Reverend Reacts: To One of the Saddest Song Ever, Hurt by Johnny Cash

[@SolaMelodica]

Thanks for joining me today! FYI, I've had some (ahem) suggestions to turn the music down a bit. I'm still working through my backlog of videos but soon that recommendation will be in place. Soon, very soon!

[@MrClobbertime]

The music sound level is fine but I can hardly hear what you say when you stop it to talk even with moving up the volume slider.

[@p.j.morris633]

Trent said i was born to write it....Johnny was born to sing it. He went on to say this is NOT my song anymore it's Johnny's. I go to Uncle Johnny's grave once a month there is nothing more humbling than standing in the presence of greatness. R.I.P. Uncle

[@maribethspence9458]

Personally it wasn't the volume of the song as much as the unevenly matched the volume of you talking and the song was. I had to turn the volume up to hear you and the volume down for the song...not that I wouldn't like to blast the song. I've been a Johnny Cash fan since I was very little and though this one makes me cry when I hear it in combination with the video and having read both of his autobiographies, loved his tv show and seem most of his movies I know many of the scenes in this video and where they are. Like much of the video was filmed in the old House of Cash museum, which had been closed to the public for many years because the public had lost interest for awhile there in the 80's. So the place was run down and in poor condition. There was even a gold record that had fallen on the floor and was shattered. Anyway yeah it was like this song was written for John.

[@tyzmar2782]

I'm a grown man and cry everytime I see this video. God bless you.

[@ThaOneChrisJONES]

I was also a single child to a single mom.. lost her two years ago to breast cancer. An irreplaceable piece of me is gone because admittedly, I'm a "moma's boy" and for better or worse, she wasn't strict enough with me ( as she had problems of her own, depression etc.. ) but with all the problems I had as a kid ( trouble maker in school, I stole money from her, got caught stealing a game from a store which she had to find out about while at work but she never gave up on me. In my later years I had overcome those issues but had them replaced with different, perhaps more intense issues ( anxiety, depression ) and it's been well over a decade where there isn't at least a moment in every day where I have thoughts about "ending it". When I hear this song.. I can't imagine living a long life full of loss and regret like Johnny when at 35 I have a mountain of regrets and scars already.

[@tonyd.944]

Love to see how music affects people. This song is definitely one of the most emotional out there.

[@SolaMelodica]

right in the feels.

[@vibingwithvinyl]

This song, especially coupled with the video, always brings tears to my eyes. It's such an emotional rollercoaster. I think it takes some age for the listener to be able to really appreciate the message. Johnny is reflecting back on his life, the empire he built, and comes to the realisation that it's all meaningless. The only things that truly matter in life are friends, family and love.

[@SolaMelodica]

yep.

[@LostMyMojo100]

Very well said!!!!

[@1221tesla]

Love this song both versions of it. One of the coolest things is how Trent Raznor said this was Johnny’s song now. Johnny went out the only way Johnny could...his way. Not a huge country fan but love Mr. Cash. If this doesn’t hit you in the feels, you ain’t alive And if it’s to loud then they are two old!! I saw turn it up!!

[@SolaMelodica]

thanks for the audio support! :)

[@tomtaft2274]

I believe Johnny used this as his personal song of repentance, especially during the final crescendo as he lamented his deepest regrets. In this final scene I saw his "sweetest friend" as Jesus. Extremely powerful. God's grace truly is amazing.

[@crimsondraak3024]

Hits the chest area right in the feels

[@SolaMelodica]

definitely.

[@duncansbuddy]

As a human being, the most impactful thing I have ever heard and viewed, and I am not especially a Cash fan. It amazes how this video affects ppl in different ways mostly depending on ppls age, this is an emotional masterpiece.. Johnny Cash is the only artist to be inducted into the Rock, Country, and Gospel Halls of Fame. Sorry for your family issues, you seemed to have handled them well. Thanks for sharing.!

[@Sherrodja]

A very deep song. Unfortunately some of us have lived it.

[@SolaMelodica]

Yup.

[@jKLa]

Yes this was my one of my mom's favorite songs and she lived it! I feel I am living it myself, trying to find a better path while respecting and building on the past. But I am struggling, -I love deeply but I really haven't done so good in much of my life. I've been hurt badly but also loved deeply and really hurt some people. God save us, God forgive us of our inequities, our sins, our unpayable depts, in Jesus' name!

[@stephaniedescoteaux4759]

Regret and contrition and warning. This legend lays it all out for us.

[@roguemerlin1969]

This was the last thing Johnny did. His wife, his rock, passed away shortly after this was released and he followed shortly after her. That was June standing on the stairs looking down at him in the video.

[@SolaMelodica]

What a life story they had.

[@MizCriz46]

The fact is that he had a 1st wife that he treated like shit while June looked the other way. Listen to Roseanne tell that story on Ken Burns miniseries "Country Music". I hope & pray that regret for that is a big part of what he's saying here.

