Robby & Brie GO TO WAR Over Israel-Palestine, 40 Beheaded Babies Report

Briahna Joy Gray AND Robby Soave discuss the bipartisan effort in the House to vote for killing resolution to censure Rep. Rashida Tlaib (D-Mich.) and keep Rep. George Santos (R-N.Y.) in his seat. #bipartisanship #house
About Rising:
Rising is a weekday morning show with bipartisan hosts that breaks the mold of morning TV by taking viewers inside the halls of Washington power like never before. The show leans into the day's political cycle with cutting edge analysis from DC insiders who can predict what is going to happen. It also sets the day's political agenda by breaking exclusive news with a team of scoop-driven reporters and demanding answers during interviews with the country's most important political newsmakers.
Follow Rising on social media:
Website: Hill.TV
Facebook: HillTVLive/
Instagram: @HillTVLive
Twitter: @HillTVLive

[@38dragoon38]

Whatever your beliefs, I cannot imagine such a conversation between presenters taking place elsewhere at other news shows. Excellent effort guys!

[@bret44]

The way Robbie pretends like this is a war between two countries is insane. Hamas is like a gang that runs the prison.

[@mgmmotiondesigns]

They were still elected to power by a slim margin in 2006. Palestinians had a choice, more than half picked Hamas over Fatah.

[@Djangoisback]

Great description.

[@Djangoisback]

​@@mgmmotiondesigns you stopped thinking when you heard that.

[@Jessicaro]

@@mgmmotiondesigns it was a democratic choice so what is your point? they never gotten the chance to rule because the us and israel immediatly after made an open air prison out of gaza. hamas has been propped up and paid for by israel themselves. they did it so fatah wouldn't win so they would keep divided so they won't have to agree on making a two state solution. now how is you chosing for biden somehow means it is oke for you to die?

[@Jessicaro]

it isn't two countries it is one country against a population with some rebels. that is it.

[@MohamedAli-ko8gc]

This debate aged well.

[@Highvibethings]

Like fine wine everyday.

[@Mimicry161]

Came back to rewatch it, my goodness is Robby a giant tool.

[@intricatic]

Especially now that MTG is freaking out about that antisemitism bill possibly making it illegal to say the Jws killed Jsus.

[@MohamedAli-ko8gc]

@@intricatic it was easy at first because it was the Moozlumz now it’s the Christians too.

[@patrickhuertas9769]

Brie you can’t argue with ignorance.

[@Independent-Thought]

Robbie insists on accuracy when it’s convenient to his narrative.

[@jerkchickenblog]

but when he argues with brie it's always hyperbole up front, then 'well i dont actually have those details but...'. very tiring

[@MadManUSMC]

Most of these commentors don't even follow that he went from "I've seen the pictures" to "I saw a picture like it" to "I drew a picture in kindergarten." The guy lied to posture and then ate her boot once called out. He shouldn't be on a "News" vod, or any vod.@@jerkchickenblog

[@Bavafa1]

She did put him on spot by saying "you are in the front of the computer, pull up the pictures you saw" and of course we all saw what he didn't do.

[@stevielogan702]

Robby: "there was literally evidence uploaded to the internet of 40 beheaded babies" Brie: "ok pull up the evidence then" Robby: "well idk if there was exactly that number of babies killed in exactly that ways" ?????

[@karelriley2406]

Robby seems to me to be intellectually lazy (White guys can get away with that), while Bri very carefully lays out her facts as Black women are required to do to be taken seriously.

[@stephj9378]

The fact that some of you are ok with killing babies at all is spine chilling to me. Acting like it aint no thang as long as they werent beheaded.

[@epicphailure88]

@@stephj9378 US government lies all the time about foreign policy. Why should we believe them now?

[@peace4721]

​@@stephj9378the thing is , there's no proof that any baby was killed on October 7th whatsoever, needless to mention beheaded in particular, on the other side more than 3500 child were killed due to continuous bombardments, but the white men don't care about that since those are human animals descendants

[@sevenwhatuknow]

​​​@@stephj9378it's not about that. Govt officials made a direct and specific statement and they should be held up to it. Were babies killed? I almost guarantee it. Terrible stuff. But "40 beheaded babies" is being used as buzz words by everyone EXCEPT the ones who said it. You don't find that to be a problem at all? People are lying to you and you're fine with it?

[@chs53021]

I get more out of Bri’s comments than I do from Robby. She is more thoughtful and makes more sense.

[@kb2x172]

Brie torched Robby on this debate. He lost the argument by many points, and was forced to back track some of his position.

[@waynekocher2985]

Well I'd you already have a left leaning socialist bias already

[@simzer]

This debate shows the difference between a real good-hearted human being presenter and an AI presenter.

[@S_j_loves]

My thoughts exactly

[@Grandmas_Favorite]

Which is which in your opinion

[@rickydee5863]

@@Grandmas_Favorite thats obvious robbie is the construct.

[@LuisVelazquezLV3]

who is the AI?

[@jellebehaegel2080]

Robbie is the AI, I'm wondering why you still have to ask 😅

[@crimpdaddy]

One time i actually agree with Brie. They put the story out about the beheaded babies but whisper the retraction. You can't unring a bell

[@Drety6]

*COVID-19 origin story has entered the chatroom*

[@stephj9378]

I down voted this becausae of her hard ball for Hamas.

[@JehsuBenIsrael]

@@stephj9378 Hamas = Sicarii

[@jonwalter6317]

She's hanging a little tough on the 500 dead because Israelis bombed a hospital story, though she's backtracked a little

[@Ramo-jw8iy]

@@stephj9378 you don’t know Ha mas! Don’t Judge them 🤨

[@jasonryan3506]

Its so sad that as a race we think killing people is a way to get things done.

[@mb9662]

If it didn’t work we wouldn’t do it

[@samdg1234]

A response to both or either of those two questions would be appreciated. Otherwise, it appears you are just deluded into thinking we live in a world that we obvious don't.

