RED (TV) IS FINALLY HERE

[@stfuolive]

the unhealthy obsession i’ve with a 10 minute song is unexplainable

[@eugenieng06]

Trust, I know it all too well.

[@ana_lynn_w2959]

The Moment I Knew about All Too Well (10 minutes) was Treacherous because Im a Girl At Home wishing for a Better Man but my life is Sad Beautiful Tragic.

[@alech8892]

Omg i love your saiki icon

[@itsjustmatty]

No for real oil this comment ain’t the most realest shit its crazy in just a week of the red release how many times I’ve listened to all too well 10 minute version

[@Ian1989-u8v]

Same . .... Blondie really did that

[@jmxntz]

underrated lyric NO ONE talks ab: “i’m a soldier who’s returning half her weight”

[@rynw.3867]

This one fucks 👏 me 👏 up 👏

[@purvigoswami_]

oh yeah traumatised me

[@EricaPapad]

I know right... it pierced my heart when I heard it.. especially knowing what happened afterwards in her 1989 era and her struggles with her weight... 😥

[@thecobe-lee9674]

Facts the IMAGERY

[@rynw.3867]

@@thecobe-lee9674 RIGHT. especially because it can be taken in so many different ways?? the loss of weight from a traumatic relationship and dwindling mental health, but also losing the weight OF that relationship/the other person - GENIUS

[@nastyasmnv1356]

Yes!! "I remember it all too well" being repeated over and over hits different after the fighting scene cause it makes you realize that she was constantly gaslighted into thinking that nothing happened and it's all in her head so she's basically trying to convince Herself that it was real she was there and she remembers it All Too Well

[@sxchsj2565]

oh my god

[@Adrianaxo.]

Wowww🥺

[@corneliastreets]

It hits even harder when you realise that people have dismissed her experiences being manipulated and targeted by older men and called her a crazy ex-girlfriend. When the rerecordings came out, people dismissed her reflection on what she went through again saying her ex “doesn’t even remember her”.

[@ermyr7743]

It's not gaslighting... he didn't even remember the moment she was talking about, he never said it didn't happen.

[@miyua4169]

@@Adrianaxo. m

[@holysickdivinenights]

fun fact: the book taylor published "all too well" at the end is actually the same cover as a book called the giving tree, which is about a tree giving everything she has to this boy and him giving nothing to her in return

[@missmaggicasares6538]

sounds interesting, it kinda FITS the idea from the film, but I also heard some comparisons to Alice's Adventures in Wonderland and other stories' book cover.

[@BuilderBobda]

@@missmaggicasares6538 yeah but look up the cover of the Giving Tree. It is the exact same cover but in blue instead of green

[@theluckycat2705]

It's not the same cover lmao but they do share similarities, mainly the style. Saying that it has the exact same cover is a long stretch tho

[@kikyaaakun]

All the Easter eggssssss

[@2000seoulsonyosound]

The more you listen to ATW 10 minutes, the shorter it gets. Her songwriting literally enchants you

[@yozume8859]

True, I'd be like "oh it's over?"

[@osen9881]

Ikr, I could listen to it 6 times in a row and wouldn't feel like a whole hour...

[@brookemckinley5709]

So true!! Never thought my adhd self could listen, much less like a 10 min song but then again it’s Taylor! So doesn’t surprise me

[@arisjournal365]

@@yozume8859 same lmao

[@lpycb42]

Honestly when I saw 10 minute version I was like uhhhh…no. Not gonna listen to this. Then I did and now I absolutely cannot listen to the short version.

[@lidiar9471]

I remember when you first reacted to Red a couple of years ago and when it came to All too well you were like “ugh songs that are this long I’m like why🙄” but when it ended you said that it didn’t feel like it was that long, I think the magic of Taylor’s writing style is that she can skilfully narrate to you so that you can’t feel the length of the song cause you get lost in the story, not everyone can pull off long songs because you need to have GREAT lyrics, something that these days is quite rare in mainstream music

[@puffzerap8648]

2 years to be more exact, but i remember that part of the video

[@DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose]

I've *never* felt the length of ATW, because as a writer myself, I always felt so invited to picture the story playing in my head like a short film, telling a relationship from prologue to epilogue, so I was legitimately surprised to learn later that it was 5 minutes long. 🥰🧧

[@liviasilverthorne7684]

I was about to say the same thing honestly

[@ccamilacedeno]

no bcs atw 10 min version feels like at most 5 minutes

[@andrewjones9603]

this is PERFECT timing because I literally just sat down with my lunch. ily tysm

[@momo2205]

same lol i just sat down with my dinner and opened youtube and found the video 😂

[@renatacerekaite2331]

Good for you I have to prepiere assigment for my lecture but when I sow notification I just dropt everything 😂😅

[@gavinmoy5191]

Sameeee

[@DandYEAHH]

Perfect is the enemy of good.

[@kaiomelo4124]

wait so are we all eating lunch rn?

[@hi.maxinne]

she made 22 tracks in red when she was 22 and now that she's 31, she literally made 31 tracks, including her message

[@justthenamekevin]

PMG

[@surerizz]

TTPD 31 TRACKS.

[@xkami0911]

@@surerizzdude. chill. she’s 34 at the time she released ttpd

[@idktbhlol9884]

The fact Taylor had someone called Jake play older Jake at the end….. she’s evil and I LOVE IT

[@JessicaGonzalez-xk1dz]

And he's Jake Lyon... like Jake lying 👀

[@idktbhlol9884]

@@JessicaGonzalez-xk1dz OH MY GOD

[@allaboutmika]

@@JessicaGonzalez-xk1dz "shes fucked in the head" is actually about taylor bcs girlie pLS STOP HURTING US

[@envyswift]

I don't get this. Can someone explain?

