आर्थिक मंदी: गिरीश कुबेर सांगताहेत कारणं । Girish Kuber: Economic crisis reasons & impact explained

देशातली आर्थिक मंदी ही केवळ जागतिक बाजारपेठेत चाललेल्या घडामोडींचा परिणाम नसून त्याला अंतर्गत आर्थिक धोरणंही तितकीच कारणीभूत आहेत असं म्हणतांना ही मंदी कधी दूर होईल हे लगेच सांगता येणार नाही असं विवेचन 'लोकसत्ता'चे संपादक आणि अर्थकारणाचे अभ्यासक गिरीश कुबेर यांनी म्हटलं आहे. 'बीबीसी मराठी' सोबत 'फेसबुक लाईव्ह' मध्ये सहभागी होतांना त्यांनी मंदीविषयीच्या अनेक प्रश्नांना उत्तरं दिली.
_
अधिक माहितीसाठी :
www.bbc.com/marathi
/ bbcnewsmarathi
/ bbcnewsmarathi

[@dr.bhausaheby.deshmukh6979]

मी अर्थशास्त्राचा एक प्राध्यापक आहे.कुबेर यांनी केलेली मांडणी अतिशय सुंदर आहे. मंदीतून बाहेर पडण्यासाठी सुचविलेले उपाय योजना योग्य आहेत .परंतु उद्योगांना पूर्णपणे मोकळीक देणे हे देखील धोक्याचे ठरेल . केवळ नफा मिळवणे हेच धोरण ठेऊन उद्योग उत्पादन करतील . उपभोग्य वस्तूंचे उत्पादन होणार नाही. त्याची झळ सर्वसामान्य माणसाला बसेल. उद्योगामध्ये स्पर्धात्मकता येण्यासाठी सरकारी पाऊले उचलली पाहिजेत

[@NikhilKhandekar]

खूप सुंदर, डोळे उघडणारी मुलाखत झाली. ही मुलाखत आपल्या तरुणांनी जरूर संपूर्ण ऐकावी, त्यातून बोध मिळवावा आणि भविष्यात केंद्र तसेच राज्य पातळींवर सक्षम आणि हुशार सरकार निर्माण करण्याची जवाबदारी स्वीकारावी. बीबीसी मराठी आणि गिरीश कुबेर सरांचे खूप खूप आभार!

[@utkarshrasane1]

अप्रतिम विश्लेषण

[@akshata2358]

Girish kuber my Economics teacher.मला जेवढही काही अर्थशास्त्रतल कळत ते कुबेर सरांमुळे कारण त्यांना अर्थशास्त्र रंजक बनवता येत.economics is something which is u must understand हे कुबेर सरांमुळे कळाल.

[@sudarshanmandlecha5977]

नशीबवान आहे तु

[@anirudhayerunkar2393]

Kharach

[@straightforward8219]

Privatization kara mhantaat he guruji tyana vichara ki private sector cha npa god god lagto ani garibachi subsidy kadu kadu ek kam kara garibala nalatun vish dya ani mara ekdacha ani shetkaryana pan mhanje tumcha paisa Kagad raddi kagad banel mag gham gala ani ghar bandha sheti kara tumche karkhane chalva

[@amitr4385]

No offence mam...bt he is a congress stooge and his views on economics change every year....he never offers concrete solutions

[@straightforward8219]

@@amitr4385 congress bjp donhi samech ahet pan Hya majority economists la zalay kay economy madhun manus kadhla tar kay rahil o ani he bolnyavarunach distaye ki hyanchi opinion firm nahiyet

[@nileshchare1165]

धन्यवाद कुबेर सर.... खूप छान माहिती दिली

[@chandrakantmargaj4724]

धन्यवाद कुबेर सर! कोणतीही अर्थशास्त्रीय शिक्षणाची पार्श्वभूमी नसलेल्या सामान्य माणसाला सहज समजेल इतक्या सोप्या भाषेत तुम्ही भारतीय अर्थव्यवस्थेचे मर्म उकलून दाखवले आहे.

[@tejassontakke1547]

Thank you for your detailed analysis..!! Enjoyed watching the vlog. So many things to think about.

