Response to 23 Questions - Part 13 - Human Nature (Fitrat) - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi

[@GhamidiCIL]

GET THE APP To Ask Questions and Join Community Discussions! www.ghamidi.org/app

[@ashkehlan4743]

About Professor Javed Ahmed Ghamidi, I not only believe that there is no scholar of his stature profundity of religious thought and precision of its understanding and lucidity of his articulation in the Muslim word, but I also believe that I have yet to see anybody more profound just and humane than Professor Javed Ahmed Ghamidi sahib, when it comes to commentary on social issues including human rights. May Allah bless his countless blessings upon Ghamdi sb! Ameeeeeen. ( USTAAD MOHTARAM MAY YOUR SEED PROSPER GOD WILLING)

[@Bilal_A_K_Niazai]

شُکر اُس رَب کا کہ جس نے مُجھ ناچیز کو استادِ محترم غامدی صاحب جیسی عظیم نعمت سے نوازا! 😍 💕

[@SamAbbasi]

Ghamdi sahab's library is simply gorgeous.. Decent, rich, elegant and also posh.

[@mohiuddinahmadsiddiqui8768]

Jazakallah o khairan. Allah aapko salamat rakkhe aur hum sab ko hidayat ataa kare. Ameen.

[@yahussainmazloom1]

So much respect, Really Great Scholar, aisa banda hamaray mulk m paida kaisay hogia :o خدا اپنی حفظ و امان میں رکھے

[@imgouher2786]

The best thing about ghamdi sahab is that he explains so well God bless you

[@mrlahoria]

Alhamdolilah, we are in the times when we have a Scholar like Ustaad Ghamidi May Allah bless him with the best of health & success in his efforts

[@abubakarmuhammad7006]

Best lecture of the series,. Love for ghamidi sb

[@humanbeing30]

A man with Genius abilities 😎

[@illogical-mind]

Although I find some contradictions in your interpretations viz a viz current human populations are the progenies of prophet Noah's three sons - revert story of Abu Hurairah - etc... However, I must say that you're one of the most authentic islamic scholars ever born in 1200 years of Islamic theology.

[@interinfo3810]

Masha allah very nice .allah aap ko issi tarha eden ki talebem deny ki tofeeq ata fermay .ameen Jnab ilyaas bhai sy darrats ha ,plz swal ky baad bilkul hamoosh raha karain,sunny walon ko acha nai lagta janabb. aap ky alfaz jesy ,theek,achaaaa,hoooon, heeee, hon,hon,hon. plz silent raha karain .thanks

[@GG-ft1bf]

GG (Great Ghamidi). Teacher of teachers. Hero of heroes. Ocean of knowledge. The best philosopher, theologian, educationist, researcher, critical thinker, Mujaddid-e-Islam. Love you Ustad-e-Mohtaram.

[@khalidh.shaikh9018]

ASSALAMUALAIKUM USTAZ E MUHTARAM May ALLAH KAREEM Shower His Countless Blessings on you and your family (Aameen).

[@buttaurangzeb5412]

Javed ghamadi is just love it allah aap ko sehat aur tandrusti day all time great for me I don't think any other better prayer than this prayer allah qabool farmaey aameen aurangzeb butt from Switzerland daska sialkot siranwali ❤

[@chshahidiqbal70]

MashAllah. True student of Islam. Allah ilm mein aur izzafa kare. Changed my lifestyle

[@MrMostNicee]

Something has to be done about the urdu that he speaks. Ii am urdu speaking from lucknow in india , but his urdu is too classic for me to fully understand. It is well to say that i should improve my urdu to his level , but meantime his message is not being followed or understood by most people. He may have to stoop a little to conquer. Even the interviewer is oblivious to this issue.

[@fjs921]

@@MrMostNicee usually he translates the word in English or explains in Urdu when used for the first time in discussion. When a discussion is spanned over few episodes the whoever missed the first episode faces this difficulty.

[@hashmiwable]

Rihan Ahmad : I do not think if someone change is natural style he might not continue. We need to improve and hopefully his followers will spread the message in easy style. Let him continue his work.

