Ryan Whitney Says Sidney Crosby is Top 5 All-Time | Pardon My Take

Listen to the full Podcast: apple.co/pardonmytake
Follow on TikTok: @pardonmytake
Follow on Twitter: / pardonmytake
Follow on Instagram: / pardonmytake
Follow on Twitch: / pardonmytake
PMT MERCH: store.barstoolsports.com/coll...
Check out Barstool Sports for more: www.barstoolsports.com
Follow Barstool Sports here:
Facebook: / barstoolsports
Twitter: / barstoolsports
Instagram: / barstoolsports

[@citizenkane454]

To me, crosby is the greatest overall player ever. Excellent at everything.

[@EvanderTrolyfield]

Crosby’s resume is insane. The guy has multiples of almost every trophy and that includes at least 2 years where he was robbed due to injury. Not to mention his national team accolades; World Junior Gold, 2x Olympic Gold, World Championship Gold, World Cup Gold. Captains most of those teams, won MVP or leading scorer of most. Unreal. He wins and succeeds at every level.

[@savagesweetheart90]

Got to see him play in 2016 against Chicago. Even traveled to Pittsburgh and it was amazing to watch him play and score. Best player indeed ❤

[@ryanmacneil2567]

To those of you who don't agree with Crosby being a top 5 GOAT - every player in the NHL would disagree with you. You are ignorant...

[@seanranelli5340]

Right on Whit best of this generation

[@chilltownallstar]

I have Crosby as my GOAT. Crosby has thrived through every era and has faced more adversity than any player in history. Never had someone protecting him and even fought to earn his respect. No rookie took the abuse that Crosby had and he still scored 100 points in a clutch in grab, neutral zone trap era. Endured concussions and came back just as strong. He is still producing even though he game is now dependant on reading plays and letting his team mates take care of the speed game. Gretzky wasn’t half as good at 35 as Crosby is rn and he sure as hell didn’t play a two way game like Crosby. Crosby is the GOAT IMO!!

[@connormcteer3319]

That's the most accurate top 5. Whit hit er on the button

[@qwwupp4763]

Gretzky, Mario, Orr, Crosby, Howe

[@tytrack95]

Great interview! And yes Sidney Crosby is GOAT

[@roryvonmeyer2643]

I think Sid would have as many or more points as Gretzky if they both played in the same era. I said "I think" because it is purely opinion and it cannot be proved.

[@jackfredricks6223]

"So you played with one of the top 5 guys of all time..."

[@SouthernSkeptic]

Bossy is in the conversation for best goal scorer.

[@fatpowerful]

Crosby got whit several million. Plus he’s the greatest in the game currently.

[@daviddelac]

Whit is an American treasure

[@getothechoppa114]

I agree with his top 5. And ovi as the greatest goal scorer 🤟

[@GordonGekko98]

Best player to ever live

[@TheMightyEye]

Crosby is the best of all time.

[@thatpensfanatic1005]

He’s top 5 all time, Common Sense LMAO

[@andrewmoore2347]

I agree with Crosby, but where is Beliveau in this list??? I know most of you have never seen him play but he was dominant. I realize that times where different back then but Beliveau's talent and abilities where so obvious! All the players listed in this top five, except for Howe, are in vert recent hockey generations. Howe played so many years (even when he probably shouldn't) whereas Beliveau kept his career short in comparison.

[@pensfan_traders8734]

Top 5 all time