RDR vs RDR 2 - PC Versions comparison (Actions and Details)

Red Dead Redemption just hit PC this week, and it's the perfect time to revisit the wild world of the game! With Red Dead Redemption 2 having set such a high bar in 2018, I wanted to compare the action physics and gameplay between these two classics. How do they stack up against each other? Let's see how it looks on PC.
Both games were played and recorded on PC, 2K resolution and ultra settings.
Suggestions for you:
1 Fact about every story mission in RDR!
👉 • One Fact about Every M...
GTA IV vs RDR 2 - Physics Battle!
👉 • GTA IV vs RDR 2 - Phys...
RDR (PS4) vs RDR 2 - Comparison of details!
👉 • RDR1 (PS4) vs RDR2 - C...
Hope you like the content. Please subscribe and support the channel. Thank you for watching! ❤️

[@BlaZe92]

Part 2 just uploaded! 👉 kzbin.info/www/bejne/jnnSlJ2CfLChgNE

[@ishuawasthi8846]

RDR horse: "U r my master i will never hit u" RDR2 horse: "Don't u dare to hit me hooman"

[@Gingersnap_Adventures]

I love my horsey and my horsey loves me.

[@Leo-mj1mt]

@@ishuawasthi8846 RDR Horses: I have sinned, I need punishment.

[@hellomate2405]

And what really amazed me the most was that RDR1 was only around 11gb

[@inferno572]

ps3 version +emulator is around 7.9 gb

[@waltuhputurdaway]

@@inferno572 and?

[@inferno572]

@@waltuhputurdaway just saying that the original game wasn't massive in size either compared to today's standards and the new pc port doesn't really add much so it wouldn't be much larger either

[@angel-kt5eu]

@@waltuhputurdaway dont start an argument lmaoo

[@SaffronHorizon]

Yeah high quality textures and pre-rendered videos usually take up a ton of space

[@EJrMFILMS]

Outstanding video, B.

[@BlaZe92]

Thank you Homie! 🥰❤️

[@stealthexecutor563]

Rdr still holds up after almost 15 years.

[@tomars3645]

it should for its performance cost it doesn't run as well as it looks didn't optimized it well

[@tomars3645]

we should be getting double of that performance because it run on xbox 360 at 720p 30 which has a very weak gpu

[@DetectivePayne]

@@tomars3645 they improved the graphics a little bit, better details and draw distance. I think those things made the game bit heavier to run

[@tomars3645]

@@DetectivePayne my settings were on ultra including all the distance scaling and somehow to me the grass and cactus distance felts worse than Xbox 360 which I played on xenia

[@tomars3645]

@@DetectivePayne it looks very similar to me

[@stealthexecutor563]

7:24 horse breaking actually exists in rdr2. You can break horses like the arabian and try to calm them while riding. Controls are similar to rdr too (using movement controls depending on the horse's direction)

[@SebaConsYt]

I would like a very long clip with comparisons between rdr and rdr2🔥

[@BlaZe92]

1 Fact about every story mission in RDR! 👉 kzbin.info/www/bejne/nGSxXqawq7BpeNE

[@TheAcabae]

RDR still better in gameplay perspectove than Starwars Outlaw

[@Kiran-kz2ku]

@@TheAcabae bro thats not even on par enough to be compared with rdr

[@99ak]

Starts wars even a game?

[@victfv]

3:55 I like how a point light is dynamically placed in the area of the fire and increases in radius depending on how much fire is present.

[@Best_of_The_West1899]

as a 14 year old game , still one of the best game with atmosphere , graphics , charcaters better than new gen games

[@HaiderPlayz_cool]

@@Best_of_The_West1899 its a creepy atmosphere

[@Und3rcov3r]

The graphics aren't better than newer games, but that's to be expected- and I'm still in awe with how they pulled it off in 2010. The atmosphere is fantastic though

[@Best_of_The_West1899]

@@Und3rcov3r i meant ubisoft tho lol

[@mist12345678910]

@@Best_of_The_West1899 ubisoft would have better graphics but the game won't feel immersive and feels flat. Enemies feel like paper cut outs and ragdoll like them too. Or make them super bullet spongey for some reason

[@MinecraftvsBurnout]

Und3rcov3r Rdr1's graphics haven't even gotten old yet. Even today the graphics are still amazing. And as you said, atmosphere is one of the important keys. Also, the soundtrack of this game is unique. It adapts very well to the atmosphere.

