]

My Madden rankings IMO: 1. 2004 2. 07 PS2 3. 2003 4. 08 PS2/360 5. 06 PS2 6. 2002 7. Madden 25 8. 2001

[@yungsamus6662]

Everyone has their favorite Madden somehow i think Madden 2003 on ps2 is the best one.

[@obiethepony2827]

And NFL 2K5 tops all.

[@teezzy.o2663]

Madden 16 - one handed catching madden madden 20 99 over all DeAndre Nuk Hopkins

[@IRUNNNEWY0RK]

I loved madden 10 🐐 on 360 06 on ps2 🔥

[@ericlee3456]

06 was one of the trash ish ones…. I hated that cone vision thing lol

[@IRUNNNEWY0RK]

@@ericlee3456 wow really loved it all the qbs visions was different

[@kidkudoD1]

Thank you bro of course another nyer would agree with me lmao 10 for 360 GOAT hands down especially when you have NCAA 10 and you import ya players to franchise shit too GOATed

[@fizzy360wolf]

I heard Madden Football 64 was so bad that the NFL didn't want anything to do with it. So they didn't put their license on it.

[@emmanuelmarthol3156]

07 was the best

[@wingoreviewsboxingandmma3667]

The first madden that came out on the original PS2 and Xbox was the best ever in my opinion. Sad that it's trash now

[@daylonsmith5283]

I agree with everything but move Madden 10 up. It was one of the best Madden games ever

[@yellowjesus6793]

97 was the best

[@JacobMathewsPanoxol]

Madden 12 and 17 were good

[@jjdilon1765]

99,03,07,12&16 for me.

[@Blackboy-ye7bk]

Madden 18 is the best madden ever 😒💯

[@ericlee3456]

2004!!!!

[@allenmitchell3534]

The Server is down again

[@penguinrea0088]

Always keep God first

[@Planclanman3]

Madden 15 was the worst one because they had absolutely stripped the game of all fun. It was barebones, the user sucked. Passing hasn't gotten the catch animations yet, ball carrier moves were cheesy and everything felt scripted. 16 was awful because the aggressive catches were extremely broken. 17-18 were still developing and had no identity. 19 and 20 were god awful. They tried to be too realistic and too new at the same time and ended up feeling terrible. 21/22 were decent and broken in certain ways

[@rodrecusadams]

2018 to 2022 are trash can't challenge plays no booth review

[@Jok3rzGrinn]

Madden 20 needs it's own category, I can't imagine worst gameplay then that garbage.

[@almiightyslvmp]

madden 19

[@ThreeKing74]

I’m sorry, but Madden 11 was pure GARBAGE. It’s was so poorly developed. If I’m not mistaken, they fired the main developer from that game.

[@thefitgurutv]

Ian Cummings

[@jamesterry391]

M 2022 ps4 ps3 25

[@yolkyboi5916]

Bro Madden 06 was trash the game was glitchy and I might be wrong but I think superstar mode wasn't in Madden 06 -_-

[@yolkyboi5916]

But on the PS2 and OG XBOX it was fire asf

[@TheStanleyfrederique]

My top 5 favorite Madden list #1 Madden 04 #2 Madden 03 # 3 Madden 07 # 4 Madden 25 # 5 Madden 01

[@yolkyboi5916]

@@TheStanleyfrederique bro Madden 03 was my favorite Madden lmao

[@iguodolafrancisco2349]

(No Order) 01 04 05 06 12

[@KrusteyDaKlown]

If your talking PS2/Xbox then yea 06 was good. If your talking 360 it's arguably the worst Madden of all time.

[@carterbontya1227]

nfl

[@benburr677]

17 sucks to running game was so trash 🗑

[@justicesmith3153]

2nd

[@brandonpoley]

22 is baddddddd

[@atown27]

Madden 13 is the worst ever!

[@joeylockwood9341]

Nah bro franchise fuvkin sucks you can’t even see the standings if you playing as a player

[@joeylockwood9341]

They removed the pop up that would come up when your close to breaking a record like break so and so record with a td pass that used to come up

[@joeylockwood9341]

Franchise mode is so shit compared to every other sports game commentary has been ass since Brandon gaudin and fuckin Charles Davis 22 sucks this year they also made MUT ridiculously Grindy to wear I didn’t play mut this year

[@joeylockwood9341]

Nothing about franchise mode is immersive or fun

[@ribertmoose]

Why u talking to urself

[@imheaty9947]

In mine opinion madden 20 was great game

[@ribertmoose]

I can see why you like it, even though I dont

[@yolkyboi5916]

hey, you enjoy it and that's good. Wish I could enjoy newer Madden games :/

[@_Jayskiii_]

It definitely was a great game set the blueprint for following games

[@_Jayskiii_]

Madden 25 was trashhhh