Ranking EVERY Paper Mario Game From WORST TO BEST (Top 7 Games + Bonus Game)

Howdy everyone, and today we are ranking the Paper Mario series from worst to best! With a bonus game! Let me know your favorites down below! Shoutout to my 1 patreon as well!
#papermario #papermariothethousandyeardoor #papercraft

[@BePostiveStayHydrated]

My 3 favs would be 1. Paper mario 2. Paper Mario TTYD 3. Super paper mario

[@Max-rv8mu]

Wow so original

[@skc4188]

@@Max-rv8mu Maybe people would come up with a different ranking if the later PM games weren't hot messes

[@uroskesic6117]

My favorite one is TOK

[@Buster5ive]

I agree. The Original Paper Mario has a special place in my heart. And I’ve played it more times than I can count.

[@mickeymoose9368]

Unpopular Opinion (because it was the first and my favorite Paper Mario game I played): 1. Super Paper Mario 2. TTYD 3. Original 4. Origami King Never played the other two

[@Max-rv8mu]

You don’t have to colour splash is mid and sticker star is dogshit

[@TopTierGamerMan]

SPM is definently at least top 3 in my books.

[@sebas1395]

Love Super Paper Mario.

[@JeremyVelez-pr1te]

Loving super paper Mario

[@liamconnollyst]

Here's my ranking based on interest: 7: Sticker Star 6: Colour Splash 5: M&L: Paper Jam 4: Origami King 3: Super Paper Mario 2: Paper Mario 1: The Thousand Year Door

[@Worst_Evil]

Paper Jam above Color Splash? Super over TOK? Correct me if I'm wrong, but I feel like you're biased against the newer games, seeing as you only moved down said games

[@slenderfoxx3797]

@@Worst_Evil his ranking is just facts 😏

[@BePostiveStayHydrated]

@@Worst_Evil Dont get me wrong but origami king is the newest paper mario game and it is 4th place out of all 7 games. And on top of that Original is older than ttyd and he put ttyd over original. No he doesnt hate newer games he just did not like their style or liked those games hut perfered the style of an older game compared to the newer ones.

[@diegocaru]

Mine is pretty much the same, with the only diference is having Color Splash over Paper Jam, I feel like Color Splash is extremely underrated.

[@slenderfoxx3797]

My ranking is: 6) PM Sticker Star 5) PM Colour Splash 4) PM The Origami King 3) Paper Mario 64 2) Super Paper Mario 1) PM The Thousand Year Door

[@jedprice7002]

Your list is literally the exact same as mine lol. Liked your thoughts and perspective! Also: cement

[@just-intime9988]

Paper Jam is technically more of a Mario & Luigi game than a Paper Mario game. Also, while I wouldn’t call it a bad game, it’s very weak compared to the other games in the series.

[@SaneiStudios]

eh i’m late but i’ll just put this here 7: sticker star 6: origami 5: paper jam 4: super paper mario 3: paper mario (N64) 2: TTYD 1: color splash

[@Foreleus]

I do agree color splash is a really good and funny as shit game tbh

[@leoah-yane1770]

For me 6) sticker star 5) paper mario ( is not a bad game ! ) 4) paper mario color splash 3) super paper mario 2) paper mario the origami king 1) paper mario TTYD

[@Max-rv8mu]

I love you for putting origami king at number 2

[@leoah-yane1770]

@@Max-rv8mu thx

[@dylantheanimator8404]

​@@Max-rv8mu I agree with this

[@Foreleus]

Heh my list is similar but origami king and paper Mario are swapped :) I personally hated origami king but that’s me :)

[@leoah-yane1770]

@@Foreleus for me origami king is underrated, is game's as default yes, but compare to other paper mario, he's good but is just for me ! Thank's for your opinion !

[@TopTierGamerMan]

Since I just finished ttyd, here's my tier list: 1.Color Splash 2. Origami King 3. Super Paper Mario 4. 64 5. TTYD 6. Sticker Star Also I completely agree with the paper jam take, its like Kirby in Smash: SO MUCH POTENTIAL and they threw it out the window. Still loved it though.

