Red Dead Online Top 5 Things That Make No Sense

[@sleepyfragor2902]

The sherrif: This criminal has been at large for the last 8 months and have killed multiple innocents and lawmen.... you have 10 minutes

[@Shine_0404]

lmao

[@ragnarokiscoming595]

And you will get 10 dollars. 👌🏾

[@jackmarston7644]

No you either have 60 minutes or 2 minutes.

[@ajlester8401]

One thing I would add to this list is that Harriet gets mad at you when you kill animals yet the book she gives you tells you to kill animals.

[@herredward9277]

It doesn't it just says if you find an animal in pain or you mess up, don't let the animal to suffer and end it with the pain, she doesn't tell you do go and kill animals.

[@gabrielluna3954]

That's the only one she could fined

[@bendakstarkiller5738]

@@herredward9277 He means the sample guide, not the mercy kill pamphlet.

[@ajlester8401]

Yeah I’m talking about sample guide

[@NoirVibesYT]

Why am I timed for delivering the supply wagon back to camp? Who’s timing me, Cripps? I’m his boss wtf?

[@Majorx93]

true

[@godlike119]

I am sure you have a flat hierarchy, right? Right

[@Erakelus]

If you are his boss so why is the company named after him?

[@ddynamite]

@@Erakelus you’re his posse leader but the trading co was his idea so he got to name it

[@chimpinaneckbrace]

Get him his supplies immediately or he’ll tell you again about the bank job in Tennessee. I also like when you bring back all of the supplies and he says: “Shame you couldn’t get all of it.”

[@jadynescobar9118]

* kills one enemy stealthily * *whole camp gets alerted*

[@AlMazrahHostileSoldier]

Lol so true

[@Mad-rg9sz]

Ive found the stealth to be pretty consistent in RDO, some missions just dont allow you to stealth it though

[@kanzai12]

well, same thing happen in GTAO.. just another R* mechanism

[@seamuskennedy9883]

I know right

[@ethanbecerra8708]

@@kanzai12 wdym I always use stealth and it works

[@holdencross6126]

The main thing that doesn’t make sense is Harriet sends you to kill 30 hungry poachers/hunters who have families to feed to save a single deer...

[@unitedglobalgaming2243]

Well I kill it and put the pelt in my trader so.

[@James_Bee]

Poachers weren't exactly killing a single deer to feed their family. Poachers aren't good people.

[@holdencross6126]

@@James_Bee true they aren’t but I’m guessing in some cases the people she sends you to kill are simple hunters who are just making ends meet

[@Batman-ro9mj]

Vegans...

[@Mad-rg9sz]

@@unitedglobalgaming2243 if your only putting pelts into your trader your doing it wrong

[@sinistersix3721]

Delivery of bounty: we can take the bounty now. Shut up you can wait ten more minutes and pay me more

[@multifantv1245]

Stupidest addition of all time.

[@fullbeans983]

Besides Sale missions, Rockstar always has paid "Time = money" If you think bounties are the problem, you don't understand the problem.

[@GamingSkeptic]

Harriet is really annoying. R* needs to allow you to send animal samples to Harriet through the mail like Madam Nazir

[@K1NG_of_ReVeNGe1]

Just let me buy sedative ammo through the fucking catalogue

[@dylanfuntime7761]

She's pretty..... fine... though. Yummmmmm

[@GamingSkeptic]

@@K1NG_of_ReVeNGe1 That too

[@trevorphilips9065]

@@K1NG_of_ReVeNGe1 He's just admiring her not wanting to worship her existence

[@dylanfuntime7761]

@@K1NG_of_ReVeNGe1 Mh- You'll do just fine.

[@ebinnisti1769]

The fact that you get nothing for selling your horse in RDO doesn't make any sense either. R* logic at its best

[@wr3eckeriv640]

"Ah yes the black Arabian. I'll take it for free, final deal"

[@FenceAKAGlasnost]

Sorry, we don't need any horses right now.

[@morningcontent7192]

The lock-breaker would be great in a store robbery or maybe even a bank robbery

[@Mad-rg9sz]

I hope the heists are more in depth like the Casino heist. Then the lockbreaker could open a unique door to give you a quicker escape or a extra safe with some special loot in.

