RDR2 - What if Arthur pushes John into the water at the camp?

[@leopoldstrauss9957]

I like how John stands up once then just accepts his fate

[@russlasky6162]

He saw Abigail.

[@dragonwings8610]

Oy Leopold, will you absolve my debt to you?

[@leopoldstrauss9957]

@@dragonwings8610 Unfortunately, Herr Wings, I cannot. In fact, I am increasing your debt to $1,000,000.

[@dragonwings8610]

@@leopoldstrauss9957 $1,000,000!? But I had a bad spring!

[@leopoldstrauss9957]

@@dragonwings8610 I'm increasing it to $10,000,000 for your rudeness, Herr Wings!

[@MinktheStorykeeper]

*The fact that the water is barely chest deep and John can just stand up*

[@stanleybochenek1862]

Swim

[@FriedTrout25]

​@@stanleybochenek1862 his character can't swim

[@hangthed]

@@FriedTrout25 he can as an npc

[@FriedTrout25]

@@hangthed I guess your right

[@fcon2123]

Reminds me of the scene from Robin Hood: Men in Tights when Little John falls in a tiny creek and keeps thrashing around screaming he can't swim.

[@chrisdadigger1018]

John must’ve been depressed he didn’t even try to survive

[@simsim6990]

No, he cant swim

[@Haiseisgone]

Lmao

[@scottishcheese13]

@@simsim6990 no, but he could stand up

[@Boppsta712]

The betrayal of being pushed by Arthur just completely deflates him

[@ErsyachIrham]

Too tired for rdr1

[@Wh173c0c0]

*Falls into water that is maybe one metre deep.* John:"I guess I'll just die then."

[@himmahooman4304]

that's the first english comment that used meters instead of inches that i saw in my entire life

[@Deltaf]

@@himmahooman4304 lmao

[@dominikkis1541]

I actually read that in John's voice😂

[@Spentastic]

Australia has been fully metric since 1966. Other English speaking countries not so long, America never converted at all

[@Magst3r1]

​@@himmahooman4304You must not have seen a lot of comments.

[@katelynslonina7993]

Dutch: You created a time paradox. Arthur, you can't go changing the future like that!

[@mightymorphingmemory6178]

Waist high water! Whyyyy *sinks*

[@alxlight6651]

"Sorry, Mister."

[@timmyg316]

Arthur? Arthur!?! ARTHUR!!!!! DA DA DA DADA DA DA DA!

[@bensxbd]

HAVE SOME FAITH ARTHUR

[@hououinkyouma3864]

Time can be rewritten

[@gabrielherman8826]

Makes sense given that in rdr1 John sinks like a rock when you go in any body of water

[@Kehzro]

Same with him in rdr2 in the epilogue 😂

[@michealmcginnis7038]

Somehow, don't ask me how, but somehow I can make john swim a bit in rdr2.

[@Basan614]

@@michealmcginnis7038 we all can but then he dies

[@juancarloslesmesducuara1239]

@@michealmcginnis7038 how?

[@sharksowneverything1]

That’s not what actually happens if you push him in water as an npc he can swim like any other

[@202cardline]

John refused to stand up just to get Arthur in trouble. Little sibling behavior.

[@SpikeyPancake]

“Arthur! What have you done!?! You’ve created a Time Paradox! You can’t go changing the future like that! You have to understand the future!”

[@Jonny_Nonzenze]

is this an actual quote?

[@GonnerMax]

@@Jonny_Nonzenze It is, but from another game.

[@is.that.veexua]

ARTHUR!!....... YOU LEFT ME TO DIE!!!

[@krishnarjunar2724]

My brother... I didn't have a choice. John I didn't....

[@Renatinho12ful]

YOU(…) LEFT ME

[@mcnuggetyeeter595]

My boy you left me You left meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

[@Basan614]

I just tried to see if you can swim marston

[@is.that.veexua]

@@Basan614 YOU EAT BABIES ARTHUR!!! 😠

[@MrTheoriginalderek]

Any water is holy water to John 😅

[@Dat_guy96]

Arthur: “Okay, I’ll catch ya later then” *takes out fishing pole*

[@fadlimuhamadikhsan8643]

There goes the end of rdr1

[@markuskaranthus7182]

I think you mean the entirety of rdr1

[@theunknownuser9609]

Can't swim, can't herd...