[@sabaqureshi8183]

His urdu is mesmerisingly beautiful. Some of us are really enjoying his command on this beautiful language! Try using the English subtitles if it helps!

[@sabaqureshi8183]

MashAllah

[@Abdulhadi-il8om]

Jazak Allah khair bhot khubsurt andaz hai sir ap ka samjane ka Allah ap ko seht o slmti k sath umer e daraaz ata frmaiy ur ap k ilm main mazeed izafa frmaiy Allah hm sb ko qurhan smjne ur aml krne ki tofeeq ata frmaiy ur hm sb ko hdayat de amen ya Rab ul aalmen

[@z.aadvertiser5206]

Allah pak aap ko sahat our tandurstgi ata kare aameen

[@khurammushtaqch]

Ustad Ghamdi sahib baat ker rahay thay aur meray samnay Surah Rehman ghoom rahi thi ... Allah jis per apna fazal ker day ... Great Scholar of this century

[@dr.azharkhan5503]

Ghamdi Sahib has a unique class. Infinite knowledge based on Quran, Sunnah and Hadith

[@ranaakhtar6912]

Best explaination of nature by ustaz Ghamdi.Proud to be student of real scholer.

[@iitorrance285]

This is very deep excellent presentation on Fitrah May Allah swt reward you this is really awesome stuff

[@khawajaimranqaisar3458]

Asalamualikum Ghamidi Sb, Fitrat per app ney bohat achi explanation dee, aik Student key hasiyat sey main fitrat ur Tajurba (Experience) key barey main apney khayalat share karna chahata ho, Insani yaa Kudrat kee paida kee howi poree kainat ka ahata karney key liyeh Insan us key khalik Allah (Wahdaho La Shareekala) key soch ka ahata Nahi kar sakta, magar phir woh hi baat key Allah ney Quran-e-Majeed main Insan ko ghoor karney kee talkeen kee hey. Main Allah kee banai howi fitrat ko Hazrat Adam Alye Salam sey Seekhney kee koshish karta hoo key Jab Allah ney Adam Alye Salam ko takhliq kiya tu woh koi 25 years key Nojawa nahi hongey balkey uss hi bachey key tarha hoin gey jis tarha aj kal key pedaishi bachey hotey hain. Allah Talah agar chahain tu woh 25 year ka Insan bee takhleeq kar saktey the magar Allah Tala key aik Adat Mujey ghuman hoti hey key Allah Tala Fitrat sey haat kar koi kam karna pasand nahi kartey, Phir hazrat Adam Alay Salam key tarbeeyat Parwarish kis ney key ur kaisey, Jaisa key main bata chuka ho key main aik student hoo ur deeni kitaboo ka ziyada knowledge nahi rakhta, Key shayad Allah Tala ney yeh baatain kahi kee hoin. bahar hall phir unko woh baatain sikhain jo woh pahaley nahi jantey they, tu aik baat yeh key Insan main seekhney kee fitrat hoti hey ur Allah ney farmaya aik jaga key aur Adam bhool gaay tu hamney jana key Insani ftrat main bhoolna bee shamil hey, aik Kamal Allah ka fitrat Insan main banatey howy bohat important jhey o main yaha batana chahata hoo woh yeh key, Insan jo fitrat Allah Subhan-Watala ney Hazrat Adam Aley Islam main paida kee woh Inheritance main abtak key haar insan main different tarha waqu paseer howi hey waarna har Insan aik hi adat ur shakal-o- surat ka hota. Baat lambi ho jay gee Allah ney mooqa diya tu phir iss baarey main baat karoin ga.

[@mohi-ud-dintariq7486]

It should be frequently. It's very informative. Better guidance. Jazak Allah

[@naseerahmad-uy3yl]

Allah apko dono jahan main kamyabi atta kare

[@firozsayyed4192]

Assalamu aleikum! I always had these conflicts within self about some of the religious practices we have been preached and we have grown up with! Although I have some issues with understanding Janab Ghamidi sahab's some of the view points, I can certainly feel the resolution of some of the conflicts after listening to Janab Ghamidi sahab! May Allah bless him with long & healthy life!