[@Nystraeline]

"i'll get older but your lovers stay my age" jake: 40 his current gf: 25 drag them miss swift

[@ansiesbakesandcooks7969]

Yesss! Lol

[@MEDSZ13.08]

WAIT OMGGG

[@nathanieldusini6085]

Add something for each re-recording like you're collecting infinity stones Fearless - Cowboy Hat Red- Scarf

[@bandrade7302]

Big ass purple dress from speak now (TV)

[@3amidnights]

seagull tshirt or seagulls from 1989 and snake or papernews from reputation

[@neilwritesstuff]

@@3amidnights ashley better kidnap a seagull before 1989 tv and it should be perched on her shoulder the whole time

[@clementinevonodd]

@@bandrade7302 HELP THIS MADE ME CACKLE

[@vecnussyy]

I could listen to an hour of you defending The Last Time. It's such a great song and it constantly gets paid dust. The Last Time walked so that Exile could run.

[@C-Iris]

Yeeees! It's a great song

[@shireenqasimm]

ONE OF THE BEST SONGS ON RED, STOLEN AND TV

[@tylerle3265]

I honestly didn’t get the song when it was first out but now with the rerecorded version, I can finally understand the appeal. After listening to the two side by side, I think I know why there’s such a difference. Taylor has really learned how to duet with people over the years. In the original it sounded (imo) like they were trying to sing over each other which created a kind of unpleasant whiny sound, but this time they really support each other and it’s so much better.

[@C-Iris]

@@tylerle3265 cool observation. I haven't listened to the 2012 version recently but I get the whiney sound that you're referring to... And I also think the new version is better because of Taylor's (and Gary's) improved vocals hehe

[@maddymp4]

The Last Time is EVERYTHING

[@Ikramabukar]

The way Taylor goes from “Will you still want me when I'm nothin' new?” in Nothing New to “Loves me like I'm brand new” in CIWYW is SO beautiful

[@BuilderBobda]

I didn’t catch that connection. Omg I love it.

[@angles4307]

@@BuilderBobda SAME. gosh i love ciwyw

[@klaralouth5801]

OMG

[@wgrodrig5651]

Her lyrics are so layered!!!!! It’s gonna take years to decipher everything she’s included in all her songs.

[@altamashg77]

Can I just say: Ashley's ability to actively listen to an album and its lyrics and process it in real-time with / for us is truly unparalleled + underrated.

[@LuLu-st8bk]

One of the best things about this channel and her as a content creator. She pays so much attention. Even with stuff she doesn't have a background in

[@fridarios101]

Okay, when she says "The only real thing you've ever known" they're showing a very familiar kiss, the spiderman kiss. Jake Gyllenhaal dated Kristen Dunst who we all know played Mary Jane. There's an old interview of Jake saying that he'd only fallen in love once, he was talking about Kristen. I think young Taylor was referring to herself when she said that, but now, old Taylor looks back at it and knows it wasn't her, so maybe it could be a nod to that, or maybe I'm just overthinking it. But also, in the spiderman movies, Mary Jane is the one who initiates the kiss with first Peter, and then another love interest as if trying to have the same magic, the same spark but after it happens, she realizes it's not the same.

[@angelthbk5932]

I just wasted my time typing this same explanation 😭

[@ferni0307]

i love how in this fandom im not the only overthinker

[@heyyitstrishh]

This is beautiful oh my god, idc if ur over thinking this is an amazing explanation.

[@nidhi9652]

Thia actually makes a lot of sense

[@yvetterodriguez2550]

Plus, let's add to the fact that Kirsten was also 20 when they first dated = "I'll get older but your lovers stay my age". Which was also around the same age he began to date his current girlfriend of 3 years who's now 25. Dude gives me icky vibes. He's 40 and still going for the younger girls. Ew. This kinda reminds me of the old man marrying the young girl in her mv "The Man" and he's all high-fiving people like he scored big time until she realizes that ain't what she wants.

[@goldenonsense]

Jake's picture in the back and Ash dragging him throughout the whole video had me dying lmfao

[@tyreek.6815]

Yea I started laughing a little but after he said hes having major mental health issues it became less funny for me. Idk

[@thetruth830]

@@tyreek.6815 when did he say that?

[@tyreek.6815]

@@thetruth830 Instagram and also (I forgot the word but when you do something secretive) on his pets Instagram. Look it up. That’s why a bunch of swifties are standing against the toxic swifties making it about him and bring up old drama. When it’s supposed to be about “music”

[@edensylvester13]

@@tyreek.6815 even apart from that, we shouldn't be making the rerecordings about her exes anyway

[@tyreek.6815]

@@edensylvester13 I don’t listen to her but I do know her music career probably wouldn’t be a thing if it wasn’t for her ex’s no? When I hear her music/talk about it all I hear is it about a man being a bad guy. Or sum. I’m sure she’s musically creative outside of that but that’s all I know. Is her being a good girl and everyone are horrible people.😭😭😭😭

[@kay2624]

timestamps 1) 2:31 State Of Grace 2) 3:21 Red 3) 4:41 Treacherous 4) 5:27 I knew you were trouble 5) 6:54 All too well 6) 7:24 22 7) 7:48 I almost do 8) 7:56 we are never Getting back together 9) 9:04 Stay Stay Stay 10) 10:00 the last time 11) 12:00 holy ground 12) 12:18 sad beautiful tragic 13) 12:44 the lucky one 14) 13:03 everything has changed 15) 13:35 starlight 16) 14:00 begin again 17) 14:39 the moment I knew 18) 15:12 Come back....be here 19) 15:26 Girl at home 20) state of grace (acoustic) skiped 21) 16:52 Ronan 22) 17:32 better man 23) 18:55 nothing new 24) 20:50 babe 25) 21:11 message in a bottle 26) 22:02 I bet you think about me 27) 23:01 forever winter 28) 23:35 run 29) 24:50 the very first night 30) 26:14 all too well {10m} 31) 30:49 message from Taylor 32) 31:12 All too well short film 33) 37:13 ranking

[@puffzerap8648]

hey, all too well is track 5

[@aizerquelvinbacerdo5927]

i love how ure editing this while watching

[@puffzerap8648]

@@aizerquelvinbacerdo5927 lol

[@kay2624]

@@aizerquelvinbacerdo5927 Lolll

[@Fucorii]

Thanks! I was fighting with some old grandpas who were really misogynistic and disrespecting Taylor Swift(the video I'm coming from is awful 😩 the amount of disrespect in one video is just....... The comment section is full of dumb heads ). I really needed this.

