Rockstar's Remarkable Maps (Feat. Badger Goodger)

[@BadgerGoodger]

Thanks for inviting me to collab! Rockstar's map design is such an interesting subject and they pack so much detail into them, I could practically spend hours talking about each one.

[@moldyshoess]

😎

[@galilalexandro4793]

Hi badger

[@yaboique6650]

I do drugs

[@METZUZ12]

@@yaboique6650 Ok

[@Nacut6c]

We give Rockstar a lot of shit for stuff like not releasing GTA 6, not making a Bully sequel or for what GTA Online has become, and rightfully so, but we have to appreciate their work and what they have put out through the years. My life would be different without Rockstars' titles.

[@CaptainAmercia]

They gave us RDR2 so give them time there in the works

[@Strange_Man1911]

Where the problem begins is on multiplayer and lack of added dlc content on some of their single player games.

[@sidwasgaming2458]

Too much content yeah but you realize how much content they have put out through the years I don’t know any other games that have added that much tbh I think we’re just spoiled when it comes to gta

[@Anson_The_Pro]

No matter how long they delay it, fact is we have to wait anyway and it will probably be an outstanding game

[@jortharob3406]

@Henrik K You gotta remember everyone is making a Open world. Plus now they might have real competition with CDPR and Cyberpunk, so whatever they are doing they are gonna put their all. into it

[@CSYON]

Thats why GTA was and still is my favourite game series. You can still find new details after playing it for years.

[@deepakbanikworld]

rockstar games rocks pal,its not a cyberpunk tragedy

[@julek4248]

Moin csyon

[@rolux4853]

Minus the damn online bullshit! I get it, they make millions from minors playing this adult game, because these kids want fancy ingame cloth. But is such a shame that single player add ons died for this bullshit! GTA 4 had so nice additional stories, that made you discover it’s whole world from a different perspective and that drew me in even more! While story wise gta 5 is still my favorite (followed closely by San Andreas) it’s such a shame that there is no way to live in this world other than the main game. It’s so sad, that they choose money over content. They abandoned everything they stood for up to GTA 4, just because of money.. It’s a perfect example of capitalism gone wrong.

[@jgunner94]

@@rolux4853 To be honest I’d rather they not put major resources towards expansions and let smaller teams like they do work on the online and have the head writers work on the next big project. In today’s age to make a very good expansion it would probably take 1-2 years compared to maybe 6-12 months like it did 10 years ago. The expectations has risen and the work to create the detail they’d want would be more.

[@EthanL21800]

@@jgunner94 with a full team it could still take less than 9 months for a good addition

[@harshswaika7845]

Such an underrated channel. This video shows how much effort went into this. Keep up the good work mate.

[@lumbagoman4938]

preach man

[@AlexanderJ420]

Seriously

[@sebastianarty549]

I think he’s been getting noticed more like 2 months ago when I started watching his channel he 20k subscribers and since then he’s gotten 34k subscribers

[@ghxstprod]

I wish we could give him subscribers

[@adeebkhan9118]

Yeah bro

[@samuelteles12]

Rockstar games are basically a love and hate relationship with their public

[@xxxod]

it's better to have a love-hate relationship. Ass-kissers are not as loyal.

[@fiercegameryt9173]

@@xxxod true(EA sports crying 😢)

[@pjetrs]

Im curious, why? I have never had anything but love for them, their games are all classics. Even with minor misses, they are miles ahead of any other game

[@ethanprice8811]

I relate so much in life haha love hate relationship it's so true tho

[@Aaron-uz8xt]

@@pjetrs because everyone wants GTA 6. We’ve been waiting 7 years and have only got RDR2 during that time (which is beautiful).

[@beesafterdark5644]

I'm absolutely obsessed with their detail and realism. They really hit the nail on the head with red dead 2.

[@Ben-io2vo]

How so?

[@jovannixr2988]

@@Ben-io2vo it’s good. That’s how

[@360eradaryl7]

In the main story yes. But when we head into the epilogue after 8 years there’s no improvement nothing drastically new to it, it felt like a cop out. It was heading towards to the end of the Wild West era like it said so I wanted to see more movements to that, maybe dead towns from the ms turned into a populated town.

[@cjmurphy7967]

Rdr2 is tied with skyrim for my all time favorite game. Not only is its map massive ( bigger than even gta5's) but it feels so full, every 8nch populated with wildlife, npcs, activities and missions, Easter eggs, no part is left empty.

[@360eradaryl7]

@@cjmurphy7967 ummm the rdr2 has been proven to be smaller than the gta v map.

[@haweewee282]

biggest proof of this video is how memorable rockstars maps are. You could send me a photo of a random curb or store in gta, and I'd be able to tell you where it is on the map instantly.

[@southpineshooligan]

facts.. i know GTAV's map better than my own city, and i know my city like the back of my hand haha

[@robinbanks1291]

Hello Goro Dogima

[@Chuked]

San Andreas for me its so memorable

[@nerdybacon6244]

Who wants to bet this guy can do this.

[@Clay3613]

No L.A. Noire? I know they didn't technically develop it, but the amount of research done to recreate 1940s L.A. was insane.

[@drgnomeblox7785]

Agreed

[@UOHCUNY]

too bad the open world is usless for that game

[@drgnomeblox7785]

@@UOHCUNY true actually but it was fun to roam around after finishing the main campaign

[@ryhanzfx1641]

@@UOHCUNY well just imagine like mafia, its linear but explorable worlds

[@dopey473]

Same with Midnight Club L.A. The most accurate depiction of modern L.A.

[@geofffreighbigginshire]

L.A Noire is underrated too. Its interesting to see a 1940 - 1950s town era.

[@suhasop4919]

Especially the Hollywoodland Sign

[@jacksonlarson6099]

There's not much to do in the open world of LA Noire, but damn if it isn't the most accurate video game map ever made. I can't imagine the amount of research it took to painstakingly recreate 1947 downtown LA, building by building and street by street. I really hope to see a map like that in the future.

[@jondoe406]

IIRC even the house numbers are correct. You can google the address and see the same house in real life

[@MitchellBPYao]

​@@jacksonlarson6099like can have your own character working with the

[@jacksonlarson6099]

@@MitchellBPYao with the what? I'm on the edge of my seat!

