RDR2 Secret Ending Arthur STAYS ALIVE

I Did the mission several times and i managed to kill micah every time but then i couldn't leave the fighting area.
Plz subscribe! it helps me out alot ;)
Red Dead Redemption 2
store.playstation.com/#!/en-u...

[@Ilikeformulaone]

Me: some how kills Micah Game: mission failed Micah died

[@Shadow-is3re]

If that happened to me, I would have kept going even if it kills Arthur, I would be upset like Hell. But killing Micah is satisfying

[@preston123jesso5]

Mission failed successfully

[@xrykiz7292]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@kennedyobrien2965]

“Micah has died” Me: I missed the part where that was my problem 👀

[@TwilightTF2]

XD

[@3.214MF]

Annoying how you can stab Micah 87 times and he doesn’t die

[@VivianisAwesomee]

28 STAB WOUNDS

[@grapefruitjuice9473]

YOU DIDN'T WANT TO LEAVE HIM A CHANCE HUH?!

[@dark6277]

HE WAS BLEEDING BEGGING FOR MERCY

[@maggotstudios4052]

99% LEVEL OF STRESS

[@totallynot_a_cookie4522]

Aaah i see u are a man of culture:)

[@maddiez2744]

If it was up to me I wouldn’t have saved Micah from the jail all the way back in chapter 2

[@blazeblack4377]

No one gives a shite about fuckin micah

[@paytonfouke]

Katherine obvious

[@fxmhreaper7176]

Ya but we all knew then that he was going to be the reason we die but didn’t know how

[@mr.marston1914]

Micah isn't a rat only till chapter 5 to chapter 6

[@RedDeadDepressionist]

@Nunya Bidness not trying to nitpick, but Micah being in jail is during Chapter 2, meaning you’re in Horseshoe Overlook. Not Clemens Point

[@Brunonfire]

Its sad that we didnt get an alternative ending if we managed to kill micah. Arthur was very sick..maybe getting an ending where he did escaped the place and was taken care of by the people who stood beside him till his end.

[@Chris267R]

Yeah while he is about to die they lay him facing the west to see his last sunset

[@FirstnameLastname-gm5nl]

It should be like they all go back to blackwater some how , and they take good care of Arthur and he becomes healthy again and beats TB , and marries Sadie and lives with johns family and uncle .

[@calumroche9217]

@@FirstnameLastname-gm5nl honestly wouldn’t like that cus then American venom wouldn’t happen

[@principe7779]

@@FirstnameLastname-gm5nl omg how old are you , this isnt some pbs kids show bruh , this is a western game , grow up

[@Heldefredus]

wear a mask at the time some spat blood in Arthur's mouth he will wipe it of i did it it worked!!!

[@dylanboyce2824]

They should’ve made an ending where if you beat Micah you run away with John and survive but because of Arthur’s tuberculosis you still have to play as John for the epilogue and after

[@iqnsoor]

Now thats a great idea

[@dylanboyce2824]

@@iqnsoor they should of also made it so instead of just being able to play as John you should be able to play as Arthur but his health stamina and deadeye drains faster

[@khias433]

Yeah but then micah wouldn't have gone to to the mountains and he wouldn't have met dutch there. How would they end his epilogue?

[@Unnamed-Cowboy]

@@khias433 does he need to meet dutch? I guess it makes more sense but I'd rather have authur

[@khias433]

@@Unnamed-Cowboy I would too. Arthurs death broke me, but i'll always remember playing as him, and experiencing his grand tale. I think his death his perfect goddamn it, and as much as i'd like to have him back, i think his story reached the best possible end.

[@bradycat7682]

They should have made something where if you beat him Arthur dies a lot later on in the game

[@LeSuperFishe]

Then that would have ruined the story

[@bradycat7682]

@@LeSuperFishe how

[@LeSuperFishe]

@@bradycat7682 a sad ending is more rememberable than a happy one

[@LeSuperFishe]

@@dagothur6739 its factual though

[@bradycat7682]

@@LeSuperFishe no it isn’t he would have died anyways from his tb the player would have seen the disease physically and mentally break him down slowly how’s that for a sad fucking ending he wakes up one day and he’s dead or he’s on the beach and than dies or he’s walking and just falls and dies

[@m1abramstankcrew467]

Micah: "You weak fool" Arthur: Is literally In-game hours away from Dying and has still stabbed Micah more times

[@quinterorafa9699]

But it was like 90 stabbs so he wasn’t lying

[@FocusingFour]

*Minutes away from dying

[@Bnd8_]

Bro he got tb😐

[@TKrobot-ze2rn]

bro arthur be like: shot, beaten, hanged by his feet for more than 5 hours, starved, and then burned micah be like: shot twice, dead

[@looney_king3391]

For those of you curious of why it took so long to kill Micah in this mission its because Micah is coded to have 1000 health in this mission.

[@chapmanmccollum6291]

Pretty obvious….the question that most people are curious with however is WHY?? Like, why in the HELL Micah would have so much LIFE. But, MOSTLY, why in TF they’d make the ending where Micah’s bi’ch a__ is the one who KILLS Arthur. It’s a sh_t ending.

