Roelly Winklaar(2018 Mr. O) vs Carlos Thomas Jr.(2023 Texas Pro)

[@TRENton2003]

DUDE PLEASE POST MORE OFTEN EVERYTIME I SEE ONE OF YOUR VIDEOS I GET SO EXCITED AND MY KZbin FEED SUCKS AND YOUR THE ONLY CONSISTENTLY GOOD AND ENTERTAINING CREATOR ON MY FEED

[@BillyTheCheeseMonger]

He’s posted like every day for years what more do you want 😭😭

[@TRENton2003]

@@BillyTheCheeseMonger NEED MORE

[@IamTheOnlySteve]

He needs to livestream for an hour a day I would def donate

[@ghostkiller.121]

​@@TRENton2003 He's a human as well.

[@davidchu2001]

is your capslock stuck?

[@zman8340]

Roelly just looks so thick and powerful, one of my favorite modern builds .

[@kaleandoscope]

The upper body is insane, arms, chest, shoulders, forearms!! Propah

[@edge3220]

Video suggestion: Who is the best Asian open bodybuilder?

[@michaelschlageter8381]

Of all time.... 😊

[@minecraftavatarofhunterbiden]

Love all your videos!

[@tbray02]

Grandma is the food ready 😂

[@pothead1980]

Roelly’s proportions are are much better than Carlos especially on the side shots carlos has no calves and huge legs and smaller delts compared to his chest which leaves an imbalance in his physique

[@oliverkeely4767]

Roelly is like a dream wrapped blanket, a very muscley blanket

[@daveyadict_]

This just isn't fair, carlos is so far behind roelly.....this is like a pro vs an npc guy

[@ReviewBros]

Not where the lower body is concerned. I’d argue that Carlos makes roelly look like the amateur in the that regard and that’s 50% of the physique

[@daveyadict_]

@ReviewBros idk, size isn't everything. And we know that the lower body can overpower the upper and it's not rewarded (tom platz is an exmple). Carlos legs are massive yes, but he has little to no conditioning

[@ReviewBros]

@@daveyadict_ fair, but Carlos is still in the early days of competing so one can only assume he’ll continue to dial in that conditioning and graininess and will eventually surpass Roelly. I hope that’s the case because Carlos has a lot of potential! Who do you have winning the Arnold?

[@daveyadict_]

@ReviewBros oh hands down for sure. He has so much potential, and if he doesn't get sick like he did last year he could be a top 10 O guy

[@daveyadict_]

@ReviewBros also the arnold will be either Samson or andrew . Derek is a bag of milk from the front

[@kaleandoscope]

I really hope Carlos finds his formula and peaks well at some point, he's slowly becoming my favourite current open pro. So much mass and a great structure, the level of roundness and fullness is great, just needs more back.

[@BrickQuake]

Roelly if you’re reading this I love you

[@thebodybeatdownDiTi]

I think Roelly has more muscle. Even early on. Carlos has a great shape. Bubbly muscles. BUT my vote has to go to Roelly simply because im a fan of his overall physique..

[@michaelschlageter8381]

But it is closer as l ever thought it would be

[@Marmaduke00]

Roelly 2018 should’ve won Mr Olympia

[@ashishdevranidevrani6015]

Totally agreed, had the size and a small waist, more muscular and aesthetic than rhoden.

[@Familyguywow1]

Marx Max Muscle vs Jay Cutler 2009

[@paulk9603]

Why?

[@halfadyazide9059]

Thank buddy

[@CypressItalian]

Gustavo Badell 2004 vs D. Lunsford 2024

[@kevinharkins6186]

Roelly's conditioning was gnarly in his debut. Very deeply separated delts. I thought condition would be his calling card until he became The Beast

[@GC-by6iz]

in no way are you making it close between Roelly and Carlos' back double biceps. As weak as Roelly's back double bicep was compared to other top competitors, Carlos is on a whole other league of bad.

[@R_00N]

Roelly is in far better condition its not even close.

[@ivanmzrnic6475]

This clearly shows a little refinements to Carlos's physique could make him top Olympian

[@tootoomcgoo9674]

Not at all. In like, so many ways. Most of all though is his back. Building a back from wildly underdeveloped to Olympia winning is not a "little refinement". Even Roelly, who has a notoriously weak back, makes Carlos' back look very underdeveloped, and this is when Carlos is MILES away from being properly conditioned. If Carlos were to have been properly conditioned, his back would be even smaller still. Carlos has many other issues, but just the back by itself is a huge hurdle he is still a long ways from overcoming.

[@johnnycampbell7691]

buT MarX MAx MuscLe yOu MiSsizEd ThEm!!!!!

[@sowetocreamery196]

2007 Olympia Jay Cutler vs Victor Martinez

[@MichaelHernandez-mv7on]

You spelled his last name wrong. It's Winklaar

[@marxmaxmuscle1]

thank you kind sir, One way you can tell im not AI lol

[@JohnPeter-bz7fi]

Devon Larrat vs Levan Saginashivili, make it happen !

[@paulk9603]

Walker vs Danilov plz

[@MeesterJ]

Roelly wins every pose dude

[@existentialcrisis31]

Would Marx even care if I committed sideways 😢

[@mikemedal]

I don't know if anyone else thinks this but Carlos, to me looks "stumpy" even though he has a small waist. Like a blown up 212 guy. I dunno.

[@afonso1816]

Very hard to judge. Carlos wins the front shots, roelly wins the side shots, the rest is a battlefield and they are in simillar conditioning

[@benjyperez5606]

Roelly sweeps it easily

[@halfadyazide9059]

You the man. dyazide is a diuretic Mr. Natural

[@malasbwenas6700]

He is actuallt better than Rolly. In terms of genetics and fullness. Just need more detail and muscle separation. Je's gonna be the futures favorite

[@leaderboard354]

do 2007 victor martinez vs 2011 phil heath please plssss

[@Marmaduke00]

I don’t even need to watch this one. Roelly Destry’s him

[@afonso1816]

Very hard to judge. Carlos wins the front shots, roelly wins the side shots, the rest is a battlefield and they are in simillar conditioning