Roy Keane RATING Players

[@EPLHYPE]

What's WRONG with MAN UTD? kzbin.info/www/bejne/hGWznqRplrVmn6s

[@TPRM1]

No Dennis Irwin. He can play left back, right back, get you a goal, good at set pieces, always fit, no off the field stuff…and he’s Irish. Yep, United need Dennis Irwin.

[@sprinter1832]

@@TPRM1 He's also well past it!

[@tonnaboy10]

People say Roy is always criticising players but he eulogises about the top boys constantly. He just doesn’t stand for mediocrity.

[@EPLHYPE]

💯 the way he talks about KDB proves that!

[@smartsquirrel1]

He's the only one with any stones to criticise Maguire because the English panel won't touch that subject. Everyone else is a problem at Utd except him. My only mark against him is that he refused to criticise Ole being ex teammates and all. Maybe he knew something about internal problems that the rest of us didn't.

[@Nopanop]

He himself was mediocre tho

[@tonnaboy10]

@@Nopanop Nope son

[@Nopanop]

@@tonnaboy10 he acts as he was the reason united win all championships 😂

[@iblaze1085]

Keane mimicking Maguire will always be funny 😂😂😂

[@JCzzzzz]

Roy Keane may sound overly critical sometimes but I feel he is fair in his analysis. No BS from him. And he seems to hate it when players doesn't try hard enough. He will be a very good manager if he is less abrasive and more diplomatic in his communication

[@Blackcain]

He shouldn't have to, but unfortunately today's generation of footballers are mostly soy boys that needs cuddling. There's a few hard lads out there still, but dying breed them.

[@JCzzzzz]

@Blackcain if the current generation needs a certain style of management then the manager needs to adjust in order to manage them properly

[@jackbolland-tw6mi]

And know something about football probably

[@JCzzzzz]

@@jackbolland-tw6mi I certainly hope so. Lol... he is a top player in his time

[@jackbolland-tw6mi]

@@JCzzzzz Roy Keane was a brilliant player in his time but his punditry is state the obvious, work hard, be a leader, and kick players when you’re losing to make you feel better, maybe entertaining for some but is bland for others

[@waynesullivan5786]

People say keane is always criticising players but he gives credit where credit is due, people dont give him the recognition he deserves for the knowledge he has for the game. Just says it how it is, as a captain and a pundit. This is why he got the respect he did when he was on the pitch. Gave his blood for u if u done the same but god help you if you put a foot out of line

[@turkeyman631]

Hey thats what the comment says above!

[@tonnaboy10]

@@turkeyman631 imitation is the sincerest form of flattery 🙂

[@turtle1701d]

Lazy

[@GG-tc8cr]

Pretty much spot on with his ratings

[@EPLHYPE]

Yeah, even though he had a go at Rashford on the weekend 🙈 but praises him in this 😆, keano is just too funny

[@ricardocoutinho9777]

i agree with him almost all the time. but you think de gea is overrated?

[@GG-tc8cr]

@ricardocoutinho9777 in the later days of his career he definitely dropped his standards in my opinion

[@ricardocoutinho9777]

@@GG-tc8cr even that he was and still is a very good keeper (without consistency unfortunately). He always looked 'shorter' to previous GK. He never met the standards of Schmeichel and Van der Sar for example. Overated? Well, if you portrait him as world class, he can be that sometimes...

[@NC--rc9kp]

Um yeah apart from Trashford. He’s awful.

[@Some-kid-called-David]

That moustache was an interesting choice

[@RichardKnows]

Mr Potato Head

[@imnottellingyoumyname3050]

Omni man cosplay

[@MrMagoor]

George Michael :D

[@kdee8166]

Best pundit out there. Honest and informed.

[@-blz624]

he was great as a player. Just pure honesty and not influenced by Maguire conspiracy.. where the media is protecting him too much

[@MrSexyg777]

he is coward

[@goldytwatus1674]

@@-blz624 "Maguire conspiracy" How do people as dumb as you find your way onto the internet?

[@Bluemoon4415-s5v]

I love it when he lays into United players, it reaffirms their demise.