[@intruderzit]

Wolves must’ve eaten his brains.

[@maximpodolny9320]

Stands...... Looks into your soul........DAAAUGH ........ Drowns

"sorry mister..." *Proceeds to push John into the water*

[@jonhyosbourne]

John Marston one of the biggest cowboys, gunslingers ever!.. 🤠 but cannot swim... 🤣🤣

[@DeathsOfTheTiger]

Everybody got flaws

[@RealMasterWindu]

how old are you?

[@Firesniw]

John just clicked "Relax" button, in the same time being in water, just look at him, he looks like he were sitting on a couch

[@FinalFury.Gaming]

"This is why mom doesn't f**king love you!"

[@jamiegoguen7384]

John forgot this was not Red Dead 1

[@midnighter4594]

Arthur: So the myths were true.

[@bigbox7479]

"Sorry mister" Proceeds to fucking drown him

[@Malvious]

Lore accurate. He can't swim.

[@LordManhattan]

What did you do, WHAT DID YOU DO

[@dpad230]

My rdr1 disc just disappeared

[@neloangelo7297]

Nah, npc john can swim. I confirmed it when i do the bronte mission to explore new austin, after accidentally pushing john in the river, i thought the mission will fail because he cant swim, but it turns out npc john would just swim back on land after getting pushed in the water

[@patchim7179]

Should’ve had Deadman’s Gun start playing 😂

[@Kyle-nz8fu]

Or maybe “That’s the way it is”

[@UmbralAzrael73]

Abigail: you seen John ? Arthur: erremm uhhh ... no...

[@kennethholder8412]

He's waiting for Arthur to save him again.

[@1stwonder788]

This is how I was taught how to swim. Had instructions yelled at me and I picked up quickly lol

[@eddiesix27]

That's not real John. Title says "stranger", so its a mod.

[@ajcorpus5155]

Idk why the way he pushes him is so funny to me 💀

[@AlexanTheMan]

Water is basically John's kryptonite.

[@cxgameitout7040]

*rdr1 stops existing*

[@chickendrawsdogs3343]

John: "May I stand unsunken, amidst - amidst the crash of..." Arthur: "Stop being dramatic, Marston."

[@lolsoutherndemocrats]

John and his water allergy. I so surprised that he still can take a bath without drowning.

[@libertyisland6950]

Everyone in the camp and Jack seeing him this way:😶

[@kassarc16]

Crazy how by 1911 every person and animal forgot how to swim just to make John feel better about himself.

[@tgtme]

I'd like to imagine that this happened before-

[@Glass-Bowl]

John's plot armor was heavy enough to drown him. ...Wait

[@DebcQ]

bro just cancelled rdr1💀💀💀💀💀 -A Clever Man-

[@Pizzaface9331]

That secret Marston ability

[@allahlsaiyed1354]

Can't herd ! Can't swim !

[@Jayzone702]

“Ok I’ll catch ya later then”

[@chrisboutabag]

“Sorry mister” pushes him in* 💀💀💀😭

[@eoin8274]

Playing the epilogue as Mr Pearson was interesting though

[@RileyPrince-m1j]

John just simply drowned

[@ilya1511]

Sorry, mister.

[@sharksowneverything1]

Ppl mistaking mods as hidden details

[@infinitedonuts9929]

9 year old me pretending to drown myself in the pool to see if anybody cares

[@ahmaddanial7044]

Suddenly wondering can unplayable NPC John swim, and even the game coded his model that he just cannot swim lmao

[@HowlSyue]

John: Shit, my ass cramps!

[@brucenator]

In defense of John dying so easily in shallow water, he was injured when he fell over the fishing pole, his hat and his jeans are made of a revolutionary material that instantly shrinks when exposed to water, which causes his hat to grip and stay glued to his head and not fall off even after tumbling head-first and causes him to go into a "relaxed" position, which causes excruciating pain in his groin, which causes him to cry out in pain and succumb to drowning. Arthur learns of this weakness in advance and is just being a bee otch while saying "Sorry, mister," and when he sees that he is dying, he just casually stands around and doesn't try to rescue him or anything; he just decides to take what little money he has, because why not?