[@joellem625]

“The last time” walked so “exile” can run! Finally that song is getting the recognition it deserves! But “forever winter” also hits differently it’s so beautiful.

[@cmcm4204]

Last time has always been my fave on Red…. So slept on!

[@nogarubinshtein6180]

The actress she’s mentioning is assumed to be Anne Hathaway, the relationship and the global premieres of love and other drugs seem pretty much in sync and Anne mentioned meeting Taylor when she was younger and being very impressed by her

[@biennereese2849]

Isn't it Jennifer Aniston?

[@mmkayy31]

Ya i thot it was jen

[@BuilderBobda]

@@biennereese2849 Jennifer commented and said it wasn’t her

[@caitlynluciano]

"did the twin flame bruise paint you blue" is such a good lyric omg Jake and her are both fire signs, twin flames mean basically your soulmate, and they both have blue eyes. Like how did she fit so many things in one line?!?

[@gazelleluna8191]

Genius

[@giovannarodrigues2647]

“Just twin fire signs four blue eyes”

[@sorakun1021]

Twin flames dont mean that in astrology it actually means someone who is Gemini not Sag but ok... if that sails ur boat lol

[@muskaan3711]

I thought jake has green eyes!?

[@cmalol]

@@sorakun1021 no it doesn't lol

[@unappealingairbender]

Ashley: RED TV IS FINALLY HERE Also Ashley: **is 10 days late**

[@bandrade7302]

(10 day late version)

[@DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose]

Sadie: "You dropped my f***ing hand!" *Meanwhile, in 1989's "I Know Places":* "Just grab my hand & don't ever drop it, my love." 😅🦊

[@Nush543]

I dropped your hand while dancing - champagne problems

[@SweetThuy]

'I'm begging for you to take my hand' in Willow!

[@jordannow13]

The thing I love with this whole vault scenario is, it doesn’t feel like she’s just shoved them on the end, or like they were kept off the album for a reason. they still fit so damn well and could easily replace a few older songs.

[@cmcm4204]

The vault songs are some of my faves on Red TV and Fearless TV! Can’t wait for 1989TV!

[@jordannow13]

@@cmcm4204 same ! I can’t wait for speak now & 1989 !

[@joellem625]

The “All too well” short film is a masterpiece!! Romance movies take directing notes from Taylor! But also Sadie and Dylan’s acting and chemistry!! Wow and the fact that the fight scene was improvised blew me away. Shows how good of an actors they are!

[@Jacobnsj]

Fr tho 😭 I need more films by Taytay 😩

[@meurieka]

My favorite vault track is absolutely Nothing New! She captures my daily struggle with getting old SO well, especially because society expects us to have it all figured out when we're 18. I also love I Bet You Think About Me purely because of how she sang "oh my god, she's insane, she wrote a song about me."

[@00Kristyna00]

"And I wake up in the middle of the night It's like I can feel time moving" hits different when you're nearing 30. I'm 27 and I literally wake up at 3am and get anxious about time as a philosophical concept.

[@jacobarellano1967]

I think it’s about how women in music are constantly needing to change and reinvent themselves to stay relevant or so she said in the miss Americana documentary

[@jaydecampbell3499]

I bet you think about me is my fav from the vault song. I’m obsessed with it

[@GabCoelhoMusic]

I'm 23 and anxious af

[@jackielopez7489]

samee

[@smh3388]

*Timestamps* ❤️🖤 0:01 - *skillshare // sponsor* 2:30 - *state of grace* 3:21 - *red* 4:42 - *treacherous* 5:27 - *i knew you were trouble* 6:53 - *all too well* 7:18 - *22* 7:45 - *i almost do* 7:56 - *we are never ever getting back together* 9:06 - *stay stay stay* 10:00 - *the last time* 12:00 - *holy ground* 12:20 - *sad beautiful tragic* 12:42 - *the lucky one* 13:01 - *everything has changed* 13:32 - *starlight* 14:00 - *begin again* 14:37 - *the moment i knew* 15:14 - *come back.. be here* 15:26 - *girl at home* *state of grace - acoustic - skipped* 16:53 - *ronan* 17:35 - *better man* 18:57 - *nothing new* 20:54 - *babe* 21:11 - *message in a bottle* 22:02 - *i bet you think about me* 23:07 - *forever winter* 23:35 - *run* 24:50 - *the very first night* 26:15 - *all too well - 10 minute version* 31:17 - *all too well short film* 37:13 - *ranking*

[@lunarbash08]

You missed everything has changed haha

[@smh3388]

@@lunarbash08 thanks ♥️

[@elliotcleaver9087]

The sheer audacity to yassify girl at home….the bravest thing she’s ever done and I’m obsessed😭

[@Rj-ow8ld]

yassify😭😫😂

[@samiajunaid7021]

Not the 'yassify'

[@seihaknou988]

NOT YASSIFICATION 😭

[@klaralouth5801]

YASSIFY IM HERE FOR IT LMAO

[@lemonily9645]

I'm surprised no one else pointed this out yet so I hope Ash sees this. The Spiderman reference actually referred to the fact that Jake Gyllenhaal dated Kirsten Dunst for a while before Taylor Swift. They even lived together. Hence the Spiderman kiss at the line "lost the one true thing that you had ever known." Taylor thought that Jake was trying to recreate his relationship with Kirsten with her. Taylor was even at a similar age as Kirsten was when they both started dating. Hence the iconic Spiderman kiss

[@peytonjames]

wasnt jake in the run to play spiderman too before tobey got the role?

