Renovating a 100 year old CAST IRON BATH 🛁 is a challenge | DIY Renovation Project

[@pilsonandrew]

Team Phillip on this one. Black would be so much more elegant

[@shelleymalone4427]

I can’t believe that I’m going with Team Phillip. I think the matte black will give the tub a classic feel.

[@vincentfollezou]

Maybe black will be a better match with black and white floor tile. Team Phillip

[@kylieharrison3782]

🤔

[@maxshuppert9725]

If it is a neutral grey it will take on the colors of the room and the light in it. The color looks green because of the paint color in the room in which it was prepped and the mix of blue window light and yellow-orange work lights. In spite if that, Team Phillipp! (Sorry Anna!)

[@sharonanderson346]

Definitely black!

[@dennispatrick4999]

I like black. But, it's obviously their bathroom.

[@canren4426]

Black to go with the tile and different color feet!😊

[@ThatsJustPeechy]

The quick “Team Phillip” flashing on the screen was so sneaky 😂 I also loved the in-stinks too 😂😂😂😂

[@mmay6621]

The subliminal Team Phillip message 😂

[@kindlydude]

Yep! No doubt that's why Team Phillip got so many votes!! 😂🤣😉

[@405Marlena]

I usually always go with Anna. But, for the first time have to agree with Philip to go with black black.

[@yolandagofigure]

I agree I like black black🖤

[@Ana-Maria-Sierra]

BLACK BLACK! Grey is fashionable now and on its way out of fashion. Black never goes out of fashion.

[@Xaerin]

Grey is a base coat. Grey is what people paint rooms when they want to sell their house so the buyers can imagine their own colours. Black is elegance!

[@jlife9092]

That's such a good point!

[@lolodee3528]

Touches of black against wood looks elegant. Black and white too.

[@jomeyer13]

older people paint white instead of dull gray it is harder to find white syoff as it still looks grayisih

[@susanparker2618]

😆

[@ZL3xtr4]

Shout out to you both for getting the tub upstairs without any casualties. It turned out amazing, well done!

[@Susan.I]

I like black on the outside and white on the inside!

[@Kerrie-AnneBruce]

I was thinking if Philip slips Anna's dead for sure ❤

[@AngelaMerici12]

​@@Kerrie-AnneBruce I was so nervous watching. I think that was dangerous but it turned out well 😂!

[@dianegriffith3006]

Me too what a task! They are Heavy!!!!

[@Sarah1212mm]

DONT TOUCH IT! Leave it as it is. Its ok to NOT have everything matchy matchy! Its deep colour is within the same tonal family. Its a work of art and if it's a slightly different colour and it stands out then that's perfect! What an excellent job. this was so interesting, thank you both and congratulations on heaving that thing up the stairs. 😉👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👍

[@thinkingbout]

Since it is technically a black and a less hard one, which will make the room feel more cozy, I'm Team Anna!

[@TheOneCleanHippy]

The grey black looks great.

[@louiseupton3363]

Wow! Phillip that bath looks stunning. You've done an amazing job 👏👍👌

[@ahhieb1302]

Team Anna ! Ce gris est presque noir mais un vrais noir absorbera trop la lumière je crois.. en vidéo en tout cas, ce gris a l'air de refléchir les couleurs et la lumière ambiante et sera moins dur a l'oeil qu'un noir mate (tout en s'en rapprochant)🌷🌷 j'adore vos vidéos c'est toujours un plaisir de voir ce château rénové avec tant de goût ! 🌻🌻

[@KvG62]

Black. I’ve seen a cast iron bath painted black and it really stood out. Remember the bath is a feature and needs that visual pop.

[@markoconnell804]

It looks good on camera

[@lindabraden7145]

Another vote for Team Phillip! I vote Black Black!

[@janetko2010]

It’s perfect now, please keep like this.

[@kimclenard]

Team Philip on this one. I think the matte black will be stunning with the floors. 👍

[@jackieangove3419]

Anna wins it looks so classy. You should be so proud of yourselves.❤❤

[@diannahill7892]

I like the grey black

[@debbiedebc]

I luv the tub just how it is, but need to see it in the room to decide if it’s right. I also like black, a shiny black...I think it’s classy too. But what you have looks very, very nice!

[@David-jm7mq]

Great job on refinishing the tub. Move the tub into the master bathroom before making the final decision on the color. Observe the tub over several days in the different daylight that comes in the windows, and at night under the bathroom lights. Remember Phillip, Happy Wife! Happy Life!

[@colinbryan333]

Perfectly sensible comment David. All options should be explored before making a final decision. Light will play an important part on the mood and aesthetic you wish to create.

