Rarest Thrift Store Video Game Find EVER

I couldn't believe it when I saw it at Goodwill. This has to be the most expensive video game I have ever found at a Thrift Store. Join me for this amazing Goodwill trip as well as a ton of other awesome thrift store visits. Go thrifting with me!
#reselling #reseller #thrifting #goodwill #thriftstore #ebay
I am a reseller based out of the greater Dayton, Ohio area. Subscribe and turn on the bell notifications to stay up to date with all my picking and flipping content! Also, please consider liking the video as it helps me out a ton! Thanks for watching!
eBay store: www.ebay.com/str/buckeyetreas...
Instagram: @propickerohio
/ propickerohio
Merch: propicker.myshopify.com/
GoPro Hero 8 (The one I use): amzn.to/3B2WuMc
GoPro Hero 9 (The newest): amzn.to/3yOMEeS
GoPro Backpack Strap: amzn.to/2UaOyaX
C920 Webcam for at the desk shots: amzn.to/3eBjFDN
Rollo 4x6 Label Printer: amzn.to/3yVhbHU
6x10 DVD Bubble Mailer: amzn.to/3B2XtMo
For a larger list of items I use or are similar to items I use for ebay and youtube everyday check out my Amazon Storefront:
www.amazon.com/shop/propicker
For mail:
Pro Picker
PO Box 1762
Miamisburg, OH 45343

[@carolwilliams8840]

I'm so sorry about the loss of your father. I hope you and your family are finding peace in the moments of joyful memories surrounding him.

[@propicker]

Thank you Carol

[@debbiebrill5413]

You have the nicest Goodwill I have ever seen!

[@janicealcibiade5369]

All online thrifters have nice Goodwill ...

[@debbiebrill5413]

You guys are killing it out there! Jess is a wonderful addition to your videos and you guys make a great team!

[@KristiWilson]

Dang, great finds! And I appreciate you discussing what you didn’t buy and why.

[@Jetskkkiii]

I also enjoy that

[@Mackten420]

Thats a great find for sure....The best Thrift store game score I ever had was Mario Party 4,5,6,7 and double dash all at the same time for gamecube...went back when they opened the next day and got Pokemon XD Gale Of Darkness...I still have em all lol

[@madmanpaul8823]

Crazy what you guys find at thrifts and goodwill stores..There's nothing like that around my area at all with goodies like that amazing finds

[@edwardsawtell5712]

The only thing you could probably pick up at the New York City Goodwill is Covid!

[@juliekastel6276]

That was amazing.

[@kapoioskapoiou9925]

That 1997 Christmas Rock and Roll is so beautifull so neat dustin..big score and easy money maker of course.Boy these 90s christmas ornament sets are so unique the decoration is in another whole level..you can understand this only if you grew up in the 90s.!

[@syphahphomma6805]

Wow insane find

[@groverscorner8946]

Wow, you found so many great things!!

[@patriciaherrington8921]

Found that game, because you had your "Lucky Charm" with you. Luv watching and listening to you.❤

[@debbiedonaldson6545]

Looking forward to see what treasures you find today! 😍

[@brenyule]

Wow great finds! I learn so much from you!

[@thomasanderson-tooth8174]

Love your videos bud! Not often I catch them the second they come out! Excited to see what finds we have this time! I hope you’re keeping well, sending good vibes from the UK ✌️

[@RKLamont-xi9qe]

Great finds 😊❤

[@AmySmith-om4kk]

Jess is bringing you some good luck on your picks. Great finds

[@L-Jay1147]

I was going to say 'Where is your Battle Buddy?!?! ' then Jess popped up 😂

[@carolbellingham7480]

You guys are so lucky with your thrift stores! I live in South Australia & our op shops (opportunity shops=your thrift stores) are so over priced and understocked. An example would be that Guess watch you put back at $3.99- here that would be in a locked cabinet with a $30-$50 price on it. And 90% of our op shops are small- like a boutique. So envious of you guys! 😀🦘🐨

[@kimross6279]

Holy smokes great pick ups 😊!

[@marcialuvs2sell494]

Congrats on those sick pick ups!!

[@karenharding3842]

Great video x

[@jackiedes-jarlais5095]

Fantastic fines Congratulations

[@johnl6333]

Wow amazing PS2 game find! Awesome video.

[@alisiosadventure6075]

Congrats on the finds

[@jackiegibson5043]

Awesome video and finds!!!