[@payalkamble5797]

Listen till end its valuable talk👍🏻

[@netajijadhav1383]

धन्यवाद

[@gawde]

Thank you Mr. Kuber. You have explained the underlying issues in very simple terms. Also thanks to the reporter for asking some good questions.

[@deepakmadake9980]

माजी पंतप्रधान मनमोहनसिंग यांची भविष्य वानी खरी होणार. एक वेळ ते म्हणाले होते की पत्रकार यानचया पेक्षा ईतिहासच मला न्याय देईल. ते खरं होताना दिसत आहे.

[@amitr4385]

Hahahaha...itka motha vakya te bolale hote? Barrr

[@gauravwaghmare1169]

Blind Bhakt protecting their Bochi wah mochiji wah....

[@ishanipimpale]

Irrelevant.. some decisions of Manmohan government are also responsible for slow down

[@deepakmadake9980]

@@amitr4385 अशा प्रसंगात बोलण्यापेक्षा डोकं चालवनं महत्वाचे असतं.

[@siddhidhuri3107]

@@ishanipimpale jeva notebandi zali tevch manmohan Singh manele hote rajsabha madhey yacha 2% GDP kami hoil Teva tyna modi murkhat kadl hote. Manmohan Singh world bank madhey head position hote uagch nahi. Modi bhakt pls thod band Kara baghat raha

[@sanketrajebhosale6928]

उत्तम विश्लेषण

[@dnyanadaprabodhan]

कुबेर सर सर्व प्रथम आपले आभार , अतिशय चांगल्या पद्धतीत आर्थिक मंदी बाबत जे काही आपण वेगवेगळ्या पैलूंवर सविस्तर खुलासा केलात हे वास्तविक जेवढं आमच्या सारख्या सर्व सामान्य लोकांना समजले तेवढे सरकारला देखील समजले तर किमान आपल्या सारख्या विद्वत्ता असलेल्या अनुभवी व्यक्तिमत्व असलेल्या अर्थ शास्त्रज्ञांकडून सल्ला सरकारने घ्यावा जेणेकरून देशावर येणारे संकटावर आपण मात करण्यास यशस्वी होऊ. श्रीमंत लोकांना काही फरक नाही पडणार मात्र गरीब बिचारा मारून जाईल त्यामुळे सरकारने आता तरी धोरणात्मक निर्णय घ्यावा हीच अपेक्षा आहे.

[@netsavvy1971]

Girish Kuber is an intelligent person. Nice interview.

[@amitmisal2175]

Great soul! Sir really salute you for crystal clear talk.

[@Amol1501]

Khup chan sir, very informative. Thanks bbc news.

[@akshaypatwari9023]

Really great information about current scenario of economic slowdown.

[@abhaymamale6730]

Kuber sir. You upload more economic analysis videos. Thank you.💐💐💐💐🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@daivatthakur526]

Very nice explanation by Kuber sir.

[@prasadoak1284]

Apratim

[@yogeshjadhao5621]

Thanks sir.

[@sushantbhogulkar7599]

Thank you sir..easy language...👍

[@kishorpatil8837]

Very nice BBC,..keep uploading such lectures..

[@amolnagapure]

Thanks Girish sir, Thanks BBC

[@official_sandipsabale]

कुबेर सरांचे मी अनेक लेख वाचलेत / वाचतो, सर अतिशय साधी आणि सोप्या भाषेत तुम्ही समजावलं आहे, नक्कीच हे GST आणि नोटबंदी ह्याचे पाप आहे, GST एक दिवस मोदी सरकार ला रस्त्यावर आणेल आणि भारतीय अर्थव्यवस्थेची वाट लावेल.

[@maheshronge6845]

अप्रतिम विश्लेषण 👌👌

[@shraddhagaikwad4056]

Nice information sir.... N good job BBC Marathi

[@blossomblossom7528]

आमच्या city मध्ये निर्जन जागी फूटपाथ बांधले आहे.आणि जिथं पाहिजे तिथं नाही अश्या हास्यास्पद गोष्टी सरकार करत आहे. सरकार ला फक्त निवडणूक आणि सत्ता याच गोष्टीत इंटरेस्ट आहेत

[@ashokband1494]

Best Subject Handel

[@krunalpatel8886]

In 1991 and in 2008 there were severe recession in india than 2019....but luckily sankat mochan manmohansingh was in ruling party ...he took tremendous brilliant steps and succeed india to come out of recession...bad luck now this time feku pm and failed economist team dnt hv any clue wat to do....this show standard of manmohansingh....i m not in any party but this is my feeling...

