Red Dead Redemption - Mission #48 - And the Truth Will Set You Free (Xbox One)

[@TheLukey27]

From Dutch's perspective. The last thing he saw was his last remaining son.

[@RYANG6916]

Morgan would be happy... 😁😁

[@arditazman6823]

Not really. Dutch is a very manipulative talker but he only really cares about himself. Remember in rdr2, he hid all of the Blackwater heist money and lied to arthur that they were lost.

[@A_29886]

@@arditazman6823 you do realise he was trying to warn John because he actually cared about him

[@arditazman6823]

@@A_29886 then why did he leave john to die in the train heist

[@A_29886]

@@arditazman6823 that was because Dutch had so much going on and he was insane no doubt about that but deep down in the long run he cared about all of them even Arthur which is the reason Dutch tries to kill micah

[@AlexKS1992]

The quote "Our time has passed" still gives me chills because Dutch told John what would happen in the end.

[@Charlie627]

Alex the Hun in the end of what?

[@luciferwithexistentialcris5457]

The end of the game, where John also dies

[@ArthurMuneh]

That is what Arthur warned him 12 years ago

[@DanielMiranda-bn4ul]

Alex the Hun no the end of the Wild West

[@Gh0st652]

Oh my god the delivery is.... HAUNTING! Dutchs voice actor is super underrated. It's so quiet and reserved, and bitter.

[@Jack_The_Ladd]

This mission is so much more deeper and tragic after Red Dead II.

[@ab_khanayy]

every line every dialogue makes sense after completing RDR2

[@A_29886]

@@ab_khanayy well it made sense before but ok

[@adificationss]

@@A_29886 it made sense before but RDR2 gave it even more sense and depth.

[@thizguy519]

Idk it wasn't that impactful for me we don't spend enough time seeing Dutch as a character and rdr2 actually made this scene better

[@Jessica-kh1qg]

In my opinion Dutch got what he deserved. Javier, Bill, Dutch, they deserved to die. This is revenge, for ARTHUR!

[@realnimrod3436]

“I got a plan, John” “You always got a plan, Dutch” “This is a good one” “I don’t doubt it” RDR2 in a nutshell

[@phil9947]

I just played this mission... and I felt so bad for laughing when I heard Dutch say this, after having played through RDR2.

[@masterblaster2678]

@@phil9947 I love how they expanded upon the whole character using this one line as a basis. We had a lot of earfuls from Dutch about his foolproof totally-gonna-work-this-time-I-swear plans. Also made me emotional when he recited the quotes from his last wholesome duo moment with Arthur, when they were escaping together from the army. And how he said "Our time is passed, John." like in the whole story of RDR2, this man was so serious and radical about his dream to make the "ideal America" that he ended up sacrificing his gang for it in his insanity. And now, you see him completely hopeless and accepting that it feels surreal. His death leaves you feeling somber after having played through RDR2.

[@phil9947]

@@masterblaster2678 For me the real turning point in RDR2 was Hosea going with the Saint Denis bank robbery. That kind of heist was far beyond the gang's realm of knowledge and experience, especially after the traps they fell into with Bronte. We could say that "Hosea should have known better" and IMO he definitely did, but it's a very real human trait to know better, but to do the wrong thing anyway.

[@judeowens8050]

The good plan was go to Tahiti and have a family

[@phil9947]

@@judeowens8050 I wish there had been a "joke ending" where if Arthur put $1 million or some other ridiculous amount of money into the contribution box, that they would have immediately set sail for there.

[@Kayciee130]

Dutch died at the bottom of a mountain, Arthur died at the top of one.

[@wolfy9549]

Emilycary thats what you call poetic justice.

[@BenDover-ch7rf]

So did micah

[@mysteryguyy9709]

Ben Dover but Micah died like a dog

[@skxlter5747]

Spoilers bro tf

[@bilalunal4927]

Well said

[@dieudonneouedraogo7206]

"And I suggest you to learn how to shoot people in the front, not the back" damnn

[@bentaro9743]

@internet drone Well he didn't learn to shoot fair and square, which is why he lost to Jack.

[@trentsolo1883]

Ross's old butt buddy Agent Milton showed us all how to shoot someone in the back

[@cableyoutuber]

He never did learn, and shot Marston right in the back...

[@josephscaduto9971]

Ross and Micah died because they couldn’t

[@yoman3690]

TRENT Solo Milton never shot anyone in the back, he actually waited for hosea and Arthur to turn and look at him before trying to kill them

[@justeyn]

That "Head home to see your family" gave me so much chills when I played this game and I was like "Wow, finally."

[@janderson6756]

That relief didn't last very long I guess. Seeing as how the game ends.

[@rustyscrewdrivr]

Justin Remalante the thing is as soon as I said that and I started riding to beecher’s hope a grizzly attacked me

[@Everik-ct6pg]

Yes, and the song *_Compass_* only builds up that moment by making you think that Marston will finally have a happy ending, especially at 18:09

[@joemahma1438]

@@Everik-ct6pg with red dead 2 it's super sad due to the fact the most gang members are dead, including the one who was your father, Dutch

[@Outpost31Research]

alternate ending: Just as Dutch fell backwards off the cliff he was saved mid air by a man in a glider. They flew off into the sunset while John watched with a single tear in his eye.

