Real Psychologist REACTS to MONK - TV Therapy

[@tropicalvirus1897]

I'm always amazed about how they portrayed monk's therapist as someone competent that we usually can't understand until we finally see how it works on monk. An also I loved how they rejected that "the protagonist cures all his illness because of the power of love or a miracle" monk is shaped in that way and they know it. I really relate to him.

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

Thank you for watching.

[@alibabapirce9782]

is so sad he passed away in the middle of the show from heart atack. dont get me wrong i like dr bell but i wish i could see kruger reaction to monk solving his case and meeting molly

[@ZZCAR1]

Monk is an amazing show. I wouldn't mind you doing more scenes.

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

ZZCAR1, I could do more.

[@MattMorris481]

@@LiveOnPurposeTV please do more!

[@SpeakLifeNotDeath]

Love Monk and remember this particular episode, thanks for reacting to it :)

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

You're welcome, Speak Live! Glad you enjoyed it.

[@Siptom369]

I do like that Monk as a character almost never changes because he will not be miraculously cured of his illness

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

Siptom, such a fun show that brought a lot of awareness.

[@GMYSTERYICTNF]

A popular talking point about the show is the fact that Monk has Autism. it's never addressed in the show, because back when it was made there wasn't much discussion about Autism, thankfully now a days autism and autistic characters are represented more often. I remember the creator of the popular show Rick and Morty, found out he was ASD and that makes sense another popular character he made was Abed from Community who was name dropped as having aspersers in the first episode. The Rick and Morty creator then went on to diagnose the main character Rick with autism which was a big win for the community, and it made perfect sense he displayed many autistic traits. But its funny that even before Autism was a main line talking point, there was a popular show about a character with Autism and how they went through the world. The show arguably is more about Monk's autism than his OCD. OCD doesn't explain his odd social behavior or his weird traits, but realizing he's on the spectrum it makes those things make much more sense. And I'm glad that people really enjoyed his character it's always nice to see Autism appreciation.

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

GMYSTERY, there were many layers to this character and I think that is why people loved it.

[@LilyGrace1990]

Monk is one of my favorite shows of all time, and I wonder if the writers were ever in therapy because it seems like they understand a lot of how it works. It's a shame people don't talk much about Monk these days; it did so many things right. I'd be really interested in your assessment of Tony Shalhoub's acting in the show and whether it mirrors OCD and whatever other disorders Monk has. Maybe even a diagnosis? He seems to have some issues reading social cues too and I've always wondered if there was more to that. Regardless, I'm really glad they got the therapy scenes accurate. Are you going to analyze Dr. Bell later on in the show?

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

Katie Marie, I don't have any plans to do so now. Let me think about it for a bit and see what comes up.

[@CreekSong.warriors]

It’s so sad the actor who plays dr Kroger died he was my inspiration to become a therapist

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

Your life is still in progress so I hope you are still becoming a therapist. You will help many people.

[@meryldanziger4870]

This was fascinating and uplifting. As a huge fan of Monk's, I feel protective of him, so I was delighted to hear your compassionate, lighthearted and astute take on this. Bravo!

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

Glad you enjoyed it! I loved the series.

[@JaneDoe-yg7eo]

Dr. Paul, it's so much fun to hear of depictions of what you do professionally from an expert 😉 Your thorough analysis uncovers some tricks, hacks, myths, stereotypes. Love it!

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

Thanks, Kasia Misianda! Honored to have you at Live On Purpose TV.

[@otdg6787]

Man, i love this show. The actors are so good at being the characters. The interactions, the individuals, all that stuff. Love it

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

It was a great show.

[@lex7968]

I’ve learnt a lot from this video. It’s amazing! Thank you!

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

I'm so glad!

[@wisteria3032]

I remember that in this episode Monk felt he was ready to go back to work and wanted to know whether his therapy thought he was ready too (he needed his recommendation). I always thought the doctor tested him here because he wanted to see if Monk was able to concentrate on the priorities the situation required over his own personal priorities. (During the episode we see Monk doing just that, getting into a sewer to save Sharona, and _that's_ when he finally gets his recommendatin). Am I reading too much into it?

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

I don't think so. Sometimes it takes an action to show that we are ready for the next step.

[@nvaranavage]

The therapist did move the pillow, right before Monk walked in....lol

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

nvaranavage, he knows where all of Monk's button are.

[@GlennaVan]

I really liked this video! Having been in therapy for a short time, I can appreciate that he is addressing Monk's issues, not a laundry list. (Mine would not discuss my reason for being there which I made very clear in the first session - how to navigate to survive after the death of my youngest son. All she wanted to talk about was my childhood which is why it was a short time seeing her!). The most annoying thing about it was that I chose her because she had lost a child and I foolishly thought she would be responsive to all the obstacles - not ask me questions from when I was four or five years old! None of that had anything to do with how I could survive emotionally, or even physically, having to walk, multiple times a day into the room where my son died. Now, more than 25 years later, it still angers me that she ignored my reason for being there.