[@graceful1537]

State of Grace -2:32 Red- 3:22 Treacherous- 4:42 I knew you were trouble- 5:27 All too well- 6:53 22- 7:19 I almost do- 7:51 We are never ever getting back together- 7:58 Stay stay stay- 9:06 The last time- 9:59 Holy ground- 11:59 Sad beautiful Tragic- 12:23 The lucky One- 12:46 Everything has changed- 13:02 Starlight- 13:33 Begin Again- 13:59 The moment I knew- 14:40 Come back… Be here- 15:12 Girl at home- 15:26 State of Grace(Acoustic)- 16:16 Ronan- 16:54 Better Man- 17:33 Nothing New- 18:55 Babe- 20:54 Message in a Bottle- 21:10 I bet you think about me- 22:03 Forever Winter- 23:08 Run- 23:35 The very first night- 24:51 All too well for ten minutes -25:44 Message from Taylor - 30:50 SHORT FILM -31:17

[@that_evermore_stan]

You slay to an unimaginable degree ❤

[@Hey_Jamie]

This is way too far down in the comments.

[@francisnoahdienzo7361]

up

[@gazelleluna8191]

I will never shut up about Nothing New. The lyrics just describes the bleak realizations you have when you're just coming into adulthood so well. Then she hits us with Phoebe's haunting, heart-wrenching voice! Goes to say I love these type of dark, gloomy songs. (Also I love Phoebe) Message in a bottle is such a bop thooo

[@pheebsvegetable]

I love Phoebe so much, it’s my favorite vault track!

[@lanemac]

nothing new is potentially the most beautiful song in taylor’s discography. love love love it so much

[@homosapien4947]

Ikr nothing new is just sooo good!!

[@aguirrelaramariep.3393]

Best vault track!!

[@JaciintaM]

The other night I listened to it on repeat for hours. My Spotify crashed.

[@dualapeeps]

im so used to not sleeping bc of taylor, since folklore and evermore bc we couldn’t sleep without thinking she was going to release an album out of nowhere, and i’ve been fucked in the head like that for almost 9 years now being swiftie, so that's not a surprise at all, but w red its A WHOLE NEW LEVEL, i literally haven’t slept in 4 days, and that was the moment i knew *wink wink* she controls my whole life now, to the point in which i just left the name of 1 red song and a quote of taylor's lyrics in evermore in this comment

[@DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose]

Honestly I cannot even *imagine* having the energy to write, record & release the number of songs that Taylor has in the last two years. Like holy hell just think about it...18 tracks on Lover, 34 songs between Folklore & Evermore (17 each), 27 on Fearless TV, & 30 on Red TV. She should become an honorary Avenger at this point because her power is *unreal!* ✨ Edit: Oops, I wrote 24 instead of 34.

[@dualapeeps]

@@DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose um, w folklore and evermore combined there’s 34, not 24

[@DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose]

@@dualapeeps *slaps forehead* Whoops, didn't realize I wrote that. I *can* do second grade math, I swear! 😆 Let me fix that real quick. Edit: Done. Thank you!

[@umchile.anywaysso1408]

champagne problems, amazing lyricism 🥂

[@hikaru1282]

@@DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose That's a total of 109 songs...wow

[@bombeproductions4216]

✨TIME STAMPS LOVLIES🧣🍁✨ State of Grace -2:32 Red- 3:22 Treacherous- 4:42 I knew you were trouble- 5:27 All too well- 6:53 22- 7:19 I almost do- 7:51 We are never ever getting back together- 7:58 Stay stay stay- 9:06 The last time- 9:59 Holy ground- 11:59 Sad beautiful Tragic- 12:23 The lucky One- 12:46 Everything has changed- 13:02 Starlight- 13:33 Begin Again- 13:59 The moment I knew- 14:40 Come back… Be here- 15:12 Girl at home- 15:26 State of Grace(Acoustic)- 16:16 Ronan- 16:54 Better Man- 17:33 Nothing New- 18:55 Babe- 20:54 Message in a Bottle- 21:10 I bet you think about me- 22:03 Forever Winter- 23:08 Run- 23:35 The very first night- 24:51 All too well for ten minutes. (Spill the tea Blondie. Spill it.) -25:44 Message from Our queen Tay tay- 30:50 SHORT FILM (I’m dying too😀)-31:17

[@mmaa9199]

Thanks bestie have a great day

[@bombeproductions4216]

@@mmaa9199 Pleasure! ❤️ I send best wishes ur way

[@roryp1756]

Doing gods work

[@bombeproductions4216]

@@roryp1756 I try to help you guys. U deserve it! ❤️

[@the1wheresamihandidntyap]

gee thx

[@biiconic6348]

On top of your great points with “The Last Time,” it’s ALSO super interesting how in the outro, you hear Taylor’s voice getting quieter and almost giving up as his voice gets higher and higher and more desperate. Like toward the end of it, she gave up and realized it was defeating and not worthwhile. But he’s desperately trying to hold on and beg her for one more time. ANYWAYS :’)

[@samanthadavelaar7452]

DON'T BE ASHAMED OF LOVING EVERYTHING HAS CHANGED!! It's an incredible song and way too underrated in the fandom