[@yaseenali8318]

lol 😢

[@Jd7172g]

I suspect this video will blow up. A few more example of Keane criticising players would be good if you do another

[@EPLHYPE]

I'll have a new one coming out into the season, when he starts on newer players/signings 😄

[@TheRedPeril]

Maybe. But there are ALOT of those videos about and people have seen most of those clips.

[@alwallace4538]

You've got to love Keano. He tells it like it is, good or bad. And he's usually right.

[@eNyaaaw]

Roys honest. Why do you want to hear an ex pro talk about football performances? For honesty. Hes critical when he needs to be and complimentary when he needs to be. EXACTLY as he was as a player and part of why hes the most decorated captain in Man Uniteds most successful period. Told his teammates how it is, and hes doing it on tv for us. I love the guy. I grew up watching Keano being born in Manchester in 88, i got to see the magic. United will never be that good again.

[@footygenes]

Great video man! keep it up

[@berkeleybernie]

No lies detected. These evaluations are all spot-on.

[@jamesfagan7823]

Roy sure knows his football ⚽ I agree with him on this

[@56postoffice]

Keane about Kane: *"I think he fancies United."* Goes to Bayern Munich instead😅

[@EPLHYPE]

Kane was too loyal to Spurs man. Could have joined a big Prem club, bit weird he chose Bayern but his life I guess lol 😆

[@keithy507]

@@EPLHYPEdefinitely nothing weird about it! One of the biggest clubs in the world and a chance to win the champions league. Also, Germany is a lovely place to live!

[@SohiniB-g9b]

​@@EPLHYPEWhy on Earth would he Choose United who have struggled to even qualify for the Champions League in the last decade. He chose Bayern who are a globally massive club and guaranteed trophy winners.

[@craigoliver8712]

​@@SohiniB-g9bUnited is the bigger club

[@Stego1819]

@@SohiniB-g9b well so much for the guaranteed trophy winners.

[@XerxesGammon200]

I pay for the Roy keane podcast if he starts one 😎

[@VODaddyFresh]

Pretty sure he has a show on KZbin

[@e10venom]

Keane is savage 😂😂😂

[@DidYaServe]

Agreed with all of his takes there apart from Rashford who is talented but too inconsistent.

[@dani45212]

Kdb is considered Worldclass but still underrated in my opinion. The best midfieldfer of PL ever and one of the best CAM graced the game

[@TPRM1]

He’s no Denis Irwin.

[@Contextualiser16-tn8nd]

Nah. Scholes and Lampard both clear. Prime Yaya, David Silva, Bernardo Silva and Gundogan all better as well. If Beckham was around today, he'd dwarf KDB as well

[@dani45212]

scholes, lampard hahahah... nice joke man

[@attila_the_hunk9685]

​​@@Contextualiser16-tn8nd Beckham better than KDB...? You sub 70 iq by any chance?...serious question.

[@OPFCartoons]

Best midfield in prem ever? You are a fool born yesterday I can see

[@davetaylor4741]

From a great at United. Who definitely had an opinion. The only one I didn't fully agree with is Rashford. He was in his purple patch at the time. But Rashford is selfish. He is a run in and score flash goals character. But he is no centre forward. His accuracy can be pitiful. And he could have ten times the number of assists. Instead of the balls into the stand from wild shots. Good player. But flawed.

[@Rua007]

Facts

[@timashworth1158]

With that moustache I’d like to see him play Quint in a remake of Jaws.

[@possessedslig]

The mustache got the biggest laugh from me

[@DavyRo]

Keano gives credit to those he feels deserving of it. The reason he comes across as being over critical. Is because he was a world class player himself & I feel if players aren't at that high standard he says it. Obviously there isn't too many absolute world class players.

[@garygriffin3647]

Actually he will openly say he wasn't blessed as a footballer and was nowhere near the level of some of the players he played with. But with tenacity and hard work and pure professionalism he maximised what he had and as a result was the type of player and man you would want in any team. I would off loved to play against him. A man of my own heart. Minimum requirement is maximum effort.