[@Avon_max]

The intro was fire 🔥

[@BlaZe92]

❤️❤️

[@recipiesmaker6318]

both look good but your comparison makes them better👍

[@BlaZe92]

Bro ❤️❤️❤️

[@maximusgames352]

I though i woule never see RDR on PC

[@BlaZe92]

@maximusgames352 Same here! Anyway, it's better. PC gamers can now play the sequel of RDR 2!

[@V-95K]

RDR1 is still better than most Ubisoft open worlds game released today, better than AAAA SW:Outlaws… unbelievable

[@RyuMatsu7]

Finally, a channel who doesn't prioritize one game so much and make the comparison fair. Love this channel so much.

[@BlaZe92]

🥰❤️❤️

[@Albertopiensa2004]

RDR 1 years 1911 and 1914 RDR 2 Years 1899 and 1907

[@blackthorne2001]

RDR1 is a Sequel of RDR2 it's like star wars..

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

@@blackthorne2001 It's more like RDR2 is a prequel, as RDR1 was released first.

[@blackthorne2001]

@@Maddog-xc2zv it's the same RDR1 is a Sequel of RDR2 or RDR2 is a Prequel of RDR1

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

@@blackthorne2001 it depends if you're thinking of release dates or story wise timeline. Would you said SW Phantom Menace is a sequel to Return of the Jedi? Never heard such. Because history timeline always come first in game/movie analysis.

[@blackthorne2001]

@@Maddog-xc2zv i never said the the return of the jedi is a sequel of phantom menace i said it's like star wars because it's a backward story in terms of released date. and there is nothing wrong on what i said because i said RDR1 is a sequel of RDR2

[@ltsmash254]

With all the mods coming out the game looks fantastic. It looked great before considering its age but damn the texture and character mods make the game slap. My 4k Marston is dope af. Cant wait for the other characters to get modded out

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

Let's hope they don't break the game engine, like many mods do with RDR2 engine, where trains become empty of NPC, rarely see one pass if not in mission, stagecoats also have the driver only, less animal spawn like Heron and roseate spoonbill, game crashes... My guess is many modders don't really even seriously try their mods before releasing them and also some users use like 60 or more mods in the game an expect that all goes good.

[@djs8024]

As a 43 year old man who had to go through john getting destroyed at the end of the first game then seeing arthur die in rdr2,do i really have to play throught this again?of course i do

[@BlaZe92]

❤️❤️

[@abrambur2]

Maybe not spoil the story for those who haven't played it yet?

[@Twentydollarsistwentydollars]

@abrambur2 ur late after 15 years lil bro 💀. Even if the game wasn’t on pc, you supposed to play it on a console or emulator earlier, stop pretending this game is new bruh

[@GameAffairsXT]

bro your content is soo good!

[@BlaZe92]

I appreciate that! ❤️

[@d.fortner6653]

It's nice to see red dead redemption finally playable on pc.

[@Thatnatsuki]

Nice one Blaze😉

[@BlaZe92]

Thanks 😁❤️❤️

[@chrisdobbins4436]

They already have some really good color lighting shad mods would love to see a comparison with that. Also the upscale grass and more the mods are coming fast. I made a joke on another sight this game will look like Red Dead 2 by Christmas. Well from the looks of the mods so far i think i might be right. LOL

[@FreeAimDog]

2:03 thats one thing i will never forget is whenever my mother plays those 2 games or gta v she would blow the cactus up or shoot the parts off to see how much they can fall apart.

[@MDzstation567]

Love both of them glad I have rdr1 and rdr2 it's nice to finally play Rdr 1 on the first time on pc! Pretty cool I can finally enjoy the John's story

[@yurivernadsky9947]

12:13 i dont know why Rockstar removed this from their games, it was present on GTA IV and RDR, its much more funny and realistic the player get this ragdoll

[@Etimm]

Funny yes, realistic hmmmmm...

[@yurivernadsky9947]

@@Etimm found a better argument 😎 kzbin.info/www/bejne/nXurgGqAjZyoidEsi=rV14ow22rO55YlzQ

[@yurivernadsky9947]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/nXurgGqAjZyoidEsi=xxmGFxAqpsrbvysN Yes realistic! Lol (if you say no you havent drink enoug)

[@yurivernadsky9947]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/nXurgGqAjZyoidEsi=xxmGFxAqpsrbvysN Yes realistic lol if you say no you havent drank enough lol

[@MinecraftvsBurnout]

Etimmm Yes. This is realistic. In Gta 5 and Rdr2 they don't go into physics/ragdoll state when drunk. They just have old preset animations and fancy colors. Therefore, they are not affected by external factors and don't lose their balance. When you get drunk in real life it's like in Gta 4 and Rdr1. You can't walk straight; it is only a matter of time before you lose your balance. You are easily affected by external factors. Man, undoubtedly Gta 4 and Rdr1 are very successful in physics/ragdoll. We hope that Gta 6's physics will be like Gta 4, Rdr1 and Max Payne 3. We shouldn't see old-fashioned, preset animations anymore.