[@jimena.the.swiftie]

i just KNOW that if "sad beautiful tragic" was in folklore or evermore YALL WOULD BE EATING IT UP

[@breeliang5616]

It's nice to have a friend~

[@rebeccaverre1120]

LOUDER

[@krishnakrupaur3727]

@@breeliang5616 The Archer too

[@nightcat7741]

THIS!!! SAY IT LOUDER

[@zefty13]

TOOK THE WORDS RIGHT OUT OF MY SOUL

[@MarissaCooperButPoor]

I am still not over how in love I am with Dylan O'Brien and then Tay comes out with that *masterpiece* of a short

[@koalakoala592]

ashley. girl. the makeup, the scarf, the hair- everything is just *chef's kiss*

[@Anna13Tonks]

Ashley's comedic editing is SO underrated

[@aubrey8954]

forever winter has been the hidden gem of the re-record for me. i liked it the first time i listened to it but now i’m completely obsessed

[@jatin368]

It's so interesting, that Taylor proved the record label wrong and proved them a 10 minutes song can also smash and the fact she broke a string of records, made a history real quick

[@peeepooopig6959]

It literally has 200mill streams on Spotify like wtf

[@goldenhyung3429]

2:30 State of Grace 3:21 Red 4:42 Treacherous 5:27 I Knew You Were Trouble 7:18 22 7:50 I Almost Do 7:58 We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together 9:06 Stay Stay Stay 9:59 The Last Time 12:00 Holy Ground 12:23 Sad Beautiful Tragic 12:45 The Lucky One 13:03 Everything Has Changed 13:31 Starlight 13:58 Begin Again 14:38 The Moment I Knew 15:12 Come Back.. Be Here 15:25 Girl At Home 16:52 Ronan 17:32 Better Man 18:54 Nothing New 20:53 Babe 21:11 Message In A Bottle 22:02 I Bet You Think About Me 23:06 Forever Winter 23:35 Run 24:50 The Very First Night 26:15 All Too Well (10 minute version) 31:16 All Too Well The Short Film

[@Ayush-zy7th]

Thanks💜❤

[@jonymateus4525]

Thanks

[@rosegcldenglcws]

37 mins of ashley is exactly what i NEED after having my heart broken over red tv and the all too well short film

[@lucianagalvagno4096]

Scott: "it's supposed to be fun turning 21" Taylor: YOU KNOW WHAT! 22!!! 22 DAD!!

[@paula-gu4eb]

"'any time now he's gonna say it's love', you never called it what it was, 'til we were dead and gone and buried, check the pulse and come back swearing it's the same, after three months in the grave, and then you wondered where it went to as i reached for you but all i felt was shame and you held my lifeless frame" - all too well (10 min version) "then you come around again and say 'baby, i miss you and i swear i'm gonna change, trust me'" and "i say 'i hate you', we break up, you call me 'i love you'" and "so he calls me up and he's like 'i still love you'" - we are never ever getting back together "'i love you' doesn't count after goodbye" - hidden message for state of grace from the red liner notes jake never said he loved her until after they had broken up in an attempt to get her back, 'he held her lifeless frame" because he only called it love after he had killed them (her and the relationship), they broke up and he came back 'after three months in the grave' swearing they could still work and that he would change 🙃

[@siemprealada]

all of this and also "words, how little they mean when you're a little too late" 😭

[@jacobmccain8794]

I love Taylor’s music and the fact that it comes from the personal place and I didn’t know about this being about Jake until this 10 minute version came out. I’m a Broadway kid at heart and have always been a huge fan of Jake and his work! He has always been a supporter and advocate and I admire that. I feel just because I support Taylor music and how she writes from a real personal place means I have to hate Jake. I’m sure he made mistakes in that three month relationship. An age difference can be hard and being with someone so famous and being such a private person like he I’m sure caused many problems. I think of it as it takes two to create a relationship and also make it work. As much as he was the older one, and honestly idc about the age because there are many married people well over ten years apart and so in love. My parents are ten years apart. I just think we don’t know the whole story. Only Taylor’s side and how she interpreted those 3 months. We don’t know anything from how Jake felt. I say support her without canceling or bashing someone we don’t have all the facts about. We don’t know what happened fully, we only have one side, but doesn’t mean we can’t support her craft! Respect your opinions tho and I like your analysis of the lyrics, shows you’re a true fan! Let’s just not be so hasty to judge and bash ppl without all the facts. More love and support👏🙏🙂 People grow and make mistakes, it was 11 years ago since that 3 month relationship.

[@paula-gu4eb]

@@jacobmccain8794 "i say support her without canceling or bashing someone" bro nowhere in that comment did i say a single bad thing about jake 😭 i literally just explained the meaning of the lyrics and gave no personal opinions. btw a ten year difference between full grown adults it's not the same as that age gap between someone who's basically still a teenager (she wasn't even 21 when they started dating, couldn't even drink) and someone pushing 30! it's weird and shouldn't be excused, specially considering how to this day his girlfriends are still in their early twenties while he's 40 😊

[@normstorm.]

I didn’t expect the disrespect towards “I almost do” - the amount of times I’ve cried myself to sleep to this song

[@bonnieyao5486]

underrated comment. THIS

[@crimeyfruit5676]

this.