[@klacontactbackend7710]

Jazzak Allah

[@MAKahsankhan]

These lecture series are indeed superb. What an intellectual teacher Javed Ahmed Ghamidi is!

[@umarp5325]

Wow mashallah ghamidi sahib

[@iitorrance285]

Qur'an 30:30 So devote yourself to the religion of monotheism-the natural instinct, God has instilled in mankind. There is no altering God’s creation. This is the true religion, but most people do not know.

[@ijazulhaq4576]

محترم جناب غامدی صاحب۔ ہمیشہ کی طرح آپ نے بہت ہی خوبصورتی سے علم کے وجود پذیر ہونے کو بصراحت واضح کیا ہے۔ فطرت کی تعریف کی ہے اور یہ کیسے ظہور میں آتی ہے۔ انسان اور حیوانات کسطرح مختلف ہیں ۔ اور اللہ تعالی نے انسانی فطرت کے اندر کونسے داعیہ رکھے ہیں۔ اگر ہو سکے تو اگلی قسط میں توحید اور انسانی فطرت پر بحث ہونی چاہیے۔ کیوں ہماری فطرت ایک خدا کا تقاضا کرتی ہے؟ اور لوگوں نے اس کے خلاف بیشمار خدا کی پوجا و پرستش کیوں شروع کی، اسطرح جو لوگ لا دین ہیں یا ہورہے ہیں، انہوں نے فطرت کو کیسے سمجھا ہے اور ان کے اس انحراف میں بنیادی کمی کہاں واقع ہوئی ہے؟ پچھلی اقساط بھی بہت اعلی تھیں اگرچہ سورت احزاب کی تفہیم و تشریح سے ذہین مطمئن نہیں ہوا۔ کیونکہ ہمارے دین کوسیکھنے کی بنیاد قرآن حکیم اور اس کے اس حکم کو فرسٹ ہینڈ سمجھنے والا افراد کا اسوہ سامنے ہونا چاہئے۔ جو کہ نبی علیہ صلوہ والسلام کی سنت مطہرہ اور صحابہ اکرام کا اس ہر عمل تھا۔ ہاں اگر اجتہاد ہے تو اور بات ہے۔ پھر اس کو اجتہادی پیرائے میں لینا چاہئے۔ نہ کہ دین کی اصل نص سے۔ اللہ تعالی آپ کو جزائے خیر دے۔

[@syedmustjabhaiderbukhari2728]

Genius man of this era ⭐

[@HomeGardening212]

Asalam o Aleikum, I love to watch Ghamdhi​ sahib's explanations on various aiterazats and in first two topics he has justified them beautifully and satisfactory As topic 3 is linked with the first two topics which also relate to NATURE(fitrat) of human beings ! I got the impression that Ghamdi sahib thinks that human nature is to go towards normality and positivity ! While Humans and Jins are the only creatures who were given AQAL E SALEEM by Allah tallah and we have found that both tend to go towards negativity i have a few examples and hope Ghamdi sahib can clear my thougts on that ! RELIGEOUS EXAMPLES 1- Shaitaan refusing sajda to Adam A.S 2- Adam and Hawwa A.S ate the forbidden fruit. 3- First murder of mankind habeel and qabeel EXAMPLES FROM LIFE 1- death represents negativity...since our birth we tend to die ! but we survive and sometimes we just don't so its in our nature to go for death. 2- dirtyness represents negativity when we are born we pee , pooh, vommit and if the family doesnt clean up we would be th dirtiest people in the world .. . so human nature is to stay dirty as long as it can 3- when children are given an option to do good and bad thing and we let them choose...why 99% choose the bad things ? touching a hot pot,,,eating soil, peeing on bed, etc etc bottomline...human nature is to go towards destruction amd negativity so when we put this destructive nature of humans into the interpretitions of Quran about HIJAB the intrepretition doesn't fit.. so the question is How to eliminate the destructive nature of human beings ? and if we cannot eliminate this nature then how would we explain the HIJAB verses thanks a lot ..hoping to hear the answer in coming videos a great series indeed...a,lot to learn from it and very unbiased approach 2- ​

[@sheikhwishakh6383]

From where did you get the inference that death and dirty things represent negativity. These views are philosophical and strictly challengeable. And who told you that 99 percent of children go for bad things? Children do things because it is in their nature to experiment and to think the use for things.