[@Vrillon2025]

RD1 even shitting on newer games

[@omijerusamala6364]

very nice Blaze92 awesome🎉🎉🎉

[@BlaZe92]

🥰❤️

[@soheiich2597]

Ich habe beide Teile auf dem PC durchgespielt und ich muss sagen, dass ich den ersten Teil in manchen Dingen besser finde und den zweiten Teil in manchen Dingen besser finde. Aber trotzdem sind beide natürlich absolute Meisterwerke. Und sie sind für mich jeden Cent wert.

[@AtilonWoW]

I like how you can brawl with anyone in rdr and not get a bounty or become wanted, and the ragdoll is really fun. The brawling in rdr2 is way better though

[@chris_player2995]

cant believe its actually on pc without emulation

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

but 50 bucks for a slightly improved 15 yo console game....

[@dest1658]

Im playing KCD and tried RDR1 PC a bit and im mind blown that this 14 year old game has more animal variety and much more complex AI behavior than KCD. Hopefully KCD2 improves those shortcomings.

[@generalping999]

@dest1658 Well, to be fair, Kingdom Come Deliverence was a crowd funded game made by a small Czech studio. Red Dead Redemption was made by Rockstar, one of the most successful and biggest and oldest studios in the industry..

[@nyxieethedoe4312]

RDR drunk John reminds me of the way Woody (Toy Story) moves 😂

[@kentang_id]

John can't swimming 🙂😭

[@siannakib]

RDR 1 is so optimized that i can run it on my phone in playable fps

[@JackJicky-s8i]

How

[@athulkrishna9114]

switch emulator? i get 13-20 depending on area

[@siannakib]

@@athulkrishna9114 Windows emulator

[@siannakib]

@@JackJicky-s8i Winlator

[@siannakib]

@@athulkrishna9114 Basically run through Wine

[@watchulookinat271]

RDR1 is a masterpiece

[@km2777]

Can't wait to play it in 6 months with mods. It ll look like rdr2

[@hesitatenothing]

Though rdr 2 have the graphics and some more content, rdr 1 is just simple the best. The ragdoll physics and shooting feels more fun in it.

[@hamzanasir1567]

Really enjoying the campaign so far. When it comes to storylines and game mechanics, no one does it better than Rockstar.

[@Ealdorman_of_Mercia]

5:51 lol

[@ajirizawa5743]

proof that John is not a good swimmers

[@papillon5107]

How did Red Dead II not win GOTY? A sin.

[@rentfree01]

TGA botlicking Sony

[@RAZM-3nq]

👍👍👍

[@Sbxuldmdcj]

rdr2 horse was like "u thought u safe cuz u punched me in the face up front lil bro? na dawg i aint takin none a that"

[@amir.music2005]

John Marston: *being a badass. Also John Marston: *touches water, INSTANT death.

[@StoryWavesGaming]

The story in rdr2 is probably the best in gaming history

[@heftychonkers]

after them good mods rdr1 is looking mighty fine

[@MinecraftvsBurnout]

Rdr1 still looks very good and realistic. Graphic mods just make the game more fancy.

[@АппетитнаяВафля]

RDR1 still looks quite decent, ragdoll and killing are really satisfying, especially for an old game! Yet I'm not fan of controls, they're a bit weird, probably with a controller could be better. Still awesome game, don't know why some people told it's outdated crap..

[@MeadeJ67]

Because there are a lot of stupid people in this world. Most people calling it "outdated crap" are spoiled kids who weren't even born when this game came out. I can't wait for even younger generations to start talking that way about games they love.

[@АппетитнаяВафля]

@@MeadeJ67 we'll see. Good I had grown up with great old games!

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

But like paying for it almost as a AAA? 50 bucks?... R* is so good writing thieves stories because R* itself owns the book on how to steal users.

[@АппетитнаяВафля]

@Maddog-xc2zv the price is gross, I agree. But I downloaded the game for free, hehe boi!

