Rich Evans gets anal

[@Hayamaneko]

Rich being covered in white sticky stuff makes this even better out of context

[@TheChach]

Jay's reaction is amazing.

[@thehammurabichode7994]

It doesn't even look like a face that he makes. I think he was truly caught off guard. Absolutely _baffled_

[@RetroBacon1]

Josh’s is more genuine looking I love it

[@reggaereggaehorse6356]

Agreed, the moment that happened i wanted that reaction to be a meme.

[@VideoMeltdown]

He's mad because he knows he'll have to edit the anal scene.

[@LinusBitchTits]

You should see the way he reacts when he’s down at The Manhole

[@anonymouss4635]

He didn't say no.

[@atticusrex9468]

I mean...would you?

[@SoybeanGravy]

@@atticusrex9468 it’s Rich Evans, how could any mortal being say no?

[@FrancisYorkMorganFBI]

@@atticusrex9468 it would be an honor

[@Venislovas]

Because he can't

[@jakoporeeno4654]

Sounds like Rich Evans making excuses afterwards

[@Tony-Gunk]

geez Rich must think he's backstage at the Ellen show

[@fsikijelfes8660]

Lolll

[@mellowyellow6572]

I love how perfectly the music syncs up

[@VintageJunior]

For a sec Jay thought he was back at The Manhole.

[@reggaereggaehorse6356]

How does Rich know my go-to pick-up line?

[@Scribbled_Death]

Rich using and saying words correctly is my fav rare reoccurring coincidence on the show.

[@HC-qc5rp]

I was hoping someone would clip this. Thank you

[@unprofessionalvideos]

My new catch phrase.

[@bencarlson4300]

Someone had to do it

[@SpikyKing13]

Ayoooo!!!

[@MissileLaneE]

Has someone made that reaction an animated GIF yet?

[@joehollingsworth4502]

Josh and Jay really said "????????????????"

[@questionmark3535]

It's only a second, i mean..

[@Akatsukileader9]

What was supposed to be his actual line?

[@3xclusiv3sodak]

That was quick

[@Venislovas]

That's what she said

[@thehammurabichode7994]

@@Venislovas -*That's what Jay said- *That's what Susan said

[@kubli365]

@@thehammurabichode7994 a second is rather quick