Reacting to "Don't Be Happy & Peppermint Chocolate" by Mamamoo! 마마무

[@krystine269]

I'll be honest, studio Mamamoo is great but LIVE MAMAMOO IS A WHOLE OTHER LEVEL!!

[@lillerin__4666]

Live is the best quality!

[@khairunnisarahayu7786]

Still remember i was amazed saw them live on fanmeet jakarta. After that i cant ignore their charm

[@lalahon2172]

When MMM debuted they came from a small company, everybody thought they were older than they actually were, and Hwasa was so hated because of her looks that people petitioned for her to get kicked out of the group. It's wild how much MMM has went through in the early days of debut and to look at them now. Piano Man and Mr. Ambiguous (the bop that they are) were not a hit and they only really took off during the Uhm Oh Ah Yeah and You're the Best era. These girls were told that they were not pretty enough to be idols (fans hate on the CEO so much for saying this to them but I think he was right in saying so and he was being realistic. MMM, at that time, were not NOT the standard of Korean beauty and trying to lie to them and tell them that they could make it otherwise would've stunted their growth to who they are now). Because of that they had to catch the audience's attention elsewhere--good songs and a good performance and man did they do it. It's why I love these girls so much. Not only do they continue to hold the banner of "self-love" but they understand and continue to grow as artists and people. They love to perform, the love the music, and they're absolute oddballs. Seeing how they started always makes me tear up, I think there's a video out there that really chronicles how much MMM has went through from being absolute unknowns from an unknown company to what they have now (Yamachan When Mamamoo Stunned the K-pop Industry with their Work Ethic). It's amazing and I can't wait to see the new heights they'll reach!

[@idkkacoolusername9157]

i hate how the ceo said that but also it gave them the chance to work on there vocals

[@kamuigrey4597]

I'm thankful that their CEO told them that. It sound scary and almost demeaning, but it was the thruth. The audience was used to SNSD (I'm a SONE, but SM got the visual nailed down), and most of all girl groups kinda followed suit. Mamamoo came from the left side in so many ways, from their looks to their music; and it was a gamble to debut a group which so different from what was the norm back then. He prepared the girls of what was coming, including what the audience will say.

[@dmo9049]

Spot on! Im not made at the CEO for his comment on their looks either. It's a tough business and you need to know what you are walking into. As we all know there is a whole ugly side to KPOP. As someone who has interviewed and hired a lot of people, you know to hire not only talent but potential. RBW nails it everytime with their artists.

[@wil6064]

The CEO didn't told them straight out that they weren't pretty tho, he told them that they weren't model looking like so many other female idols that are tall and skinny so they would have to find a way to get past those looks and preconceived expectations in K-Pop girl groups. It wasn't a bad thing.

[@Superion74]

I'm glad that CEO told them the truth instead of sugar coating it. While it may seemed cruel, it's also reality in an entertainment industry that was (and still is) dominated by women who adhere to the Korean standard of beauty, and Mamamoo doesn't have it. What they do have, though, is abundance of talents, stage presence, and incredible vocals. When these are added to their hard works and never-say-die attitude, it makes sense how they went from absolute unknowns to one of the top girl groups in Kpop right now.

[@boperadotto8703]

Don't be happy is a hidden gem

[@vitavitaaa]

In Moonbyul's case, she really had to pitch her voice up in the beginning of their career. It was a strain but she had to fit into that 'girl group' image because of the gender standards. They had to really be careful of how they portrayed themselves because they came from no money, and despite their talents, their image could make or break them (I'm sure you have been told time and time again how much Hwasa struggled, and still does to this day). After the successes of UOAY and YTB, you can really see how their rising popularity attributed to their own growth and individuality on stage. They really blossomed at the end of 2016 with Decalcomanie, I must say.