[@heathernagel5252]

Nice score on the Bionicles!!

[@matthewcolicigno8132]

Your wife looked super impressed by your Tenkachi 3 nerd talk

[@gg_yvonne4442]

Hello Dustin and Jess really have great thrift stores nice pick ups 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@Retro-2-now]

I will be heading out to that area soon! I’m tired of the same over priced thrift stores in my town. We have 3 Goodwill stores in my area. One of them is basically 2-3x’s the price of the other two.

[@jaxxonvideogameresale]

Great video like always 😊

[@propicker]

Thanks!

[@idrafthalflinger9494]

Hey just hoping all is well you, for a couple of years have always been in my feed. Now I have to seek out you videos I hit the bell icon so it should work. But, I never had to do that before . You both are wonderful

[@propicker]

Thank you!

[@Flidays]

I missed these longer style videos!

[@carolynscadern6787]

Hi Dustin! I found a PS2 Silent Hill 3 game at my local Goodwill. I knew horror games went for a bit, and when I saw the price on price charting, I was also shaking. It was complete, but a little scratched. I ended up buying a used PS2 at a flea market just so I could verify that the disc worked and take screen shots for my listing. Buying the PS2 cut into my profits, but I didn't want to risk selling an expensive game untested. I sold it, and never saw anything close to that game's worth since! So exciting to randomly come across these in the thrift stores! Thanks for sharing!!

[@propicker]

Silent hill games are always an awesome find!

[@DOUBELUPPICKER]

Great Haul can't wait for this warmer weather I'm ready for them yard sales. I noticed on your back to the future time machine you picked up it's missing Mr.Fusion it broke off. I got the same one in my collection

[@propicker]

thanks for the heads up!

[@LPSgirldreama]

Awesome freaking video ❤

[@bruceweigle7597]

WOW!!! Amazing finds, congrats on the ps2 games!!!

[@cynthiarollins3949]

That Augusta Masters shirt should have been a good resale…of course I live near the golf course🥰

[@lecarra7505]

Wow, that's amazing! I had no idea that DBZ game was worth so much, I'll be sure to be on the lookout for it! :O

[@jaxxonvideogameresale]

Same here lol

[@francis-kp9cw]

1:14 .🇺🇲 Hawaii 🤙.

[@brendawhitt1964]

Love ya❤

[@debbyhodges1931]

So sorry about your dad. Love your videos.

[@carolwilliams8840]

I came to the comments to say the same thing. It's a shame out of all of the comments, yours is the only one I found offering condolences on the loss of his father. I don't understand the lack of compassion.

[@JonathanAlfaro]

Swore off ski. 😁

[@Slick_Rick859]

You didn’t leave the 50 shades behind you took it home and watched it tell the truth. 😂 just messing with you. I really like watching your content I have been binge watching your videos. Keep up the great work.

[@propicker]

Thank you!

[@cryptolockxrp2014]

Best video game find for me was a sealed oblivion for the Xbox 360. Sold it for $350 back in the peak market 😊

[@propicker]

Nice!

[@richporter2168]

Could you start like a pick orders and ship vid ? Would love to see how you store and pick inventory.

[@propicker]

Hey, we did do a video of order picking for the black friday weekend last year. kzbin.info/www/bejne/e4jJeWynlKqffpo

[@fearnone6800]

Wow no wayyy bro me and my brother used to play that dragon ball Z game on the ps2 when we was little, we moved and I forgot it but I always wanted to get it again that’s fire bro good work 🦾

[@Mr-Divine]

I found the empty case about a month ago and sold just the case and manual for $90 and right before that I found pokemon Coliseum for game cube I sold overnight for $210

[@alenaroberts8372]

I'm so jealous that you guys can pick stuff off the carts at your Goodwills. I did it and the employee nearly had an aneurism.

[@thecapecodder]

same with mine, they don't allow it

[@blackbeardpirate]

Goat 🐐 hope ur well

[@FrankCostanza82]

I found that DBZ game a few years ago when it was only worth $50 (paid $3), which is still good but not near what it's worth now. Also found Pokémon XD Gale of Darkness when it was only worth $50 (also paid $3)

[@corystrobel8024]

Wish I knew which goodwill locations you go to. Me an my dad hit those alot as well as st vincent depals

[@WotanSkyFather]

At 0:01 you walked right past some really interesting brushstroke camo pants on your right hand side. Some rare camo patterns can be worth a TON for militaria collectors, and vintage realtree and mossy oak patterns sell for ALOT to American vintage buyers. Google Lens usually does an excellent job at identifying the patterns. Don't pass that stuff up!

