People hate Micah, but he was actually right in this Argument

[@alishojaei9156]

Jenny....Mac...Davey.... (Looks to the other side) and now Arthur.... They mattered to me

[@Cobra_Kaii_2002]

Bruhhhh that’s hilarious

[@triyanuari9473]

Dutch:"artuh we need more moneh"

[@themomiuss]

Lmaoo

[@AJ_Evo]

This made me laugh out loud 😂😂

[@alinpetrescu2309]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@Sonjsing_of72]

I like how they just ignore Arthur falling from the heavens

[@mysaysthings5512]

That's just Arthur on any tuesday afternoon

[@lewisjohnston7077]

Arthur fell out from the sky lol

[@goodestpupper9311]

lol that’s why Hosea paused he’s like “you hear something?”

[@nameynamename3758]

"you're a good man, arthur morgan" arthur after reaching heaven's doors:

[@GMP1isReal]

Ignore what?

[@BurtChintus]

In all fairness, Micah is a more realistic depiction of a western outlaw. Those guys are romanticized these days but the were very cruel and brutal.

[@jasperzanovich2504]

It's probaby more realistic that they didn't exist at all.

[@BurtChintus]

@jasperzanovich2504 as violent as America is today, I guarantee it was worse than we even think.

[@TNAROHfan]

@@jasperzanovich2504 Well you would be wrong in that account. There were plenty of unsavory individuals prowling the western territories after the civil war. It was a perfect storm kind of event, where there were vast stretches of open, nearly lawless territory, wealthy boomtowns and those looking to take advantage of that, both with and without badges and with and without standing in the community. The civil war itself was a watershed moment that shaped a lot of the violence of that period, both ideologically and in terms of the often unspoken and relatively unexplored damage it dealt to the psyche of the nation, particularly those who fought it. It's one of the bright spots, in what would have otherwise been a relatively mundane series of Hollywood "cowboys and Indians." They did a good job of portraying that grey area dynamic, particularly through Micah and Ross, even though it's basically the tail end of the "wild west". It always brings me back to the scene in Deliverance where Lewis (Burt Reynolds) exclaims to Drew (Ronny Cox) "What Law? Where's the law Drew?" Are you gonna get the benefit of the doubt with their friend who is Sheriff, or those good old boys on the jury who are their cousins? No..Lol!

[@BrackstonCathey]

@@jasperzanovich2504please don’t speak on topics you know nothing about. It makes you look like an idiot

[@jaxsienplays9884]

Every outlaw was different

[@Soldierboytrey]

“I don’t answer to you” Micah, Hosea is literally the co-boss at this stage in the game

[@smileyfawler8454]

Yes but he doesn't care because he completely outclasses Hosea in skill.

[@BRNardy]

Exactly, dude, he was even somewhat afraid of Arthur's authority in the group by the start of the game, and Arthur was the 3rd in command. And then he talks trash like that to the 2nd. I guess it's because, since Micah is a coward, he preys on those who appear weak. Hosea because he's old, and later Arthur because he is sick.

[@smileyfawler8454]

@@BRNardy Micah fearlessly runs into gunfights when he's completely outnumbered and you're trying to frame him as a coward. Honestly, this fandom and their delusions are something else.

[@Soldierboytrey]

@@smileyfawler8454 Micah is stronger and healthier than Hosea but I think Hosea would definitely put up a good fight if they started shooting. He’s an old gunfighter whose only resource are his guns now that he’s so sick. The argument that he doesn’t fear Hosea is true but I wouldn’t say he completely outclasses him in skill

[@Soldierboytrey]

@@smileyfawler8454 Micah is totally a coward. He hid and slithered behind Arthur in chapters 1-5 then when Arthur got sick and Dutch started to lose it he took advantage of Dutch and manipulated him into making him the new right hand. He would never have acted the way he did in Beaver Hallow at Horseshoe Overlook or Clemins Point because of Arthur. He’s dumb enough to run into gunfights then need someone to help him but that doesn’t mean he isn’t a coward

[@darkmp4c]

Hosea: Jenny.. Mac…Davey they were Arthur: AHHAHHAHHHHAHHAAAAAA thats 3 dead right there

[@fighter500mx3]

Without Arthur the whole gang is doomed to fail very early in chapter one😂

[@marquviousgreen4674]

Don’t forget Sean getting captured and john almost dying

[@Scouser1995]

That's 2 bones right there

[@knowwudimean1064]

​@@Scouser1995lol you beat me to it

[@dardosalinas4426]

Random dialogue can be made into cutscenes too. This game honestly.