[@EberHampton]

Dear Reverend, I so appreciate the strength expressed in your tears of empathy and honestly to identify with sorrow, pain, and regret. And, I respectfully ask you to prayerfully reconsider the doctrine of infant depravity. Most, if not all of us suffer some struggle between what we espouse and what we do. A doctrine of inherent depravity may be some kind of explanation but there might be a better one involving epigenetics and toxic cultures. I actually really hope some theologian has handled this. A really nice lady told me Jesus loved me and was knocking on the door of my heart. That if I asked him in, he would come in and help me. I did, he did. That was about 74 years ago. In the 60s I told him I was going to stop calling myself a Cristian because I just couldn't believe the part about french frying people in hell because they didn't believe the exact right thing. Asked him to let me know if I was making a mistake. Spent about ten years making regrets. Could've been worse. Told him i needed help. Near as I can tell he didn't care what I called myself, he was better at forgiving me than I was. Made me want to try to be a kinder more helpful better person myself. Had a stroke a year ago May. Recoverd, stepped out the kitchen door to see a beautiful spring sunrise. Told him, "if I wake up dead some morning and turns out you were a rubber crutch I'm going to be pissed. I imagine we both laughed. Actually, I can't help believing that we both laughed. Thanks Rev for inspiration and space to speak. I do appreciate the other comments and am curious what anybody may think of mine.

[@JP-jm9fy]

I’ve listened to this song many times. Much has happened throughout my life to reflect on and I suppose that’s why I love this song so much. I have seen suffering by many people. I was one of them and at times it lead me to question Gods purpose. After a long look in the mirror one day I realized I didn’t like who was looking back at me and it was then I realized Gods purpose isn’t the same for everyone. Many of us suffer through many means be it addiction or the kind of pain that hurts but it’s through the pain that we learn of Gods love. To many of us have lost sight of that. My hope is one day many more will look in the mirror as I did and ask what did I do to make my life and others lives better? Did I love God as much as he loved me?

[@SolaMelodica]

even Jesus learned through suffering. It's not fun and I wish there was another way but sometimes that's what gets our attention. thanks for sharing, JP.

[@briancunningham594]

The best reaction and analysis of the meaning deep within in this torturous, but beautiful song. God bless from 🇬🇧

[@xbeaker]

I am not a religious person, but I enjoyed your reaction. This song is so well written that not only can the singer change it's meaning, but so can the listener. When Trent Reznor wrote this song he was writing about his addiction to drugs. Battling against it, and wondering if the drugs are all he really is. Could he have been someone else without that addiction? He says "If I were born again, a millions miles away. I would keep myself. I would find a way." So no matter his circumstances, even if he were not a music star, he would still have been a junkie. That is who he is. When Johnny Cash sings it I hear a different version. A man with regrets is reflecting on his life. He is at a point where nothing matters to him, but reflections of what he was has a comforting pain to it. The song paints regret for things he could have done better, but pride in who he is. "...I would keep myself...". And at the end, (Johnny recorded this just months before his death as a fare well to family and fans) what more can we hope for than to be who we are, but wish we could have done a little bit better too. You brought a whole different view. I'm glad this spoke to you in your own way.

[@elisamcgowan4774]

Very deep reaction, thank you for it!.

[@aintnoreason1480]

It’s a whole different song than NIH. And I can barely watch it. I cannot even watch it without crying. Four years ago we did a genealogy and I have a whole side of the family with the last Cash but never thought bu yes he is a relative or was. He was so talented and he had many gifts and people don’t know very much about him. He was an author, an ordained minister, was in the service, lost his closest brother to a horrible accident at the age of 12. He even helped dig his brothers grave which is heartbreaking he was addicted arrested and then found in june Carter. Thank God for her. i don’t think he wanted to live without her. I don’t think he could

[@SolaMelodica]

Both are well done. Yes, Mr. Cash had difficult life that beautifully tells a story of redemption. There is hope for us all.

[@brianc96]

When Trent Reznor heard Johnny's version he said "I realize this is no longer my song"

[@williamcrouch1321]

Such a deep emotional song for me...So much I could say about this song..my life and grew up listening to Johnny before evolving to rock,prog. rock metal,growing up going to church..Going through the motions of trying to turn it all over to Christ in my 40's but still struggle every day with what life throws at me and bad choices I make still at 54..I so agree with you about music..something that has always deeply effected me and now try to help share/promote up and coming mainly younger bands that are very talented and have deep meaningful songs like the band Motion Device..I consider myself a Christian but have never fit in or conformed to any religious sect etc..Loved your reaction and on the spiritual end seem very approachable which is something I rarely feel with anyone..i'm subscribing

[@SolaMelodica]

Thank you for the kind words. Not sure if Johnny really said this or not but I've heard that he said, "Christianity is not for sissies." It's not always easy. Hang tough and lean on the grace of God!