[@mohammadalisoomro6127]

Also if we look at a child, it's there curiosity to touch and eat things that make him eat and touch things that he shouldn't. But after he touches for example a hot pot and realizes that destruction it causes, he avoids it totally! And similarly eating soil, when he understands that when he became sick, eating soil was the reason, he avoids it.

[@mohammadalisoomro6127]

Even if we go to those remote isolated from the world islands of Papua new guinea, we still don't see people there puddling in their urine or feces or vomit. They still don't eat poisonous things, once they understand it's poisoned. So all these are indications that there is something that a human is being sent with

[@mohammedtoufiq-lk7wt]

,, محترم جناب غامدی صاحب بہت خوب بہت اعلی بحث کی میء علماء سے پوچھنا چاہتا ہوں آپ لوگ اتنے بڑے عالم سے اختلاف کرتے ہوۓ تمھیں اپنے اندر حیا محسوس نہیں ہوتی یار آپ علماء کو غامدی صاحب سے علم حاصل کرنے کی بہت ضرورت ہے کمال کے صاحب علم ہیں غامدی صاحب ماشاء اللہ بہت عمدہ سبحان االلہ

[@inamkohli8545]

❤️❤️❤️🌺🌺🌺🌺Love. from Kashmir

[@afnanaltaf6020]

I'm waiting for the day when #Ghamidi sb will be laying foundation in Sweden and Scandinavian countries

[@afnanaltaf6020]

I mean his institutions will be founded here one day in sha Allah, I pray for that with all my heart 😇😍

[@fjs921]

@@afnanaltaf6020 start a circle of like minded people even if a handful and start listening to his lectures either Al-Bayan or Mizan. It will grow automatically.

[@shaziasaher3557]

Jazakallah sir for great explanation

[@scholarwrites2077]

Ghamidi shb you are great asset for us

[@trashidamparastidamshikast4389]

bhai ek sath record karke uplod kardo. Cant wait for next one.

[@shakir-baba5114]

Speechless ❤️

[@explorermominnorway3119]

subhanAllah what an amazing deep strength of knowledge. May Allah bless you ustadh. Aameen ❤️

[@Aasifkhan-np3qm]

Jazāk Allāhu Khayran

[@mahalam2391]

Assalamo Alaikum. I am from capital city of India by name New Delhi

[@Homoeopathicore]

Indirectly Ghamidi Sahab Explained many concepts of homoeopathy...

[@MrMostNicee]

Great in communication. Find his dissertation on most subjects to be truly great. But why does he hav so few followers.

[@fjs921]

Level & language...

[@farooq6315]

غا مدی صاحب جیسا مفکر عالم اسلام نے آج تک نھیں دیکھا۔ غامدی صاحب میری نظر میں آپ اسلام کے اصل داعی اور 1400 سو سال کے سب سے بہترین مجدد ہیں۔ ایک وقت آئے گا جب عالم اسلام آپ کی خدمات سے مستفید ھوگا اور آپ کی شان میں قصیدے لکھے گا لیکن کاش آج کا مسلمان آپ کی شخصیت اور غیر معمولی علم سے استفادہ کرتے ہوئے اپنی آخرت بہتر بنا لے اور اصل اسلام کی روح کو سمجھے۔ لیکن مستقبل قریب میں ایسا ہونا ممکن نظر نہیں آتا کیونکہ آج کا مسلمان ایک رٹا رٹایا روبوٹ بن کر رہ چکا ہے جن کو علم اور عقل سے کوئ لینا دینا نہیں ہے۔

[@hashmiwable]

Well said brother.

[@muhammadsajidjavedkhan7577]

Agreed by 100%

[@mansoorahmad1489]

This discussion needs an International Panel. I am amazed how a single guy sitting in a small room dissecting the very basics of the Origin of the human conscience. This discussion needs a much bigger platform.

