S Jaishankar : भारतीय विदेश मंत्री या Modi के प्रवक्ता? | The Caravan Magazine - Baatcheet Ep 21

S Jaishankar, India’s external affairs minister, has helped consolidate Narendra Modi’s hold over the operations of the external affairs ministry and is rebranding Indian foreign policy in Hindu nationalist terms.
In this episode of The Caravan Baatcheet, host Vishnu Sharma speaks with Sushant Singh, The Caravan’s consulting editor, and Eram Agha, a reporting fellow at The Caravan, about Jaishankar’s impact on India’s foreign policy. Agha has profiled Jaishankar in the March cover story of The Caravan, “Modi’s Messenger,” where she analyses how the BJP outsider has become the voice of India’s Hindu nationalist foreign policy. Singh has written extensively about foreign policy and international affairs for The Caravan.
Both Agha and Singh argue that Jaishankar has been acting less like India’s foreign minister and more like the ruling BJP’s spokesperson. They believe that this has diminished the position of the foreign minister as Jaishankar focuses more on managing the perception of the government than handling India’s foreign policy. As constitutional values ​​are being ignored in foreign policy, Singh warns about what this could mean for India.
Read Agha’s in-depth profile of Jaishankar here: caravanmagazin...
Singh’s insightful commentary on India’s foreign affairs can be read here: caravanmagazin...
The Caravan Baatcheet is a Hindi talk show featuring engaging discussions on politics, culture and society. Every fortnight, our host Vishnu Sharma will be in conversation with journalists, writers, experts and observers on pivotal issues that matter to you. Cover photograph by Brendan Smialowski/AFP/Getty Images.
Subscribe to The Caravan here: caravanmagazin...
Contribute to The Caravan here: caravanmagazin...
Visit The Caravan website: caravanmagazin...
Visit The Caravan Hindi website, Karwan: hindi.caravanm...
Join us on social media!
Follow us on Twitter: / thecaravanindia
Follow us on Facebook: / thecaravanmagazine
Follow us on Instagram: / thecaravanmagazine
___________________________________________
कारवां बातचीत के इस एपिसोड में कारवां के कंसल्टिंग एडिटर सुशांत सिंह और रिपोर्टिंग फेलो इरम आग़ा से भारतीय विदेश मंत्री एस जयशंकर के दौर में भारतीय विदेश नीति पर बातचीत. इरम ने कारवां के मार्च अंक में जयशंकर की प्रोफाइल की है.
सुशांत और इरम दोनों का कहना है कि जयशंकर भारत सरकार के विदेश मंत्री कम और मोदी के प्रवक्ता अधिक लगते हैं. दोनों ने बताया कि जयशंकर के दौर में यह पद संकुचित हुआ है क्योंकि वह सरकार का परसैप्शन मैनेजिंग पर अधिक ध्यान दे रहे हैं.
सुशांत का मानना है कि विदेश नीति में संवैधानिक मूल्यों को नरजअंदाज किया जा रहा जो एक गलत परिपाटी है.
कारवां बातचीत हिंदी टॉक शो है जिसमें राजनीति, संस्कृति और समाज से जुड़े महत्वपूर्ण मुद्दों पर होस्ट विष्णु शर्मा हर पखवाड़े पत्रकारों, लेखकों, विशेषज्ञों और संपादकों से बातचीत करते हैं. #CaravanBaatcheet
कारवां में प्रकाशित एस जयशंकर की प्रोफाइल यहां पढ़ें,
caravanmagazin...

[@leebogi]

Please, there are a huge number of Indians who do not understand Hindi - we need subtitles!

[@onlineaakashvani6145]

Subtitle : 🐕 bhook rhe h😅

[@prateekdeoli1552]

We Indians have good "Crab mentality"!!

[@acrobat6217]

Bilkul sahi. People blindingly praising Jaishankar shud understand that he's spent more hours debating against the opposition than against foreign diplomats. He reads out of a pre scripted play on how to respond if so and so is said which is total whataboutery

[@sanjeevtripathi1925]

Two bogus person sitting and do analysis of FM

[@sharadgovind1126]

Very good discussion

[@lampyclampy]

हाथी चले बाजार , कुत्ते भोके हजार ।😂😂

[@santanumaiti5325]

Jai shankar is most suitable foreign minister. No need of ur advice, do not teach,

[@anantgarg8741]

Why are u even here when u already have preconceived notions on him.

