Response to 23 Questions - Part 29 - Return of Jesus ( Nazul e Massih (A.S) - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi

[@GhamidiCIL]

GET THE APP To Ask Questions and Join Community Discussions! www.ghamidi.org/app

[@aliabbasi697]

Kindly convert these videos to podcasts.

[@hafizbutt8485]

اسلام وعلیکم استاد جی اللہ پاک اپکو صحت والی لمبی زندگی عطا فرمائے آمین آپ نے جو مسلم کی روایت 2897 بتائی ھے اسکا اسلام،360 میں نمبر غلط ھے براے مہربانی اسلام 360 کے مطابق نمبر بتائیں بہت شکریہ میرے پاس اسلام 360 ھےظ اللہ پاک اپکو خوش رکھے آمین

[@YusufKhan-ip5wf]

السلام علیکم Mulim hadith no7278 Int no 2897

[@AhmedRaza-gq3je]

غامدی صاحب کو چاہئے کہ اپنے خلاف 23 اعتراضات کے جوابات پر مستمل ایک مکمل کتاب لکھیں۔ جس طرح انہوں نے اپنی کتاب میزان لکھی ہے جس میں پورا دین بیان کیا گیا ہے۔

[@zaheerstates9895]

Please contact me with Javid Ghamdi.

[@r.mtubafathima4717]

بسم اللہ الرحمن الرحیم اللہ تعالی غامدی صاحب کو دنیاں و اخرت میں عافیت میں رکھے امین

[@muneebkhan7465]

These types of Questions always used to creep in my mind but the traditional ulema's stagnant interpretations always disappointed me.But Ghamidi sahab's visionary and Intellectual explaination came as an ice cutter... Thanks a lot for doing this much needed task...👌 Respect from Indian Occupied Kashmir

[@clippers9059]

I’d suggest reading Mirza ghulam Ahmad for further research.

[@adma7298]

@@clippers9059 mirza ghulam admed was sunni and believed upon all hadith of nazool e masih. He took all indication of masih and approved himself from Tashbeehat and Ista'ara. He declared himself masih e mo,ud ( promised masaiha). He did not believed that Essa masih died and taken up. He surely accepted other believe that he was alived and taken up amd return back. He only claimed He himself is that masaiha. Please check your claim, wrongly attributed to Ghamidi sahab.

[@SZAS1978]

@Saqimations no, he isn’t a crap but an excellent and honorable researcher of his time. FYI he was a great scholar, a true student and follower of Alama Iqbal and a sincere helper to Quaid e Azam. Allama Iqbal himself introduced him to Quaid. After freedom he was maligned by the Mullahs because of his liberal and scientific views and interpretations of Islam. He never wavered in spite of insults and name calling just like what is happening to Ghamidi sb from conservative mullahs.

[@lifegamerpro4033]

@@SZAS1978 isn't it really laughing situation while people wasting time in history and future instead of focusing on "present" yes history n future always push people in ultra comfort zone orthodox ulema and so called modern libral ulema give stress on historical events or future events... 😃😃😃 ...i don't know when till what time Allah ji will keep arrest under past n future... As formula Allah ji won't help until unless self help .. jabtak ummat past aur mustaqbil ki haseen wadioun se nikal kar ASR e hazir ko na sudhar le jab tak ulema moghal osmania Alan falan kay qisse deeni qidmat ki tarah sajaa tay jayeingay....

[@sanaullahkhan9097]

Very thorough and analytical

[@iamfaisalsiddique]

کوئی کچھ نہیں کہنا ہمیں۔ صرف ایک ہی بات۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔ "شکریہ غامدی صاحب"

[@back2basicsezard404]

Yaqeenan ALLAH ES BANDE KO JAZAY-E-KHAIR ATA KARE...

[@adma7298]

آمین

[@efazsiddiqi454]

Mashallha, he literally give us treasure of knowledge to discuss with other Muslims about this topic. I’m lucky to understand Urdu.