[@Secondliferacquet]

Jess and Dustin, this length video is perfecto! Have y’all shown this store to us before? Doesn’t look familiar. What’s it’s name?

[@propicker]

All the stores in today's video were Goodwill stores.

[@charlesadkins8305]

Great Finds !!!!! I was wondering if you have any suggestions for me because our goodwills are nothing like what you have as far as selection .... almost everything good here goes to ebay auction .

[@propicker]

Yard sales, amazon liquidation bins, flea markets, estate sales, etc.

[@KevinDurantisnot]

Man this video was loaded! How many days of thrifting was this? Definitely could’ve been two videos lol

[@propicker]

This was numerous days. I decided to try a longer thrift video.

[@tylers4645]

Missed a Pyrex dish @ 12:10

[@mirandacosgrove4377]

I only like the video games but not the toys I used to like the toys

[@NickelNationCoinsMore]

👍

[@dRob24]

Long videos are backkkk 🫡🫡🫡🫡🫡

[@hymanspecialty879]

You had the break down of your cog, shipping, etc percentages for your store. Which one was that? Thanks in advance…

[@glyndaallenbaugh1334]

50 shades trilogy is definitely worth the read tho 😮

[@propicker]

Never read it. Not much time for reading these days unfortunately.

[@vXenfiniti.]

HEY PRO WHEN YA GUNNA WASH DAT DOGMEAT… HUHUUUUHHH

[@antoniovinaccia6824]

Would love to see what was in the Bionicle tub🥺

[@propicker]

If I find any crazy grail pieces I'll try to update here or on my instagram

[@antoniovinaccia6824]

@@propicker thanks!

[@debbiebrill5413]

Did you look at the Longaberger canister set on the cart where you found the Honest shampoo? You missed out on some big money.

[@propicker]

I don't think I did.

[@Allthingsintersting]

Dustin what's the best way to find comps?

[@propicker]

Search on ebay and filter by sold listings

[@lauriegani8136]

17:45 mark- Passed on a tan Polo Ralph Lauren Coat?

[@emptychamber5565]

You used my listing for that halo game 😂 you should have bought it I sold it instantly.

[@mezajw5]

Ten-Kai-Itch-e

[@dirtisbetterthandiamonds]

We're all moving to Ohio now! I lived just outside North Canton for acouple winters and Goodwill would give us a 10% off coupon if we made a donation. Do they still do that? It was the one by the Harry London chocolate factory so we'd load up on Buckeyes and go thrifting. I've never seen another Goodwill do that but it was the 90s when the world was better 😉

[@propicker]

I believe they still do give a coupon when you donate. I think it's 5 off $20 or something. My parents get it, but we donated to a store once that didn't offer us a coupon.

[@jamesmardel2677]

Absolutely love the videos but you need to remember what you pay!!!

[@raid_or_die8962]

It always shocks me how dead your thrift stores are. Im not even joking if that was at my thirft and there was a cart out you would be waiting in the 2nd wave of people for a shoulder to shoulder spot to pop up so you can squeeze in and have other peoples hands touching yiu tryna look threw the cart. And I feel like I do pretty well with some sweet finds myself since I go thrift daily and im a full time reseller for about 2.5/3 years now. But it's crazy to me the type of stuff you find. Like Miss Me Jeans for 5 bucks? My Goodwill puts it on black tag which means high fashion for 34.95. And my value village also has a flat price of 28.99. Carhartt pants are 16.99-29.99. Carhartt Sweatshirts are like 25-30. Like 2 years ago I was getting Carhartt Double knee pants or Carhartt jackets several times a week for like 10 bucks. Now the Detroit jackets are like $50-60 ussualy. It always shocks me when I watch vids of people getting stuff like Miss Me jeans for cheap beacuse everyone knows about them. Which in my area if a thrift store knows it's a good brand or has value it's furshure gunna be overpriced

[@propicker]

Honestly, in one of the two stores there's always a small group hitting the new stock carts. It's why I show most of the stuff off to the side at that one.

[@dakotaflora6998]

jealous of your thrift stores. Mine would have either A priced every item you just showed to the point it's not worthwhile or B just not even put it out on the shelf. They literally never put out video games. They accidentally had a few in a media cart and I tried to buy them and they freaking took them back when I was at the register.