[@sowhat5399]

Wheein was so young yet she sounds like a veteran singer she was like 17 she is insanely talented

[@aznsk8erboi182]

Yeah Wheein was 18, Hwasa was 18, Moonbyul was 21 and Solar was 22 they were so young lol

[@sowhat5399]

@@aznsk8erboi182 no these songs were released when she was 17 these songs probably were recorded on 2013 and filmed early 2014 she was 17 years old

[@aznsk8erboi182]

@@sowhat5399 Fair but it would've been have to be really early 2013 for her to be 17 years old, so we'll never know

[@sowhat5399]

@stop fanwars everyone paved the way because i am a mamamoo fan also I know when Wheein was born and when the songs released and filmed!??)

[@aznsk8erboi182]

@stop fanwars everyone paved the way ?

[@cluster_f1575]

Just remembered a couple other tracks to consider: "My Hometown", "Words Don't Come Easy" & "I Love You Too". The last of which will melt your heart as a Moomoo.

[@Bongi344]

Up up up up Also Recipe (another weird mv) Btw has he reacted to Taller Than You?

[@cluster_f1575]

@@Bongi344 I'm pretty sure he's reacted to Taller Than You.

[@Bongi344]

@@cluster_f1575 okay

[@tehlaser]

Yup. "Words Don't Come Easy" especially. That one's right up your alley.

[@ajtan06]

Basically the whole "Melting" album!

[@evuie]

peppermint chocolate is definitely more fun live, where they sing all the parts themselves (and there's no men) LMAO

[@mieindie]

they even flirt with each other

[@aversion7140]

“And Sky sky...I’m just...gonna...forget that happened...” In a van in South Korea driving away from the DMZ: *Hwasa Shudders*

[@taosnguyen4628]

4:42 Yep, which is why I think you should listen to her old album "Solar's Emotions", she will let you hear it even more. If you got the time, please listen to all the songs, if you can't, please give "Lived like a fool", "Only longing grows", "Happy People" and "Nada Sou Sou" a chance.

[@gianellab.4953]

OMG I second that. Lived like a fool is my favorite cover from her and Nada Sou Sou made me cry! They absolutely awsome!

[@krystine269]

@@gianellab.4953 Omg Lived like a fool is my favourite too!!!

[@LoHaLc]

Lived Like a Fool is superior 😭😭

[@dmo9049]

Nada Sou Sou! Bring your tissues!

[@Bongi344]

"Where The Wind Rises", "Autumn Letter", "Nada Sou Sou" and "In My Dreams" are my fav...so good.

[@kalaksed]

Bumkey was the featured artist in the first song, yeah. Its name is "don't be happy" and the mv isn't the whole song, since they wanted to squeeze in that amazing intro at the end. Bumkey is a pretty well-known korean r&b artist. I believe he knew kim dohoon, one of rbw's ceos, since pretty much all the artists that appeared in "mr ambiguous" were doing a favor for him If you ever have time for a full hour and a half long show i definitely suggest the first episode of yu huiyeoul's sketchbook that mamamoo were on. It had multuple artists, with each one doing a collab with the artist before them, doing an interview with the host, then doing a collab with the artist after them. Bumkey was the artist before mamamoo, they did "all of me" together and i still dig that cover up on a regular basis And then k will is another amazing singer and i def suggest adding him to your list if you want to check out more male singers. I saw someone mentioned "please don't" and that song and its mv are still so relevant even today

[@joysotic488]

Thanks for reacting to two of my requests... still need "Easy" and "Ah Oop!" But, I find your pikachu shirt adorable, btw, I'm playing pokemon go right now. Yes, Wheein had the fro, I think she looked good with it actually. These two predebut songs had the featured artists to help promote MMM. Moonbyul was still finding her rap style at this time. That is why it sounds so different from now. Moonbyul had originally trained to be a vocalist but the company "asked" her to be a rapper in order to debut because they already had very strong vocalists.

