Real ER Doctor Reacts to THE PITT S1:E1 | Medical Drama Review | Dr. Taylor

[@srvntotlrd]

I love how you dealt with the moment of silence. When you see things often it’s also necessary for your own humanity.

[@DoctorTaylor_Reacts]

I’m working on episode 2 currently and will hit a few key topics. Glad you enjoyed the first video.

[@user-mv6ym3th9l]

Thanks for the video doctor!! You’ve made a really interesting and novel learning resource as well. Can’t wait for more episodes (and more shows)

[@DoctorTaylor_Reacts]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@Cheesefist]

9:34 they do touch on this in the 2cd or 3rd episode, where one of the med students breaks some ribs doing CPR trying to save a crashing patient.

[@DoctorTaylor_Reacts]

@@Cheesefist yeah working on episode 2 now and hope to post on Saturday. Episode 2 critique is taking a little longer.

[@squidleyskidley]

I loved your breakdown of this episode, especially having the clinical info on the screen. Your level of detail is fantastic. Happy to be a new subscriber- looking forward to more analyses!

[@DoctorTaylor_Reacts]

Thanks!! Currently working on episode 2 and 3. Episode 2 will be a little longer review given a few big clinical things, but glad you are enjoying it. Thanks for the subscribe!!

[@FiresCollide]

You will be pleased to know that a few episodes later, one of the med students breaks ribs doing CPR and is told that's how he knows he's doing it right. Also, while it's fun to see medical doctors react to shows, sometimes you guys need to remember that every single detail can't be included in a show because there's a thing called run time, and that matters. And sometimes angles are for the camera, not for accuracy - by necessity.

[@DoctorTaylor_Reacts]

Yeah you will enjoy the review for episode 2 and 3 that I’m working on currently. Really what these shows need, if ER specifically then a panel that includes ER tech, nurse, RT, and doc. Obviously you can’t include all details but the details that are included should still be realistic and accurate.

[@ada5851]

This is great! I’m planning to go into ER nursing after I get my RN (I’m an RPN or practical nurse but have been floated to ER units to care for stable admits-to-no-beds in my previous job), so I love hearing about real experiences from doctors and nurses in the field.

[@DoctorTaylor_Reacts]

Glad you loved the review and critique. 2nd critique coming soon

[@brandonkea]

As a former LPN who’s now an ER RN, go for it!!! Get versed in critical care and learn your meds, and don’t let anyone stop you from meeting your goals!

[@Tcrror]

I'm not a doctor, but as someone that spends a lot of time in doctor's offices and hospitals.. this is easily one of the best medical dramas I have ever seen. Also, it seems to be one of the most realistic.

[@DoctorTaylor_Reacts]

You will def love the episode 2 review for sure. Hoping to post within the next week or so just with the amount of medical detail!

[@ssenkubugeumarmukz8821]

Great commentray doc!!! Loved it!!!!, super informative❤❤👍👍👍👍👍

[@MaryFrazier-r6t]

Nice critique. I think it would be interesting to learn more about how different experience and knowledge is passed down depending on a med student's/resident's teaching hospital. E.g., using ultrasound vs. ordering xray for something like pneumothorax.

[@AdderTude]

Obviously, they're not gonna do anything dangerous on live extras (re: the LUCAS) but otherwise, I've seen reactions by other doctors on YT being impressed with how accurate the show is just from the first episode.

[@DoctorTaylor_Reacts]

@@AdderTude yeah it’s impressive but needs better. And for the Lucas. Again, as I mentioned. If the editorial cut is just right or it’s a realistic body you can give that appearance.

[@DoctorTaylor_Reacts]

@@AdderTude and I did this channel as a reaction yes, but this is more than a review. I called it a critique. We are looking at details that some doctors reviewing don’t discuss. When episode 2 and 3 is done and posted you will def see more of what I mean. Episode 2 critique is a little more extensive. Doctor Mike just posted a review, great review for sure, but you will notice how in depth this went beyond his especially coming from an ER doctor where I am critiquing on a different level.

[@ada5851]

I think the amount of criticism in the review depends on the doctor’s specialty. I would expect an ER doctor to have a more detailed critique and “nitpick” certain things for a show set in the ER setting compared to a family doctor like Dr. Mike (although he would have had rotations in multiple specialties as a med student, he is more removed from this specific context). I have seen another ER doctor who was also critical about different details in the first episode of this show.

[@DoctorTaylor_Reacts]

Hope you love the review for episode 2, I hope to post it by end of next week

[@HappyPerson870]

Nice reaction thanks for takint time fo these

[@DoctorTaylor_Reacts]

Glad you enjoyed!!

[@JiffyBeey]

Definitely need to try “Code Black” it’s a great and realistic series

[@DoctorTaylor_Reacts]

It’s on my list for sure

[@DeeJayResist]

A detailed breakdown of this episode alone could take 2 hours

[@DoctorTaylor_Reacts]

Easily for sure! Episode 2 could take even longer, working on that one currently.

[@andyaug84]

I still didn't see this yet... everbody is talking about it...

[@squidleyskidley]

Wasn't a fan of them not doing compressions at all…

[@shanigribben9158]

Could I recommend Code Black as another ER based medical drama to react to? There's only 36 episodes total

[@DoctorTaylor_Reacts]

For sure. Brand new channel. Working on episode 2 and 3 currently of the Pitt. Was debating on the good doctor vs code black next.

[@shanigribben9158]

@ Code Black is definitely more ER focused and Good Doctor is quite widely hated by the autistic community

[@christianheco8648]

Great video! Was the resident doctors concern about the calcium gluconate becasue of a potential for hypercalcemia? - med student

[@DoctorTaylor_Reacts]

@@christianheco8648 likely yes, but the monitor/ekg changes are not typical of hypercalcemia and none of the patient’s story indicated hypercalcemia.

[@DoctorTaylor_Reacts]

And thanks for the like:) my first comment on my new channel

[@GwenadePins]

I’m excited to see how poorly they depict radiology

[@DoctorTaylor_Reacts]

Already 4 episodes in and you never see a trauma xray at all

[@GwenadePins]

@ I was thinking the same thing in eoisode one like whoaaaa you’re gonna set a degloved extremity no X-ray to see if or how it’s dislocated or broken and no post reduction lol

[@DoctorTaylor_Reacts]

Yeah I get even for lung eval they keep doing ultrasound with the linear transducer to rule out pneumothorax which technically is more sensitive then X-ray for ruling that out but also to be done properly to rule it out needs 6 places of ultrasound, 3 each side of the chest, which takes time and it’s much easier to just get a chest X-ray, u can at least have a look at the mediastinum, ribs, etc.

[@christymallesky8670]

Are you making fun of the pit because I like this show Noah Wiley. Seems like you took all the excitement out of it.

[@DoctorTaylor_Reacts]

It’s a critique