[@maxkrepps9474]

@@chapmanmccollum6291 its not, probably one of the best endings ive seen in media

[@gillesgrindel7985]

@@maxkrepps9474 No matter which one all ends are boring because it doesn't make any sense with Dutch going crazy and Arthur following him and trying to fix things. I would have prefered Arthur giving up on Dutch, taking the crew with him and the game ending in a duel between Arthur and Dutch with no TB at all. Arthur being abandonned by Dutch and keeping having his back is a pure joke.

[@maxkrepps9474]

@@gillesgrindel7985 I think a lot of people don’t like the ending just because arthur dies. Its the same reason people quit shows when favorite characters. It doesnt make it bad writing just because you don’t like it.

[@gillesgrindel7985]

@@maxkrepps9474 It's not the bad writing, it doesn't make any sense and it makes Arthur looks pretty dumb after hours of playing this character. If Arthur would make things right as the story says, he didn't do what it would take for that. But I understand what you mean and at least, they didn't make us playing Micah like we had to play Abby in the last of us II. I almost didn't finish the game as it was very upseting.

[@GigaTrap6000]

Player: *kills Micah* The game: what the fuck have you done that's not in the script

[@trace_0725]

What happens after u kill him

[@khalifalfaritzi155]

@@trace_0725 Itll say "Mission failed Micah killed"

[@seggsmcmuffin6630]

@@khalifalfaritzi155 no?

[@taztouz1191]

The mission freezes

[@aee14]

it's a canon event 🗿

[@mrjosh92100]

Rockstar Manager: Okay we have planned for and added every conceivable detail that most players will never see, added hidden cutscenes for different outcomes for quests. Can anyone think of something we forgot to add? RS Employee: what if the player wins the knife fight against Micah at the end? Rockstar Manager: lol you’re funny! As if THAT would ever happen!

[@danielbeltran7678]

"Oh don't worry, it happened"

[@Masonbeets.0012]

Wow that's just sad

[@isaacgillespie1301]

That's. Bullshit Micah is an a****** through the whole game through the whole game he doesn't deserve to be in it and I don't appreciate him killing Arthur it's not right the ending sucks I hate this game because of that Arthur should have lived!!!! 😡🤬

[@carltonbanks5470]

Seriously. Most of the stuff I discovered was only because of youtube. I wouldn't know about half of this game because it's all random and hidden.

[@robertlafrance9974]

@@carltonbanks5470 fax

[@nathankessel9110]

Well now we know that micas weakness is 10000 stabs to his kidney

[@thelegitdude_1232]

Micah finds it hard to land a hit on Arthur even when he is sooo weak from tb

[@ma-k-a-rparshin6449]

'Cause his a weak bastard. That's said the game itself. And I will notice he's weak how morality and so physically.

[@poopfart9801]

Surprised the Invisble sniper didn't help Micah out

[@johncorvo3132]

The amount of stabs he takes makes the assassination of Julius Caesar look fun and sweet in comparison

[@garry_wshld]

Julius wasn't a rat!!

[@so2be]

Caeser was killed by something like 5 stabs, the fatal one to his groin. Then, after he was dead, others stepped in and sticked their knives into him too, and smeared themselfs with his blood, so that outside before the people, they could proclaim they also were involved in bringing an end to the reign of Caesar, the great tryant.

[@StacieMMeier]

Indeed, and Micah was stabbed in possibly one of the worse parts of the body, the kidney area, this was deadly if it was done correctly. Micah would not even been able to do much because of that stabbing. Micah may have managed to survive it (very unlikely because of where they were). Even if Micah had managed to kill Arthur, his own death was likely minutes away. It would been a very painful and disabling death.

[@Neo_..]

Imagine if a player actually killed Micah on the first playthrough and thought that was the end of the game

[@Dan23579]

Micah's plot armour wasn't strong enough 😂

[@CustodialRuby58]

Hahaha good one

[@Yeetmachine308]

He was stabbed like 200 times

[@Yeetmachine308]

He was stabbed like 200 times

[@AntonioMaceo0740]

@@Yeetmachine308 thank you

[@baldman4589]

U can literally shank Micah for 739274 times and he just rubs it off like it’s nothing

[@prettygirlbones9928]

Everyone Else: Still trying to find a way to save Arthur. Me: Still trying to find a horse that I don't mind True Gritting in the end. 😂

[@katiejomcnair6069]

I felt this in my SOUL 😂

[@drecarter694]

Tru … Gritting ?? Omgg

[@TacoSlobberknocker]

That's funny! I'm about to sell all of my best horses and switch to my temporary horse for the last couple missions in chapter 6. I have to meet Micha's ratsnakeass in Annesburg to kill Cornwall now. Can't put it off any longer. This sux.