[@zefty13]

SAY👏🏻IT👏🏻LOUDER👏🏻

[@flxwercxrpse1871]

I love that song so much

[@BlakeStylinson]

Me too 🥺

[@cassiaferreira3205]

We collectively need to start appreciating The Lucky One more, it is a masterpiece idc idc

[@maddymp4]

The Last Time is truly such a heartbreakingly beautiful song, when you said "i'm gonna cry" i was like girl me too. Also Better Man fucked me up, it really captures the complexity of missing and leaving an emotionally abusive relationship

[@crestfallen_moon]

So something I found out with this album. Mr Jakey is dating a girl who's as old as Tom Holland and there's a whole interview where he calls Jake a kid. So Taylor was not wrong with that lyric 👀🚩

[@parawolfwolfsbane9524]

Thanks for the info! So really kinda like Leonardo DiCaprio they both date younger because easier to manipulate/power balance kinda like Tom cruise/Katie Holmes. He used her starstruckness to manipulate her as well. Sorry I went off on a tangent

[@user-no2sp2kf1l]

29:33 the fact that he was gaslighting her so badly that she began questioning her own reality so intensely that she had to write a song repeating the words "i was there, remember it " over and over again?????????? jake gyllenhaal UR DONE

[@klaralouth5801]

^^^^^^^UPVOTE

[@honeymoonfaded]

32:30 someone on the internet notice how everyone glass is almost empty while Sadie’s one is still full cause she (taylor) wasn’t like legally allowed to drink, I can’t stop thinking about this THE DETAILSSSSSSS

[@MEDSZ13.08]

And the purity ring she wears most of the movie and then she takes off when the sex scene comes on

[@honeymoonfaded]

@@MEDSZ13.08 OH GOD UR RIGHT.

[@MEDSZ13.08]

@@honeymoonfaded Everything has a reason with the blondie

[@honeymoonfaded]

@@MEDSZ13.08 Im kinda scared of her at this point tbh

[@MEDSZ13.08]

@@honeymoonfaded I’ve always been scared of her…especially Fearless era Taylor

[@tristaskye7794]

I really loved The Last Time when it was first released but Gary's voice in the re-recording sounds so heavenly and it's sending me

[@Ale-jy6xi]

As someone who turns 22 this week I am in tears I was feeling so many emotions listening to the album especially nothing new

[@mathiangx9047]

As some fans mentioned it, the sections of the short film being titled as chapters was a foreshadowing to Her becoming an author 😭😭 and how we've actually been following her narrative through her book 😭

[@missmaggicasares6538]

NOW all I want is a REAL book from her!!!!!!!

[@johngeraldagbayani6532]

😮😮😮

[@idkman3096]

i mean she does have a couple full length books written from years ago, that her parents keep for her

[@daniellaLmiller]

🤯

[@Fatimakeyrr]

oh my goodness

[@SuperSinister55]

At this point, this rivalry between Ash and 3AM will never end. 🤣🤣🤣😭

[@nach7882]

The Last Time is severely underrated. And Message In The Bottle? YALL DID IT DIRTY.ITS A BOP

[@klaralouth5801]

MESSAGE IN A BOTTLE IS A BANGER I TAKE NOTHING ELSE

[@SierraByrd]

I'm honestly so surprised that Nothing New wasn't your favorite of the Vault tracks (aside from 10 minute version obviously) I figured that song would be right up your ally. Nothing New and Message In A Bottle I immediately thought of you when I heard them.

[@preetidash2217]

When she was reading the book, she was actually saying the lines of all too well “I walked through the door with you, the air was cold. But something about it felt like home somehow” 😉

[@crestfallen_moon]

Oh and I don't know if you've seen this but on an interview, so she was doing rehearsals for tour and she was really sad so one day she went into the studio and she just sat with the band and started singing all too well she was just speaking from her heart and the band was playing along. That's the original 10-15 minute version. And she just left but her mom went to the studio people and was like "hey, you don't maybe have a recording of that?" and they did so that's how we got all too well. And then she had to decide between better man and all too well for the album and chose the chopped up version of All Too Well instead.

[@neutralman9124]

It's getting hard to pick my favourite album of hers. folklore, evermore, Red (TV) and 1989 are all number 1.

[@hassanmansour9857]

For me its folklore evermore Red TV and Speak Now🥺❤

[@kat_wayward]

Ashley. Girl. You can't keep skipping the acoustic versions when they're better than the original ones. State of Grace and Forever and Always acoustic are MASTERPIECES

[@mirandabee2323]

My favorite vault track is "I Bet You Think About Me" because it's fun, I'm petty, and regarding a certain person I'm acquainted with, I fluctuate between "I bet you think about me" and "I hope sometimes you wonder about me."

[@ishabirb]

Ashley: This song is the definition of sad girl autumn vibes Taylor: released All Too Well (Sad Girl Autumn Version)

[@leedalite]

Can I just say Ash perfectly represents all of us when we listen to Holy Ground. I will never not dance/skip/jump aggressively when i listen to it!

[@sol_117]

I know that the swifties don't talk too much about Ronan because it's meaning and I understand that, I'm new to the fandom and I didn't listen Red when it came out, so I listened to it when Red TV came out and Ronan was the song that hurt me the most, and it's not just because it has a really sad backstory, it's just that I relate to the lyrics so much and they are a big help for me rn, my dad died 5 months ago, it's going to be 6 in 3 days and I just miss him so much, he didn't die because of cancer, he die because kidney failure and it was so hard because I saw him getting weaker in his hospital bed for 3 months, I heard his screams of pain on my 18 birthday and it was a slow process of waiting the best just to be crying the next day because nothing good was happening. Sorry, this is the first time that I talk about this since everything happen, what I wanted to say is that Ronan it's a really wonderful song and we should support it more, because we can bring much more awareness about cancer and other horrible diseases that can take away our loved ones.

[@OfficialDeanAdler]

Girlie! Did you watch the Jimmy Fallon and Seth Meyers episodes last week with Taylor Swift as the guest? She talked about how this time around, she’s listening to the fans and and fan favorite songs into singles and having music videos. We have a chance to get Getaway Car, Don’t Blame Me, and/or I Did Something Bad as a single!!! Edit: Enchanted is rumored to have a music video too.