[@baigsulenan1571]

Such hi Haq he

[@mohammedalam1649]

No words to appreciate Ghamdi Sir. Allah unko salamat rakhe with full sehat and wisdom.

[@arifaslam9879]

غامدی صاحب ! اللّه آپ کے علم میں اور اضافہ فرمائے۔ آپ کا وجود ہمارے لئے خدا کا تحفہ ہے 🌹

[@mehmoodkhokhar]

Aisa Alam is waqt Pakistan main koi nahi. God Bless him always.

[@extraorchidinary6347]

Alam to bohot bura hai tubhi aise alim ko pakistan chhorrna parra.

[@adnanqureshi761]

@@extraorchidinary6347 pakistaniyon k liye fakhar ka muqam sirf wohi aalim hain jo awaam ki khawahishaat k tarjumaan, aqal sy farigh aur shiddat pasand hain.

[@mohdshafi6044]

Wo bhi Pakistan se hi hai

[@adma7298]

فرقہ پرست مولویوں نے مسلمانوں کو جاہل اور تقسیم کر دیا ہے

[@rehanahmed6370]

Every lecture is an eye Opening. God Bless you sir.

[@awaisjaved1402]

We Can differ from Ghaamdii Sahb on his opinion, but There is no Doubt that he is teaching us the way how to Investigate and Analyse. Thank you Soo Much Ghaamdi Sahb We love you 💙

[@minhajkhan7172]

I am speechless....whatta living legend.....Sir you nailed it.

[@muhammadsajidjavedkhan1252]

Real respect & Regard for Ghamidi Sahab

[@lON734]

MashaAllah may Allah SAW increase our knowledge about ISLAM Amin

[@Historelic]

استاد محترم غامدی صاحب کو اللہ تعالیٰ صحت اور تندرستی کے ساتھ لمبی زندگی عطاء فرمائے۔ اللہ تعالیٰ دین کے لئے ان کی کی گئی محنت قبول فرمائے اور ہر طالب حق کو اس سے آشنائی دے۔

[@geoschool5533]

استادِ محترم جناب جاوید احمد غامدی صاحب کی خدمت میں میرا سلام

[@hassanraza-tt5ob]

The thing is that Sir. Ghamidi has no ambiguity in his thoughts,,he is very clear in every aspect of religious perceptions,,his way of conveying the reality and convincing others is out of this world. He is really a blessing to us from ALLAH

[@khanjehangir60]

Mashallah. Allah Ghamdi sahib ko lambi or tandrust zindagi day. I haven't seen any Islamic scholar like him.

[@masaabsoha]

Beshak Sir per Allah ka khaas karam hai...Allah aap ko lambi umer de. Jub aap boltey hain tu video Rokne ka dil nahi Chahata🌺🌹🌷🌸💐

[@naqash353]

غامدی‌صاحب اللہ تعالٰی آپ کو دنیا اور آخرت کی خوشیاں عطاء فرمائے 🤲🤲 جس طرح اپ نے دین اور دنیا کا علم ہم تک پہنچائیا ہے... وه اپنی مثال اپ ہے. هم اپ کے شکر گزار ہیں... کہ اپ نے دین کو اور قران و سنت کو اس کی صحیح اور اسان شکل میں هم تک پهنچانے کی کوشش کی... الله پاک اپ کی کوششوں کو قبول فرمائے...اور همیں سیدھے راستے پر چلنے اور رھنے کی توفیق دے. امین

[@189bhalli]

Alhamdulilah for sending us Ghamdi. Allah has not given up on us

[@adnanqureshi761]

This lecture really cleared my confusion about this topic... Respected Ghamidi sb taught us the right way to investigate through riwayaat.

[@adnankhan4143]

Food for thought... MashaAllah very well explained..