[@8x808]

when u loot the micah as nothing happened i laughed hard xD

[@eeemiryyy]

Agreed feritciğim :)

[@bryanosegueda6103]

I like how you named him “The Micah” He is obviously the unreleased Legendary Rat 🐀

[@valentijnschaap8332]

Yeah dude 🤣

[@abusulayman4037]

@@bryanosegueda6103 genius comment 🤣

[@leoplayz1082]

Micah was to poor 🤣

[@yaboisaintit975]

2:42 that shot though😭😭😂😂

[@legohaloboy]

Idea: If Arthur did survive the encounter, he went with John to live a new life for the remaining time he has, as he still has TB. Arthur helps in making Beechers Hope what it is, and near the end, is a cutscene like in Red Dead Redemption, where it just changes to a grave in front of John. The final mission of the epilogue is to hunt down Dutch and Micah (or one of them) as a bounty from Sadie, which you can finally get the money.

[@StacieMMeier]

Rockstar made a mistake here, it was 1899, there were treatments for consumption (TB). These treatments weren't true cures, but it did prolong and healthy people like Arthur may have managed to overcome it. Consumption weakens and causes the body to lose weight, it is this more than the lungs that ends up killing you. However by 1899, treatments were around and because of Saint-Denis, they would have had them. Here Rockstar made a historical mistake.

[@isaaccarter9007]

Yeah but if arthur kills micah you'll have 40k anyway. So there'd be no need to collect the bounty on micahs head.

[@legohaloboy]

@@isaaccarter9007 true, but then I was just mentioning if Arthur got away when Dutch walked away from Micah, and I doubt Arthur would have been able to kill Micah (even though you can in game if you dodge every hit). If John decided to come back for Arthur, it would be a different story

[@olahmarkjozsef2712]

Why is Arthur being killed??? Although there are 2 ends, they left Arthur to die on the mountain. This is the other. Micah. Not strong at the end of the game with a few shots and die..

[@legohaloboy]

What?

[@alanmccooker7829]

I started playing RDR2 faithfully from storyline in April 2020. I finished it around mid August. I completed most of the secret maps etc. and found all the gold there was to find. I really didn't know till to late about honor nor did I really care. I helped many who needed help along the way and when I robbed for money to survive I'd usually tie them up and loot them and take their horse if it was better than the one I had. I kept two at the stables in Valentine one being the horse from the old civil war veteran Hamish Sinclair, who lived in a cabin up on the lake in the mountains and a black Arabian I stole. Hamish was killed by a wild bore the day he and I went hunting. He gave me his horse. So as respect I kept him and rode him now and then. The one I rode though the game mostly was a male quarter horse I named Banjo. So when Micah killed me up on that mountain ledge that dreadful morning before sunrise I was buried with a black coyote standing at my grave. I like to when I'm home from being out of town working, play the game just to unwind and it helps to ease my mind and gives me peace from the craziness that's going on in this country and throughout the world. I can just ride out and enjoy the vast country, hunt, fish. I saved my games so if i want i can go visit old friends. If i want to talk to sweetheart Sadie I will play the early part of the epilogue. RIP Arthur Morgan!

[@partlycloudy9443]

You put a lot of effort into that comment. I think you love this game as much as I do.

[@mayurpatel9420]

​@@partlycloudy9443I read yours too, we all love the game and Arthur Morgan too

[@sb99503]

10:38 the best moment everyone wanted to see 😁😁

[@oscarjohnson2130]

It would be a facinating experience if by the time we get a rdr3 Rockstar creates a story so vast and so open that you change the outcome in as many different ways as you want. rdr2 was great but there were things about the story and ending that were set in stone no matter what like Arthur's contraction of TB and eventual death. But imagine a rdr game where Rockstar accounts for the butterfly effect of every single choice you make so you could get any of 100+ unique endings. Idek if that would be possible but it would be awesome

[@gaydolfbitler]

Games like Papers please and anything tell tale do that so it would be easy if anything for rockstar, but, cmon Arthur would have to die eventually but maybe a bit more valiant like saving John at the end of rd1

[@nickt1301]

This is how it shoulda ended Arthur shoulda killed Micah faked his death so the Pinkertons and law was off his back and ran away with Mary linton

[@oscarjohnson2130]

@@nickt1301 fuck Mary Linton dude she wasn't good for him

[@aft5264]

Do you realize how fucking big of a game that would be? Nobody would even been able to play it on console

[@pagansaiyan8114]

They did it right. You'll remember it and its got you talking about it.

[@sonoschiaffato6370]

Micah is not dead, he's just fell asleep after fighted Arthur for 1 hour

[@nicolasgerken8919]

He stab him a thousand times and he not gonna die immediately after the 3 first stabs

[@theesweetscience2084]

Never hated a character to the core like Micah. In my 2nd plythru he is the only person in camp that I triple antagonize every chance I get, and I can't tell ya how many times I've held my guns up to his head and wish the game would let the lil dot turn red!

[@jestvipual3501]

Same

[@shaitanlavey]

You can kill Micah with fire arrows when he is in the Strawberry jail. If you get him in the right spot you can even pick up his gun when he dies.

[@jake-7945]

@@shaitanlavey what happens after that? can you play on or does it come up as mission failed micah died?