[@muhammadnabeel6622]

One and only Ghamidi sahab the best teacher in the world alhamdulillah

[@younisaminy2427]

Gamidi sahib speak the truth mash Alah

[@ridudragneel219]

Explain so beautifully 👌

[@SaqibAli-1989]

Jazakallah

[@shahruk115]

Ghamdi Sahab is living legend

[@ranaabdulhanan1992]

ہم خوش نصیب ہیں کہ اردو کے علیم مفكر ہمارے لیے موجود ہے۔

[@illogical-mind]

I'm also waiting....

[@shaistazuberi7835]

Best scholar nowadays ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@asadniazi7031]

Kash k Pakistani.qoum ap jesy scholar.ki.qadar krti

[@qasimjahangir5308]

Great teacher sir ghamidy❤❤❤

[@user-ie1qm1wj6p]

Thanks for update

[@KhuramShahzad-n2z]

Great scholar mashah Allah

[@afzalrahman2053]

JANAB GHAMDI SAHEB, ONE OF THE GREAT SCHOLAR OF OUR TIME. AAP KI FIKR KO SAMAJHNE KE LIYE HIGH LEVEL KI YRDU DARKAAR HAI. EK ORDINARY AADMI AAP KI SPEECH KO SAMAJHNA BAHUT MUSHKIL HAI. PLEASE AAP APNI SPEECH AASAN URDU MEIN BAYAN KAREIN TO LOG SAMAJH PAYENGAY. ENGLISH TRANSLATION BEHTAREEN HAI, JAZAKALLAH.

[@GhamidiCIL]

Please post any questions you have to ask.ghamidi.org/

[@MuhammadNadeem-zb8bz]

Mashallah jee

[@haSHAH1]

A true intellectual!!!

[@booksbrains1249]

What a knowledge this man has ......❤

[@asififtekhar1411]

The discussion on the topic was quite analytical and intellectual, however seems to be fairly difficult for a common Muslim to understand. I think such complex cum intellectual topics may not be chosen because it's of no use to explain such academically dry subject to average humans. In my view focus should be on core issues which are misleading the Muslim ummah to get real dividends. Otherwise, people will lose genuine interest. Thanks for such a wonderful brief.

[@riffatayaz7970]

Assalam o. Alaikum..

[@qurantafseerbymrsadnan2837]

Aslamoalakum ghamdi sahib alhamdolilah

[@Khan-70]

The amount of difficult words of Urdu used in this video is insane! In the previous 12 parts of the series , the urdu was very hard and difficult to understand at some points but in this part , I cant understand a single sentence lol. Please someone tell ghamidi sahab , that us pakistanis cant understand such high level Urdu , I know its shameful that we cant understand our own language but its the truth. Next time when you say a difficult Urdu word , also say its english translation too side by side , so that we can understand.

[@efazsiddiqi454]

yay ali we need to do our homework also, i know the vocabulary he uses for intellectuals. We can look into dictionaries and next time it wont be difficult. Inshallha

[@fjs921]

Musha-hidah = observation Is-tiq-raa = repetitions (of observation) Is-tim-baat = inference

[@fayyazkhan4428]

Many A time, I thought of translating him in American English idiom, but seeing the plethora of his work and time constraint, I just hesitate to undertake such a daunting task. Can we identify a few volunteers who could help in this endeavor?

[@ro0o0my]

He is simply telling the four steps of scientific method of study, observation, hypothesis, experiment, conclusion

[@fjs921]

@@fayyazkhan4428 if we can create a dictionary of his frequently used words it should suffice for common Urdu speaking person. Urdu to Urdu to Roman Urdu to English. It should not be mor than a couple of hundred words, terms.

[@TheOsmanSafdar]

This discussion would have been more beneficial if difficult urdu words were avoided.

[@TheOsmanSafdar]

Also the discussion could've been better organised with more specific points rather than a general broad discussion.

[@sohrabkhan1186]

Aap chahy ghamidi sahib k nataaij sy ittefaq kary ya k ikhtelaaf, ye baat to atal hy k inho ny mazhab ko jazbaat sy maawara ho kr bator e ilm awaam k saamny bayaan kiya.