[@declankasch5388]

Kevin F and here I was thinking this game was flawless, wasted potential, rockstar....

[@federicobenitez5481]

Deadlus and Dutch.

[@thisguy4193]

Kevin F plot twist John shot the man flying the glider with a sniper and dutch fell to his death and John just walked away with a satisfied look on his face

[@CellJr.]

Or his name wasn't Charles Kinnear

[@Jason32Bourne]

Or spiderman, "Everybody gets one"

[@freebird264]

Dutch facing John in RDR: "There's always a choice. You're just too blind to see it." Dutch facing John in RDR2 after leaving him for dead: "I didn't have a choice." *Micah or no Micah, Dutch really did go insane*

[@joelwright3918]

@Severed me too I always thought Hosea was the voice of reason for Dutch I pla

[@josephscaduto9971]

Yeah I always thought Dutch was a traitor and selfish and Micah helped Dutch bring out his true colors than Dutch would have otherwise

[@CursedWheelieBin]

Maybe he’s just full of shit like most people in his position 😂

[@amir.music2005]

Nice detail.

[@paco680]

Especially after Hosea died, because I think he was the only person that kept him sane a bit

[@OhYouMusty]

He jumped cause he knew John was next on the list

[@julianvillafane2598]

Mc Johnson yep

[@noamias4897]

Yeah, I think that’s why he dropped his revolver too instead of just making them shoot each other

[@ArthurMuneh]

Exactly the more I rewatch RDR I realize how dumb John really is, that he cannot figure what would happen next. You just have to figure out how Dutch is warning him and the answers he gives

[@milktree4545]

@@ArthurMuneh he's not dumb. He knew they were coming for him eventually. It's why he instantly told jack to hide once he saw them in the distance. There was nothing he could do

[@milktree4545]

@@xanderlaskey2753 it's explained why he didn't do that. They would never stop hunting him until he was dead.

[@wolfy9549]

Hearing him say “I got a plan, John” seems hilarious in this situation after Rdr 2.

[@droffapybbob7651]

Its funny alright but I GOT A PLAN!

[@wolfy9549]

Still waiting on it Dutcheth

[@MickeyMouse-jg8ql]

Tasty burger have faith we just need some muneh

[@MickeyMouse-jg8ql]

And noise

[@BatailleRapTishort]

Tahiti

[@KumiesCummies]

I like to think that Fordham genuinely respects John after this mission, and that’s why he didn’t show up to his execution.

[@noamias4897]

I used to think so too, then he called Abigail a whore despite her not doing that for 16 years

[@BeatleHarrison]

He is at the execution

[@clxutz]

@@noamias4897 I feel like he got anger issues or something, cuz there was a deleted dialogue where someone said about Fordham that went something along the lines of “That agent was never the same after what happened to his mother at that massacre in BlackWater”

[@BeatleHarrison]

@Claytonislit 420 In the back, you need to look very closely

[@unclelumbago9745]

@@BeatleHarrison That wasn't him,it's a Isaac Mckinnon,a town marshal(or sheriff) that look alike him

[@IvanTorresBntz]

"We can't always fight nature. We can't fight change." Damn! It gives you an amazing experience from start to finish for a midia that is just a game. Red Dead Redemption is more than that.

[@dalaxdercrisper957]

@Mr. Somebody Screw off man

[@v-22osprey56]

Sure,but that does not mean that he said something wrong.

[@darkseid8120]

"Our time is passed,john....bUt wEE juSt NeeD mOney"-dutch

[@VTuber_Redgrave]

GODDAMNIT DUTCH WE SHOULD HAVE STAYED IN GUARMA!! wait, what?

[@MarcellPlazOn]

darkseid Mangos!

[@Danger_Noodle]

*Muneh

[@dennishuang7764]

Can anyone explain me the paradox Dutch said

[@dutchvanderlinde8053]

Yes!

[@ivikaputova3177]

So many people say, that the most iconic moment of the game is when you enter Mexico and "Far Away" starts playing. For me, the first moment, when I wanted to cry my eyes out was THIS, first - dialogue between John and Dutch and right after "Compass" started and I saw the A on map. I was riding that mtfckng horse the fastest way possible, feeding him with horse pills, just to see Abigail asap. Like, "Far Away" is bomb, but "Compass" melted my heart... and then "Deadman's gun" broke it into million pieces :D

[@EthanBradburyVlogs]

It seems like alot of pussies play red dead and always cry

[@django8875]

@@EthanBradburyVlogs gtfo you old bag of fleas

[@crono3015]

I love how Ross just calmly says he's only joking. Such a bastard, but I fucking love that arrogance. Also, his voice actornis great.

[@legendofstamfordbridge377]

Crono Ross is a pussy

[@2bdamned213]

I love myself.

[@rosaria8384]

He's like the law's Dutch. So arrogant, yet has a way with words.

[@boah1668]

This time Dutch really had a plan. He knew John will come sooner or later, he knows the mountain good, he knows where to bring John for their last meet. He just wanted to die talking one last time to his last son.