[@kD0Gg1000]

Yeah people have been asking for bank and train robberies since the game came out, but they would do it like they did bounty hunting, when you got the money or whatever it is your taking there would be a time limit to get to a certain place if you didn't make the timer it falls off the horse and robbery is over, and if they did heist like in gta5 where you need other people and one dies you all fail cause rockstar seems to think the the rest of the crew wouldn't keep going they would just turn themselves in. You know anything to make it as much of a grind as possible so you might buy gold bars.

[@seamuskennedy9883]

If they added a bank robbery in Red Dead Redemption 2 we would probably use dynamite to break into the bank vault

[@Joelaaaaa]

It wouldn’t work on a bank vault but Yeah it would be great for stores

[@bigt100]

Hell naa it takes to long u wouldnt have enough time to break all the locks

[@Saayan_ide]

Flaco : get rid off that bounty first Professional: how about you get rid off your bounty huh flaco Flaco : 😢

[@vollhorst9995]

Flaco is a goat in rdr2... he is my favourite character... I would love to see more Del Lobo's in RDO❤

[@Syukur1992]

had me lmao

[@oswk9]

I think it makes sense he is in hiding so he wants people coming to see him to not be suspicious or followed by bounty hunters

[@JRV4606]

For halloween they could add ghost rider as an easter egg imagine seeing a flaming horse and person riding through the forest

[@bordlandsmoe3513]

Or a headless horseman that would be cool

[@JustCharlesBro]

I would shit myself bc the fog in Lagras is spooky enough at night

[@tejpalpanesar6012]

Sounds cool but I don’t think the owners would allow it

[@tanakaharutora4309]

@@tejpalpanesar6012 oh they will for enough money cause yk ghost rider is a marvel character

[@ChamChamRealSmooth]

We could also get zombie horses from that weird RDR1 DLC.

[@Ricardo_Rick]

About Bonne's age, she could have lied in both the Paper and to the protagonist, if only there was a 3rd instance where she says a different age we would be certain. About the bounty, its not that they are scared of you taking the law to them, they are probably scared that you may fail the mission because either the target is going to recognize you or the cops might intervene, if they needed a wanted man to do the job, they would do it themselves, don't you think?

[@Erakelus]

Smart

[@sulkii9437]

Why would she even lie in the first place

[@supersmarty8496]

But why would she lie about her age? She obviously trusted John.

[@Erakelus]

@@supersmarty8496 every women does that.

[@TheinvisibleTV19]

there´s something else, she said that the barn from the farm was made when she was a little girl and it was a gift from her father so when she grow up, she could take care of it; it wasn´t entirely like this but it was between those lines, either way the barn is none existed, not even in story mode when you can go as john in 1907

[@jjoorrggeegr]

Why a METAL detector can detect a STONE arrowhead and a WOODEN family heirloom?!

[@illuziioonsipop6726]

It detects the boxes they are in. 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@jjoorrggeegr]

@@illuziioonsipop6726 oh ok lol

[@jjoorrggeegr]

@@illuziioonsipop6726 but why are there arrowheads in chests if they’re supposed to be ancient?

[@leoistired29]

@@jjoorrggeegr probs someone found them and then burried them

[@mingusdingus6959]

@Derek Davis These Dino's had adamantium bone man

[@stale_potato791]

Why does it cost 5 gold bars to change the metal of my gun barrel?? I realize this was a stupid comment I’m just not good at this game

[@Penguin-lc3eg]

Seriously they should make it cost cash not gold. Super annoying

[@tannersrdr2clips432]

@@Penguin-lc3eg if it costed cash I would quit the game just because you want gold right now with no work doesn't mean u get ur way it's expensive because it's GOLD

[@tannersrdr2clips432]

Because good things take time make it black for cheaper or stop crying

[@stale_potato791]

@@tannersrdr2clips432 I understand and I grind in this game. I’m just trying to say that it seems a little expensive for something so little.

[@tannersrdr2clips432]

@Veer Pal yes because then everyone would be able to get gold guns easily and I wouldn't feel good about all mine being gold anymore and it wouldn't be cool if it was easy to get to me

[@WilliEverStop]

top 5 things that make no sense in Red Dead Online: 1. Not being able to break and sell wild horses. 2. Having to buy a wagon for the trader role and not being able to steal one of the many that we see on the road everyday. 3. All "legendary" garments being the same jacket with a different hood. (I don't even bother bringing them to Gus) 4. Players being able to lasso each other in "protect the legendary animal". (I've been dragged out of bounds 3 times already.) 5. Not being able to select certain story missions to replay because of low/high honor.

