RANKING ITZY & AESPA & NMIXX & IVE & KEP1ER & (G)I-DLE & LOONA & STAYC (+ 3 MORE)

ᴛʜᴇ ᴠɪᴅᴇᴏ ɪꜱ ʙᴀꜱᴇᴅ ᴏɴ ᴍʏ ᴘᴇʀꜱᴏɴᴀʟ ᴏᴘɪɴɪᴏɴ. ᴀɴᴅ, ɪꜱ ɴᴏᴛ ᴍᴇᴀɴᴛ ꜰᴏʀ ʙᴀꜱʜɪɴɢ ᴀɴʏ ɪᴅᴏʟ.
♥︎
☃︎ S͎o͎c͎i͎a͎l͎s͎ ☃︎
𝙸𝚗𝚜𝚝𝚊𝚐𝚛𝚊𝚖 ☁︎ / jxnnirenefilez
𝚃𝚠𝚒𝚝𝚝𝚎𝚛 ☁︎ / renesjensbxtch
𝚁𝚘𝚋𝚕𝚘𝚡 ☁︎ www.roblox.com/users/85304643...
ᶠᵒʳ ᵇᵘˢⁱⁿᵉˢˢ ᵖᵘʳᵖᵒˢᵉˢ ᵒⁿˡʸ - [e-mail]
★
˜”*°•.˜”*°•〈ꜰᴀQ〉•°*”˜.•°*”˜
⚬ 𝚆𝚑𝚊𝚝’𝚜 𝚢𝚘𝚞𝚛 𝚗𝚊𝚖𝚎?
⇢ Sana (She/Her)
⚬ 𝚆𝚑𝚊𝚝 𝚍𝚘 𝚢𝚘𝚞 𝚞𝚜𝚎 𝚝𝚘 𝚎𝚍𝚒𝚝?
⇢ iMovie & VLLO
⚬ 𝙷𝚘𝚠 𝚘𝚕𝚍 𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝚢𝚘𝚞?
⇢ 15
⚬ 𝚆𝚑𝚊𝚝 𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝚢𝚘𝚞𝚛 𝚞𝚕𝚝𝚒𝚖𝚊𝚝𝚎 𝚐𝚛𝚘𝚞𝚙𝚜?
⇢ Blackpink, Red velvet, Stray Kids, Aespa, TXT, Twice, BTS, ITZY, Stayc
⚬ 𝚆𝚑𝚊𝚝 𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝚢𝚘𝚞𝚛 𝚋𝚒𝚊𝚜𝚎𝚜 𝚏𝚛𝚘𝚖 𝚝𝚑𝚎 𝚊𝚋𝚘𝚟𝚎 𝚐𝚛𝚘𝚞𝚙𝚜?
⇢ Jennie, Irene, Lee Know (OT8), Karina, Yeonjun, Mina, Jungkook/Jin, Chaeryeong/Ryujin, Sumin/Seeun
⚽︎ 𝕊𝕦𝕓𝕤𝕔𝕣𝕚𝕓𝕖𝕣𝕤 𝔾𝕠𝕒𝕝
16ᴋ
-𝐃𝐨𝐧'𝐭 𝐩𝐢𝐜𝐤 𝐟𝐢𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬 𝐣𝐮𝐬𝐭 𝐛𝐞𝐜𝐚𝐮𝐬𝐞 𝐲𝐨𝐮 𝐡𝐚𝐯𝐞 𝐟𝐫𝐞𝐞 𝐭𝐢𝐦𝐞 𝐢𝐧 𝐲𝐨𝐮𝐫 𝐡𝐚𝐧𝐝𝐬, 𝐎𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐫𝐬 𝐡𝐚𝐯𝐞 𝐢𝐦𝐩𝐨𝐫𝐭𝐚𝐧𝐭 𝐭𝐡𝐢𝐧𝐠𝐬 𝐭𝐨 𝐝𝐨 🙂

[@Minty_Sana]

The vocal ranking is hugely based on a vocalist’s Vocal Support and then, pitch, consistency, stability, technique, etc, were taken into consideration. Jiyoon and above are the vocalists who have support, even if it’s shallow/inconsistent it’s better than none (jiyoon can arguably support, with stylic approach that is) This video was in editing for a long, I tried to make the vocal ranking as ‘accurate’ as possible. If there is any error you can comment ‘with’ reasons, or else I won’t consider it. ~-~-~ Besides that, the rap ranking is completely based on my taste (I did take flow, delivery, pronunciation into consideration but didn’t go in as deep as the vocal ranking) ~-~-~ I have trained as a classical dancer for almost 8 years, And hence, the dance ranking was ranked from my pov. 🙉

[@katykim]

You don't have make a ranking based on technique people need learn some rankings are based ones opinions

[@juliawilliams3682]

Hi! I just had a few questions, I’ve watched some of your previous videos and was wondering why a few things changed. I was wondering why you decided to bump up both Liz and Sieun? Also why you moved down Haseul, Chuu, and Bae? I’m really starting to get interested in vocal technique so I was just curious too see your thought process. Thank you for making these videos!