[@Wiskerthefif]

"You are someone else... I am still right here" is about feelings of being stuck and depressed, as though you haven't lived up to the expectations of society, your family, or maybe yourself, etc. I feel this is true because it ties into the general theme about regret present in this song, and especially with the last few lyrics about starting again.

[@SolaMelodica]

Excellent - thanks for the contribution!

[@philfoster8789]

From what I know, Johnny found that "Way", "Sola"; I'm not fearful for his eternal destiny. (It's just that... the pain of life's regrets still cut deep with him.) God bless, Phil

[@lisamayreed6399]

God bless you for this work...powerful. I'm a believer and I love all genres and it's refreshing to find a preacher who is able to dive into music most will not touch. Ty and God bless your work abundantly. Ty.

[@SolaMelodica]

Thank you Lisa that is very kind of you. Your gratitude is really appreciated. At times it can be quite challenging on both sides. Some believers think I've lost my mind and some others think I'm crazy as well...

[@mikes.6751]

Love your reaction. As Paul says “there’s no one who does good no not one.” “ the heart is deceitful above all things but who can know it?” Jerm 17:9

[@SolaMelodica]

Yup, those are two solid ones.

[@jonofwndlnjn]

Yes we must share in this hurt, thank you for sharing your emotions with us.

[@SolaMelodica]

Life can be brutal and none of us escape without at least some pain. thanks for listening and checking in.

[@rebeccajohnson8769]

All of the momento mori images in the video - the feel of a 17th C still life with all of the death symbolism - really gets me too.

[@wackyvorlon]

Interestingly the “crown of thorns” reference is actually a change made by Johnny Cash. The origin lyric was “crown of shit”. I think Johnny Cash’s version is dramatically better honestly.

[@SolaMelodica]

I wasn't aware of that tidbit.

[@brianc96]

Well the nin version was supposed to show how far removed from gods grace he was.

[@kathybeall3986]

Your reaction out of the many I watched, was probably the best. Thank you for the biblical explanation, not all appreciate it but I sure do. Hope Johnny Cash was saved at the end 🙏🏼

[@FlippyHambone]

Beautiful reaction and analysis.

[@macielmelo5391]

Hi. I'm a pastor too. Presbyterian Church of Brazil. It's amazing how this song fits with Psalm 88. Very good your channel! God bless you.

[@SolaMelodica]

I will need to re-read Psalm 88. Thank you, Pastor. Blessings!!

[@mkwilson1394]

I really love your message. These videos are a gift as well!

[@SolaMelodica]

That's very kind of you! Thanks!!

[@aintnoreason1480]

“I would keep myself“ wow does that one hit close to home.

[@SolaMelodica]

Agreed - me too.

[@97warlock]

You mentioned about your dad & calling them, making the move,take innitiative .... My dad got in a bad accident just as i TURNED 18 & HE WAS MENTALLY DRUNK , i WAS YOUNG & STUPID , THE SPACE WE HAD BETWEEN US GOT EVEN FURTHER THE LONGER i STAYED GONE, ... when I got into my 40s I kept getting these thoughts of how can I fix this,then Id forget about it due to no solution,didnt have the words of know how ..... years go by , still dont know how to fix our loss of communication,when Id see him it was 2 quik words a litt;e smile & the rest Id be talking to my mom, because I knew I couldnt get on his level & accepted that we were too far apart to reconnect ...... years go by, the feeling of wanting or wioching I could fix things someohow came along more regularly & after not knowing how to fix it Id disregard the idea, Till later. .Thats what i did, put it off,till later. aS LONG AS HE KNEW i WAS ALIVE & OK & i KNEW HE WAS ALIVE & OK, i PUT IT OFF TILL LATER, . in 2018 My mom called me crying,never heard her cry . - My dad had passed away the night before . - T FIRST IT WAS SHOCK SURPRISE , BUT AS THE MONTHS GO ON, THE HEAVY REGRET & PURE STUPIDITY ON MY PART NEVER DISSAPEARS FOR LONG. - SORRY FOR THE CAPLS LOK , - wHAT THIS GUY SAID IN THE VIDEO- MAKE THE MOVE,TAKE THE INIATIVE, CLOSE THAT GAP & CLEAR THE AIR & FIX THINGS BECAUSE SOMETIMES WITHOUT WARNING, THE DOOR WILL CLOSE ON THAT PERSON & YOU WILL NEVER SEEN THEM AGAIN. Id probably do the same stupidsh*t again if I had to do it over , .. but because of it, All I have is 8 pictures of me & him when I was a little kid.

[@the-jevster]

The part where he starts pouring the cup on the table is the part that breaks me every time, without fail.

[@bryanc6235]

I don't think this song is about regret, I think it is about acceptance. I think this is an extremely rare moment/gift where we can see a tortured soul accept his life for what it was as he prepares for for death. Regret is for those who still have life left to live.