[@shaitanlavey]

@@jake-7945 Apparently KZbin had a problem with my answer to you and took it down. There are several videos that show you how to do this without triggering the mission. Start a fight with someone in Strawberry so you'll have a mild "wanted" level. When the cops leave the sheriff office, head inside and downstairs, the mission will be "unavailable" and grayed out. You can dispose of Micah, get his gun, leave town and come back to do it as often as you like.

[@tobifanboy1635]

@@shaitanlavey is it still working till now? Cuz i want micahs gun so early

[@originalname8770]

there should've been an alternate ending where you can flip the farmer around so he won't spit blood on you, then you will be able to kill Micah, dutch, and all the other traitors.

[@sebi9132]

Whaz Farmer?

[@iulianionut6191]

@@sebi9132 sup bro..arthur beat a farmer who owes him money..and ge cough on arthur s face with blood..that moment arthur got TB...all for some fucking 25 dollars

[@namandhasmana]

Still Arthur killing Dutch is not possible as John killed Dutch in Rdr.

[@originalname8770]

@@namandhasmana not the first time it's been non canon tho John said he used to be a big leader in his gang but in rdr2 he's just ur average gang member

[@eyeball7465]

@@originalname8770 but he's one of the leaders, Micah Charles etc are under John in the rankings, he's been there ten years plus. He's a bit out of favour cos he left in the begining and once before

[@julianstan2017]

i wish if someone or something interfeered arthur from dying giving him a cure and taken him away for a few years leading arthur being dead by everyone thinking like that...then all of a sudden he makes a baddass comeback aka rose back from the dead and kill micah dutch and help john.....or maybe re apear in rdr 3 i cried like a baby when he died his personality is unique in the game.

[@iqnsoor]

literally every time they make us get attached to the main character then they get him killed same as RDR1 with john

[@franksanchez8111]

There was no cure for TB at the time

[@mr.cobrastan7685]

@@franksanchez8111 it came until 1943 😭😭😭

[@arthurmorganofficial4713]

@@iqnsoor tbh I think Arthur's personality is the best in the rockstar games franchise

[@phillipburrell5365]

John dies in the shootout, Rains fall finds John's body and Arthur barely breathing. The Indians take him to their sacred spot and perform a ritual and BAM.... Avatar style Arthur's soul moves into John's body and his eyes open

[@ambasing638]

"How many times can you get stabbed?" Micah: "YES!"

[@masmainster]

Micah would have bled out in the first 3 minutes, how many knife stabs was that anyway 50 plus?

[@roberthaas6430]

Now it makes me wanna go back and count it lol

[@MAEX25]

And all of them in the kidneys.

[@Lucas_Tulic]

Well, to be fair, Arthur should've died after Micah stabbed him in the side at the start if we're talking about realistic stuff. Or even earlier, when he was shot multiple times before reaching the cave.

[@crumples8]

I counted at least 75 confirmed stabs or cuts

[@TG626]

OTOH, the knife in Arthur's kidney? Yeah you don't get up from that and fight, I don't care how much cocaine gum you chew.

[@aflyingman5751]

Going with John is the best ending but i like the idea of going back for revenge on dutch and micah

[@domthasbigmuscles]

I mean it goes against everything he stood for but I think it gives a good reason for john to kill micah. Revenge

[@aflyingman5751]

@@domthasbigmuscles Exactly

[@WanderingLoner1]

I agree! It's just something about going back for revenge... Maybe it's cuz it gets you hyped to go and give one last bite to those two who've used you for too long.

[@aflyingman5751]

@@WanderingLoner1 Exactly Get a bit of payback

[@rasheedidris3231]

@@domthasbigmuscles Arthur went back for Micah and Dutch since he knew his time was done at that point but wanted John to live a new life and so wouldn't want John to kill Micah.

[@clyde1685]

If only we got to kill micha and complete the game the game like that....

[@GLJ94]

I think an interesting, alternative ending, would be Arthur and John leave together, they get away, but Arthur takes a turn for the worse and John takes him to a hospital in Saint Denis. Kinda like the ending of the movie Tombstone where Doc Holiday slowly dies from TB while Wyatt visits him every now and then. John could visit Arthur every now and then until he passes. Arthur could even ask John with his dying breath to kill Micah, and being John he would do it. Thus we still get the same ending with playing as John but Arthur live a little longer and john could have had some different dialog with Micah and Dutch on the mountain like them claiming Arthur died the night of the Pinkerton raid but John tell Dutch the truth about Arthur living till the TB overtook him and asked John to kill Micah. Just a thought i had just now.

[@alcornoquealvarez8717]

Arthur said to not look back, so killing Micah would be against his wishes

[@theremnant117]

@@alcornoquealvarez8717 That was before he failed to dispatch him lol - it'll always be revenge, but it's more than revenge with someone like THAT walking around, raising a freakin army in the mountains like this is LoTR with guns. Revenge at that point sounds like the angle's blessing lol

[@Carlie_flower]

Don't look back. Also, Arthur would never let himself die in some hospital room. No way. Personally, I think the high honor ending on the cliff was perfect. I hate that Arthur dies but if he has to die at that moment, that's the perfect ending.