[@Minty_Sana]

Liz has good support, Sieun has support too. Haseul is very shallow, she has a good head voice but it’s still underdeveloped, bae currently degraded in the sense she has more of a stylic approach, chuu is quite nasal when going high

[@navisoori5391]

Top 5 best vocalist in 4th gen so far Nayul A3-D5/Eb5 (resonant) Yaechan (resonant) G3/G#3-C#5-F#5 Ningning F#3/G3-C5/C#5-F5 Lily A3/Bb3-C5-F5

[@katykim]

@@navisoori5391 Monday?

[@sun_623]

Monday, NingNing and Lily are the main vocalists of this generation ❤️

[@BOSS-nz2hw]

If Haewon is a main vocalist, she is also part of this Holy 4.

[@randomsheep1165]

Pink Fantasy Yeachan ♡

[@user-pj8oe2rn5v]

@@BOSS-nz2hw she is!

[@aikatsudash4833]

Chaeryeong is not only the best dancer here but also one of the best female dancer in the industry, and I feel like she’s improving comeback after comeback, it’s just a matter of time until she becomes a top5 best female dancer

[@lovelcy8461]

100% and she’s definitely in top 5!!

[@ulauelu]

@@sanatmanhare5912 she very much is and the only female idol along with her sister that came from the 4th gen

[@randomsheep1165]

@@ulauelu maybe she's top 5 in terms of current active current girl groups, but 3rd and especially 2nd gen had some great dancers we can't forget about imo

[@re1kolux]

Mhm prolly in the top 10

[@ulauelu]

@@randomsheep1165 imo it would be 1.Hyoyeon 2.hyolyeon 3.Boa 4.momo/Lisa 5.chaer siblings

[@skaielvs_]

Heejin and karina are like the all rounders of this gen....plus Yena

[@JuJu-ki8cg]

i cant tell if yena or chaeyeon is the all rounder of izone tbh

[@Max-ly2tj]

@@JuJu-ki8cg probably yena, chaeyeon excels in dancing but isnt as good as a vocalist since she doesnt support and isnt as good as rapping

[@everglow6378]

Plus Mia

[@soomiewleng5227]

I think they should be more all rounders on ur list ,is not like there aces which are harder to have.

[@HELLO-vi8nq]

Giselle is a rapper with vocal support. Her flow, tone and pronunciation are just satisfying

[@iamspooky2209]

yepp

[@lisaicanmeow5157]

Monday, Lily and Ningning The 4th Gen. BEST VOCALIST!

[@heuniofied]

@@challiev don't forget yechan

[@tastethatpinkpussy5595]

Its Nayul and Lily

[@mydearpiano]

and jiwon.

[@lisaicanmeow5157]

@@challiev who's Nayul? The Minseo u mentioned is Minseo of WooAh!?

[@lisaicanmeow5157]

@@mydearpiano Jiwon of?

[@aysathulrameela9947]

Hey minty Sana did u watch Aespa's Coachella performance??? They absolutely rocked the stage with their stage presence and vocals 🤧🤧

[@leafleaf6575]

@@Manchis123 y are u saying this to her ?? May I know ?

[@taasnimzaman5622]

No they were good but their vocals were shaky and Stage presence was still boring

[@MORDHWAZ]

Still Ning Ning best vocalist of 4th generation

[@tzuyurs]

@@MORDHWAZ I think Lily (NMIXX) and Ningning

[@rigsfsg]

sp? must be a joke

[@jodellmahinay3068]

Haewon low in dance? Like girl?? Have you ever seen her freestyle dance?.. Yes she isn't in the dance line but damn so good in dancing!

[@si_multifandom_ch_5099]

Ironically, Haewon is really in top 3 best NMIXX dancers lol

[@chewieqtpie]

JYP did her dirty not adding her to the dance line

[@durgashankar5008]

True she always put Aespa members on Top

[@durgashankar5008]

@@Forever_2424 Yes! Karina is one of her ultimate bias so she always put her higher in Rap, Dance and Stage Presence even though her Stage Presence level is 0%

[@SnowyNayeon]

Why is Haseul so low in the list? (in vocals) Although she rarely showcases her vocals well enough, she's a really good vocalist and can support and in my opinion, she's better than some vocalists above her. Edit: honestly, I understand why she’s this low. I would probably actually put her lower now. 😭

[@lisaicanmeow5157]

I know Soyeon is no. 1 in Rap... She's 4TH GEN QUEEN OF RAP

[@beautiful4816]

Yes 👍

[@leafleaf6575]

And also better than many 3rd gen rappers

[@SashaTsy]

@@leafleaf6575 She is the best female rapper in k-pop. There are no other idols that will surpass her in terms of delivery, fast, flow, recitative and at the same time write lyrics for their rap parts.