[@gregwilson9931]

Ya the lassholes are pretty annoying.

[@maniacsangel9046]

For Number 4: You can still blow them off their Horse with Dynamite Arrow other than that there is no Real quick Defense and against nonsense like that.

[@thisisafalseaccount105]

For number 3. I think you should do it, because money.

[@leonlinewatcher]

Self defense against agressive Animals *ahem ahem cargo greifers ahem ahem*

[@herredward9277]

All the things I knew made no sense made it in! Exept one: In RDR1, Bonnie says that the barn was built when she was a little girl, although even by 1907 it isn't build, so does she consider "Little girl" to be when you're 26 or something?

[@keisari8838]

this one always makes me angry like cmon

[@James_Philip915]

@@Journey_to_who_knows I wonder why they change the idea of letting Arthur go to new Austin

[@herredward9277]

@@Journey_to_who_knows All they did was change the 99 model by the 07 and here ya go. I used a mission replay to go to New-Austin as Arthur and yeah, only the models have changed, not the map.

[@herredward9277]

@@James_Philip915 Right? It's not like they went there, (Although there is a picture of the gang in Hanging Rock, but I'm convinced it's supposed to be elsewhere because you can see John on the picture so it can't be there.) I'd love if you could just cross the whole Great Plains area and get to New-Austin without getting sniped and without being wanted Dead or Alive. I guess they put that in so you'd have to finish 3/4 of the game before getting there but come on, Arthur wasn't appart of the robbery and he is wanted (Exept for Red Dead Redemption where he isn't.) while John isn't wanted but he participated.

[@jinxthatsme2317]

Just like the whole 1906 situation. John says he was shot in a failed robbery and the strange man reaffirms this idea when he reveals that John was shot on a ferry raid a few years ago. Naturally one would assume that the newspaper that covers Dutch’s failed robbery in 1906 would be the same one John was shot and left for dead on due to the fact that it had only happened five years ago. But Rockstar went around and said "nope" and changed it to the date of the Blackwater Massacre from the first game for some odd reason.

[@alfiemitchell3026]

I imagined bonnie lied about her being 27, as she had the hots for John. She presumably wouldn’t want him to think she’s passed her prime

[@mrtubbs1402]

You can find a letter mentioning Bonnie in the RDR2 Campaign as Arthur, which is crazy. Her age is a Mystery lmao

[@Dark_Randy]

The man dies as you loot him, he's washed ashore. I believe he wanted to marry her lol I hoped we could send the letter as Arthur or deliver it but nope :(

[@megaavonaco9954]

It isn’t that crazy when one of the red dead online missions has an old man married to a young woman.

[@englishpatriot545]

@@megaavonaco9954 I'm playing that mission right now

[@traegoins6903]

@@megaavonaco9954 not that crazy for the time. Kinda messed up tho.

[@kowboikown706]

Flaco is probably scared of a Bounty Bunter stumbling across him while they’re looking for your $10 bounty

[@JustSomeBoredGamer]

Bonnie also said her Pa built a barn when she was just a little girl. There's no barn. We called her out on her bs.

[@reek3654]

Nah, just Rockstar fucked up right there. Almost everything about New Austin in RDR2 is not accurate to RDR1. I'm RDR2 New Austin is orange but it is not orange at all in RDR1. Also John tells Bonnie that he had never been to New Austin before but in RDR2 there is a mission where he goes with Sadie even though it is established that he never went to New Austin until the beginning of RDR1

[@bigsmoke394]

I hate them wolves They run after me every time

[@noinfo438]

Friendship ended with Harriet, Gus is my new best friend.

[@ProDTeach]

Horse: stares down a pack of wolves. Also horse: yeets me into next week at the near sight of a snake...

[@uncle6431]

The only thing that doesn’t make sense is why Uncle isn’t the most feared gunslinger

[@Jackster1]

Lumbago

[@uncle6431]

@@Jackster1 it’s a slow and painful death

[@justinportillo3996]

I’m pretty sure the person who voiced flaco also thought that it was a stupid idea

[@herredward9277]

Sounds like that!

[@r3mus47]

I feel like the lock breaker had uses that they've cut earlier on or forgot to add.

