Robot Dogs Competition 2024

[@santiagoH-vo6so]

Very impressive! The 1300 dollars Go2 is better than the 74500 dollars BD. Unitree will be the next DJI.

[@PiefacePete46]

I do not know which is better... if you have reached your conclusion based on what you saw in this video ONLY, the fair thing would be to research further.

[@lmn6335]

@@PiefacePete46 From the video, it’s clear that the Chinese robotic dog wins. Without any preconceived notions, acknowledging the facts and giving some praise isn’t that hard.

[@PiefacePete46]

@@lmn6335 : Fair comment. As you say, "the Chinese robotic dog wins"... however, it only wins this run of this challenge. I note you did not say it was "better" which was my point. I have no problem giving praise for a resounding win on this run. Sadly, I was not at the actual event. My reply was prompted by people deciding one contestant is "Better", based on what was shown in a single run. I believe that contestant can be declared the winner of that attempt... nothing more. Olympic Decathlon contests are decided after a number of attempts at a variety of challenges, which makes sense to me. One of the contestants here had an obvious catastrophe on the run shown... subsequent runs may have resulted in the opposite result. The winner of this challenge may not have won a different task. I also feel that the price, and the country of manufacture should not be used to reach a conclusion. Of course, if you are actually buying one, these would be extremely important factors! I am not able to do that either! 😜

[@cabasadefogo9533]

The Uni tree dogs are being deployed in real world situations. Carrying supply up mountains, being SWAT team member of police, retail consumer use etc. this level of penetration means refinement and feedback will be orders of magnitude higher for Unitree. It’s already better than BD in some aspects. It will become light years better in a year or two!

[@zhli4238]

One is still at experimental stage, the other is marketed as consumer electronics. You'd know the unit price difference.

[@Floucensuremoi]

Unitree Go2 : 1.600$ and Boston Dynamics spot : 75.000$ 😅

[@DIY_RC-j2g]

Like electric cars, BYD vs Tesla 😂😂

[@aftereffects00]

Obviously, GO is better than BD, and the price is cheaper

[@franklee9353]

BD is better

[@jzNottobee]

Go look at the Chinese robo wolves! This dog is miserable!

[@samtat5873]

​@@franklee9353 🤭🤣🤣😂😂

[@chihhou]

Fail to understand why GO is better? Go has hard time to find the right path and struggle to move smoothly and efficiently.

[@nandehutu2194]

Sorry. BD is much better. If there is no wall, the Go2 is allready fall dowan outside.

[@AwardQueue]

Unitree serials got the top medal.

[@LokeKS]

videos?

[@chankaan888]

Unitree B2 is a quadruped robot product released by China Unitree Technology on November 3, 2023

[@xwqi]

Obviously, this road barrier is designed for BD.Appropriate height，The B2 radar is on the back.The horizontal line of radar scanning is inaccurate, while the radar of GO2 is below.It's about to hit the ground.

[@VituswongWong]

This kind of competitions, no matter you are win or lose, it is good to the whole robotic development and improvement.

[@laujimmy9282]

Definitely, it's an interesting competition

[@cmleong]

It was stunning to see the Boston Dynamic dog going backwards and recalling its precise successful steps to its point of origin.

[@mangafandi]

Impressive performance by BD, but due to the sheer price alone I think the GO2 will have a lot more community developed software in the future (an in turn find more use in real life projects). Often times a large community trumps enterprise grade hardware/software.

[@alhkcblack9617]

Cool video. The Boston dog is more accurate but slower. I think the Boston dog must be scanning multiple times more than the unitree and and so the processing is also longer. The unitree looks faster but not as accurate. Prioritizing recovery from trips vs avoiding mistakes to begin with. I would say if these were weaponized and chasing me. I would not be scared of the Boston dog as much because it's slow. I'll just throw a bunch of junk on the floor and it'll take longer to get past it but the unitree I'd be terrified of because it just scrambles over whatever it is, not caring if it trips or what, and just keeps coming.

[@byhyew]

It's DJI vs Skydio all over again.

[@zephyrwestern3056]

6:08 this is shocking

[@turningnull2538]

exactly!! such a cool move and flip back within 1s

[@dogymal7260]

BD took 10s to get up

[@川建国-n9l]

@@dogymal7260 More like 45 seconds from 0:13 to 0:58

[@shaulbenshimon6463]

Разный размер роботов и соответственно масштаб полигона. Трасса полосы препятствий должна быть в одинаковом масштабе пропорционально.

[@jzNottobee]

Go look at the Chinese robo wolves! This dog is miserable!

[@50Herosim]

Учитывая что китаец в 10 дешевле то он более перспективный

[@chengjung5300]

Boston dynamics has been researching on its robots for at least 20 years. I wonder why they don't come up with some commercially affordable dogs (I do know they have some industrial and military products). To say in another way, even if the BD dog is "smarter", it's still too far away from the general public.

[@dapje2002]

Why BD doesn't have cheap robots? Because like you yourself said, they have been doing research for more than 20 years, bearing all the costs for R&D. China just uses industrial espionage to pillage BD's IP, so of course they can do it cheaper without the research costs. I hope this answers your question.