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

@@АппетитнаяВафля oh, you're the kind of guy "I just care about myself". Cool. It's the same saying to you I'm one of the guys that can pay 50€, fawk the rest poor and needy people. ironic heheheh. PS if you mean I pirated and stole it you're no better than R*. Cheers

[@عبدالله-غ9د]

The best moment 😂

[@zbychukilichu9422]

Both games look amazing at night

[@Nasrul260]

pretty noticeable that the deadeye in RDR is way faster than RDR2, but at least RDR2's deadeye more cinematic than it's 14 year old counterpart lol either way, both games are good imo

[@mrbungle8493]

10Gb of data vs 150gb on disk! 😅

[@yousefsalem3058]

Still john cant swin 4:58

[@whoistroy-q7s]

@@yousefsalem3058 there's a mod like this any protagonist can swim

[@Yoweslah-ph3ls]

No wonder why Arthur always insult John about swim😂

[@DiabolicCrusher]

RDR1 has better DeadEye, RDR2 has way better horse handling for sure(and better controls responsiveness in general honestly). If they ported Red Dead Revolver too that'd be a dream come true.

[@MeadeJ67]

Lol RDR2 has much clunkier controls, I'm not sure what you're talking about here. The horses are so frustrating over rough terrain & they entirely ignore input whenever they want.

[@sutapachakraborty9337]

@@MeadeJ67 I mean, quite realistic if what they doing is simulating irl horses I assume..

[@Pedro_Le_Chef]

@@DiabolicCrusher RDR2 has better responsiveness? 😂 Someone hasn't played RDR1

[@DiabolicCrusher]

@@Pedro_Le_Chef I did though, played on RPCS3 before and currently trying to 100% the game on pc.

[@mist12345678910]

Rdr1 had less annoying gun play for sure. I wish rdr2 had some tweaks to make it like so

[@DanielHaduniuk]

That's the same game engine with improving with better physics and behavior

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

and AAA price. amazing...

[@sportanis]

please bro reply what animation you're using for intro logos.

[@BlaZe92]

It's intro from RDR 2 and just moving animations for logos.

[@sportanis]

what is the moving animation name bro please?

[@HEKFACT]

It's a port, not a remake.Why would you make a video, you already did it.

[@LyricBossYT]

Rockstar just gets better with each game

[@maxhighscoredk]

5:09 What about Arthur he swims

[@BlaZe92]

Yeah, Arthur can swim a bit longer.

[@nafian_n]

good

[@CenabNagiyev]

Arthur Morgan can swim.

[@gamzillio]

Like for 10 seconds.

[@Megatallica666]

He can also cough repeatedly

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

@@Megatallica666 and coughs blood too

[@hamidrezam2681]

It was hard for Rockstar to rebuild RDR1? No. They don't care at all.

[@Gonzas97]

Why do you want a rdr1 rebuild?

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

@@Gonzas97 because I paid 50 bucks for a 15 yo game, that's why

[@anymyo9882]

Crazy how much better RDR1's gunplay + euphoria physics are... RDR2 would be close to perfection when it would use this from RDR1...

[@williamwen3477]

too shame R* did not remake RDR1 with RDR2 engine......

[@gamzillio]

It's a lot of hassle for them, they immediately focus on the next huge project, as is GTA 6. They invest ALL of their studios for just one project, not just one or two, like it was before Max Payne 3.

[@MinecraftvsBurnout]

That would be bad. Ragdoll/physics would have been completely changed. I would say that they should do whatever they do without touching Rdr1's engine, but they have already ported it to PC as it is.

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

@@gamzillio that's for what we users paid 50$. instead we got a game with the same graphics and mechanics of those of 15 years ago. pure theft

[@Falcon-699]

​@@MinecraftvsBurnout Who gives a F about the Ragdoll Physics anyways? If people cared about ragdoll physics so much then no one would get their hands on Gta 5 or other games like Minecraft, Last of Us, Uncharted etc

[@Mastakilla91]

They took the oumph out of RDR2

[@Stillhandling2794]

You can horse break in rdr2

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

one who never broke the white arabian really never played or cared for rdr2, just to support your point. And there's a horseman challenge where you must break like 15 entire breeds of horses or pretty close, as many are only found in the wild.

[@Yukii3223]

Rdr1 👄👑 Rdr2 👄👑👑 That they are beyond their time

[@starboy10z]

Blaze can you use Red Dead Overhaul Mod bro it's so good it's maker

[@gamzillio]

@@starboy10z dude, Rockstar invests a LOT of money and manpower compared to Warhorse, let alone any big publisher (maybe except Activision). Rockstar is in the league of their own.

[@starboy10z]

Bro it's a mod​@@gamzillio

[@Iloveyourmom8888]

Why doesn't Rockstar make it this difficult in RD2? I died a lot in RD1, I died after getting shot a few times, in RD2 I never died.