[@corrienotcorey]

I LOVED Girl at Home (Taylor's version). I honestly thought the original sounded like a demo. You're totally right though about Jack being written all over it I screamed

[@babii6168]

When I first originally heard of RED, it didn't hit for me because I felt like it she's diving into so many sounds that it short circuited my unprepared brain but over time and the fact that I experienced my first heartbreak, I grew to love the album. For me RED encapsulated the mess and disorient that my heartbreak left me in, the tracks reflected the feeling of having every emotion all over the place. It amazes me how the record showed me the process of letting the pain out, feeling it and learning to let it go because finally I was healed.

[@leosauro782]

OMG PERFECT TIMING! All Too Well (Taylor's Version) just debuted at #1 at BB100. The longest song to ever chart. A 9 year old song, no radio airplay DID THAT! So happy for Taylor 😭 WE DID IT JEAUX!!!!

[@khalidrenegade]

“Jake Gyllenhaal, welcome to your tape” I hollered😂

[@MarissaCooperButPoor]

I died in that moment specifically 😂

[@somethingaboutthewoods]

Low-key might be one of your best reacts yet!!! The editing, the singing, the yee haw hat and the commentary, all immaculate 🤌

[@muhammadzikri8492]

I hate the thumbnail, taylor releases this to celebrate with fans, not to shit on jake. Swifties being respectful challenge

[@kagitopia]

i'm hoping ashley keeps BOTH the hat and the scarf for the next re-recording and she adds another one everytime lol

[@captainaaron96]

A camera for 1989, a snake for rep…what for Speak Now and debut?

[@JustAnotherGeekX]

@@captainaaron96 Speak Now maybe a dress, and for the debut a guitar ig? Not really sure

[@cc1526]

@@captainaaron96 for debut, maybe that purple flower that she was holding in her album cover photoshoot!

[@cc1526]

@@captainaaron96 and maybe for speak now, a fake engagement ring since the song speak now was about breaking up a wedding 😆

[@joapol0628]

It's perfect because even the songs she says that aren't her favourites, she can notice the differences with the old version, which means that she's heard it a lot of times

[@heli_3105]

Every time a new Taylor Swift Album is out, I am like, this has to be her best album and then I go back and listen to other albums and I am like, no this one is her best. Its almost impossible to choose my favourite Taylor album

[@stevents1987]

Yap, I can't even choose what's her best album even though folklore/evermore has been released too (which is we might can't get those masterpieces if theres no pandemic but we get Lover Fest tho 😍😍)

17:22 this is why I love you. Your kindness to people and the way you raise awareness about mental health is everything.

[@brookemckinley5709]

Her having Jake on the screen behind her and talking to him is just another reason why I love her and her videos so much!! 😂

[@kyoka1528]

Agreed, it's the first time I've seen someone put in such effort to humiliate Jake Gyllenhaal... The effort is amazing 😂

[@brendanjyoung_]

Ashley saying Stay Stay Stay is such a polarizing song where you either love it or hate it then follows that statement with I’m in the middle had me laughing so hard 😂 I love Stay Stay Stay ✨

[@gemini3076]

PERIOD ASHLEY I LOVE YOU AND YOUR CONTENT MAKES MY DAY 🤍🤍🤍 ps Thank you for reacting to Ronan! I don’t see many people doing it!

[@marlaoliva746]

"Dylan, please call.. the kids miss you" HAHAHA I PASSED OUT

[@Ijnebsb]

Time stamps 1 State of Grace 2:30 2 Red 3:21 3 Treacherous 4:41 4 I knew you were trouble 5:26 5 All too well 6:37 6 22 7:04 7 I almost do 7:43 8 We are never ever getting back together 7:56 9 Stay stay stay 9:03 10 The last time (Ft Gary Lightbody) 9:58 11 Holy Ground 11:59 12 Sad beautiful Tragic 12:17 13 The lucky one 12:44 14 Everything has changed (Ft Ed Sheeran) 13:02 15 Starlight 13:23 16 Begin again 13:58 17 The moment I knew 14:37 18 Come back…. Be here 15:11 19 Girl at home 15:26 20 State of Grace (acoustic) 16:16 21 Ronan 16:32 22 Better man 17:32 23 Nothing new (Ft Phoebe Bridgers) 18:53 24 Babe 20:53 25 Message in a bottle 21:10 26 I bet you think about me (Ft Chris Stapleton) 22:02 27 Forever winter 23:06 28 Run 23:34 29 The very first night 24:50 30 All too well 10 minute version 25:42 31 Message from Taylor 30:50 32 All too well 10 minute version film 31:10 33 Ashley’s ranking 37:14

[@fran9707]

i know you’re working your ass off with arcane atm but i really need a motherly and maternal opinion on harry’s house. more importantly though i miss you and i really hope you’re doing okay xx

[@RhapsodyHC]

Bro Ash and Ajay being gone is so sad. They might end up like Dylan.

[@everlynalvera4]

Bro no don't jinx it....

[@k.i.w.i.7451]

wait nevermind ajay's last vid was actually after this one but they've both been gone for like half a year😭

[@JackOfAllTrades2004]

She’s not completely gone. She has a channel called ur internet mom ash

[@leonorbarrelas1378]

i've been procrastinating for hours and when i feel finally motivated ashley posts... studying is not that important right?