[@rodriggrrr9788]

Ocean: "Urrh, already said too much bad things about Rockstar. Let's do the reverse"

[@mog7501]

At this point we gotta accept R* is gonna take forever for GTA 6 and will continue to milk the shit out of GTA 5 Online so why not just focus on the positive and push Rockstar to make GTA 6 an absolute banger?

[@mrshortlegrick884]

@@mog7501 I agree

[@riptidev10]

@@mog7501 they went overboard with RDR 2 times over which led to a reform. There's nothing you can push for gta 6, gta online is so broken everywhere, cuckstar needs to address the game breaking bugs

[@ryhanzfx1641]

@@riptidev10 you must have a shite pc to even complain the slightest bugs, this channel already tells you to DO NOT play the online mode

[@motherhors7036]

@@mog7501lol

[@Razorjaw86]

Trust me dude, not matter how big the map is, you don’t want 300 players in a lobby at once

[@pentaboss1351]

Max 60-100 in my opinion

[@Razorjaw86]

PentaBOSS Not everyone has good internet though

[@nazriljimmy2688]

Imagine having 50+ Oppressor Mk2 flying around the map

[@reverietapes]

I feel like having that many players at once would just break the game

[@Lucas_Antar]

Razor jaw86 then they’ll lag out. Bye bye.

[@bydreaminc]

One of the details that always got me in GTA IV was when you had an incoming call and you happened to be in a car; You can hear a faint buzzing on the radio station moments before the call is connected. That blew me away as that is so unbelievably true to life.

[@inzanity490]

When I first heard it I looked for my real life phone.

[@Lucas_Antar]

I know Southern San Andreas(GTA5 Map) better than my own hometown. I can navigate without a map or GPS. Rockstar did such a good job to make the world feel real. I may have been born in Massachusetts but I was raised in San Andreas.

[@hawkskipper5537]

Damn, very well said.

[@Bindogz]

That's sad, raised in a gta game 😂

[@JMR_2028]

C B bruh it was a play on words

[@brettdown1521]

@@Bindogz he wasn't actually raised in it lol just played it a lit

[@arandomboi7611]

Imagine having low emotional intelligence

[@mazda9624]

2008 really was an incredible year for open world games: GTA IV Saints Row 2 Burnout Paradise Fallout 3 just to name a few

[@yaboique6650]

And Rockstar's Midnight Club: Los Angeles!

[@jhean3415]

And Rockstar's Midnight Club: Los Angeles!

[@mazda9624]

How the hell did I forget Rockstar Game's Midnight Club: Los Angeles? I've spent more hours of my life than I'd care to admit in that game!

[@DurangoCzechoslovakia]

And Rockstar’s Midnight Club:Los Angeles!

[@tlam3028]

And Rockstar’s Midnight Club: Los Angeles!

[@spartan117zm]

I think one big thing Rockstar needs is more interiors in GTA. Even if it’s just the podium/lobby areas for skyscrapers and then maybe one or two floors near the top, that’s still more than most of what they’ve got now. And what about that huge mall near the Ponsonby’s? That would’ve been great to have a lot of stores in. I also think more overall world interaction would be good; I miss that they took out the ability to go into a Burger Shot or the chicken place and actually sit down and eat, for example.

[@IskenderCaglarM41B441]

I would like to explore airports.

[@chris86simon]

@@justanotherghost4589 Or actually be able to order at Burger Shot or Clucking Bell again. Go to the gym and actually get ripped. They had tennis, so why not be able to use the gym equipment on the beach?

[@HomoErected]

To think they did that in V to give us gorgeous underwater

[@bluscout1857]

Honestly for me it’s even if it wasn’t a seemless transition I’d still be fine if they just brought it back at least

[@Jiub_SN]

4 had that with a lot of locations. Anywhere you could enter for missions was open, and there were even some extra places. V was lacking in so many areas tbh

[@22XERO22]

"You can find the smallest of details in the biggest feature of every GTA game" Same thing with your videos.

[@PabloRodriguez-cl4ox]

Ass kiss

[@xShottyXSpartan45]

@@PabloRodriguez-cl4ox lmao my thoughts exactly.

[@itzGKG]

Bro the edits have me amazed

[@22XERO22]

@@PabloRodriguez-cl4ox cry about it.

[@K3hlz]

EVERYONE SHOULD KNOW ABOUT THİS CHANNEL DUDE İTS SOOOO GOOD

[@bakbanaantjed8508]

How’d you get out of karlson?

[@K3hlz]

@@bakbanaantjed8508 computers

[@tsitsush]

Shut up thicc Billy

[@peterpirateblaze]

Yo billy wtf? How did you escape from the basement?

[@InsertHandleHereYo]

Frick billy

[@mystexe]

R*’s map design is why people think we all live in a simulation

[@adwaitshrivastava10thb35]

Exactly

[@Rodeo_Rodeo]

I mean we theoretically could be We could just be inside a book and God is the author and assuming every character in a story people create is alive, then i feel bad for the people who live in the universe where their God just straight up destroy them 24/7

[@Yujuchingu]

@@Rodeo_Rodeo lmao

[@IskenderCaglarM41B441]

I want to live in rockstar worlds. It's better than real.

[@Yan2295.]

I've randomly stumbled upon this video in my recommended to then see myself mentioned in it. Small world, uh. Great video!

[@DarkSpaceStudios]

Glad to see you back on this channel!

[@doomslayer5453]

5:17 I already have 2 reasons to leave the city 1. My bunker is at the very tip of the map 2. It’s just fun!

[@huzzzer6083]

And also just standing on top of Mount Chilliad, admiring the view is amazing.

[@doomslayer5453]

@@huzzzer6083 true

[@Sopranos608]

Not as san andreas...., I really feel lazy to go to paleto Bay

[@omegadomega]

You should get a zancudo or chumash bunker as paleto bunker kinda sucks

[@aj-sj6xc]

I have my bunker and my 3 MC businesses in Grand Senora, but it is true that i don't visit Paleto Bay that much outside of setups and resupplies but it isn't that bad

[@warnut8]

San Diego has huge potential for a GTA game. It's right on the border with Mexico (cartels, people smuggling?), has lots of military bases (secret weapons and stealth break-in missions?) and has a huge biomedical industry, which has a story potential too.

[@drippydooku6347]

id like chacargo aswell

[@cube9967]

I’d like a gta set in like Canada, New England or the Pacific Northwest

[@kendrezflournoy2429]

What about an GTA set in Atlanta?