[@RoboMarioBros]

This gotta be a troll

[@Foreleus]

Interesting list I personally disagree but that’s my opinion

[@TopTierGamerMan]

@@Foreleus understandable, have a nice day.

[@TheRealHedgehogSonic]

You put SUPER below Origami King!? The turn based battle in Origami King got so old so fast, while Super still had the best story and a lot of the other concepts that made Paper Mario good. TOK felt just like a "There, HAPPY!?" from Nintendo with its returning mechanics. Also, pavement.

[@derrickray4666]

The graphics and world is beautiful tho

[@uroskesic6117]

Soo is the music

[@IHaveToEscapeTheVoid]

Origami king is actually a great game. I love it SO MUCH. I got it when I came out. It was actually amazing. There were real sad moments in it. It actually made me cry.

[@nathanwright4967]

It's disappointing that we haven't gotten Switch ports for 1000 year door and WindWaker. My two favorite GameCube games.

[@jasonwitt8268]

It's your lucky day

[@JohnLucPicard98]

You lucked out so hard 😂

[@Nick-gy6ed]

I honestly hope they’ll port Super Paper Mario too someday. I played it back when I was a child and it was one of my favorite wii games

[@scottnito2640]

Origami kings battle style is terrible for me. It doesn’t click at all and I do not have fun. Sadly I’ve still not finished that game. It’s really good in every part that’s not combat

[@xabitron]

1.super 2.origami 3.color splash 4.64 5.sticker star i have not played ttyd

[@monsterhighforeverafter7206]

I LOVE MIMI!! Best thing to come out of Papee Mario🙌

[@Tronked]

My list: 7 colour splash 6 sticker star 5 paper jam 4 origami king 3 paper mario 2 super paper mario 1 thousand year door

[@rpgranked]

Let me guess, Bug Fables is the bonus game Edit: Knew it.

[@uroskesic6117]

Finally some love for the origami 😊

[@Hi-fd4cw]

Drinking game idea: take a shot every time the word “sticker” is said during the sticker star segment

[@ericm215]

Mario needs shy guy and ninji partners

[@Jimmygaming711]

6: Sticker Star 5: Color Splash 4: Thousand Year Door 3: Origami King 2: Super Paper Mario 1: Paper Mario 64

[@Jimmygaming711]

@dread1420 because I like the top 3 better

[@countquackula8539]

I despised The Origami King's combat system. It felt like a repetitive chore. I avoided battles as much as I could.

[@Worst_Evil]

TOKs battle system is a pretty interesting topic. Basically it's either hit or miss, you love it or hate it. There isn't really an in between.

[@gonefist]

@@Worst_Evil you are protecting tok as if your life depends on it, and the fact you said its better than spm shows you only played tok

[@priceycelery911]

@@gonefisti prefer tok battle system then the og 2 if im honest

[@gonefist]

@@priceycelery911 ☠️

[@priceycelery911]

@@gonefist just my opinion tho

[@Blutao22]

Damn I’m trying to play the others since I’ve only played Sticker Star and liked it just to find out it’s the worst amongst most people. At least I know I’ll love the others

[@kledbul2843]

sticker star on 1👆🏼

[@xnoiceboix1201]

Ive played every single game on this list and i still think origami king is the best one. The first 2 games honestly to me feel very basic in comparison

[@Wario1382]

1. Thousand Year Door 2. Origami King 3. 64 4. Super 5. Color Splash 6. Sticker Star

[@Zilla17707]

1. Thousand year door 2. Paper Mario 3. Origami king 4. Super paper Mario 5. Color splash 6. Sticker Star

[@Phantommmx]

My Opinion is very Unpopular so don't hate, but before I say it, I enjoy every game. To me, none of them are bad. 1. Color Splash 2. TTYD 3. Origami King 4. Super 5. PM 64 6. Sticker Star 7. Paper Jam

[@sensitiivv_]

why color splash on top? besides the humor there isn’t anything that makes it better than than any of the other games besides sticker star

[@BigShowGunnoe]

Can some explain why anyone would believe the original Paper Mario is better than TTYD? I don't get it.