[@giraffeman326]

Before playing Red Dead 2: “Well he’s dead” After playing Red Dead 2: “I gave you all I had Dutch”

[@dutchvanderlinde8053]

You didn’t give me anything. You BETRAYED me.

[@SardonicJosh]

@@dutchvanderlinde8053 HAVE SOME GODDAMN FAITH, DUTCH.

[@Anonymous-yq6wy]

@@SardonicJosh he needs *TIME*

[@SardonicJosh]

@@Anonymous-yq6wy AND *MONEY*

[@lucassangalli6103]

@@dutchvanderlinde8053 you started

[@Professional_Ghost]

I only wish that it was possible to kill the corrupt agents to get a secret ending. As the ending in this game really comes at you at full force.

[@noamias4897]

moon how and how are they corrupt

[@yusufkadri4972]

Noamias search the meaning of corrupt kid, it means evil or morally depraved

[@noamias4897]

Yusuf Kadri yes, and doing their job isn’t evil

[@40kanon]

@@noamias4897 Yah brainlet.

[@noamias4897]

40kanon LOL XD SAVAGE DANK FUNNY NICE ROAST

[@ThatGuyKh1]

He was a fucking maniac but in the end he was the only ex friend that I felt kinda bad for in the end. he even foreshadowed what would happen to john

[@joshuawilliams8252]

Because he isn't a good man, he never was. He even says so himself, many times.

[@edwardhernandez6668]

+xXSilentAgent47Xx Jesus fuck dude. Thats the way R* wrote the story. Go write your own story you hack.

[@Bacxaber]

I feel bad for Bill, even though he's objectively a bad person. He got bullied a lot for literally no reason, and he wasn't wrong about the double standard of him failing and being reprimanded whereas Arthur could fail and it's "just one of those things".

[@justice_of_Youtube]

@@edwardhernandez6668 .

[@lefez9015]

@@Bacxaber Agreed.

[@arhickernell]

God I remember that painfully long horse ride...

[@Blastfluff]

I just rode ahead.

[@patstaysuckafreeboss8006]

arhickernell I'd always use trip skip

[@hock417]

Lol same

[@allenbrown7572]

The dialogue is interesting enough for me to stay on the ride

[@KaiZX]

Allen Brown same here

[@yusufkadri4972]

Dutch no longer has a plan

[@ilearnedhownottobejealous2301]

His plan was the jump, allways the jump

[@ablazedemon1149]

Yusuf Kadri He always had a plan

[@RafaelPereira-dc9ir]

Yusuf Kadri He had by going to take an detour to Tahiti through the heavens

[@jacksonbuchanan3643]

No this was the plan

[@therebellion96]

"...Then it is revealed that he had no plan!"

[@zionfernando2830]

We need a remasterd version of this game

[@gangstabraze2048]

Zion Fernando “We” speak for yourself you dork.....I love it just the way it is.....

[@maz4589]

Gangsta Braze My ps3 barely runs, and I don’t even think old gen games are even sold anymore at GameStop. It makes sense to make a remastered version.

[@toxicchild335]

@@maz4589 just yesterday i got gta iv at game stop

[@THEREALGAMEMASTER-gz5xg]

@@maz4589 but Gamestop still sells PS3 games

[@AVCI711]

İ want that on PS4

[@TheRabaxyka]

After 6 years this game is a true fckng masterpiece! Rockstar on top

[@haircut]

It was a masterpiece at day 1 not 6 years later.

[@Assassino275]

This comment was made before R* became the king of Microtransactions I see

[@facundoriesco1369]

7

[@FabLoveGA]

@@haircut What a dumbass comment.

[@Kira-ik8ld]

TheRabaxyka and now... 9 years... time fly.. man

[@johnhoma7145]

"Our time is past John" This quote gives me chills when I think of it in the context of GTA and RDR, its the same message, that you can't change who you are and you can't bury the past, because the law of society is a way to justify savagery.

[@harryshuman9637]

Man, don't bring GTA with its cardboard cut-out characters into this.

[@dionruffin3996]

U can say that about any GTA except lV

[@justadude9101]

@@harryshuman9637 whatever you say bub

[@fartass8299]

​@@harryshuman9637man, don't be an emotional retard

[@tblcyek]

As is with lawlessness. People will always find a way to excuse savagery.

[@kwproductions4455]

“We’ve got to stop meeting like this...” very clever rockstar...

[@xXSlyferDragenXx]

The last enemy that shall be destroyed :'(

[@gibbar3335]

One of my favorite missions in the game. Compass is a beautiful song.

[@moviemetalhead]

Hell yeah. Just don't get off your horse if you want to be able to hear it. I made that mistake the first time I played this. haha

[@gibbar3335]

***** Me too, but with Far Away. Good thing with Compass I didn't do that mistake

[@moviemetalhead]

+Gib Bar Unfortunately, I did it for both. When I first played this I had to loot every body and kill any animal I came across. As a result I missed out on both songs the first time around. I didn't make that mistake again when I played through my second time.

[@gibbar3335]

***** In my case, because of the "Spoiled to Victory" trophy. I was using the Kentucky Sadler at that time, and I thought that when I ride the horse Irish provided to us in that mission when we enter Mexico, the trophy progress will reset. What an idiot I was

[@moviemetalhead]

+Gib Bar Nah fortunately it doesn't count against you. Live and learn.