[@sunmunmid6470]

In my opinion, Karina is the best all rounder among girl groups of the 4th generation, at three ranks she took high positions and visual’s she would be included in the top 5 of the best.

[@raphaelezra4571]

This !!

[@chillen8413]

100% I’ve never seen such a well rounded idol

[@hyacinth6552]

For me Monday is the best all rounder.

[@tiiyaalyn7851]

for me heejin & yeji

[@aysathulrameela9947]

Sooo true 👍🏻

[@babyxo1740]

e:u beats giselle in rap just by a little bit she has better technique and follow t

[@pd.z]

Bro the fact bae is so low in the vocal category is hilarious to me 💀💀💀 is this a joke?!

[@vvenuskook4170]

Bae has no support

[@Devikapk3]

@@vvenuskook4170 she has but now she is singing with stylistic approach

[@vvenuskook4170]

@@Devikapk3 yeah, she maybe has a little bit of shallow support. But the stylistic singing really affects that

[@chewieqtpie]

Shes the weakest vocalist in Nmixx what do you expect, some nswers are so delusional thinking shes lead vocalist material when they dont understand she has the weakest technique in the group from her stylistic singing

[@vvenuskook4170]

@@chewieqtpie SAY IT LOUDER 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

[@byuntaeyeonnie4251]

another day of aespa slaying the ranking! btw, don't forget to watch the livestream of their coachella perfomance around 2pm KST.

[@emzzzzzzzzzz]

another day another slay

[@vvenuskook4170]

Omg I’m late but I love the promo

[@vx184]

yes, i hope

[@clara._0862]

>> Lily (NMIXX) *Clip: m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z4XYiYdmf76tjtE 0:11 supported D5/sustain support D5 1:22 phrase D5 sustain C#5 2:16 spam C#5 2:35 supported Eb5 2:45 supported D5 Only D5 0:57 tight I watch clip "Finesse" before her debut and she good support C#5. She supported D5 not bad in 2:44 in Kill this love cover *In this clip: m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/g3ndp36enqeEm8k OMG she good support headvoice to G5 2:01 C5 phrase => She supported pretty good C#5, D5 and headvoice. Lower register supported to A3 >> Sullyoon (NMIXX) She supported pretty good A4/Bb4 (she supported Bb4 in 1:38 in Kill this love cover) so she is substandard to standard vocalist, and >= Jinni, better than Giselle and Miyeon >> Haewon (NMIXX) and Winter (aespa) Haewon better than Winter agility, headvoice She supported Eb5 in m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/j4aWeJd-lL2Ur8U Bonus 2:00 Lily supported F5 not that good but okay Haewon lower register same same or little better than Winter Now, I think Haewon better than Winter in mixed range because she pretty consistent C5 and she support some phrase D5 >> Kyujin (NMIXX) With her quality support, I think she better than Miyeon, pretty good A3 in Fine cover >> Miyeon ((G)I-DLE) m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/moWXY4qEYtKad5Y 0:23 0:32 A3 not support 0:39 B4 high larynx, phrase A4 tight 0:47 0:53 more A4 1:45 A4 high larynx 2:30 D5 2:40 E5 and F5 => Miyeon A4 not that good :v

[@rere9991]

Honestly Lily is inconsistent above C5 so those were rare moments, if there's more materials and she supports regularly over C5 then maybe she'd be #1, but for now the vocal ranking is accurate

[@Sylvaincks]

@@rere9991 inconsistent ? I think all of her C#5s are supported, and a majority too for her D5s

[@luizizn165]

Haewon lower register is mjch stronger than Winter's

[@chewieqtpie]

@@rere9991 yeh but shes supporting Eb5s

[@haneulnee9562]

4th Gens female Ace Karina: rank 8 - vocal (d+/c-) - 8,2/10 rank 5 - rap - 8,5/10 rank 11 - dance - 9,33/10 + amazing leadership, best personality, soon to be songwriter and producer, Taekwondo black belt, cgi/unreal visuals, swimmer and rocket puncher!