[@Jackster1]

It’s called storymode

[@Almighty_Sweetapon]

Try Nerfing the Wolves Spawning Points, I’ve Encountered that MANY TIMES. And I’m Scared on going to Harriet Right now. So I crafted my own Sedative Ammo and Animal Revival. The Naturalist update is even worse than The Bikers update from GTA Online.

[@Almighty_Sweetapon]

To compare stuff, In GTA Online, you can go to another Public Session in Order to avoid getting Gunrunning and CEO Warehouse Raids, But not the Bikers or else you lose your stuff? That’s why I F*cking hate LJT. For RDO, Harriet might be annoying, because you can’t exactly measure how many animals we killed, and I bet the Wolves and Cougars were the Most Obnoxious Animals in Red Dead History.

[@3mt565]

I agree on that. I once was passing by near the Wapiti area and found 3 packs of wolves that just started to follow me while I was minding my own business.

[@nickdimitre]

Lyro Lungcay wolf spawns may be bad, but clearly the naturalist update isn’t the worst if you care about Harriet being mad at you, plus all she does is spray you and lock you out for 5 minutes which isn’t really a big deal. What I do when she sprays me is just go around collecting shit while you’re waiting for the cool down

[@CatWith-AHat]

@@Almighty_Sweetapon I've found out when using the MCT in the arcade when you click on a property to resupply if you black screen and alt f4 before the raid pops up you cancel the raid and keep everything

[@Almighty_Sweetapon]

@@nickdimitre I’m not generally against Harriet, but the Wolves spawns are needed to be Nerfed. Because Wolves came out everywhere mostly on the map.

[@deadgambler879]

Bonnie is the major plothole.... He age is broken as hell

[@xkaosdark]

And bonnie even says in rdr1 say pa built the barn WHEN I WAS JUST A LITTLE GIRL but that aint so little i believe

[@wizzle9961]

I never thought and never heard anyone talk about #2 and #1. I like that you keep ur content as original as it can be in this game and not just going over the same subjects.

[@kyeflint1]

Bonnies age 😂 I mean if she was 18 maybe I could believe that but 14?!?!? When did she hit puberty at like 7 🤣

[@krissimmers818]

Bonnie is 29 in rdr1.

[@krissimmers818]

27*

[@krissimmers818]

She looks a lot younger in rdr2

[@HyperboreanJihad]

She looks about 16 in online

[@BR78973]

I dont understand this dudes point she looks a lot younger in rdr2

[@ReHsA]

Since when does Rockstar ever made a fair game that makes sense? They don't know how to create skill-based missions, they only depend on how to make a player feel like shit

[@crunchy273]

Still wondering why I couldn’t get the legendary animal outfit after I accidentally sold the whole carcass to Gus. It just not making any sense that he actually doesn’t know how to skin an animal.

[@crunchy273]

@oxytocin the game is just, stupid...

[@matteo4282]

The last one actually makes sense as a high bounty just means more eyes on you, more people that recognize you, more trouble, more heat which logically make the mission harder and put the employer in a dangerous position as someone may be watching you take jobs from them which gives them trouble too

[@SheepTacoMan]

Rockstar needs to add a mask that defends us against Crazy Harriet’s spray

[@mycaht364]

Letting us rob her shop would be better.

[@SheepTacoMan]

@@mycaht364 Yes of course but this would be funnier 😁

[@azizt6773]

Hogtieing her and then throwing her to the alligator would be preferable let’s see if she’s gonna have some pitty on them predators

[@lewiskent550]

Bonnie MacFarlane lied about her age she is 29 in 1898 and real 41 in 1911

[@lewiskent550]

She probably feels bad about her age and hides 14 years

[@SHMEGAF]

Her barn ain't built yet. So she must be at least 3 till the end of Red Dead 2. XD

[@lewiskent550]

@@SHMEGAF she is really 18 or 29 in 1898

[@SHMEGAF]

@@lewiskent550 twas a joke. XP cause she claimed the barn was a gift when she was a little girl. It isn't even built while she's clearly 18 already. XD

[@lewiskent550]

@@SHMEGAF Oh ok thanks and like comment please

[@JTmaxx]

Number 6. That People are still playing it.

[@yetusthatfeetus]

Yup, I stopped playing after the naturalist update

[@jaywilliams9721]

Im still playing and I love it

[@JTmaxx]

@@jaywilliams9721 I'm so sorry to hear that.