[@oncourthomicide5499]

I’d be cool if you went into cinematic mode it had angles for camp arguments and chats 😮

[@mr.wilson9178]

I never Heard this dialogue and had 7 playthrough... WTF?

[@firstandlast4]

​@@mr.wilson9178Its fake, like everything else, its either AI, or cheats/mods

[@chris_player2995]

​@@mr.wilson9178 its one of those random events

[@mr.wilson9178]

@@chris_player2995 and here i thought i knew all about this game! Gamer hubris! ^^

[@Longshanks1690]

Arthur fell out of the hot air balloon again. 😂

[@lewisjohnston7077]

Blame Arturo Bullard

[@commander144]

What is this, 1850?

[@napoleoncomplex2712]

Did he break his chocolate bar?

[@forsakenwarrior814]

Jenny...Mac...Davey (Splat)....Arthur

[@justsomeguy747]

I think he just doesn’t want to make a big drama out of people dying because it’s part of the life they chose. Micah sees Hosea as weak because he dwells on death in their line of work and in Micah’s worldview he is whining.

[@TheGreatDearLeaderJimPickens]

Or it’s because he’s trying to divert them from thinking there’s a rat

[@slimdarcy9503]

Micah was a cold blooded killer. He talks about it all being for survival but he took great pleasure out of violence and killing. Yea no one in Dutch's cult was innocent but Micah was a well written monster.

[@justsomeguy747]

A rat wouldn’t endanger himself with a high price on his head. He ratted when he was disillusioned with Dutch. He’s annoyed by Hosea because because he had more influence on Dutch at the time and he gives him crap for the heist going wrong even though they were a whole group dealing with it. Basically my whole point is, sometimes failure can be caused by poor leadership, and Dutch is just that in many occasions.

[@TheGreatDearLeaderJimPickens]

@@justsomeguy747 Could be that the price on his head is exactly why he ratted. However, I do agree with you that Dutch is a failed leader. Hosea and Arthur are the only real leaders of the gang. Dutch just brought his personality and charisma to the table and took control

[@triyanuari9473]

In Micah defense they are criminal and he knows anything can happen especially death

[@biterwastaken]

where tf did Arthur come from 💀

[@jalengeneblazo1772]

Tahiti

[@SeanMacguire1879]

He pressed replay and he ended up in valentine (that’s where the gang’s camp is located in chapter two, right?)

[@biterwastaken]

@ yup, the camp was called Horseshoe Overlook

[@luzandal4521]

UFO, Probably..

[@KL_MMD]

​@@jalengeneblazo1772 it makes sense now

[@SlurpyPie]

I love how the cinematography in this clip is on the same level as the actual cutscenes in game, if I didn't know any better I would've assumed this was an actual cutscene I somehow missed.

[@Sean-0-JH]

The main difference I can see is that the camera moves around Hosea and Micah. During the entire story I can’t recall a single cutscene where the camera moves around characters. Normally it’s staying still rather than rotating around.

[@SlurpyPie]

@@Sean-0-JH I could be wrong but I think the mission where Arthur is trying to find one of the debtors and one of the miners says he’s dead and the camera does subtly pans around Arthur other than that instance I can’t recall any other times the camera does that but regardless it’s still pretty good cinematography on the guy’s part imo

[@Innocuousmale]

I didn't know any better and thats exactly what I thought it was. Until around the 40 second mark.

[@jarlballinofswagrun4229]

@@Sean-0-JHI think it moves during the Guarma chain gang escape through the forest?

[@chimpswag3492]

I have a feeling that arthur falling from the sky is a pretty solid giveaway

[@bobdole7451]

The whole gang was doomed from the start. The majority were bad people or trouble makers. Micah just hurried the inevitable

[@R0ZEMARI-GS4L]

Not to mention that the Wild West was pretty much fucked in this time.

[@earnem4175]

@@R0ZEMARI-GS4L yeah, 1899, and 1900. which was the last we see of wild west gangs, anywhere over 1900 is the end of outlaws and lawmans. they either died or retired

[@sebastianjimenez5455]

​@@earnem4175Actually by 1899, the Wild West era had ended at least 5 years before, according to some historians and 9 according to the rest. So what we see is actually the last gangs being hunted.

