Fake Makita VS Makita TD172D 20V Lithium-Ion Brushless Impact Driver

Which one is more cost-effective

[@thegreatiam316]

For the price difference the cheaper one would be enough for most people.

[@mBaggins]

Honestly for $16 the knock off is suprisingly good for a home DIY tool

[@MichaelGavrilov]

Link store?

[@arls833]

​@@MichaelGavrilovI think Aliexpress

[@user-ak0917faking]

На AliExpress нет таких цен!

[@igorovcharov7424]

@@user-ak0917faking 6 662 ₽ это около 70$

[@Fergiemc]

@@MichaelGavrilovyou can but it on eBay for £16-£25

[@МихаилБаклыков-ъ3з]

Молодцы китайцы, спасибо! Я себе уже заказал.

[@ourclock9273]

IMPRESSED HOW GOOD IS THAT TOOL, 16 DLLS !

[@marcelocarretero2469]

No veo que el Maquita sea 10 veces superior al fake, gana el Rongsheng por lejos en relación calidad/precio.

[@tade769]

Hmm, the thing that intrigues me how can such a tool perform even wholesale at $ 16 and save a living ?

[@Kiskassklan]

I got one on Aliexpress $37.00 total. It has a Makita label on one side but doesn't say Makita on the other only DT172 and Chinese letters and symbols. The chuck works like the real thing and is very fast well built. I'm impressed.

[@LLF1234]

Do you use original makita batteries on them?

[@Kiskassklan]

@LLF1234 Yes

[@Sir-Kay]

@@Kiskassklan How long have you own them now and does it bug down when working on bigger bolts and screws? how much torque do you think they're putting out?

[@Kiskassklan]

@Sir-Kay Not sure about torque but I can tighten down lug nuts with a 4 way wrench and it will take those off easily.

[@Kiskassklan]

@@Sir-Kay I've had that one about 6 months.

[@BB-sm8ey]

I happen to have tried a slightly better knock off, which costs about a sixth of the price of the Makita. Very impressed with the build quality and performance. Really nice little tool.

[@timhankins3436]

Which model did you buy? There's so many out there. Thanks. I've tried the Seesii WH710 impact wrench and it's great. Got it on a sale and with coupon it was $81.00 That's the 900n.m. Plenty enough for me.

[@BB-sm8ey]

@timhankins3436 32€ on Ali Express. No longer listed, sorry. It has become one of my favourite tools though. I've probably got a dozen different sizes Makita drills/screwdrivers but they're always trying to break your wrist when you least expect it. An impact wrench is a great thing.

[@ВилиамРит]

Сначала купил китайскую копию 173, а как попробовал покрутить саморезы то, сразу заказал оригинал 172. Для евробит сделал проставку в патрон, длинна 9.4 мм, но в патроне есть ямка на дне, глубиной 3,5 мм и под диаметр 4,5 мм, с полусферическим дном под носик двухсторонней биты. Проставку сделал из старой биты для импакта, та часть биты что в верху имеет 4 мм, а та часть что к низу так же 4 мм по длине и сточил под диаметр 4,5 мм, на конце, как упор полусфера, а между этими двумя сторонами, верх и низ просто конический переход, какой выйдет. Именно с проставкой с такими размерами можно нормально пользоваться европейскими битами и механизм автомат у патрона работает, Проставка легко из патрона извлекается, только не забывайте обточить фаску на срезе, а то так проставку там просто расклинит в патроне и она там застрянет.

[@alecchi]

Excuse me but 16 dollars on which site can you buy it?

[@kof2604]

不可否認現今的中國工業已經進步很多了 一個低價的工具足以一般使用者使用了! DIY用個幾年就回本了 不用買貴的牧田 ^^

[@raymondtam6148]

我買了个假的磨机404, 电不能用於原廠充電器, 跟机充電, 但好好用.

[@LuisGustavo-g1p]

Palito chino, tenel razón!

[@haajee1]

The Makita is better and stronger constructed. BUT the clone is also very good and look also robust. And it get all done like the original one only it takes some more time. If it's your daily tool maybe a good choice to pay a lot more for the real one. But for sometime use and even with semi-professional use the fake is a good choice i think.

[@QuockhanhPham20]

maybe rewinding the stator may make the Knock off working better

[@ohihoang4446]

Honestly for that price. It meets all needs at work and at home, fake and real products are not much different

[@Николай-н5х5й]

Да не так уж и плох клон за 16 баксов.

[@HAMMER13]

Есть 2 варианта покупки. Если вы хотите красиво, качество и презентабельность на своей раьоте:покупаете оригинал. Но если вам без разницы что написано на этикетке и вы понимаете что на сколько красив не был инструмент , он испортится. То покупайте Китайские инструменты, они дешевле и в эксплуатации почти не уступают оригиналам ни в работе ни в сроке. Пользуюйсь уже 12й год как, за последние 3/4 года Китайцы улучшили качество.