[@cherylbrookshire3290]

If it was a goodwill the probably put them on- line on their site which has auctions or E-Bay. I don’t see video games much it at all at the goodwill I go to.

[@dakotaflora6998]

@@cherylbrookshire3290 That's all well and fine. I'm a business man, they are a for profit business I get it but I had it in my cart ready to purchase. Next time you're at the grocery store grab a couple random items out of someones cart and tell them they can't purchase that there, see how well that goes over for you. Still doesn't beat the time I took a hat to the register and the cashier took it to the back and put a $15 price tag on it and had the audacity to look upset when I told her to put it back on the shelves with the other items I had intended to purchase. When ever they ask me to donate I tell them they already have done it for me by continuously raising prices. I'm of the opinion they should be working with resellers not against them.

[@RyanKipp]

Hey picker, have you played that game before?

[@propicker]

I haven't. I played Budokai on the 360 before.

[@KristiWilson]

How is Jess liking the full time reselling?

[@propicker]

She's enjoying it. There's definitely a big change when it comes to making your own schedule versus a 9 to 5.

[@CamsFinds]

@@propicker Of course, freedom is the best part of it IMO. And best of all you guys are doing what you love and making a living off it. Very cool! Love the longer videos 100% by the way. Perfect video length btw! Really miss the longer videos.

[@trtr5586]

Pretty crazy. Found that exact game at a garage sale for $1 not too long ago.

[@propicker]

That's awesome!

[@robinmohn9082]

Did you grab those Longaberger canisters?

[@propicker]

no

[@newhampshirenate]

That was a rare 'Prison Sex Luigi', you shoulda grabbed it.

[@megamanwins2016]

Do you know how I can get a completely new ebay account I'm on mercari because ebay won't let me list anything anymore because I failed and gave bad customer service the first time with my first ever account I've learned alot on how to ship better since then and I want back on ebay cause it's better Any advice to start fresh on ebay Dustin

[@propicker]

I would reach out to ebay and try to explain your situation and see if you can be unbanned. Just making a new account would probably be seen as ban evasion and could lead to another ban.

[@propicker]

Try reaching out to them on Facebook on their ebay for business page.

[@megamanwins2016]

@Pro Picker idk if I am banned it says I can list x amount and stuff but when I try it says to contact customer service I guess that is ban?

[@JPREBEL123]

Great finds for sure. You might hold on to the DragonBall games. I'm sure the value will keep going up.

[@HermannTheGreat]

lol no it won't. They're all available digitally.

[@alexrocks135]

It will cuz budaki tenkaichi 4 is coming out

[@user-my7mb2xq1t]

Hello 😊

[@propicker]

Hi Jeanetta!

[@ohdimas]

whats the app you use called

[@propicker]

I use the ebay app

[@musik210]

voodoo voodoo voodoo

[@OhmegadJT]

Prices must’ve gone up like crazy in the past couple years cuz I remember it not being worth that much, at least for the Wii. Now it’s worth close to $100, crazy!

[@edwardsawtell5712]

How come we don’t see that African American lady that worked at one of the spots anymore?

[@edwardsawtell5712]

10:17 Does LL Bean still offer free exchanges for life? I would think if a reseller picked up used L.L. Bean items and just sent them in in exchange for new ones, you could clean up?!

[@irishgymbro]

🇮🇪🇮🇪💪

[@jonathanargueta8448]

Sheesh man! This is what living in a high income area gets ya for sure.

[@KevinDurantisnot]

Maybe there are certain areas that are better but overall Dayton Ohio is below average income compared to average US. It’s more so his stores seem to put more good stuff on the floor compared to selling online, along with the fact he is hitting multiple thrift stores every day , sometimes the same stores more than once a day for the new stock carts.

[@JavierArensperez-ql1xp]

Do you make good money off thrift store finds

[@propicker]

Yeah, we do pretty good with it. Yard sale season is pretty wild for finds and that's coming up soon in our area.

[@andreastenberg855]

I just sold that game loose for 185$ but complete you will get way more. Sold in 4 days too

[@marlettekaraguzman497]

I know your trying to make money but really you milk it.

[@propicker]

Just trying to make a living

[@deenation110]

Flamer

[@propicker]

🙄

[@lewisjohnson2732]

@Treasure Hunting With Jeabz