[@jeanpierreveraalvarado7329]

Yesss sister, you're spelling facts only💅👑

[@Minty_Sana]

Karina is higher D+ and nearly Lower C

[@rere9991]

@@Minty_Sana I'd say she's lower C her approach isn't as shallow as the others below her but yea. She surprised me didn't think a lead rapper main dancer would be a good vocalist but I guess it's water thingz! Knowing Sm hoping she continues to also improve she has one of favorite voices currently

[@leechaeryeong9861]

dance should be lower tbh her technique is underdeveloped for a main dancer

[@aura-bj4wr]

@@leechaeryeong9861 she actually has strong technique, it’s her transitions and fluidity that end up making her seem stiffer in more complicated dances. But compare her Step Back dance to any of the other great dancers in that lineup and you’d actually be surprised how well she holds up against them.

[@qiluv4247]

I personally think Hikaru,Dayeon and Youngeun are shine here, they like all-rounder skills ! Hwaiting Kep1er

[@lovelcy8461]

CHAERYEONG CAN JUST ABOUT IT ALL SHES PRETTY CAN SING DANCE PICK UP CHOREOGRAPHY FAST AND REMEMBER IT MAINTAIN STABILITY WHILE DOING BOTH SINGING AND DANCING HAVE GREAT STAGE PRESENCE SHES HILARIOUS CUTE AND LETS NOT TALK ABOUT HER GAZE HER DANCING IS SO EFFORTLESS PRECISE AND FLOWS WITH ANY GENRE HER HAIR FLIPS DON’T LOOK OUT OF PLACE BUT ADD MORE SPICE SHES AN AMAZING PERFORMER AND HAS SM TALENT OVERALL SINCE YOUNG YOU CANT HELP BUT FALL IN LOVE WITH HER, i hope she gets more chances to participate in shows be a host do music/dance videos collabs as an artist herself but she’s perfect for itzy!!!

[@caliparis]

this ranking is questionable...

[@vvenuskook4170]

Why

[@thedetective5718]

@@vvenuskook4170 cause lily is most definently a better vocalist then ningning and bae and jiwoo should be a lot higher in rank im not even an nmixx Stan but i know what they are capable of

[@ivy2267]

Haewon is C+/B- she’s not weaker than Monday or Ningning, and so is Lily she’s stronger than everyone on the list… also Kyujin, and Sullyoon are at minimum D+ not just D

[@chewieqtpie]

I think this was made before they showed more improvement, jiwoo and bae should now also be much higher since they have shown some sense of support

[@riolvche]

jyp groups dancers are next level

[@durgashankar5008]

Yes

[@nancybiee5296]

To those who are slandering aespa , watch their Coachella performance to shut ur mouths

[@vvenuskook4170]

Agreed💯

[@Kyovocals_w]

NingNing best vocalist from the fourth generation 👌👌

[@Queeeenfm]

Miyeon voice deserves better

[@JuJu-ki8cg]

right

[@RunnerForImSol]

It’s very funny how IVE members are all vocalists but all of them except Liz are in the F section. So basically; Liz carries the group

[@ayden121hr]

Chaeryoung really is that girl!

[@lovelcy8461]

YES

[@Sylvaincks]

Imo Miyeon, Giselle, Sullyoon and probably Kyujin are substandard to standard. Karina isn't average yet. Lily > NingNing > Haewon > Monday

[@izekielsanjho7964]

I agree. Karina being average makes her on par with vocalists like Jihyo, Seulgi, Winter, Yeonjung and manu more. I don't think she is that good. but she is very good. I think she is more like on par with Rosé & Nayeon

[@Sylvaincks]

@@vintasahi Imo Miyeon and Giselle are less shallow than everyone in the Weak tier, and it has been debated whether they should stay in Weak tier or move up to W-A

[@minari3303]

Yes

[@ayeon5609]

@@vintasahi Kyujin doesn't even support. Like I agree Sullyoon is definitely better than Giselle, but not Kyujin.

[@marigold4135]

@@ayeon5609 idk where but a lot of people have been saying that kyujin has supported (shallow)

[@Maryxzi_.]

6:00 Haseul VOCAL 25? What? WHAT? WHAT? WHAT?

[@itzykep1ianonceteume28]

Can you do a part 2 with more undareted groups like Billie, cherry bullet, pixy, tribe, Wooah , purple kiss, rocket punch, lightsum?