[@LearningWithMrHolt]

The areas are bigger. There’s one more partner. Ttyd does a lot of things that kinda just waste time (the backtracking in ch 4,5, and 7, or having to go to the door every chapter). The dungeons were bigger. The map/world was more cohesive (you exclusively traveled by pipe or vehicle to new lands in ttyd). I ultimately think ttyd is better, but paper mario was a REALLY good game that definitely did some things better than ttyd. So I could see how some people like it better.

[@pummi1176]

I would rank the games like this 1.Paper Mario the Thousand year door 2.Paper Mario 3.super paper Mario 4.Paper Mario thr Origami King 5.Paper Mario sticker star 6.Mario and Luigi paper jam bros 7.Paper Mario color splash

[@TransformersFan1991]

Paper Mario 64 is the only Paper Mario game I can tolerate because it had many references to Super Mario World and Yoshi's Island.

[@scrungel6003]

Nice List! Also cement das conk creet baybee

[@taylorhession1905]

None of these will ever top Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars.

[@justintendo4302]

For me it goes 7. Sticker Star (Yes, everything that has been said before. The combat is terrible, the story is terrible, there’s no unique characters or world environments, the puzzles in the game are terribly designed leaving you with no indication of what to do. Although, chapter 4 is okay with the enigmansion being genuinely fun to go through but the rest of the game is just a slog. And whoever thought it would be a good idea for bowser not to speak at all completely dropped the ball) 6. Paper Jam (Essentially like sticker star with its characters and worlds however the story is slightly better and the gameplay is much better than sticker star but nothing compared to the previous Mario and Luigi or paper Mario games) 5. Color Splash (In some ways a huge improvement over Sticker Star. The writing is so much better and the worlds have a bit more creativity to them. The worlds feel like mini chapters, feeling like they took the idea of the enigmansion and built on it. I overall did enjoy it a lot but the battle system was terrible however the graphics were gorgeous.) 4. Origami King (Definitely by far the strongest of the new Paper Mario Trilogy. I loved the writing and the world felt much more alive with it being fully interconnected like the original two. In some ways it could make top 3 games for me, however it still suffers a bit from the characters designs. However I did love the graphics again. Initially I thought I’d hate the idea of the legion of stationery being the bosses but the writing for them was just excellent and the battle system itself for the bosses was excellent and I found it really engaging and required a lot of strategy. However the same can’t be said for the regular battles which are generally just pointless and a bit of a chore. But overall it does feel a lot like the original 2 games with its progression which does give it extra points but it’s lack of many original characters brings it down a bit. The story is an improvement over the previous 2 games with Olly and Olivia and they brought bowser back to his role in the games being fun and comic relief) 3. Super Paper Mario (First Paper Mario I played. The gameplay is okay but nothing special. Where the game really shines a lot is in its story which is absolutely incredible and it’s atmosphere. I think if it wasn’t for the story and it’s characters this game wouldn’t be this high and origami king might’ve overtaken it but as it stands I have to have this game at number 3.) 2. 64 (The original game is simply fantastic. It has the basic bowser kidnaps peach storyline however there’s extra layers and details to it which is where the game just really shines imo. The characters are memorable, the chapters are memorable and the gameplay is great too. Overall just an excellent game and I love it a lot. Plus it has my favourite chapter in the whole series with chapter 7) 1. TTYD (A cliche i know however this game imo is just the pinnacle of what Nintendo can do when they really get creative with Mario. The worlds, the characters, the atmosphere, the story, the chapters, the gameplay all fantastic and memorable. This game really builds on what the first game did and cranks it up a lot especially with that twist at the end. I hope one day we can finally get a sequel that builds on this game like it did to the original and I’m more hopeful than ever with the remake coming next year)

[@Nojjhhhhh]

My ranking 6: Super paper Mario 5: paper Mario 4: Thousand year door 3: Origami king 2: paper jam 1: Color splash

[@Hi-fd4cw]

I hope you mean 6 is best and 1 is worst, because if not… Yikes

[@Nojjhhhhh]

@@Hi-fd4cw just my opinion 😂

[@Devilsaur]

I aint played most of these but heres my rating 3. Paper mario 2.Origami king 1. Paper jam

[@Foreleus]