[@davepenn9181]

Who's the "we" here? Speak for yourself.

[@SNAFU78]

Agreed, if only. World peace is a novel idea, just isn’t the reality. I’m very much a dreamer, but I’m a stone cold realist when it comes to everyday life. We have all this potential for consciousness but most people operate at base level. It’s unfortunate, but that’s how it is.

[@humans.from.earth.]

@@SNAFU78world peace is a possible realty, it is just a possibility most do not yet understand. it has been uniquely possible for about 100 years

[@iamharnam]

Whoaaa good on ya Briana great composure in the face of Robbies tantrum

[@JeffreyFay]

I must say, it's nice to see these guys engaging like this. Most organizations have everyone in lock step. This is more credible. Kudos to The Hill (I didn't think I'd ever say that...)

[@marioques]

Let's see if both keep their jobs or who's the one who is going to loose it first.

[@JeffreyFay]

@@marioques If The Hill are smart they'll embrace and encourage their new found diversity of opinion. Definitely sets them apart from the rest of the mainstream media and, judging by the comments, viewers seem to dig it.

[@muhammadkutty8754]

​@@JeffreyFaythr hill fired Katie helper for her opinion, I don't think theHill is different than any other mainstream media

[@rmurphy911]

There's no evidence of beheaded babies. Bri is right that this is an important point.

[@bencarter7839]

What exactly would constitute evidence you would accept?

[@coryascott]

@@bencarter7839 more than just taking their word for it

[@ollecram8647]

Max Blumenthal of the GrayZone has even written an article that indicates that there is no sound evidence tha 40 babies have in fact been decapitated

[@mattconstantine9884]

wrong. there is no evidence of 40 exactly, and no evidence of someone actually slicing a head off. there is more than enough evidence of multiple children misssing heads, unless you think that reporters all over the world who have been shown videos by israel of what hamas did including children missing heads, and other limbs, and burned alive with their families. and no. its not an important point. its an important point that hamas took pleasure in it. that the barbarity of it WAS the point. they celebrated it they shared it with their families, and the families of their victims THAT is an imporant point. not that you havent YOURSELF seen videos of a beheading,. that is absolutely unimportant. would the children who werre blown apart by a handgrendade and dragged off of theri dead fathers body and taken hostage in gaza be any less brutal to you? does that in ANY way make hamas LESS brutal>? no. it does not. if it does for you? then i no longer care about what you think, and i suggest you get professional help.

[@bencarter7839]

@@coryascott Specifically, what would constitute evidence you would accept. Give an example - or are you now beginning to see the problem?

[@fengusburnt]

I can’t believe someone would go onto a news show to defend false reporting. The weirdest hill to die on, let alone get so indignant about it.

[@donvong9798]

He’s hoping to get recruited by CNN

[@jerkchickenblog]

but robbie does it every day and often wonders aloud why he can't get some conservative billionaire to support him. he does this, but he's so ready to sell out even more if he gets the chance. it's disgusting really

[@Uda007]

They were acting. He acts as Pro Israel. So, both of them can debate and came out the argument normally brought out by public on certain issues.

[@jeffrodrequez]

I guess I'm one of the lone voices to say does it really matter about 40 beheaded babies? As if that story is proven to be false everyone would say "See? Hamas isn't that bad, they blew up 40 babies they didn't behead them".

[@owenm.traves4964]

I don't think this is acting, Bri seems genuinely annoyed because of his lack of nuance especially since it relates to the governments use of propaganda during a really volatile time

[@calarencrow7480]

This is what I got from this whole conversation: Robby: "Hamas is evil". Brie: "How dare you call Palestinians evil". Robby: "No.... listen...the terrorist organization, Hamas is evil". Brie: "Palestinians are good people, they are not evil". Robby: "Hamas, Hamas Hamas...don't you listen...". Brie: "Your speech is despicable". Robby: "......", "w/e lets cut to commercials"

[@ScrupulousAtheist]

I never though Brie was pro terrorist

[@adamevert1618]

Robby: 40 babies were beheaded Brie: No it's proven falce Robby: No it's not omg I can't believe you are saying this Brie: Find a link Robbie: So there have not been children killed Brie: Find a link of that incident that Biden claimed happened Robby: I dont care about that incident or that anybody in media or politics claimed it happened, children died somewhere

[@lu881]

This is how it should be. Ideas and viewpoints are debated until a consensus is reached. Not cancellation, not "censure"

[@aneurindavies5943]

This is how sensible debate, and discussion, which represents good journalism should be like, however main-stream journalism, and media propagandists are agents of the corrupt Deep-state, who Parrot the Lies!

[@jeremysametz1699]

Then the debate will continue, because there was no consensus between Bri and Robbie in this clip.

[@lu881]

@@jeremysametz1699 exactly. Let it continue until we can find something to agree on

[@kb2x172]

Brie torched Robby on this debate. He lost the argument by many points, and was forced to back track some of his position.

[@KriZtiaN17VL]

​@@lu881do you think there can be agreements if either side is unwilling to "agree"? What if it never ends? At what point it becomes unproductive to debate someone who just wants to win, rather than to agree.

[@adamwatkins5217]

I feel like their positions can be summarized by: "Hamas was wrong, AND ISRAEL IS ALSO WRONG" vs "HAMAS WAS WRONG, and Israel is also wrong"

[@Defiant420]

Are you implying one was more deserving? That's wrong. No people deserve any of this.

[@adamwatkins5217]

@@Defiant420 i wasnt implying anything. I was just summarizing BJG & Robbys arguments. Highlighting how they appear to be similar but they feel more passionately about different parts

[@mgyb8269]

Perfectly put

[@Defiant420]

@adamwatkins5217 I understand 👍. Robbie is super calm usually. Except for that "I don't give an "F" Brianna" moment...😁

[@garrymcfadden4105]

Well said

[@yvonneclaes5208]

Well, this didn't age well, now did it Robby? smh

[@foumalins5452]

It’s mind boggling how Robbie got into that position with his takes. He deeply lacks critical thinking. He definitely makes me feel good about myself 😁

[@jasonpetrise]

The man is cretinous

[@patrickahaus6570]

Robby surely has to answer to his master who pays him. It must be a very stressful job for him to be so hysterical Man up Robby and get some anger management training. You are taking this personally for some reason.