[@lheon8360]

"the truth is out here (GTA SA) - And the truth will set you free (RDR)"

[@chair7261]

Oh shit, I just broke down when I heard Dutch say “you can’t fight change? You can’t fight Gravity” because he said the same thing when he and Arthur were pinned in the cliff and jumped off into the river

[@albertinon1]

YES! EXACTLY!

[@noamias4897]

It’s funnier to think that he was so crazy that he thought there was water under him

[@PipoStanII]

He must have had that speech planned for a while (like he has done for his past speeches).

[@Charles-hy6gp]

_Then you will know the truth, _*_and the truth will set you free_* ~ John 8: 32

[@nfh0849]

Charles 8777 The last enemy that shall be destroyed is death Corinthians 15 : 26

[@zionfernando2830]

Yeet him ~ Zion 69: 9/11

[@felorpy]

I have a plan ~ Dutch 13 : 17

[@Dorkeydaze]

Felipe Gamerzinho Virgin Dutch “I got a plan.” Vs chad Jesus “I am the way the truth and life.”

[@talentoveranything2838]

+Charles 8777 love how atheists got butthurt over some bible verse and start mocking you , lmao

[@TrickyTalon23]

Dutch: *My whole life, all I ever did was fight.* John: *Then maybe fighting isn’t the answer. Maybe the only way to fix all this is with talking. Here, show everyone that you surrender and tell them why we did the things we did. Maybe the world will listen and realize how corrupted the government is and how much it needs to be stopped. Maybe we can get a happy ending where we all live in a world where life is finally fair-* Dutch: [Falls off cliff] John: *Oh well I tried. Hopefully Edgar Ross isn’t planning to kill me later out of bitter anger. Welp, time to get back to my family!*

[@alefsilvavieira8442]

Luke McNamara they would never listened to them, this is How America became the today contry, over a Lot of killing and corription. That time was really hard to live and prosper correct....

[@koolandblue]

In the end, Angleo Bronte was right when he told Dutch “you are nothing, you mean nothing, and when the law catch up to you, you will die like nothing.” Dutch spent his last days desperately trying to mean something, fighting against a world that didn’t need outlaws and gunslingers like him anymore. In the end, he threw away his gun and killed himself rather than let John shoot him. Dutch didn’t even go down fighting- he took the coward’s way out and died like nothing.

[@johnnyquantum8125]

No I don't think Bronte was right and I think you're being to broad. Dutch would probably be remembered throughout history rather infamously, one of the most famous terrorists of the late 19th and early 20th century, someone responsible for the deaths of major American figures and stealing millions along with his gang also as for his death, both are suicide, suicide by jumping off a cliff rather than suicide by letting John shoot him with his gun is still also suicide, so then both would be equally cowardly ~ which I wouldn't say that either because he had no option but to either be taken in by the government and hanged, or kill himself right then, which obviously is the better option

[@wetube6513]

He's a tasty greasy spaghetti for the gators.

[@a_loyal_kiwi88]

Horrible take. He didn't fall off the cliff because he was scared, he did it because he realized the pointlessness in fighting on. There is no scenario where he lives once he meets John at the top of that maintain. Bronte wasn't right either, because in context he went on to to compare what he had to what Dutch had. He "ran a city" and Dutch only had his followers, yet those followers were loyal to Dutch for the man he was. Dutch did infact possess things someone like Bronte could never comprehend, and he still had those things at the end, only fighting for those things was now fruitless due to the amount of change brought about by societal advancement.

[@koolandblue]

@@a_loyal_kiwi88 Dutch didn't possess his followers. They started leaving him once it became clear that Dutch was only interested in his own selfish reasons for fighting. Anyone that ever put any faith in Dutch ended up suffering because of it. Also, Dutch didn't possess anything by this point. During the encounter with Dutch at the hotel, Dutch claims he and his men are "fighting for an idea, not just for ourselves." But if you let John and Dutch dialogue during the sequence when Dutch is shooting at John with the gatling gun, John questions Dutch about what he's fighting for and what he's accomplished. Dutch only gives vague responses like "you'd never understand" and "you'll never know." It was obvious Dutch was only fighting because it was all he knew how to do. He meant nothing, stood for nothing and the law finally caught up to him.

[@lonestarbuckeye6889]

You're right, Bronte was right, and Dutch was right there in the end telling John he couldn't erase the past and killing him wouldn't change anything. They still gunned John down like a rabid dog after using him.

[@robin961000]

I have a plan john, You always have a plan dutch!! Have some god damn faith john... this is a good one

[@borys0917]

Just one last train

[@javierescuella1389]

As long it isn't Guarma!

[@MrMdub34]

i swear to you when Compass kicks in.. i get goosebumps everytime!!

[@ebbtide4233]

The mission objective take out dutchs gang hit me

[@thegothicmetalhead2877]

“I got a P L A N John” “You always got a plan Dutch” Dutch Van Der Linde. Planning since 1899

[@limdennis813]

After playing rdr 2, now i know why John said:"you always got a plan,Dutch"

[@oliverpony]

Dutch in RDR 2: I didn't have a choice Dutch in RDR 1: There's always a choice!