[@Abbadonhades]

How he judges the players, is how anyone would judge those particular players. Keane is just pointing out what's obvious to everyone. De Bruyne, Saka and Kane being good players, who wouldn't recognize that? And conversely the level of play coming from Maguire and De Gea (when he still played for Manchester United) has been terrible. You could account for some of it with the fact that Manchester United is a dysfunctional team, and a dysfunctional club at the moment, but there's no denying their individual performances have often been below par. It would be more interesting to follow panel members who are able to recognize the underlying talent of players who's had several bad games, but who's still on their way to becoming great players. That's a talent in itself, rather than spouting what's obvious.

[@KidTheHakim]

i hate keane, he's so biased. and like what you said even I can say what's he's saying. there's no value add lmao.

[@-BuddyGuy]

Had several bad games? You mean not doing their job

[@Abbadonhades]

@@-BuddyGuy More like, players having a cold or a small injury plaguing them, lack of self-confidence et cetera, but still being played, and consequently performing badly. As for the pundits, rather than wholesale condemning players in a tabloid manner, being able to see the underlying talent. It's heaven or hell with the pundits, and all to often it seems to be their job to tear individuals and teams down, instead of looking at the big picture. Then when such players reemerge as champions and great talents, they're suddenly hailed as the players of the century. We should demand more from our experts, is what I'm saying.

[@T.J.S.]

3:29 looks like 50% John Cleese

[@OkosBacsi]

when a highly critical man is praising you, there is some serious truth being revealed there! mind you he aint always correct, but quite often is, though.

[@eymerich6872]

Roy speaks the truth.

[@BenjaminButton6573]

Roy is honest and if he says your good your bloody good.

[@tomgreen2737]

The truth is a beautiful thing.

[@staticx1324]

Truer words never been spoken

[@user-ct1lf3hf1v]

3:14 savage against Maguire 😂

[@calebcampbell3854]

roy has the same passion of hate to de gea as sourness had to pogba

[@camdecorations9779]

I think Roy didn't like pogba as well , but dunes savaged Paul pogba 😂😂😂

[@imnottellingyoumyname3050]

Both warranted

[@intergalacticmuffin7071]

3:39 that muzzy is majestic I am a Liverpool fan, but love Roy he's is class. If you don't love the muzzy your in kookoo land.

[@hbahr028]

Spot on

[@vancityred1]

DE GEA still without a Club at 32 while 40 yrs old backups all playing for Big Clubs!

[@briancox9357]

Keane saying that Harry Kane 'fancies United'. 😂😂😂😂

[@robinelliott-ni2eh]

Kane would've gone United over Bayern but Levy would not have sold him to United as they're opposition and in the end Levy didn't want to let Kane go for free. I guarantee Kane would've chosen United over Bayern if it was completely upto him.

[@SohiniB-g9b]

​@@robinelliott-ni2ehWhy on Earth would he Choose a team that has struggled to qualify for the Champions League for over a decade now,let alone winning trophies. At Bayern, he is guaranteed trophies and he can also win the Champions League. United fans need to realise it's not 1997 anymore.

[@harukrentz435]

3:28 OMG how come ive never seen Roy with mustache before 🤣

[@zeo4481]

Roy is spitting FACTS! EVERY ! TIME! Imagine how delusional you had to be as a ManU fan to say De Gea is the best goalie in the world? Every! Single! Time! On the big occasion, he flops. Vs Messi UCL - flops Vs Cristiano for country - flops Title determining games - flops

[@LeaderofAlMadrid]

Adolf keane looking mighty menacing with that stache 😅

[@peterpereira3653]

Roy talking sense.

[@gmunna704]

Lool Keane is the most successful captain in Prem history and is the definition of world class

[@aabidamn]

Roy "DoMeAFavourThatsHisJob" Keane.

[@danielsnekkerhaug141]

Keane used the term sexy about Kevin De Bryune. I'm not ashamed to say seeing De Bryune is a little bit homoerotic.. And I'm clearly straight.. And to Chelsea, well done with the scouting development regarding De Bruyne (*ironic*)

[@sonofanarchy6628]

Got to love kean❤

[@omgblastbeatslol]

These vids would be so much better without the background music.