[@nomnom103]

He is so dumb and not with this issue only. I too wonder how he was recruited

[@crhu319]

He's as Libertarian as they get.

[@shomarinelson6017]

Fuq hammas / fuq isreal. Fuq democrats and rhino repubs. Fuq all who fall for this nonsense . cancel the internet forever because it has made us weak.

[@sek5050]

Have to side with Robbie on this one. Bri really despises the Israeli people…

[@YouTubeHandle42069]

Robbie criticizes the wrong on both sides. Bri only criticizes half the wrong.

[@philipangelo595]

Better watch it again.

[@dr.wolfstar1765]

​@@philipangelo595I watched twice. This comment is correct. Where does Bri condemn Palestine for their terroristic actions?

[@willejones1918]

ikr. typicaly of post neoliberals.

[@russ4moose]

As far as I can tell, Bri thinks that Hamas is somewhat justified in their actions because the power imbalance between the people in Gaza and the Israelis is so vast that doing something to bring attention to the plight of the Palestinians is justifiable, and there is not much else that they can do. I think she'd say that what they did do was bad, but they are so cornered and abused that its hard to imagine what they should be doing instead. I'm more aligned with Robbie, though. F Israel for the way they have handled Gaza historically, but also F Hamas for killing Israeli babies. The US should withhold aid to Israel at least as long as they are committing humanitarian atrocities.

[@JuliusGalacki]

Absurd. No he doesn't.

[@Larkon979]

I love to watch them because they go at it! It's like watching your friends debate.

[@fadhlmohamed2896]

A woman with humanity speaking truth she put him in his place!

[@thepsychnurse4406]

I love the fact they keep it real on here. It beats cnn, fox, msnbc,nbc, abc, and on and on. Keep up the great work guys!

[@joesabet2001]

it’s possible it’s partly show. I mean to say perhaps they’ve agreed beforehand to argue as much as possible but no it’s never personal and often exaggerated, the emotions, everything. This never crossed your mind yet?

[@fishmud3264]

They keep it 60% real. There's a lot more that could be said but doesn't

[@marjoriestclair]

Best coverage is Channel 4 in the UK. Balanced, truly balanced, without all the yelling. Channel 4 Uk deserves a journalism prize for its coverage of the Gaza/Israeli war.

[@joesabet2001]

@@marjoriestclair Best show to me is Democracy Now!, youtube clips from TYT, Piers Morgan, Katie Halper, etc

[@jeremysametz1699]

Bri keeps it real. Robbie is a bully

[@berniculus]

When Robbie says "What is wrong with you." he exits the realm of formal debate into a media show.

[@promark5317]

The dude argues like a middle-schooler.

[@danny_chestnut253]

He has no respect for bri and is very unprofessional. Always making it personal cursing screaming its annoying.

[@acbower4468]

Well after Bris take yesterday on the Hamas spokesman, and that ballet she orchestrated dancing around the obvious of what he said with he interpretation, then she follows it up with a literal interpretation of what Biden said, it would get on my nerves too…she is being an activist

[@austinbux]

Yeah, he's really rude and belittling and should potentially face disciplinary action by his employers.

[@danny_chestnut253]

@@acbower4468 and shes giving her opinion which is her job and robbies NOT insulting and personally attacking your coworkers and acting like a child who doesn't know how to properly debate without screaming and throwing a tantrum.

[@floorfan7987]

She must have missed the hamas leader saying what happened on oct 7 will happen over and over again !!!!

[@peachjwp]

Brie, you go girl!! Thanks for arguing so effectively holding Israeli accountable to its crimes!

[@aliayatolla1419]

usa who veto every single un resolution against israel dont get a pass ,when the time came amerikkka will pay

[@tethergobrrr]

The “40 beheaded babies” story doesn’t matter if no Israeli official ever says it again. While they are using it as lore to justify genocide, it matters.

[@blastermaster5009]

They already used it to justify genocide, so it does matter - even if no Israeli official says it again, it doesn't undo what has been done.

[@rizzlervontrappe1515]

How do you think the US would respond if this happened to them? You just don’t like Jews, be honest. They’re fighting a regime that wants to wipe their country and their race from the face of the earth, Hamas has clearly stated this unapologetically. The Arabs have consistently rejected a two state solution. There is no reasoning.

[@porter9276]

50+ babies were unalived though (out of 1400+ victims). Beheaded or not, they are still dead. And that's a fact.

[@AlOfNorway]

@@porter9276did they though? I haven’t seen any reports about that.

[@tethergobrrr]

@@porter9276 If they didn’t find the lie to be a useful propaganda tool they wouldn’t be repeating it in every interview.

[@chessman70]

If the story about the decapitated babies was true it would have been all over the media for everybody to see

[@isuriadireja91]

i bet the israelis got the inspiration for that sick propaganda from that controversial Beatles album cover with all the cut up dolls. 🤣🤣

[@damienalvarez2957]

Oh, you mean like the “totally fake, totally Russian misinformation” Hunter Biden laptop the MSM tried to sweep under the rug till it was validated months after Biden got elected? Get real.

[@bobweiss8682]

The story about the Kuwaiti babies thrown out of incubators by Iraqi soldiers was all over the media, and helped galvanize public opinion in favor of the Gulf War. But it was all a propaganda campaign orchestrated by a US public relations firm....

[@char73]

My thoughts exactly

[@reggiebrown4911]

I can't believe people still think that actually happened

[@douglasmccannpiano]

Brie thinks. Indiscriminate bombing killing innocents is worse than purposeful slaughter.