[@back2basicsezard404]

Sir aap ki baat samjhne k liye waqeetan insan ko apne deen ko samjhne ka ShawQ chahiye....love u sir...

[@WaqarAhmad-sy1uq]

غامدی کا جواب کسی کے ہاس نہیں سوائے فتووں کے جزاک اللہ خیرا ، بے شمار اشکال رفع کر دئیے ، کاش ہم اللہ کے دین کو سمجھنے کی کوشش کریڻ

[@junaidakhter]

دنیا علاجِ زخمِ جگر کب کا کرچکی ہم انتظارِ فیضِ مسیحیٰ میں رہ گئے

[@adma7298]

نبوت ختم ۔ آپ کے بعد کسی نے نہیں آنا

[@AftabAlam-vl4iz]

It was eye opening, you're the best mentor. Thank a lot for conducting such informative videos.

[@abdullahbhatti543]

جزاک اللہ خیرا - اللہ آپ کو صحت کے ساتھ لمبی عمر دے آمین

[@ihsanahmedwains]

Ghamidi Sahib spent at least 20 percent of the entire time clearing his position for the expected backlash. It is so sad that people like him have to do it.

[@asad-kc8zf]

The reason is we muslims, vast majority are not well educated.

[@adma7298]

And adamant on ignorance. ابا ، علماء ، امام پرستی کو ترک کرنا ھو گی

[@zangbaar1]

Exactly...he repeat his position again and again for people to use reason and do not judge blindly..

[@kubrab2617]

No brother...infact its a good sign that muslims dont belive blindly for their religion..

[@baghi536]

uski wajah jesa k Ghamidi Sahab ne khud bataya k hmare so called Musalmano men ilmi zauq or students wala attitude nahi hai. Tanqeed or tabsaray ki adat nahi hai bs propaganda krte hn kuch alfaz ka chunao kr k.

[@autoparts3592]

even how is it humanly possible to have this much research in depth ? Masha Allah, Ghamidi sahab, jakak Allah

[@NaushadShafkat]

Masha'Allah! This is absolutely brilliant! Mind boggling. Ghamidi Sahab is just amazing.

[@abdullahkamalzai5817]

Loveu Ghamdi saab Allah apko duniya akhrat me apne rehmato or barkato me rakhe Ameen

[@AbdulHameed-bw4cg]

جس کی آنکھیں کھلنی ہوں وہ کھل جائیں گی اور جن کو نہ کھلنا ہو وہ نہ کھل سکیں گی کبھی۔

[@fazalhakeem1910]

Aap na bilkul sahi farmaya... Ghaamdi sb ...

[@muhammadaslamjavaidmalik3708]

Each and every lecture delivered by Ustaad e Mohtaram bestow after every repetition. Whenever any one listens the lecture , gets more and more knowledge and research goes on peak. May Allah bless Ghamdi sb with sound health!

[@Onionfumes2024]

Javed Ahmad Ghamidi sahib is the most profound, brilliant and erudite scholar of Islam. It is indeed an honour to be able to listen to him. He has unparalleled intelligence, knowledge and understanding of the religious text with unmatched lucidity of communication and expression.

[@yasiralikhan7616]

Bhai mai pagal ho jaunga is aadmi ke ilm se. Just unbelievable. Unbelievable. Allah salamat rakhe. Subhanallah subhanallah.

[@ChoudhryMuhammed]

Zindabad Ghamidi Sahib. Allah Jaza day aapko Aameen.

[@faranrazi3902]

We are truly blessed to have such a scholar in the form of Ghamidi Sahab who takes an extensive research-based and a deeply systematic approach while considering each and every aspect of our religion... And I consider myself extremely fortunate to be blessed with an acumen to listen, understand, and appreciate the conceptual religious thought presented by Ghamidi Sahab...