[@pyetr7120]

​@drippydooku6347 Chacargo??? 😂 Holy shit our schools are abysmal

[@mikopiko]

The production quality of this video is astonishing, promise me you will keep it that way!

[@DarkSpaceStudios]

It's a promise!

[@meghanachauhan9380]

Fangirl

[@SFH_Jenkins]

This channel has a better production quality than some professional multi million dollar companies

[@CuteSkyler]

It has so much overediting, I can't focus on a single thing in a video The reverb in his voice is so weird and jilted

[@DarkSpaceStudios]

@@CuteSkyler I agree, the reverb is out. Audio is honestly my biggest weakness so I'm working harder at it for the next video. Addressing the over editing, idk man, that's just the point of the video - to be very edited.

[@olliebonugli8881]

I never noticed any issues with audio or overediting

[@jaredthebest154xbox]

Take two *cough* cough*

[@Tamaldo]

Watching this after the GTA trilogy definitive edition was released... Kinda feels like a kick in the teeth seeing how low Rockstar have stooped

[@minor7607]

My thoughts exactly, tragic really...

[@evilbluntgaming]

They were lazy n hired the wrong ppl for the job

[@anonymous_dot_com2326]

But dude, why are we rockstar fans so selfish... Rhey are busy creating whats about to be the biggest game for decades just for us, so that we dont feel like we waste 60usd... These type of games only come out once every 10 years... Watch when gta 6 releases, everyone will jump back and suck rockstar's dick again just like how they did after rdr2 dropped .... Before rdr2 dropped, people were trashing on rockstar for online.... But when rdr2 released, all of a sudden, Rockstar is king... Now that rdr2 is aging(that game doesnt age though, ive never seen a game so ahead of its time) people are back at trashing rockstar... Then when gta 6 drops, its the same shit... And dont say it wont be the same because Of Dan and lezlie.... There is only 1 VIP in rockstar, if he leaves its the end of rockstar games, and thats Phil Hooker, Leading Director of Technology and programming in Rockstar Studios... Calm down Rockstar is working in something huge, thats why expanded and enhanced and the trilogy are ass

[@JudeTheYoutubePoopersubscribe]

They didn't make it lol. They did fuck up though by tasking mobile phone game developers to do the job. It should of been done in house and all 3 classics should of got the mafia treatment but on the gta 5 engine.

[@JTidiotboy]

I love how people just completely forget about RDR 2 as if it wasn't the last thing they've made. Grove Street Games handled the trilogy remasters. And yeah, that was a really dumb decision, but it's not a situation where Rockstar just completely forgot how to make good games. They chose poorly. Wait until GTA VI before you start assuming the worst. I know I sound like a fanboy (and I kinda am, I guess) but people shouldn't panic before we even have a glimpse of VI.

[@RadionYT]

to be honest porting every map of gta into one big map sounds cool but imagine the file size of such a map. probably 250-300gb?

[@PolarisCastillo]

Not to mention starting up the game every time would take longer than GTA V takes now

[@DirtyMikeHoncho]

@@PolarisCastillo lol ps5 is capable of loading 5gb a second or some shit

[@benjaminkaric2874]

Well the things is, if u put them all together, you have to change the textures of the maps before GTA v, it's a huge amount of work.

[@RadionYT]

@@benjaminkaric2874 and huge maps like gta San Andreas have to be redone from scratch. That's adds up to the work

[@sensacionsombria5125]

@@RadionYT GTA SA map is not huge, it's actually pretty small

[@CancerGaming56]

What is underappreciated in terms of RDR2 map design is that they made a large state (New Austin) with loads of easter eggs, two towns and more, when you never go there in the story or in side quests. You're only able to go there starting the Epilogue. That's genuine commitment

[@CaptainAmercia]

Mafia 1 did this as well with the city of Lost Heaven having a countryside outside of the city map where you only really go for a number of missions to single locations but Instead they made a whole area 90% you will never go in the story.

[@htmlrulezd00d99]

Well its the map of rdr 1 so they didn't make it just for rdr2. But it's cool tjat they included it, i would love to see San Fierro or Las Venturas in GTA V

[@anakinskywalker2707]

@@htmlrulezd00d99 i believe they tried but the current console of that gen would not be able to hold such a big map at the time so they expand the map using mountain and plain field instead.

[@reasons2live]

They also believe it or not have Mexico from rdr1 in there too. It’s really well made but not rendered correctly and missing walls in some buildings but it’s still really impressive

[@evrythingisayisfactzzlolll6642]

Fun Fact: rockstar only put new austin because the RDR2 map was leaked and they wanted to include something to suprise people. Thats why new austin might seem rushed or empty. (imo they did everything they could because john cant really do anything there story wise other then bounty hunt and stranger missions could of been cool but at the same time it would just feel like rdr1 again)

[@gonzolonzo1383]

My favorite party about GTA IV is the fact when recreating New York, Rockstar did what we wish we could all do and sank Staten Island into the sea

[@MaxB00M]

This reminds me of the first time I went to New York and being absolutely blown away by how many things I were able to recognize after playing gta 4 as a kid. It made me kinda feel at home in a city I've never seen before.

[@inzanity490]

@@MaxB00M man I wish I could go to New York and LA someday and experience familiarity due to hours of playing GTA 4 and 5. Unfortunately I'm in a third world asian country

[@petriusmaximus8187]

Sink Staten Island?? Dont you already know?? Wu-Tang aint nothing to fuck with......

[@Evanxbdlt]

@@MaxB00M i'd probably be able to find myself and where i am without needing a map in LA

[@BRxRanger]

Rockstar never opened the burger shop that were open in GTA 4 in GTA 5, it was one of the first places I tried to get into.

[@anuarudinbadawi428]

also gta san andreas has burger shop

[@mrk3655]

Karl Taylor you can still get food from a gas station

[@64siskat96]

@@anuarudinbadawi428 gta vice city too

[@Zman201]

@@mrk3655 but its not the same

[@mrk3655]

@@Zman201 food is food, there are different kinds of it.