[@default3136]

Yea i like your idea . It was worth

[@michaelascott8285]

perfect absolutely perfect

[@glibbleglobble8598]

Imagine Arthur stayed in the cave and waited to ambush Micah.

[@srjr91402]

No, imagine if Arthur stayed in the cave to wait for Dutch, hogtied him and finally took the deal Agent Moron- I mean Milton offered him in chapter 2 in exchange for his freedom

[@hoodiemanlp3538]

@@srjr91402 Agent Moron was killed by Abigail earlier in this mission, so it's impossible. Maybe he could offered Dutch to agent Ross

[@srjr91402]

@@hoodiemanlp3538: Well obviously that's what I was tryin' to imply that Agent Moron is dead at that point so the only one Arthur could turn Dutch in to would be Ross, which still would be badass if you could end the game that way, earnin' Arthur his freedom by handin' over Dutch as a bounty

[@professionalgamer6522]

@@srjr91402 Earning his freedom which would have not lasted long because of his TB

[@srjr91402]

@@professionalgamer6522: That's not necessarily accurate, Arthur told the Doctor in Saint Dennis, that it wasn't possible for him to take it easy in a warm, dry place, when he made his smart-ass comment sayin' "he'd just take his winter's in his country club in California" the only reason that wasn't possible was cause' he didn't have his freedom and was still runnin' with Dutch, well if Arthur turned Dutch in to Agent Ross as a bounty in exchange for his freedom, he would then be free to prolong his life takin' it easy in a warm, dry place like California

[@aflyingman5751]

Am surprised to see that you can actually kill him

[@bigbob4676]

Dudes an elden ring boss

[@proherobrine3884]

I wish arthur stays alive in the game it would be a happy ending red dead redumption real ending made me cry for 3 hours

[@knrz2562]

:^

[@fatenharoun1254]

That's a great ending

[@treykings07]

You broke the game after this, and had to restart the console, didn't you? Im pretty satisfied to see Micah die at the hand of Arthur. But sad that this is just a dream

[@charlielatner8225]

They should've made an ending where Arthur got to run away with Mary Linton and live the life he never got but always wanted. And the reason you play as Marston is cuz Arthur moved away with Mary

[@LaylaCarlson-ez2uo]

that would be a great ending

[@JMBWizard84]

*gets stabbed in the kidney* Micah: You weak fool. *gets stabbed in the kidney again*

[@mrbrayden9032]

It would’ve been cool if the time traveler went to the future and then came back with a cure for tuberculosis for Arthur

[@KalElKent821]

I always have this thought I wish it were possible

[@leonidezfromdafuture4747]

you guys go and apply at rockstar and when u guys get in there make that shit happen, That would be really gangster if rockstar did that. It would be a different version of rdr2 where the game begins with already cured Arthur morgan teleporting back from the future with the time traveler dude and they are completely naked like in termenator. Later on u find out the time traveler is a bad guy and has a evil plan and builds an army of bunch of cold blooded killers (and some of the killers where the ones that killed arthurs first girlfriend & son Isaac) also,rapist,psychos, thieves.......and then u also find out that the time traveler is fu**en satan bro......so when ur riding around when ur not doing any mission the devil will appear at night behind trees,rocks n shit sometimes in the afternoon and he will f**k with u making aruthor morgan lose his freakin mind. To be continued........

[@cyruzhrl339]

@DirtySaint22 tbh the original comment was dumb anyway

[@gojirasm]

@DirtySaint22 yeah ngl it was dumb no offense

[@gojirasm]

@DirtySaint22 you got it all wrong i was saying no offense to the person who wrote the original comment

[@FirstNameLastName-vf9hf]

Micah after this fight: Blood Lung

[@ronin8741]

“I’m half dead and you still can’t kill me” 💯💯🔥🔥🥶

[@CaptnCrunch247]

This is basically a glitch because the mission could never progress/end after that point, but it's still pretty cool.

[@BlankityBlank]

At one point Micah would be holding the knife with his right hand, and holding his guts in his left hand.

[@susiedeltarunedistinguished]

If he’s holding his guts, he’d be leaning over in pain.

[@J0shu476]

I like the way arthur gets stabbed in the back and dies a minute later and micah survives 87 stabs in the same place and is still standing HOW?

[@fiddlerooster9581]

There should be a way to recover because theirs hints everywhere in the game were they tell you oh you still got a chance or all of that

[@synkaster5946]

This was a prequel. Arthur had to die.

[@gigachad5369]

It's weird how in the epilogue part 2 when dutch shot micah, you as john had to shoot him and you had to shoot him in the head, and he didn't die. You had to shoot him like 15 times into his head and then he'd laugh turn around put his arms up and then he died. I don't get why he was so strong

[@RowanShankaras]

Micah with Aurthur: takes 1,000 knife hits to die Micah with John: takes three bullets to die

[@stetzify6694]

Man, so many stab wounds! I could hear Connor screaming more than "28 STAB WOUNDS!"