[@DanaClarkDana]

I feel like the Holy Spirit sometimes moves of its own accord through music unintended and unbeknownst to performers (e.g. pink floyd) and this is another case - with that remarkable series of collaborations spanning time (Reznor, Rubin, Cash and all others involved).

[@John3_16Q]

I love your message in the end

[@grassrootsflshp]

Can't hold back the tears, it's the story of my life too (sans the "empire" part coz i've got none, but all "dirt" lol). The inclusion of the imageries of Jesus at the cross made it even more poignant, giving the song and the tragedies and absurdities of Johnny's (and most everyone's) life the needed context and redemptive conclusion.

[@jKLa]

Mine as well. This song makes me cry!

[@webdev3r]

Best reaction and best explanation. Looking at the video, when Jesus is shown and the nails are piercing his hands, Johnny says "I will make you hurt". I'm sure he is also referring to the fact that the way he lived his life when young was indeed hurting the people around and the Lord Jesus. This is like his repenting message -- his last message. He wished he could lived differently by finding "The Way, The Truth and The Life" earlier in his life. There is another great short image where the trophies are put side by side with an icon of Jesus Christ, and Johnny saying "my empire of dirt" -- all his trophies = dirt, Jesus is the "treasure". Very powerful imagery. The video together with the sound track is an art masterpiece that touches the heart and soul and makes me think every time to what's really valuable. God bless Trent Reznor the original author, Rick Rubin the producer and Mark Romanek the director -- awesome job!

[@SolaMelodica]

I agree - the song video combo are painfully brilliant. thank you!

[@jiveAt5]

Song feels like the rapture, I lost so meny close friends and family, this cuts deep to the bone.

[@SolaMelodica]

It's definitely painful.

[@rorykostman4447]

Every single time I hear this song, or watch the video, I lose it. Like a switch. first time, hundredth time. Its an apt metaphor for the tragic situation of mankind. Lonely, imperfect and bereft of hope without Christ.

[@SolaMelodica]

waterworks for sure.

[@thomastreece6773]

As a more progressive Christian, I truly can't handle this continued message of being born into sin. Innocent babies are born in God's image. God's image is pure. "Sin" or evil/imperfection comes from this world we are born into. I don't think God intended for us to believe "innocent" children to be considered the same as adults. Jesus not only said that "unless (we) become like little children, (we) cannot enter the kingdom of heaven"... but, He also added, “If anyone causes one of these little ones-those who believe in me-to stumble, it would be better for them to have a large millstone hung around their neck and to be drowned in the depths of the sea." I know your theology is different, but I wanted to point out this is a major claim (born into sin), and it causes much undo suffering. However, Christians can take comfort in the Bible as Jesus had a different message to impart.

[@geneaikenii1092]

amen, brother

[@arlanandrews9946]

Every one of my sins was another blow of the hammer on a nail. I indulged without thought; He felt the pain.

[@SolaMelodica]

Wow, thanks for sharing Arian.

[@mikenicolay2483]

He sang this shorty after his wife, June, who was the love of his life, died and he died shortly after this.

[@aquamarine0023]

Touching reaction and touching words to this haunting song. Johnny did an exquisite cover of this powerful song. Trent Reznor singing it live is incredible, as is a live version with Trent and David Bowie performing it which is simply amazing. Could you please do a reaction to "Nutshell" by Alice in Chains (The MTV Unplugged version, as it's even better than the studio version.) In case you're not already familiar with it, it's a deep song reflecting Layne Staley's struggle with addiction (a battle he ended up losing) and feeling trapped by his life in the spotlight.

[@SolaMelodica]

Thank you. I wasn't aware that Bowie and Reznor did one together. Interesting. I will definitely add the Alice In Chains song to the list. I probably will do an entire series of videos on songs about addiction. There is a ton of great music covering that aspect of humanity.

[@Real_McPhee]

Hey there Rev! I just came across your channel and really dig it so far. Perhaps a unique perspective as both a music lover and an atheist. Definitely appreciate the way you approach reviews. Regarding this episode: Trent, who is uber protective of his music, said “This song is no longer mine”. Wow! What hits me the hardest is time. NIN version is a young person who has time to change the course of their life, at least attempt to repair the damage. In the Cash version, the regret is final…there is no chance or hope to fix any of it. The toll age takes on a person’s voice cannot be faked. The fact Johnny Cash died about 7 months after this video was made is almost prophetic. Sorry for the long post. Keep up the great content, sir! Rock on! #ImNotCryingYoureCrying (ok, we both are)

[@SolaMelodica]

Johnny does it quite well. That's quite the compliment, right.