[@littlebigcarrot]

that intro legit just made me get chills that was amazing

[@kylo8846]

ikr

[@rabbitwithm2495]

Have your.100th like

[@rhino5250]

Except for the music :/ that was garbage

[@stonereynolds3410]

Nah that intro was 🚮

[@conner983]

It’s like rockstar making an official promo

[@rodrigoadiogo]

I've been replaying gta 3 and even for a 2001 game, the map is really impressive, the ambience, really feels like its own world on a parallel universe

[@is2ismysenpai]

“When you play a game from rockstar you can tell that they woeked hard to sell you, not a map, but a reality” A reality with flying motercycles with rockets

[@estellaruiz3125]

The people who made the map and game are not the people who make gta online

[@jacobtremblay6568]

@mo gamer rockstar created some new vehicles that r possible to create in real life like how does the ufo's fly whit no motors? They r advanced civilization, we r not advanced as those people, so ya in movies they said it possible to have a flying car, and the oppressor it a small jet engine and small wings it possible to build those but we need to advance whit technology before building stuff like this

[@comicrandomness3289]

Well they did sell the reality first but with the help of updates that reality has fled

[@goncalojaneiro4657]

@mo gamer yeah, that was just a move on rockstar part who wants get more milk than the cow can give, i am tired of gta v. yeah it's a great game but i already finished the story game 5 times and the online. don't even talk about it. full of oppressor mk2s and 10 year old kids, killing you the moment you spawn on the map. yikes i don't even imagine getting around the map without being exploded

[@sour3000]

They said a reality not realistic 😂😂

[@krazyhorse215]

Rockstar knows how to make a good game, they seem to lack the knowledge or heart to keep it alive.

[@ob1934]

More like rockstar would be consumer friendly if they weren't owned by greedy take two

[@krazyhorse215]

Yeah, unfortunately money changes things and now they know what they can do and will continue unless people stopped playing their shit altogether

[@anakinskywalker2707]

People need to stop playing gta online thats all and i read somewhere that rockstar stop making another single player dlc after realizing they didnt make money as much as their multiplayer dlc so please if they make one in the future consider buying it

[@maaax1173]

@@ob1934 Rockstar is greedy too but Take 2 is even worse

[@maaax1173]

@mo gamer It’s NOT mostly Take 2, it’s the same with Rockstar. Unfortunately

[@NatjoOfficial]

TLDR: they suggest a few things that range from “might be possible” to “sending game makers to the torture chambers”. Even only keeping suggestions to “might be possible” can lead to catastrophic failure while making such a game. Non game devs talking about what they’d want from a game. It’s hopeful but not possible. Add too many systems to a game which might clash then you’ll be dealing with more and more bugs. A massive landscape is totally possible to make within a game, even if it’ll take a stupid amount of time, but adding destruction to each building? That’s a piss take and a nightmare for artists, developers and technical artists. 300 players is also a stretch (and hell with destruction physics). Possible, but a stretch. It’d be easier on their servers to make it possible to seamlessly slide in and out of servers depending on what region of the map you were in, with a proximity chat, but that’s still a stretch.

[@nickrustyson8124]

Shit I can imagine the lag you would get from destructive environment

[@tunacanjerry8693]

Destruction to buildings is probably the dumbest thing anyone can ask rockstar to do. It’s cool but pointless when there’s already so much attention to detail in these games that already make you feel like you’re in a real world.

[@TheRealSpicySucc]

@@tunacanjerry8693 yea it makes no sense for gta, its works in bf because it's a sandbox shooter with matches and limited chaos that resets every game.

[@connerlandie2025]

A ''reality'' with flying bikes that shoot missiles in seconds

[@tardigras7822]

That's only in GTA Onl**e, which I hate by the way

[@e14ee]

I like to think of GTA ONLINE as non canon. Like undead nightmare in RDR

[@thisrandodude4787]

@@e14ee that's what they should say, but they make references in Story Mode to Online. Like Lester saying there is one other person but they're too unpredictable, he's talking about your Online character. Also they'd need to come up with another way for how Trevor got his Impotent Rage figurine.

[@shockarmy100]

Moises Guzman no, I think it was about Niko, even mentioned it was in liberty city

[@thisrandodude4787]

@@shockarmy100 You're partially right, Lester does mention Niko, but he says, "There was an Eastern-European guy, ah but he went quiet." That's Niko, the other one, the is your online character

[@ktunedcrx]

“The map” Yea that same map where that skyscraper never got finished in the span of 8 years.

[@mangaming1942]

Canonically the Mile High Club building is over 30 years old.

[@DarkSpaceStudios]

@@mangaming1942 it is? how ?

[@gamesplash8668]

It will be finished in a new gta online update!

[@wanilimbe]

Maybe before story mode it got robbed and they quit building it

[@sugandhakohli]

What do you think will be in the "Expanded and Enhanced" GTA V? Obviously the completed building.

[@rolin8076]

The map expansion thing aged like milk...

[@mrk3655]

They did make Cayo Perico though so... you’re partially correct

[@batuu5166]

Bro what expansion? Its just a misson map with poor optimization and vibranium trees/bushes

[@mrk3655]

@@batuu5166 yeah I said he was partially correct

[@mrk3655]

@@batuu5166 it wasn’t too much of a map expansion anyways

[@mrk3655]

@@batuu5166 Hah, poor optimization? Try out GTAIV on PC 😂

[@gabetheborkingdog5985]

No other game's car handling physics, sounds, ambient noices, character and NPC details even comes close to GTA games. Not even Cyberpunk could do it.

[@xenthia]

cyberpunk has a nice concept, and story, but the fanbase defending that monstrosity and claiming that it's "100x better than gta" is what makes me lose interest in it

[@miguellamego13]

Cyberpunk couldnt do anything

[@ThePandafriend]

@@xenthia It's a mediocre game which was ruined by bad decisions and being pushed out too early.

[@ProjectYoutube]

@@xenthia lol I'm already done playing cyberpunk but still playing gta after all these years

[@TheDennys21]

LOL what do you mean "not even Cyberpunk could do it" Cyberpunk is trash!

[@nickthekidNL]

As a staten islander the pain is intense that my home was missed out in gta4.

[@sour3000]

😭😭😭😭

[@Clay3613]

Ever meet Vinny?

[@michaelladd4049]

I love how when talking about the problems on gtao all he had to do was show a picture of the Mk2 lol

[@mrk3655]

The MK2 has good

[@gaveup1504]

@@mrk3655 ewww (get off chair) (Screams WTF)

[@mrk3655]

@@gaveup1504 I think I had a stroke when writing that or something

[@Nick_Red]

MK2 is an excellent choice for grinding ! Unfortunately kids using it for the wrong purpose!