[@krystine269]

I think that Sir Austin might be uncomfortable with Ah Oop because Sir Austin is kinda uncomfortable with razors (if I'm not wrong)

[@joysotic488]

@@krystine269 Oh yeah, good point! I forgot about the razor thing. Yeah, he might have to skip the MV and maybe he can just do a listen on the audio.

[@xapokalypse]

@@krystine269 ah oop is a good and underrated song oof

[@krystine269]

@@joysotic488 Maybe a live performance

[@krystine269]

@@xapokalypse Truu tho

[@repz9190]

they are consider one of the best debut of kpop in 2014 by industry critic and general public if im not mistaken. their road to stardom is mostly because of their participation in Immortals Songs 2 where they showcase their vocal and performance. and they became one of the audience beloved performer on immortal songs. but now they are too busy ad had their own schedule. last time they at that show was 2018 if im not mistaken. so yeah. they off to a good start when they debut. probably cuz they debut with jazzy/retro concept with their strong vocal and performance.

[@neynee8065]

No, they actually appeared in IS in 2019. They covered a song titled meeting and moonbyul gave us her soothing vocals there . ICYMI you can check that out ..

[@Ashea92]

this pre debut intro made me fall in love with them

[@mmrn2574]

You should react to their subunit songs Rapper line/ Hwasa & Moonbyul- Dab dab and Angel Line/ Wheein and Solar- Angel

[@jaiyashree]

There is a busking video of debut mamamoo where they perform peppermint chocolate, it's amazing 💕

[@o.8684]

Yess dont be happy is one of my fav mamamoo songs. I know you dont like sad mamamoo songs but you should listen rainy season. And words dont come easy and my star are not title songs but they are masterpiece. I hope you react to them 😊

[@hawthorn4248]

The reasons they sound kinda 'weird' or 'different' in Peppermint Chocolate is because their singing voice doesn't match what is showed on the screen. The rap at 9:24 is done by Hwasa, and at 9:38 by Moonbyul (+ a bit of Hwasa in the end) but they only showed Moonbyul on video. Also from 10:55 to 11:04 Hwasa is singing, not Wheein. These pre-debut MVs can be pretty confusing for this aspect (Don't Be Happy, too), I'm not sure why they edited them like that, my guess is that the people in charge of the MVs didn't really know their voices that well yet.

[@cotesilva4217]

this songs are soooo good! when you finish the songs with mv you have to react to the live performances, especially these two songs!! I love your channel❤️

[@301th-wanderer]

I just love their pre-debut and debut eras! Since you love their jazzy vibe, you should overcome your fear of shaky barbers and react to "Aah Oop" MV and "High tension" song. Thx for the vid

[@Bongi344]

Up

[@boperadotto8703]

Bumkey is the man in Don't Be Happy. He's a fairly famous vocalist and producer and he actually shows up in the Mr. Ambiguous mv.

[@TheNocturnalFey]

Mamamoo came from a really small company but their CEOs are known as producers and composers for big k-artists even before RBW was built. So I think they used the connection in the industry for their pre-debut and debut projects to help the girls. Bumkey, K.Will, and Wheesung are all really known veteran singers in the industry. In their Mr. Ambiguous music video, there are a lot of known personalities (mostly musicians) like Baek Ji Young (the prankster), Rhymer, and K. Will and Wheesung were there as well. But since Mamamoo's sound is a bit different from the usual kpop or at least the trend back then, they didn't really took off immediately, not until Um Oh Ah Yeh. Many people think they are an older group because of their concept. Then, joining Immortal Songs 2 also really help them gain general public exposure and where they started to get known for their vocal talent. The general public and other veteran singers they're with on IS2 started calling them "BeLisMamoo" which means "Believe and Listen to Mamamoo". So, MAMAMOO really started and came from nothing and it's just their talents that really helped them get to where they are now.