[@somenmohanty6460]

Why are u barking at everyone's comment chutiye 😂😂

[@pravendrarj]

Tujhe mirchiii lagi toh main kya karuu…!!! FYI… he is former IFS

[@sudhirgupta6157]

Dictator ( Modi) has plenty of slaves….. S Jai Shankar (GULAAM) is one of them.

[@santanumaiti5325]

Both guests are uncomfortable, this is new Bharat, everything is running good in India now. U r unqualified for any position. U keep shouting

[@anantgarg8741]

Yes, everything is fine in wonderland.

[@abhinavverma3406]

Real foreign policy making of foreign ministry is under control of NSA Ajit doval jaishankar has no control of foreign policy he is just defender of Ajit doval foreign policy making

[@balwantsinghrathore4831]

We can’t say vk singh is not belog to MFA he was a ex state FM .I can’t agree on is point

[@dudepandey736]

at ine point sushant ends up declaring cabinet under British Colonial rule as equivalent of cabinet rule under democratic India - Uneducated discussion reinforcing Ideological biases from a bygone era!

[@sirrobertdowneysenior8080]

No he is like cheap troll rather BJP spokesperson.

[@ipsitamishra0577]

🤲🏾🙏🏽

[@rahulramyaa]

Please improve quality of interview.

[@RahulSingh-yj3is]

Puri duniya jiski tareef kar raha ho, uske against ue bakwas kaun sunega,

[@anantgarg8741]

Tabhi to use sunne aaya hai yahan pe.

[@bhishm09]

Sushant Singh is an army veteran..Please respect Indian Army 🙏🙏

[@jayaramsridhar5978]

Hello Please keep your mouth shut. The Foreign Minister knows what he is doing. The world is changing And new India is emerging.

[@manlike2323]

More conspiracies… 🤫🤐🤐

[@karthikpatra]

Very poorly researched interview. The criticism has no coherence at all. Personal ambition is wrong? The entire interview is just ideological gibberish. Pakistan's example in equating our foreign policy with a failed state shows how the entire conversation is plain stupid.

[@BhanuPrasad-hp4vm]

These descussing people are taking anti India stand.

[@RudradeepMukherjee]

Talk about points that are untrue in their discussion. Don't randomly mention "anti-India" like BJP.

[@rranjan3439]

@@RudradeepMukherjee Sushant Singh is just repeating the of Opposition parties-like 1. China encroaching 2000 Sq km of Indian territory. Where is the proof? Does he know the pace of Border infrastructure development being done on the last 5-7 years which was earlier ignored and rather gloried to do so. He mentioning 2. why 80% people taking free rations from the govt- that should also be asked to the NonBjp govt who ruled for over 6 decades at the centee, they expect BJP to make India drvelppoed and Super in power in one decade ? 3. He mentioning India's lousy foreign policy regarding Afghanistan,Myanmar and short sighted relationship with Russia - Arey Sushant bhai, Foreign Policies and agreements are mostly done in the closed doors, what we see is just the tip of the ice berg. What you think, the Indian Foreign Ministry is not doing anything about these issues, or they are not seeing the long term relations? So naive of you . 4. He said "Taking soft on Pakistan and China and staying on the backfoot ". What,are you f***ing kidding me? Come on. Don't act like a blind man describing an elephant. I can go on countering many things they discussed. A very few substantial logical arguments to agree upon, while most are just anti-eshtablisment rants tainted with political vendetta like Chai Sutta gossip.

[@ammumylife2244]

Foreign minister ho ya lok sabha speaker, ya rajhya sabha speaker. Sab ke Sab bj spokesman hain, Sadan me Rahul Gandhi ko bolne nai diye na.

[@rajumehta8109]

Bat chit nahi bakwas he

[@lifeisnevereasy5512]

Bjp Modi ka mantri hai s jai shankar

[@dominicdsouza4227]

USA will deporte Fecu panauti ji and his mate Netanyahu to Pakistan for their war crimes and his master's voice is in Manipur meditation unable to attend Ani or Godi media shameless

[@dipangshudev2257]

Aapke liye to kamjori hoga Na leftist mindset walon ka abhi to koi churan bikini raha hai India mein isiliye aapka narrative hi khatm ho gaya hai😂.

[@va8085]

Thumb rule: If communists & Islamists are criticising you, you’re doing something incredibly right 😅

[@debopammajumder5071]

Thumb rule: if communists are criticizing you it means you are not working for common people and supporting cronyism

[@Critic224]

Thumb rule : if right wing is critical of you, then you’re doing something right.