[@stobe187]

that stache look is filthy

[@Imbdop]

Deep this for a moment, if it wasn't for Micah Richards we may never have witnessed Keane crack a smile

[@felipec.santos4370]

I'm not an united fan, but oh God, is Roy Keane funny! Lol!

[@Oscarji888]

"thinks he's gonna shut up his critics, embarrassing".... That made me soooo happy for some fucked up bitter reason. And I'm not even a Man Utd fan😂

[@hmgamingofficial]

HE IS THE MOST LEGIT HONEST PUNDIT, HE NEVER BLAME OR CRITIZE SOMEONE WITHOUT REASON. WHAT EVER YOURE IF YOU BAD YOU BAD THATS IT. EVERYTHING HE SAID IS TRUE. EVERY WEEK WE EXPECT SOMETHING FROM RASHFORD PAST 7YEARS. BUT NOTHING SPECIAL THATS TRUE SAME US DEGEA. ONCE UPON A TIME HE IS A WORLD CLASS PLAYERS.. BUT MANUTD POOR DEFENSIVE PLAYERS GIVES TOO MUCH PRESSURE ON DE GEA EVERY WEEK MAKE HIM WORST. FOOTBALL NOT SINGLE PLAYER GAME.

[@TheLibermania]

De Gea was shocking? Good that they paid 50.000.000 for a better Keeper then.

[@casteltheghettomonk4392]

De gea last 3 seasons were shocking cause he lost motivation, the team was no moving from dead end . Don't forget he was 4 years in a row POTS !!! Yes he wanted to leave utd but who didn't !? After dinmaria left after 1 season all of you should have knowed the train for sighing top class players left

[@mister3566]

How does he grow a beard so f#@kin quick?

[@EPLHYPE]

Irish Potatoes 🥔

[@arpussupra]

By raging at it. Growing is the beard's job after all.

[@tritri5107]

And De Gea is still a free agent , some hours before the deadline. Not even Saudi clubs want him 😂

[@deathrager2404]

without de gea united would be relegated. onana is trash dude. watch this season for united. if they let eth finish the league he will end like 9th or something.

[@lotuseater7247]

@@deathrager2404 ok De Gea

[@shoag-u1s]

still dea gea is the best ballstopper in the world. the reflex on that man is unreal. look all the saves he does, noone not alisson, not ramsdale could make those saves!

[@deathrager2404]

tell these kids. @@shoag-u1s

[@harukrentz435]

@@shoag-u1s its 2023 not 2016 anymore!

[@philwalkercuriousmind]

I respect Keane. Macguire makes my blood boil. He's spot on with him.

[@Jin_Sakaii]

Roy❤

[@yutehube4468]

2:46 Keano is right. Why is Maguire passing it back to the goalie when he has enough time to collect the ball, turn with it and pass it forward? C**t! We don't want this guy but he's lingering like a bad smell.

[@JerzyFeliksKlein]

De Gea - not good enough for Man United, good enough for Real Madrid and to win Champions League. Did anyone else get the vibe of the Da from Derry Girls when he was rocking that moustache?

[@paulnutter1713]

I remember the many mistakes Mr Keane made during his playing days......before social media of course

[@keithy507]

Yeah it’s strange, but he was human after all. Imagine that….

[@lawrencemanzanga4871]

Character is the thing that separates players at the top. Always giving 100pc. Pogba Ozil Cassano Pato Anderson Pepe are type of players Roy would've a problem playing with. Mistakes are part of the game.....

[@johnbooth3073]

I’m a Liverpool fan but I bet you can’t count Keane’s mistakes on more than one hand. Brilliant player, captain , manager ( Sunderland) pundit.

[@skillsmachine9164]

​@lawrencemanzanga4871 ozil gets a bad wrap. Won german player of the year 4 times, assist record for madrid in title year, crazy amount of assists for arsenal a couple of seasons...he just arrived at a time when arsenal had the stadium bill to pay off so they were just aiming for top4 every year. He would have been disappointed with that. Put him in cities team today with quality around him he'd be the best player going.