[@badspinbowling]

Absolutely fantastic. I wish other ulema had the same approach towards research and communication

[@aabishamber6728]

Apny to aankhein khol di hmari God bless u much more

[@fawukhan]

Was waiting for this part eagerly

[@abidrahman3869]

Allah apko salmat rakay ameen

[@Umerkhan2.0]

Javed ahmed ghmaidi, thank you Rasool ALLAH (SAW) K apny jo is gumrahi k dur me sahe introduction kia hain usky liye ap k hamesha shurkar guzar raho ga. Ustad-e-Muhratam ALLAH SWT ap ko us hamesha rehny wali dunya ma awla mukam diye 😘

[@JavedAkhtar-vs5wz]

Alhamdulillah Very Very clear Jazak ALLAH khairan

[@madmax5756]

JazakAllah ustaz, Allah apky ilm men meazeed izafa kary👍❤

[@shahzebkhan8774]

MasaALLAH ! Amazing research ! JazakALLAH

[@mjawadhaque9832]

Awesome..may Allah guide us all..ameen

[@zaheerahmed9549]

Great information. Thanks a lot for your great efforts to have these brilliant videos.

[@am1475gr8]

JAK .ITS INVALUABLE source of knowledge. Please make this topic so comprehensive that it covers all angles and criticisms on the subject once and for all.

[@AhmedRaza-gq3je]

اس میں کوئی شک نہیں کہ غامدی صاحب نے دین کو افسانوں اور کہانیوں سے نکال کر تحقیق کا موضوع بنا دیا ہے۔

[@hafeezullahbutt2071]

محترم غامدی صاحب سلام ھے آپ کی تحقیق اور حقیقت کو واضح کرنے کے لیے ۔ اللہ تعالیٰ آپ کو اجر عظیم عطا فرمائے ۔

[@IrfanAhmad-en1cs]

MashaAllah Ghamidi sab for in lightning us. May Allah reward you in dunia and Akhirah. Ameen

[@azeemsarfarazlexicon101]

Alhamdolillah. Ladies n gentlemen. Wait is over. What a cliffhanger it was, the last episode.

[@heisenbergkhan7951]

Bhai your comments making it a thriller though I am watching it when all episodes are available but back at that time when this episode wasn't uploaded or streamed yet those chills and thrill I can feeling

[@muhammadshakir5452]

Tassali karwa ke jaaeyn gay Ustad e Mohtaram.

[@baghi536]

JazakAllah khair Ustaz Ghamidi Sahab, thank you for making this clear.

[@muhammadtalha199]

Amazing ♥️♥️😭 What an intellectual justification. Hat's off to you Man ♥️♥️♥️😭 May Allah bless You😍

[@awaisjaved1402]

Ghaamdi Sahb is Not doubting the Saying of Prophet (SAW). He is Just investigating, Analysing and raising some questions on the narration which is *ATTRIBUTED* to To Prophet SAW. * AGAIN* HE IS NOT RAISING QUESTIONS ON WHAT PROPHET(SAW) said, He is just raising questions on the authenticity of Narration. Please understand the Difference between these two things

[@upquark31415]

Thank you for putting it crisply. Although it's a no brainer, still you will find people saying "Ghamidi Sb rejects authority of hadith". Their problem is that they neither understand the rich critical appraisal of our tradition, nor do they realize the nuanced approach towards navigating the primary texts. I call them binary-brains, they just need someone to fill them up with a string of yes or no answers.

[@adnanqureshi761]

I am 100% agree with you 👍

[@ashkehlan4743]

You explain it clearly to clear narrow minded people

[@nayeem.ahmad1987]

Yes absolutely. People are misunderstanding the matter

[@qasimjahangir5308]

Thanks ostaaz muhtaram

[@buttaurangzeb5412]

Javed ghamadi is just love it allah aap ko sehat aur tandrusti day all time great for me I don't think any other better prayer than this prayer allah qabool farmaey aameen aurangzeb butt from Switzerland daska sialkot siranwali ❤ ♥

[@Thecontrarian-l3h]

An eye opening analysis.