[@earnem4175]

@@sebastianjimenez5455 some say it was 1895, while government it was 1890. lots of historians are conflicted. It ended In 1911, 1899. But there was still lots left in 1900. All died in 1901.

[@earnem4175]

@@sebastianjimenez5455 Greer Gang operated in 1900-1902. Some say in 1917. But 1904 seeme more appropriate. Greer gang were much younger and caught up with times.

[@rhetiq9989]

Arthur just casually re-enacting the Mr. Bean intro

[@A1eczander]

Micah was absolutely *not* right in this scene. Three people died in the gang died because of the ferry job, and it was described as a massacre. We don't know exactly what happened, but Hosea is simply correct - "we're running for our lives because of a bad call you made." That's the plot of the game. Viewing death as an "occupational hazard" is fucked up, entirely morally bankrupt. This scene encapsulates why Micah is a terrible person and why we as an audience grow to hate him.

[@toastyeditz]

I think there's an argument to be made for both sides. Realistically, Micah is right. With the life they live, death should be an expected occurrence. But to have such an outlook is what gives an argument for Hosea, because he is morally correct. To view death as nothing more than a minor inconvenience is just simply immoral. Especially if it's towards those that you supposedly call friends or even family.

[@TH3CAPN]

Oh please like another comment said all Micah did was hurry up the inevitable, if it wasn’t black water it would of been another town where people died. Perfect description “occupational hazard”

[@bonehed1]

Death absolutely is an occupational hazard when your occupation is stealing things and shooting people. You're acting like this conversation is happening between 2 cashiers. Micah is indeed morally bankrupt, but he is also right. The sad truth about Micah is that even though he is an amoral sociopath, you can hardly say he's a worse person than most of the gang. Almost everyone in the gang is robbing and killing. The only thing the rest of the gang has over him is loyalty to each other, save for a high honor Arthur who truly does make a difference to those around him even if he does a lot of bad things too.

[@kujochurch3133]

Has everyone forgotten micah was a rat and hurried everything? He wasn't right, he was diverting attention.

[@TheRealChappers]

​@kujochurch3133 Micah wasnt a rat to begin with. The ferry job was just a bad call that was bound to happen at somepoint. Micah's philosophy is survival, by the end of the guama chapter micah can see the van der linde gang is done for so he does what it takes for him to personally survive ie become the rat

[@user-pi3hd2bt3f]

0:31 he's not wrong though.

[@taxicorky]

But he is though. This wasn't a gang like any others. They had women and a child with them and they went for the con trying to avoid violence where nescessary. So Micah calling his screw up just an occupational hazard is not right

[@ellieh.5419]

​@@taxicorky that's what they were meant to be but it's different to the reality of what they actually doing, remember that robbing people and banks were Dutch's call as much as Micah's and they had been doing it for a long time even before the Game starts

[@ellieh.5419]

And when Micah says "Dying, that's part of the game" he really is refering to the game Dutch and Hosea chose 20 years prior to the game events. Yes Micah would eventually rat everyone out, but during their time at Blackwater, the gang was already being chased by pinkertons for 20 years of crimes mostly by Dutch, no matter how you see it the gang is no better than just that, a gang of Thieves and Murderers, just that by Arthur's pov they are aswell family

[@GorchakovVS]

​@@taxicorky They were exactly like all other gangs, just more hypocritical. Keiran even lampshades that when he says they're not so different from O'Driscolls.

[@taxicorky]

@GorchakovVS Lmao i was talking about actual gangs in history 🤦🏻‍♂️🤣 There were no gangs like that with women a child and a priest and a loan shark lol.. this is completely fictional and this gang is portrayed to be something different. Stop the nonsense please 🤦🏻‍♂️🤣

[@Goated_ChrisBreezy]