[@Lamm139]

I think Trent Reznor wrote it for Johnny Cash. He just didn't know it in the first place. 😀 When I heard this song for the first time I couldn't stop crying. Made me repent from my sins. And listening to it for the 20th time (appoximately) it made me feel happy and excited. Why? Because I realized that he happily hops into that train at the climax of the song. He leaves all the worldy things and worries behind to start new. I think this can have two meanings: Firstly, he knows that he's going to die soon and he's going on his last ride to Jesus now. Secondly, for those who will be longer on this earth than he himself: There is a way to redemption. We can all hop into the (gospel) train and start a new life. Oh, I wrote this comment before watching the video. This video is filled with so much symbolism. As you stopped it I realized that when Johnny is on the train in the beginning of the video he is the locomotive driver. I thought of us humans - me included - living our lives without God's guidance, thinking we know it all and we don't need him. Later he jumps into the train with only his guitar (for me it's our gifts we got from God). He goes wherever the train will lead him to and wherever the train will stop. I feel that God is telling me this right now by this song.

[@SolaMelodica]

thoughtful comment. thanks!

[@kristopherwood7521]

When people talk about the "inhumanity of man" I cringe a bit. The most human thing we do is fail, rebel, hurt people. Cash absolutely made that song hid own. God bless you and keep you, brother!

[@SolaMelodica]

Interesting take. I am going to ponder your first two sentences. Not sure I understand yet...thank you!

[@buckismith]

Thank you for sharing Jesus. 😄

[@shootermav11]

very nice job in incorporating the gospel message, with this song..

[@SolaMelodica]

Thank you! Nice to know that it was noticed. Most of my comments are about headphones these days! Blessings!!!

[@khalben6]

Also in case you didn't know the full background of this song already June, who is the wife you see in the clip died a couple of weeks after turning it, Johnny cash died 3 weeks later, and their daughter died a month later, the song takes a new meaning afterwards once you know these facts

[@SolaMelodica]

Oh my. I was not aware of those details.

[@hauoleguyify]

Based on the final imagery, it seems the price paid for his sins is what haunted him the most.

[@jamesohara4295]

My sweetest friend is my Kinsman Redeemer :)

[@SolaMelodica]

That might be the first reference to the book of Ruth on this channel, thanks!

[@joannbrooks9410]

johnny cash died 4 months after his wife june shortly after making this

[@lextek.]

Your comments are spot on. Silly question, but did you notice Jesus being nailed to the cross in several of the quick edits? I'm sure you did. When Trent Reznor heard this track he said "This is Johnny's song now".

[@SolaMelodica]

Yes. those scenes are gut-wrenching.

[@Silent-yp2sj]

Hi, here’s a hug!! Thought you might need one.

[@SolaMelodica]

Aww, thank you. Tough song!

[@riffhard7605]

Right now this song and Tom MacDonald's Churches are the soundtracks for my life right now. Be Safe. Love and Peace.

[@SolaMelodica]

thank you, Amber. Grace to you.

[@regnadkcin6702]

Johnny Cash was deeply religious, in his last interview before he died, he said that he was never angry at God, for his entire life, and never doubted that God was there.

[@wesselvidge5070]

Amen

[@SolaMelodica]

Yes, amen.

[@mikenicolay2483]

You might want to see this video, Glen Cambell when he was told that he had Alzheimer's. He was saying goodbye to his family and friends, while he still could: kzbin.info/www/bejne/r6OsiGiIpdt1pK8

[@mikesmicroshop4385]

Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails said that this is not my song anymore it's Johnny's!

[@dianeritthaler7792]

Great reaction. Im a Christian

[@terrybrennan425]

Johnny changed the lyric "I wear this crown of shit" to "I wear this crown of thorns"

[@amyyeasley5189]

As we get older it takes on a different meaning.

[@SolaMelodica]

definitely!

[@jonathanwobesky9507]

He finally sings: "I will keep myself. I will find a way." Obviously, this is about reincarnation and the determination that next time he won't fall for the glamor and legend of his commercial persona. His "empire of dirt". Which in this life he succumbed to to great detriment.

[@SolaMelodica]

Obviously? Perhaps, that's what the author had in mind. Or it could be that none of what we attain on this side of eternity matters.

[@jonathanwobesky9507]

just kidding on the "obviously". after studying J Cash's astrological chart, I believe that he was doing a masterful job acting in this song (he an artist foremost and this gave him a chance to be heard once more in the 21st century, long after his museum (in the video) had gone to dust...) and he really knew, had a sense where he was going on to. A person who was seeing and living spirit all along

[@jonathanwobesky9507]

@@SolaMelodica ps none of what we attain (on this side) matters, perhaps, In The Way We Think It Does. I don't think actual, subtle beyond words "spiritual growth" is "lost" upon translation from this plane (death). I'm sure the awareness was there all along. Maybe that's the reunion JCash (enacting Trent's words) was looking forward to.

[@babzcovington492]

not i will , i would .i would keep myself , i would find a way. it is about regrets

[@jacobthompson8981]

My dad left me and he didn’t what!!!!❤️🥺😭❤️💯❤️

[@SolaMelodica]

ahem.

[@jsw469]

He never opened his piano again after this.