[@chengjung5300]

@dapje2002 I'm afraid that it doesn't answer the whole question. (1) If Unitree did infringe BD's IPs, BD should have filed lawsuits, but I can only find BD tried to sue Ghost robotics. And it brings to (2) If that's not easy to define IP theft in the robotics field, then that's probably explain why BD's ownership has been shifted around. And (3), probably the most important point, high research budget doesn't prevent it from coming up with some commercially affordable products.

[@suryatobing]

@@dapje2002 by saying china doing industrial espionage to pillage BD's IP, can you your proof?

[@emhgarlyyeung]

Agree with u

[@ttfoo]

@@dapje2002 Whenever China come up with something equivalent or better, we'll see this same old accusation of espionage & IP theft, without presenting any evidence. Go and get yourself understand the actual China, how many STEM graduates & PhDs they produce every year & how much they spend in R&D each year.

[@MengGuoZhou]

Asia eating the USA in plain view. Meanwhile, American diapers have been doing an outstanding job. Job's done!

[@kennethkay1144]

Aisa stealing American tech again.

[@Player2blood]

Wrong Boston dynamics robot place it feet correctly on surface. Chinese robot don't know where to place feet

[@MengGuoZhou]

@@Player2blood A matter of weeks. Keep dreaming and playing poker :)))

[@orion3253]

Which year did you become a racist?

[@BACA01]

They are copying USA in plain view, while unable to innovate on their own, i bet the diapers you talk about are yours own.

[@Alex-zz6vt]

It's obvious BD has an advanced algorithm for Parkinson syndrome and Elderly dementia build in. That's why it's selling for so high.😂

[@bcda-sl3gi]

3:42 is Unitree B2, not Unitree GO2

[@codersvoice1213]

Thanks! You are right! I made a mistake.

[@snoopy81]

Unitree feel like drunken step😂

[@hangug_gamja]

god damn, let them fight I wanna see oil

[@camdenuptown1777]

oilbath fight😂

[@RodrigoPalma700]

Always choose original robots and never cheap Chinese copies. It would be suicidal.

[@JanasonJin-w3w]

波士顿的狗老了

[@TomLo-i9c]

擺明強迫機械狗勞動,大家一定要成立一個,保護機械動物協會,禁止強迫勞動,虐待機械動物💪💪💪

[@laujimmy9282]

😂😂😂

[@alxvideos6634]

你整天刷手机，手机要罢工了

[@lotfree]

智械危机的时候：留这个人类一条命😂

[@yaglehoole5662]

Modi and Jaishankar can just run their mouths and then all is well.

[@combat_fighter1]

now we all know how to trap robot dogs hahaha

[@50Herosim]

Мне интересно другое какая дальность управления в городской застройки. Я бы ещё на них добавил трёх осевую стабилизационную камеру на верху с углом поворота 300°

[@cloverpower4662]

go 2 data is changed by japanese, so it is not fluent

[@chinagod1]

莫名其妙

[@cloverpower4662]

@@chinagod1 确实是，本来很流畅，他做研究的，一直改里面的数据，研究，弄得很不协调

[@petechen794]

Go is better

[@dustwatcher1963]

Someone is controlling the Unitree dog?

[@blackknight4996]

Yes, advanced AI ...United Snakes has NONE!

[@laujimmy9282]

Right, because everyone is blind

[@Player2blood]

Boston dynamics robot. Know where to place it feet. Chinese own don't. It just place it leg randomly

[@GeoPoly214]

Chinese robot much more agile than American robot

[@pinkeggrollwaffle]

@@GeoPoly214 i will take open source chinese robot girlfriend from aliexpress please

[@aftereffects00]

Obviously, GO is better than BD, and the price is cheaper

[@aftereffects00]

If the Boston Dynamics robot knew where to place its feet, with its price, it shouldn’t walk like a drunk man.

[@Player2blood]

@@aftereffects00 look at the video. You will see that it's placing it feet's wisely. Not disorderly like unitree. But I recommend, unitree is cheap than spot mini and the difference interms of capability is not much

[@kavorka8855]

Unitree uses an adapted American open source software LeRobot, the hardware is obviously also open source.

[@aronyang]

meaningless statement, why don't you build a better one?

[@kavorka8855]

@@aronyang what do you mean? Why should I build better one and what's that to do with my factual comment?

[@infoworld7706]

more like references

[@SamuelSo1018]

酸🍋

[@fufu9352]

幽默开源哥

[@gregoriosalazar1418]

Chinese dog is a copy from BD dog, China didnt have a dog before BD reveal his.

[@chinagod1]

在非洲人之前也没有欧洲人，所以你们是非洲人的翻版吗？

[@gregoriosalazar1418]

@@chinagod1nop, that doesnt eliminate the fact that China copies everything.

[@masterwong5568]

波士顿动力只是没有拿出他们最厉害的机器人而已

[@ethanzhong5717]

真的是太孝了。🤣🤣🤣

[@中国螃蟹哥]

最厉害不就是你这傻狗吗(👉≧ヮ≦)👉😂

[@AwardQueue]

美国的大殖子

[@emhgarlyyeung]

洗刷刷 洗刷刷😂😂 玻绿心

[@ricosu192]

这就是一个骗钱的公司

[@假行僧-m1i]

BD选错了路 液压式关节一旦漏夜下场会很惨 电机式关节才是未来的发展方向