[@montylean9663]

they should’ve made 3 endings like in gta

[@LinkedStudios-qf7fc]

They made like 4 based on your choices

[@Partizani99]

why does micah call arthur a liar when its only them two, its not like someone else would hear it, what if milton really did lie

[@outlawsforlife8296]

I alwys think about it

[@akeol5230]

Nah milton didnt lie. Back in chapter 2 micah's camp has a Dutch Van Der Linde wanted poster with a 1000$ price tag on it so he was conspiring against them from the start.

[@assault112]

@@outlawsforlife8296 i love ur profile picture

[@TheWoodsmanMilling]

@@akeol5230 tge exact point I've made before

[@thepistolguy859]

Why would Milton lie tho. Every time Micah was in on twists pinkertons wasn't far behind.

[@xanderaguado9984]

Kills Micah with Arthur Me: *What, excuse me?*

[@SemiOtto]

2:45 Amazing Shot!

[@tarragoni4161]

when my horse died i was DAMN IT cause i got the best horse in the game and then arthur died and i was like NOOOOOOOO

[@xm2467]

if only arthur had a chance to survive... he would be able to find gavin!!!

[@loganwebb2839]

Who is Gavin

[@Ilovechocolatelabs]

I once shot Dutch and killed him before a mission I had to restart

[@Rik-theking]

How did you....

[@brucebeaver6929]

Should've been an ending where Arthur gets to spend his last days with Charlette up north of Annesburg and dies peaceful with her by his side.

[@dazureseventy-seven6748]

Just seeing Micah die at Arthur's hands is well worth it. Just wish he could've done it in Chapter 1. Don't think I've ever hated any game character as much as I hated Micah Bell. Thanks for the video and the patience!

[@dead-tq8ui]

Micah ran out of potions

[@KingCapone704]

They should of made a dlc where it had a alternate ending where Arthur never caught tb, left the gang when he noticed Dutch started to become unhinged and turned crazy, took the money and split it with John, Charles, Sadie, Tilly, Mary-Beth, etc, became a bounty hunter and hunted down Micah in a epic chase scene/ final showdown, and married sadie

[@fatenharoun1254]

Nice that's what you get Micah

[@Snootingson]

Best ending Arthur finds a box of thin mints and eats them in the mission money lending and other sins and doesn’t get TB and then micha gets caught and killed on gaurma

[@Snootingson]

@Gaming kid wish it was my friend

[@emerpus01]

I want those thin mints.

[@nickdaboss8u546]

The amount of stab wounds Micha would have had tho Lol.

[@serpentoni420]

imagine this is his first playthrough and he's like damn why wont he die?

[@ErichKartmann]

If It was optional to choose to leave Micah in strawberry or Send Micah to collect the debt of Downes I would do it i rather lose all my honor in that and boost it back to full honor just by going to St Denis

[@callsign_ace8113]

I like to think that Dutch and Micah were right ahead of Arthur and that they could hear him in this blood rage of pure revenge and betrayal

[@kaylabrown4699]

They need to come out with a 3 where it’s Morgan’s son or something and he takes over for Morgan and gets revenge on Dutch for betraying him

[@dusty1005]

? dutch dies in rdr1

[@2elss]

@@dusty1005 RDR1 is a sequel to RDR2

[@monkedude1863]

Arthur's son died along with Arthur's wife in a robbery for 10$. Arthur talks about it in the story

[@FNAF_World55]

What if there was an ending were you kill Micah and you survive, but Arthur doesn’t die from tuberculosis because later they make a cure or something and Arthur survives!

[@ackelson89]

I hate that we lose Arthur.... But he wouldn't be as special if he had lived. Feeling like we truly lost someone we grew to really care for. That was the point I think. We love Arthur and it crushed us when we finally completed that final mission with him. We wouldn't have the urge of vengeance and venom we have for how things played out if he had stayed alive and well. I want it that way too. Losing our friend is what makes it count and gets into our hearts. Could have been all the same if all went well with Arthur riding into the sunset. Still iconic, still legendary. But after that, what do we feel we owe the character that had a happy ending. This way there is no ending. Our hatred for those who wronged him, and the Love for our character is what keeps Arthur alive. Even years after we avenged him through John. It wouldn't mean as much, and it wouldn't sink in the way it has if gone the other way. Best character ever developed in my opinion!!

[@panuiperriam2845]

i never wanted arthur to die but i knew he had to, i wouldnt have him go any other way but the good ending, to me that was a perfect way for him to go and cry myself to sleep till 3am in the morning lol but it was powerful- and made me very upset for days, i still get upset and literally cry about it if i think about it too much, my only regret is not being able to play it for the first time again.

[@wadecornell2034]

You cry over a game character?😂😂😂😂 wtf

[@panuiperriam2845]

@@wadecornell2034 damn right i did! and so did a lot of people LOL

[@Corvus78]

@@wadecornell2034 .. bro you play like 100h on this btw its realistic and when really good man and + its your main character dies bc of rat its really really sad

[@DJLKM1]

I killed Micah in the end, it took just one punch up on that ledge. It was extremely fun to kill him, but the game wasn't ammused as it stalled and left me trapped on there within a small invisible box :(

[@voltageart6064]

They need to make some kind of update with a secret ending or AU side game thing were Arthur lives and slowly recovers from TB , He is my favorite video game character of all time and him dyeing was just hard .