[@JBKNL]

Doctorrrr Jennnnnnkinnnsss!!!! Couldnt resist.. my apologies

[@lyndsiemmiles]

This is so fun. You should look at some episodes of Psych.

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

Lyndsie Jones, that is a great suggestion.

[@dorisdmwdaddelt9528]

Dr. Jenkins, unfortunately I cannot remember the exact episode where a therapy takes place but the whole series "united states of tara" starring tony colette playing a housewife who experiences life with her alters was very interesting to see when which alter appears, seemed to be a pretty functional self protection method of a deeply traumatized inner child. Besides... Monk was an amazing and famous tv show here as well. Love your positive videos as much as the ones with your lovely wife giving great advice for parents and stressed out moms 😏 stay safe during these challenging times. Best wishes from Germany 🤗

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

Thank you dorisdmw daddelt. I appreciate your kind words and will look into the episode. Best wishes back to Germany!

[@dr.d3007]

As a Psy.D. I really enjoyed this content. Good processing. Ty.

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

Dr. D, thank you.

[@jamesamick3298]

What I really really appreciate about monk because I see a therapist myself is that those scenes never are portrayed as being funny or making fun of people that have these kinds of issues. That's something I think that sometimes in film or tv it's more about making fun of the profession or the people getting treated. So, I am thankful for shows like monk and certainly law and order and others that treat the profession with respect. I think the creator of monk said a lot of therapists had sent letters about how thankful they were for how well those sessions were portrayed on the show. Anyways thank you for posting the video.

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

You are welcome, james.

[@fansinatra]

This was so fascinating. Do more please!

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

I plan on it, fansinatra! Any ideas? Thanks for watching.

[@fansinatra]

I was marvelling one day at how Andy Griffith was parenting Opie with regards to an injured bird. I think it was about bullying. He sure worked some psychological voodoo there. I can’t think of any suggestions which is why it would be refreshing to see what you come up with.

[@ianbui5356]

I think I'll always think highly of the thought that went into making Monk because they worked with OCD specialists, so I'm glad to hear that as a doctor you believe they did a great job bringing the show to life. I'm curious what your thoughts are on other therapy sessions on the show, including the ones with Dr. Bell and the replacement therapists from that one episode where Dr. Kroger retires early.

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

I will have to consider another episode.

[@traceyparnell9137]

Larry David on CURB your enthusiasm - Therapy session about the size of CHAIRs each of them have, the writing down notes and timing and watching the clock - pretty funny stuff

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

Thanks for watching.

[@mylife-23]

I have OCPD (with ADHD n some other things) as a kid growing up seeing him on tv I finally saw someone I actually related to. Someone that was alot like me. N so I got all 8 seasons on DVD 😂

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

mylife 23, that is great! It is fun TV.

[@einsteindarwin8756]

Thanks! I was going to ask my therapist. Now I don’t have to waste my 45 minute session.

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

Einstein Darwin, awesome.

[@GypsyoftheSun]

I love both Monk and What about Bob. Great entertainment ☺️

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

Agreed.

[@TheNocturnalLogician]

If you do "music therapy" videos, I would suggest covering the band, Citizen Soldier.

[@aliciaray9839]

thanks for reacting to this, please can you react to the documentary child of rage Beth Thomas, it’s a documentary about a young girl who has an attachment disorder and it’s really interesting!

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

You're welcome, Alicia Ray. I will put your suggestion on the list and consider it!

[@Atrippyboy]

I LOVE THIS

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

Thank you, Liam collins.

[@AmmonNelson]

Under what circumstances would you recommend changing therapists?

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

Ammon Nelson, that is totally up to you. If you are not seeing progress or the therapist makes you feel uncomfortable might be some reasons, but that is totally your call to make. If you are looking for someone new, we have a team of Live On Purpose certified coaches. You can check them out at liveonpurpose.coach/

[@stephaniepage4334]

I'd like to see prequel tv series about young monk just like they did with young Sheldon young Hercules young rock everybody hate Chris also tony could do voice over and I'd like to see troy gentile play young adrian?

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

That would be fun to watch.

[@jamesamick3298]

This might be kind of a stupid question, but in monk, a few times, dr. Kroger sees monk at night. So, I was wondering is that true to life? Do psychiatrists see patients at night, in the case of an emergency, which in a few episodes dr. Kroger gives monk an emergency appointment. So, since you're a psychiatrist, is that something that ever happens either with you or anyone?

[@LiveOnPurposeTV]

james amick, It is very rare. Most psychologists have regular hours. If there is a life-threatening situation that could change, but not normally for regular appointments.