[@crhu319]

It is when a nation state does it.

[@dark_winter8238]

What is the difference? The only reason we in the west think it's okay is we have never feared being hit in an airstrike.

[@merriemerrie7378]

@@crhu319 Did you happen to miss that the Hamas attack was funded by Iran?

[@Emils_really]

And she can't separate hamas and Palestinians.

[@merriemerrie7378]

@@dark_winter8238 Did you miss Pearl Harbor? On Dec 7, 1941 Japan, in its imperial lust for power, attacked Pearl Harbor, Hawaii. 350 Japanese aircraft sunk 18 US naval vessels, destroyed or damaged 300 US airplane and killed 2,403 men. The US entered the war. As a ground invasion neared the Japanese islands, their suicidal=spare-no woman-or-child mentality made victory very costly. The battle for Okinawa alone cost over 100,000 lives. Truman decided to drop two atomic bombs on Japan, which killed over 120,000 Japanese, and brought a quick end to the war. More lives would have been lost if the war continued, but debate still rages on the decision to bomb.

[@kevinbanks6456]

In America when a school shooting happens and children get killed they may or may not show blurred out pics...BUT ONE THING THAT IS A GUARANTEE IS THAT THE MOTHERS OF THISE CHILDREN SPEAK OUT AT NEWS CONFERENCES. Can someone on planet earth send me a video of 1 mother crying about losing their child? Please!!! It's that simple. You can't tell me that 40 mothers have a gag order but everyone else don't? Iam so grateful that some of us don't have that disease that doesn't allow you to critically THINK FOR YOURSELF.

[@tyepearson3293]

I love it when the debate between these two get heated

[@agreeneish]

They love it too cuz ratings skyrocket !!!

[@ThePrinceraj88]

I know it turns me on I google interracial right after…

[@davidbush131]

It feels like Robby is a bit afraid of getting heated with Brie Brie.

[@jacquelynnschoenack1707]

@@davidbush131 if they brought Jessica in I think they should bring in reinforcements for Robbie too haha

[@sarahsuze7742]

Mee too they're perfect for each other

[@hillybeaner9689]

I'm glad he specifically called her out for attempting to minimize the losses caused by hamas

[@robtautges6395]

Robby said "I don't think the demonization of Hamas should be pushed back on." I guess that is why he does not mind that the 40 beheaded babies story is not factually true and that POTUS said it anyway. He is essentially saying, well there were babies who where beheaded somewhere somehow and since Hamas is sub-human we should not concern ourselves with the veracity of the story. As a journalist Robby, it is your job to care about the accuracy of the story, especially when so much is at stake. Thank you Bri for refusing to be gas lighted like every day.

[@bojo2770]

But there were no beheaded babies anywhere

[@go0dy338]

They literally found the head of a hostage yesterday.

[@devcam8843]

@@go0dy338I guess that confirms that 40 babies were beheaded then.. thank you clearing things up.

[@michaelkulman7095]

When did Biden say forty beheaded babies as you claim?

[@hunterkil1er342]

​@@go0dy338it was a small skull fragment.

[@barbaraibiel]

Bravo, Robby.

[@barbaraibiel]

@@garyallen8824 I care about what he says, not what his voice sounds like. His voice sounds normal.

[@lisa-ul4vi]

Good job Rising! Robbie and Bri make great opponents and good faith partners. They can have a knock down drag out, remain professional and still love and respect each other in the end. This is the one of the ONLY places in town to find this kind of dialogue! You both are what Americans should strive to be. Passionate respectful good faith debates in the end no matter we are ALL Americans

[@Don-C.L.]

This is way better than when Bri went against a democrat couple (Kyle and Krystal). When she tries to reset the stage, Rob actually listens instead of being a DNC/RNC cuck.

[@felicous]

@@Don-C.L. listens? he was inerrupting your points and said, "What's wrong with you!" ummm.... I disagree with how he took things way to personal Very unprofessional, especially for a so called journalist.... or a commentator

[@Don-C.L.]

@@felicous yes, that was outta pocket, but towards the end, when she was talking a bit more docile, he was listening. The Kyle discussion was just like that, but a tad bit worse.

[@crhu319]

For now. It's unlikely evangelical empire cults can be supported by the majority.

[@morrispaulmarks4101]

IF IF IF Israel did not have the Iron Dome how many? HOW MANY many Jews innocent BABIES,children, women, old, JEWs Would BE DEAD ? from over 7,000 rockets NOW that they shot..5000 DAY ONE. You want to talk about genocide that would have killed MEGA thousands to tens of thousands of Jews.. you think Israel could trust anybody that hides Rockets under hotels under hospitals under kindergartens under ? ? God bless Israel from American Jews

[@mikebear7636]

Robbie has compassion for Israel civilians attacked by terrorists, we can also have compassion for Palestine civilians and children, not all are Hamas, don't minimize Israel victims, don't minimize Palestine civilian victims.

[@zaneleb8597]

Well done, Brie, especially on the closing points! I’m concerned that Robbie only gets emotional over victims of Oct 7. He shows no emotion when it comes to civilians that he now claims are innocent who are dying by the thousands since. You can hate hamas but what does that have to do with the civilians in refugee camps and elsewhere? Where’s your outrage at their killings.

[@philipangelo595]

Exactly!! I can't believe that our government and media have normalized genocide.

[@daniel-zh4qc]

Yeah there is something not white, errr I mean right about it....

[@ericward284]

That's called a whataboutism.

[@zaneleb8597]

@@ericward284 ok

[@breebartkowiakova]

I think Robbie nailed it- Bri is 100% trying to minimize the cruelty of hamas.