[@ap2149]

In 1991 there was no global recession and what do you think we were out if 2008 recession? That recession is still continue till date...

[@krunalpatel8886]

@@ap2149 its v strange that effect of trade war betwwwn us nd china affect india more than itself usa nd china...infact v shud benefited by it...nd recession of 2008 was last for 6 month only thereaftee growth reached to double digit n share market grow 3 times from der...better u do homework

[@siddhidhuri3107]

@@ap2149 in 1991 v p singh sold gold for cash because we completely bankrupt in that time. as finance minster in narshima govt he changed the whole economy . In 2005 Americans market completely crashed which effect globally effect still manmohan control our economy our GDP in that time 8% .I that world amazed by the manmohan Singh in that time. As modi bhakt u should study that

[@ap2149]

@@siddhidhuri3107 world know how mediocre economist Manmohan is and its proved when his ministry declared rs. 27 as per day income for a household is inough.. As gandu u cannot see these but people on street were laughing and world realised how stupid an economist can be..

[@patekarm]

@@ap2149 तू स्वतःला ब्रोकर म्हणून सांगतोस, ब्रोकर म्हणजे हिंदी मध्ये दलाल, मराठीत भडवा - तुझी ओळख तू योग्यच सांगतोस ते मराठीत सांगत जा ।

[@jivankumartondwalkar2273]

It's a eye opening information by kuber jee.

[@abhayk2658]

Jabardast....kiti saral ani sop vishleshan kelay...

[@kaustubhclasses2751]

very nice information we need discipline in economic decision thanks to bbc news

[@saifuddinabdulqadir575]

Right information on right time

[@shrigurudevdatta9895]

Nice information sir....real conditions

[@sagarbandekar7585]

Very informative

[@asknew7927]

खूप छान आणि सुस्पष्ट विश्लेषण सर

[@ashwiniumade5021]

Thanks sir

[@benaturalbacktonature3408]

Nice information

[@rahulkumbhar6905]

Very good knowledge sir thanks

[@siddheshwarnagansur9533]

Best

[@sukhadevpandhare4597]

प्रश्न खूपच छान विचारले आहेत... सुंदर माहिती मिळाली

[@suraj_hirade]

खुप चांगली माहिती मिळाली! thanks!

[@yogeshchaugule9132]

Superb

[@girishnarale3681]

At what level Share market will affect How about real estate investment

[@abhijitmali4901]

Khup chan

[@adeshtalgaonkar4447]

Khup Chan sir

[@dharamchandfulfagar196]

Very nice

[@ranjitsuryawanshi7911]

Very nice interpretation kuber sir..

[@sonaljadhav9230]

Nice information... Sir ....bt its most dangerous situation....thank u ...sir

[@randeepgaikwad1569]

Thanks Girish sir 🙏🙏

[@marotisuryawanshi9531]

Khup khup thanks kuber sir...65%youth aakal asel tr nakki arthik sakshar hoil aaplya economy cha dokyani vichar karel sir ase vedio bbc canal cha madyamatun takat raha..plz tx...lot sir

[@peednas007]

superb sir

[@finelookStockResearch]

Brilliant explain sir

[@csjadhav9969]

ह्या 'सरकार'ला 'राजनीती' छान पैकी जमते...; पण 'अर्थनीती' या 'सरकार'ला बिलकुल जमत नाही...'अर्थकार'णात या सरकारने 'धसमुसळेपणा'च केला...म्हणून हा देश आर्थिक मंदीच्या उंबरठयावर उभा राहिला...

[@amarbarad5211]

Nice Sir U R So Brilliant 👍👍👍

[@srh60]

You are right sir.