[@karenombler5629]

I like the grey..team Anna 😊

[@joshde4807]

Team Philip, everything is greenish

[@robinmcqueen8874]

I like the grey but seeing it in the bathroom will definitely help you make the final decision.

[@ulrikaholmquist140]

Well done on the bathtub restoration Philip, it looks fab 😊

[@emerk40]

I think the black will go with the bathroom floors better, sorry Anna I agree with Philip

[@melaniejones9576]

Philip’s choice of black gets my vote!👋😊🇨🇦

[@l.k.53]

team philipp! black would look much more timeless and goes better with your tiles 🥰

[@sophieostria9113]

GREY !!!🤩

[@rettaantwine5506]

Black Black!

[@dorothy2770]

Team Phillip for this one 🙂🇨🇦

[@SouthernPioneer1965]

BLACK.. nice shiny black, looks more elegant in my opinion.

[@KimDe05]

I think the Lamp Black looks beautiful. I vote to keep the color.

[@susangyorky2110]

It looks more blackish than grayish. Like a charcoal black. Looks great!

[@patstoughton]

Black is definitely more classy and elegant, especially for a beautiful chateau. But then, I don't have to live with it. Great job, Phillip!!

[@kaystewart2630]

Love the gray! Leave it!

[@Pattyjohnson476]

I think the lamp black looks beautiful! My vote is to keep the color as is.

[@annneusidl5794]

I was impressed before with your DIY, but this Phillip takes the prize. WOW. You can really rock out your projects. 👊🏻👍🏻

[@Burbankelly]

Phillip should get his choice once-in-awhile and this is a good one for him to have that! Plus, I thought the fire plate he brought out was a good color for the floor tiles!

[@carjhb]

Well done! It looks beautiful! Lovely honest portrayal of the previous time, and marriage in general. Your high five with wedding rings on was just perfect.

[@bobbiejay2085]

From what I can see ... Team Philipp. More imposing. Decider will be when it's in the bathroom.

[@paulinebrennan3260]

❤❤❤ team Anna.. grey would be lovely.

[@kerriegreen9057]

Lamp black contrasts beautifully with the wall colour! it's gorgeous

[@unnirenesilen5602]

I agree with Philip you should have painted it black matt on the outside. ❤

[@rosemariedeschenes7013]

Would prefer black black especially with the fixtures you have chosen. Great job on the tub. Can’t believe you got it up the stairs just the two of you. Bravo 👏 🎉😍😘

[@tibisaygarcia8429]

I’d go for black black as well!!!

[@elizabethwezelman8547]

Very impressed that just the two of you managed to get that cast Iron tub up the stairs without extra help and you did a beautiful renovation Philipp. The black and shining white looks excellent together. I loved the opening view of the garden, it looked classy and very elegant. I always enjoy how clean and tidy you are regarding clearing up, to me, that is special. 🏵Well done to you both. 🏵

[@barbaramcmillen1893]

Grey black

[@janinejohnson801]

Team Philipp on this one Black!!

[@knjmoorhouse5093]

I prefer black, too. It will go better with the black and white floor

[@davidlogan8152]

Team Anna, tres chic.

[@billgolcher2537]

Great job i thought the black looked better but your decor is awesome great job

[@namimainuwu]

I think I am Team Philipp this time. The black would look better and seemingly more fitting in my imagination

[@dalentourmexico8530]

I would put the bath inside the bathroom first and then decide, however whatever color you choose will be incredible, congrats on the restoration!!!❤❤😊

[@melissavanrickley7762]

Team Philip and matte black for the win! The dark grey doesn’t pop enough.

[@pamcronje6932]

Team Anna, dead black too cold! Lamp black is a good colour, has some soul!😂❤

[@angelashowalter3069]

Definitely black. It would be classier looking!

[@paulinelogan1400]

Love the gray Black colour much better ❤

[@merlebrown1565]

Philip for the win on this.

[@MarySchlotter]

I agree that lighting and the color of the walls of the room the tub is currently in can change how it may look. So maybe after it’s in the room it is going in you could make the decision? However it looks beautiful! I would be so nervous applying the tub paint. Well done Anna and Philip and of course adorable Ziggy.

[@mariagillinson8527]

Phillip earned getting his way with the colour.

[@lucigzz]

I love the color! I'm Team Anna!

[@LS-vo5lg]

Team Philip! Black looks better!

[@joyceannrunions4127]

WOW WOW WOW !!!!! Beautiful.

[@lylerainger-scott]

Definitely black black. It's much more elegant in my opinion. The restoration looks great though, well done!

[@jo-annephillips3946]

black black !

[@deeash9955]

Team Phillip on this one

[@sandraloughran]

Black most definitely.