[@beckyjohnson5057]

Bri: "Israel put Hamas in charge." Such a distortion of facts. Yes, Israel did foster the growth of Hamas in Gaza in the 1980's when it was opening breakfast programs for kindergartners & emphasizing community service. As for how Hamas was "put in charge," that's complicated. 2006 election, Hamas won a majority of seats in the PLC. 2007 Hamas & Fatah got into a civil war, and Hamas shot it's way to supreme power in 2007. there have been no more elections since. Hamas is a theocratic military dictatorship & a terrorist organization whose fighters number about 30K.

[@risacohen4131]

Thank you for your excellent explanation. I appreciate it, and it goes a long way in understanding.

[@noxologcayiya1378]

It's wild watching a reporter saying accuracy in reporting a story doesn't matter.

[@travismckay6522]

Robbie’s got so much patience for war crimes from American allies

[@kyle-ri5mz]

or perhaps.. he just isn't a gigantic P)ssy and knows what war is.

[@CHX_37]

Agree

[@evanwilliams4532]

Just like those war crimes committed by hamas, am I right?

[@mindped]

@@evanwilliams4532 Who put Hamas into power again? Who as early as 2019 was saying lets fund them.... oh yea... israel gov

[@djinghiskhan9199]

@@evanwilliams4532 Hi Hamas-brain

[@SS-xv7xf]

Thank you Brie for your empathy of the Palestinian people.Understanding their struggle and speaking up on their behalf!

[@MadManUSMC]

Robby is and always has been a cuck. News should be facts and not bloviated opinion with absolutely nothing to back it but "My brothers, uncles. cousins, neighbor said so."

[@vineetmishra2690]

They should stop making so many children. Its not good for the environment.

[@fatdoi003]

@@vineetmishra2690 when one side is being ethnically cleansed.... they got to build back the numbers....

[@FreshLyte]

@@vineetmishra2690 That's hilarious coming from you.

[@rizzlervontrappe1515]

@@fatdoi003you have no idea what you’re talking about

[@Ballardian]

I'm with Brie on this one, Robby has gone way down in my estimation.

[@collinmcgovern1017]

Maybe we should all take a step back and realize we are ignorant in this conflict.

[@jacquelynnschoenack1707]

I appreciate you both - Brie and Robby- you show up everyday and have debates, disagreements and straight up fights, but you both do so in good faith, and you leave us viewers with the ability to form our own opinions. This is becoming increasingly rare by the day.

[@heyitsme881]

Why would you appreciate Bri? She’s not even honest.

[@ScottyKirk1]

​@@heyitsme881Exactomundo

[@johnrborowski]

That’s only becuase you disagree with her. Think about that. When someone doesn’t agree with you it means THEY’RE lying. Yikes

[@jacquelynnschoenack1707]

@@heyitsme881 yeah she is, she’s honest even if she’s not correct. If YOU watch them in good faith (not to “hate watch”) regularly you’ve seen both their perspectives shift on issues over time.

[@heyitsme881]

@@johnrborowski i disagree with her BECAUSE she lies.

[@look9005]

Robbie, You owe Bri a huge apology

[@alexg3067]

I feel so sorry for Brie. She handles herself with grace and steadfast speaking. The bias in the reporting between Israel and Gaza is so vivid here.

[@rogersingh1849]

Brianna has more balls than robby...the truth will always prevail.

[@andrewtintle2857]

Imagine Robbie spending 1 day in Gaza, dude would be singing a much different tune.

[@brasidas2011]

Or in the Kibbutz's attacked by Palestinians?

[@yikeslikes4457]

@@brasidas2011 stop deflecting

[@majedtaleb3944]

@@brasidas2011that’s 1 day vs Gaza’s misery which is 365 days a year

[@bromack3]

I think Brianna should spend one day in Gaza. She has a lot of answers but no real knowledge of whats going on.

[@maxpowertastic]

I have been to Israel. It is quite nice. 20% of the population is Arab. If Hamas didn’t want to exterminate the Jewish people and Israel didn’t have to worry about terrorist attacks out of Gaza the Palestinians would be far better off. This is a Hamas issue.

[@stringX90]

Love to see REAL debate and conversation happen. Hope they stay open to each other's ideas and POVs

[@NicolasSauveur]

Exactly !

[@worldadventuretravel]

That only works when there are two equally valid sides of an issue. There is no other valid side to the issue of Israel and Palestine. Israel is an apartheid state committing a holocaust against Palestinians, full stop.

[@chiefswife1212]

THEY'RE SUPPOSE TO REPRESENT THE CONSTITUENTS NO VOTE THEIR CONSCIENCE!!!!

[@juancifuentes7404]

Love this show, I get very suspicious when everyone agrees and they have an entourage clapping.

[@nikosantikythera2422]

Good point.

[@dustinavant2003]

Please clap.

[@anthonymusto3537]

👏

[@heckensteiner4713]

Genuinely agree. 👏

[@Kal93]

Yeah the lack of clapter (clapping laughter in agreement) and the lack of pandering to a specific audience is refreshing. Except for when they interviewed Anthony Fauci and gave him very soft-ball questions without Kim Iversen a couple of years ago. I think they do have to cave a certain way sometimes but at least it's not NEARLY as biased as a lot of other news sources.

[@MissBrennan]

“What’s wrong with you” asks Robby. Dude, I’ve been asking that every time she goes on her self-righteous rants. Good for you standing up against her finally!!

[@kb2x172]

Brie torched Robby on this debate. He lost the argument by many points, and was forced to back track some of his position.

[@fluffykitties9020]

he's totally wrong here! IDF lied. Bravo to this woman!

[@ziam6210]

Bri thank you.

[@danielfebus666]

This show is so good. Keep it up guys love the back-and-forth.

[@xGx471]

NO... back and forth is not progress

[@grocerybaggy]

@@xGx471yes it is… you don’t progress without discussion. Discussion sometimes involves back and forth to make points more clear. There is so much emotion in this conversation, we need more of that.

[@orlandopenahernandez7631]

clearly robbie does not value Palestinan life as much as the israeli ones.