[@jaijawanjaikisan6007]

Khup chan mahiti dili sir

[@Viraj_2305]

Kay apratim paddhat ahe sir tumchi...sadhya parasthitila khup yatharth rupane tumhi rekhatlet...ma napasun dhanyawaad

[@sudhirchakkarwar9214]

Is there any correlation between recession and FDI investment...?

[@patilprasadc2007]

Mr Kuber has lots to stay. I think the interviewer should have done a better job of moderation. Overall an informative video. 👍

[@sharadmahajan6638]

Very good and informative vedio.

[@swarajyesade7837]

Earlier only ministers used to get pension...and now even MLA's are getting pension ...Why ? From where this government is bringing this money ..This wastage should be stopped

[@amitr4385]

Good suggestion..stop pension of all ministers b it any party...

[@parthshah9863]

Swaraj Yesade pension facility should be stopped completely

[@parthshah9863]

Swaraj Yesade even of govt officers private jobs also don’t give pension i think pf is enough

[@aniket4713]

@@parthshah9863 agree

[@pundlikbhise5648]

Good interview.

[@funwithchiusamu2248]

Pundlik Bhise of oh I I gkk ii

[@umeshcheke9377]

It may Affect On Electronics Market Like Gyser Water Purifiers

[@pravinaru816]

Goverment ni ..Manmohan singh & Raghuram Rajan Hyanchi Help Ghyavi...Aani mandi madhun Baher yanycha praytna karava..Rajkaran karnyapeksha Sadhya Desh IMP aahe..

[@amitr4385]

Manmohan tech bolnat je sonia sangnar...kay upyog ? Ani raghuram rajan ni swatcha kalat ghetlelya decisions var question mark taklay te pan videshat rahun...kay ghanta upyog honar yancha

[@that_fat_rider]

Jya Rajan sir na hya lokan mule resignation dyava lagla aani tyani dekhil hya mandiche bhakit 2 varsha purvi international summit madhe sangitla hota tyana aata parat bolva hey mhanje vihir bhujavli aata pani pahije mhanun parat khoda asa aahe sagla

[@amitr4385]

@@that_fat_rider Mandi worldwide ahe...fakta bhartat modi mule ali asa kui kui koni karu naye ani rajan la second term offer keli astana to palun gela...term cha madhe resign ka nahi kela kaam karu det navhte tar..

[@amitdhanke4013]

@@amitr4385 tu economist ahe ka chatya

[@amitr4385]

@@amitdhanke4013 tujha kade congrss chate classes chi degree ahe ka re economist chi bhadkhau...nusyya shivya det ahes....ek ajobacha cha ashil tar ye economics debate la tujha aaila paani pajto...

[@jayashrikapse9075]

खुप छान विश्लेषण

[@s.k714]

Nice explained..constructive criticism . Economy recession analysed.. 👍👍

[@adikvehale9441]

Well Done. Honest person. Real Hero

[@rajendragumaste6274]

what will be effect on real estate

[@vikrantgajbhiye9191]

100%true

[@vikrantdeshmukh5207]

I have a question. Before demonitaiton they matched and after demo why notes of any value doesn't match in stack

[@lalitmulay2851]

I don't completely agree with him .1) Bank NPA gone to 10 Lakh crore.Out of 10 lakh crore 7 lakh crore is from Indian PSU banks & only 3 lakh crore from pvt banks. 7 lakh crore was due to phone banking service by congress Manmohan Singh govt. He himself gave a letter to SBI to give Loan to kingfisher . Why kuberji is not telling that? 10 lakh crore npa has continued from UPA govt. 2) The real reason is there is no demand for any goods & there is a over production of each goods for ex passenger vehicles: .once a family buys a car it doesn't buy for another 6 years. Auto companies in India produce 30,000 cars on daily .So today around 2 crore cars are lying in warehouses. It's same with TV, Fridge, AC etc. 3) Most important real estate sector was itself a balloon which had to burst some day. Since builders were getting cheap black money from corrupted ministers , IAS officers, Excise officers, bmc officers, Income tax officers, sales tax officers, Dist. collector, police commissoner etc. They all ensure that prices remain high . This was happening from last 20 years . real estate is directly related to the salary a middle class person earns . When a person earning Rs.1 lakh salary / month also cannot buy a 2 bhk flat in Mumbai which cost 2 crore . It itself should have been alarming for policy makers. There is nothing special in Mumbai for which a 2 bhk flat should cost 2 crore rupees. It is one of the most polluted city in the world . Balloon had to be burst some day . Demonitization was just a trigger point . Rs. 70 to 80 Lakh is the right price for a 2 bhk flat in Mumbai. The same follows for other major cities too.since the flow of black money has stopped builders don't have money to complete their projects. So to tell that because of Modi Govt Real Estate is down, auto sector is down is not true . He rightly said that govt. Should should sell all the major govt companies like Air India , SAIL, BHEL . Also withdrew major stakes from PSU banks . In a slow down when a investment doesn't come from pvt companies it is a job of Govt. to invest in Infra projects like Roads, Railways need to develop water ways, affordable housing etc this will again generate employment .