Micah is one of the Greatest characters in Rockstar's history, the fact he is still talked about and this hated by the fandom all these years later proves that Here's why Micah is not "just a one dimension evil bad guy" Micah spares High Honor Arthur Micah shows concern for his members safety constantly showing concern for Arthur specfically although this is because he values his gang members as tools for Survival rather than actually caring about them as people Micah asks Mary Beth to dance with him and is devestated when she rejects him, shown he has a secret desire to be loved or accepted by a Woman Micah seems like the opposite of a Rat, yes he's a horrible person, a Monster but his plot twist shocked me, i thought he was gonna be one of those characters who are horrible people but Loyalty being one of their redeeming qualities Micah is complex in the fact that we dont really know what his true motivations are, did he really wanna rule with Dutch? Did he use Dutch? Did he respect Arthur deep down despite his hatred of him? Did he plan for Arthur's capture by Colm? Why does Micah stay on his own in the camp, and when everyone goes to sleep its always him sitting at the camp fire in the middle of camp? Why doesnt he sit there in the day time, why does Micah never eat food? In a campfire speech Micah admits he is going to hell, so he's aware of his evil, but is he broken? What got him to do this level of immorality? If Micah was a True Rat, then why has he betraying the Pinkertons in the mission "just a Social call?" In that mission why didnt Micah just turn Dutch and Arthur into the Pinkertons when it was such a perfect opportunity? Its things like this that make you question if he truly even was the rat, Micah is a Character who you could analyze for hours, one dimensional evil Characters are basically just "muhahaha i wanna take over the world because im evil!" This is insulting to Micah's Character as an antagonist to say hes that simplistic This the problem with people's takes on modern day villains Being morally grey does not automatically make a well written or interesting Villain And being Pure Evil doesn't mean the Villain is "boring". Is the Joker a boring Villain because he's pure Evil by that logic? The Joker is a very complex Character and yet he's pure evil Micah steals the Scene nearly half the time he is on screen, also notice how RDR KZbinrs constantly post Micah content? Because Micah videos pull views for a reason, the fans hate him, but keep watching Micah related RDR videos which proves he's one of the greatest Rockstar characters

[@apehawk]

I don't even think Micah is the worst antagonist in RDR, that title goes to Ross. At least Micah is actually willing to co-operate sometimes, Ross only thought about himself.

[@nameynamename3758]

​@@apehawk ross makes some good points, not to say he's good but he wasn't completely wrong

[@0902_]

​@@apehawkFor me they are the same level.Sure, Micah was somewhat useful and cooperated as you said.But Ross didn't pretend to be your friend with only subtle hints that he isn't and then betray you.He also wasn't a racist, sexist, rapist and didn't prey on the weak.Well maybe he did if you count John's family though

[@jeffreeves3137]

This right here, I love Micah, in a sense he’s an amazing villain. Guy did a great job, makes me excited for gta 6, hope we get a great villain or 2

[@williamfrank962]

@@apehawkpeople forget that he’s actually somewhat appreciative and kind to Arthur in the beginning giving you a second gun for letting him out and genuinely trying to make an effort. Yes he’s an ass but he was willing to co operate with you before giving up to the Pinkertons which frankly after every screw up of Dutch was expected for someone who’s only been in the gang for eight months.

[@Man_Toast]

arthur awkwardly ruining the vibes, once again

[@quintinjansevanvuuren9638]

"Okay, I'll catch you later then"

[@szynkacz1069]

"Jenny, Mac, Davey, they were..." I can bet my ass he wanted to call them good people and his friends, but then he remembered there are no good outlaws

[@Berserker3624]

Yeah but he can claim them as family

[@realQuestion]

even people who do bad things can be mourned when they die before their time

[@Ben_2040]

By that logic, the two agents are saints. And the people responsible for all of the racist and sexist laws back then. I think Dutch himself is better than those people. I agree with him in many ways.

[@danim8414]

0:39 how children are made

[@gamercreature2587]

People are meant to be stronger but the force of the ground hitting our bodies makes us permanently weaker.

[@DutchPlanDerLindeFromTahiti]

​@@gamercreature2587Baby lore

[@Pilot119]

Why would Micah care about Mac, Davey, Jenny, or really anyone in the gang? After all, he did join the gang around six months ago

[@asco4189]

He called the callender boys "real fighters" in the beginning in chapter 1. And he also slept with Jenny, which he also told arthur in a side mission in chapter 4.

[@ethanwood6832]

​@@asco4189He "respected" or feared the Callender brothers because they were "good fighters", ruthless, and probably higher ranking members in the gang. He slept with Jenny because he felt like it, he didn't care about her. He only joined the gang out of convenience and the potential to steal a score from them.