[@melmel1071]

Go study bestie xoxo

[@Nik-xk1jm]

Timestamps... Skillshare - 00:00 Video starts - 01:16 State Of Grace - 02:30 Red - 03:21 Treacherous - 04:41 I Knew You Were Trouble - 05:26 All Too Well - 06:36 22 - 07:18 I Almost Do - 07:43 We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together - 07:58 Stay Stay Stay - 09:06 The Last Time - 09:59 Holy Ground - 11:59 Sad Beautiful Tragic - 12:23 The Lucky One - 12:44 Everything Has Changed - 13:02 Starlight - 13:31 Begin Again - 13:58 The Moment I Knew - 14:38 Come Back...Be Here - 15:11 Girl At Home - 15:25 State Of Grace - 16:15 Ronan - 16:53 Better Man - 17:33 Nothing New - 18:54 Babe - 20:53 Message In A Bottle - 21:11 I Bet You Think About Me - 22:02 Forever Winter - 23:06 Run - 23:34 The Very First Night - 24:50 All Too Well (10 Min Version) - 26:14 A Message From Taylor - 30:40 All Too Well (Video) - 31:16

[@DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose]

Having always pictured the All Too Well story in my head whenever I'd listen to the album (granted *every* song tells a story but ATW, The Last Time, & Sad Beautiful Tragic were always the most vibrant & moving to me), to see it come to life the way it did through Taylor's film was so beautifully poignant. I legit almost cried watching. And that ending though...ouch. 🧣📕 Edit: NOOO Ash doesn't connect with SBT still. 😔

[@AmoriMoori]

Yesss living for the whole red aesthetic with the speaker, lights and scarf. We have similar ranking for the most part but for me "state of grace is" #2 and "nothing new" and "better man" are much higher

[@Annatje121]

The last time is SO UNDERRATED it is so good and especially this rerecording just GRABBED me by the throat ugh

[@dancortat7445]

I just play part of the music Ronan and then skip, cause cancer is very regular in my family, many of my relatives had cancer (my grandmother had and survived, my two grand-uncles had and died, and my favorite cousin had and survived) and it's a genetic predisposition for me, my mom and my sisters. That song just makes me cry my eyes out. Sorry my rusty english, it is not my native language

[@williamsousa1281]

🧣 TRACKLIST 🧣 1. State of Grace - 2:30 2. Red - 3:21 3. Treacherous - 4:42 4. IKYWT - 5:26 5. All Too Well - 6:52 6. 22 - 7:18 7. I Almost Do - 7:42 8. WANGBT - 7:58 9. Stay Stay Stay - 9:06 10. The Last Time - 9:59 11. Holy Ground - 11:59 12. Sad Beautiful Tragic - 12:22 13. The Lucky One - 12:45 14. Everything Has Changed - 13:01 15. Starlight - 13:31 16. Begin Again - 13:58 17. The Moment I Knew - 14:37 18. Come Back… Be Here - 15:11 19. Girl At Home - 15:25 20. State of Grace (Acoustic) - 16:16 21. Ronan - 16:53 22. Better Man - 17:30 23. Nothing New - 18:53 24. Babe - 20:53 25. Message In A Bottle - 21:10 26. I Bet You Think About Me - 22:01 27. Forever Winter - 23:06 28. Run - 23:34 29. The Very First Night - 24:50 30. All Too Well (10 minute version) - 26:14 31. All Too Well (Short Film) - 31:16

[@heli_3105]

Easter eggs in the short film- I have heard from many Swifties that Sadie was wearing a purity ring before the bed scene, and so she probably lost her V-card to him, maybe due to which the breakup hit even more Yep Ash caught another easter egg- the Spiderman kiss , cause Jake plays a role in a Spiderman movie m Considering how poetic Miss Swift is maybe the scarf symbolizes something as well, cause she keeps referencing it again and again Also in scenes like when she is with Jake's friends and a party, she wears a red lipstick to look older and to fit in

[@stay_rosey1753]

I feel like every single song on the album with the addition of ATW10 and the vault tracks just tell so much more of a complete story about their relationship! It just ties it all together and gives so much more context.

[@swonino]

"Perfect is the enemy of good." this hit me so much. I think imma go and see this class. Thank you, Ash.

[@oliviacharlotte2093]

I’m only 11 minutes in but thank you for giving the last time the respect she deserves I love that song. I don’t listen to Taylor’s music that much but I know a handful of this album and prior to the re-release I did know the last time and it was my favourite. It’s now my favourite after all too well 10 minute version but I don’t hear enough people talking about it. I just love it.

[@sierra930]

sad beautiful tragic is one of my favs from the rerecording but i can see why its not everyones jam. but i love your album reviews and this one is no exception

[@letguelere1102]

I can't listen to Ronan without crying or tearing up as someone who lost someone else at such a young age it just, hits so hard right in the heart Miss you Igor 13 and Luby 7 :(

[@hassanmansour9857]

May their pure souls rest in piece❤

[@TobiasTK]

Dylan and Sadie killed it great chemistry and you could feel the song even more by the way great directing by Taylor

[@devoneytaylor890]

This album was so therapeutic and nostalgic it put me on my ASS. It came out when I was 12 and it was my fucking BOP, and I’m 21 now and had a horrible breakup right after my 21st birthday and it shook me to the core how similar this was. ANYWAYS Also my ex had the same beard and FUCK I was like AH EW *sprays with a bottle of water and vinegar* get out!

[@deborahbada3161]

Thank Ashley for feeding us with the content we need

[@reginaphalange5932]

I was feeling down and anxious. I was anxiously scrolling through my phone and I accidentally opened KZbin. This was the first thing I saw and I'm glad I will get to watch you laugh, cry and curse XD. You made my day a lot better. Thank you Ashley💖 I love you so much 🥺💖

[@alexandra.1702]

love ur name and pfp

[@mayarm6924]

I hope you feel better soon

[@reginaphalange5932]

@@alexandra.1702 thanks hun☺️

[@reginaphalange5932]

@@mayarm6924 feeling much better. Thank you ☺️

[@hi_there1239]

when ash decided she'd bring out the hat for anything country, i immediately went "oh ok so 'i bet you think about me' then"

[@cambenji]

i think the end basically reflecting her singing at concerts to swifties was perfect