Raspberry Pi C/C++ Baremetal Programming | Using C to Direct-Register Control Your Raspberry Pi

[@DavesGarage]

Really appreciate the starting point! You might want to mention how to get the SDK or whatever assembler and linker you're using. I'm about to search for it, but a link would have made it easier!

[@alexandrohdez3982]

Hi Dave great to see you here 👏👏👏

[@ChandlerKluser]

Dude that's great!! Could you please tell us more about how these linker files are and how these C compilers work? thanks in advance!

[@CallousCoder]

It’s much easier on ARM to run bare metal is easier than on Intel. I was about to start a series of making a cooperative multitasking OS. But I got a new project, so no time for now. I wasn’t aware about this header file, when I did my GPIO video I had to deep dive into the documentation.

[@LowLevelTV]

Yeah x86 baremetal programming is much more difficult, and there isn't a ton of learning value there. It's just annoying. The header files are nice. Digging through documentation is something you should know HOW to do, but shouldn't have to do often. Thanks for watching!

[@zapiton]

I was searching for gold, but found platinum. until the end of the video I thought, that u coding for rasbian os😅😅 this is cool staff

[@meoDomicio]

I love low-level programming, thanks for your videos.

[@alexroman6246]

the most difficult for me was linker script and assembly regions explanation. could u tell me where to find good help to understand how linker scripts work and how arm cpu reads data from linked and compiled file. (assembly start file+C files that contains below in file)

[@packa5676]

Any plans to work in graphics later on in the series? Btw great series!

[@maksimmuruev423]

Is it any timer usage possible instead of empty while loops? Will be also interesting to see. should be more energy efficient.. I suppose

[@butterfinger4393]

This is awesome!! Can you make a hello world on hdmi example. Is it even possible using c++?

[@LowLevelTV]

It's definitely possible to interface with the HDMI controller in baremetal. It's probably a fair amount of code but you can do it.

[@maxhouseman3129]

The kernel does nothing else. So HDMI output is for sure possible.

[@petermuller608]

@@maxhouseman3129 are you sure? To my knowledge, the ARM core isn't even connected to the HDMI port on the raspberry pi. It uses a dedicated video chip

[@maxhouseman3129]

@@petermuller608 Yes. I know. Because the ARM processor has not the power to drive a hdmi device. But the kernel sends the commands to this chip anyway.

[@TooSlowTube]

Is there a video explaining the process of compiling it all (after installing a tool chain, maybe?) and loading it onto a microSD card? I don't get how to actually make use of this information and get the code running on a Pi.

[@bryanhutson6741]

would really love to see this done on a more modern intel/amd x86 cpu.

[@StEvUgnIn]

I disagree with the implementation but basically every concept shown on this channel is right

[@dertom1895]

Amazing stuff! 👍But when you wrote the 'sleep'-logic I thought, that won't work (8:36), at least not as a 'sleeper'. It looks like a perfect example for a compiler like gcc(with -O2) to optimize the loop out and replace it just with setting i to the value of 0x800000. Thought you should have used 'volatile' keyword for i-variable or -O0. But no,...too many thoughts 😆, worked as intended... 👍 Really need to try this at home 🤩

[@neelabhpaul3024]

great informative video!!

[@jugnu361]

Very Skillful

[@lxw5231]

Thanks for the simple example. I just make and flashed kernel7.elf to a SD card. put it in RPI3. the LED connected to GPIO21 did not turn on and off. compile has some warnnings. and check BCM2837 datasheet, the GPIO_BASE is 0x7E20,0000. not 0x3F20,0000. Is there anyone meet the same issue?

[@ORIofficialchannel]

that's something new, thank you!

[@diegoporras7769]

Good Stuff 🔥

[@hallkbrdz]

Q: Instead of a loop for delay, is there a high-resolution counter I can use to turn on a GPIO pin, wait, and then turn it off again after 5µS?

[@petermuller608]

Your CPU clock is the high resolution counter ;)

[@Henry-sv3wv]

@@petermuller608 doesn't work if you want to have none blocking wait

[@maksymiliank5135]

When I did some ATMega16 programming the chip had two clocks (one of them was 8-bit and the other 16-bit). You could write an interrupt function which would trigger when the counter reached a value set in the proper register. I'm guessing that there should be something like that on the arm chip as well. You need to reference the datasheet.

[@edgeeffect]

I'm trying to write assembly in a modular (hopefully) scalable way.... I'd love to see if other people could maintain it. ????????

[@Gyannea]

I am still trying to understand how you can write directly to memory or a hardware register from user space without the OS preventing that. Is it because the program only runs when booted? I asked a similar question in your assembly example. I take it that it is not possible to create a normal executable that can be started by the user.

[@benjamindreyer9884]

i think its because there are no OS, its baremetal so there are no kernel i think

[@benlee6140]

Can I write the write() & read() function in Pi OS? By that I mean can I access the register using the address mentioned in the datasheet (just like what you do)? ex. If I want to change the value of BCM2837_GPFSEL2 by point to the address "0x3F200008

[@Henry-sv3wv]

no, Linux doesn't want you to have direct access Edit: found out you can map physical addresses into your virtual adress space of linux process if it runs as root. google: mmap gpio raspberry pi you need to translate the bus address into the physical one. if there is no mapping into a physical one then you cant mmap it...

[@jeffcauhape6880]

Where can we go to learn more about linker files?