[@JohnDonovan1968]

Micah was good friends with Mac & Davey and he said it was a shame losing the brothers and he had a drunk fun night with Jenny too But i think the way he see is just you have to move on. In this life, it is expect to lose folk

[@AncientDogeFly]

It’s unrealistic to think that you can rob and kill so many people without losing anyone on your team. Micah was real before he became a rat

[@magtinfal7908]

The thing about Micah is he's really one of the few guys in the gang that's honest about who they are, criminals

[@jakehull465]

0:38 seems Hosea forgot to say Arthur as well lol 😅

[@lordofcinder8884]

Random events has better acting and facial animations than the entire ubisoft modern line up

[@TheNikoBellic2008]

Micah is what I thought most of the characters would be like in this game, but it ended up having a very different tone and philosophies compared to RDR1. Most of the gang is delusional and act surprised when bad things happen to bad people.

[@KASLAN4]

I love someone points this, all Rdr2 players are brainwashed into thinking Micah destroyed the gang from the start when he just took part in it at the end after guarma.

[@Royal_Giant_o7]

In the end it was Dutch and everyone else. Micah just sped it up a bit

[@KASLAN4]

@Royal_Giant_o7 It was the modernization, when you start a new game in Rdr2 thats literally what it first says and in Rdr1 Dutch admits that their time passed and its inevitable but he cant stop fightning against it cause its his nature and thats a "Paradox" so the change of time destroyed the gang and Dutch wasnt willing to disolve the gang before it and putted everyone in danger.

[@Randomeditor1389]

​@@KASLAN4 Dutch once said you can't fight the gravity

[@siredrediii7015]

Micah literally set Dutch up with that job in black water

[@ethanwood6832]

The Blackwater job was Micah and Dutch's idea. I think Micah's plan was to steal the money and ride into the sunset once the gang got away with it. He didn't snitch to the Pinkertons about Blackwater because he wouldn't have been able to get away with the money, or at all without the gang's help.

[@thefallenvalley4340]

Game so good random dialogues can be made cinematic…

[@nwcoastlife]

It’s like Lenny said on the ride to rob the bank in Valentine, “at first I thought it was a bad idea, but then I figured they’re all bad ideas if you think about it, so just roll with it”

[@shadowspirit93]

Whole time he’s like “idk man we got shit up pretty good in that last job but we lived I guess”

[@rndomdude2558]

"Jenny... Mac... Arthur:Ahhahahahaha...,Davey they mattered to me"

[@kalvin187douglas]

True, they are outlaws and usually wanted by multiple towns and states. Running for their lives is known to be a predictable pattern. I wish there was a happy ending where most people survived and actually lived their lives free in Tahiti but I know tradegy and suffering usually attracts the best story writing and audience interest

[@emilianomunozdiaz9494]

0:37 mr bean falling from the spaceship

[@tbar67]

That’s how Arthur respawns after he dies or fails. From everyone else’s perspective.

[@xXSilentAgent47Xx]

He also made great point to Strauss about loan sharking.

[@cesarv2804]

Not y'all falling for Micah's diversion tactic. Lmao. Ofc he wouldn't tell what actually happened.

[@Enno9]

Damm! I like how you turned this into a cutscene

[@proximacentauri2684]

Micah is the only one, except mid-late game Arthur and Sadie, who is honest with himself about what he is. They are killers. Plain and simple. Why they kill is arguably irrelevant. They kill and take what they please.

[@zematic_4881]

0:33 "were vikings"

[@antoniojaimesdepaz8178]

Huh?

[@zematic_4881]

@antoniojaimesdepaz8178 httyd reference

[@gimmeyourrights8292]

Micah knew the reality of the life, everyone else believed Dutch's lofty dreams.

[@jr5343]

It's weird how Micah doesn't make any dark humor or poisonous comments like always, he just say what he thinks and leaves. (damn, they denied Arthur to enter the pearly gates)

[@CyberController-]

Times have changed. Hosea knows it, Arthur learns it, Dutch and Micha ignore it.

[@bobafittness1346]

Mannn, I loveddd dialogues with this dramatic camera. Please do more

[@AXELSZE]

Can you see what happens if you go to the strange man's cabin at 100% complete with Arthur? We re not supposed to be there at that point with Arthur and is Jhon who writes on the diary

[@realQuestion]

yeah, he's right...except that HE was the rat worsening the occupational hazard, right?