[@JTmaxx]

@Ethan Nah, I don't want to play it regardless because I just want another singleplayer game. You ain't ever gonna catch me playin' online homie. Besides, doesn't even feel like an online game. Almost impossible to find other players on the map, nobody voice chats (as usual come 2020) and it feels emptier than a kid saying he's dead inside.

[@JTmaxx]

@Ethan If you're going to insult someone, make sure it actually works next time. You dunce.

[@Federico-sv8yj]

In the naturalist role can you just forget about Harriet and focus on gus

[@tonyarmstronggames9207]

Gus is not part of the naturalist role he is just a trapper u can talk to him, sell him stuff and buy stuff from him even if you don’t have the role

[@SHMEGAF]

@@tonyarmstronggames9207 still wish he could give you legendary missions though. He talks about them at times so it'd make sense. Maybe we get a poacher/trapper role down the line? XD

[@MacheteRed09]

Also why don't we take a bounty's weapon from them when we hogtie them

[@JD-ip4fs]

You know I’ve been watching you since you had 50k subscribers and you continue to be the most honest, consistent gta/rd2 content creator. No fluff, bs ads every 2 mins, and real info that has helped me enjoy these games more. I hope you see this, I can’t wait for the big million subscribers! You deserve it!

[@MrGoober60]

I think there’s a timer on bounty missions cause when you start a bounty mission you can kill lawmen and people without getting the law on you. So you basically get a 10-15 min window on creating chaos. That could easily be used by griefers to their advantage.

[@herredward9277]

Yeah, but from a world point of view it doesn't make any.

[@antoniotomas5243]

Professional will you make a video about Astro Soup? He, his yt channel,instagram and twitter channel are all gone.I was thinking you will make a video since you are good with him. Jk gamers and Molecural Mage made a video about this tragedy. Is such a sad moment to a gta community.

[@valsago]

dude nooo

[@whiskeyracer]

I know

[@whiskeyracer]

He was one of my fav youtubers

[@Cptcrippled]

@Danny Morrissey he removed all his socials his KZbin and other stuff and nobody knows why

[@Ghost-yi7qc]

I found one of his personal friends, he’s on Reddit and his username is flaming0sniper0

[@BreakingWhite]

Pro I agree with your list. But the 3rd one (timer on bounties) is actually kind of helpful because what if you accidentally start a mission, the mission is glitched or you don’t want to do the mission then you would have to find a new session, if anything it’s a good thing. Anyway love ur vids pro keep the new content up!

[@selectdevotee6810]

LUCA then just add a quit mission in the pause menu.

[@BreakingWhite]

@@selectdevotee6810 exactly

[@selectdevotee6810]

LUCA They won't do that tho. They'll be to busy making a 100 million dollar car.

[@BreakingWhite]

@@selectdevotee6810 yeah, or a 500 gold mansion

[@tobeypett7998]

What I don’t understand is Alden says he is a discouraged man, but this is set before the story takes place

[@ruzhyophoenix4370]

In SP, Trelawney mentions that term yo arthur and to me it sounded like a preexisting code, so 'discouraged men' could have been established well before sp. That's ny interpretation anyway

[@sebqss6991]

i sometimes bring dead animals to harriet to make her mad

[@Cptcrippled]

😁👍😂

[@user-pq5ct6my4y]

Lol savage

[@mycaht364]

I would flip her off and where my garmet sets.

[@oh_god_dammit]

Wow how hilarious and original

[@SHMEGAF]

I literally tossed a dead deer at her after she sprayed me for the 5th time. XD

[@Johnny_JD]

They actually fixed the bounty hunter missions timer in the newest update

[@tjohn4569]

They could make such amazing heists it would bring so many new and old players to the game

[@TheRedzKing]

What would you do with the money anyway ?

[@Batman-ro9mj]

@@TheRedzKing Maybe release some new guns, a war wagon, and honestly I’m not even joking a flying horse would make the game so much more lively or at least one that could glide.

[@TheRedzKing]

@@Batman-ro9mj lol i think we are more likely to see the firsts cars before flying horses but i dont hate the idea it would be a lot faster to travel haha

[@Batman-ro9mj]

@@TheRedzKing If they do end up putting flying horses they’re probably going to pull an oppressor mk2 and make it have homing Gatling guns which fire dynamite.