[@rnsabnis]

The main reason might be stoppage of black money/easy money, which had inflated prices and created unsustainable unuseful commodity industry in long run...

[@darenijat1530]

He is very true Now a days it is very unusual to find true analysis on economic issues

[@seemabastikar9477]

Govt ajun sudha Mandi ahe Manya karat nahi toparyant upay yojana kay karnar

[@natasha3047]

He made the subject very easy to understand for the laymen.

[@swapnilpavane3397]

Kuber sir nice information 💐💐💐💐💐💐👌👌👌👌👌

[@arvindmohite7034]

सरकार कोणतंही असो अथवा देश कोणताही असो.... हे होणारच... कारण प्रत्येक देश एकमेकांशी जोडले आहेत.. आणि प्रत्येक गोष्टीची मर्यादा असते...

[@pankajjadhav3755]

Engineering ketravr ksa prinam hoil?

[@SANDYTAWARE111]

Now share market is down, I request all Modi Bhakt to invest in market.....😂

[@patpat2456]

Yeah bring it down and rich CEO will buy it back. Douchbag

[@aniket4713]

Not right time it will go more down more deep

[@somnathyelvantge541]

above abp

[@SantoshChavan-xc6oe]

ITS RIGHT

[@PST9]

भक्त तर आता गिरीश कुबेर यांना चूक ठरवतील.. !!

[@amitr4385]

Itka pan yala serious nahi ghet..pan yacha navavar congress walyanchi tingal karayla lay maja yete....trump nivadnuk harnar ashi popatpanchi keli hoti yani...tikde pan modi ni evm hack kele yala khali padnyasathi...aika next vyakhan

[@sushilm2686]

अरे त्याने मनमोहन चया पण चुका सांगितल्या आहे ! 😂😀😂😀 इतकं फुगूवू नको !

[@amitdhanke4013]

Bhakt nahi manege 😆😂🤣

[@smashboy4628]

Murkha Manmohan sing kay dive lavle

[@Indiantrav]

भक्त भिकेला लागले की अक्कल येईल त्यांना

[@vinitapethkar1421]

Insurance sectors var Kay parinaam hoil sell kartana Kay tras hou shakto

[@rajendrapatilofficial5241]

Side effects of demonization

[@NileShindePatil.]

कशाला सांगता सर.... भक्तांना नाही पटणार...!!

[@yogeshyadavofficial8193]

Chan mahiti deta ali

[@aniketchile7588]

BANK FD VR KY EFFECT PADEL KA ECONOMY CRISIS CHA

[@sandeepwale6072]

Bharat Pakistan yudhha chalu honar bahutek.. Aapoap lok mandi visartil

[@ZeeshanMRaje]

Pakistan kade paise naahit ani aapla desh sudhha tyach margavar aahe , yudh naahi yudh sadrushya paristhiti kkartil he panchat PM

[@rohitadhatrao6877]

lokancha arthik dnyan kamkuvat aahe, ani structural reforms vhaila havet as said by girish kuber, pan tarihi ek mhanto....pakistan ha madarchodach aahe

[@anikettilekar5225]

Yudh jar zala trr mandi ajun jast vegani vadhel

[@amitr4385]