[@babbabenji3212]

Turns out this is just Arthur's purgatory in the afterlife, re-living the moment before he dies.

[@ismellthecheeze6436]

Me: kills michea and loots him Game: dead rat carcass collected

[@trevthekidd]

I'm just saying, the game kinda nerfs Arthur here, not necessarily with TB, but there's many ways you could snuff Micah here and they're inaccessible, take it from a PvP player, there's a grab you can achieve (way easier on NPCs) that let's you throw the enemy, a full second in that fire and he's out like a light, literally.

[@caromorales753]

Micah can fight, so I doubt he’d just get tossed in that easily. Probably pulls Arthur in with him

[@johnmarstonedits5140]

Rockstar: sorry you can't kill Micah me: you f*cking with me right

[@ItzFarmerJerry]

Arthur died and now I don’t wanna play anymore

[@superman-rp5fu]

*I KNOW THIS IS LONG BUT ABOUT A QUARTER WAY IN I GIVE AN EXPLANATION AND ALTERNATIVE ENDING FOR ARTHUR THAT I WOULD LIKE TO HEAR EVERYONE'S OPINION ON...... THANKS FOR YOUR TIME IN ADVANCE!:)* First though to IQ Nsoor...... THANK YOU BRO! Wanted to see Arthur get the upper hand in the end..... even if it didn't really count! Rockstar gets you this invested into a character, then gives him the most unsatisfactory ending of a game I have personally ever played (well, except for Joel from TLOU but I don't count that one considering I never played it because in my mind TLOU2 was never made)! To be completely honest, I STILL haven't made it past the point where the game finally forces you to go get TB! When I first played it, I avoided the Downes farm like the......... Tuberculosis. I'm not one that cares about "spoilers". I would rather watch videos and get the most out of a game by making as few mistakes early as possible, getting the best start as possible, and squeezing every ounce of fun from it even on the first playthrough..... so as expected I learned what happened to Arthur in the end and how it started (here's where I'm hearing everyone say, "how's that not caring about spoilers thing working out for ya"). So, even with the relatively short amount of time I spent as Arthur, when the time came to go to the Downes farm...... I just shook my head, saved the game, and said "F THAT..... I'M NOT GETTING TB!" and never went back to it. The other day I had a video pop up in my suggestion list about RDR2 and I thought, man that game was great! Well, right up to the moment it was forcing me to go catch a terminal disease I didn't even get to get "the fun way" from like a hooker or something..... no, I had to get taken out by some guy coughing in my face, but whatever, I digress. Anyway, I decided to give it another try to see if I am willing to get TB when the time comes...... I seriously doubt it, but even if I don't, its still a blast to play even up to that point! Arthur may have done things in his life that earned him a death scene at the end of the game but ABSOLUTELY deserved better than the one he was given. He was a typical normal young man that was forced on his own with life dealing him a bad hand which hardened him. Then, with his remaining years on earth going from unknown to painfully visible, it caused him to take immediate stock of his life (as it usually does). He didn't like the view and realized in order to change HIS view he needed to first start with the view of OTHERS by trying to make things as right as he can WHILE he can! That's a character that deserves a bit better ending than being surrounded by the two worst people in his life standing over him as "the winners" when they are the ones that deserved Arthurs end! Again, IMO, the last scene with Arthur could have still been very close to the same but with two MUCH MORE SATISFYING differences (and a BETTER feeling of "closure") as follows (basic thoughts here remember); Dutch shows up and steps on the gun and after Arthur and Micah make their case, Dutch raises his head to Micah telling him "You EARN "number two" in this gang..... it isn't GIVEN." (basically see's Arthur in his weakened state and does this as a gesture to a dying Arthur "the right to die like a man" believing Micah to be the one to win). Arthur gives him a nod, Dutch looks up at a confident Micah and he lifts his foot off the gun, Arthur and Micah look at each other, both raise their guns and the screen goes black as you hear one shot. It comes back and in a close up of Dutch's face, he goes from no expression to wide eyed because as the smoke is clearing you see Micah, with blood squirting from a recent hole put in his neck, falling backwards off the cliff! Micah's last moments in the realization that not only was the A hole not even good enough to beat Arthur ON ARTHUR'S DEATH BED, but he is being sent on one last mission, AND BY ARTHUR, to check if gravity still works (FYI..... it does)! :) Dutch looks down and starts to draw his gun but see's Arthur is one fine motor skill away from making it a twofer. Arthur says, "I'm not leaving this world owing you a damn thing..... but NOW YOU DO OWE ME (leaving him alive knowing Dutch has the money and taking one last gamble that he can maneuver it into the hands of John)! Then says, "You go on and live out whatever miserable existence you want, BUT...... 1. YOU WILL LEAVE THE REST ALONE! 2. YOU WILL MAKE ARRANGEMENTS THAT WHEN YOUR MISERABLE LIFE ENDS, ON THE SMALL CHANCE THERE'S ANYTHING LEFT, JOHN, ABIGAIL, AND JACK GET IT ALL..... BECAUSE WE BOTH KNOW LETTING THEM HAVE IT IS THE ONLY REAL CHANCE THE VAN DER LINDE GANG IS EVER REMEMBERED FOR ANYTHING BEYOND "PATHETIC AND POINTLESS" AND DUTCH, OUR EFFORTS AND SACRIFICES WON'T HAVE BEEN FOR NOTHING (adding a dash of ego seasoning)! Dutch nods his head, turns to walk away and then Arthur crawls to the edge to watch the sunrise for the last time. THEN, the second change, John gets a message from Dutch to meet him at Micah's cabin. Dutch has ideas of finishing it all but when John arrives Arthurs voice starts echoing in Dutch's head. He opens the door, stares at John for a bit then starts walking towards him. Then with the voice of Arthur still in Dutch's head, he just walks by John and says "Take it..... its all yours". When John says "thank you". Dutch about out of view says, "Don't thank me...... thank Arthur". A bit confused John goes into the cabin and raises the lid to the chest to see the money and gold. John removes Arthurs hat, looks at it while memories of Arthur begin to flash slow to fast until the moment Arthur places the hat on Johns head (which coincides with John replacing it), and when the screen goes black you hear John say, "THANK YOU..... BROTHER"! Then while the credits roll you see the images of him returning home and then getting married etc........ I don't know about anyone else but that would have been an ending I wouldn't mind as much reaching! Wow, that was much more than I planned on...... I actually had to "scroll" to get to the top of this! SMH. I don't know why I got so into it just now (maybe it has a bit to do with the whole "Joel" thing from the last of us too but I just think characters that you are meant to get that invested in, should have better endings where you aren't feeling a little "cheated" when its all over (or A LOT cheated where Joel is concerned). Again, this is just my opinion and the ramblings of an idiot. Sorry to those of you still here!:)