[@fishpants7764]

It sucks that rockstar ruined what could've been an amazing aspect, gta online. They ruined it by corporate greed. But great video, loved the editing.

[@prateekpanwar646]

Problem is people who keep buying old game and shark cards. Common they should be ashamed by selling a 7 years old game and even using 9 years old trailer for the new console. You still don't know how it actually looks in PSV

[@mrvespuccia.k.ameganite1747]

Especially with the cancelled story mode dlc because to me after I completed story mode I felt it was half baked(mostly on franklins part and a bit on trevors too)

[@fishpants7764]

​@Mercury Noone ever said they weren't, its just rockstar turned microtransactions into the only way to be good at the game and win, it became a pay to win game, which is the worst type of game to have when you involve multiplayer.

[@Ser_Salty]

@Mercury Ah yes, such great game design, playing a multiplayer game in solo because that's the only way to actually enjoy it

[@Frost-bs6xr]

FishPants not at all, anyone who still doesnt have every money making opportunity in gta online is either new or simply shit at the game. everyone should have an upgraded mk2 by now

[@shroom6850]

if you want multiple cities in a single game and want every area of the map to feel unique, then don’t complain about rockstar taking so long to release gta 6

[@xxxod]

They statistically shouldn't take this long even with all those features

[@borismurillo2834]

@@xxxod ah I disagree, red dead redemption 2 took a long time to produce aswell and that was on ps4/Xbox one hardware. Imagine their possibilities with ps5/Xbox series x hardware.

[@thegamelabgaming7556]

@@borismurillo2834 they use computers to make video games

[@borismurillo2834]

@@thegamelabgaming7556 I didn’t mean literally on their hardware, I meant FOR that hardware in mind, with the limitations of the system architecture.

[@borismurillo2834]

Less limitations means more room for detail and expansion which will undoubtedly take time. Rockstar has made their name with simulation of life in their games so I know they’d take their time.

[@juicestains52]

As someone who grew up in New York, everytime I play GTA 4 I get nostalgia. Everything from the Duplexes near the train tracks to the tolls you have to pass in order to get to NJ captures the exact feeling of what it’s like to be in NY.

[@maaax1173]

The problem: they’re so desperate for any money they could get going as far as making RDR Online cheap and tricking the new players into buying gold so they can get the new pass with a bonus of 10 gold which is only available in the first few days

[@wanilimbe]

Micro transactions are big now. Don’t blame rockstar, blame take two, they have the second greediest game of all time, NBA 2K is so fucking greedy. Your head would blow if you played that trash

[@maaax1173]

Niko Bellic It’s not only Take Two it’s also Rockstar. Sure does Rockstar belong to Take Two but it’s not like EA where it’s a dictatorship over all the companies they own. Rockstar can make their own decisions and they decide to milk this game, it’s not Take Two only

[@shockarmy100]

its max the thing is , this game is not pay to win, and no one forces you to buy shark cards, but at the end of the day , they’re a business, they need to make money and make a profit

[@maaax1173]

Me Or You I‘m not even gonna argue about it. Rockstar obviously only cares about the money and gives a shit about what the community wants, there’s no denying that. Of course no one forces you to buy a shark card, that’s not the case in any game. The point is that they are doing everything to get people to buy shark cards. Most if not all of the money making activities are made as tedious, boring and repetitive as possible and they slowly increase prices with every update, for example the VW Golf GTI that came out in the last dlc a week ago, they are charging 1.4 million for it. 1.4 MILLION! You don’t have to tell me they need to make money but they obviously value money over anything else, just one example is that they use p2p severs which are the cheapest available. They have many problems like people occasionally being stuck on the loading screen and much more. That further proves that they don’t care about the quality of their online game modes

[@refreshh5]

@@Yunprek ??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? What are you talking about? Gta online it's not even close to other games that literally force microtransactions on you. You can still play gta online and do heist and have fun especially if you are playing it with a group of friends

[@Defense0001]

Even though Watch Dogs 1 barely even come close to Rockstar's level of map design and atmosphere I still think that if you look past the mediocre story and clunky controls it really feels like Chicago, the atmosphere is nice and looking at the city from far away looks just like Chicago. It captures that Chicago feel.

[@nickrustyson8124]

Plus, Car design is pretty good in Watch Dogs too, they don't feel as, "Real life car but with thing added to it." as some of Rockstar's cars.

[@thearousedeunuch]

@@nickrustyson8124 They feel like crap to drive, though.

[@agoogleaccount4891]

@@thearousedeunuch meh they feel fine ( coming from someone who likes gta 4 driving )

[@muhammadhussain4952]

The story was not mediocre rather it was garbage. Ubisoft made a very bad decision making that game, and luckily Ubisoft is recovering

[@felixnurscher6017]

watch dogs 1's world honestly felt more real than gta 5 ever did to me

[@AidenAlias]

I legit love that gtav has the map open from the beginning. Its more immersive and allows players to do what they think is fun.

[@Jiub_SN]

Nah, it ruined exploration. In the other games I get to spend time exploring each area as the story progresses and I get familiar with it all, in V I couldn't tell you how to get anywhere from anywhere because I'd just drive all over the place between missions lmao

[@Kattytatty02]

I agree, having San Diego as a subsection of the GTA 5 map would have been awesome. We could have had a Comic Con mission with Trevor.

[@CaptainAmercia]

That’s true but GTA maps are far less though out in the long run like RDR where you actually have land mass surrounding the whole map making it possible for future expansions like how RDR2 was. All GTA games take place on an island which is very strange but a funny joke at how Americans see themselves making map expansions really strange as the area would magically appear the next time you jump in like it was always there. It’s also a universe thing how Los santos in both SA and GTA V are very different.

[@nood1le]

comic con?

[@nickrustyson8124]

@@CaptainAmercia Honestly just making another island that you can fly or sail to is probably a better idea.