My ranking: 6: stick star: poor story, poor combat, poor characters and designs, the only highlight is the music and even that isn’t the best of the best. Overall poor game 5: origami king: the combat system is annoying as shit and the story was interesting at first until we heard olly’s motivation. Olly is pathetic as shit and hot take I find Olivia annoying so I’m not a fan of her personally. Music is ok at best better than sticker star. I didn’t finish the game cause I got tired as shit of the gameplay and watched a let’s play for the rest. I prefer sticker star’s combat over origami king’s combat 4: color splash: this game is funny as shit and that’s basically the only positive I can say. The combat is slightly improved from sticker star and bowser is better but still poor. Overall it’s passable for me and I did have a decent time with it 3: super paper Mario: I’m a story person and the story hard carries super paper Mario, but the gameplay is poor. It’s easy as shit I do enjoy the designs though. Tbh color splash and super are very close and depending on the day I can lean to either or. If the story wasn’t so godly good super would be like 6 or 5 overall I love this game’s story but everything else for the most part is average 2: paper Mario 64: the story is weak but aside from that it’s a really good game. From character to gameplay to music to designs it’s all iconic and really good I had a great time with it 1: ttyd: it basically improved on everything that paper Mario 64 did. Better story better combat system, better character with actual story archs higher stakes, everything is improved the only “flaw” with the game is its minor backtracking issue, but if that’s all I can find it’s literally a great game. One of the best out there Overall 2 games I didn’t enjoy so good track record plus this is my opinion nothing about my list is objective take it as you will

[@l0bbymusicx314]

Hot take 6) Sticker star 5) color splash 4) super paper Mario 3) paper Mario 2 thousand year door 1) origami king

[@uroskesic6117]

Woooooo 😃

[@Level1gyatt2789]

Same

[@enygma1313]

I never got to play TTYD and I see its coming out on the Switch soon should I get it? Literally the first one I played was Origami King and the battle system is INCREDIBLY annoying but I love the open world play

[@ChrisMS0815]

Yes you should get it, if you havn't played PM64 it's battle system is an improved version of PM64. Have you played PM64? If not it's on Switch so you can get an idea of what TTYD will play like. Not only is the world fun to explore but the battle system is actually good unlike Oragami King plus you also get a far better story than Oragami King, Color Splaah and especially Sticker Star.

[@rpgranked]

7. Sticker Star 6. Paper Jam 5. 64 4. Color Splash 3. Super 2. TTYD 1. Origami King

[@sensitiivv_]

why is 64 so low and origami king at the top

[@rpgranked]

@@sensitiivv_ I played all of them recently, I'm just telling the truth of how I felt... a game isn't only defined by it's battle system...

[@sensitiivv_]

@@rpgranked you’re right. imo the story in TTYD gaps every other pm game, the characters and dialogue weren’t that good in origami king, the only thing they really got right was the aesthetic

[@manoahmakes]

Super paper mario is my favorite

[@BrysonBorchers]

your opinion is correct

[@manoahmakes]

@@BrysonBorchers it was my litteral childhood and where i learned how to pronounce idiot

[@rdj900]

my ranking: 1: ttyd 2: paper mario 64 3: origami king

[@rpgranked]

Are you saying Bug Fables is the second best? Or were you just mentioning it?

[@Noah-11.21]

I always thought sticker star was amazing, probably because it was my first one played, but i jever knew it was this hated and its everyones least favorite. I still think its really good after playing a few other ones

[@Level1gyatt2789]

Hot take, origami king is the best

[@Tejiknasten]

My top 7, this far: 1. Paper Mario 2. Color Splash (The writing makes this game a joy to play) 3. Origami King 4. Thousand year door 5. Paper Jam 6. Super Paper Mario 7. Sticker star

[@ssomenerdd]

I love how EVERY paper mario fan no matter if they like color splash or super or origami king all agree "yeah FUCK STICKER STAR"

[@fatnakedjimmyneutron]

How can you rate Origami King over SPM? You can't even level up! There's no point to battles when there is no progression. The game is literally a broken mess

[@mickeymoose9368]

Not to mention the STORY alone, as he explained 🤦‍♀️

[@eydasdendavejonge7740]

I liked origami king way more than spm. I hate everything about spm gameplay.