[@Monoloquitoa]

"The day Dutch van der Linde stopped having a plan"

[@ottomanfritz3041]

"When I'm gone they'll just find another monster" Dutch knew that the next monster from Ross' perspective is John

[@Yorker1998]

RDR 2 really gives so much more perspective and to this mission especially. I can actually listen to the dialogue while knowing and thinking about the events of RDR 2 that unfolded. Amazing.

[@louieandtommysdiscountedit3177]

17:30 After the opening of RDR2, the wolves chasing Marston here, combined with the music, makes this VERY fitting. It almost looks like a stoic, cheesy scene from an action movie. (I know it’s just a coincidence, but that’s the power of an Open World Rockstar Story. Amazing stuff can just happen like that.)

[@Overquoted]

I came here to see Dutch die after the terrible things he caused in RDR2.

[@AS-rf6rw]

Yeah dutch killed him self which is suiside

[@Jessica-kh1qg]

Me too. I'm glad Dutch is dead. This is for ARTHUR!!!

[@EthanBradburyVlogs]

@@Jessica-kh1qg Arthur didnt want Dutch to die

[@Jessica-kh1qg]

@@EthanBradburyVlogs Maybe but Dutch betrayed Arthur and he got what he deserved.

[@Jessica-kh1qg]

@Paige I hate both Micah and Dutch. Dutch is not better than Micah.

[@walkmanboi465]

Dutch being held at gunpoint by the cliff must have reminded him a lot of Arthur so much

[@user-VeryStrange]

All the gang members slowly tragically dying as time goes on in the game gives so much emotions At arthur's death you got sad at dutch's death you felt dread at micah's death you didn't feel neither of those...

[@Strangeminds38]

Micah's death wasn't even satisfying, i literally didn't feel anything. John getting to live in peace for a few years felt quite rewarding though.

[@SxVaNm345]

“You can’t erase the past, John, Killin’ me, It won’t make it go away.” “That’s where you’re wrong!” “You’re just like me, John. You can’t change who you are.” “I ain’t like you!” “When I’m gone, they’ll just find another monster. They have to, to justify their wages.” “That’s their business...” “Our time has passed... John.”

[@Zz0Z79]

Nothing nice

[@randommetalhead7]

Best. Fuckin'. Game. EVER. Period.

[@captainpoontah4888]

Does rdr2 change your perspective?

[@yaswantha.1468]

@@captainpoontah4888 rdr1 second best.. best is rdr2

[@armandodias3532]

@@captainpoontah4888 this ending still more impactful for me.

[@jsoqbwbeks2653]

@@captainpoontah4888 didn't change my perspective.

[@thenukeanims]

@@armandodias3532 rdr2 was emotional and less impactful

[@Pablo-V]

14:52 Dutch wasn’t wrong at all, after him, John was the one the federals were after to justify their wages.

[@fajarardiansyah8591]

Who's here after playing RDR 2?

[@UGLYBOYwrld]

I was here before rdr2 I just came to see this cuz I don’t feel like putting my rdr1 disc in my Xbox atm

[@WanderSeth]

This game was hard as hell but fun without autoaim. But Red Dead 2, it's damn near impossible without autoaim.

[@prashanthraghavendran2628]

The curse us console players must bear

[@sulista4855]

Yeah

[@joelramdhan405]

Myraseth idk but never used auto aim in rdr2 and it was passable

[@sharp7079]

I really can't see why they didn't release RDR1 on PC, it would give the pc players like me, a chance to experience this game.

[@adamcadag8210]

rdr2 was easy without auto aim as long you have dead eye

[@cosmicspacebub5978]

The “our time has passed” quote gave me chills when Dutch first said it. But now with RDR 2, that line was still in effect even at the gang’s high point. It all just went downhill

[@masterm537]

14:55 this is a warning from Dutch that they might get John as well after this. And Arthur used to say they aint the forgetting sort when he was captured by Colm and spoke about the hand Dutch's gang to the Pinkertons.

[@deathrager2404]

one thing we ve learned from all of this, the us government hasnt changed and never will change.

[@the_boi1175]

Napoleon Bonaparte 2true4me

[@noamias4897]

Fucking edgy son of a bitch, using a video game as historical fact against the government

[@gussmann6580]

@@noamias4897 You're very naïve friend...

[@noamias4897]

Guzzman 65 how is it naive to thing using a fictional story to judge real life is dumb?

[@gussmann6580]

@@noamias4897 I'm talking about the government itself, do you really think our dear uncle sam is honest and that there is no corruption?

[@D0C391]

I love that line from John when he’s talking to that army soldier. “take it from me mister. When we get up to there it aint gonna matter. It’ll be every man for himself.” 😂

[@ericcastro1309]

when I'm gone they gonna find another monster

[@gibbar3335]

They have to, because they need to justify their wages.

[@ericcastro1309]

that's their business

[@ericcastro1309]

so at the end you didn't had guts to shoot him?

[@gibbar3335]

The man is dead, Ross.

[@ericcastro1309]

Sure. can i see your gun?

[@КириллФёдоров-г5ц]

Finally. I was waitin' continuing of the walkthrough for the week

[@Youtuber10121]

ikr

[@КириллФёдоров-г5ц]

+TOO HOT 4 YOU what does it mean

[@YazidBens18]

+Кирилл Фёдоров it means : i know right. that means he agrees with what you say.