[@Minty_Sana]

this video was a hussle, i will think about it

[@beautiful4816]

Aespa 💙 💫🦋🌙 Vocal 13. Giselle 8. Karina 5. Winter 1. Ningning Rap ( Rap line ) 5. Karina 2. Giselle Dance: 66. Giselle 46. Ningning 38. Winter 11. Karina Aespa queens 👸 💙 ✨ 💖

[@vandanaparulekar325]

Karina literally proved that she is an ACE

[@rashisingh5336]

In my opinion Yuqi should be higher in dance Aisha higher in rap Eu at 2nd in rap Giselle 3rd Also haewon much higher in dance And i think Chuu is a better vocalist than Yves

[@phoenix_renegade]

Totally disagree, Yuqi should be even lower in dance. Base Ownership - very low / as my teacher used to say, such as she / he is made of wood / poor plasticity of the body / as well as poor isolation and coordination. Individuality - she dances as a 7-11 year old girl... Moreover, on straight legs (giraffe style)... There is a constant parasitic bouncing around that makes her dance comical... Musicality - flabbily. Originality - not present. Style - not present. Her only advantage is her energy, which puts her in 3rd place in the group, 'cause this is Miyeon, Minnie & Shuhua Main problem.

[@Queeeenfm]

Gidle , nmixx , loona 👾❤

[@19RRR]

Bruhh Everybody Is Arguing who's better than Yuna,Ryujin,Onda but you Put Karina over this 3 who's have A minimum dancing problem? Are you literally kidding Us?😆

[@honeypk]

TOTAL RANKING OF GROUPS VOCAL 1. aespa (8.57/10) 2. NMIXX (7.19/10) 3. Stayc (6.12/10) 4. Weeekly (5.99/10) 5. (G)I-dle (5.93/10) 6. Kep1er (5.4/10) 7. Fromis_9 (5.35/10) 8. LOONA (5.31/10) 9. Itzy (4.97/10) 10. IVE (4.82/10) 11. Everglow (4.59/10) RAP (rap line only) 1. aespa (8.82/10) 2. Everglow (8.35/10) 3. (G)I-dle (8.2/10) 4. Itzy (8.17/10) 5. Kep1er (7.87/10) 6. IVE (7.72/10) 7. LOONA (7.15/10) 8. Weeekly (6.95/10) 9. NMIXX (6.43/10) 10. Stayc (6.1/10) 11. Fromis_9 (5.65/10) DANCE 1. Itzy (8.15/10) 2. NMIXX (7.63/10) 3. Kep1er (7.5/10) 4. Everglow (6.94/10) 5. Weeekly (6.78/10) 6. LOONA (6.53/10) 7. aespa (6.33/10) 8. Stayc (6.22/10) 9. Fromis_9 (6.18/10) 10. IVE (5.96/10) 11. (G)I-dle (4.94/10)

[@pinkystar6469]

the nmixx vocal actually wrong . nmixx should be 1 .

[@gfgggfggf4375]

Yeah 👍

[@khadeeja1228]

this ranking seems really wrong.......

[@vvenuskook4170]

Why?

[@vvenuskook4170]

@@Forever_2424 how are they wrong tho

[@vvenuskook4170]

@@Forever_2424 idk about the rest but Karina is definitely a better rapper than Aisha. Literally the best thing about karina is her flow so idk what you’re talking about lol. But karina has better flow, dictation, delivery, pronunciation, versatility, etc. Aisha is really good too but her delivery and versatility isn’t on the same level as karinas. Also Aisha seems to rely on her deep voice a lot instead (which is more of of stylistic choice) instead of actual technique.

[@nomorenoise2374]

Vocals: Bae and Jiwoo definitely should be higher. higher than sumin and isa for sure. Bae has breath support but she has been going for more of a stylistic approach lately. She sings with her throat which is why she can sound tight and nasally at times. Jiwoo basically has the same issue but she has better moments where she can possibly support. Lily is above average while NingNing is average to above average. Lily clears NingNing in mix, upper and headvoice so she definitely takes first. Haewon and Monday are arguable since Haewon has a better mix and hv. Sullyoon is definitely higher than Giselle as well since she’s only shallow on Bb4. Dance: I want to keep this one short. so lemme just say that Haewon is definitely much better than Jiwoo and Jinni in idol dancing so she would be higher. She’s right around Yeji level.

[@nomorenoise2374]

@@user-jr6do3pv7b that wouldn’t even make sense… support is the basic for a vocalist. her vocal ranking is based off of the vocalist’s support range, technique, dynamics, pitch, stability, consistency (ofc) and placement etc.

[@riverkhaos1668]

Totally agree

[@afeliz2642]

You did not say haewon dance better than 💀 I know hae is good and has an amazing charisma but you’ll don’t even watch professional dancers analyzing them? And it’s kinda obvious that, jinni, jiwoo and ryujin are better than her but anyways...

[@nomorenoise2374]

@@afeliz2642 I said what I said. Haewon is better than Jinni, Jiwoo and Kyujin in idol dancing. and I’m right. SIT DOWN!