[@super_pro1000alt]

Some say hisfingers still hurt

[@zombiereaperOnXbox]

I dont understand how micha doesnt get tb like come on 10:30 that knife that arther is using has arthers blood on it

[@Idiopidity]

Micah doesn't live long enough to get TB

[@aperson5466]

There should have been an alternative ending where Arthur fatally wounds Micah and they both bleed out as Dutch looks over them and walks away and Arthur looks at the sunset and also dies along Micah. And for the epilogue ending John, Sadie, and charles find out that Dutch is still alive and try to kill him but fail, This brings us to Red Dead Redemption 1 where John ultimately kills Dutch.

[@nikolator1241]

imagine rockstar makes RDR3 and the title says "Back from the dead"

[@mad9271]

the best nsoor up

[@DarkIcy64]

so you block and stab for a long time

[@d4ppl3]

The annoying part is, if you somehow kill Micah in the knife fight, the game will mission fail.

[@mythic386]

Me : oh Micah I have a minigun in my hand ready for u

[@_BENJOSEPH]

Bro how to get out of there!? Or how do u switch to John now!?

[@fahrizal7313]

This is bug/glitch but I loved it

[@bundybxtch3062]

I love all the gang members, including Dutch but Micah… man he pisses me off, I wait until I can’t go any further in the game to get him outta jail and then wait until I can’t do anything else before he comes back to camp.

[@samirrazik2705]

since arthur wasn’t in red dead 1 there could’ve been an ending where he lived but he ran away with mary linton and got better that would’ve been nice

[@randomperson2888]

I get it would be wholesome and all if Micah dies to Arthur but really, it would ruin the story line if he dies there then well, you won’t be able to play as John unless it pulled so GTA5 stuff which then would miss 30% of the story and you wouldn’t get the ending where John shoots Micah with a whole clip of ammunition

[@jestvipual3501]

So you believe the epilogue is more important than Arthur?. You have disappointed me outlaw

[@Bas1cgam3r_4]

If he died then a couple of days after he will die to the sickness I think

[@anthonypetrovic8907]

There is anator way to mace Arthur stile alive do every mission just don't do the last won

[@tracewashburn86]

Micah is the toughest bastard I've ever seen, 100 stab wounds and six bullets to the face and still walks it off.

[@Silverwing4137]

What lasts longer : The wagon burning The tent burning Micah getting stabbed 87 times

[@supremeleader_riley9159]

Idc how many endings there is going with John and having high honour is the canon ending

[@vanta_blvck]

If only the story continued

[@raulg9803]

It'd be amazing. Imagine Arthur runs away with Mary, and he has a kid of his own.

[@lordfarquaad1319]

@@raulg9803 he can't because he's already dead either way cuz of the disease

[@minakothememequeen1281]

@@lordfarquaad1319 if he goes to NA he might have a chance

[@A_Randomguy_]

The sad thing is if Arthur wasn't sick he would probably win against Micah

[@RealCasperMan]

IT'S JUST A BURNING MEMORY