[@iesousdark]

That would wreck economy for solo players

[@Erakelus]

You forgot about Sean's front teeth that he don't have in RDO. And to be honest, Bonnie looks quite older in RDR1 than in RDO.

[@Oshidorinohina]

yeah bc it's 10 years later.

[@Erakelus]

@@Oshidorinohina i know, but the guy in the video said that she looks the same.

[@Oshidorinohina]

@@Erakelus oop yep sorry, idk why I mixed up your comment I misread it. But I will say Sean mentions the loss of his tooth during his captivity by the lawmen. So it hasn't happened yet.

[@Erakelus]

@@Oshidorinohina yeah, he should have those teeth in online. But he don't have them.

[@Oshidorinohina]

@@Erakelus he had em for me

[@Mad-rg9sz]

One thing i noticed. Theres many missions including one with pinkterons that take place at Horseshoe overlook in RDO, it can also be a camp location for players..... So your telling me the Van Der Linde gangs super secret hideout while robbing trains and shooting up towns was an ex pinkerton camp, as well as a location many outlaws previously camped at???

[@mpzakhaevski8988]

RDO is set before the story, so as you can see in the online, the gang is nowhere near to be found.

[@Mad-rg9sz]

@@mpzakhaevski8988 yeah thats my point, i think the online is set a year before chapter 1 in 1898 which means the gang was still fairly close by in blackwater or just a little west in new Austin. which means by the time the gang set up camp in horeshoe, its only been a year or less since it was last used by many outlaws and pinkertons.

[@sl1mreapa398]

@@Mad-rg9sz no if you look when you create your character it is 10 years before story 1879 I think which is why Shaun is available and Anthony and flaco and why black Belle moved etc

[@mycaht364]

@@Mad-rg9sz 1899

[@mycaht364]

@@sl1mreapa398 it's spelled sean

[@user-um2js1rm3b]

It's been 11 months since you've done a big sale on red dead when are you doing another? I love those type of vids.

[@crabsy6452]

I cant think what a really big sale in red dead could be, maybe moonshine trader and collector as naturalist isnt really a big sale

[@loganrcooke]

What’s a big sale in rdr2?

[@diplomatic630]

Hes probably waiting for a good event week to sell stuff

[@loganrcooke]

@@diplomatic630 like a sell bonus?

[@kd1441]

@@loganrcooke a big sale is when the professional sells all of his business goods and determines how much he made. I saw the one he did on gta, he saved up all of his business stock and sold them all and calculated how much he got in the end.

[@greg27160]

I can remember the times where I literally delivered bounty targets a second after the timer expires. All that work for nothing.

[@SHMEGAF]

Same. Always cause they give a tiny timer despite wanting us to take time normally anyway. XP

[@CuriousJosh]

Also how Sadie Adler’s house is still there but the building in valentine is under construction, half way to completion.

[@dkdaredevil747]

The second thing makes a little sense, as Harriet has not been attached to often, so she just sees murder. She’s annoying.

[@SHMEGAF]

I wish we could see her get attacked by a bear and just sit there coyly as she's screaming for help. Like what? You want me to save you? Naaaaahhhh... The bear is just hungry. Right...Harriet?.. 😈

[@Der_Bierbaron]

My thoughts to improve these: The lock breaker might probably used for an upcoming role or is just there and forgotten. The whole honour (and I also think price) system needs to have a revamp. I am sure we get one when we finally get an outlaw role. But I hope I don’t have to be low honour to do missions (I don’t mind getting negative points though) because the game is leading me stronger to high honour without doing much like caring for my horse or skinning an animal. The whole Harriet killing animals stuff is annoying but redundant if you maxed the role. I would have preferred if we had a new icon visible when we killed too much animals. Also there should be an animal kill cooldown that vanishes after 6-12 hours. Everything feels rushed, not very thought through

[@SHMEGAF]

She seems to forget about it if you do a mission thankfully. I literally slaughtered a load of animals. Did a Cripps trade delivery and went to her. She acted like... A normal human being? What a concept eh Rockstar? XD

[@nulle.k]

Red dead online actually takes place in 1899 because you can find Sean Maguire as a stranger near black water which means that he has been left by the gang but not yet caught by bounty hunters. And sadie's ranch has not been burnt down yet. Which means the gang is currently fleeing up to the mountains at the event's of red dead online.