[@skyhawk9429]

Jazak ALLAH khair 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰 25 / AUG/ 24. ❤😍❤

[@fatimazahra8226]

Ghamdi sb please Aam faham zabaan me lecturer diya karen .

[@asf8246]

God give supernatural minde he is Superman

[@gmwani691]

نگہ بلند سخن دلنواز !

[@aqibbashir1986]

what's the English word for mutakhayyla?

[@faisalhameed3200]

Imagination

[@imranahmad360]

Imagination

[@shayanarif1718]

I think it means the power of imagination

[@greybeard9396]

Look it up in Google Translate!!! You can either type or speak the word.

[@fatimazahra8226]

Istikra????

[@sanwalyarbutt3530]

Sir Mera question irrelevant ha sorry, wasq kis measurement ka naam ha jis pr zakat hiti ha, aj k dour mn??

[@hassanrajput9576]

22:33

[@o56_idress_ahmed_ee32]

💓💓

[@MazzayKaro]

اسلام علیکم ۔۔ معزز بھائی کیا مجھے غامدی صاحب کی کتاب المیزان مہیا کی جا سکتی ہے۔میں کتاب خریدنے سے قاصر ہوں۔ آپ ایک تحفہ دیجئے علم میں برکت کیلئے۔میں آپکا مشکور ہوں گا۔

[@esolpk]

آپ غامدی ایپ ڈاون لوڈ کر لیں۔ وہاں سب کچھ مل جائے گا۔

[@sidrakanwal2126]

Ap google pe ja k i think download kr skte hn

[@asf8246]

One man Army 💪👌 💯💯💪👌

[@BabuKhan-ov8yd]

Bht mushkil topic ha 😥

[@HafizMatiullahofficial]

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@mfarooqumar]

گفتگو کا عنوان تو انسانی فطرت کا دین کی بنیاد بننا ہے۔ مگر انہوں نے انسان کا علم بنانے کے عمل کو بتایا ہے۔ علم بنانے کے عمل کو ہم فطرت کیونکر کہ رہے ہیں ؟ پھر اس انسانی علم بنانے کے عمل میں نقص رہ جاتا ہے تو اسے ہم دین کی بنیاد کیسے کہیں گے؟

[@syedmustjabhaiderbukhari2728]

اس قسط میں صرف فطرت کو سمجھایا گیا ہے اور بتایا گیا ہے کہ انسان علم کیسے بناتا ہے۔ اگلی اقساط ملاحظہ فرمائیں سب کچھ واضح ہو جاۓ گا۔

[@mohammadmughal7211]

غامدی صاحب آپ شکاگو کب آ رہے ہیں

[@BeHumanWithOutBorders]

Janwaroon kozibah kerna khanay kay liay hanari fitrat me shamil nahi per apni khoraak k liay esa kerna parrta hai? Is baray me ghamidi shahb ka kiya khyal hai?

[@fjs921]

From ancient times humans are doing this. How can we say this is not in the fitrat? Observation, experiment & inference all are consistent in this.

[@BeHumanWithOutBorders]

Fahad Javaid Siddiqui fitrat woh hoti hai jis ko kernay ka dil chahay, ancient time say log majboori me khataya rahay hen q k humay esa hi banaya gaya hai, hamara system meat digest ker sakta hai. Nera question ye tha k humay be jaan chezen khanay wala q na banaya gaya? Jesay k plants pani dhoob oxygen urea etc per zinda hen?

[@adilkhan352]

Aik lafz b samjh nai aya. Hasan bhai topic py rhain Fitrat ki behas topic nai hy

[@KMdiscovery]