[@ndutndut1993]

Please next reaction for "star wind flower sun" ,"ahh woop" one of my favorite.. Wheein did a lot collab with male artist... haha

[@ThisIsNotIt37]

I don't think I have seen you react to "Sleep in the car". If not, do check it out. It's one of those fun Mamamoo songs that stemmed from Solar and Whee in complaining that they'll have to sleep in the car because of late night/early morning shoots. There's no official MV for it except for performances. Hopefully you can find one with subtitles.

[@ben-rj6fw]

YAS OMG DONT BE HAPPY MY FAVE SONG!!!

[@franciscadelacruz64]

Can’t wait to watch for your MAMAMOO reactions also can’t wait for Immortal song reaction from them

[@chrispaulgeorge-hill7291]

The three guys (BumKey, K.Will and Wheesung) were all featured in the MV of Mr. Ambiguous. Could you please do Wind Flower in your intro next time? 😁

[@TheBreakingmoon]

I don't know if you've seen it yet, but all the mamamoo members did the show King of the Masked Singer. It would be great to see if you can guess who's who ( that probably wouldn't be a challenge for you) and give a critique on their voices. It's something i often come back to just because I love the individuality of their solo performances. I wouldn't be the best at recommending which videos exactly to watch, but I'm sure a helpful moomoo would know the best ones for you i.e. with subs, or like the best to avoid copystrike etc. keep up the hard work! You're one of my daily channels I love to watch!

[@shoichi8474]

Yas!!! I saw Peppermint Chocolate when it first debuted and was instantly obsessed. Took them a while to become popular but I'm so glad they were able to last this long. One of my favorite groups of all time, kpop or otherwise.

[@yelenna1428]

I recommend you react to more of their live performances, specifically, more immortal songs reaction!

[@eclipsed8357]

Yesss! Been waiting for this. Don't Be Happy is one of my favorite songs from them!

[@holywaterofskz3681]

Wheein sounds so good and pro even when not officially debuting. Particularly whole Mamamoo, they are born to sing and perform!

[@niceye8841]

Thank you. There are a lot of great fan cams out there that would be safe for reactions. Enjoying your channel, Sir.

[@eloise7871]

Yes !!!! Don’t be happy is my favorite 😭💜

[@bunglonsugus4097]

Yeah i remember in 2014, finding them through another idol mentioning them as promising rookies, so ofc i took a chance and search their Piano Man live performance in Music Bank and i think i just went crazy over their vocals and style and it's just raise my standard for kpop so much higher ngl

[@tartali2956]

The way they are trying to hide Hwasas face in the early songs TT It hurts

[@yangda5096]

I never noticed, and now I can't unsee it.

[@fifi8736]

No, i dont think they are trying to hide her face. it is because of her hair. Cause hwasa cut her hair before they debut.

[@suiuwu9166]

She did a pixie cut right before they debut, that's why during the whole mr ambiguous era hwasa was the only one in a hat

[@abbysantayana9672]

ahm I don't think they are trying to hide her face ..

[@tartali2956]

@@abbysantayana9672 I was more thinking that Net thing (dunno the name) and the sunglasses not the hat

[@denverone7991]

Gosh I'm so early! Don't be happy and Peppermint chocolate are my fave MAMAMOO song. Wheein's vocal there really shined.

[@cheng1768]

Don't be happy one of my faves to this day

[@nicolevl896]

don't forget!! "eSNa" is who wrote "don´t be happy" song. A great singer

[@xheralt]

"Ah Oop" was supposed to be eSNa;s debut song, but the label "persuaded" her to let Mamamoo have it with her "featuring". And then she got pulled from the live performances! She talked about it in a recent interview.

[@AegisKHAOS]

When you get a chance, do give the full version of Don't Be Happy a listen. Aside from the fact you get the song in its entirety, you get to also hear Bumkey's vocals more. Also, I like the fact it has two key changes in the full song. Btw, I miss their jazzy concept.

[@jellllu]

Bumkey and K.Will are famous vocalists in SK, so having them collab with MAMAMOO as new upcoming gg got them critics interest and some anticipation but they didn't take off in popularity until Um Oh Ah Yeah and You're The Best in 2016. Mamamoo even said they were in danger of disbanding bc their early albums didn't do so well.