[@Tenkay0]

Thanks for clearing the lock breaker problem I spent 95 dollars on that a while ago thinking I would be able to get into any house lmao

[@Jimov]

Yep totally agree with you on bounty mission timers. I always hate missions with illogical timers.

[@justapencil391]

Bonnie might be in her early 30s

[@Kent933]

Yes she really 41 In 1911

[@patrick_notpakky]

I thought I’m the only one who don’t like Harriet’s anger for killing animal for self defense.

[@johnmarston1419]

9:36 I agree but a bad person would have the knowledge that having people that are looking for is not a good thing when your trying to get shit done they dont want that extra attention

[@konhaiwoh10]

Yeah right

[@BronsonFan111]

Bounties need FIXED payouts. It doesn’t make sense to do a $$$ bounty and get paid $4.

[@herredward9277]

Like, a $ bounty alive would be 10$ and 5$ dead, a $$ bounty would be 20$ alive and 10$ dead and a $$$ would be 50$ alive and 25$ dead. (Per bounty.)

[@BronsonFan111]

@@herredward9277 perfect example. I wish rockstar thought of this. It would make the actual bounties fun.

[@DemonLordGamingAC0]

You mean rockstar giving players actual payouts? HA!

[@Misio7972]

@@herredward9277 yeah that would be awesome but we know Rockstar

[@Peanut_Arbuckle]

bounty missions are like pizza delivery missions

[@bodesea8586]

another detail about bonnie's age, in rdr1 when she makes u visit the ranch ,she says that her dad built the barn when she was a little girl . But whatever age she really has in rdr2, she inst little anymore but the barn isnt here yet

[@Fullofit1950]

Honour levels make no sense either. Kill someone and you lose honour but brush and feed your horse short while later and you get full honour back again. Don’t understand that at all.

[@bluepilgrim3]

I can dodge a charging boar, but not a crazy lady spritzing me with hallucinogens.

[@theprofessional6229]

LOL

[@theprofessional6229]

I can survive a several bullet shots but I can’t survive that lady!

[@MrArcher7]

What is also stupid is that you can see a bounty all the way across the map on the way to the bounty, but once you get there, you have to rely on map pings of their location.

[@gamerzrulez6629]

How a bounty being like 50 feet away is considered escaped

[@HummingbirdSound]

I have a cousin who is 16 and a half and she looks like she is at least 25, so I can understand that, especially in those times where life was harder and people usually matured younger.

[@CRAZY-M6641]

Number 1 should be the economy

[@ninorandazzo844]

4:46 I think it should give you the option, because the WORST thing in gta online is when I was a low level and I bought the criminal enterprise pack and couldn't do missions like the helicopter one and I was stuck chasing some stupid helicopter around the map for 30 minutes

[@_thestraightjakketsofficial_]

Another thing that makes no sense is that when playing as John Marston if you go to Mcfarlans Ranch the barn isn’t there and in the first game when Bonnie is touring John around the ranch she points out the barn to John and I says “pa built it himself when I was just a little girl” but it makes no sense because in 1907 when you play as John in rdr2 the barn is not built and in 1898 in rdr online bonnie is in her 20’s so where is the barn??

[@sulkii9437]

Stupid Rockstar is the answer

[@kentuckyjerk323]

I love RDR2 online... But this video is spot on. Can't rob trains (as Rockstar wants you to pay to play). Can't have your hunting wagon at the same time with your horse...

[@AZodiacCancer]

You can use the lockbreaker on doors, yes you can just kick it down, same with chest and shooting them, if you're doing a mission that's stealth you can do it silently. Harriet can speak/commune with animals, see her harrietutm. That's why she gets upset if you kill animals. Doesn't matter the animal. Bounty timer mission is stupid, the reason for it is because people in GTAO were doing missions as quick as they could so R* added that timer to make you unable to farm missions and get a big payout. Bonnie is more than likely them overlooking stuff. The bounty is a game mechanic.

[@SASSY-tw6mv]

The bounty thing makes sense because when your doing bounties it dedicates the part of the server and there’s a timer so the server can help and do other stuff in case it’s too long

[@VulpesChama]

The timer for bounties. It forces you sometimes to rush in guns blazing instead of going in smart. And while you can take out the target silently and alive, the guards will always know. And then I had this bounty of which the timer ran out while I was stepping through the door of the police station. About Harriet: it makes sense, as in her eyes you are not supposed to run around without the vermint or even be out there.