[@goldytwatus1674]

@@keithy507 Suppose that would completely take away from Keane's points though wouldn't it then... Making everything he says worthless....

[@robayetsalehin5719]

Only roy keane has the right be that critical of players because he has won everything. 3:30 low key omniman look btw

[@CharlieL292]

Roy Keane doesn’t protect his mates, that’s why his comments are always honest

[@prakashm1468]

Liverpool fan here. He is always 100% spot on.

[@nickrider5220]

There's no grey with Roy and he's honest.

[@porps1]

The only opinion i'd argue with was his opinion of De Gea, and even on that i can see where he's coming from.

[@kaidenhall2718]

He generally doesn’t rate keepers

[@CYP0]

3:28 Roy’s mustache is embarrassing. 👨🏻

[@aidanban]

Not an utd fan but anyone that questions his abilities is an idiot... champion league semi vs juve or another 100 examples where he just wrestled games by the neck and they won... like i said hate utd but on his day best player in the world or at very least most effective, could bend a game to his will... that game for me was proof positive even knowing he couldn't play the final motm and made them all look like kids... beast mode for sure

[@1344662]

Surprised that Keane likes American football. It's his kind of game though.

[@robinelliott-ni2eh]

Cant stand the guy but i agree with everything he says except Maguire... United dont play how Maguire was used to with Leicester or with England plus its not his fault United paid 80 million for him, they overspent and then moan that Maguires not worth 80 when they're the ones who set his worth by paying 80 million 😂. Maguire needs to leave to a team that will use him properly but i think he's pissed off with United and how he has been portrayed so is taking them for as much as possible.

[@eamonreidy9534]

Maguire needs to work on scanning the pitch and learn positioning. The things you teach teenagers

[@56postoffice]

Maguire was a beast at Hull City BEFORE Leicester.😅

[@davidcrowe4876]

Agreed, having to play in front of GK who wasn’t good enough for Spain Squad and behind fred/ Mctominny who couldn’t tackle but he gets on without complaint. Verane & Martinez conceded 7 v Liverpool??

[@arjitjere1559]

Didn't know he didn't rate ddg😮

[@deepzepp4176]

Keane totally wrong on Rashford.

[@TAI_05]

2:35 lol his hair

[@johnmason9286]

As a pundit he tells the truth so did sourness people don't like the truth as a players sourness and Keane wear leaders legends of the game they would fight for there team there lazy players today some are

[@suffern63]

Maguire had the last laugh...actually he didn't,increible that he's still at United.

[@aqibfreed4672]

When he violated Maguire whilst he ( maguire ) was celebrating was one of the best things ive seen on tv🤣

[@williamunsworth933]

I support Liverpool, but I like Roy Keane tells it how it is❤

[@andrewhughes9278]

They definitely got big Duncan Ferguson right

[@kevinjames8752]

How about analysing Keane’s managerial career ?

[@mtbfever8578]

Never seen the moustache before 😂😂😂😂

[@mrheckles6076]

Roy Keane, the guy not rated by anyone outside England...

[@JFP1988]

I tend to agree with Roy Keane but he was wrong about De Gea. So wrong. De Gea was the best player we'd had for years, letting him go was a massive mistake and it shows.

[@dharmawiguna3232]

he was fair man

[@amrasfour1718]

Sure he can talk about overrated players , after all he is their goat .

[@espymu]

no denis irwin?

[@shetysify]

My captain!!

[@nick4399]

Keane himself has put more talent out of the Premier league than in it with his career ending tackles.

[@shajiaa2]

debruyne and ronaldinho are the real kings of football

[@EPLHYPE]

Zidane 🤴

[@The-Saxon]

Roy Keane...... A legend in his own mind.