[@drewelliott9062]

Anyway, I won't disturb you.

[@ChykGec]

Потрясающе. Обязательно опробую во время перепрохождения. Забавно что Джон обозначается как незнакомец...+ к теориям.

[@mydarkness]

Congratulations! You have done RDR1 doesn't exist anymore!

[@dkainsworld]

Bugs me so bad John can’t swim

[@unclewheelchair]

Greasy Johnny Marston should've been able to float if he was so greasy, literally unplayable.

[@Pr0ud4ng3l]

that voice, didnt sound like john

[@StepbroNate]

Took the man's belt buckle smh where's the dignity Arthur?

[@varenichek7505]

и Джон сразу стал незнакомцем

[@sushijuice6895]

lore accurate John

[@animedz9908]

Bro is a Devil fruit user 💀

[@brainstew8922]

Arthur says sorry 'mister' not Marston or John. So this must be a mod

[@tiagomira4717]

Bro hate a devil fruit

[@TheToysThatWrestle]

Lil' Johnny Marston

[@RileyPrince-m1j]

R.I.P John

[@ramen_guru]

Ok, I'll catch you later then

[@xzeedmorty6428]

John can live in vice city

[@thatthinginyoureye]

I've seen toddlers who swim better than John

[@joshuaminke6629]

seems about right. going into the want in RDR1 killed john instantly.

[@rashadd2615]

Just lasso him out, he'll be alright.

[@lordcaedus8713]

And after that day, RDR1 never happened

[@gamingcatdude3251]

who just said GAWW in the background 💀💀💀

[@FaizKTG]

He died instantly just like rdr1 lol

[@erintheangry]

Fake. NPC John can swim. You can knock him off the dock in Lakay I think it is. Whichever one has the boat dock where Dutch hangs out. He'll swim back to shore.

[@mickyb.8014]

Interesting..

[@KalizVidz]

I honestly wish Micah couldn’t swim in this vid and I’d rather push Micah-

[@MicrowaveGoesMMMM]

sorry mister

[@DeadShot-bh8ys]

This is funny 😂

[@RandomPersonadude123]

Alternative ending: arthur killed john and red dead redemption 1 never happened

[@mowiiman357]

Free John cattleman and his hat too

[@OngaroArt]

You alright BOE?

[@drewelliott9062]

OK I'll catch you later then

[@littlehorn3533]

Am i the only one who find the lack of the ability to swim on John really stupid? Is it mean that the horses can't swim either? No, the only try to make John look bad

[@MinktheStorykeeper]

Well back in rdr1 whenever John touched water deeper then like 3 feet he'd just instantly die, I feel like rockstar never implemented swimming and then just lore wise said he doesn't know how swim. Hell even the NPCs didn't swim.

[@Eme025]

Joooohn made it

[@RileyPrince-m1j]

Man I liked John but I don’t like how he died it should have been a different ending

[@hugosmith6498]

He really can’t swim can he?😂

[@bulkvanderhuge9006]

So John is actually a Witch or a Vampire.

[@barrybobert9294]

wth drag his corpse through camp

[@ivanmendez6252]

Bro thats like half the annoying missions you don't gotta do anymore

[@Tanmandapio]

Tiene los pulmones en las patas

[@Kiwi-gn8tf]

Wait. John fishes?

[@GeoffreyBronson]

GET UP BRUH

[@flintmcgraw6957]

Can you get Jhons hat doing this🤔🤔🤔?

[@MeaghanEdwards]

I LOL'd. I'm going to hell.

[@oliverhart7013]

You looted him?!? 😂😂

[@irollerblade13]

I never knew John was black.

[@johnmarston-mn1he]

Rdr1 be like

[@danielwilliamson]

Sooo, Does John just respawn?

[@comeoninmykitchen82]

C'mon now, you know Little Johnny can't swim! 😂

[@DanielRodriguez-nl6nj]

So no Red Dead Redemption 1?