[@cathypagel7325]

David Bowie also did a song called Lazarus before he passed both this song and David's make me emotional but also hopeful because both men seemed ready to meet Jesus and our Father I heaven🦋❤

[@SolaMelodica]

I wasn't aware of that (Bowie). I will give it a listen. My son's a huge fan of his final album.

[@dennishinkle5010]

People are like water we take the path of least resistance that why there's crooked rivers and crooked people.

[@darlaflorence7428]

Johnny Cash. God's Gonna Cut You Down.

[@SolaMelodica]

thanks for the suggestion

[@joannajohnson8210]

Have you looked at Toby Mac's "21 Years?" If not, it's worth a watch... be aware that the emotions are very strong in that song/video.

[@SolaMelodica]

I've not heard it, yet. Thanks for the suggestion and I will add that to the list.

[@tinacoon6199]

New sub with this reaction. Loved it!! Please react to James Blunt's Monsters. Can't wait but be sure to have plenty of tissues!!

[@chriscalfee9593]

Johnny cash believed the Lord spoke to him after attempting suicide. He told him to get up, he wasn't through with him yet. He spent the rest of his life serving him. Gary Allan has a song about it called nickajack cave

[@SolaMelodica]

A beautiful life transformed.

[@TheObscureRambler]

Oh, how many of us have those 'knuckle-head moves' in our past, in our lives we so desperately wish we could take back, undo, go back in time to avoid. The bitter truth for those who have not found God is that we can't. We can't undo the hurt. We can only try NOT to do the same move twice. Now... for those of us who HAVE found God, through His son, Jesus Christ? The bitterness fades into awe. We have redemption. Not only do we have a redemption, we have sinless, faultless, perfect redemption. It doesn't mean we'll never mess up again, no - but it means that we can be washed clean as snow by only turning to the only one who can. And God does not remember our sins when they've been carried to the cross - Psalm 103:9 He will not always accuse us, nor harbor His anger forever. 10 He has not dealt with us according to our sins or repaid us according to our iniquities. 11 For as high as the heavens are above the earth, so great is His loving devotion for those who fear Him. 12 As far as the east is from the west, so far has He removed our transgressions from us. 13 As a father has compassion on his children, so the LORD has compassion on those who fear Him. I take heart in that every single day of my life. I hope I will remember to hold the spirit of thankfulness for my own redemption till my last breath.

[@robwheelut]

This should be a test for Psychopath..Have them watch this video and if their not crying its a Psychopath

[@SolaMelodica]

Well said.

[@katmarino4120]

My sweetest friend.....dear dear Jesus Christ...😪😂😪😂🤗🤗🎆

[@bruceheckerman7343]

To go with your channel and bring in subscribers: Brooks and Dunn's BELIEVE. A true story from Ronnie Dunn's childhood. That old man meant so much to him that he says he cannot perform it live without starting to cry. God bless and good luck with a rare Christian KZbin channel.

[@SolaMelodica]

That's been a common request and it's on the list. Thanks for the engagement!!

[@bruceheckerman7343]

So sad that he and his wife would both be gone within 7 months of recording this.

[@SolaMelodica]

Yea, that is super sad. It's almost like this song was written for him to perform.

[@bruceheckerman7343]

The writer of this song met with Johnny and said "This is your song now."

[@babzcovington492]

shuts the piano lid like a coffin , doesn't he?

[@SolaMelodica]

brutal.

[@denveradams4909]

What Johnny sings about here is the very reason why I have chosen to sing Christian music. No, I haven't received riches, glory, awards, etc. I am not known beyond the region where I live. I did tour, semi-professionally, with a gospel group for several years. I have never considered myself as an entertainer. I carry the gospel of Jesus Christ. He is the one who gave me the talent, and it is He that I want to glorify. Oh, I can sing just about every George Strait song out there. But, I have no desire for that kind of fame. I would rather lay up treasures in heaven, than accumulate earthly treasures that will all go away in the end. This is Johnny coming to the realization that his life and the empire is all vanity. Just a pile of dirt.

[@SolaMelodica]

Keep doing it, Denver! Lay up those treasures in heaven!

[@oakinwol]

Definitely love that picture of Christ on the cross paying the price. I definitely feel the image of the cross making a way for restoration. My biggest pet peeve with fellow "christians" is the idea of them "trying" to be better, but really having no actual process to get better. Like if God asked us to be really good a free-throws then sitting and reading about it isn't going to help. We need to get in the gym and shoot, a lot. But there is almost no concept of that in the church. Just mainly a bunch of people getting together to talk about how to be better without much actual concrete discipleship or path on how to manage building the emotional, mental, relational skills necessary to actually succeed. And then just chalking up their making mistakes to their sinful nature rather than their persistent, unrepentant laziness to actual do what's necessary to be better. I feel like if someone actually cared about God's hurt and not just enamored with themselves and having a get out of jail free card, then they would have an actual plan and path to decrease the pain they inflict on God and those around them. Then after decades of talking about love we'd have people actually capable of love vs what the church mainly is now

[@SolaMelodica]

the sanctification paradox is legit. Does God do the clean up (Philippians 2:13) or do we (Philippians 2:12)? Both.