[@kamranhashmi009]

My curiosity has immensely increased

[@NSNCNB]

Brilliant and outstanding and incredibly deep understanding of these confusing things. Thanks Ghamidi Sb May Allah bless you and your family here and in the hereafter. 💓💓🌷💓💓🌷💓🌷💓🌷💓🌷🌷💓💓💓🌷

[@zohaibali1358]

Behtreen explanation di ha inho ne kash ye gali k mullah bhi kuch ishi tarah logo ko explain kren asal islami talimat ko

[@karachiboy45]

such a deep reserach remarkable

[@rashideng1234]

Great Analysis of Hadees of Sahih Muslim.

[@muhammad9428]

بہت خوب،،، عظیم استاذ محترم

[@novelnomad1230]

Any AUDIO, if any, should get extinct. What an analysis! An ocean of knowledge & wisdom. May Allah Bless you, Sir ji.

[@ziasatti7260]

Couldn't understand your statement " any audio should got extinct?? Plz elaborate

[@m_masud1086]

what i can not argue about here is that the research and knowledge about deen cant never be ended specially those matters of deen which have not came to us through tawatur and inconceivable sources. May Allah guide us all.

[@ilayatshah9079]

Jazakallah Ghamdi sir and also credit goes to the person who is asking questions. Mashaallah

[@ashkehlan4743]

I not only believe that there is no scholar of his stature profundity of religious thought and precision of its understanding and lucidity of his articulation in the Muslim word, but I also believe that I have yet to see anybody more profound just and humane than Professor Javed Ghamidi sahib, when it comes to commentary on social issues including human rights. (MAY HIS SEED PROSPER GOD WILLING)

[@GG-ft1bf]

I am coping your comment in Ghamidi Sir lectures. I hope you don't mind.

[@Norjahan307]

MashaAllah Salamat Rahe Ghamidi Sahab May Allah bless u ❤❤❤❤

[@muhammadumerhanif6572]

Shukar ha nxt part aagya is video ka , shadeed w8 k bd

[@areedkhalid6549]

Im speechless MASHALLAH.

[@youngvynz2229]

OMG ghamdi Sahab I have no words literally the way you explain and the amount of knowledge you have you left me speechless literally

[@MarkhorTech]

These videos of Ghamidi sb are priceless

[@joeblack2230]

Jazakumullah. Jino ne nahi maanana uno ne nahi maanana. They will remain in self denial.

[@farzanakhan3587]

Awesome eye opener Amazing

[@KaleemIqbalravian]

Ghamidi sb ki mehnat aur research qabil e qadr hai aur un k samnay kuch kehna bht bari jasarat hai ... lekin agar Muslim ki hadith ko sahi tasleem kr lia jae to Allah k liay baqi kamon main se koi aik kam bhi mushkil nahi na hi koi hesiat rkhta hai .. k hathyar khatam hojaen aur Roomion ka ghalba hojae ... Allah k liay asan hai ..

[@shafiurrahman797]

Ghamidi sahib great

[@achakzaibrothers3601]

i have No words

[@imtiyazkhan930]

Allah aap ko slamat rakhe

[@deen-e-quranaursunnatdawwa8917]

May Allah give him good health and long life

[@firozsayyed4192]

SubhanAllah!

[@muhammadasifkhan2296]

Mashallah ghamdi sahab allah pak app ko hamary saro pay salamat rakhy ameen ta k app hamari rahnumai kar saky ameen allah pak app k ilm o umar sehat aur iman may barkat ata farmay ameen

[@farzanakhan3587]

A great scholar

[@zafarkhan-oh3rf]

MashaAllah..what a conclusive proof deduced..