[@afeliz2642]

@@nomorenoise2374 HELP- hhahahah bye girl, you are a loser who doesn’t even know how to move a finger and you want to say who’s better💀🤡

[@jasperhermosura9815]

How does Kyujin, Sieun, Lia and Heejin higher than Haseul??

[@the.madu.]

@@vintasahi since when can sieun support?

[@the.madu.]

@@vintasahi ohh ok. i didn't mean to underestimate her, i was asking if she improved and when did she improve tostart supporting(if that makes sense)

[@taemin626]

æspa itzy kep1er everglow loona (g)i-dle

[@plumslight24]

Ty for using my intro

[@dreamgirl4660]

how is giselle so high at vocal??

[@user-ke8sl6ed1o]

It's just fact watch her covers and vocals

[@pinkystar6469]

ning over sully for dance 💀💀

[@maryyypural1018]

I miss Iz*one. Back then, they're still in your videos. My fave vid was the bp twice, rv, iz*one, itzy, aespa, loona, everglow & (g)-idle rankings.

[@mochimanoban8836]

Honestly forgot aespa was in this video until Giselle popped up at 13 for vocalists xD

[@irenervjisoobp819]

Vocal rank (my opinion) 👑 1. Ningning AESPA 2. Monday WEEKLY 3. Lily NMIXX 4. Winter AESPA 5. Haewon NMIXX

[@tiktokspam883]

Agree, Lily had this rich flavor in her voice becoz she was raised in Australia but Monday has better vocal techniques than her, I believe that Monday and Ningning are the 2 vocalists from 4th gen. who were actually fighting on the spot of best 4th gen vocalist. But for my ranking, Ningning is better than Monday in terms of proper breathing, mixed voice, high note stability, and vocal soul than Monday. So yeah, I agree with your ranking.

[@chaelliri]

kep1er dayeon is easily among top 5 dancers

[@squezzos2.0-mx2ub]

Liz being at 10th position is soooo amazing. She deserves this and definitly carries the group.

[@_p__ion7151]

so happy seeing Youngeun place 5th in dance ranking TT

[@rajwantkaur4385]

some vocal rankings were really shocking

[@rajwantkaur4385]

you shouldnt judge support, consistency, stability WITHOUT live singing examples.

[@Minty_Sana]

We do have live singing examples for every group in this list

[@oliviabrown1337]

Giselle #2 in rap???? Heejin is a great dancer but shes definitely not better than Yeji, the vocal ranking was baffling too

[@vvenuskook4170]

Why is the vocal ranking baffling?

[@durgashankar5008]

How can you put Karina and Jennie in same level in stage Presence Karina doesn't have good stage Presence and literally you're ranking her same as Jennie, Jennie's stage Presence is so good and Nayeon also have good stage Presence than Karina Ig Karina is your ult bias that's why you rank her higher in every category

[@Lss125]

I think you're commenting on the wrong video, this video doesn't have sp ranking and it doesn't have Jennie

[@oncexblink7068]

Why no one appreciate Mia vocal, her breath support is very good and her vibrato make me chill😭💘

[@banhcacuajisung]

Karina is not as good at dancing as Ryujin, Ryujin is the lead dancer but she dances better than the main dancer Karina ^^

[@izekielsanjho7964]

Weeekly Soeun is better than Karina actually. They have the same lower register but Soeun is consistent with A4/Bb4. Karina has only A4

[@rere9991]

Karina safely has A4/bB4 esp recently she's been consistent plus she's fuller and isn't as shallow

[@izekielsanjho7964]

@@rere9991 disagree she barely has any materials

[@1121AUYEUNGNOKSZE]

Soyeon is the queen of kpop🧡 Ning Ning is the queen of vocal💜 Chaeyeong is the queen of dance💗

[@justj3060]

There’s not way Kyujin from Nmixx is better vocalist than Mia. My rap ranking 1. Soyeon 2. Eu 3. Aisha 4. Giselle And you also forgot to put Mia in rap ranking, if she’d be in aespa or Itzy, definitely lead rapper material

[@Devikapk3]

Giselle is wayyyyy better than aisha

[@vvenuskook4170]

Giselle is a better rapper than Aisha

[@kitkitlotino4509]

So pretty Vivi Yiren E:U Ryujin YeoJin Hikaru Zoa Jiheon Yuna Gaeul Jaehee Go Won Jisun Rei Saerom J Onda Shuhua Olivia Hye Leeseo Dayeon HyunJin Aisha Wonyoung Chaeyoung Yeseo Soyeon Kep1er Yujin Bae Jiwoo Xiaoting Nagyung Soojin Chaeryeong Choerry Seoyeon Seeun IVE Yujin Yeji JinSoul Mashiro Bahiyyih Youngeun Kim Lip Hayoung Minnie Jiyoon Isa Sumin Mia Jihan HaSeul Yoon Yuqi HeeJin Chuu Yves Sieun Sihyeon Gyuri Lia Sullyoon Giselle MiYeon Jinni Liz Soeun Karina Chaehyun Jiwon Winter Haewon Monday Lily NingNing and Kyujin 🥶❄️

[@nemeuseiquemeusouquemdirav7416]

FINALLY SOMEONE WHO APPRECIATES CHAR, she deserves first place!!!