[@StabilizerGaming]

No wonder RDR 1 is 10 Gb and rdr 2 is 115 GB

[@ganeshbabu8151]

5:52 😂😂😂🤣🤣

[@abdoellemo1129]

no game could beat rdr2😊

[@MinecraftvsBurnout]

Rdr1 beats Rdr2 in many aspects. But still Rdr2 is a very good game.

[@JohnDoe-np7do]

@@MinecraftvsBurnout r1 is great but ur delusional if u think its better than r2.

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

@@JohnDoe-np7do Absolutely

[@MinecraftvsBurnout]

JohnDoe Delisional? It is true that some features of Rdr1 are better than Rdr2. If you've experienced both games yourself, you know this.

[@Falcon-699]

Every Game Sequel should be like RDR 2.

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

a sequel that's a prequel...

[@samueljohansson6584]

I can't hear character dialogues in cutscenes in rdr pc, how to fix it?

[@thakrangameplays34]

Rockstar is your only hope to earn money. Lol

[@cornichoncrepu]

As a PC port, RDR1 is better, As a game, RDR2 is better. (Not talking about the things in the video, but about the optimisation, bugs, performances, etc.)

[@jameskattoor1415]

Why does the shooting in RDR 1 feel lot more fun than RDR 2?? I never realised how unsatisfactory shooting in RDR 2 was!!

[@Megatallica666]

@jameskattoor1415 Was my exact thoughts back in 2018 the moment I went on a rampage for the first time in rdr2 lol, the deadeye is easily more satisfying in rdr1 not to mention the randomly physics

[@adrierreemeese]

i think is because rdr was made to look like a western videogame and rdr2 was made to look like real life, thats why ragdolls in first game are more exaggerated and funny

[@adanaligamer8666]

RDR 1 horses are faster.

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

harder to control too. I dislike it's mechanics, almost as bad as the witcher III

[@حسينمحمد-ز7م7د]

اسبر من العمر

[@NIKHILSHARMA-or6vw]

Rdr is felling like gta sanandreas

[@nibirhasan9600]

why cactus 🌵😂

[@BlaZe92]

Good way to show how detailed, how physics works on objects, etc. 😌

[@informativegamers4700]

i liked the drunk animation of rdr way better than rdr2 😂😂

[@DajjalSlayers]

RDR1 graphics are much better than rise of the tomb raider lol

[@shinobimsh5687]

@@DajjalSlayers you need to checkup your eyes

[@DajjalSlayers]

@shinobimsh5687 yes just try both games

[@shinobimsh5687]

@@DajjalSlayers I tried both games and rise of the tomb raider has better graphics than rdr 1 easily

[@DajjalSlayers]

@@shinobimsh5687 yes rottr is more detail but the graphics dog shit

[@Raphael16045]

Stop the cap

[@ZahraShayesteh-ib2hd]

Rdr1 >>>>>> 2❤❤❤❤❤

[@taqiyyan]

RDR1 = RDR2

[@DutchPlanDerLinde-se9fk]

​@@taqiyyanbased

[@ZahraShayesteh-ib2hd]

@@taqiyyan no please

[@ZahraShayesteh-ib2hd]

@@taqiyyan rdr1 is better

[@taqiyyan]

@@ZahraShayesteh-ib2hd That's subjective.

[@Game_Genius1]

How to download rdr in pc for free

[@darknesswithin38]

RDR1 is way better. RDR2 is boring as hell

[@ethanfullerton1620]

Says you

[@KalanaPraveenEdwards1]

RDR 1 එක Intel hd ගහන්න පුලුවන් නේද ❤

[@BlaZe92]

RTX 2070 thamai recommend karanne. Lag wei mn hithanne.

[@KalanaPraveenEdwards1]

@@BlaZe92 😭

[@Creationseed9]

what a s show rdr is...

[@jorikaish]

Now rdr1 is shit I think PC version will be like rdr2

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

agree. and we paid as much as if it was a AAA game... disgusting

[@hesitatenothing]

Rdr 1 cuz the mexican womans are fine LOL

[@Ludde1478]

Rdr2s shooting is so dull

[@jakubmichniewicz343]

Hate that annoying shaky shaky when u use snake oil or tobacco sometime

[@MuhammadAdam-jo6ge]

I love both games but tbh rdr1 animations are shit compared to rdr2

[@serkançel04]

Rdr1 looks like: 🥱🙄💩😮‍💨😑 Rdr2 looks like: 🫨😲😍🗿🥹

[@detective3354]

@@serkançel04 stupid

[@detective3354]

Idiot

[@ayoubmonno9662]

Ok, kid.

[@taqiyyan]

It looks good then and still looks good now, graphics are important but it's not everything.

[@Curious_George01]

It's like a 15 year old game. The graphics are outstanding for a game that old