[@Александр-ш4ь2г]

и это какая нафиг презентабельность, когда заказчику глобоко не иниересует чем кто работает - ему как всегда важен результат

[@bbesser1138]

Great video!!! Thank you very much!

[@hunterx405]

I bought a fake Makita Impact driver online for around $60 and I found out it was fake and returned it because the mode select didn't even work, it just has a useless mode button and random indicator lights.

[@AndreasC81]

You also have to consider the build and material quality. The cheaper tool may be good out of the box but how long will it hold up? It might be a good choice for people who want to to lighter jobs and not very often but for people who use it for more heavy duty stuff and on regular basis, there is no alternative to a properly built quality tool. Drop the cheap one a few times or put a serious work load on it and it will die pretty quickly. It’s definitely not for workman’s trade. A Makita would last 10 of these cheap ones. If not more. I saw another comparison video between a cheap impact wrench and a Makita impact wrench. The hammer inside the cheap one was badly worn and the one in the Makita had minimal marks. So it’s also about the quality of the materials that will determine how well it will hold up. If it’s built for the job or not. Cheap knock offs never is. That’s why they’re cheap.

[@ojeanjo]

Man, I've to thank you for this vídeo! Certainly helped me to not buy a fake tool!

[@staceyismine]

Be good to see whats inside of both

[@robertopereira1433]

A Makita com certeza é uma ótima ferramenta, mas pela diferença de preço eu compraria essa falsa porque vejo que ela é muito bem construída

[@suvijakengr3374]

Thanks for the great information and great video.

[@Uriel-vf7hp]

Where can I get clon at that price? Sounds pretty cheap I can not believe it

[@kinficher]

Me gasto un poco más y me compro la original, también no arruino la industria, nacional, comprando Chino gracias

[@EMIRHAN_DEMIREL-d2n]

Orjinal japon üretimi MAKİTA TD173D Aliexpress'deki Sahte çin üretimi MAKİTA TD173D aynı renkte karşılaştırma videosu gelsin lütfen!!!

[@diegoalonsourrearestrepo5403]

Link for to buy the fake one please 😁

[@maximkayarosh2316]

Hello dear sir, can you tell please where did you bought fake Makita ?

[@repairrestoration4232]

You can find it at alibaba.com

[@billykulim5202]

if you are buying cheap chinese clone powertools, recomended to disamble and put more high temp grease on it, the factory default have minimum grease cause the tools to have short life span

[@screw_and_paint]

Question, buy 1 makita or 10 ronsheng, who work longer? Bravo ronsheng

[@repairrestoration4232]

I think Makita is reliable

[@noelarcilla60]

Would be great if you can provide a link where to buy the cheaper impact driver you tested.

[@СерыйВолк-л1д]

good work, thanks!

[@Fallen2536]

For that price is completly OK

[@billykulim5202]

if you are buying cheap chinese clone powertools, recomended to disamble and put more high temp grease on it, the factory default have minimum grease cause the tools to have short life span

[@Fallen2536]

@@billykulim5202 thanks a lot for the advice

[@Chinhnguyen0497]

can you replace the makita clone trigger switch for the better one? the clone has stepped with with only 7 resistor so it can not run at low rpm as the original makita

[@FerSniper]

Лучший, спасибо за потраченное время!!!

[@harritoivonen7478]

it is so funny, to watch people doing work, with bare hands. lol

[@marekskvarek3589]

Super video

[@superpooper_2030]

Add $25-$50 to upgrade cheapo Chinese tools with better battery like Samsung 30Q and could last as long as other branded tools

[@alimughal7258]

Where can i buy this fake one?

[@anonymously241]

China

[@wizardpower4300]

link please for the fake impact

[@repairrestoration4232]

It's only available in China now，I think

[@yeagerxp]

@@repairrestoration4232 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@xaziain]

Nice video🎉

[@tithrepair-Makita-mikaza]

good job pro

[@Bond-uh6yj]

If only using once or twice a year for diy buy the el' cheapo

[@ShaifulislamMajumder]

Fake one is convenient for small use. 🌞

[@layanesilva5934]

A réplica séria segunda linha. Custo benefício

[@ismaelferra3037]

Could you left the rongsheng link, please?