کوئی مولوی یہ اردو ہی سمجھ کر بتا دے اس طرح کی گفتگو کرنا تو دور کی بات، میں اس مولوی کو اسلام پیش کروں گا۔ اللہ تعالٰی جاوید احمد غامدی صاحب پر اپنی رحمتیں نازل فرمائے آمین۔ ہمارا دین بے عقلی یا صرف قصے کہانیوں پر مبنی نہیں ہے بلکہ وہ دلیل سے، علم سے، حکمت سے، حقیقت پر مبنی عقلی دلائل سے ثابت ہوتا ہے۔ آج سے پہلے ہمیں مولویوں نے کہا کہ دین میں غوروفکر نہیں کرنا چاہیے بلکہ اس کو بنا کسی دلیل کے مسلمان ہونے کے ناطے جوں کا توں مان لینا چاہیے۔ اور یہاں تک کہا گیا کہ قرآن کو اگر تم اکیلے پڑھنا چاہو گے تو دین کے راستے سے بھٹک جاو گے۔ اور ہم سب یہ ہی مانتے آے کہ شاید ایسا ہی ہے۔ لیکن اللہ نے جب کسی کو ہدایت دینی ہوتی ہے تو وہ خود اس کے سامان پیدا کر دیتا ہے، اللہ استاد محترم جناب جاوید احمد غامدی صاحب کی ہر ممکن مدد فراہم تاکہ وہ تیرے دین کی صحیح خدمت کر سکیں۔ آمین

[@mohdtariquekhan1372]

Is tmam guftgu ko samajhne ke liye mukammal urdu zuban pahle seekhni padegi 😒

[@Khan-70]

Same , ghamidi sahab , mirza ghalib ke zamany ki urdu bolte hain :D ek lafz samjh nai ata

[@fatimazahra8226]

Bilkul sahi .... mirza ghalib ke zamane ki urdu 👍😀

[@farooqcheema467]

Kia Mr. Ghamdi sb non-political islam per believe rakhtay hain????

[@hashmiwable]

I think so. He does not believe in political Islam.

[@madeehasaeed786]

If by political Islam you mean Islamic expansion, occupation of non Muslim countries and lands, the enslavement of non Muslims in those lands and turning those people into 2nd and 3rd class citizens in their very own countries, the taking of female sex slaves from those you occupy and from anyone you declare as being non Muslim etc, the reestablishment of the institution of slavery and the denial of the right of people to choose their own governments in their very own countries, the destruction of all Muslim countries on the basis that the only legitimate state is the Caliphate state and as such all Muslim countries are therefore deemed to be illegitimate necessitating their systematic destruction and replacement by only one state called obviously the Caliphate, the only legitimate state that there could be, meaning all fifty Muslim countries have no right to exist, meaning there should only be one state of the Muslims in the world, if this is political Islam then without a doubt Mr Ghamidi not only does not believe in it but would reject it as a gross and ugly distortion of Islam, and that would be my humble opinion too.

[@mohammadhakim4161]

اللہ رب العزت غامدیت سے محفوظ رکھے(جو آدمی قرآن کی آیت اور حدیث کا اپنی سمجھ بوجھ سے بیان کرے اور اس بات کا صحابہ کرام کا عمل نہ ھو )تو یہ تشریح ذاتی ھے جو دین نہیں ھوتا

[@arifaslam9879]

دلیل قرآن و سنت سے دے رہیں ہیں ۔ ذاتی کیا چیز ہوتی ہے ۔ وضاحت کرنا پسند کریں گے ؟

[@arifaslam9879]

دلیل قرآن و سنت سے دے رہیں ہیں ۔ ذاتی کیا چیز ہوتی ہے ۔ وضاحت کرنا پسند کریں گے ؟

[@aylinnoor9890]

یہ کونسی اردو ہے جو غامدی صاحب بول رہے ہیں۔ یہ اردو تو ہم نے اسکول و کالجز میں نہیں پڑھی۔ بار بار سننے کے باوجود بہت کم سمجھ آیا ہے۔ انشااللہ غامدی صاحب کو سنتے سنتے اردو اچھی ہوجائے گی۔

[@wasifhassan7]

Urdu heavy h ni samjh ara kuch b

[@fjs921]

یہ صرف اردو نہیں ہے، بلکہ دینی اصطلاحات بھی ہیں جو غامدی صاحب نیا عنوان شروع کرنے کے بعد ابتدا میں اکثر بتا دیتے ہیں.

[@sanwalyarbutt3530]

Is ki rawayt bukhari mn ha

[@qudsiatabassum2394]

Difficult talk