[@fuziahjiha2968]

PLEASE ADD WOOAH,CLASSY,TRIPLES, KISS OF LIFE,LAPILLUS,AND NIZIU❤

[@kpopuniverse1113]

nice

[@lisaicanmeow5157]

Hikaru, Heejin, Hayoung, Youngeun, Yeji and Chaeryeong Best 4th GEN. DANCERS.... And Also CHAEYEON!!!

[@skiieblue8521]

True I would add dayeon too

[@gta8555]

Chuu 20th?!

[@JuJu-ki8cg]

xiaoting didn’t rlly deserve that high of a vocal ranking in my opinion

[@pramilauikey4294]

For kep1ians: vocals hikaru - #71 dayeon - #56 yeseo - #51 yujin - #49 xiaoting - #46 shiro - #36 hiyyih - #35 youngeun - #34 😶 chaehyun - #7 ❣️ Rap ( rap line only ) xiaoting - #27 youngeun - #10 dayeon - #6 hikaru - #4 ❣️ dance chaehyun - #59 hiyyih - #55 shiro - #51 yujin - #32 yeseo - #19 xiaoting - #17 dayeon - #10 youngeun - #5 hikaru - #2 🎉

[@annisanuragni5241]

Can you do viviz, ily:1 , ive ,nmixx ,billlie, kep1er ,class:y ,le_sserafim, and purple kiss Thank u

[@ivy2267]

Have you seen that Jiwoo and Bae have already shown some support now?

[@Kyovocals_w]

Hi again! Can you tell me what app do you use for thumbnails?

[@Minty_Sana]

I use canva for the collage, Then move to Polarr for the filters, And add the text in Phonto

[@diegooo283]

I dont get sieun being D, she doesnt support, and she raises her larynx as soon as G4

[@itzzmaeri]

I don't think the vocalists ranked as 2,8 (example) are bad, but it's ur own rank so I respect ur opinion! I don't agree with some (I like their voices but don't think they are the good good vocalists). Wonyoung, Dayeon, Yeseo, Yujin, Jinsol, Jiwoo, Leeseo, XIaoting, Chaeryoung, Seeun (In my own taste, I think she's above Sumin, no hate, both my biases!), Yujin, Yeji and more I don't think they are bad vocalists, I could rank them as perfect bc I don't take time to see stage presences.

[@arjunmaharvlogs1505]

What about Yeji in vocals as I didnt saw u mentioned her

[@Minty_Sana]

She is there

[@leafleaf6575]

Soyeon and karina 🔥🔥 Aespa💜 and (G) I- DLE 💜

[@sweetcandystan8493]

because chuu was so low on vocals and Yves is never better than her on vocals, you can't take this ranking seriously

[@karin5631]

I think Sieun voice tiny but so strong,She best vocalist.

[@jrkln27]

Shuhua has improved her vocals and dance too much for you to place her in such a low place.

[@DeeDeeDeeeee]

She still cannot support her vocals and has problems with her dance technique

[@tjsquibbofficial]

@@DeeDeeDeeeee She's still at least a better dancer than Minnie nowadays though.

[@kpopenthusiast9755]

TOP 3 VISUAL 1. IVE 2. AESPA 3. LOONA/NMIXX DANCE 1. NMIXX 2. ITZY 3. KEP1ER VOCALS 1. NMIXX 2. STAY-C 3. LOONA RAP 1. G-IDLE (SOYEON ALONE CAN CARRY) 2. NMIXX 3. ITZY STAGE PRESENCE 1. ITZY 2. NMIXX 3. G IDLE MUSIC SHOW WINS 1. ITZY (2019-2022) 3 YEARS 2. G IDLE (2018-2022) 4 YEARS 3. IVE (2021-2022) 9MONTHS

[@sicndjisifkskis727]

I think liz is overrated in vocal? And i think Lily is 1 in vocal

[@Devikapk3]

Liz is not overrated And yes lily is 1stin vocals(professionals agreed)

[@rajwantkaur4385]

anyone heard JIWOO thunderous rap?