[@umarrandhawa5381]

It is my request to anchor to please ask ghamdi sb regarding how the concert of return of jesus came into Christians because they adopted this narrative at large

[@hamzakhan7495]

Ghamdi sb the great ... wish we had more religious minds like him ... Bless you Sir

[@zkkhan1529]

میرے نا چیز کی رائے ہے، کہ انسان کی موت قریب تر ہے بجائے قیامت سے، کیا میں نے موت کے آنے سے پہلے بخسیت مسلمان اس مختصر سی زندگی میں اس ابدی زندگی کے لئے کیا کچھ کیا روزانہ کی بنیاد پر، اپنی ذات، یا دین اسلام کے لیے، کیا ہم وقت اجل تک ان باعسوں میں الجھتے رہ کر اپنی زندگی کا مقصد پورا کر ینگے،

[@MuhammadKamran-te1hd]

Masha Allah, nicely explained

[@darkbright1662]

Most logical scholar I know of ❤️

[@Bayqaeda]

Anchor's acha'aaaa is Supreme than the lecture even

[@shaikhmehmoodjilani2115]

MashaAllah kibat ustad ji.

[@maqboolhashmi2619]

Such a great scholer

[@umarbhatti5663]

Brilliant as usual

[@malik_e]

We seem to have become accustomed to living bifurcated lives. We will blindly follow 'conventional religious wisdom' that includes all sorts of stories which have become increasingly unrelateble to the day and age we live in with its massive stock of knowledge accumulated over the centuries. Yet, when faced with the challenges of daily existence or in our attempts to realise our wordly ambitions, we exhibit total pragmatism and realism because we know success and progress dictate that attitude. Ghamidi sahib is peerless in showing how this dualism can be removed. The spirit of deen is intelligent not dogmatic. JazakAllah o Khair.

[@explorehongkong1149]

He is such a brilliant scholar ...other scholars should listen to him...

[@rafayulabad6813]

سورہ النساء کی آیت نمبر 156/157 کی وضاحت کر دیں جس میں کہاگیا ہے کہ کوئی اہل کتاب نہیں ہو گا جو موت سے پہلے حضرت عیسیٰ علیہ السلام پر ایمان نہ لے آئے

[@omarabbas5613]

وَ اِنۡ مِّنۡ اَہۡلِ الۡکِتٰبِ اِلَّا لَیُؤۡمِنَنَّ بِہٖ قَبۡلَ مَوۡتِہٖ ۚ وَ یَوۡمَ الۡقِیٰمَۃِ یَکُوۡنُ عَلَیۡہِمۡ شَہِیۡدًا ﴿۱۵۹﴾ۚ (یہ اِن کے جرائم ہیں، اِس لیے اب قرآن کے سوا یہ براہ راست آسمان سے اتری ہوئی کسی کتاب کا مطالبہ کر رہے ہیں تو اِن کی پروانہ کرو، اے پیغمبر)، اِن اہل کتاب میں سے ہر ایک اپنی موت سے پہلے لازماًاِسی (قرآن) پر یقین کر لے گا [237] اور قیامت کے دن یہ اِن پر گواہی دے [238] گا۔

[@muhammadArshad-tt5tu]

Very well explained in light of traditions. But to say logically what use of Esa coming back alive from sky near the end of world or closer to doomsday when trillions of people would have died on a wrong faith that Christ was crucified for their sin why not Esa might come much earlier to save the trillions of people from adopting a wrong faith about him. The fact is that in the holy Quran hazarat Esa forecasted that after him a prophet will come named AHMED so when he may come you accept his prophethood. So quite obviously after Muhammad pbuh no one is coming Esa or Mehdi. ALL are fabricated stories and Quranic scholars like Gamidi sahib are those ones who are at the right side. May Allah bless Gamidi sahib with good health and a long life to lead people to the right path.

[@drkanwalkhan1521]

Yes our prophet PBUH IS LAST Prophet.. no one will come now.

[@WAMTRADER]

استاد صاحب اللہ تعالی آپ کی عمر دراز کریں۔

[@YusufKhan-ip5wf]

جزاک اللّٰه