[@КириллФёдоров-г5ц]

+Yazid Bensafir thanks. Now I understand

[@YazidBens18]

+Кирилл Фёдоров no problem.

[@rogue7100]

"When I'm gone, they'll just find another monster. They have to, because they have to justify their wages." -Dutch ('Wages' here refers to Romans 6:23, "The wages of sin is death," which shows Dutch is far more intelligent and knowledgeable than he lets on, but decides to let the interpreter find out what he truly means, like a twisted puzzle.) --- The Irony of this line is how the true meaning of it went over John's head in the heat of the moment. It was both a warning to John and a philosophical statement relating to a biblical verse about the consequences of sin. - From Dutch's mind, he was saying two things: "You don't get it. They're going to come after you too." + "They will not be stopped, as they are trying to justify their own existence as well as their own bad deeds by hunting down those they consider worse than them, hoping to prove that they are good people for putting down 'bad' men." - But, from John's mind, he was hearing two different things entirely: "They're just gonna go after some other bad guy after I'm dead." + "They won't stop because they need a reason for having their wages." ^ John construes 'wages' as in literal pay; money. For John, Dutch is the last obstacle between him and his family. He isn't overthinking it the way Dutch is. For Dutch, these are his final moments, he knows he is about to be dead, so he tries to teach John one last lesson. --- When John said "That's their business," John was thinking "Why the hell does that matter? How is that relevant? I don't care what they do, I'm here for my family." - And when Dutch said "Our time has passed," he was thinking "My poor boy does not understand the gravity of the situation, nor does he understand what I have tried to allude to. If he can't see that, there is no point in stating it in a more obvious manner. His mind is made up. There is no hope for either of us." ----- The dialogue in this game is incredible.

[@shaggysnax01]

"Nice revolver, John. Been a while since I used one of those. What happened to your other one?" "It's packed away on my horse's saddle, Dutch."

[@rico-dasico5394]

Hands down. Probably the best game I have EVER played. An absolute masterpiece.

[@Tahiti_mangos]

I disagree

[@Basan614]

@@Tahiti_mangos John: what do you mean Arthur? My game is amazing!

[@Tahiti_mangos]

@@Basan614 5 words: red dead redemption 2 + Tahiti

[@therebellion96]

I played this mission with the Legend of the West outfit and the LeMat revolver. Makes me feel like 10 times the badass!

[@happy5642642]

It'd be funny if there will ever be a RDR 3 where we actually get to Tahiti

[@RiBA__]

honestly even if RDR3 ever happens, only way i see it work out storywise is have Dutch as the main protagonist during the ”good old days” of the gang where you’re being like a REAL outlaw doing real messed up and twisted stuff that’s only about survival. and right after the story ends they should have young Arthur Morgan as the playable character making up his name.

[@RafaelPereira-dc9ir]

happy5642642 RDR 1 México ( canon like this 1 ) RDR 2 Guarma RDR 3 Tahiti Fair enough

[@pedinhuh16]

If RDR3 ever happens then I want it to be about Sadie hunting her bounties in Sout America, and Charles joining a tribe in Canada and fighting the oppression of the Canadian government.

[@Hecx000]

11:20 YOU MARRIED!!! 😂😂😂

[@hock417]

John honestly think it was over? After robbing banks n trains for over 10 years thats some serious crime right their n back in that time people were hung more.

[@hock417]

Yeah, it was dutch really in 1899 he Couldn't break the law as easy as in lets say year 1890 or 1899 at the final mission with sadie arthur believed it was all just a lie an excuse what dutch said to them living "free" he just lied to get them to break the law with him to get them to believe in something that was never their.

[@hock417]

Shit i meant to say 1889 lol.

[@hock417]

But nonetheless john and arthur are really great characters i like em both the same both bad assess both people you do not wanna mess with lol.

[@princesaha36]

17:00 the song. Goosebumps, I finished the game yesterday and kinda felt relieved even though short lived that John will finally meet his family😢

[@cableyoutuber]

“I hAVe a PlaN” *Dutch Van-Der-Linde took the easy way out* Me: damn tryhard...

[@Angry_Peanut_52]

Got to preserve that KD no matter what the cost

[@SICPARVISMAGNA3018]

How did Dutch and Javier go from dressing respectable to people who look like they found their clothes in the nearest discount store

[@rahulverma8774]

They were at their prime in rdr2 But in rdr1 everything is falling apart

[@sakuraaaa101]

That army Captain was pretty badass in this mission he didn't even flinch when the explosives went off to break the gate and he seemed like a pretty good leader. I hate how he not only led the assault on the Marston ranch he seemed to have respect for Marston

[@Kacpa2]

Yeah, he and Archer didnt take part in hunting down John.

[@osbaldohernandez9174]

Dutch was pretty much warning John saying when Dutch dies there gonna kill John because there’s no one else to kill

[@peridot12782]

15:33 If you look close enough, you can see that in the left side of Dutch's face is gone. You can see it clearly in a Reddit post called: "You can't see it properly but Dutch in RDR1 after he falls:". It's really disturbing and sad.