[@wonyjen1151]

woahh i don't know heejin is better than yeji in dance? heejin is literally an ACE

[@tavleensachdev8591]

Karina and Heejin, the aces of 4th gen

[@terrellcalloway7124]

But jinsoul 37 place for vocal and Minnie 31 and chuu 20

[@Kyovocals_w]

Hi! Can you tell me how do you don’t get strike by copyright in your videos?

[@hazylsalon9156]

Yeah I'm also curious

[@Minty_Sana]

i get copyright claims, i don't know why i don't get any strikes tho

[@AsiaTikCutee]

My overall ranking 1) soyeon 2) monday 3) karina 4) chaeryoung / yeji 5 ) winter

[@justuraverageperson1464]

imo Ningning and Lily are about the same level, but I enjoy Lily’s voice better (and I think they are grade B not c, I read it somewhere)

[@dumblechel21]

all rounder ranking for me: 1. soyeon (cuz ace, if just vocal rap dance she will be around youngeun and dayeon’s level) 2. karina 3. monday 4. heejin 5. mia 6. jinni 7. haewon 8. dayeon 9. youngeun

[@jeanpierreveraalvarado7329]

Nah, Karina is first, she has vocal support.

[@jacobbocaj8756]

karina is definitely first since this is, as you wrote, an all rounder ranking not ace ranking

[@durgashankar5008]

@@jeanpierreveraalvarado7329 No

[@Devikapk3]

Youngeun is wayy higher

[@manegevorgyan5556]

Vocal 1-Lily B

[@Amber_freeman]

Is leeseo really that bad of a vocalist?! may I have your reasoning bestie💕🙏

[@vvenuskook4170]

She is just underdeveloped and lacks support

[@ProphetMisfit09]

Look up Ive blackpink cover, I forgot the name of the song, but... I thought the whole time Leeso was Gaeul, but when I realize it was her.... Man, it was bad. Her vocals were not good there at all.

[@javabeaan]

there's no way giselle is higher in vocalist ranking than chuu. AND I LOVE GISELLE'S VOICE 😭

[@user-wc9vw6om4l]

NingNing is a Queen😭💔

[@coneyenriquez3405]

Soyeon, kyujin, ryujin is better than karina at dancing lol

[@Devikapk3]

Thy are not

[@cool_bunnyyy]

Nmixx real vocal tier: 1. Lily (B) 2. Haewon (B-) 3. Sullyoon (^D+/C-) 4. Kyujin (^D+) 5. Jiwoo (D) 6. Bae (D-) ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@graffinpark3398]

for me vocal 1.NingNing 2.Monday 3.Lily 4.Winter 5.Haewon I don't know about rap but your rap ranking is what I expected In dance,I think Dayeon is better than Mia(I don't hate Mia❤️)

[@vvenuskook4170]

Totally agree 💞

[@anonymousbitch419]

Aespa’s vocal line are insane. Anyways NINGNING 4th gen rapper

[@JVH2510]

vocal : the top 10 is...okey but what about the other positions?

[@7m934]

Sieun voice so amazing 🤩 ❤❤😊

[@yejisolostan5456]

Lily should be first for real she is the only one in the 4th generation to be an above average vocalist with Yechan

[@vvenuskook4170]

No💙

[@rere9991]

No she’s still average to above average due to her being inconsistent on even C5s also her habit of pushing & shoutiness.

[@vvenuskook4170]

@@rere9991 exactly

[@yejisolostan5456]

@@rere9991 all of her C#5 are supported , her upper register (F#5/G5) and her whole supported mixed range(D5, Eb5) put her in the above average tier

[@rere9991]

@@yejisolostan5456 they aren’t even some her C5s are inconsistent let alone C#5s or D5s. We don’t know the full consistency of her head voice due to lack of material but I guess giving her up to F5 is fair. Still A-AA not AA

[@heyhaha265]

Omg so proud of aespa and formis9

[@MayeFilms]

My Top 3 In Each Category: Vocal. 1: Sihyeon (Everglow) 2: Isa (STAYC) 3: Minnie ((G)I-dle). Rap. 1: Soyeon ((G)I-dle 2: Yuqi ((G)I-dle) 3: Yuna (Itzy). Dance. 1: Chaeryeong (Itzy) 2: Yeseo (Kep1er) 3: Onda (Everglow). By the way this is all my opinions. I may have chosen them because, their voice is clear and satisfying, their rap is smooth and ear pleasing, or their dance is smooth and elegant but no matter why just know it is no hate to them or anyone else in this video.

[@aengeliss1019]

And Giselle better than Chuu. Chuu one of the best vocalist in kpop industry

[@richardcosta5203]

Please make with NewJeans, Purple Kiss & LE SSERAFIM

[@thereallemon7050]

hikaru is 2nd in rap for me