@@ZeeshanMRaje zeeshan raje .... Laath khaun gap zhopaychi savay congress ni lavli hoti...sadhyacha pm ulat vaar pan kartoy.... Ek tari desh ahe ka jyani bhartala yuddhakhor declare kelay...modi avadat nahi hi vegli goshta asel..pan deshachi security is a seperate topic

[@m.k.714]

@@amitr4385 murkha Manasa yuddha mule konacha kahich fayada hot nahi aani aataparyant Congress ne deshachi pratima changali Keli hoti mhanun koni aata bharatala yuddakhor mhatale nahi

[@pradeeppatil7594]

कुबेर सर आपण मांडलेले विचार खर्च विचार करण्यासारखे आहेत आपल्या सर्वांचे खूप आभार

[@drvaishalizod6618]

भारतातील श्रीमंत मंदिरातील पैसा सरकारने बाहेर काढून टाकणंही गरजेचे आहे.

[@akshayathavale8526]

Kasa kadhanar Te swatantr arthik entity ahet Te tax pay karatat Tyamule to kayadeshir paisa ahe

[@thepowerofmoney9192]

Sir आर्थिक मंदीला कारणीभूत कोणती गोष्ट आहे.

[@Satish-ei5to]

What steps govt should take to improve?

[@Abhishek-gr7rp]

Government should step down😂

[@PST9]

हें च तर अच्छे दिन आहेत, या पेक्षा काय पाहिजे.. देश केलिये अपनी नौकरी कि कुर्बानी देणी पडेगी... !!!

[@amitr4385]

Kuber bolala ani ikde tujhi company band padli ka re ? Are to apla bolun jato....majha sector automation mechanics is doing mighty good..atach 10 million chi order milali south africa kadun..tula kay vatata kuber ek ek industry cha abhyas karun alay ka ?

[@PST9]

@@amitr4385 तर्काना तिलांजली... !!!

[@amitr4385]

@@PST9 Answer nasel ki asa vatata... Kuber mhanje to jyotishi ahe jo election nantar result sangto

[@ameetbhangare2178]

@@amitr4385 sir kuthe aahe tumchi company ani Kay naav aahe tumcha firm cha, hot head hey tumcha real name aahe Kay...??

[@PST9]

@@ameetbhangare2178 hot head हा भक्त दिसतोय.. ज्यांनी आपले डोके वापराने सोडून दिलेले आहे... लाचार.. !!!

[@abhijitdeshmukh6675]

Please ase lecture jasta asavet sir che.

[@sadgirps7549]

Sir common people need traditional investment aivaji kuthe investment karavi in those days

[@sharadkharat3568]

आयातीच्या बदलता निर्यात का करत नाही अंबानी व अदानी ला मंदी का नाही

[@amitr4385]

Koknala samudra kinara ka ani satara la ka nahi ?

[@that_fat_rider]

Tya doghana taksaal kadhun Dili aahe separate nota chaapayla 😅😅

[@amitr4385]

@@that_fat_rider Jashi congress kala madhe chidambaram..raja...kanimozi..kalmadi...ashok gehlot ani robert vadra la dili tashi ka...bhari re

[@that_fat_rider]

@@amitr4385 ho agadi tashich mhanun satta milalya var notabandi keli aani satte madhe aslelya lokani swatasathi navin notanchi soy keli aani ajunhe tech chalu aahe Hey pan bhari aahe na? 😅😅

[@amitr4385]

@@that_fat_rider tumcha note gele ki ahet...majha mate jyanche Pandhre paise hote titke parat ale... Jyancha kade kala paisa hota tyanche gele...tumcha kay zhala ale ki gele ? Te sanga mag pudhce bhari points discuss karu

[@ashoka1437]

Sir maj mobile shope ahe ..lokanca keshat payse nastil tar kashe kai te esatra khridi kartil..lokana kam asal ki teva bijnes pan aevstit caltil..

[@MWKhan-iv7pr]

Bank deposit chya sandarbhat ( F D ) kahi sangata yenar kay

[@umakantkulkarni8810]

ग्रेट माणूस

[@kninad2000]

Superb information root cause explored

[@Jyoti89700]

कुबेर साहेब देशातील नामांकित अर्थतज्ञांपैकी एक आहेत