[@oakinwol]

@@SolaMelodica I appreciate your thoughtful reply. I honestly think we're creating an unnecessary paradox though. The Bible compares it to planting, because God is faithful. It's who he is. Sanctification is a teamlift where God is always ready to lift. It's us who dont want to lift. But our willingness not to lift is what proves that we dont really love him. That's what the bible says. "If you love me, you'll keep my commands"; "Why do you call me Lord and not do what I say"; "Those who sin are slaves to sin, if the son sets you free then you will be free indeed". If we're staring at barren fields then we can make that a God issue, but it's not a God issue. We should look at how we're planting, how deep, how much water have we provided, are we returning nutrients to the soil, is there a plant virus killing the crop that we can mitigate, are there pests devouring the crop, etc. This is how agricultural yields grew over time, through people's increased knowledge of agriculture, despite the fact that we dont "cause" seeds to grow. We just give them exactly what they need to grow and they grow because God is faithful. This is how people go after things they actually care about with all their heart, soul, mind and strength. That's why literally everything people have put their mind to in this world has advanced: art, music, science, tech, sports, everything. Everything except most congregations' ability to love, listen, connect, and be responsive to God and others. Because almost everyone in the church besides a small minorty serve God worse than the people in the world serve their idols. Because church leaders dont take responsibility for their discipleship responsibilities since who knows maybe God's the one not pulling his weight. Like waiting for manna from heaven to feed one's family. But in all other successful human endevours where they count the costs, the outcome is prioritized, and the sacrifices are made the mantra is basically "Do or do not. There is no try." Getting better at swiming isn't a paradox. Get in the water regularly, 20 min a day even, push past your comfort zone. You'll be a better swimmer. Getting better at guitar isn't a paradox. Play your guitar regularly, 20 min a day, push past your comfort zone. You'll be a better guitar player. We have people who say they want to get better at love, but do not "put it into practice". They do not break it down into components, the ability to listen, the ability to communicate, the ability to connect with one's own heart and the heart of others, the ability to manage one's own mental, physical and emotional health. They do not practice one thing daily to master it. They generally as a rule avoid discomfort when trying to deal with these things as often as possible. Or they're trying to learn 10 instruments at the same time and therefore suck at all of them instead of spending focused time mastering one and moving forward. How can we get better? I'm horrible at it myself. Trying to put together the pieces because to me there's no excuse to why Steph Curry can be a master at 3's through sacrifice and I say I love Christ more than anything but I cant sacrifice 20 min a day to master something instead of constantly asking God to help me be a master at something I never have time to practice. Seems weird to me, and seems like status quo church behavior. It's why we can keep saying, as Jesus said of the standard religious leaders of his day, that we're going to go to the field, for sure we're going to go, but we never get there. Sorry for the long wall of text. A young man trying to make sense of this around his own life and his own church family.

[@omitimo77]

Wow..great react. I totes love both versions of this tune. How about When The Man Comes Around? I often think about the whirlwind in the thorntrees. Might I suggest You do some Social Distortion? Mike Ness is a fantastic songwriter..they have somewhat a cult following, it's amazing reading comments on their videos about how the music/words saved someone's life--I know without a doubt, that Mikes presence got me through a worst of time or two. Please try Untitled, or Angels Wings. Also, Do some NOFX! They are mundo known for bashing religions..the religious, but more in a fun way. Their songs Pods and Gods or The Happy Guy are often overlooked songs when it comes to balancing those things out..NOFX is the largest punk rock entity many have never heard of, and they also have a cult-like following. Fat Mike is a brilliant lyricist and word-player..lots a silly songs, but many more that offer some serious contemplation when one goes beyond the surface level. Awesome channel..subbed, and looking forward to watching it grow.

[@SolaMelodica]

I appreciate the thoughtful comment and subbing. I'm gathering a list of recommendations and have added these to the list. Lots of new music for me!

[@markp8581]

He curses himself at the end that even if he had a chance to do it over again a better way he would find a way to keep it the same because that is who he is. So say we all. Also, we all let down all those we love, but it really is only the way we always see it not them most of the time.

[@jameshileman5829]

I think the two lines mean he would still be want the drugs and would find a way to take them again.

[@davespiess947]

Check out Martina McBride's "Gods Will" I can't wait to see your reaction.

[@SolaMelodica]

thanks for the suggestion. It's on the list now.

[@rhondaharris6673]

Amen by Kid Rock

[@SolaMelodica]

now, that's a great one. I have it on my list.

[@silverfiste]

I've a recommendation for you, Badflower "Ghost", heavy topic thou

[@SolaMelodica]

I've had some Ghost recommendations recently but that wasn't one of them. They seem quite nuanced in their musical approach.