[@kudgeond755]

Listen to these songs a couple of times and you won't be able to get them out of your head. They're still my go-to songs in between comebacks and never fail to get me chair dancing or bopping around the room. Mamamoo didn't make much of an impression in kpop until Um Oh Ah Yeah. By then they had a better rep among their colleagues, senior artists and the general public because of their appearances on Immortal Songs than they did for their early retro singles among kpop fans. They seem to have established themselves as artists before becoming popular as an idol group. At this time Moonbyul obviously hadn't found her "voice" in both a vocal sense and as an artist. Of all the members she's the one who's come the farthest in her artistic development and it's been fun and satisfying to follow her development. As they used to say, she's come a long way, baby. New moomoos tend to look at early MMM MVs and performances on Immortal Songs and ask why Moonbyul isn't singing or rapping the way she does these days but if you remind yourself, as you did, that they were a new group under a new label starting from scratch with few resources (financial or staff) other than the skills they had to work with at that time you can better appreciate the talent, passion and excitement they brought to the table from the get go and marvel at what they've done and how far they've come over the years.

[@hannaariel3604]

MMM pre debut featurings just gold,they r the definition of rookie monster they hv the VOCAL, charisma and even stage attitude they already hv it.

[@carat9372]

Honestly, I love your intros 😂 also yeah Bumkey is the featuring artist in "don't be happy" btw the full version is really good too

[@ayn1772]

YESSS dont be happy !!

[@aclark7920]

Having heard him briefly on Don't Be Happy (he has a verse to himself on the album version), please react to more Bumkey, you could start with Bad Girl and Gain ft Bumkey F**k U.

[@SwimingPolarbear]

A Clark f**k u is a very good song but maybe someone should warn Austin about the music video having domestic violence in it... considering that he doesn't like having to watch violence.

[@aclark7920]

@@SwimingPolarbear Fair point. I ought to change my second recommendation to Attraction.

[@adlinsafiyya4935]

Two men dance at the front with mamamoo is N and hongbin from vixx but one of the member vixx is hongbin left of this group last year and now vixx have five member

[@sarrajanelirio8500]

I never thought I would ever get to see and hear Sir Austin spit some bars

[@katyal.3601]

Moonbyul did say that before she was taught to rap in a higher pitch and it hurt her throat a lot. Moomoos are really soft for the journey of Vocalist Moonbyul but her rap evolution is really fun to explore too.

[@hayatosato1333]

Is there a video? I've never heard her say this before. My poor Byulie :(

[@Arifmdenadel]

Oooh if you search for peppermint chocolate live but just with the girls you can hear all the rap done by Moonbyul Amd omg the cringe in the intro jajajaja but you have gooood vocals

[@cec8520]

Dont be afraid to overload us, i can take it. GIVE IT TO ME

[@haymondongo]

I like your videos a lot. I can relate to your questions because something similar happened to me. I got to Mamamoo backwards: from the latest hits to the oldest songs and many things I didn't understand at the beginning. These two bops were relesed prior to debut. RBW knew Mamamoo's concept was a bold move and a risky project due to the maturity and well-positioned success of 2nd Gen girl groups. Therefore, they considered it would be a good idea to get the endorsement of renowned artists with distinctive sounds (which later would be one of the defining aspects of 3rd Gen). This created a positive association and their concept was welcomed as a gush of fresh air in an industry that had been dominated by rigid concepts and music formulas. I heard in other of your videos you're falling for Wheein. She's my ultimate bias. Make a reaction vid for their solo song Easy feat Sik K, please. Cheers on your good work!

[@louq11]

in fact dont be happy was the theme chosen and modified to make the predebut video to show each member.

[@mooltimoo6424]

re-reacting to mamamoo‘s older releases with you makes me miss retro mamamoo 😔

[@raindrop3714]

My favourite song Peppermint chocolate when they sing it live just by themselves.