[@shaheedkareem9700]

🎯

[@jasper_of_puppets]

I hate to break it to you, but Hamas doesn't value Palestinian life either.

[@promark5317]

Baaaah baaah! Blame hamas ! Baaaah baah! 🐑🐑🐑

[@user-qr7xk4fz7t]

Huh? Robby clearly stated none of this is the Palestinians' fault and that Hamas is to blame.

[@johnhorner1969]

You can say the same in reverse about Bri. She thinks Israel is guilty and Hamas are blameless victims.

[@SBoss281]

Bri is unhinged at this point.

[@user-zq7xi1dc4y]

So well said. Dehumanization is how one gets to genocide. It happened in Germany, we can't ever let it happen again

[@delmar418]

I like this show because they each have different views, counterpoints that don't push narratives. They argue, they make editorial points AND they have POINTS OF VIEW.

[@heyitsme881]

You have really low standards.

[@josephinetracy1485]

Yeah... but lets not over do it..

[@robp.5553]

Brie's bias is definitely showing. She doesn't want to hear facts that are objective that might go against her own narrative. It's getting pretty hard to watch.

[@rileyrussell7476]

To say Bri doesn't try to push a narrative is questionable at best. She's constantly pushing her own narrative while ignoring facts and skewing others.

[@cathjj840]

Are your facts coming from mainstream media?If so, that's why she has to refute or nuance them@@robp.5553

[@catalyst385]

This typifies why this conflict is so scary. People are taking the staunchest positions and writing off horrible things and mounds of dead bodies in the process.

[@emersonasuncion4724]

actually its easy to make a stand if youre not brainwashed....israel invaded palestine thats the crux of it nothing else

[@jeremysametz1699]

People? You mean Robbie.

[@therealcirclea762]

@@jeremysametz1699 Right, because both side are not guilty of it? Hamas is somehow saintly? Are you an idiot or an ideologue?

[@jamiedee36]

The manner in which Hamas slaughtered innocent Israelis does make a difference. I also don’t blindly believe the numbers of Palestinian deaths their Health Ministry releases. Also, it’s not like ALL Palestinians are these innocent people. Many of them CHEER on the brutal deaths of Israelis AND were dancing in the streets after 9/11. Lastly, most Palestinians want the Israelis out of the area altogether.

[@Blobby192]

im not taking sides on this one they both seem as bad as each other

[@Jcholla]

“What is wrong with you?” Whether you agree with him or not on this topic, Robby finally grew a backbone.

[@bebopkirby]

In America if one wants to have a successful career in any field it is best to sound more like Robby than Brie. Robby is not burning that bridge.

[@mullroid]

OMFG, Robbie's balls dropped. Better late than never

[@hamzazad5258]

when you look into the past Israeli attacks on Gaza, historically, Israel was the one breaking the past ceasefire agreements.

[@xycap8351]

Uuuh No

[@fredneck83]

This is THE debate. I find myself in the middle of both of these hosts. Finally, I agree with Bri. It’s hopeless in my POV. But I definitely do NOT think that the US should be funding this genocide. It’s disgusting

[@hvalenti]

If you call Isreal defending itself and Hamas purposely throwing women and children at targets Isreal continually warns to *please leave* then you ain't in the middle.

[@xycap8351]

Bad faith arguing. YOU are saying its ok since they were murdered, burned alive , baked alive bur beheaded afterwards....Despicable

[@fredneck83]

@@xycap8351 didn’t say it was ok. None of it is ok.

[@elgandahc]

I’m actually kinda digging the tension between these two. It’s been building for weeks, and now it’s actually something “a little bit different.” Keep it going!

[@W1ZY]

Remember, the i24 News reporter who started the beheaded baby story is an American from Colorado. A local newz reporter who went to Israel.

[@user-gr2yb5sq7e]

and she got the story from an extremist jewish settler..... totally kosher!

[@nikosantikythera2422]

So what.

[@jammin1881]

We have so many reports and so many atrocities that happened , it became impossible to release the true scale of it. The footage is still surfacing and it's shocking. Only hosted on gore sites or military sites. I don't stand with that. It wasn't freedom fighting or resistance. It was an atrocity.

[@joseywales148]

Only Americans are childish enough to believe in such nonsense that hasn’t been independently verified…

[@gompsie]

@@nikosantikythera2422 She lied thats what..........

[@ocan1033]

When she starts saying “Robbie” a lot things have gone off the rails.

[@TheNancypoo]

Exactly, she's so condescending! And it doesn't help that he goes by 'Robby' 🙄

[@QuikNik14]

@@TheNancypooy’all are so sensitive. Robby must be on the Israeli government payroll

[@ef7971]

The one that is so condescending is Robbie@@TheNancypoo

[@choppermorgan9946]

God bless Israel God bless America

[@captainz9]

There us no mystery why I pretty rarely bothering listening to The Hill anymore.

[@tenayasims]

Awesome episode; going toe-to-toe without descending into chaos. Many thanks.

[@natashber]

Brie is excellent in presenting the hypocrisy of this whole situation

[@23BRBurton]

The only hypocrisy here is that Hamas is to blame, they took the money the world gave them and bought rockets and weapons, and built tunnels instead of investing in infrastructure.

[@sdljvbnskvdsdvkjva5131]

Brie is wrong, and you are one with the sheep.

[@Smoothblue90]

Bri is a little snarky and condescending.

[@gghstlr]

@@sdljvbnskvdsdvkjva5131 what an intelligent comment

[@liamwayne6703]

While I agree with Robby, Bri is handling herself far better in these heated debates. "What is wrong with you" is the most Ad Hominem attack as there can be, and he needs to be denounced for it.

[@OCP74]

No. She keeps insinuating that he means something other than what he is telling her.

[@bpmtatom]

Robbie was out of line. Bri is very careful about what she says and how based on comments of people on here. The fact that distinction is not taken into account is what is bothersome. The burden always seems to be on the black woman. Yet she is always the most composed, articulate, and respectful in terms of discourse.