[@VoidSoul_Draigon]

Wtf was that!?!?!! That was outta nowhere.. I always knew deep down Arthur was a fallen angel 😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@chrishilton3626]

You don’t know what a fallen angel is do you? Well I can tell you it certainly isn’t good.

[@VoidSoul_Draigon]

@chrishilton3626 Neither was Arthur at the beginning but he turned a new leaf at the end depending on how u play

[@chrishilton3626]

@@VoidSoul_Draigon no he wasn’t. But your answer shows exactly what I’ve just asked. You don’t know what the fallen angel is do you?

[@VoidSoul_Draigon]

@@chrishilton3626 I do know what a Fallen angel is dude.. I was making a joke anyway u don't gotta be annoyin and ruin it

[@chrishilton3626]

@@VoidSoul_Draigon somehow I don’t believe you but fine if you know what one is don’t compare Arthur to one because they are infinitely worse than anything. Any murdering outlaw can be technically I don’t find jokes like that very funny

[@SamP-by7iv]

He would've been right if it wasn't literally his fault.

[@HonorGoose]

I have to disagree because Micah calls the gang bank robber like that’s all they ever do but they also help people in need when they come across it.

[@aidendavies3085]

Love this style of editing!

[@Parley_legend7]

0:40 was so random 😂

[@DamienGGW]

no one was a true outlaw but micah

[@LFPman]

Arthur dropping from the divine skies above is how everyone in camp sees him spying in on their conversations

[@lumin_AU]

Arthur: Where we dropping boys?

[@Fishingonvideogames]

At my sub button

[@Quetzalpugle]

Arthur has made the conclusion that gravity still works

[@rkhale02]

He's not right though. Hosea didn't lose anybody, Dutch and micah did. He kept the gang together for years, so he knows better what the life means.

[@yazidefirenze]

"Damn this is like a cutscene." (arthur falls) "Arthur!'

[@YeeterMcyeeterson]

Freeing Micah from Strawberry is what broke the gang and sealed their fates.

[@geludduk2407]

The way they both went silence for one second is gems and pure artistry there

[@DoubleEditzz]

Arthur just fell out of nowhere 🤣🤣🤣

[@BeefcakeKARS]

Honestly, probably the most realistic depiction of what the gang is. There was no delusion coming from Micah, no matter how much time we spend as Arthur going about the gang, at the end of the day, they truly are people that wronged anyone who wasn't a part of their gang, we feel bad for the bad things that happen to them, but that's because we get attached to them throughout the story. At the end of the day, they might as well be the equivalent of Odriscolls. I mean, how else did Dutch and such got a bounty that large? For what's worth, they are all truly bad people, despite some of them are trying to make a change, they are still killers, thieves, robbers etc. The only "redeeming" quality of the gangs evilness is Jack, who still becomes a fucking outlaw in the future, so yeah. It's truly the matter of perspective, if you are a ordinary folk, Dutch's gang might as well be evil personified if they ever come across your path and probably kill your family in cold blood because Dutch deemed it necessary.

[@steveorsomthing7600]

“…… OK catch you later then.”

[@TalionWolfe]

I love how well the camp interactions are scene played by the actors. Add a little "cinema"💫 and volia indistinguishable from a normal cinematic. Bravo to all involved with rdr2

[@christianjacinto7042]

One of the worst things you can do when in a gang is make a bad call. With how bad that robbery went, all eyes would be on Micha, people wondering if it was a setup.

[@dillicopter2665]

Nice of you to drop in Mr Morgan!

[@alvincampo5811]

I love how dramatic this is and you see Arthur plummeting from the sky in the background

[@phillipwalling7470]

0:38: Brings me back to those cutscene glitches.

[@gabbingabee]

I love how you changed the camera to make it look like a real RDR2 cutscene. Makes it really authentic

[@mickymcfarts5792]

One of those videos I wish I could upvote twice.

[@silashurd3597]

He’s simply a realist

[@Azure029]

this is cool, id love to see all the game's camp conversations in cutscenes like this

[@VEGETABREIFS-b1y]

Occupational Hazard, not very accurate. During that time of history they didn't know those 2 words and especially what each word means.