[@silverfiste]

@@SolaMelodica the song is named "Ghost" by the band Badflower. As I am famillar with the band Ghost, I should have been more clear in my recomendation.

[@bigjay123]

Whats the other one "Gods gonna cut you down". Thats a good one too

[@SolaMelodica]

Yea, that's intense.

[@bruceheckerman7343]

Just thought of one MUST SEE for you: Creed's One Last Breath. Just watch the very last shot of his eyes; tell me and your viewers what you see. Sadly, last I heard, he was living in his car because of an IRS mistake. When he contacted them about it, they laughed at him, not knowing he is a Christian and would do as Jesus did. I'm excited to see a Christian react to this and BELIEVE because we are basically non-existent on here!

[@SolaMelodica]

Thanks, Bruce. I will keep grinding these out and taking some pot-shots for the team. I don't have a Creed song scheduled and will add this one to the list.

[@khalben6]

I'm an agnostic, and I'm not trying to be antoganistic, when I became of age and I asked my father, what's the right religion and he dropped all of the Holy books on my table and said: read for yourself and decide your faith, I read all of them and although they were a different version, they were trying to say the same thing, that's when I decided that god might be all powerful but it's not all knowing, it has his flaws, he created us all flawed, if you're Christian, the morning star was flawed, if you're Muslim, the prophet was analfabet, if you're Juish, there are 5 sacrifices described in the old Testament, so who is right, who is wrong, and who should just not care and try to be a better man for others and himself?

[@SolaMelodica]

Hi Kal - thanks for commenting and your question/comment is really appreciated. I'm no apologist and have never played one but will attempt to answer. If these answers are insufficient and you're genuinely curious I will refer you to Mike Winger (here on KZbin). Brilliant mind and super kind...you just won't get the awesome tunes you get her. There are similarities between all world religions and vast differences as well. Christianity is unique in that the creator paid the penalty for our sin. The Christian faith hinges on the resurrection of Christ. If that didn't happen then I am doomed. I believe that it did indeed happen for many reasons. It happened because Christ perfectly fulfilled the righteous requirements of the Law that were established in the Old Testament. Historical proof of His resurrection by hundreds of eye witnesses has been meticulously documented. The Bright Morning Star (Revelation 22:16) was not flawed. He was perfect. Truly God and Truly man. Believing in the resurrection of Christ and trying to be a better man are not mutually exclusive events. We can do both. As a Christian, I am supposed to "get better" on the daily. Most days I do okay and some days I fail miserably. I turn to God and ask for a fresh start multiple times per day. Who is right and who is wrong? I wish I could answer that question without depending on faith but I cannot. I believe the evidence in favor of Christ is sufficient for me. Again, thanks for the comment and the question. Blessings to you and you will be in my thoughts and prayers.

[@khalben6]

@@SolaMelodica thank you for your comment, and even if I have no particular faith myself, I believe in the faith of all others, and maybe I might be trying to find my way, maybe I am not but that's the thing about being agnostic, you have faith in something, that faith might change or stay neutral, but it also means I have enormous respects, for people like you are, who truly believe in something

[@johnhunter5724]

@@SolaMelodicathoroughly enjoyed this reaction, especially your exhortation to pick up the phone and have that awkward conversation. Could you provide some citations or references to these meticulously documented eye witnesses please?

[@eloflin]

Thank you for the Christian views on this song/cover.

[@SolaMelodica]

You are welcome!

[@elisamcgowan4774]

Sir, I am only mentioning this because you talked about the topic of hate etc. I myself am a Transwoman, and I do no one any harm, and try to live the best life I can, but a LOT of hate is levelled at me, someone even saying that I am a sin against God, and will be going to hell. I hope that those who read this realise the hurt they are causing innocent people, to the point where we are being murdered. Thank you.

[@joanstrater3047]

First time here, impressive! You might like to check out Distirbed -Hold on Memories, I wouldbe interested in your take on it.

[@SolaMelodica]

Thank you. I was in need of a Disturbed song --- thank you!

[@jeffcamp481]

When you see the scene of Christ crucified and Johnny says he causes hurt, we all caused the pain for Christ , because of our short comings ,(sin)!

[@richardkelley9224]

If you get a chance check out Little Jimmy Dickens-Raggedy Ann

[@thomaswhite3831]

you can't take it with you .

[@SolaMelodica]

Nope.

[@andywright6713]

First time here.Could you check out Tom MacDonald's songs "Castles", "Angels" & "Church"?

[@SolaMelodica]

Definitely.

[@jimtuell4076]

If you want to react to an emotional song, go to "Monsters" by James Blunt. Be sure to watch the official video. It makes me cry every time I watch it. (I am also a retired pastor.)

[@SolaMelodica]

thanks, I'm not familiar with that song and will give it a listen (official video). Thanks for serving the KINGDOM!

[@chriswebb1679]

Don't blow your head off man. You are of value. Anything I can do. Please

[@SolaMelodica]

uhhhhh....okay. thank you?