[@wgnd1614]

@@CaptainAmercia kinda like the GTA V los santos is 20 years in the future

[@vegito5626]

Red Dead 2 is by far my favorite Rockstar title, for the characters and their storys through the fall of the wild west. Charles is my favorite(dont kill me for not saying Arthur) because he was the one who buried the ones most loyal to Dutch, Arthur and Susan. He was also a beast of a warrior, almost as good as Arthur

[@trollege9488]

It good man both Charles and Arthur and John aswell are amazin

[@pmp1337]

If anything. The competition needs to step up. Rockstars making billions of a game that is close to 10 years old. You are telling me other big studios can't invest to create a good match? The maps not even the problem, Watchdogs 2 has a good map despite repeated assets. The problem is the game engine, driving and shooting in the other open world games is atrocious. And even if one turns good, the other doesn't. CoD Warfare is open world, obviously the shooting is better than GTA(not by a lot), but the driving is atrocious, worse than watchdogs(or cyberpunk). Rockstar is just too comfortable to make anything fresh. They are asleep at the throne.

[@Ben-io2vo]

That is true never thought about it

[@kal-el4781]

There asleep on a throne of selling Sharkcards. Wow pretty mindblowing.

[@vinujabandara1566]

The reason gta 6 is taking so much time is basically it’s going to be a real life simulator

[@huzzzer6083]

Yeah, I mean they finished RDR2 in late 2017, maybe early 2018. 3-4 years is NOT enough to create a game that's literally bigger and better than GTA V. I wish more people would understand this.

[@vinujabandara1566]

@@huzzzer6083 Yeah, I mean rdr2 starting being made in 2012 or 2013 (not sure of the exact year) so already it 5-6 years and to make a better game more time is needed. And although I don’t play rdo and gtao people say they care only about money, but imo I think they need the cash to make a great game.

[@matt6843]

See this is exact answer I want, now it takes games more than 3 years to create especially a gta 6 map that is over 100x bigger than gat 5's map, can't ppl be patient?

[@officerspooder]

i hope so, i hope online is a role play simulator

[@nambo1445]

@@huzzzer6083 People see that it's been 8 years since a GTA and assume Rockstar is lazy, despite the release of RDR2, which sparked a controversy for overworking devs. Like you say, the actual amount of time Rockstar has had to develop a new GTA is likely only 3 or 4 years.

[@ksupremex180]

I like how every single time I talk about Rockstar’s attention to detail, everyone shits on my opinion simply because of their thoughts on GTA Online

[@estellaruiz3125]

@Lurker M so gta 5 (not gta online), gta 4, gta San Andreas, red dead redemption, and bully don’t have proper detail?

[@estellaruiz3125]

@Lurker M In my opinion, the detail in gta San Andreas and bully were very good for the time due to limited storage and hardware.

[@Crushhyt]

@Lurker M if a game was made before detail standards were raised how the hell do you think they are gonna meet them

[@automation7295]

If Rockstar pays attention to detail, why do many vehicles lack a 3rd brake light, many vehicles even lack reverse lights and turn signals. Also not every vehicle have a fuel cap unlike GTA San Andreas. Many pedestrian lights are facing the wrong way, many intersections doesn't have pedestrian lights both end of crosswalks. Have Rockstar never seen a intersection in real life? Rockstar attention to details my ass. You can still can underwater or even up high in mountains, which isn't possible in real life. All motorcycles have radios, which in real life only some models do. In real life, submarines doesn't have radio that plays music. Not all motorcycles have radios at all. Rockstar doesn't really pay attention to details. Cars can still play music, even there's no radio unit. Traffic lights are fucked up in GTA V or any GTA games, many intersections get green lights turning rights onto flow of traffic. Even SCS Software are better at programming traffic lights, no cars will get a green light onto flow of traffic.

[@burb3ryy]

@@automation7295 its not traffic simulator holy shit man, no need to write 4 paragraphs about turn signals.

[@Hello-iv7fm]

I remember driving through gta 4’s version of Times Square. It was so breathtaking to me.

[@ZacCoxTV]

ANOTHER MASTERPIECE!

[@LonelyDriver99]

Hello Mr. Clickbait

[@PrinceGummy]

@@LonelyDriver99 bruuu. 😆

[@Abhinav_Rajdan]

@@LonelyDriver99 I feel bad for him but you're spittin' truth.

[@darthwarspite8544]

@@LonelyDriver99 He's a cool but he and Mr.Boss are the masters of Clickbait

[@seantheman1886]

Sup Zac

[@JowoHD]

one thing that i do find really strange is how none of the dlc vehicles spawn in online traffic, meaning if you play alone it still feels like the 2013 map. would be cool to see some modern hypercars driving around, lowriders, electric cars and such

[@darthwarspite8544]

Forreal it's the same old cars they also should have put online cars in Single player

[@thearousedeunuch]

@@darthwarspite8544 I started playing Online because all those cars weren't available in Single Player.

[@xxxod]

@@darthwarspite8544 it's more realistic. In real life you see the same old boring vehicles in boring colors. Very rarely do you ever see anything unique.

[@buss-E-]

Saints Row 2 was criminally underrated.

[@TwisTedFiLmZ-LM]

Bro literally

[@mickgovernor]

its probably one of the best open world games even by today

[@ddcs0s]

It's so sad how bad they messed that franchise up they could have just keep doing what they did in the second one ... Update map cars guns clothes and get a new story and it'd still be a great game with a graphics update

[@Cuban4Life4]

They also need to have every building in the game accessible to some degree. It would be fun to break into different houses and have some funny dialogue to go along with it. Maybe even some hidden special items you get from raiding special houses/buildings

[@josephmccafferty4172]

Maybe a random chance Easter egg where someone mentions this isn't legend of Zelda (or GTA's in-game version) and barge into people's houses.

[@easyhq4475]

Kind of like assasin's creed unity where you eneter some houses from the window or some shit

[@juanordonezgalban2278]

At least public areas such as shopping mals

[@wanilimbe]

Why the fuck would every building be accessible if that’s trespassing and that would be a huge game that would be a Terabyte or more. There’s no point anyways. We need Las Venturas and San Diego with Los Santos

[@user-xo3jw3hc6d]

Like the gta SA burglary side missions

[@GTAVictor9128]

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt should've been an honorable mention for an open world game that is on par with RDR2, etc. In the Witcher 3, there is great attention to detail with each region not only having its own unique atmosphere, but also having a distinct ethnic group for each region. There is also a bloody war happening in the background which is often reflected in the game world.

[@justinandrew7310]

I don't really agree with that, just like in gta, once you beat the story in the Witcher it's an aggressively empty game, no one has new dialogue except for dlc and side missions mostly center around uneventful characters.