[@LIA-io7ps]

That intro is soooo good 😍.

[@kaireenkim9976]

Plz do those Piano intros on your videos! It's so entertaining and I'm kinda obsessed to it! ❤️

[@Bongi344]

OMG my two top songs from Mamamoo yay 🎉

[@harveyjeresano4025]

Its best to react to every song in their albums, their are bunch of hidden gems you'll surely add to your playlist....

[@bahhesaid]

ooh, Mamamoo electroswing moment! Have they done anything more approaching that?

[@wil6064]

About Moonbyul rapping in a "girly" tone: she wasn't a rapper, she didn't trained or prepared for that before MMM. It wasn't the label pushing her to sound this way, she was just in the middle of discovering her style and this higher pitch rap is something common amongst female rappers in K-Pop groups. She has a different style now because well, +6 years of experience can do that.

[@kalayojack]

K.Will's an amazing singer, would definitely recommend watching the "Please Don't" video.

[@seahawksedvencha232]

can't believe these masterpieces are pre-debut songs

[@dehuntr9908]

Oh my lord, the intro was super cringe AF. Lol 😂😂

[@SirAustin]

😂

[@user-ameliarmpz]

omg ur voice is sOOOOOO GOOOOOD

[@phloxparadox]

Don't know if anyone said yet but there's a video of Dami and Yoohyeon covering Peppermint Chocolate!

[@autumneagle]

Beautiful vocals fire rap I really like this new soloist you featured at the start.

[@SirAustin]

Haha! Thanks. I think they're a bit ahead of their time though.

[@autumneagle]

@@SirAustin So was Mamamoo. ;)

[@zahraa4149]

There is a full version of "don't be happy" without the mamamoo intro. It starts out with bumkey and it's amazing!

[@gogojojo2718]

OMG AUSTIN!!!!! YES! I'm so happy you reacted to these songs! These two songs are simply amazing 😩 you made my morning!! You'll love AKMU too, and I can't wait for that video. Also, if you haven't already, please check out Ateez - Inception. You'll like the harmonies in that one ♥️♥️

[@anairaam]

"It's so weird hearing a man with my girls" lmaoooo then here are some suggestions for what you could listen to next: Wheein - Easy (feat. Sik-K) Loco & Hwasa - Don't Monsta X - Ex Girl (feat. Wheein) HIGH4 20 - HookGa (feat. Hwasa)

[@TheGroovyJones]

Meanwhile Solar and Moonbyul are too alkong dalkong to have any collabs with dudes in the last 6 years.

[@xheralt]

MMM (and Red Velvet) debuted at the cusp of 2nd & 3rd generations. That's how the groups became friends. RV is much more 2G in style, even now.

[@rollinjoie]

Don’t Be Happy and Peppermint Chocolate both have live performances with just the girls ☺️

[@Brickerbrack]

K.Will, Wheesung and Bumkey are also all part of the extended cast of Mr. Ambiguous... Bumkey was the chorus/backing vocalist, Wheesung played the director, and K.Will was the photographer... For funsies, Yoohyeon and Dami also did a cover of Peppermint Chocolate 3 years ago for Heyo TV... kzbin.info/www/bejne/kHKaqZtmmKijg8k Note their tweaking of the lyrics at the end... 😉

[@mikailagray]

Fun fact when Mamamoo first came out people assumed they were older and that they were like Big Mama which was a soul duo, they thought they were like bigger because of how soulful they were.

[@casualsuede]

Check out Hwasa's collab with dua lipa called Physical. K.will, who appears in Mr. Ambiguous, never appears in his mv (he was a huge supporter of their launch to appear), is the male singer. He has one of the all time biggest international youtube reactor mv's called "Please don't" that every international youtuber has reacted too. I recommend you check it out.