[@repairrestoration4232]

It's only available in China now，I think

[@РустемСадриев-ж2з]

короче , на макиту цена завышена в 5-6 раз , как минимум 🤣

[@anunnak9912]

конечно я на алике взял холмендингер шурик мощная штука руки выворачивает закрутил 30 кв.м пол деревянный 75 ые саморезы штук 800 где зверь просто. 3 дорогих биты сломал а шурику пофик. И гайковерт есть этой же фирмы гайки колесные на уазике на 22 по грязи откручивает и ступичные на 32 на лекговых крутит весь уже в грязи много работал им и пашет еще

[@HAMMER13]

😂😂

[@carrestore]

nice video

[@zuzuzaza6211]

Makita does not have 20 Volt baterries or tools which use that voltage 😉

[@billykulim5202]

have u ever test that with multimeter? its labeled 18v because thats what normal battery voltage, but if the battery at 100% it will read 21/20v. between 60% to 80% it will read 18v

[@МихаЛукин-с1ж]

Внешний вид одинаковый, конструкция одинаковая и принцип работы одинаковый. Но, огромная разница в схемотехнике электрической и электронной части. А именно: У оригинала, используются датчики холла (положения ротора), которые ему позволяют управлять двигателем с высокой точностью, чтоб добиться максимальной отдачи. У копии, используется схема без датчиков, все процессы отслеживаются по проходящему току. Вес молотков, тоже имеет значение. (Не экспериментировал, только теория)Уменьшив количество витков в копии и увеличив их сечение, произойдет увеличение числа оборотов, но и небольшая потеря в мощности. Оставив тоже самое количество витков, но увеличив сечение обмоток - скорость останется прежней, но немного вырастет мощность(на сколько позволяет плата управления, возможно потребуется замена шунта тока)

[@ИгорьМанерко-и3х]

Всë так.. Но качество этой серии китайских импактов кроет всём понятные преимущества оригинала от Макита, как бык овцу. На уровне рынка свойства Макита перестают перевешивать, по крайней мере, в данном случае.

[@네임노-y3c]

What do I need to change to get the torque of the original Makita? Hall sensor? Or a magnet motor?

[@Giovanni-e5r]

Scusami ma a un certo punto dei test utilizzi solo Makita, Makita non ha bisogno di presentazioni tutti sanno che è un marchio più che ottimo. Le viti autofilettanti nell'acciaio ce la fa o no ad aavvitarle l'imitazione di Makita? Nelle altre prove il fake per quel che costa si è difeso più che bene.

[@user-cp7pw4if1e]

Конечно оригинал будет лучше,но никак 10 раз

[@DarkSnake_93]

Я ничего не пойму! Оригинальная макита фиолетовым цветом??? А какой-то ронгшенг сейчас в России под видом макиты что-ли?!?

[@danielgradinaru9656]

Da sunt toate culorile de Makita originale galbena albă verde roșie neagra și roz dacă nu mă înșel caută pe google și găsești

[@Александр-ш4ь2г]

скок же этих наклейков лепят все кому не лень на безымянные тушки...

[@sydsyd2665]

I want one for home job, link to buy please, $16 just skin or skin and battery and charger $16?

[@ohihoang4446]

That price is for buying used. If you buy the same as above, the price will be 20-30 dollars higher

[@cryingeva]

My Makita TD148 10 years until now still working good, china won’t be the last

[@raulduke85]

China costs 10 times less, so if the first knock off won't last as a makita, probably the fifth one will last more and you'll save enough to buy another 5 knockoffs

[@kenlu8657]

I want fake one!

[@giaxlab]

I want one fake for my lab😅

[@donkeykong516]

My money is on the makita replicas

[@aliveandkicking1977]

👍

[@gudzev78]

Нет таких цен 16 баксов

[@TheEmpire2222]

Ты курс рубля видел? 😂😂😂

[@ИгорьМанерко-и3х]

~3000тр с небольшим, всех цветов радуги)

[@binhthanh8756]

Qua VN mua,15$

[@thongtran72]

Ở VN tôi mua với giá $18 cho món đồ fake kia

[@my.epicearth]

help me improve my skills like you

[@Ветер-г5у]

👍🇺🇦

[@rcexcavatortruck6825]

마끼다 너무비싸다 품질은 예전만못하던데 가격이 너무올랐다

[@Utuber-x44]

Don’t buy the RONG one

[@TheWangbolizhong]

😀

[@Jeritude]

that's so rong

[@iamdarwin5739]

Not much of a difference. .

[@billykulim5202]

for business use use original makita, for home use just to fix thing not so often go with fake one, you can buy 7 different powertools with a price of 1 makita impact driver

[@igorovcharov7424]

чушь собачья а не тест! Нормированное нажатие человеческой рукой ну никак не обеспечишь! Тест из репертуара британских учёных!

[@Mettim-h7k]

Problem is which fake makita! I am sure there is lot of fake makita manufacturer. If you buy one according to this useless video, you might get trapped.

[@genaddijborov8979]

Не нужно это бестолковое видео, лучше были предыдущие!

[@amirmaleki3478]

First

[@mdunit2911]

Похоже следующее поколение китайских клонов уже будет превосходить оригинал. С электроникой китайцы разберутся..