[@prodn7xt252]

But the story itself is far more open and every quests is actually a real thing not a filler like a lot of games (gta included) do

[@Ettrix]

Such a shame then, the drought of GTA/Rockstar maps in past 10 years, compared to the previous 10 years prior to them

[@Jamanator9]

10:20 I'm pretty sure every single building on the map would be rubble about half an hour after that update would come out 😂

[@fuziking505]

So would your pc or console 😂

[@Jamanator9]

@@fuziking505 true lol

[@dragongod9000]

If only Rockstar saw this video, it does a really good job explaining why their should be multiple cities, and why we need an upgraded map

[@aesie1229]

Fr I really don’t know why they didn’t add a second City in the GTA V map

[@04smallmj]

10:50 I love the paper maps! I also have one from Test Drive Unlimited and I remember Midtown Madness 2 having maps in the manual.

[@comicrandomness3289]

I want a new rockstar game where you can do everything in past games that they have made, like riding a skateboard (bully) or fighting so badass like in the warriors, or doing police work (old gta games), ambulance/firefighter missions, owning a business like in gta vc stories where you can be a pimp or protection/or gangs like in gta sa how sometimes you protect your hood and other time you provoke a gang war. Etc. I'm sure you get my point, we need more to do than just shooting people, I'd even like hunting like in rdr2 since animals react differently that people. Just everything

[@gaveup1504]

That will take a long ducking time to make maybe 14 years and map will be huge

[@rayounited4249]

@@gaveup1504 well it will almost be that long since the last gta lol

[@slm3y580]

Everyone want a huge map in online, until they have to sell things in one side of the map from another side, but really great video tho.

[@Muradachi]

My god I never even thought of that

[@isteall8140]

or steal a plane from one side of the map and fly it farther than the edge of the map

[@jaysonholzer758]

You could have a huge map without missions like that. I would like to play at one area of the map for some time, then go on a road trip to another part and stay there. Just like it was handled in the single player modes of the gta series.

[@l3wismoreman9227]

Rockstar needs to get their heads out of their asses and listen out to us the community as well as do what you people said and add another city to the online world

[@LILROB0]

If the money is good then it's fine

[@typhoon109]

The desert in gta v makes me feel like a warm summer night in the country. but what would also be cool is instead of them being connected you can fly to them via the international airport by going on flights that you are a passenger too

[@NoName-lr2gg]

The editing is insanely well done!

[@KiranaRutoCh]

I'm still under the impression that if Rockstar were to put their attention to detail on a fantasy setting, it would break the mold that Rockstar's maps are always realistic and bring some more variety on the locations they could craft. However, I do agree on the side of details. The amount of detail they could put is certainly impressive, especially in the realistic settings that became their bread and butter. Should they decide to go for a fantasy (sci-fi or traditional) setting, though, they should treat it similarly to how they treat Red Dead (separate from GTA's modern settings), but better.

[@WASpectrum]

It’s this level of detail that keeps me playing their games over any other. But they’re so mean to us

[@prodn7xt252]

12:26 I don't really agree with that statement. It looks normal like 2 of those houses were built at the same time and the architects wanted the buildings to look very similar. That happens in real world as well. I don't see this as a mark of laziness. WD2 map is super great as well as GTA's.

[@Amar-ux7gi]

@Toby MacDonald its still a good map nonetheless

[@prodn7xt252]

@Toby MacDonald well it compares in many aspects. and also wins in many

[@jaywalking0d]

@Toby MacDonald but can gta 5 pet the dog?

[@jaywalking0d]

@Toby MacDonald watch dogs 2 was an actual recreation of san francisco. Player are rewarded for exploring the map and taking pictures of famous landmark they also hide upgrades and stuff for players to find and sometimes you have to use your brain to slove it. Unlikw in gta v The collectables only give you a % on a completion screen. You are not rewarded for taking pictures and exploring the world watch dogs 2 was a sleeper game because it was released in 2016 same year as Call of Duty and Battlefield 1. Also its GTA. Everybody have heard of gta at least once in their life and if rockstar sell a peice of turd and call it GTA people will buy it

[@jaywalking0d]

@@mrmoztaza yes. you just can't accept the fact that u can't pet dogs in video games

[@abzzs]

the editing tho 😍

[@William_15_]

The amount of chaos from 300 players would be absolute madness

[@nydax]

I dont understand how your so unknown. The insane levels of editing on each video is remarkable. Absolutely Amazing ❤

[@samueljonathan6101]

Its because he isn't a toxic meme compilation channel that creates shitty meme reaction videos. Everyone in the Rockstar community complains about Sernandoe being the only big GTA youtuber but really anyone could be a big youtuber you just need to follow all the silly meme trends and put every edgy meme in your video and loads of fuckboy tik tok douches will subscribe to your channel en masse so they can see those dank memes you can enjoy games or you can be a big youtuber lets playing or talking about games.

[@philosophicality]

im convinced you have like a whole animation company working for you

[@TrunkFilms]

I love how we can love and appreciate the old rockstar achivenments and still compelety roast them for GTA online's mess

[@georgeruellan]

The production quality of this video is INSANE! I hope your channel gets the love it deserves in the future bro

[@lewiz18]

8:33 that would either crash or you'd get booted by a modder every session

[@niczaz58]

I would love some kinda map expansion, I already spend hours in story mode driving up to paleto bay and back, so if gtao added new areas I’d be so much more motivated to hop on and either fly or drive from los santos to liberty city

[@wiekengels8602]

the two best rockstar content creators in one video Absolutely beautiful

[@QwertyQwerty-so4kw]

i like Gta Sa map the most. That game is peaceful to play.

[@madridista6862]

I remember driving city to city and feeling like I just made a 12 hours long roadtrip or something back when I was a little kid back then lol, amazing memories man

[@TWilsonSE]

The one problem I had with the SA map was if you rolled your car, you could spend up to 2 minutes running to the nearest road. Otherwise, the map was pretty good.

[@prateekpanwar646]

It gives most adventurous feel, They should divide GTA 6 maps so it feels different. GTA V is good as per online and story, But I'd prefer sa map

[@prateekpanwar646]

@@TWilsonSE It's not a problem as it's same with GTA 5. Only thing is you can roll back in V

[@CaptainAmercia]

GTA 4 is my favourite the most detailed and filled with detail. They focused on the city so much as that’s all there was no large outside area just a single city with so much detail compared to GTA V which was disappointing In a lot of areas.