[@luketaylor750]

that bounty thing somewhat makes sense actually. if they don't want to be discovered and a person with a bounty keeps visiting them... you could be potentially followed/seen/tracked BECAUSE you have a bounty on you. obviously

[@justinamerican8200]

On the bounties... when I first started playing a few weeks ago, I found someone trussed up on the side of the road, no one else around. Having no clue what they were (maybe some kind of random quest, I thought) I cut them free. Dude attacked me, I shot him dead, and then I got a "murder" indicator.

[@MariusBoss11458]

8:26 That sound effect makes me die on the floor from Laughing 😂😂😂😂

[@ParadoxicWasHere]

The low honour / no bounty thing makes perfect sense Flaco has a high bounty, so he stays hidden in his shack - he is sending you out, so if you have a bounty, that could lead to him. These people send other, less recognised people to do their jobs for them, because if they did it, they'd get arrested, so they don't want you to get arrested because you may lead the law back to them

[@travismeta3727]

Harriet expects you to be the next Steve Irwin

[@tombuchanan7302]

I accidentally bought the lock breaker and I was mad

[@Justini0]

The only use for the lock breaker would be if there’s one dude on the carriage, and you lasso him off and hogtie them without spooking the horses. Then if you were to shoot the lock, they’re spooked. How many times have I done this? Only about 3 times. Not worth it for a biscuit.

[@FastGunner2040]

The simple answer (to most things) is that it's Rockstar trying to make money in the Online mode.

[@Amoicavalli]

Bonnie Also says something in the first game about her Dad building the barn when she was a little girl. And there is no barn in rdr2.

[@whosrevxnge5582]

A Shrek Easter egg would be nice

[@crzi_xtaters]

Good video Pat I’ve been waiting for this one. Can you make Top 5 most annoying NPCs? Anyway love the content keep up the great work.

[@HummingbirdSound]

The bounty thing is actually very logical. If you are a hot target at the moment for lawmen, criminals in hiding would have to be stupid to hire you to do dirty jobs for them and take the risk that you bring lawmen who would watch or pursue you to them. They need some low key hillybilly to do their bidding without getting too much attention to themselves, so that lawmen do not suspect they are behind it all, so a high priority target who shows up for a job will understandably be rejected.

[@elite-mellonyt725]

5th about the bounty, They assume that over $10 bounty that you wouldn't be good for the job since you would be a snake in the dirt.

[@frazier00]

TheProfessional: talking about things that don't make sense in red dead redemption KZbin: he's playing fallout 4 in the video!

[@Deadbolt75]

Bonnie also says, daddy built the barn when she was a little girl, but there is no barn in rdr2

[@RatBoyTriple6ix]

#1 makes perfect sense to me, especially if they have bounties themselves... they probably don’t want u getting in trouble and ratting out on them. They’d rather have someone who isn’t a high risk of tracing back to them

[@ShadowbornRaven]

You missed the part where Bonnie says in the first game that her father built the barn when she was she was just a young girl (meaning a very young age) yet in red dead redemption 2, the building hasn't even started.

[@michaelz.3993]

It also doesn't make sense that you find Shaun in west elizabeth looking for the gang a year before the events of the story

[@fernandom.varela1109]

"Joe, Mama Watson" I see what you did there

[@ladyjaydee9891]

It bothers evil characters because if you’re doing shady stuff and you get caught they are now being looked at. Guilty by association as they say

[@stefangalarza1751]

Online takes place in 1899 a few months before the story lines starts and that newspaper clip from 1914 at the end of red dead redemption 1 so she would have been 28 at the time of the new paper clipping meaning she would b 17 in RDR2

[@NudePizza69]

Bonnie also mentions in RDR 1 that her dad built the barn when she was a little girl, Jump to Rdr online and there is no barn

[@redplague2133]

What doesn't make sense to me is 3rd person auto-centering on horses/wagons if you're right beside those (or just got off one). Even if you're not looking at them directly and they're just in the corner of your screen, the camera will turn you that way instead of letting you aim or use emotes. It's possible to disable this "feature" in first person, but NOT in 3rd. WHY??? I play on PC, but always prefer 3rd person mode to enjoy the aesthetics of the game more.

[@Misio7972]

The bounties should be just like in the story or irl you get a promised amount of money of the bounty the timer is one of the reasons I don't do bounties so often