[@wolfwind1]

@@bpmtatom She is arrogant, manipulative, and inflammatory. Reject your race essentialism.

[@ef7971]

@@OCP74 so you would be okay with someone yelling at you the same he yelled at her? It helps to put yourself in other peoples shoes. Theres's good and respectful ways of communicating, but his yelling is not the right way. Also, she asked him to look it up in his computer to proof her wrong......and he didn't which means he's wrong, and you're wrong as well.

[@Schismatise]

Yeah I used to side with Robby over Bri on most issues, but since this one started I'm not as much of a Robby fan. His emotional expressions are fair-ish, but he does interrupt a lot.

[@CraigJS91]

I love how Robby kept correcting her on the difference between Hamas and Palestinians in general. She constantly tries to conflate the two as if anyone who is opposed to Hamas is in favor of Palestinian civilian deaths. Either her world view is truly distorted or she's playing a devious trick to try and make anyone who sees Hamas as the primary enemy in this conflict be viewed as pro-Palestinian genocide. Also find it funny how she continues to ignore the fact that Hamas intentionally uses it's civilians as human shields.

[@JuliusGalacki]

The human shield shibboleth is pulled out frequently, yet no definitive proof is ever given. Israel releases propaganda videos with animations or photos of missile batteries in Syria and then labels them as Hamas, etc., as if that's actual proof. On the other hand, there has been UN documentation of Israel using Palestinians as human shields forcing them to walk along their tanks in 2014. Even if Hamas is putting its weapons near civilian infrastructure - logically a possibility given the population density of Gaza - it's still a war crime to bomb civilians. Just as it would be a war crime for Hamas to shoot rockets at all the Israeli military bases which are also built near civilians (e.g. the main headquarters in Tel Aviv)/.

[@ef7971]

I don't think you watched the same video as we all did. Who is the person who kept funding Hamas? FYI Bibi. I think you're the one who's world view is truly distorted. No one is saying that Hamas is good. What Bri is stating is that Robbie always puts down the Palestians the same way he puts down Hamas. If you don't know, they are BOTH different. And the ones who are the same is the Israel government, Bibi, and Hamas. Get it straight.

[@emandm1822]

Brie makes the best arguments when i mute the volume anytime she speaks

[@bvfckyou]

Ribby has the patience of a Saint with this manipulative, hypocritical and deceptive woman

[@Guadalupe1130]

Whatever The Hill is paying Robby is not enough. It's remarkable that he can remain as composed as he does during these holier-than-thou tirades from Bri.

[@nicolegilzene7995]

Because he is afraid of being called a white Supremest

[@bambooblinds]

correct

[@ryanrex297]

It’s a tough subject with many angles. I applaud the spirited debate as long as you both respect one another at the end of the day. Thank you.

[@joshbobst1629]

You would enjoy the Callin episodes where some of us have had...heated...criticisms of Robby, and Briahna says you got to leave my guy Robby alone, I love him.

[@barbaraibiel]

The population of Gaza overwhelmingly voted for Hamas.

[@crhu319]

Once in 2006.

[@edyouwakim998]

And the US voted for biden? It's all bs.

[@dark_winter8238]

A majority of the population was not alive the last time they voted....

[@thomasgreene4709]

Thats why they re in the situation they are in.

[@NaymitMayne]

They didn’t and that was - long time ago and they didn’t want the PLo who was working for the cia and isrsel. It wasn’t majority but enough and it was the only choice and hamas hadn’t become what Netanyahu turned it into

[@riancreamer6904]

I saw footage of Israeli first responders in bits who described the babies without heads. People asking for 'proof' really need to ask themselves if they'd want images of their headless, murdered baby shown around the world. How many asked for: proof of masks efficacy, that ivermectin didn't work or that lockdowns were effective. Barely anyone, that's who! Get you all happily went along with it ... We believe what we want, or are told to, unless we actively and critically think about things.

[@jayglover9961]

Not all went with b.s. some of us saw right through it.

[@samabderrazzaq1836]

I have more respect for Brie every time I hear her speak.

[@lady4191]

😂😂😂

[@5Gburn]

@@lady4191 Feels like this entire commentsection is.bots, doesn't it?

[@awesomerpower]

On this subject she’s throwing him to the floor every day.

[@deltabravo3477]

Nah she can’t see anything but her side. It’s embarrassing to listen to her. Almost as bad as when she reported a parody as news.

[@paaklapi]

To be honest, I've lost almost all respect for Bri because of her coverage of Israel and Palestine. She is so entrenched in her pro-Palestine position that she's willing to clutch at any straws to minimise Hamas' crimes. This makes her appear utterly psychopathic.

[@peterdrake9615]

Bri's correct isn't she? Is there photo evidence of those dead babies anywhere on the net? I haven't seen it. But babies or no babies I still feel it's a deflection from the real issues involved in this conflict.

[@NPC-bs3pm]

Remove George Santos? What about the man that pulled the fire Alarm not that long ago⁉

[@DavidJohnson-dc8lu]

Rather than casting blame the MASS of the world must call for peace, peace for Palestinians and Israeli's!

[@Allahverdieva]

Brie, you’re absolutely right! The fact is a fact. You are very honest, smart and brave journalist on American Tv today. Stay strong and tell truth, no matter what.

[@17Clovers]

She's not a journalist though, she doesn't do any investigative reporting, a liberal media analyst more accurate.

[@paaklapi]

Bri is hanging on the 40 beheaded babies story precisely because she's clutching at _any_ straws to minimise the depravity of Hamas' terrorist attacks. I'm glad Robby pointed this out.

[@gorkyd7912]

Yes, it's always smart and brave when you choose the side of the murderous people so you don't get murdered from the safety of the countries you're betraying. She should change citizenship.

[@Allahverdieva]

⁠​⁠@@gorkyd7912she speaks from the position of humanism and non-selective justice. The rest is your fantasy.