[@tonypadd7939]

you are alone with that statement lmao

[@ComettableMabel]

Roy’s not wrong 3:34 maybe here I cannot stand Rashford for United

[@dondamon4669]

Everything he says about Manchester United has been or become true! I believe if he didn't fall out with Ferguson he would of definitely been manager and only reason not is Ferguson holds to much power. Ole being our manager our super sub is and was embarrassing! Ole a player to scared to leave and happy to warm the bench when we have Kea e who is exactly what the players need, someone they can talk to, banter with, as long as you give your all, knows how to win and what is required to win just doesn't have all the tactical talk of a Pep or Artega etc which is mainly all rubbish when all you got to do is pass quick, forward, move, attack, score and defend

[@EPLHYPE]

It would be interesting to see him at a big club with world-class players for sure. A lot has changed since Fergies days/style though and he only got away with it towards the end because he was Sir Alex. Keane is deffo a bit of a Fergie type. Sadly seems like players have the power now, managers go much quicker than them. The Man united players pushed out Ole and Mourinho from what I remember? People were calling for Klopp's head last year🤯. Patience is just gone out of the window 😆

[@awesomeddz1rt]

Pep and Arteta know how to talk to players. Look at Arteta, man is pure passion about football but that does not diminish from his social skills. He supports players and if you look at Ramsdale story about his unfortunate loss of son you'd know that Arteta was there for him. So while I do agree Keane is great man no need to take others into it without knowing what are you talking about.

[@aabidamn]

He tried being a manager. All you said worked at first, but then they got staled quickly. Roy is a bully, not a motivational type of person. He picked fights with everybody; the team, his staffs, the media, the club bosses. There's no way someone like that would survive long as a football manager. He was like Mourinho, but without the tactical nous. You need a combination of a bully, motivational, and tactically sound to become a great manager for the long run. Roy Keane didn't have those. Now he realized it's easier to work as a pundit than doing an actual groundwork to manage a football team.

[@Rua007]

​@@aabidamnFacts

[@Tigman401]

*would have definitely become manager It absolutely mystifies me how people still make that mistake.It's simple English.

[@shaunjenkinson5089]

Right about everyone but Rashford, who is a lazy good for nothing

[@ashleyb397]

Agreed

[@johnlees6019]

Roy Keane should be new uniteds manager

[@boxingfit]

Roy...openly admits he has no patience.... and it is the one thing that holds him back ... slaughtered the u item keeper when EVERY TOP CLUB looked to buy him every year

[@SerioussoccerfanYT]

When Ten Hag suggested that he wanted Antony, he was priced at €60m but the board bought him after losing the first games of the season to Brighton and Brentford, towards the end of the window....now he was priced at €85m..so tell me who's at fault here, is it the manager or is it the board ? This isn't FIFA that merely buying players results in them making a seamless transition. Also, what about the Gakpo deal in Jan or the CB that Ten Hag had wanted earlier this summer (surely Evans wasn't his pick) also why do United take so very long to get every single deal over the line unlike City or Liverpool. As self-anointed "biggest club in the world" , surely they ought to be more efficient in carrying out transfer negotiations and getting more money for their outgoing academy starlets.

[@freezydmx7820]

And united fans are saying bruno is better than kdb joke of a club

[@kol9382]

Roy doesn't rate Rashford at all 😂😂😂😂😂

[@EPLHYPE]

Not when he's playing as a striker, but he does when he's on form and out wide!

[@kol9382]

@@EPLHYPEon form which ain't often. He called him a child the other week. He ain't having him.

[@dondamon4669]

He's correct as well , downing tools because not in his favourite position is outrageous and if we were in a better position he would be sold. I reckon he is a negative character in the dressing room and has been for years. Our players like Keane said will throw every manager under the bus, done it once Will do it again a d Rashford must be a ringleader! If he is capable of playing rubbish on purpose coz not in his favourite position then he must be spoilt little brat

[@PLUTOXGOAT]

​@@dondamon4669couldn't of said it better

[@Mizpah5]

Harry McGuire is a poor defender. Couldn't pass a bus in a car.

[@TomUK7]

I cant help but feel he's had a negative effect on the club since he left. Constantly berating players.

[@kyliemiriam]

His comment on De Gea did not age well…