[@2013TombRaider]

People can talk all they want but guess what it was all Dutch the fact that he kept taking Micah side every single time proves what kind of idiotic leader he was. He had so many chances to change yet he was hell bent to make more and more trouble. A group can have 1000 members with different opinions but a leader needs to make a final call and Dutch always made a bad call despite of multiple people warning him, he ignored all and only listened to Micah.

[@justadudeh3re]

Arthur: *dies* God: "It is not yet your time, go back." Arthur: 0:38

[@odkjqedlkd]

Hosea is an old man just wanting to assure everyone is safe and well before he passes

[@GameTavern2224]

On the one hand Micah is right. Running into law and losing gang members js part of the life but Hosea is also right to be upset about how badly it went. Local law or even state marshals are one thing but the Pinkertons were basically the FBI at this point in history.

[@justadudeh3re]

Arthur: *dies* God: "It is not yet your time, go back." Author: 0:38

[@DarkSeraph95]

A broken clock is right twice a day, that doesn't mean you should set your clock by it.

[@Zghost276]

Crazy how these two would later die in the game. You never know when it’s your time

[@roanmartin1996]

This is why I think Micah was a rat from the very beginning

[@JohnDonovan1968]

Nope that's a delusional lie made by liars with 0 proof to back up. Micah sold out us after Guarma and that's the truth.

It was hard to keep my attention on the rest of the conversation after Arthur fell. I just couldn't stop laughing! 😂

[@fungustheturd4004]

The more I see Micah’s alternative dialogue the more I see him a true outlaw compared to the gang members. Unlike the gang members that are just orphans that turned outlaws, Micah is the third generation of “pure blood” outlaws. Even tho we want the gang to succeed Micah was right that they wouldn’t last because they always stick together and put emotions in front of all when the outlaw life is pure survival and only animals like Micah, Colm and later, Dutch, can survive long in this trade

[@chopper1050]

Hosea is wrong, Dutch is the one making the calls, mica only suggest suggest thonga as all the members in the crew.

[@PrestonWillis]

“Sorry to drop in” - Arthur

[@Kenny1999tra]

Arthur was in the tree listening made a bad call to move 😂😂😂

[@Kenny1999tra]

And no Micah was just a poser, he was playing a part he thought was accurate to how gang members were. He might have had a few points but he is still a pinkertons lapdog

[@jacobleetaylor]

It’s like when firefighters die in fires, it’s a tragedy no doubt but no one made you become a fire fighter (queue all the angry people who are related to firefighters…)

[@metalltitan]

Arthur didn't just fall. Man dropped like a bloody anvil...

[@339gabriel]

Drunk Arthur in the background

[@andrestl7052]

I don't understand how they are making cinematics with the game if it doesn't have recording mode like GTA V or GTA 4, but it's amazing

[@DragonTypeTrainer]

I’d love to hear Dutch’s reaction if he heard Micah talking to Hosea and Arthur the way he did. He might’ve gotten cut loose

[@justin2308]

Dutch’s gang were primarily running on an ideal when they started. When they picked up people like Micah (a realistic outlaw) and Strauss (loanshark), it just hastened what was going to be inevitable lest they change their ways.

[@SuperArppis]

Well, you can do things well, or poorly like Micha did.

[@JosephMcCaskill-s6b]

Jenny, Mac, Davey, they mattered to me. Arthur: ahhhhhhhh

[@Fishingonvideogames]

😢

[@markmyers894]

Dear lord, Arthur was falling at the speed of light.

[@ajayfitnessproductsreviews3265]

Before the blackwater ferry job, Hosea already planned a score. But, Micah got Dutch excited about the blackwater business and everyone followed.

[@Aaron-sx7zf]

Then that's on Dutch, Micah is just doing his job scouting for a score

[@TenzukaRabbit]

"JENNY....MAC...DAVEY!" *[SPLAT]* "Not now, Arthur."

[@speks36]

I see Arthur's up to his player character shenanigans again.

[@WandersALot]

Does anyone else notice how Micah starts breathing heavier when he tries to defend himself from other gang members questioning him?

[@koolaid33]

Micah was correct... I died 257 times in my playthrough of RDR2, dying truly is part of the (video)game.

[@tylerlogsdon8623]

micah didnt want to talk about it because he helped set it up

[@Brad.04]

I actually like micah at first till the 3rd chapter

[@NateGoodnight]

It’s the fact that Micah doesn’t care if anyone dies besides himself