[@datbuiquang6251]

Why in the linker, start location is . = 0x8000

[@robotboy3525]

Hi , I'm assuming this uses the same C/C++ SDK as the RPi Pico right ??

[@isaiahkroeker7062]

Very helpful. Though I was running into an issue. I think I had the code the same as yours, but for some reason the raspberry pi stalls whenever a c function returns (it just no longer does anything). But if I start the start.s file with a line that sets the frame pointer and stack pointer to a spot of memory I set, it works perfect. Any clue why this would be?

[@LowLevelTV]

Yup! When you call a function in C, the return address is put onto the stack. If you don’t initialize SP, the return address gets lost and you crash the device. Setting SP fixes this.

[@isaiahkroeker7062]

@@LowLevelTV Did you do this in your code? That made sense to me but I thought I didn't find a place where you set SP so I assumed there was an initial stack already setup for the pi.

[@petermuller608]

Nice tutorial, however I would have preferred using uint32_t from stdint.h instead of uint, especially when dealing with writing a certain amount of bits

[@armchairtin-kicker503]

Why not implement the delay routines as function calls, reducing code duplication, decluttering the mainline with open-code? Other than that, very nice. Thanks.

[@DonVintaggio]

and on that note, since he's using C, why not use sleep(5) with the inclusion of the necessary headers (i.e. ) ?

[@Moronicsmurf]

Have you done a Raspberry Pi Rust Baremetal yet? :D

[@LowLevelTV]

Coming in the next month!

[@haider_sh3692]

can you do the same to stm32f103c8t6?

[@NourMuhammad]

now do this on i7!

[@moustafanofal2919]

Am trying this for a couple of days and I saw your video. I wrote to the registers but I faced segmentation fault, do you have any idea?

[@rylandavis2976]

How do you know you are having a segmentation fault when the raspberry pi has no os or drivers to alert you that you are having a segmentation fault?

[@gregoryfenn1462]

The read function is wrong.

[@williamdrum9899]

If I had to guess it probably happened from either a command with a register in square brackets such as LDR R0, [R1] or moving a value into R13 or R15

[@sebimoe]

unsigned int* GPFSEL = (unsigned int*)BCM2837_GPFSEL0; GPFSEL[2] |= (1

[@jeffreymusser8450]

Why read the register before configuring for output?

[@largepimping]

Because he needs to only flip one bit within the register. I.e., you don't want to change any of the other bits, you only want to change the bit specific to the GPIO pin being used for the LED.

[@admink8662]

Nice

[@otaxhu]

wait, assembly isn't a compiled language?

[@TooSlowTube]

It's not regarded as one, no. Assembly is assembled. There is a one to one correspondence between what you type and the machine code it produces... with the exception of macros, but they're also a literal substitution. Compiled languages use compilers, which are free to produce any code they like, so long as it gets the job done. The actual code can vary quite a bit, even just by using different optimisation setings.

[@pavelperina7629]

All the time I thought what? You can't just write into memory like that without getting segmentation fault. Maybe mapping page from /dev/mem can work, but i'm not sure. Last seconds ... copy to SD card and boot ... well, ok no kernel, just "Pin Operating System"

[@jonasfelipe777]

Can I apply it to Raspberry Pi Pico with the RP2040 microcontroller?

[@teksolucians6989]

Wow I didn't even know people still write in C. I thought by now C++ is the preferred main family of C by now

[@LowLevelTV]

I think C is still the preferred language in embedded spaces. C++ is just as fast, although it tends to bloat code if you're concerned with size constraints.

[@maxhouseman3129]

MCU standard language is C.

[@Henry-sv3wv]

libopencm3 ... is a pure C lib

[@windowsxseven]

C++ gives me a gag reflex every time I see it

[@windowsxseven]

@@EmbeddedSorcery 🤮

[@steffanjansenvanvuuren3257]

void does not need you to type return;

[@anwar6971]

You are saying Assembly is hard, but write in C. But you are still writing in Assembly.

[@KarstenGongoll]

warning: passing argument 1 of ‘read32’ makes pointer from integer without a cast [-Wint-conversion] 3 | #define BCM2835_GPFSEL2 0x0008 | ^~~~~~ | | | int I cant figure out why this is happening can someone pleas help me (I'm new to C...)

[@ShootingUtah]

It's hard to tell not seeing all the code but it seems like you're trying to give a function an integer when it wants a pointer. Or vice versa. So if you're currently passing it an int just use &myInt to pass the address of the int, if that doesn't work make a new pointer that points to your integer and pass read32 that pointer. It's probably not as big of a problem as it seems and you just need to figure out exactly what you need to give to read32 and cast your integer into the correct format. Hopefully this helps, I'm no expert but know a bit about this stuff

[@DFPercush]

Easiest way is probably change the parameters of read32 to take an integer instead of a void*. It's being explicitly cast to a pointer inside read32 anyway. But the way I would do it, is change the way those addresses are defined in the header: #define GPIO_BASE *(volatile uint32_t*)0x3F200000 That way you can just say GPIO_BASE |= 0x40; and treat it like a variable. Just make sure you use the right integer type for the size of the register. Some are arrays, so probably uint8_t or unsigned char.

[@aginghacker5602]

..sudo ping -f -s 60000 {russian domain} 🤔👍🖖

[@wildwildwestfan_69-kj9sp]

9:00 come on, you guys! You're dereferencing a null pointer! Open your eyes!

[@Indi_DevJames]

what did i just watch