[@Nikshith_Sk]

​@@Critic224well seeing caravan magazine videos i doubt they are neutral and they are anti hindu and have slave mentality

[@hasannigarkhan3769]

Its true n very bold discussion hatts off to Both Persons N Carvan magziene💪👌👌💖💖👌

[@mrinsvids]

English subtitles please.

[@ishaanasahni5099]

Apka pta nhi kis desh main reh rhe hai.. Ye donu expert sirf anti Modi hai.. Expert advice nhi .. Sirf ek side ki negitive bt ho rhi hai.. Fake channel..

[@rranjan3439]

Dr S Jaishankar is doing just fine as the MEA, infact he is one of the finest External Minister India has had in the last few decades. This is the perception of not just me, but a regular Indian as well. You people have every right to criticize his work and point out his failures and how he can do better. But picking up on him on a trivial matter like "he being more a spokesperson of BJP than the MEA", is the proof of your intellectual constipation. He is also a politician now, though he doesn't sound like one most of the time. He still speaks like a diplomat. And when needed he changes his frequency of a politician. When occasionally he sounds like a politician ,why should it pinch you at your dorsal south. He is the MEA,a career Foreign secretary. And you three will give him "gyan". This is no constructive criticism, this is like another propaganda piece on "The Wire" Sushant Sing is related to an NGO Centre for Policy Research (CPR),the same NGO run by Manishankar Aiyar''s Daughter Yamini Aiyar, the same NGO which is under the red radar for violating FCRA norms. The Caravan magazine is an Opinated one giving platform to the Left leaning Intellectuals. So what could one expect from these biased and intellectually Handicapped fellows. And BTW, this "chomu" Sharma sounds like the midget version of comic Rajdeep Sardesai or Karan Thappad.

[@rranjan3439]

@@pr3148 Don't be delusional.😂

[@harshkashiv4265]

Great analysis

[@Aum763]

Meanwhile these ppl : Dr. Jaishankar knows nothing but mereko sab maloom hai. Btw these are the same chomus who blamed brahmins for destroying Nalanda in order to save Khilji's image. Need I say more..🤷

[@rranjan3439]

Dr S Jaishankar is doing just fine as the MEA, infact he is one of the finest External Minister India has had in the last few decades. This is the perception of not just me, but a regular Indian as well. You people have every right to criticize his work and point out his failures and how he can do better. But picking up on him on a trivial matter like "he being more a spokesperson of BJP than the MEA", is the proof of your intellectual constipation. He is also a politician now, though he doesn't sound like one most of the time. He still speaks like a diplomat. And when needed he changes his frequency of a politician. He is the MEA,a career Foreign secretary. And you three will give him "gyan". This is no constructive criticism, this is like another discuasion of "The Wire" Sushant Sing is related to an NGO Centre for Policy Research (CPR),the same NGO run by Manishankar Aiyar''s Daughter Yamini Aiyar, the same NGO which is under the red radar of violating FCRA norms. The Caravan magazine is an Opinated one giving platform to the Left leaning Intellectuals. So what could one expect from these biased and intellectually Handicapped fellows. And BTW, this "chomu" Sharma sounds like a midget version of Rajdeep Sardesai or Karan Thappad.

[@sauravindraguru3377]

Uska iq .... tm teena ka mila ke usse jyda h

[@kamalchauhan5470]

Duniya bhar k diplomats jaishankar kibtareef kr rahe hai or hamare yaha k kuch behuda log jo ki dr jaishankar k kad se jealous hai woh unki bhrayee kr rhe hai .....hey bhagwaan bas yehi dekhna baaki tha..........😂😂😂😂😂

[@RudradeepMukherjee]

Can you add references to how world diplomats are praising Mr. Jaishankar?

[@harshitsingh1600]

​@@RudradeepMukherjeeSee the German Ambassador as well as Australian Foreign Minister Peny Wong

[@sreechandlunia2158]

Jab Janet ho Bharat ke bidesh mantri hai to beukuf jaisa ? kyo.

[@mradultiwari1959]

अनपढ़ आदमी बताएंगे कैसे विदेश नीति करनी है 🤣🤣

[@anantgarg8741]

Anpadh log satta chala rahe hain aur unki anpadh jamaat lagi padi unko support karne mai.

[@onlineaakashvani6145]

​@@anantgarg8741 hathi chale bajar kutte bhoke hazar

[@anantgarg8741]

@@onlineaakashvani6145 tu unme se ek bhaukne wala kutta hai?

[@syednazeerhussain3049]

👍

[@mdsarfrajalam2755]

Useful discussion,,,,

[@clickflikstudio]

After ndtv these is the channel i like 🙏