[@JR7noir]

Dutch has his own philosophy. In RDR2 and RDR

[@blessedxxiii5583]

Ross had a plan, even if John died he would have sent the Army after Bill, Javier, and Dutch anyways. That's why Ross kills John cause he was the Last member of Dutch's gang and he took the credit of taking down all 4 of them which is not true but of course they believe him and i hate to say it but Ross is right you can't just erase the past and pretend it never happend, John lived that Outlaw life and he has to pay for it. But in my opinion John earned his Freedom when he did everything what Ross told him to do. But ross had other ideas.

[@MyJanvic]

And you will learn how hypocrite Ross is.

[@-v2175]

He should have gone to tahiti

[@SpandexMovie1]

We nEed MoRE MoNeY.

[@Sillytommysadventure]

عپدالمجيد - V man of corse someone with that profile pics fuck you

[@Sillytommysadventure]

fعپدالمجيد - V dumb fick

[@player70477]

@@Sillytommysadventure calm down yankee

[@elsadabbasov8187]

As his true gang is no longer with him, moving to Tahiti is just meaningless for him. He knew money is not everything. What about his new gang in RDR? They were just greedy, anti-law, and last remaining outlaws who were riding with Dutch because they carried same goal.

[@flakyy_ow]

I honestly think john didnt wanna kill dutch.

[@yang6642]

He didn’t, he even said to Ross and Fordham that he’d kill them 100 times before he killed Dutch but they had Abigail and Jack so he had no choice.

[@mechalapod5901]

I think he did want to in RDR2, but when Dutch shot Micah, he gained some respect for realizing what Dutch did to the gang and himself

[@professionalgamer6522]

@@mechalapod5901 Yeah, he writes in (Used to be Arthurs) his Journal that he saw Dutch and wanted to kill him but didn't

[@gamingandrewbro8815]

@@mechalapod5901 which makes no sense and is just a other plot hole.

[@chriswilliams4700]

@@gamingandrewbro8815it isn’t a plot hole, it genuinely makes a lot of sense. John hated him and wanted him dead after Dutch left him behind at the train robbery. But after Dutch killed Micah and let John have the Blackwater money, John somewhat forgave Dutch, but still hated him a bit. When he has to track him down, he doesn’t want to because it was his former father, even if he still hates him a bit, but he knows he has to for his family. Pretty self explanatory. No plot hole

[@s4127419]

His words r sooooo deep after the release of RDR2.... so deep

[@legendofstamfordbridge377]

Oblitz Katoki deadass

[@sonrouge]

Gonna be interesting seeing what Dutch is like in the upcoming prequel.

[@lks7842]

Well, you can see now.

[@kennethshiro9500]

He's exactly like this.

[@CNR666]

Kenneth Shiro not exactly. We see him sane and rational during the first few chapters. Upon Hosea’s death Micah starts to become his advisor. It’s because of Micah advising him that the gang fell apart and Dutch went mad.

[@kennethshiro9500]

They certainly make it seem that way, also, SPOILERS.

[@imaleenab6694]

His different in rdr2

[@mouhamadfouadeid5688]

“Our time has passed John” 😢

[@bartabouttocry2471]

Watching this makes me feel im the bad guy.

[@azazel166]

You ARE the bad guy.

[@Jessica-kh1qg]

Screw you Micah.

[@danielbold6167]

"HE'S LYYYYYYIIINNG!"

[@breadlover302]

Technically you're not a bad guy, just a man trying to get your family back.

[@chriswilliams4700]

@@azazel166not here. John was a bad man, but he’s not the bad man in this game. He’s doing the right thing and protecting his family

[@giraffeman326]

I really liked Dutch at the beginning of the second game and it really upsets me that he went crazy and ended up like this.

[@KrissyGabagool]

Giraffe Man mee2

[@OG-jc2vl]

"And the truth will set you free", all words Dutch said to John is nothing but a true, he tried to open his eyes, to set him free, but at the end when he got himself killed solved his problems, same as Dutch, he understood it right before his death even if he was crazy old man he still knew the truth and tried, tried to open the eyes of his last son - John Marston.

[@Jfr4nk1]

My childhood died with john and watching this made me relive it

[@twizztedfps]

"You can't erase the past john, killin' me, it won't make it go away" Dutch was right

[@viciniscaletta9861]

When the army breached in Dutch’s camp it reminded me of the ending of rd2 when the Pinkertons came rushing in the camp when Arthur and John ran in the caves

[@_angel04]

Dutch- *Stands behind a shielded turret ready to shoot at john* John- runs for cover behind a wooden crate

[@jocatorejenerico]

For some it might be a liberating opportunity for revenge; for me it is the darkest and saddest mission of the entire saga.

[@speedking7224]

This mission is the climax of the red dead series.