[@bethoverby1]

Grey

[@nicarazzi]

Love the grey black. Very elegant and stylish.

[@sandicoppins]

Initially I thought black would be best but the lamp black looks softer and really beautiful. Fabulous result👏👏👏👏

[@itsAna4]

Team Philip this time 🙌

[@sarahjtripodi1514]

I think the gray is good and agree that the walls are reflecting on it.

[@jofromhenley]

Looks great! I’m team Anna 😊

[@patriciablanton6243]

Mat black since you have black and white tiles on the bathroom floor.

[@TeresaOneill-h2m]

Yes, I agree it is best to decide once the bath is in the bathroom. The black floor tiles may have a big impact. Lovely work!! 😊

[@michaelcima5772]

flat black is my vote

[@David-e4l4w]

Grey black is gorgeous!

[@1CelloOne]

Black for the tub 😊 your chateau is beautiful! I think it’s the other way around, women strive for truth, men strive for power. 😁

[@waltercook4868]

Team Anna. Also, Phillip looks healthier. It looks like he is watching his diet and exercising. Keep up the good work!

[@hlu777]

Team Phillip🖤. I'd also paint the feet to match the fixtures in the bathroom i.e. chrome, brass, or whatever you went with, but that's me. It looks beautiful no matter what color you decide.😍

[@lisaholgash2924]

Grey black.

[@joconnor2717]

Black for sure

[@TheasChristmasVillages]

Love the grey, whether there's a greenish cast or not -- Team Anna.

[@madolynway6612]

I like it as is. The gray black is more subtle especially beside the muted colour of the room. Magnificent job. I wondered where you would get the appropriate plumbing when you were removing the old.

[@northwoodfalls1403]

Ok, I don’t know what Phillip is looking at …. Green?!? Lol. On my screen it looks like it has more purple in the undertone. I like it. It’s softer. Black would be too harsh. I went back and looked at the tile in the bathroom and it’s not porcelain so it’s not a true black, either. It’s softer. The variation in the striations of the marble soften it especially as the white tiles are likewise not stark white but softer with striations of grey running through them. I think the colour you chose is lovely, Anna. Although, I do think (as you probably will anyhow) it’s best to wait to decide definitively until you see it in the bathroom. Besides, a stark black is kinda expected. I think the softer black will give the tub the character it deserves to have in that beautiful bathroom. The good thins is that it’s a beautiful tub and Phillip did an excellent job refinishing it, so it will look lovely either way. ❤

[@pennybrashears9676]

Black, Black Team Phillip

[@lucillepommier5834]

Wow you are so creative, it, s beautiful your work, it, s a wonderful chateau, congratulations, and thank to share with us!!! ❤❤❤❤❤

[@deborahdoll4111]

Just as Forest Gump says “ both can be happening at the same time”. Both colours are sophisticated and beautiful. Not a contest but a matter of convenience. The experience of the bath in your exquisite renovation will soothe away any shades of darkness.❤️

[@vfl5211]

Wow, what a stunning restoration - it looks fantastic. The white gloop looks terrifying going on, yet it dries so smooth - amazing! Good job Phillip. I think I'm with Anna on the colour though - black is a little too bold and masculine and modern. But I'd like to reserve judgement till we see it in situ! Either way it will look amazing.

[@MaryseRacine7640]

Black all the way!

[@michelledion8847]

Your guys banter is my favorite part. I so much enjoy watching you guys make this so beautiful. I love your respect for the arts and both of you have such an eye for elegance 🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻

[@LynnBFoster]

The bathtub is gorgeous. Lamp black or dark black either would look nice.

[@lizdillon1277]

Great job Philip, I'm Team Phillip, I think it would pop being black

[@Strocophate]

Definitely Team Anna for this one. At least on my monitor, the tub is a dark blue-grey, which coordinates really well with the other paint colors in your suite.

[@juliajoplin4238]

I think it turned out stunning! I also think the walls makes it look greenish instead of grey/black… It will look great in the bathroom 🛁✨🥰👌🏾

[@ZoePerrault]

I have worked in many ways with colours in many years, … Anna’s choices of colour are always excellent. For this particular project, I agree that black is elegant, classic, chic, etc but when you imagine this bath tub in its final setting black will be a heavy and bold colour that won’t easily blend with other things around it. In this project greyish colours are better! They seem neutral and easily match the setting without disturbing the harmony.

[@jeanmariemclain2836]

Agree. This whole chateau is soft and feminine. The dark gray is a slightly softer hue than black. More complimentary to the subtle femininity. Black-black would be traditional but too strong.

[@stephaniedeegan853]

I love the color. It is different😊