[@hanadarmymoo]

I can clearly understand what you're trying to say, I've been with them for 6 years😭😭😭 The excitement I had before my gosh

[@akeekle2766]

Based on this reaction you definitely need to check out recipe and cat fight (aka 고양 이) From the Melting album, they are old time style classics.

[@軟糕]

Peppermint Chocolate has radio live,search "140709 mamamoo" you can find it

[@Sirah1981]

Fun fact: Bumkey's scatting starts up Mr. Ambiguous.

[@lishakeyz5920]

Dont be happy outro is an epic intro for our girls! I too wish I discovered Mamamoo at that time 😭 I now watch reactions vids on them like a proud parent 🤣

[@LoHaLc]

Btw! Bumkey is amazing, if you want to hear the full version of Don't Be Happy with more of his vocals [he sings a whole verse] and just general amazingness, it's in Mamamoo's first album, "Hello" :D

[@angelayc203]

Moonbyul said that she struggled to find her rap voice so that's probably why she sounded "girlier" back then.

[@aizchama]

that short singing and rap in the intro was really cool! i enjoy hearing your voice despite the cringe that comes skskssksksksk

[@jessawn]

Dami and Yoohyeon did a cover of peppermint chocolate and they sound so good

[@sml5925]

You should combine your two loves, and watch Dami and Yoohyeon's Peppermint Chocolate cover

[@TheGroovyJones]

He's... not... ready!!! Yoohyeon: You ready? NO! He's not ready!

[@Orbits_Loona]

😂omg I love this intro 💖adorable!

[@yo_hana4141]

i love songs of MIMIMOO

[@Olympewolfie]

Yoohyeon and Dami did a little cover of "Peppermint Chocolate" you really need to listen to it if you didn't !

[@yogurLAPIZ]

You need to listen or watch mamamoo intros. XD Since back in the day, we have plenty and I love them.

[@Ruby_30]

I love hwasa's style in don't be happy I feel it looks great on her, I really love her, they were babies

[@YoZentrus]

All the celebrity cameos were in support of their CEO Kim Do-hoon, who was already a well regarded producer before co-founding RBW. It's true, Moonbyul didn't get much shine in the beginning. Also I'm pretty sure they also pitched her voice up a bit for that rap. It's a little sad to look at now, but also makes me proud to be reminded just how far she's come since those days.

[@hossetttren253]

i missssss their old retro style so much

[@hossetttren253]

that electric slide style awesome

[@TheLeaf424]

You should totally check out their songs dab dab and angel! Dab dab is hwasa and moonbyul and angel is solar and wheein

[@MannyHuhnni]

Bumkey is the featured artist haha 😅 Also yes, these songs are BOPS ❤️ Thanks for giving Wind Flower more chances too haha

[@LudmilaRamirez7]

No no no, in Perppermint Chocolate the rap was by hwasa (besides they shown byul face) and the second verse when you said "yes wheein" was hwasa too (besides they shown wheein face)

[@jolie0921]

Haha I enjoy your intros

[@germaineleung888]

That's what I realised when I was listening to Mamamoo's older songs -- Moonbyul tended to rap in a higher pitch (somewhat forcibly? It sounded really contrived) and I think it's either she or the company that wanted her to fit in the mold of a girly girl who raps. I don't know when that changed but I'm so glad Moonbyul is comfortable in her own skin now and embracing that lovely low tone she has

[@parafoxs]

belive me, this songs' live versions are really good. im glad you react to them anyway but itd be awesome if we could see your reaction to live versions! moonbyul's raps are better in live ofc and girls' vocals are just 👌🏻👌🏻

[@crisenbernardtacod5906]

Moonbyul Did the full rap in Peppermint Chocolate at their concert Moosical Curtain Call 2017

[@dmo9049]

LOVE your MMM reviews. If you like jazzy you should listen to Heize. Jenga is a good song to start with.

[@jolie0921]

Omg I forgot Vixx was in one of Mamamoo’s videos. That made me happy haha