[@tf2scout16]

Because SPM is mid as fuck. It’s honestly baffling how it escaped the paper Mario hate circlejerk since it has shit level design and mediocre gameplay. The only reason people talk about it is its fanfic tier story

[@SkilledHooper]

Because it’s his opinion

[@mickeymoose9368]

@@tf2scout16 That is an opinion if I’ve heard one from a very biased fan 😬. Look, I will never touch Sticker Star, but I don’t hate on it. Same with Color Splash. I might not like it, but some people do. You don’t have to be so aggressive about my favorite Paper Mario game aka, the first one I ever played 😂.

[@jiggling86]

Sticker Star is the best game

[@JerginBootwyler]

I agree with everything on your list except oragami king, for me thats 4 and super paper mario is 3

[@TopOfAllWorlds]

I i can see why you'd rate origami king over spm. I disagree with you because characters and story matters more to me, and I feel like Origami kings gameplay is worse. ^_^

[@BrysonBorchers]

super paper mario was ranked incorrectly, it’s the best one out of all of them

[@xDomaTV]

not even close to the first two

[@Worst_Evil]

This ranking is identical to mine (though I'm yet to play 64 or TTYD)

[@XsYoutube]

How have you never played the 2 best ones

[@Max-rv8mu]

Dang that’s sad

[@ChrisMS0815]

Play PM64, it's on Switch Online right now, it holds up very well and it would be nice to play it before TTYD Remake comes out.

[@priceycelery911]

6 super 5 ttyd 4 64 3 sticker star 2 color splash 1 tok

[@Max-rv8mu]

This is an April fools joke right?

[@priceycelery911]

@@Max-rv8mu nope my opinion

[@eydasdendavejonge7740]

@@priceycelery911i have the exact same ranking !

[@michaelsnyder421]

Must’ve been Opposite Day when you posted this. Sticker Star is universally recognized as trash.

[@priceycelery911]

@@michaelsnyder421 nope this is my exact ranking i like all of them tho

[@Everweed420]

I would have liked oragami king if it weren't for the battle system i wish there was a way to skip it. Paper mario battles have become so annoying and made it so i couldnt finish a paper mario game past the first two. Idk why they had to go so far away from the rog turn based element just because of mario and luigi being their rpg which is such a narrow dumb way of thinking like how they ruined the new yoshi island its terrible. They can make a million 2d platformers but can only have 1 rpg when the mario world seems to thrive more from rpg games than even the platformers. Like the ones that they released that were good rpg games are some of the best like mario rpg epic first 2 paper mario and mario luigi games are epic games and the mario rabbids games are cool so idk why they are trying to limit themselves from having good content like they keep wanting to create all these gimicks and find new cool styles of games and failing like its cool they're experimenting but i wish they did it more as a side project like have gimicky paper mario games releasing but still have a main rpg style paper mario releasing

[@YadugovindM]

Why Delete this ?

[@Level1gyatt2789]

Ttyd is probably the weakest

[@polar9984]

I honestly think origami king is close to being as bad as sticker star. That battle system was pure ass.

[@leoah-yane1770]

That your opinion but origami king Was objectively a very Good game

[@polar9984]

@@leoah-yane1770 how is it objectively a good game?💀 sounds like just your opinion bud.

[@Livio_05]

well in my opinion origami king is literally the best paper mario game there is. The battle system was something new, and i guess it just depends on if you like that system or not (i personally loved it), but nontheless the rest of the game was fantastic imo

[@polar9984]

@@Livio_05 have you played all the others?

[@leoah-yane1770]

@@polar9984 yes i have play all paper mario, my favourite is ttyp, but i love origami king too

[@jussblur1361]

idk why ppl hate sticker star i loved that game 💀

[@mickeymoose9368]

How? HOW could you rank Super Paper Mario BELOW Paper Mario and the Origami King?!🤦‍♀️

[@Livio_05]

cuz origami king is a wonderful game, i played both spm and tok and id rank tok on top actually

[@handsomelyditto4215]

if you like origami king you likely have a extra chromosome

[@l0bbymusicx314]

if you dislike origami king that extremely then you likely have a extra chromosome