[@ulisesgil4209]

I feel like this video never gets anywhere. Watching it was a weird experience but a good one.

[@chachiebalboa7023]

I grew up with rockstar and I never imagined myself that in 20 years I'd still be playing there games. Cheers R*

[@crypticrunner1200]

"every building is unique" small shops: throw my beer off a cliff

[@KRAFTWERK2K6]

One thing i really like is the interconnectivity of their games. That there's references to each game in Red Dead Redemption and GTA. You even have an old wild west photo of Arthur on his horse on Mr. Rubio's office on Cayo Perico. And it seems.

[@ng4148]

Well,the gta map is finally getting expanded with the cayo perico island..not sure if its for mission purposes only though..

[@tarunbasra8230]

Hashanah

[@nandawakankar8072]

It's only for mission. BRUH. we cant go there in free roam.

[@ryhanzfx1641]

This was uploaded 5 months ago

[@64siskat96]

@@nandawakankar8072 we can

[@danwordgod2017]

*The GTA V map Stop calling GTA V as just "GTA" there are 12 games in the franchise.

[@TracyNorrell]

Damn! That production value was tight! I'm not even done viewing the first video I've seen in your channel, and I'll already subb'ed. Great job.

[@freecharles3902]

Wow great video actually had me thinking about rockstar maps and games in a way I never had. Instant subscribe can’t wait to see more from you

[@AmongUs-mb4qx]

8:34 "Raise the player cap from 32 to 300" *Loading times* : So you've chosen death

[@Infernuth]

No

[@drippyog3935]

@@Infernuth yes

[@fuckyoutube75889]

This joke is more overused than the shitty game your channel is based on

[@xxxod]

@@fuckyoutube75889 what game? Oh you mean the thing i've been ignoring since it came out... yeah that game doesn't exist.

[@zepic9093]

I feel like gta 4s map was the most detailed. But in gta 5 some of the details were lost as the map does not feel alive

[@CaptainAmercia]

I agree but again GTA 4 was a single city while GTA V you have both City and a large countryside.

[@HungNgo-ir7eq]

Lurker M no it isn’t, Just shut up 10 year old kid, Star junction in gta 4 is beautiful and detailed, go back playing gta online with shitty flying broomstick and unrealistic crap.

[@migaslz8444]

Most remarkable thing here is the edits of this video

[@maninthebox2771]

Hey when you get big, don't forget about us ok?

[@DarkSpaceStudios]

Never. If that even happens lol

[@ZacCoxTV]

6:45 I hate that guy!

[@Alexzw92]

came here to make that same comment, you beat me too it. nice

[@ayushgupta7273]

Lol

[@ZacCoxTV]

@@Alexzw92 Lol weirdo

[@eatacrow5313]

So do I

[@yeaotaku5790]

Woah zac I haven't seen one of your videos since I was like 9. Back when I believed you clickbait titles and thumbnails

[@TripCantGame]

The quality of this is insane

[@evanriddile7420]

“Saints Row Steelport was such a mess. It was mostly based on Pittsburgh...” As someone from Pittsburgh that’s a real bad attempt at imitating our city. It does not look like that. Maybe a couple decades ago but even when SR3 released we didn’t look like that.

[@kadnaz]

It's based on New York City primarily. Like just look at the map

[@asrr62]

lol i seen pics of Pittsburgh way cooler setup with the hills! but no i dont see it either. i kinda think of saints row last city was kinda based on chicago and the first one detroit. very far out there guesses.

[@BaldinBlack]

1:42 GTAOnline: I’m gonna end this man’s hole career.

[@ojasgupta6169]

production quality of this video is just marvelous

[@wizardpenguintb2968]

That intro was orgasmic, my dude. The production level on this video is amazing. You've earned yourself a new sub

[@sammyhiggs4202]

I personally would love for them to remake GTA San Andreas and the San Andreas map is one of my favorite maps. RDR 2 is my favorite map they created but I'd go as far as saying I love San Andreas LS better then 5's LS. Yes I know GTA 5 is better graphics and more realistic but I really loved how in the 3d universe the cities were not an exact copy of the city. Just my opinion.

[@maxideutsch]

I can understand that rockstar doesn't add more cities because: bigger City= more players in one session= more modders in one session Rockstar could fix this problem by improving Modmenu detection. But I totally agree with you.

[@augakem]

I will always remember London and Manchester. Sure, 2D, but for once it's not in USA. No american dialect, it's all British. And it's set in 1960s! I would love to see London games remade in CTW's style. Speaking about Chinatown Wars... Liberty City in Chinatown Wars was redesigned due to... Well, DS limitations. But the city got more colours, it seems. Neons, eltrain sparks, street racers with their "neonified" cars... It also felt very silent. Since the only people who speak in the game are pedestrians. Vice City in 1984 (VCS) was your beloved Vice City, but more 80s. Buildings had neons, billboards were shiny and noticeable, pedestrians looked like they are from 1980s Miami. Heck, you even have more nature to explore, carnavals, motorbike officers... Looking at 86' VC, it looks... Downgraded on city's budget?

[@riffattanveer4722]

Try watch dogs:Legion bro

[@riffattanveer4722]

And yes it ubisoft

[@augakem]

@@riffattanveer4722 Depressing, I know.

[@HdyMac22]

Ocean (Dark Space): 7:59 Rockstar when adding the Cayo Perico Heist: Say no more

[@taste9689]

its a shame its only for the heist, and limited exploration out of it. I thought we would be able to do more but it's just another option rockstar give for us to grind money faster, which is a plus and a minus since the island just get boring after a couple of heists granted its more fun than casino

[@HdyMac22]

@@taste9689 Honestly I kinda expected more but Rockstar overhyped it tho.

[@googanmcboogie9307]

Multiple maps would work better as individual cells where you need to catch a plane from LC to SA or a large boat/yacht to get to VC. It will give it space and a travel cut scene to show distance.

[@Big_daytona]

i feel like all of his vids are just him flexing his editing

[@nadporucikmaso1106]

Try it urself 😏

[@mostafaalghalibi162]

@@nadporucikmaso1106 well said

[@Bmoneydollarsign]

@@nadporucikmaso1106 ok, i’ll edit a monkey with a human face, i’ll put it on my channel