[@wilderjacob6]

I've never actually seen two people physically hold themselves back from just a slew of words coming out to make their point😂 Still though absolutely great work you two!!

[@gregcoogan8270]

You think its great work to justify the actions of a terrorist organization?

[@ndcoltsfan]

@@gregcoogan8270stop

[@MadManUSMC]

The terrorist organization created by Israel to stop a 2 state solution? KZbin "ron paul hamas" Do you think it's great work spouting nonsense, knowing nothing about the conflict since 1948? What about the USS Liberty? Nothing? You may be in the way of the new dawn.@@gregcoogan8270

[@fatdoi003]

the Hill should move the set to a pub...

[@wilderjacob6]

@@fatdoi003 😂😂😂😂

[@rafchez1970]

She needs to be this upset with the black on black crimes in our own country

[@timothydudley3106]

Rashida Talib should be censored it’s crazy not to censor a person who speaks so antisemitic as a member of congress!!!

[@syashadeed7552]

Hasbara AIPAC commenters all over these videos. Thanks Brie for being composed and delivering the correct message

[@nuriben7910]

your American tax dollars in action.

[@SixOneNiner23]

Wait til Elon and Bibis new AI kicks in, we’ll never know the truth again.

[@chadwalrod795]

@@SixOneNiner23 Yeah, kinda like stolen elections and a media/govt relationship suppressing anything that may not fit its narrative. 🤔

[@mauscuba]

Not just YT... Every social media platform you see AIPAC money is at work... The floodgates of Pro-IDF, Pro-Israel (and the Arab=terrorists) "commenters" has been opened... All trying to curb the contributions of people like Brianna Joy Gray...

[@1antoniov1]

Calling Jews hasbara is degrading them . Does it make you happy ?

[@SlimFadi]

It’s interesting how Robby only gets emotional while defending Israel genocide

[@narendra62]

What genocide? I guarantee there will be plenty of Palestinian terrorists for Israel to worry about in the future. Feel sorry for the Jews, Muslims have a pathological hatred for them. First they steal their religious myths, then their wives and children, their dignity, their homeland and their capital.

[@intricatic]

Oh, how the mighty have fallen. And today, MTG is freaking out because she might have to stop being antisemitic if the antisemitism bill passes.

[@atom7134]

You know Robbie's losing a debate pretty badly when he starts getting extra dramatic for the cameras 💀

[@saulgoode5923]

This is why I love this show. One person is factually correct and doesn't let the other one move the goalpost on the conversation. Good stuff Brie-Joy, and Bobby.

[@aM-nc8ix]

I’m proud of this sista, finally a someone vwith my complexion is defending oppressed people

[@alaskayoung3413]

@@aM-nc8ixwow you’re such a bot. Maybe try to hide it better next time. Made me physically laugh at loud with the whole complexion bS.

[@aM-nc8ix]

@@alaskayoung3413 when your great grandfather is hanging from a tree in Tennessee in his uniform after fighting the nazis WW2, you may cultivate a little more compassion for people other than European

[@BelowMeGoggle]

No, just Brie. Bobby is pro-open borders and pro-home invaders, antithetical positions for a Libertarian.

[@alaskayoung3413]

@@aM-nc8ix what’s your grandfathers full name? I’d love to look him up.

[@wdjaz]

Great discussion. Thanks guys. This is the only way we'll understand each other. Keep on talking!

[@marilynbouziane5530]

And what about 4000 thousand babies torn apart at the other camp? I forgot that 1 Israeli is maybe equivalent to 10 arabs!

[@the.shahjahan]

That guy needs to reprogram himself from his Israeli indoctrination

[@Goldun-nah]

It’s that last statement Bri made. That’s sums up exactly why we stand where we stand.

[@yn5568]

As in straw-man argument? Brie’s last statement is a clear example of thay

[@m_moehring]

Her final statement is that she's a "humanist." A humanist who downplays, disregards, and even denies the deaths of Israelis? Biden shouldn't have said what he did, but that doesn't discount actual deaths, and Bri seems much more concerned about the Biden inaccuracy than the actual deaths. She uses it to dodge the question of whether or not she believes there are any Israeli blown apart children.

[@kb2x172]

Brie torched Robby on this debate. He lost the argument by many points, and was forced to back track some of his position.

[@kirktravis5780]

​@@kb2x172only because he doesn't have his talking points down. And I'm sorry her beheaded children was a false claim so everything is a false claim is poor debate.

[@ericb6048]

@@kb2x172 you really don't comprehend structure of discussion. On this level, there is no win-lose.. there is only the furthering or deafening of clarity for both parties. Stop thinking like a 2nd grader... think like an adult.

[@moetube74]

Why is it that every time Robie blames HAMAS for something she tells him he is blaming the Palestinians? In her eyes are they separate or not? Doesn't seem like it.

[@zufalllx]

Probably because Israel treat them both as one in the same

[@moetube74]

@@zufalllx I'm talking about the discussion between the two on the show not what Israel is doing. Is he an individual or is he Israel?

[@janemueller653]

Are you watching the same video? 10:39 She said he’s correct it’s Hamas that’s guilty! She’s 100% correct about everything else cuz it’s facts not her opinion! Robbie believes what he wants to believe but after getting debunked, he says he doesn’t know the exact number etc. he’s a closeted racist and genocide supporter, and so is anyone that agrees with him!

[@moetube74]

@@janemueller653I suggest you listen again. I’m talking about her responses to Robbie talking about Hamas. When he blamed Hamas she kept trying to include Palestinians. She kept doing it.

[@moetube74]

@@janemueller653 Robbie even had to correct her a couple of times and tell her don’t you mean Hamas.

[@butragenjo007]

Don't forget Egypt was blockading Gaza for years too

[@mohamedrabie3646]

Are you crazy ?? Egypt borders gate are open and has no access for a goods entrance .. Rfah gate is for passengers only … omg Zionists are breathing lies