[@blueberrylive6277]

Dutch doesn’t go to heaven or hell when he dies he goes to tahiti instead

[@kingofsciencefiction3808]

I'm probably stating the obvious here, but after playing RDR2, seeing Dutch and his new gang causing problems i.e. murdering and threatening innocents, robbing banks, capturing folk and executing them, basically just shitting all over Nate Johns, Ross and Fordham and the entire Government because they hated the civilised world, just shows how he never learnt anything from the events of RDR2. He lost his first lover (Annabelle, who got killed by Colm) because of a murder he committed (he killed Colm's brother), which started a long-term feud with the O'Driscolls (where it would inadvertently cost the life of Kieran and, before that, Arthur's brief capture and torture), he got completely brainwashed by Micah, a man who was there right from the beginning to break Dutch and the entire gang apart (even though it's not confirmed, it's heavily speculated by the game and quite a few fans, myself included), which led to him going along with Micah's plan to rob a ferry in Blackwater where 3 members were killed (Jenny, Davey and Mac - although that could easily have been a lie on Milton's part) and 1 was captured (Sean - who gets rescued anyway). He then leaves a trail of mass destruction from that point on: robbing a train and creating an enemy in Cornwall, sending Arthur to break Micah out of Strawberry Jailhouse where the entire town would end up slaughtered, rather than going himself, effectively wiping out two rich and powerful families because him and Micah decided to play both sides for money, walks into an obvious trap set up by Bronte for more money, murdering Bronte, and then undertakes a bank heist - directly after murdering Bronte and destroying his security - where his best friend and the youngest gunmen (Hosea and Lenny) were killed and watched as John was arrested and sent to prison. Upon returning from Guarma, he murders the richest man in the state and then uses the Native Americans' hatred of the the government to his advantage, where Eagle Flies and hundreds of Wapitis are killed during the Oil Factory raid, which was suggested by Dutch. He leaves Abigail to be tried for murder until Arthur and Sadie rescue her, while all around him, people are doubting him, until only a few remain in his gang, and right at the end, he sides against Arthur and John, the two sons he brought up, in favour of Micah. He watches Arthur die and then disappears. Years later, the only decent thing he actually did was shoot Micah, even though John finished him off. 4 years later (RDR1), he's leading a new gang full of Native Americans, despite the fact he used a similar tribe 12 years previous to get what he wanted, and even though he caused sooooo many deaths - good and bad guys - spanning about 30 years (Annabelle, Heidi McCourt, Jenny, Davey, Mac, Sean, the Braithwaite and Gray Families, Kieran, Bronte, Hosea, Lenny, Levi Simon and Alberto Fussar, Molly, Cornwall, Eagle Flies, countless Native Americans, Arthur, Susan, Micah, Muriel Scranton, Nastas) - he still continues to rebel against civilisation and doesn't give a shit who he hurts - even if it's his own sons - and what the consequences will be afterward. I get he didn't directly cause everything and he wasn't alone in his actions, but the fact he still carried on after everything that happened is incredibly sad after seeing the events of RDR2 and RDR1. Nevertheless, I really like Dutch as a character, and all of the above pretty much is down to his personality and beliefs, even if it meant sacrificing himself to hold onto them.

[@tracyrae4854]

Yea very very Tragic Character 😭😭😭

[@kingofsciencefiction3808]

@@tracyrae4854 Definitely 👍

[@tracyrae4854]

@@kingofsciencefiction3808 mhm

[@abtestbctest]

"And I suggest you shoot people from the front, not the back." *Ross really took John's advice WAY too seriously.*

[@squidparty2000]

when will gta get a storyline like red dead redemption and max payne. come on rockstar.

[@TimpanKanava]

Too bad original Max Payne wasn't made by Rockstar

[@solidus2916]

in my opinion GTA V Has the greatest story of all rockstar gamez

[@squidparty2000]

+KiiNG 561 gta 4s storyline confused me.

[@squidparty2000]

+KiiNG 561 it was too long and had repetitive missions. I like gta 4 but how was the Italian mob boss, a character you meet around the end, the main antagonist? I thought dimitri was. what happened to karen? it had a lot of missions that were worthless. gta 5 was an improvement and so was red dead redemption.

[@mcmadskillz4897]

They already did, it's called GTA IV

[@Capex567]

Dutch not only became an ol Driscoll but he even ended up looking like one

[@thewwebeastatgamesnetwork]

I don’t think that was part of ...THE PLAN

[@SpandexMovie1]

*TAHITI*

[@killionare72ify]

I know it's late but why does Dutch switch weapons in this playthrough, for every other video of this scene he's carrying a Borchardt

[@blessedxxiii5583]

it's either Dutch has a few pistols or it's just a glitch

[@beardfam3485]

I cannot believe the man who mentored John predicted his death.

[@bitkohit9941]

"we got to stop meeting like this John" on top of a snowy mountain, like RDR2

[@peytocool8201]

Dutch: Ah shit there isn’t water here this time.

[@YoungYuri19]

"Our Time has passed, John." He finally listened to Arthur and Hosea.

[@hiimakememes]

imagine it was milton instead of dutch and his last words were “goodbye.. rip van winkle..”

[@nickcrazygamer9130]

"Our time has passed John...."

[@redrxses6998]

It’s only been 8 years now, and the art is still hanging on the wall.

[@matos7050]

My horse was attacked by a trio of bears just when the music was playing, just when I wanted to enjoy the poetic moment...

[@noamias4897]

I honestly loved Dutch, my favorite character in the game tbh

[@legendofstamfordbridge377]

Noamias agreed

[@django8875]

Seth or landon ricketts is my favorite